SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
`1
How Do You Get$200,000 From A WhiplashCase?
By NelsonHendler,MD, MS and WilliamGallagher,D.C.
(seniorauthorcontact-email NelsonHendler,MD,MS at DocNelse@aol.com)
The answerto thistitle questionissimple. Getacorrect diagnosis. Inordertoimprove yourrecovery
fromany whiplashcase,softtissue injurywithnoobjective medical findings,oracervical sprain,there
are several easy stepsatrial attorneycan follow.Firstandforemostistoobtainanaccurate diagnosis.
Often,atrial attorneyasa clientwhohasbeenrear-ended,sufferedahyperextensionhyperflexion
injury,asnormal x-rays,MRIs,and CAT scans,and has had numeroussessionsof physical therapyand/or
chiropracticcare. The treatingphysiciantellsthe trial attorney"Ican't findanythingwrong.Itmustbe
cervical sprainor strain."Nothingcouldbe furtherfromthe truth. JohnsHopkinsHospital physicians
reportthat 63% of these patientsneedsurgerytoimprove (18).
It isimportantto understandthe mechanicsof arear endcollision.Evenwithrestraints,andhead-rest,
the 20 poundball sittingontop of the neck (the head) isfirstthrustbackwards,andthenforward.
Additionally,the chesteitherhitsthe steeringwheel, oriscompressedbythe airbag,andoftenthe seat-
beltdislocatesthe 10th
rib.
These motionsresultinaconsistentpatternof injuries,whichare oftenoverlookedbytreating
physician,andmore importantly,are notreadilydetectedbyx-ray,MRI, orCAT scan.
These injuriesare:
1) Postconcussionsyndrome
2) torn ligamentsinthe cervical spine,producingeitherspinal instability,ora damageddiscs
3) thoracic outletsyndrome
4) temporomandibularjointsyndrome
5) Tietze’ssyndrome
6) Slippingribsyndrome
Each of these syndromescanbe clinicallydetected byathoroughhistory,andphysical examination,
and,more importantly,documentedbyobjective medical testingwhichcanbe usedforan early and
large settlement.
What are the stepsto followinordertoachieve thisit improvedrecovery?The firststepistodocument
that yourclienthasa validcomplaintof pain.Thisisaccomplishedusingatestdevelopedbyateamof
doctorsfrom JohnsHopkinsHospital,calledthe PainValidityTestfoundat
www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com. There have beennine articlespublishedaboutthistest,
involving794patients,authoredbyfacultymembersatJohnsHopkinsUniversity School of Medicine,
and otherinstitutions (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9).
`2
The PainValidityTesthas beenadmitted asevidence inover30 casesin8 differentstates.The Pain
ValidityTestcanpredictwhichpatientswill have abnormalitiesonobjectivemedical testingwith95%
accuracy, and predictswhowill nothave abnormalitieswith85% to 100% accuracy. Therefore,thistest
can be usedtorefute the defense claimthatthe patientisfakingormalingering,eveninthe presence of
normal MRIs, CAT scans,and x-rays. Also,the PainValidityTestcanpredictintra-operativefindingswith
93% accuracy (8),and identifydrugseekingbehaviorwith95% accuracy (9).
Researchfroma team of doctors at JohnsHopkinsHospital indicatesthatonly6% to 13% of claimants
are exaggeratingtheircomplaintsof pain (2,3,4). More importantly, 87% to 94% of all claimantshave a
validcomplaintof pain,whichwill be documentedbyobjective medical testing. (2,3,4,5,6). Actually,
more correctly,the validcomplaintof painwill be documentedbythe correctobjective medical testing.
The x-ray,MRI, and CAT scan are not the correct medical testforposttraumaticlesions.
What are the correct medical test?A trial lawyershouldunderstandthatpainisa subjective
physiological experience,whichcannotbe measured.Youcannottake a picture of pain.The bestwayto
explainthistojuryisto ask “If I had an ovenup onthe wall,andI tooka picture of it, andI handedit to
you,couldyou tell me if the ovenishot?" Then ask"If I puta thermometerinthe upand I handedto
you,and itread 375°F, couldyoutell me if the ovenishot?" These questionsclearlyandquickly
demonstrate toa jurythe difference betweenanatomical test,suchasx-rays,MRI,CT comparedto
physiological tests,suchasfacetblocks,rootblocks,andprovocative discograms,aswell asflexion
extensionx-rays,orrotational 3D-CT,ora cine-MRIof the temporomandibularjoint,ora SPECT scan or
PET scan of the brain,or vascularflowstudieswiththe armsupinarms down.Typically,atrial attorney
may nothave a clientwhohas receivedthe lattergroupof test,orin some cases,the trial attorneywas
neverevenheardof some of the testsinthe lattergroup.
What isthe real distinctionbetweenanatomical testingandphysiologicaltesting? The MRI (an
anatomical test) missesdetectionof damageddiscs78% of the time comparedto provocative
discograms(aphysiological test) (10). UprightX-raysneverreveal the pathologyof atorn ligamentina
patientwhocomplaintsof worse neckpainwitheitherflexionorextension. Onlyflexion-extensionX-
rays can detectmotion,whichproducesthe pain. Likewise,the CTmissesboneylesions56% of the time
comparedto a 3D-CT (11, 12), and EMG-Nerve conductionsstudiesmissthe vascularcompressionwhich
ispart of the pathologyof thoracicoutletsyndrome (13). That's whyclientsare somisdiagnosed.
Once the PainValidityTestisbeenobtained, the trial attorneynow knowswhetherornotitis
worthwhile topursue medical testingforhisclient.The nextquestionbecomesdeterminingwhich
medical testisappropriate.Before proper testingcanbe obtained,the client needs anaccurate
diagnosis.Researchfromanumberof medical institutionsindicatesthat40% to 80% of chronicpain
patientsare misdiagnosed,andmayreach91% to 97% for electrical injuriesand“fibromyalgia.”
(14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21). The same group of physiciansfromJohnsHopkinsHospital whodeveloped
the PainValidityTestalsodevelopedThe DiagnosticParadigm andTreatmentAlgorithm, from
www.MarylandCliicalDiagnostics.com.Afteraclientcompletesthistest, within5min.resultsare
available,whichlistsdiagnosesthathave a96% correlationwithdiagnosesJohnsHopkinsHospital
doctors(22). Basedonthese accurate diagnoses,the correctmedical testislisted.The resultsof the
`3
correct medical testare whata trial attorneyhasavailable tohimtotake to settlement.Thesetestare
readilyavailable the medical community,andprovide irrefutableevidence of pathology. Armedwiththis
information,the attorneycannowbegintoassemble the materialneeded topursue settlement.
POST-CONCUSSIONSYNDROME:Thisis a physiological phenomena,soitrequiresphysiological testing.
Pathology: The brainis like abowl of Jell-Ocontainedwithinaveryhard skull.One of the mostcommon
areas of damage is when the brainslidesforward andstrikesthe petrosalridge.Typically,thisdamages
the temporal lobe.Thiscanproduce difficultywithspeech,memory,personality,andcanproduce
partial complex seizures.The otherareasof the brainwhichare damagedor the frontal lobe,the
occipital lobe,itwastermedacoup-countercoupphenomena.Damage tothe frontal lobe will affect
smell,taste,andpersonality,whiledamage tothe occipital lobe mayproduce difficultywithvision.
Complaints:The patientoftenwillcomplaintof memoryloss,lossof smellortaste,trouble
rememberingwords,orevenperiodsof lossof consciousness.
Physical Examination: A skilledclinician willperformthe followingphysical testingona patient: testfor
sense of smell,testforsense of taste,tuningforkhearingtest,bothWeberandRhine,testeyesfor
nystagmus,checkthe pupilsreactivitytolight,andequal size,subtract7’sfrom100,give 5 cities,andask
the patienttorepeatthemin 5 minutes(alwaysgive the same 5citiessoyourememberthem),ask
similarities,I.e.howare an apple andan orange alike?(bothfruits),How are canoe anda basketball
alike?(bothfloat),Howare aflyand a tree alike?(bothliving).
Medical Tests: Whenpost-concussionsyndrome suspected, there islimitedvaluein obtaininganMRI or
CT of the brain.Thiswoulddeterminesub-dural hematomas,orotherspace occupyinglesions,butnot
the subtle intellectual changesthatare associatedwithpostconcussionsyndrome,suchasmemoryloss,
alteredspeechpatterns,change inemotion,andsometimespartial complex seizures.The objective
medical testwhichcanbe usedtodetermine elementsof post-concussionsyndrome are EEG,SPECT
scan of the brain,anda PET scan of the brain,as well asa WAISIQ test,Bender-Gestalttesting,Raven
progressive matrices,andLuriaNebraskatesting.
Treatment: There are some exerciseswhichcanhelptoimprove functionally,whereone areaof the
braintakesoverfunctionforthe damagedarea. Thisisa time consuming process,andoftennomajor
improvementisseen.
TORN LIGAMENTS IN THE SPINE OR DAMAGED DISC:
In additiontothe incorrectmedical tests,physiciansfailtoaddressthe clinical featuresof the patients
withchronicpain.One of the mostoverusedgroup of diagnosesissprainsandstrains.Sprainsare
definedasoverstretchingof the ligaments,the fibroustissuewhichholdsthe bonestogether.trainsare
definedasanoverextensionof muscle tissue,whichisattachedtothe bone by the ligaments.(23).
Sprainsandstrainsshouldlastno longerthana month.Afterthat periodof time the problemis
somethingotherthana sprainor a strain.In fact,the Departmentof HealthandHumanServicesof the
US governmenthasdefinedastrainasa disorderwhichcausesan average of 7.5 daysof restricted
`4
activity,twodaysof bed disability,and2.5days of work loss(24).So any “sprainor strain”which
persistsbeyondthe monthisincorrectlydiagnosed100% of the time,andrequiresamore directed
medical evaluation.
Pathology: inthe flexionextensioninjuriestypicallyseenwithwhiplash,the ligamentswhichholdthe
vertebral bodiestogetherare oftentorn.Thisallowsexcessivemotionof one vertebral bodyonthe
other,accentuatedbyeitherflexionorextension. However,the facetjointsof the neckare oriented
horizontally,soa tornligamentmayalsoresultinpainwhenturningthe headside toside. Additionally,
the inter-vertebral discmayalsobe damaged,butnotbe visibleonCATscan or MRI.
Complaints:The patientwill complaintof worse painleaninghisheadforward,orleaninghishead
backwards,worse paininthe neckand possiblythe armwithcoughingorsneezingorbowel
movements.
Physical Examination: One obviousexaminationistohave the patientleave hisheadforwardandlean
hisheadbackwardsand tell the physicianwhathe experiencesatthe time.The Spurlingtestconsistof
hittingthe patientontopof the head,to see thatreproducesthe painworsens the painthattheymay
feel inthe neck and/orthe arms. Thismovementcompressesthe diskinthe neck.Muscle tendernessis
oftenpresentinthe scalene muscles, spleniousmuscle. semi-spinaliscapitusmuscle,trapezius,and
othermusclesof the headand neck,butreallycontribute little tothe diagnosis.
Medical Tests: The patientshouldhave flexionextensionx-rayswithobliques,andopenmouth
odontoidviews. If there ispainwithturningthe neck,thena3D-CT withrotationwill show rotational
subluxation. Thenthe patientshouldhave facetblocks. A temporaryfacetblockgivenatthe level of
suspectedpain,andthe level aboveandbelow the suspectedlevel,since afacetjointhassensory
innervationnotonlyfromthe levelof the pain, butreceivescontributionsfromthe levelabove and
belowthe areaof physical damage. A facet denervationisthe treatmentof choice.
If there is paindownthe arms, rootblocks,of specificlevelsC3throughC7 shouldbe performed.
EMG/Nerve conductionstudiesare oftennormal since they donotmeasure sensorynerve damage very
well.Soa sensorynerve test,call the currentperceptionthreshold(Neurometer) will documentsensory
nerve damage. (25). If there'sassociatedheadache,painoverthe ear, radiatingtothe eyebrow,the
patientshouldalsohave aC2-C3 root block.
Finally, if the patientcomplainsof worse neckandarmpainwithcoughingandsneezing, orflexionor
extension, the patientshouldhave provocative discometry,C2throughC3 (18).
Treatment: If facetsyndrome isconfirmed,thenafacetdenervationwill provide relief.However,only
40% of patientsgetupto 2 yearsrelief. The definitivetreatmentisafusion.The same holdstrue for
root damage,althoughaforaminotomymayhelp,insteadof afusion.If there isa damageddisc,the
treatmentisdiscectomy (18). Infact, researchfromJohnsHopkinsHospital documentedthat63% of
`5
patientswithnormal MRI,CT and X-ray,whowere diagnosedwith“whiplash”reallyhaddamageddiscs
and neededsurgerytoimprove (18).
THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME:
Anothercommonlyoverlookeddiagnosisafterarear-endcollision isthoracicoutletsyndrome.In90% of
these cases,compressionof the brachial plexusbetweenthe anteriorandmedial scalenemuscle isthe
source of the symptoms(see Figure 1below). Only10% have vascularcompression(26,27).
FIGURE 1-Anatomyof the thoracic outlet
Pathology: The nerve,arteryand veinsupplyingthe armpassesbetweenthe anteriorandmedial
scalene muscles,but34%of the time,nerve goingdownthe armalsopass betweenthe posteriorand
medical scalene muscle(17).
Complaints: Typically,the patientcomplaintsof painand/or numbnessinthe armgoingto the lasttwo
fingers,orperhapsall fingers.The symptomsworsenwithholdthe armselevatedfor3minutesormore,
oftenseenwhentryingtohanga picture or brushinghair,or paintingaceiling,Extensionof the heador
rotatingthe headwill alsoworsensymptoms.
Physical examination:
`6
Since the pathologyof thoracicoutletsyndrome ismostlyneurological,orcombinationof neurological
and vascularpathology,the bestclinical testsisthe Roosmaneuver (26,27). A Roosmaneuverconsistof
askingthe patienttoelevate theirarms,withtheirelbowsashighastheirshoulders,andbent90° at the
elbow.The patientisthenaskedtoholdthatpositionfor2 min.,andthenaskedwhat theyfeel intheir
fingertips.If the fingertipsare numb,thenthisisa positive Roostest.The Adsonmaneuverconsistsof
feelingthe radial pulse andaskingthe patienttoturntheirheadinthe opposite direction.A diminution
of the pulse isindicativeof apositive Adsonmaneuver. Obviously, thismaneuverdetectsvascular
compression,whichoccurslessthan10% of the time in thoracicoutletsyndrome, andeventhenitis
unreliable80%of the time.
FIGURE 2- Clinical testsforthoracicoutlet
Medical tests
However,whenvascularcompressiondoesaccompanythoracicoutletsyndrome,the Roos maneuveris
a bettertestthan the Adsonmaneuver,asdemonstratedbyvascularflow studieswiththe armsupand
arms down,inthe bruise position,comparedtothe Adsonmaneuver.Over80% of the time,vascular
compressionwillbe demonstratedbythe Roos maneuver,butmissedbythe Adsonmaneuver.Again,as
`7
istrue withall sensorynerve damage,the neurometerstudiesare useful fordetectingsensorynerve
damage,andare especiallyvaluable,if the studiesare conductedwhenthe patienthastheirarmsin the
Roos position,comparedtobeingatrest(28).
FIGURE 3- Vascularflow studies
The EMG-nerve conduction studiesare of little use intryingtoestablishthe diagnosisof thoracicoutlet
syndrome. because the distance acrossErb’spointislessthan5 inches,whichdoesnotproduce reliable
EMG nerve conductionvelocitystudyresults. Neurometerstudieswiththe armsupand downwill help
documentsensorynerve compression.
Treatment: Resectionof the firstribto decompressthe thoracicoutletisthe definitivetreatmentof
choice. Some surgeonsdecompressthe brachial plexusfromabove,andresectthe anteriorandmedial
scalene muscle,andfirstrib(29).
`8
TEMPRO-MANDIBILAR JOINT SYNDROME:
Tempro-mandibularjointsyndrome (TMJ) maymanifestaspaininthe temple,the TMJ,and a clickwith
openingthe jaw.Itmay be associatedwithassociatedbruxism, whichisgrindingof the teeth.Thiscan
be causedby damage to the ligamentsand/ordiscof the jointbetweenthe skull andthe headof the
jaw. The temporomandibular(TMJ) jointisaveryunusual joint. Itslidesforward,slidessidetoside and
hinges. Itisformedbythe headof the condoyle of the jaw (mandible) insertingintoarecessinthe skull
rightbeneaththe temporal bone.
Pathology: The jawis heldagainstthe skull byligaments. The temporomandibular(TMJ) jointisavery
unusual joint. Itslidesforward,slidesside toside andhinges. Itisformedbythe head of the condoyle
of the jaw(mandible) insertingintoarecessinthe skull rightbeneaththe temporal bone. Excessive
motioncan be causedby damage to the ligamentsand/ordiscof the jointbetweenthe skull andthe
headof the jaw. In an accident,when the headisthrownforward,the jaw moveswiththe head,buthas
enoughmomentumtocontinue togoforward,evenwhenthe headstopsgoingforward,whichtears
the ligamentsholdingthe jawtothe skull. These are the stronglateral temporomandibularligaments
and twoweakermedial ligaments (8). The nervesthatsupplythe jointare the auriculotemporal and
branchesof the thirddivisionof the trigeminal nerve (8). Irritationof these nervesproducespaininthe
jaw,cheek,and/ortemple.
Complaints: Tempro-mandibularjointsyndrome (TMJ) maymanifestaspaininthe temple,the TMJ,
and a clickwithopeningthe jaw.Itmay be associatedwithassociatedbruxism, whichisgrindingof the
teeth.The patientmayalsohave ringingintheirears,andtendernessinthe sternocleidomastoid
muscle,anda sensationof a stuffyearwithreducedhearing. Othersymptomsmaybe facial pain,inthe
cheek,paininthe area of the joint,paininthe jaw line,dizziness,paininthe templeand clicksinthe jaw
on openingorclosingthe jaw (30).
Physical Examination: The patientmayfeel tendernessoverthe massetermuscle,the temporalis
muscle,andthe sternocleidomastoidmuscle.There maybe aclickin the TMJ withopeningof the jaw.
Medical Tests: If there issevere ligamentousdamage,the discwill be displaced,whichisbestseemon
cine-MRI,whichisa movie takenusinganMRI machine,while the patientopensandshutshisjaw.
Triggerpointinjectionsintothe sternocleidomastoidmusclemaygive temporaryreliefandserve asa
confirmatorytest.
Treatments: A bite plate mayhelpthe grindingof the teeth.Undernocircumstancesshouldthe teeth
be ground downto“line upthe bite.” Onlyinrare and extreme caseswouldsurgical repairof the
ligamentsbe indicated.
`9
FIGURE 4: (Image fromradiopaedia.org-usedwithpermission). Normally,the discresidesasacushion
betweenthe fossainthe skull andthe headof the mandible,calledthe condyle. The image showsan
anteriorlydislocateddiscwithoutrecapture onmouthopening.The bestwaytodetermineif the disc
displaceswithmovementistouse a Cine MRI. Thisis a MRI movie of the TMJ as the patientopensand
shutshisor her jaw.The patientisperformingthe veryactivity(openingandshuttingthe jaw) which
producessymptoms,sothe physicianhasthe opportunitytosee whatactuallyhappenswhenthe
patientopensandshutshisor herjaw.
SLIPPING RIB (“ABERRANT TIETZE’S SYNDROME”) FROM A SEAT BELT INJURY: ThisIs an often
overlooked sequelaof anauto accident. Seatbeltinjuriesoccuronthe side where the seatbeltinserts
Disc isdisplacedhere
Disc belongshere
`10
intothe restraint.Typically,thiswill be onthe rightside fora driverandleftside fora front seat
passenger.
Pathology: The 2nd
through9th
ribjointhe sternum.However,the 10th
,11th
rib and 12th
ribhave a
cartilage joiningthesebones tothe ribabove it.Thiscartilage can tear as the resultof trauma.
Complaints:The patientwill feelpain inthe loweroutsideribcage withbendingoverortwisting,or
pressure onthe 10th
and 11th
rib. Painwill be inthe side of the chestat the level of the 10th
ribin line
withthe nipple.
Physical Examination: The “hook sign”isthe bestwayto determine slippingribsyndrome. (31). A
physicianputshisfingersunderthe ribcage of a patient, atthe 10th
rib, and liftsup. If thisreproduces
the pain,thisis a positive hooksign,andthe patienthasslippingribsign.Also,if pressure atthe site of
the painintensifiesthe pain,thisiscompatible withslippedribsyndrome.
Medical Tests: Althoughwidelydiscounteddue tooveruse,thermographyoftenwill show a“hotspot”
at the site of dislocationandinflammation.
Treatment: Steroidinjectionsatthe site mayhelp,butthe ultimate treatmentisexcisionof the ribtipof
the 10th
rib, 11th
riband 12th
rib.
TIETZE’S SYNDROME (COSTOCHONDRITIS) FROM HITTING THE STEERING WHEEL OR AIRBAG:
Tietze’sSyndrome (Costochondritis)occurswhenthere is inflammationatthe junctionof the ribbones
2 through9, and breastbone (sternum).There iscartilage joiningthese bones.Thiscartilage cantearas
the resultof trauma.
Pathology: Costochondritiscanbe foundaftera traumatic injury.Typically,thisisafteracar accident,
where the driver'scheststrikesthe steeringwheel,orfromthe air bag deployment.
Complaints:Most patientswithcostochondritisexperiencepainoverthe frontof the upperchest(the
area of the breastbone).Because of seriousconditions,mostimportantlyconditionsrelatedtoheart
problems,costochondritisshouldonlybe diagnosedafterexcludingothermore seriousproblems.
Costochondritispainisusuallyworsenedbyactivityorexercise.Oftenthe painisworsenedwhentaking
a deepbreath.Thisstretchesthe inflamedcartilage andcancause significantpain.
Physical Examination: Touchingthe area involvedbycostochondritiscanbe extremelypainful forthe
patient.
Medical Tests: Althoughwidelydiscounteddue tooveruse,thermographyoftenwill show a“hotspot”
at the site of dislocationandinflammation.
Treatment:
Costochondritisusuallyrespondswell to rest. Inorderto decrease the inflammation, avoidactivities
whichcause pain,such as lifting. Applyingheat severaltimesaday to the chestcan be helpful in
`11
relievingsymptomsof costochondritis.Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatorymedications(I.e.Motrin,Advil)
may helpdecrease inflammation,whichisthe primaryproblem.While symptomsusuallyimprove within
a fewweeksandresolve completely withinafew months,some patientshave thisproblempersistsfor
months. Inpersistentcases, costochondritismaybe treatedwithcortisoneinjections.
The bestexample of whatto expectfromathoroughevaluationof whiplashandcervical spraincases
was reported inanarticle by a teamof physiciansfromJohnsHopkinsHospital,ledbyDonlinLong,MD,
PhD,who wasthe chairman of neurosurgery (18). The article wastitled“FusionforOccult
Posttraumatic Cervical Facet Injury,”andwaspublishin Neurosurgery Quarterly(Volume 16,Number
3, September2006, pages129-134). Dr. Long and histeamevaluatedseventypatientswithnormal MRI,
CT and X-Rays, whohad persistingpainafter injury(median1.7y),who hadfailedall usual conservative
formsof care.Theyhad beentoldbytheirreferringphysiciansthatthere wasnothingmore todo to
helpthem. The patients were offeredadiagnosticblockprotocol todetermine the originsof the
persistingpain.BlocksincludedC-2-3rootsbilaterally;C-2-3-4zygapophyseal joints(facetjoints) and
provocative discographyatC-3-4,4-5, 5-6, 6-7. Of the 70 patients,68 completedthe blockprotocol,and
of these 68 patients,44 of them(65%) wentonto have posteriorcervical fusionsof C-l,2,3, 4 inseveral
combinations. Seventy-nine percentof patientsachievedcomplete painrelief,while 14% received
satisfactorypainrelief.
If the trial attorneyhastheirmedical personnel evaluate their“whiplash”orcervical sprain casesafter
an auto accidentforeach of the 6 commonlyfounddisorders,thereisastronglikelihoodthatmanyif
not all 6 of the disorderswill be found,and63% will likelyneedacervical fusiontoimprove. Thiswill
provide betterpatientcare,and certainlyincrease recovery,whichhelpsbothpatientandattorney
alike.
REFERRENCES
1) HendlerN,ViernsteinM,GucerP, LongD., A preoperativescreeningtestforchronicbackpain
patientPsychosomatics. 1979 Dec;20(12):801-8.
2) Hendler,N.,Mollett,A.,Viernstein,M.,Schroeder,D.,Rybock,J.,Campbell,J.,Levin,S.,Long,D.:
"A Comparison Betweenthe MMPIand the 'Mensana ClinicBackPainTest' for Validatingthe
Complaintof ChronicBackPainin Women." Pain. No.23:243-251, 1985.
3) Hendler,N.,Mollett,A.,Viernstein,M.,Schroeder,D.,Rybock,J.,Campbell,J.,Levin,S.,Long,D.:
"A ComparisonBetweenthe MMPIand the 'HendlerBackPainTest' for Validatingthe Complaint
of ChronicBack PaininMen." The Journal of Neurological &OrthopedicMedicine&Surgery.
Vol.6, Issue 4:333-337, December,1985.
4) Hendler,N.,Mollett,A.,Talo,S.,Levin,S.: "A ComparisonBetweenthe Minnesota Multiphasic
PersonalityInventoryandthe 'MensanaClinicBackPainTest'for Validatingthe Complaintof
ChronicBack Pain." Journal of Occupational Medicine. Vol.30,No.2:98-102, February,1988.
5) Hendler,N.: "ValidatingandTreatingthe Complaint of ChronicBackPain:The Mensana Clinic
Approach." Clinical Neurosurgery. Vol.35,Chap.20:385-397, eds. Black, P.,Alexander,E.,
Barrow,D., et.al.,WilliamsandWilkins,Baltimore,1988.
`12
6) Hendler,N,Cashen,A,Hendler,S,Brigham, C,Osborne, P,LeRoy,P.,Graybill,T,Catlett,L.,
Gronblad,M. A Multi-CenterStudyforValidatingThe Complaintof ChronicBack,NeckandLimb
PainUsing“The MensanaClinicPainValidityTest.” ForensicExaminer,Vol. 14,# 2, pp.41-49,
Summer2005.
7) Hendler,N. andBaker,A.An Internetquestionnaire topredictthe presence orabsence of
organicpathologyinchronicback, neckand limbpainpatients, PanArabJournal of
Neurosurgery, Vol.12,No.1, pp:15-24, April,2008.
8) DavisR, HendlerN,BakerA (2016) PredictingMedical TestResultsandIntra-Operative Findings
inChronicPain PatientsUsingthe On-Line “PainValidityTest”. JAnesthCritCare OpenAccess
5(1): 00174. DOI:10.15406/jaccoa.2016.05.00174
9) HendlerN (2017) AnInternetbasedQuestionnaire toIdentifyDrugSeekingBehaviorina Patient
inthe ED and Office. JAnesthCritCare OpenAccess8(3): 00306.
DOI:10.15406/jaccoa.2017.08.00306
10) SandhuHS, Sanchez-CasoLP,Parvataneni HK,CammisaFPJr,Girardi FP,GhelmanB. Association
betweenfindingsof provocative discographyandvertebral endplate signal changesasseenon
MRI., J Spinal Disord.,Oct;13(5):438-43, 2000.
11) Hendler,N., Zinreich,J.,Kozikowski,J.: Three-DimensionalCTValidationof Physical Complaints
in`PsychogenicPain’Patients. Psychosomatics. Vol. 34,No. 1:90-96, January/February,1993.
12) Zinreich SJ, LongDM, DavisR, QuinnCB, McAfee PC, Wang H.Three-dimensionalCTimagingin
postsurgical "failedback"syndrome. JComputAssistTomogr. 1990 Jul-Aug;14(4):574-80.
13) Empting-Koschorke,L.D.,Hendler,N.,Kolodny,A.L.,Kraus,H.: "TipsonHard-to-Manage Pain
Syndromes." PatientCare. Vol.24,No.8:26-46, April 30, 1990
14) Hendler,N.,Kozikowski,J.:1993 “Overlookedphysical diagnosesinchronicpainpatientsinvolved
inlitigation.”Psychosomatics 34(6):494-501.
15) HendlerN.,Bergson,C.,Morrison,C.1996 “ Overlookedphysical diagnosesinchronicpain
patientsinlitigation,Part2.“ Psychosomatics.37(6):509-517.
16) HendlerN.2002 “Differentialdiagnosisof complexregional painsyndrome.“ PanArab Journal
of Neurosurgery Oct;6(2):1-9.
17) DellonAL,Andronian E,RossonGD. 2009 “CRPSof the upperor lowerextremity:surgical
treatmentoutcomes.”J.Brachial Plex PeripherNerve Inj. Feb;4(1):1-7
18) Long D, DavisR, SpeedW,HendlerN.2006 “Fusionforoccultpost-traumaticcervical facet
injury.”Neurosurg.Q. 16(3):129-135.
19) Hendler,N.2005 “OverlookedDiagnosesinElectricShockAndLightningStrikeSurvivors.”
Journal of Occupational andEnvironmental Medicine,Vol.47,Aug.No.8, pp. 796-805.
20) Hendler,N,andRomano,T. 2006 “ FibromyalgiaOver-Diagnosed 97% of The Time:Chronic
PainDue To ThoracicOutlet Syndrome,Acromo-ClavicularJointSyndrome, DisruptedDisc,
Nerve Entrapments,FacetSyndrome and OtherDisordersMistakenly CalledFibromyalgia.”
Journal of Anesthesia&PainMedicine, Volume 1:1: 1-7 .
21) Landro,L ( laura.landro@wsj.com)The Wall StreetJournal,Nov.17,2013.
22) Hendler,N.,Berzoksky,C.andDavis,R.J.2007 “Comparison of Clinical DiagnosesVersus
ComputerizedPaininthe Neck,BackandLimbs.” Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery,October:8-
17,
`13
23) Bonica,JJ andTeitz,D , in The Managementof Pain,Lea & Febiger;2ndedition, p.375-376,
April 1990.
24) DHHS # PHS,1587-1592, 1987.
25) Raj,PP, Chado,HN,Angst,M, Heavner,J,Dotson,R, Brandstater,ME, Johnson,B,Parris,W,
Finch,P,Shahani,B, Dhand,U, Mekhail,N,Daoud,E, Hendler,N,Somerville,J,Wallace,M,
Panchal,S,Glusman,S, Jay,GW, Palliyath,S,Longton,W,Irving,G,:PainlessElectrodiagnostic
CurrentPerceptionThresholdValuesinCRPSSubjectsandHealthyControls:A Multicenter
Study,PainPractice,Vol.1,#1, pp 53-60, 2001.
26) Roos DB., Historical perspectivesandanatomicconsiderations. Thoracicoutletsyndrome.Semin
Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1996 Apr;8(2):183-9.
27) Roos DB.,Thoracic outlet syndrome is underdiagnosed.Muscle Nerve. 1999 Jan;22(1):126-9
28) Orlando MS, Likes KC, Mirza S, Cao Y, Cohen A, Lum YW, Freischlag JA. Preoperative Duplex
Scanningisa Helpful DiagnosticTool inNeurogenic ThoracicOutletSyndrome.VascEndovascular
Surg. 2016 Jan;50(1):29-32.
29) Hempel G.K.,Shutze W.P.,AndersonJ.F.,Bukhari H.I.,770 consecutive supraclavicularfirstrib
resectionforthoracicoutletsyndrome,AnnVasSurg.,Sept10(5):pp.456-63, 1996.
30) Hendler,N, Facial painfromvarioussources-diagnosesanddifferential diagnoses,Dental,Oral
and Craniofacial Research, 2017, Volume 3(5):1-5.
31) GregoryPL, BiswasAC,Batt ME, Musculoskeletal problemsof the chestwall inathletes, Sports
Med. 2002;32(4):235-50.

More Related Content

Similar to How Do You Get $200,000 for a whiplash case

Why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed
Why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosedWhy chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed
Why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosedNelson Hendler
 
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painfulNelson Hendler
 
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painfulNelson Hendler
 
AMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdf
AMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdfAMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdf
AMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdfShahriarAhmedSujoy
 
2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_trauma
2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_trauma2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_trauma
2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_traumasadaf chandio
 
Transcranial Brain Stimulation: Science and Ethics
Transcranial Brain Stimulation: Science and EthicsTranscranial Brain Stimulation: Science and Ethics
Transcranial Brain Stimulation: Science and EthicsJames David Saul
 
Emergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnath
Emergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnathEmergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnath
Emergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnathTeleradiology Solutions
 
Differential Diagnosis Generation
Differential Diagnosis GenerationDifferential Diagnosis Generation
Differential Diagnosis GenerationClinton Pong
 
Strategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Case
Strategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury CaseStrategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Case
Strategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury CaseEdward K. Le
 
Walmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save moneyWalmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save moneyNelson Hendler
 
Week 3 the neural basis of consciousness overview of important clinical cas...
Week 3  the neural basis of consciousness  overview of important clinical cas...Week 3  the neural basis of consciousness  overview of important clinical cas...
Week 3 the neural basis of consciousness overview of important clinical cas...Nao (Naotsugu) Tsuchiya
 

Similar to How Do You Get $200,000 for a whiplash case (17)

Why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed
Why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosedWhy chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed
Why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed
 
Paper
PaperPaper
Paper
 
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
 
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
 
Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1
Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1
Progress in Clinical Neurosciences Vol 28, Chapter 1
 
AMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdf
AMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdfAMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdf
AMC Clinical exam preparation Course ! AMC part 2 notes.pdf
 
2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_trauma
2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_trauma2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_trauma
2009 11 05-boyko-abdo_trauma
 
Pediatric neuroimaging
Pediatric neuroimagingPediatric neuroimaging
Pediatric neuroimaging
 
Evidence-Based Medicine Overview
Evidence-Based Medicine OverviewEvidence-Based Medicine Overview
Evidence-Based Medicine Overview
 
cek.pptx
cek.pptxcek.pptx
cek.pptx
 
1. clinical reasoning
1. clinical reasoning1. clinical reasoning
1. clinical reasoning
 
Transcranial Brain Stimulation: Science and Ethics
Transcranial Brain Stimulation: Science and EthicsTranscranial Brain Stimulation: Science and Ethics
Transcranial Brain Stimulation: Science and Ethics
 
Emergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnath
Emergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnathEmergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnath
Emergency ct-is it being overused dr.amarnath
 
Differential Diagnosis Generation
Differential Diagnosis GenerationDifferential Diagnosis Generation
Differential Diagnosis Generation
 
Strategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Case
Strategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury CaseStrategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Case
Strategies to Maximize Recovery in the Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Case
 
Walmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save moneyWalmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save money
 
Week 3 the neural basis of consciousness overview of important clinical cas...
Week 3  the neural basis of consciousness  overview of important clinical cas...Week 3  the neural basis of consciousness  overview of important clinical cas...
Week 3 the neural basis of consciousness overview of important clinical cas...
 

More from Nelson Hendler

Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docxThird Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docxNelson Hendler
 
GIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdfGIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdfNelson Hendler
 
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdfTop_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdfNelson Hendler
 
Thermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic painThermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic painNelson Hendler
 
Alternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic painAlternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic painNelson Hendler
 
Anatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of painAnatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of painNelson Hendler
 
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcoticsMemory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcoticsNelson Hendler
 
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by teamThoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by teamNelson Hendler
 
Bipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactoneBipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactoneNelson Hendler
 
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthyEmg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthyNelson Hendler
 
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuriesValuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuriesNelson Hendler
 
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staffHeadache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staffNelson Hendler
 
Medication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiodsMedication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiodsNelson Hendler
 
List of authors of articles
List of authors of articlesList of authors of articles
List of authors of articlesNelson Hendler
 
List of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of ArticlesList of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of ArticlesNelson Hendler
 
Three Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndrome
Three Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndromeThree Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndrome
Three Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndromeNelson Hendler
 
Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...
Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...
Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...Nelson Hendler
 
Letter from Tom Vesper
Letter from Tom Vesper Letter from Tom Vesper
Letter from Tom Vesper Nelson Hendler
 

More from Nelson Hendler (20)

Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docxThird Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
 
GIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdfGIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdf
 
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdfTop_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
 
Thermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic painThermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic pain
 
Alternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic painAlternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic pain
 
Si joint dx and rx
Si joint dx and rxSi joint dx and rx
Si joint dx and rx
 
Anatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of painAnatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of pain
 
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcoticsMemory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
 
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by teamThoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by team
 
Bipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactoneBipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactone
 
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthyEmg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
 
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuriesValuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
 
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staffHeadache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
 
Medication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiodsMedication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiods
 
List of authors of articles
List of authors of articlesList of authors of articles
List of authors of articles
 
List of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of ArticlesList of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of Articles
 
Proctoring Handbook
Proctoring HandbookProctoring Handbook
Proctoring Handbook
 
Three Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndrome
Three Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndromeThree Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndrome
Three Dimensional CT Imaging in post-surgical "failed back" syndrome
 
Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...
Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...
Association between finding of provocativediscogram and vertebral endplate si...
 
Letter from Tom Vesper
Letter from Tom Vesper Letter from Tom Vesper
Letter from Tom Vesper
 

Recently uploaded

👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...rajnisinghkjn
 
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...dilbirsingh0889
 
Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...
Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...
Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile Call Girls
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...Janvi Singh
 
Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...
Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...
Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...gragneelam30
 
Circulatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanisms
Circulatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanismsCirculatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanisms
Circulatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanismsMedicoseAcademics
 
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...Dipal Arora
 
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...dishamehta3332
 
Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...
Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...
Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...chanderprakash5506
 
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptxANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptxSwetaba Besh
 
Chennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Chennai
Chennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in ChennaiChennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Chennai
Chennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Chennaikhalifaescort01
 
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana GuptaLifecare Centre
 
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan 087776558899
 
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book nowChennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book nowtanudubay92
 
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableJanvi Singh
 
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their RegulationCardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their RegulationMedicoseAcademics
 
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableSteve Davis
 
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room DeliveryCall 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room DeliveryJyoti singh
 
Bhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICE
Bhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICEBhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICE
Bhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICErahuljha3240
 
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptxANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptxSwetaba Besh
 

Recently uploaded (20)

👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
 
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...
💞 Safe And Secure Call Girls Coimbatore🧿 6378878445 🧿 High Class Coimbatore C...
 
Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...
Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...
Guntur Call Girl Service 📞6297126446📞Just Call Divya📲 Call Girl In Guntur No ...
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...
Call Girls Service Jaipur {9521753030 } ❤️VVIP BHAWNA Call Girl in Jaipur Raj...
 
Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...
Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...
Call Girls Bangalore - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 💯Call Us 🔝 6378878445 🔝 💃 ...
 
Circulatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanisms
Circulatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanismsCirculatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanisms
Circulatory Shock, types and stages, compensatory mechanisms
 
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
 
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
 
Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...
Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...
Russian Call Girls In Pune 👉 Just CALL ME: 9352988975 ✅❤️💯low cost unlimited ...
 
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptxANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEM.pptx
 
Chennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Chennai
Chennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in ChennaiChennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Chennai
Chennai Call Girls Service {7857862533 } ❤️VVIP ROCKY Call Girl in Chennai
 
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
 
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
 
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book nowChennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
 
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Mussoorie Just Call 8854095900 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their RegulationCardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
Cardiac Output, Venous Return, and Their Regulation
 
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room DeliveryCall 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
Call 8250092165 Patna Call Girls ₹4.5k Cash Payment With Room Delivery
 
Bhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICE
Bhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICEBhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICE
Bhopal❤CALL GIRL 9352988975 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Bhopal ESCORT SERVICE
 
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptxANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY OF RESPIRATORY SYSTEM.pptx
 

How Do You Get $200,000 for a whiplash case

  • 1. `1 How Do You Get$200,000 From A WhiplashCase? By NelsonHendler,MD, MS and WilliamGallagher,D.C. (seniorauthorcontact-email NelsonHendler,MD,MS at DocNelse@aol.com) The answerto thistitle questionissimple. Getacorrect diagnosis. Inordertoimprove yourrecovery fromany whiplashcase,softtissue injurywithnoobjective medical findings,oracervical sprain,there are several easy stepsatrial attorneycan follow.Firstandforemostistoobtainanaccurate diagnosis. Often,atrial attorneyasa clientwhohasbeenrear-ended,sufferedahyperextensionhyperflexion injury,asnormal x-rays,MRIs,and CAT scans,and has had numeroussessionsof physical therapyand/or chiropracticcare. The treatingphysiciantellsthe trial attorney"Ican't findanythingwrong.Itmustbe cervical sprainor strain."Nothingcouldbe furtherfromthe truth. JohnsHopkinsHospital physicians reportthat 63% of these patientsneedsurgerytoimprove (18). It isimportantto understandthe mechanicsof arear endcollision.Evenwithrestraints,andhead-rest, the 20 poundball sittingontop of the neck (the head) isfirstthrustbackwards,andthenforward. Additionally,the chesteitherhitsthe steeringwheel, oriscompressedbythe airbag,andoftenthe seat- beltdislocatesthe 10th rib. These motionsresultinaconsistentpatternof injuries,whichare oftenoverlookedbytreating physician,andmore importantly,are notreadilydetectedbyx-ray,MRI, orCAT scan. These injuriesare: 1) Postconcussionsyndrome 2) torn ligamentsinthe cervical spine,producingeitherspinal instability,ora damageddiscs 3) thoracic outletsyndrome 4) temporomandibularjointsyndrome 5) Tietze’ssyndrome 6) Slippingribsyndrome Each of these syndromescanbe clinicallydetected byathoroughhistory,andphysical examination, and,more importantly,documentedbyobjective medical testingwhichcanbe usedforan early and large settlement. What are the stepsto followinordertoachieve thisit improvedrecovery?The firststepistodocument that yourclienthasa validcomplaintof pain.Thisisaccomplishedusingatestdevelopedbyateamof doctorsfrom JohnsHopkinsHospital,calledthe PainValidityTestfoundat www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com. There have beennine articlespublishedaboutthistest, involving794patients,authoredbyfacultymembersatJohnsHopkinsUniversity School of Medicine, and otherinstitutions (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9).
  • 2. `2 The PainValidityTesthas beenadmitted asevidence inover30 casesin8 differentstates.The Pain ValidityTestcanpredictwhichpatientswill have abnormalitiesonobjectivemedical testingwith95% accuracy, and predictswhowill nothave abnormalitieswith85% to 100% accuracy. Therefore,thistest can be usedtorefute the defense claimthatthe patientisfakingormalingering,eveninthe presence of normal MRIs, CAT scans,and x-rays. Also,the PainValidityTestcanpredictintra-operativefindingswith 93% accuracy (8),and identifydrugseekingbehaviorwith95% accuracy (9). Researchfroma team of doctors at JohnsHopkinsHospital indicatesthatonly6% to 13% of claimants are exaggeratingtheircomplaintsof pain (2,3,4). More importantly, 87% to 94% of all claimantshave a validcomplaintof pain,whichwill be documentedbyobjective medical testing. (2,3,4,5,6). Actually, more correctly,the validcomplaintof painwill be documentedbythe correctobjective medical testing. The x-ray,MRI, and CAT scan are not the correct medical testforposttraumaticlesions. What are the correct medical test?A trial lawyershouldunderstandthatpainisa subjective physiological experience,whichcannotbe measured.Youcannottake a picture of pain.The bestwayto explainthistojuryisto ask “If I had an ovenup onthe wall,andI tooka picture of it, andI handedit to you,couldyou tell me if the ovenishot?" Then ask"If I puta thermometerinthe upand I handedto you,and itread 375°F, couldyoutell me if the ovenishot?" These questionsclearlyandquickly demonstrate toa jurythe difference betweenanatomical test,suchasx-rays,MRI,CT comparedto physiological tests,suchasfacetblocks,rootblocks,andprovocative discograms,aswell asflexion extensionx-rays,orrotational 3D-CT,ora cine-MRIof the temporomandibularjoint,ora SPECT scan or PET scan of the brain,or vascularflowstudieswiththe armsupinarms down.Typically,atrial attorney may nothave a clientwhohas receivedthe lattergroupof test,orin some cases,the trial attorneywas neverevenheardof some of the testsinthe lattergroup. What isthe real distinctionbetweenanatomical testingandphysiologicaltesting? The MRI (an anatomical test) missesdetectionof damageddiscs78% of the time comparedto provocative discograms(aphysiological test) (10). UprightX-raysneverreveal the pathologyof atorn ligamentina patientwhocomplaintsof worse neckpainwitheitherflexionorextension. Onlyflexion-extensionX- rays can detectmotion,whichproducesthe pain. Likewise,the CTmissesboneylesions56% of the time comparedto a 3D-CT (11, 12), and EMG-Nerve conductionsstudiesmissthe vascularcompressionwhich ispart of the pathologyof thoracicoutletsyndrome (13). That's whyclientsare somisdiagnosed. Once the PainValidityTestisbeenobtained, the trial attorneynow knowswhetherornotitis worthwhile topursue medical testingforhisclient.The nextquestionbecomesdeterminingwhich medical testisappropriate.Before proper testingcanbe obtained,the client needs anaccurate diagnosis.Researchfromanumberof medical institutionsindicatesthat40% to 80% of chronicpain patientsare misdiagnosed,andmayreach91% to 97% for electrical injuriesand“fibromyalgia.” (14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21). The same group of physiciansfromJohnsHopkinsHospital whodeveloped the PainValidityTestalsodevelopedThe DiagnosticParadigm andTreatmentAlgorithm, from www.MarylandCliicalDiagnostics.com.Afteraclientcompletesthistest, within5min.resultsare available,whichlistsdiagnosesthathave a96% correlationwithdiagnosesJohnsHopkinsHospital doctors(22). Basedonthese accurate diagnoses,the correctmedical testislisted.The resultsof the
  • 3. `3 correct medical testare whata trial attorneyhasavailable tohimtotake to settlement.Thesetestare readilyavailable the medical community,andprovide irrefutableevidence of pathology. Armedwiththis information,the attorneycannowbegintoassemble the materialneeded topursue settlement. POST-CONCUSSIONSYNDROME:Thisis a physiological phenomena,soitrequiresphysiological testing. Pathology: The brainis like abowl of Jell-Ocontainedwithinaveryhard skull.One of the mostcommon areas of damage is when the brainslidesforward andstrikesthe petrosalridge.Typically,thisdamages the temporal lobe.Thiscanproduce difficultywithspeech,memory,personality,andcanproduce partial complex seizures.The otherareasof the brainwhichare damagedor the frontal lobe,the occipital lobe,itwastermedacoup-countercoupphenomena.Damage tothe frontal lobe will affect smell,taste,andpersonality,whiledamage tothe occipital lobe mayproduce difficultywithvision. Complaints:The patientoftenwillcomplaintof memoryloss,lossof smellortaste,trouble rememberingwords,orevenperiodsof lossof consciousness. Physical Examination: A skilledclinician willperformthe followingphysical testingona patient: testfor sense of smell,testforsense of taste,tuningforkhearingtest,bothWeberandRhine,testeyesfor nystagmus,checkthe pupilsreactivitytolight,andequal size,subtract7’sfrom100,give 5 cities,andask the patienttorepeatthemin 5 minutes(alwaysgive the same 5citiessoyourememberthem),ask similarities,I.e.howare an apple andan orange alike?(bothfruits),How are canoe anda basketball alike?(bothfloat),Howare aflyand a tree alike?(bothliving). Medical Tests: Whenpost-concussionsyndrome suspected, there islimitedvaluein obtaininganMRI or CT of the brain.Thiswoulddeterminesub-dural hematomas,orotherspace occupyinglesions,butnot the subtle intellectual changesthatare associatedwithpostconcussionsyndrome,suchasmemoryloss, alteredspeechpatterns,change inemotion,andsometimespartial complex seizures.The objective medical testwhichcanbe usedtodetermine elementsof post-concussionsyndrome are EEG,SPECT scan of the brain,anda PET scan of the brain,as well asa WAISIQ test,Bender-Gestalttesting,Raven progressive matrices,andLuriaNebraskatesting. Treatment: There are some exerciseswhichcanhelptoimprove functionally,whereone areaof the braintakesoverfunctionforthe damagedarea. Thisisa time consuming process,andoftennomajor improvementisseen. TORN LIGAMENTS IN THE SPINE OR DAMAGED DISC: In additiontothe incorrectmedical tests,physiciansfailtoaddressthe clinical featuresof the patients withchronicpain.One of the mostoverusedgroup of diagnosesissprainsandstrains.Sprainsare definedasoverstretchingof the ligaments,the fibroustissuewhichholdsthe bonestogether.trainsare definedasanoverextensionof muscle tissue,whichisattachedtothe bone by the ligaments.(23). Sprainsandstrainsshouldlastno longerthana month.Afterthat periodof time the problemis somethingotherthana sprainor a strain.In fact,the Departmentof HealthandHumanServicesof the US governmenthasdefinedastrainasa disorderwhichcausesan average of 7.5 daysof restricted
  • 4. `4 activity,twodaysof bed disability,and2.5days of work loss(24).So any “sprainor strain”which persistsbeyondthe monthisincorrectlydiagnosed100% of the time,andrequiresamore directed medical evaluation. Pathology: inthe flexionextensioninjuriestypicallyseenwithwhiplash,the ligamentswhichholdthe vertebral bodiestogetherare oftentorn.Thisallowsexcessivemotionof one vertebral bodyonthe other,accentuatedbyeitherflexionorextension. However,the facetjointsof the neckare oriented horizontally,soa tornligamentmayalsoresultinpainwhenturningthe headside toside. Additionally, the inter-vertebral discmayalsobe damaged,butnotbe visibleonCATscan or MRI. Complaints:The patientwill complaintof worse painleaninghisheadforward,orleaninghishead backwards,worse paininthe neckand possiblythe armwithcoughingorsneezingorbowel movements. Physical Examination: One obviousexaminationistohave the patientleave hisheadforwardandlean hisheadbackwardsand tell the physicianwhathe experiencesatthe time.The Spurlingtestconsistof hittingthe patientontopof the head,to see thatreproducesthe painworsens the painthattheymay feel inthe neck and/orthe arms. Thismovementcompressesthe diskinthe neck.Muscle tendernessis oftenpresentinthe scalene muscles, spleniousmuscle. semi-spinaliscapitusmuscle,trapezius,and othermusclesof the headand neck,butreallycontribute little tothe diagnosis. Medical Tests: The patientshouldhave flexionextensionx-rayswithobliques,andopenmouth odontoidviews. If there ispainwithturningthe neck,thena3D-CT withrotationwill show rotational subluxation. Thenthe patientshouldhave facetblocks. A temporaryfacetblockgivenatthe level of suspectedpain,andthe level aboveandbelow the suspectedlevel,since afacetjointhassensory innervationnotonlyfromthe levelof the pain, butreceivescontributionsfromthe levelabove and belowthe areaof physical damage. A facet denervationisthe treatmentof choice. If there is paindownthe arms, rootblocks,of specificlevelsC3throughC7 shouldbe performed. EMG/Nerve conductionstudiesare oftennormal since they donotmeasure sensorynerve damage very well.Soa sensorynerve test,call the currentperceptionthreshold(Neurometer) will documentsensory nerve damage. (25). If there'sassociatedheadache,painoverthe ear, radiatingtothe eyebrow,the patientshouldalsohave aC2-C3 root block. Finally, if the patientcomplainsof worse neckandarmpainwithcoughingandsneezing, orflexionor extension, the patientshouldhave provocative discometry,C2throughC3 (18). Treatment: If facetsyndrome isconfirmed,thenafacetdenervationwill provide relief.However,only 40% of patientsgetupto 2 yearsrelief. The definitivetreatmentisafusion.The same holdstrue for root damage,althoughaforaminotomymayhelp,insteadof afusion.If there isa damageddisc,the treatmentisdiscectomy (18). Infact, researchfromJohnsHopkinsHospital documentedthat63% of
  • 5. `5 patientswithnormal MRI,CT and X-ray,whowere diagnosedwith“whiplash”reallyhaddamageddiscs and neededsurgerytoimprove (18). THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME: Anothercommonlyoverlookeddiagnosisafterarear-endcollision isthoracicoutletsyndrome.In90% of these cases,compressionof the brachial plexusbetweenthe anteriorandmedial scalenemuscle isthe source of the symptoms(see Figure 1below). Only10% have vascularcompression(26,27). FIGURE 1-Anatomyof the thoracic outlet Pathology: The nerve,arteryand veinsupplyingthe armpassesbetweenthe anteriorandmedial scalene muscles,but34%of the time,nerve goingdownthe armalsopass betweenthe posteriorand medical scalene muscle(17). Complaints: Typically,the patientcomplaintsof painand/or numbnessinthe armgoingto the lasttwo fingers,orperhapsall fingers.The symptomsworsenwithholdthe armselevatedfor3minutesormore, oftenseenwhentryingtohanga picture or brushinghair,or paintingaceiling,Extensionof the heador rotatingthe headwill alsoworsensymptoms. Physical examination:
  • 6. `6 Since the pathologyof thoracicoutletsyndrome ismostlyneurological,orcombinationof neurological and vascularpathology,the bestclinical testsisthe Roosmaneuver (26,27). A Roosmaneuverconsistof askingthe patienttoelevate theirarms,withtheirelbowsashighastheirshoulders,andbent90° at the elbow.The patientisthenaskedtoholdthatpositionfor2 min.,andthenaskedwhat theyfeel intheir fingertips.If the fingertipsare numb,thenthisisa positive Roostest.The Adsonmaneuverconsistsof feelingthe radial pulse andaskingthe patienttoturntheirheadinthe opposite direction.A diminution of the pulse isindicativeof apositive Adsonmaneuver. Obviously, thismaneuverdetectsvascular compression,whichoccurslessthan10% of the time in thoracicoutletsyndrome, andeventhenitis unreliable80%of the time. FIGURE 2- Clinical testsforthoracicoutlet Medical tests However,whenvascularcompressiondoesaccompanythoracicoutletsyndrome,the Roos maneuveris a bettertestthan the Adsonmaneuver,asdemonstratedbyvascularflow studieswiththe armsupand arms down,inthe bruise position,comparedtothe Adsonmaneuver.Over80% of the time,vascular compressionwillbe demonstratedbythe Roos maneuver,butmissedbythe Adsonmaneuver.Again,as
  • 7. `7 istrue withall sensorynerve damage,the neurometerstudiesare useful fordetectingsensorynerve damage,andare especiallyvaluable,if the studiesare conductedwhenthe patienthastheirarmsin the Roos position,comparedtobeingatrest(28). FIGURE 3- Vascularflow studies The EMG-nerve conduction studiesare of little use intryingtoestablishthe diagnosisof thoracicoutlet syndrome. because the distance acrossErb’spointislessthan5 inches,whichdoesnotproduce reliable EMG nerve conductionvelocitystudyresults. Neurometerstudieswiththe armsupand downwill help documentsensorynerve compression. Treatment: Resectionof the firstribto decompressthe thoracicoutletisthe definitivetreatmentof choice. Some surgeonsdecompressthe brachial plexusfromabove,andresectthe anteriorandmedial scalene muscle,andfirstrib(29).
  • 8. `8 TEMPRO-MANDIBILAR JOINT SYNDROME: Tempro-mandibularjointsyndrome (TMJ) maymanifestaspaininthe temple,the TMJ,and a clickwith openingthe jaw.Itmay be associatedwithassociatedbruxism, whichisgrindingof the teeth.Thiscan be causedby damage to the ligamentsand/ordiscof the jointbetweenthe skull andthe headof the jaw. The temporomandibular(TMJ) jointisaveryunusual joint. Itslidesforward,slidessidetoside and hinges. Itisformedbythe headof the condoyle of the jaw (mandible) insertingintoarecessinthe skull rightbeneaththe temporal bone. Pathology: The jawis heldagainstthe skull byligaments. The temporomandibular(TMJ) jointisavery unusual joint. Itslidesforward,slidesside toside andhinges. Itisformedbythe head of the condoyle of the jaw(mandible) insertingintoarecessinthe skull rightbeneaththe temporal bone. Excessive motioncan be causedby damage to the ligamentsand/ordiscof the jointbetweenthe skull andthe headof the jaw. In an accident,when the headisthrownforward,the jaw moveswiththe head,buthas enoughmomentumtocontinue togoforward,evenwhenthe headstopsgoingforward,whichtears the ligamentsholdingthe jawtothe skull. These are the stronglateral temporomandibularligaments and twoweakermedial ligaments (8). The nervesthatsupplythe jointare the auriculotemporal and branchesof the thirddivisionof the trigeminal nerve (8). Irritationof these nervesproducespaininthe jaw,cheek,and/ortemple. Complaints: Tempro-mandibularjointsyndrome (TMJ) maymanifestaspaininthe temple,the TMJ, and a clickwithopeningthe jaw.Itmay be associatedwithassociatedbruxism, whichisgrindingof the teeth.The patientmayalsohave ringingintheirears,andtendernessinthe sternocleidomastoid muscle,anda sensationof a stuffyearwithreducedhearing. Othersymptomsmaybe facial pain,inthe cheek,paininthe area of the joint,paininthe jaw line,dizziness,paininthe templeand clicksinthe jaw on openingorclosingthe jaw (30). Physical Examination: The patientmayfeel tendernessoverthe massetermuscle,the temporalis muscle,andthe sternocleidomastoidmuscle.There maybe aclickin the TMJ withopeningof the jaw. Medical Tests: If there issevere ligamentousdamage,the discwill be displaced,whichisbestseemon cine-MRI,whichisa movie takenusinganMRI machine,while the patientopensandshutshisjaw. Triggerpointinjectionsintothe sternocleidomastoidmusclemaygive temporaryreliefandserve asa confirmatorytest. Treatments: A bite plate mayhelpthe grindingof the teeth.Undernocircumstancesshouldthe teeth be ground downto“line upthe bite.” Onlyinrare and extreme caseswouldsurgical repairof the ligamentsbe indicated.
  • 9. `9 FIGURE 4: (Image fromradiopaedia.org-usedwithpermission). Normally,the discresidesasacushion betweenthe fossainthe skull andthe headof the mandible,calledthe condyle. The image showsan anteriorlydislocateddiscwithoutrecapture onmouthopening.The bestwaytodetermineif the disc displaceswithmovementistouse a Cine MRI. Thisis a MRI movie of the TMJ as the patientopensand shutshisor her jaw.The patientisperformingthe veryactivity(openingandshuttingthe jaw) which producessymptoms,sothe physicianhasthe opportunitytosee whatactuallyhappenswhenthe patientopensandshutshisor herjaw. SLIPPING RIB (“ABERRANT TIETZE’S SYNDROME”) FROM A SEAT BELT INJURY: ThisIs an often overlooked sequelaof anauto accident. Seatbeltinjuriesoccuronthe side where the seatbeltinserts Disc isdisplacedhere Disc belongshere
  • 10. `10 intothe restraint.Typically,thiswill be onthe rightside fora driverandleftside fora front seat passenger. Pathology: The 2nd through9th ribjointhe sternum.However,the 10th ,11th rib and 12th ribhave a cartilage joiningthesebones tothe ribabove it.Thiscartilage can tear as the resultof trauma. Complaints:The patientwill feelpain inthe loweroutsideribcage withbendingoverortwisting,or pressure onthe 10th and 11th rib. Painwill be inthe side of the chestat the level of the 10th ribin line withthe nipple. Physical Examination: The “hook sign”isthe bestwayto determine slippingribsyndrome. (31). A physicianputshisfingersunderthe ribcage of a patient, atthe 10th rib, and liftsup. If thisreproduces the pain,thisis a positive hooksign,andthe patienthasslippingribsign.Also,if pressure atthe site of the painintensifiesthe pain,thisiscompatible withslippedribsyndrome. Medical Tests: Althoughwidelydiscounteddue tooveruse,thermographyoftenwill show a“hotspot” at the site of dislocationandinflammation. Treatment: Steroidinjectionsatthe site mayhelp,butthe ultimate treatmentisexcisionof the ribtipof the 10th rib, 11th riband 12th rib. TIETZE’S SYNDROME (COSTOCHONDRITIS) FROM HITTING THE STEERING WHEEL OR AIRBAG: Tietze’sSyndrome (Costochondritis)occurswhenthere is inflammationatthe junctionof the ribbones 2 through9, and breastbone (sternum).There iscartilage joiningthese bones.Thiscartilage cantearas the resultof trauma. Pathology: Costochondritiscanbe foundaftera traumatic injury.Typically,thisisafteracar accident, where the driver'scheststrikesthe steeringwheel,orfromthe air bag deployment. Complaints:Most patientswithcostochondritisexperiencepainoverthe frontof the upperchest(the area of the breastbone).Because of seriousconditions,mostimportantlyconditionsrelatedtoheart problems,costochondritisshouldonlybe diagnosedafterexcludingothermore seriousproblems. Costochondritispainisusuallyworsenedbyactivityorexercise.Oftenthe painisworsenedwhentaking a deepbreath.Thisstretchesthe inflamedcartilage andcancause significantpain. Physical Examination: Touchingthe area involvedbycostochondritiscanbe extremelypainful forthe patient. Medical Tests: Althoughwidelydiscounteddue tooveruse,thermographyoftenwill show a“hotspot” at the site of dislocationandinflammation. Treatment: Costochondritisusuallyrespondswell to rest. Inorderto decrease the inflammation, avoidactivities whichcause pain,such as lifting. Applyingheat severaltimesaday to the chestcan be helpful in
  • 11. `11 relievingsymptomsof costochondritis.Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatorymedications(I.e.Motrin,Advil) may helpdecrease inflammation,whichisthe primaryproblem.While symptomsusuallyimprove within a fewweeksandresolve completely withinafew months,some patientshave thisproblempersistsfor months. Inpersistentcases, costochondritismaybe treatedwithcortisoneinjections. The bestexample of whatto expectfromathoroughevaluationof whiplashandcervical spraincases was reported inanarticle by a teamof physiciansfromJohnsHopkinsHospital,ledbyDonlinLong,MD, PhD,who wasthe chairman of neurosurgery (18). The article wastitled“FusionforOccult Posttraumatic Cervical Facet Injury,”andwaspublishin Neurosurgery Quarterly(Volume 16,Number 3, September2006, pages129-134). Dr. Long and histeamevaluatedseventypatientswithnormal MRI, CT and X-Rays, whohad persistingpainafter injury(median1.7y),who hadfailedall usual conservative formsof care.Theyhad beentoldbytheirreferringphysiciansthatthere wasnothingmore todo to helpthem. The patients were offeredadiagnosticblockprotocol todetermine the originsof the persistingpain.BlocksincludedC-2-3rootsbilaterally;C-2-3-4zygapophyseal joints(facetjoints) and provocative discographyatC-3-4,4-5, 5-6, 6-7. Of the 70 patients,68 completedthe blockprotocol,and of these 68 patients,44 of them(65%) wentonto have posteriorcervical fusionsof C-l,2,3, 4 inseveral combinations. Seventy-nine percentof patientsachievedcomplete painrelief,while 14% received satisfactorypainrelief. If the trial attorneyhastheirmedical personnel evaluate their“whiplash”orcervical sprain casesafter an auto accidentforeach of the 6 commonlyfounddisorders,thereisastronglikelihoodthatmanyif not all 6 of the disorderswill be found,and63% will likelyneedacervical fusiontoimprove. Thiswill provide betterpatientcare,and certainlyincrease recovery,whichhelpsbothpatientandattorney alike. REFERRENCES 1) HendlerN,ViernsteinM,GucerP, LongD., A preoperativescreeningtestforchronicbackpain patientPsychosomatics. 1979 Dec;20(12):801-8. 2) Hendler,N.,Mollett,A.,Viernstein,M.,Schroeder,D.,Rybock,J.,Campbell,J.,Levin,S.,Long,D.: "A Comparison Betweenthe MMPIand the 'Mensana ClinicBackPainTest' for Validatingthe Complaintof ChronicBackPainin Women." Pain. No.23:243-251, 1985. 3) Hendler,N.,Mollett,A.,Viernstein,M.,Schroeder,D.,Rybock,J.,Campbell,J.,Levin,S.,Long,D.: "A ComparisonBetweenthe MMPIand the 'HendlerBackPainTest' for Validatingthe Complaint of ChronicBack PaininMen." The Journal of Neurological &OrthopedicMedicine&Surgery. Vol.6, Issue 4:333-337, December,1985. 4) Hendler,N.,Mollett,A.,Talo,S.,Levin,S.: "A ComparisonBetweenthe Minnesota Multiphasic PersonalityInventoryandthe 'MensanaClinicBackPainTest'for Validatingthe Complaintof ChronicBack Pain." Journal of Occupational Medicine. Vol.30,No.2:98-102, February,1988. 5) Hendler,N.: "ValidatingandTreatingthe Complaint of ChronicBackPain:The Mensana Clinic Approach." Clinical Neurosurgery. Vol.35,Chap.20:385-397, eds. Black, P.,Alexander,E., Barrow,D., et.al.,WilliamsandWilkins,Baltimore,1988.
  • 12. `12 6) Hendler,N,Cashen,A,Hendler,S,Brigham, C,Osborne, P,LeRoy,P.,Graybill,T,Catlett,L., Gronblad,M. A Multi-CenterStudyforValidatingThe Complaintof ChronicBack,NeckandLimb PainUsing“The MensanaClinicPainValidityTest.” ForensicExaminer,Vol. 14,# 2, pp.41-49, Summer2005. 7) Hendler,N. andBaker,A.An Internetquestionnaire topredictthe presence orabsence of organicpathologyinchronicback, neckand limbpainpatients, PanArabJournal of Neurosurgery, Vol.12,No.1, pp:15-24, April,2008. 8) DavisR, HendlerN,BakerA (2016) PredictingMedical TestResultsandIntra-Operative Findings inChronicPain PatientsUsingthe On-Line “PainValidityTest”. JAnesthCritCare OpenAccess 5(1): 00174. DOI:10.15406/jaccoa.2016.05.00174 9) HendlerN (2017) AnInternetbasedQuestionnaire toIdentifyDrugSeekingBehaviorina Patient inthe ED and Office. JAnesthCritCare OpenAccess8(3): 00306. DOI:10.15406/jaccoa.2017.08.00306 10) SandhuHS, Sanchez-CasoLP,Parvataneni HK,CammisaFPJr,Girardi FP,GhelmanB. Association betweenfindingsof provocative discographyandvertebral endplate signal changesasseenon MRI., J Spinal Disord.,Oct;13(5):438-43, 2000. 11) Hendler,N., Zinreich,J.,Kozikowski,J.: Three-DimensionalCTValidationof Physical Complaints in`PsychogenicPain’Patients. Psychosomatics. Vol. 34,No. 1:90-96, January/February,1993. 12) Zinreich SJ, LongDM, DavisR, QuinnCB, McAfee PC, Wang H.Three-dimensionalCTimagingin postsurgical "failedback"syndrome. JComputAssistTomogr. 1990 Jul-Aug;14(4):574-80. 13) Empting-Koschorke,L.D.,Hendler,N.,Kolodny,A.L.,Kraus,H.: "TipsonHard-to-Manage Pain Syndromes." PatientCare. Vol.24,No.8:26-46, April 30, 1990 14) Hendler,N.,Kozikowski,J.:1993 “Overlookedphysical diagnosesinchronicpainpatientsinvolved inlitigation.”Psychosomatics 34(6):494-501. 15) HendlerN.,Bergson,C.,Morrison,C.1996 “ Overlookedphysical diagnosesinchronicpain patientsinlitigation,Part2.“ Psychosomatics.37(6):509-517. 16) HendlerN.2002 “Differentialdiagnosisof complexregional painsyndrome.“ PanArab Journal of Neurosurgery Oct;6(2):1-9. 17) DellonAL,Andronian E,RossonGD. 2009 “CRPSof the upperor lowerextremity:surgical treatmentoutcomes.”J.Brachial Plex PeripherNerve Inj. Feb;4(1):1-7 18) Long D, DavisR, SpeedW,HendlerN.2006 “Fusionforoccultpost-traumaticcervical facet injury.”Neurosurg.Q. 16(3):129-135. 19) Hendler,N.2005 “OverlookedDiagnosesinElectricShockAndLightningStrikeSurvivors.” Journal of Occupational andEnvironmental Medicine,Vol.47,Aug.No.8, pp. 796-805. 20) Hendler,N,andRomano,T. 2006 “ FibromyalgiaOver-Diagnosed 97% of The Time:Chronic PainDue To ThoracicOutlet Syndrome,Acromo-ClavicularJointSyndrome, DisruptedDisc, Nerve Entrapments,FacetSyndrome and OtherDisordersMistakenly CalledFibromyalgia.” Journal of Anesthesia&PainMedicine, Volume 1:1: 1-7 . 21) Landro,L ( laura.landro@wsj.com)The Wall StreetJournal,Nov.17,2013. 22) Hendler,N.,Berzoksky,C.andDavis,R.J.2007 “Comparison of Clinical DiagnosesVersus ComputerizedPaininthe Neck,BackandLimbs.” Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery,October:8- 17,
  • 13. `13 23) Bonica,JJ andTeitz,D , in The Managementof Pain,Lea & Febiger;2ndedition, p.375-376, April 1990. 24) DHHS # PHS,1587-1592, 1987. 25) Raj,PP, Chado,HN,Angst,M, Heavner,J,Dotson,R, Brandstater,ME, Johnson,B,Parris,W, Finch,P,Shahani,B, Dhand,U, Mekhail,N,Daoud,E, Hendler,N,Somerville,J,Wallace,M, Panchal,S,Glusman,S, Jay,GW, Palliyath,S,Longton,W,Irving,G,:PainlessElectrodiagnostic CurrentPerceptionThresholdValuesinCRPSSubjectsandHealthyControls:A Multicenter Study,PainPractice,Vol.1,#1, pp 53-60, 2001. 26) Roos DB., Historical perspectivesandanatomicconsiderations. Thoracicoutletsyndrome.Semin Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1996 Apr;8(2):183-9. 27) Roos DB.,Thoracic outlet syndrome is underdiagnosed.Muscle Nerve. 1999 Jan;22(1):126-9 28) Orlando MS, Likes KC, Mirza S, Cao Y, Cohen A, Lum YW, Freischlag JA. Preoperative Duplex Scanningisa Helpful DiagnosticTool inNeurogenic ThoracicOutletSyndrome.VascEndovascular Surg. 2016 Jan;50(1):29-32. 29) Hempel G.K.,Shutze W.P.,AndersonJ.F.,Bukhari H.I.,770 consecutive supraclavicularfirstrib resectionforthoracicoutletsyndrome,AnnVasSurg.,Sept10(5):pp.456-63, 1996. 30) Hendler,N, Facial painfromvarioussources-diagnosesanddifferential diagnoses,Dental,Oral and Craniofacial Research, 2017, Volume 3(5):1-5. 31) GregoryPL, BiswasAC,Batt ME, Musculoskeletal problemsof the chestwall inathletes, Sports Med. 2002;32(4):235-50.