SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Download to read offline
Social Media and
Social Media and
Nationalism: Evolving
Nationalism: Evolving
Concepts
Concepts
Anastas Vangeli MA
New Media Center Skopje
#glocal09
Presentation Outline
 Nationalism and Internet: Basic Approaches
 Reflections on Nationalism and Social Media
 Survey and Examples
 Shortcomings
 Concluding Remarks
Statement
 Social media extension to reality
 Nationalism is real, at least discursively
 Therefore social media “extend” nationalism
 Nationalist sentiment + use of social media =
reframed, arguably advanced concept of
nationalism
Nationalism and Internet: Basic
Approaches
 Erica Schlesinger Wass, Addressing the world:
national identity and Internet country code
domains, Rowman & Littlefield, 2003
 Contested domain names: the case of
Macedonia: Greek vs. RM Macedonian
domains, Macedonian and Bulgarian VMRO
domains
 Sociological approach: Eriksen and Bakker
Nationalism and Internet: Basic
Approaches
 T. H. Eriksen: the Internet (media) can
nevertheless be instrumental in creating and re-
creating a shared, collective past among its
users. Examining the role of the Internet in
building and maintaining national identities may
thus enhance our understanding of the
character and the enduring power of national
myths and symbols.
Nationalism and Social Media
 Major changes brought by social media, both
on individual and social level
 Fragmentation, decentralization, and the
emergence of user-generated content
 Social networking, virtual individuals and virtual
“collectives”
 Nationalist PR and brainstorming via social
media
Nationalism and Social Media
 Social media related to the emergence and
development of strong and durable forms of
nationalism-from-below, or a genuine
decentralized form of nationalist discourse
notably different from everything before
 No need for nationalist leaders, elite, budget,
headquaters to produce nationalist propaganda
 Social Media as an asset to nationalist
mobilization
Nationalism and Social Media
 The modernist/constructivist/instrumentalist
approaches to the nation are challenged with
the idea of decentralization as there is no more
just one single and most important agency of
the nationalist mobilization; there are plenty and
they have the possibility to reach anyone.
 The ethnosymbolist approach is challenged too:
it is not THE exclusive single shared narrative
that prevails as a crucial factor of mobilization,
but the one which the Wikipedia contributors
agree upon.
Nationalism and Social Media
 Nation reshaped: one of the basic premises
was that the nation is imagined because its
members will never meet the rest of their
fellows. However, with the possibility that social
networking offers, it is very simple for people
that share interests to find each other, and
befriend each other, even though it is online.
The imagined “horizontal friendship” of the
nation gradually becomes very concrete – yet
no less imagined.
Facebook Nationalism: A Survey
 (Methodological shortcomings)
 98 respondents
 85% said that were invited to a
nationalist/patriotic group/page/cause
 Only 4% said they have never seen
nationalistic/patriotic content being posted
 More than half see such contents frequently
Counting the Members of the Nation
34K Facebook Users Hate Greece
60K People “Kosovo is Serbia”
50K Serbs Get Ready to “Welcome”
Croats. Time needed: 10 Days
General Impressions: Facebook
 More support for “United Macedonia” than
“United Ireland”
 => Most of nationalist content originates from
SEE?
 Radical and hate groups sanctioned fast (ex.
Knife, Wire, Srebrenica; Holocaust Deniers)
Shortcomings
 Generalization of what is nationalism
 Replace nationalism with _______ and you
might get similar results
 Lack of content analysis
Concluding Remarks
 Nationalism not outdated even in post-industrial
age
 Social media content not necessarily
progressive
 The two (can) coexist
 Social media an asset to nationalism
 Surging nationalism 2.0?
Thank You
anastas.mk@gmail.com
www.vuna.info
www.twitter.com/woona
www.delicious.com/woona

More Related Content

What's hot

Habermas’ Theory of Communicative Action
Habermas’ Theory of Communicative ActionHabermas’ Theory of Communicative Action
Habermas’ Theory of Communicative ActionTabea Hirzel
 
Horkheimer & Adorno: The Culture Industries
Horkheimer & Adorno: The Culture IndustriesHorkheimer & Adorno: The Culture Industries
Horkheimer & Adorno: The Culture IndustriesDustin Kidd
 
Claude Levi-Strauss
Claude Levi-StraussClaude Levi-Strauss
Claude Levi-StraussJeevan Lal
 
How Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling Analysis
How Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling AnalysisHow Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling Analysis
How Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling AnalysisJakob Pedersen
 
Cultural studies 2 cs
Cultural studies 2 csCultural studies 2 cs
Cultural studies 2 csAbdul ghafoor
 
Fredric jameson
Fredric jamesonFredric jameson
Fredric jamesontcaple
 
Cultural Imperialism by Abid Zafar
Cultural Imperialism by Abid ZafarCultural Imperialism by Abid Zafar
Cultural Imperialism by Abid ZafarAbid Zafar
 
Postmodernism theories and texts
Postmodernism theories and textsPostmodernism theories and texts
Postmodernism theories and textsraybloggs
 
Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'
Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'
Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'Greg Downey
 
Cultural Studies
Cultural StudiesCultural Studies
Cultural StudiesArun Jacob
 
Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-nmbinq
 
Louis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
Louis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State ApparatusesLouis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
Louis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State ApparatusesArzumKALFA
 

What's hot (20)

Habermas’ Theory of Communicative Action
Habermas’ Theory of Communicative ActionHabermas’ Theory of Communicative Action
Habermas’ Theory of Communicative Action
 
Horkheimer & Adorno: The Culture Industries
Horkheimer & Adorno: The Culture IndustriesHorkheimer & Adorno: The Culture Industries
Horkheimer & Adorno: The Culture Industries
 
Claude Levi-Strauss
Claude Levi-StraussClaude Levi-Strauss
Claude Levi-Strauss
 
The Culture Industry
The  Culture  IndustryThe  Culture  Industry
The Culture Industry
 
How Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling Analysis
How Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling AnalysisHow Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling Analysis
How Does This Work? An Affective, Diffractive Storytelling Analysis
 
Emile durkheim
Emile durkheimEmile durkheim
Emile durkheim
 
Cultural studies 2 cs
Cultural studies 2 csCultural studies 2 cs
Cultural studies 2 cs
 
Fredric jameson
Fredric jamesonFredric jameson
Fredric jameson
 
Culture industries
Culture industriesCulture industries
Culture industries
 
Convergence culture
Convergence cultureConvergence culture
Convergence culture
 
Theory
TheoryTheory
Theory
 
Phenomonology
PhenomonologyPhenomonology
Phenomonology
 
Cultural Imperialism by Abid Zafar
Cultural Imperialism by Abid ZafarCultural Imperialism by Abid Zafar
Cultural Imperialism by Abid Zafar
 
Postmodernism theories and texts
Postmodernism theories and textsPostmodernism theories and texts
Postmodernism theories and texts
 
Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'
Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'
Posthumanism: Lecture for FOAR 701: 'Research Paradigms'
 
Cultural Studies
Cultural StudiesCultural Studies
Cultural Studies
 
3d printing
3d printing3d printing
3d printing
 
What is postmodernism
What is postmodernismWhat is postmodernism
What is postmodernism
 
Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-
 
Louis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
Louis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State ApparatusesLouis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
Louis Althusser _Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses
 

Social Media and Nationalism: Evolving Concepts

  • 1. Social Media and Social Media and Nationalism: Evolving Nationalism: Evolving Concepts Concepts Anastas Vangeli MA New Media Center Skopje #glocal09
  • 2. Presentation Outline  Nationalism and Internet: Basic Approaches  Reflections on Nationalism and Social Media  Survey and Examples  Shortcomings  Concluding Remarks
  • 3. Statement  Social media extension to reality  Nationalism is real, at least discursively  Therefore social media “extend” nationalism  Nationalist sentiment + use of social media = reframed, arguably advanced concept of nationalism
  • 4. Nationalism and Internet: Basic Approaches  Erica Schlesinger Wass, Addressing the world: national identity and Internet country code domains, Rowman & Littlefield, 2003  Contested domain names: the case of Macedonia: Greek vs. RM Macedonian domains, Macedonian and Bulgarian VMRO domains  Sociological approach: Eriksen and Bakker
  • 5. Nationalism and Internet: Basic Approaches  T. H. Eriksen: the Internet (media) can nevertheless be instrumental in creating and re- creating a shared, collective past among its users. Examining the role of the Internet in building and maintaining national identities may thus enhance our understanding of the character and the enduring power of national myths and symbols.
  • 6. Nationalism and Social Media  Major changes brought by social media, both on individual and social level  Fragmentation, decentralization, and the emergence of user-generated content  Social networking, virtual individuals and virtual “collectives”  Nationalist PR and brainstorming via social media
  • 7. Nationalism and Social Media  Social media related to the emergence and development of strong and durable forms of nationalism-from-below, or a genuine decentralized form of nationalist discourse notably different from everything before  No need for nationalist leaders, elite, budget, headquaters to produce nationalist propaganda  Social Media as an asset to nationalist mobilization
  • 8. Nationalism and Social Media  The modernist/constructivist/instrumentalist approaches to the nation are challenged with the idea of decentralization as there is no more just one single and most important agency of the nationalist mobilization; there are plenty and they have the possibility to reach anyone.  The ethnosymbolist approach is challenged too: it is not THE exclusive single shared narrative that prevails as a crucial factor of mobilization, but the one which the Wikipedia contributors agree upon.
  • 9. Nationalism and Social Media  Nation reshaped: one of the basic premises was that the nation is imagined because its members will never meet the rest of their fellows. However, with the possibility that social networking offers, it is very simple for people that share interests to find each other, and befriend each other, even though it is online. The imagined “horizontal friendship” of the nation gradually becomes very concrete – yet no less imagined.
  • 10. Facebook Nationalism: A Survey  (Methodological shortcomings)  98 respondents  85% said that were invited to a nationalist/patriotic group/page/cause  Only 4% said they have never seen nationalistic/patriotic content being posted  More than half see such contents frequently
  • 11. Counting the Members of the Nation
  • 12. 34K Facebook Users Hate Greece
  • 13. 60K People “Kosovo is Serbia”
  • 14. 50K Serbs Get Ready to “Welcome” Croats. Time needed: 10 Days
  • 15. General Impressions: Facebook  More support for “United Macedonia” than “United Ireland”  => Most of nationalist content originates from SEE?  Radical and hate groups sanctioned fast (ex. Knife, Wire, Srebrenica; Holocaust Deniers)
  • 16. Shortcomings  Generalization of what is nationalism  Replace nationalism with _______ and you might get similar results  Lack of content analysis
  • 17. Concluding Remarks  Nationalism not outdated even in post-industrial age  Social media content not necessarily progressive  The two (can) coexist  Social media an asset to nationalism  Surging nationalism 2.0?