060812 EEOC Response (IRISH)1. USPS.comÂź - Track & Confirm https://tools.usps.com/go/TrackConfirmAction.action
YOUR LABEL NUMBER SERVICE STATUS OF YOUR ITEM DATE & TIME LOCATION FEATURES
Âź
03120090000050973601 Priority Mail Delivered June 09, 2012, 10:28 am CINCINNATI, OH 45202 Expected Delivery By:
June 11, 2012
Hide Details Delivery Confirmationâą
Out for Delivery June 09, 2012, 9:15 am CINCINNATI, OH 45203
Sorting Complete June 09, 2012, 9:05 am CINCINNATI, OH 45203
Arrival at Post Office June 09, 2012, 5:19 am CINCINNATI, OH 45203
Depart USPS Sort June 09, 2012 CINCINNATI, OH 45235
Facility
Processed through June 08, 2012, 11:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45235
USPS Sort Facility
Acceptance June 08, 2012, 6:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45234
Âź
03102010000042767898
042767 Priority Mail Delivered June 09, 2012, 8:26 am COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Expected Delivery By:
June 11, 2012
Hide Details Delivery Confirmationâą
Arrival at Post Office June 09, 2012, 5:48 am COLUMBUS, OH 43215
Processed through June 09, 2012, 4:34 am COLUMBUS, OH 43218
USPS Sort Facility
Depart USPS Sort June 09, 2012 CINCINNATI, OH 45235
Facility
Processed at USPS June 08, 2012, 10:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45235
Origin Sort Facility
Acceptance June 08, 2012, 6:58 pm CINCINNATI, OH 45234
NOTE: Correct Tracking No. For Ohio Civil Rights Commission Is: 03102010000042767898
042767
6/14/2012 2:50 PM
2. IARRATAS AR ATHBHREITHNIĂ A DHĂFHOSTĂ AGUS FĂGRA UM CHEARTA, FĂGRA
SĂRUITHE NĂS IMEACHTA RIARACHĂIN AN TACHT, IARRATAS AR EEOC'S A
CHINNEADH "SCRĂOFA" - TORTHAĂ DE FĂRICĂ AGUS CONCLĂID AN DLĂ, IARRATAS AR
"SCRĂOFA" TEIDEAL VII LĂIRIĂ / TUAIRIM, IARRATAS AR IARCHUR LEIS AN OHIO
CHEARTA SHIBHIALTA AN COIMISIĂN, IARRATAS AR STĂDAS NA MUIREAR
GCOIMISIĂN CHUIG CEIST; AGĂIDĂ BEALTAINE DEIS COIMISIĂN FOSTAĂOCHTA'S 31,
2012 DHĂFHOSTĂ AGUS FĂGRA UM CHEARTA; FREAGRA AR LITIR OHIO CHEARTA
SHIBHIALTA AN CHOIMISIĂIN DAR DĂTA 9 BEALTAINE, 2012 MAIDIR "DO
FIOSRĂCHĂIN MAIDIR LE MUIREAR CUMAS NA IDIRDHEALĂ; "agus IARRAIDH 2 ND
LE IĂL NA" COIMHLINT-DE-LEASANNA " [1]
CURTHA ISTEACH: 8 MEITHEAMH, 2012
CURTHA ISTEACH TO: VIA US MAIL TOSAĂOCHTA ADMHĂIL UIMH 03120090000050973601 -
StĂĄit Aontaithe Roinn Labor
US CoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta ("EEOC")
Oifig Ceantair Cincinnati
ATTN: US-RĂșnaĂ na Labor - Hilda L. Solis
f / ch bhr: Wilma L. Javey (StiĂșrthĂłir)
550 Main Street, 10 Ăș UrlĂĄr
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
VIA US MAIL TOSAĂOCHTA ADMHĂIL UIMH 03102010000042477898 -
Ohio Chearta Sibhialta gCoimisiĂșn ("OCRC")
An PhrĂomh-Oifig
ATTN: Michael G. Payton, Esq (StiĂșrthĂłir FeidhmiĂșchĂĄin).
30 East Broad Street, 5 Ăș UrlĂĄr
Columbus, Ohio 43215
EEOC C OMPLAINT: Muirear Uimh 473-2012-00832 (An gnĂłlacht Garretson RĂșn GrĂșpa, Inc)
Muirear Uimh 473-2012-00837 (Messina Foirne / Messina CĂłrais
BhainistĂochta)
GearĂĄnaĂ / FostaĂ: Vogel Denise Newsome ("Newsome")
Bosca Oifig Phoist 14731
Cincinnati, Ohio 45250
FĂłn: (513) 680-2922
FreagrĂłir (Ă) / An gnĂłlacht Garretson RĂșn GrĂșpa, Inc
FostĂłra (Ă): Faoi bhrĂĄid: Sandy Sullivan (AcmhainnĂ Daonna IonadaĂ)
Faoi bhrĂĄid: Matthew Garretson (Bunaitheoir / PrĂomh-Oifigeach
FeidhmiĂșchĂĄin)
7775 Cooper Road
FĂłn: (513) 575-7167 nĂł (513) 794-0400 / (888) 556-7526
Contae: Hamilton Chontae, Ohio
** Ohio Oifig Ag 50 + fostaĂ
Messina Foirne / Messina CĂłrais BhainistĂochta
Faoi bhrĂĄid: Vince Messina (UachtarĂĄn)
11,811 Mason-Montgomery Road
Cincinnati, Ohio 45249
(513) 774-9187
3. Tagann ANOIS Gearånaà Vogel Denise Newsome ("Newsome") agus cuireann seo, sé r IARRATAS AR
ATHBHREITHNIĂ A DHĂFHOSTĂ AGUS FĂGRA UM CHEARTA, FĂGRA SĂRUITHE NĂS
IMEACHTA RIARACHĂIN AN TACHT, IARRATAS AR EEOC'S A CHINNEADH
"SCRĂOFA" - TORTHAĂ DE FĂRICĂ AGUS CONCLĂID AN DLĂ, IARRATAS AR "SCRĂOFA"
TEIDEAL VII LĂIRIĂ / TUAIRIM, IARRATAS AR IARCHUR LEIS AN OHIO CHEARTA
SHIBHIALTA AN COIMISIĂN, IARRATAS AR STĂDAS NA MUIREAR GCOIMISIĂN
CHUIG CEIST; AGĂIDĂ BEALTAINE DEIS COIMISIĂN FOSTAĂOCHTA'S 31, 2012
DHĂFHOSTĂ AGUS FĂGRA UM CHEARTA; FREAGRA AR LITIR OHIO CHEARTA
SHIBHIALTA AN CHOIMISIĂIN DAR DĂTA 9 BEALTAINE, 2012 MAIDIR "DO
FIOSRĂCHĂIN MAIDIR LE MUIREAR CUMAS NA IDIRDHEALĂ; "agus IARRAIDH 2 ND
LE IĂL NA" COIMHLINT-DE-LEASANNA " I dtaca ("RFROD & NOR ..." anseo feasta) chun an:
"OIFIGIĂLA GEARĂN / MUIREAR AR IDIRDHEALĂ AGUS NA
COMHDAITHE IN AGHAIDH AN FIRM GARRETSON RĂITEACH AN
GHRĂPA INC AGUS / NĂ MESSINA FOIRNE / MESSINA CĂRAIS BAINISTĂ
LE STĂIT AONTAITHE AN ROINN SAOTHAIR - STĂIT AONTAITHE AN
COIMISIĂN DEISEANNA FOSTAĂOCHTA EQUAL - OIFIG CEANTAIR
CINCINNATI agus OHIO CHEARTA SHIBHIALTA AN COIMISIĂN - AN
PHRĂOMH-OIFIG; AGUS IARRATAS AR MUIREAR COIMISINĂIR LE
EISITHE CURTHA ISTEACH CHUN COMHDĂ AR 30 AIBREĂN, 2012 " (DĂĄ
ngairtear "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș")
Mar thaca leis sin, agus gan a tharscaoileadh na cearta cosanta a chaomhnĂș anseo, deir Newsome mĂ©id seo a leanas
i CAOMHNĂ na saincheisteanna a ardaĂodh i "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" agus iad siĂșd. atĂĄ
leagtha amach sa toirt "RFROD & NOR . . ":
I. IARRATAS AR ATHBHREITHNIĂ A DHĂFHOSTĂ AGUS FĂGRA UM CHEARTA
Gonzalez v Firestone TĂre & Co rubair, 610 F.2d 241 (1980) - [2] Is fĂ©idir EEOC
eisiĂșint an dara 90-lĂĄ-go-ceart agartha aige fĂłgra ar chrĂochnĂș a athbhreithniĂș
lĂĄnroghnach a chinneadh roimh rĂ© ar choinnĂoll go mbeidh fĂłgra tugtha an dĂĄ
phĂĄirtĂ a chinneadh a athbhreithniĂș laistigh de 90 lĂĄ trĂ©imhse dĂĄ bhforĂĄiltear trĂ fhĂłgra
tosaigh de cheart ag agairt a dhĂ©anamh. Chearta Sibhialta Acht 1964, arna leasĂș §
706 (e) mar 42 USCA § 2000e-5 (f) (1).
4. 29 CFR § 1,601.18
DIS MISSAL: NĂS IMEACHTA AGUS ĂDARĂS:
(A) I gcĂĄs ina muirear ar a aghaidh, nĂł mar a amplified ag an rĂĄitis ar thuairimĂ an
duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir nochtann, nĂł i gcĂĄs ina gcinnfidh an CoimisiĂșn tar Ă©is
imscrĂșdaithe, go bhfuil an muirear agus gach cuid nach bhfuil de trĂĄthĂșil chomhdĂș, nĂł
ar shlà eile a mhainneoidh ståit éileamh a dhéanamh faoin teideal VII, an Ada, nó
Gina, cuirfidh an CoimisiĂșn an cĂșiseamh a dhĂbhe. . .
(B) fĂłgra i scrĂbhinn ar dhiĂșscairt, de bhun an ailt seo, a eisiĂșint chuig an duine a
Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir agus an duine a rinne an muirear ar son an duine sin, i gcĂĄs inarb
infheidhme; i gcĂĄs muirear CoimisinĂ©ir, le gach duine a shonraĂtear i § 1601.28 (b)
(2); agus leis an bhfreagrĂłir. Beidh fĂłgraĂ cuĂ de cheart ag agairt a eisiĂșint de bhun §
1,601.28.
(C) an CoimisiĂșn toscairĂ leis seo ĂșdarĂĄs do StiĂșrthĂłirĂ DĂșiche; an StiĂșrthĂłir ar an
Oifig ClĂĄir Field, nĂł ar thoscaireacht, an StiĂșrthĂłir ClĂĄir BainistĂochta Field, mar is
cuĂ, a dhĂbhe muirir, mar atĂĄ teoranta ag § 1601.21 (d). An CoimisiĂșn toscairĂ leis seo
ĂșdarĂĄs do StiĂșrthĂłirĂ Field, StiĂșrthĂłirĂ Ceantair ĂitiĂșil agus StiĂșrthĂłirĂ a bhriseadh as
tĂĄillĂ de bhun mhĂreanna (a), (b) agus (c) den alt seo, mar atĂĄ teoranta ag § 1601.21 (d).
An t-ĂșdarĂĄs ag an gCoimisiĂșn chun athmhachnamh a dhĂ©anamh ar chinntĂ agus
cinntà mar atå leagtha amach i § 1601.21 (b) agus (d) a bheith infheidhme maidir
leis an alt seo.
29 CFR § 1,601.19
Uimh cinntĂ chĂșis: NĂłs Imeachta agus ĂșdarĂĄs.
(A) MĂĄ chrĂochnaĂonn an CoimisiĂșn a imscrĂșdĂș muirear agus faigheann sĂ© nach
bhfuil cĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach aige chun a chreidiĂșint go bhfuil dea-chleachtas fostaĂochta
neamhdhleathach tharla nĂł go bhfuil ag tarlĂș maidir le gach saincheist a thabhairt
orthu sa chinneadh, dĂ©anfaidh an CoimisiĂșn a eisiĂșint litir cinneadh a na pĂĄirtithe go
lĂ©ir leis an muirear a lĂ©irĂonn an cinneadh. Beidh an ChoimisiĂșin litir a chinneadh
an cinneadh crĂochnaitheach ar an gCoimisiĂșn. DĂ©anfaidh an litir a chinneadh in iĂșl
don duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir leis nĂł an duine ar thar a cheann a comhdaĂodh i
gceannas ar an gceart chun agra a dhĂ©anamh i gcĂșirt dĂșiche ChĂłnaidhme laistigh de 90
lĂĄ tar Ă©is an litir a chinneadh .. .
(B) FĂ©adfaidh an CoimisiĂșn ar a thionscnamh fĂ©in athmhachnamh a dhĂ©anamh ar a
cinneadh crĂochnaitheach ar aon chĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach agus fĂ©adfaidh stiĂșrthĂłir a
eisiĂșint, ar a thionscnamh nĂł ar a tionscnamh fĂ©in cinneadh a chuid nĂł a cuid deiridh
gan aon chĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach a athbhreithniĂș. MĂĄ chinneann an CoimisiĂșn nĂł stiĂșrthĂłir a
eisiĂșint chun athbhreithniĂș ar chinneadh crĂochnaitheach chĂșis ar bith, dĂ©anfar fĂłgra
rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a eisiĂșint go pras do gach pĂĄirtĂ leis an muirear. MĂĄ tĂĄ an
fĂłgra sin ar intinn athmhachnamh a eisiĂșint laistigh de 90 lĂĄ tar Ă©is an cinneadh deiridh
gan aon chĂșis, agus an duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir leis nĂł an duine nach bhfuil ar thar a
cheann a comhdaĂodh muirear a chomhdĂș oireann, agus nĂ raibh a iarraidh agus a fhĂĄil,
fógra de cheart ag agairt a dhéanamh de bhun § 1601.28 (a) (1) nó (2), déanfar an
fĂłgra rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a fhĂĄgĂĄil ar an litir a chinneadh agus dĂ©anfaidh an
pĂĄirtĂ muirir ceart agra a thabhairt laistigh de 90 lĂĄ a chĂșlghairm. MĂĄ tĂĄ an trĂ©imhse
90 lĂĄ in Ă©ag agra, tĂĄ an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș comhdaithe agra, nĂł a bhĂ iarrtha an pĂĄirtĂ a
mhuirearĂș fĂłgra ceart agartha bhun § 1601.28 (a) (1) nĂł (2), dĂ©anfaidh an fĂłgra hintinn
a athbhreithniĂș fhĂĄgĂĄil ar an litir a chinneadh, ach nĂ bheidh an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș ceart
agartha i 90 lĂĄ a chĂșlghairm. Tar Ă©is athbhreithniĂș a dhĂ©anamh, dĂ©anfaidh an
CoimisiĂșn nĂł a eisiĂșint stiĂșrthĂłir cinneadh nua a eisiĂșint. Sna cĂșinsĂ inar cĂșlghaireadh
an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș ceart agra a thabhairt i 90 lĂĄ, cuirfidh an cinneadh san ĂĄireamh
fĂłgra go mbeidh trĂ©imhse culaith nua 90 lĂĄ ag tosĂș ar an bpĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș ar Ă©is an
cinneadh. I gcĂĄs go mbeidh comhalta den ChoimisiĂșn a comhdaĂodh CoimisinĂ©ir
ghearradh, déanfaidh sé nó sà aon iarratas faoi cinneadh a dhéanamh sa chås sin.
29 CFR § 1,601.21
CINNEADH CĂIS RĂASĂNACH: NĂS IMEACHTA AGUS ĂDARĂS.
(A) Tar Ă©is chrĂochnĂș a imscrĂșdĂș, i gcĂĄs nach bhfuil an CoimisiĂșn socraithe nĂł
briseadh muirear nĂł a dhĂ©anamh ar chĂșis ar bith a aimsiĂș maidir le gach lĂomhain
aghaidh orthu sa chinneadh faoi § 1601.19, dĂ©anfaidh an CoimisiĂșn cinneadh a
eisiĂșint go bhfuil cĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach aige chun a chreidiĂșint go bhfuil TĂĄ dea-chleachtas
5. fostaĂochta neamhdhleathach tharla nĂł go bhfuil ag tarlĂș faoi theideal VII, an Ada, nĂł
Gina. TĂĄ cinneadh a aimsiĂș cĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach bunaithe ar, agus nĂ teoranta do, aghaidh a
thabhairt fianaise a fhaightear ag an gCoimisiĂșn agus nĂ lĂ©irĂonn sĂ© aon bhreithiĂșnas ar
fhiĂșntas lĂomhaintĂ sa chinneadh.
(B) DĂ©anfaidh an CoimisiĂșn fĂłgra go pras ar a cinneadh faoi mhĂr (a) den alt seo a
sholĂĄthar don duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir, an duine a rinne an muirear ar son an duine
sin, mås ann, agus ar an bhfreagróir, nó i gcås de mhuirear Coimisinéir, an duine atå
ainmnithe ar an muirear nĂł a aithnĂodh ag an gCoimisiĂșn sa deimhniĂș trĂĂș pĂĄirtĂ, mĂĄs
ann, agus an freagrĂłir. FĂ©adfaidh an CoimisiĂșn, ĂĄfach, ar a thionscnamh fĂ©in
athmhachnamh a dhéanamh ar bhreith nó an cinneadh d'aon duine då oifigigh
ainmnithe ag a bhfuil ĂșdarĂĄs a eisiĂșint Litreacha Cinneadh, Ach amhĂĄin nach mbeidh
an CoimisiĂșn athbhreithniĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar chinntĂ de chuid cĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach a eisĂodh
roimhe i gcoinne an rialtais, aonĂĄn rialtais nĂł foroinnt pholaitĂochta tar Ă©is teip ar idir-
réitigh mar atå leagtha amach i § 1,601.25.
(1) I gcĂĄsanna ina gcinnfidh an CoimisiĂșn a athbhreithniĂș maidir le dĂfhostĂș nĂł
cinneadh a aimsiĂș cĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach aige chun a chreidiĂșint go bhfuil muirear fĂor, beidh
fĂłgra rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a eisiĂșint go pras. MĂĄ tĂĄ an fĂłgra sin ar intinn
athmhachnamh a eisiĂșint laistigh de 90 lĂĄ tar Ă©is fĂłgra ceart agartha aici agus nach
bhfuil an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș comhdaithe oireann agus nach bhfuair fĂłgra ceart
agartha bhun § 1601.28 (a) (1) nĂł (2), beidh an fĂłgra rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a
dhĂ©anamh ar fhĂĄgĂĄil an dĂfhostaithe nĂł litir cinneadh agus an fĂłgra de cheart ag
agairt a chĂșlghairm. MĂĄ tĂĄ an trĂ©imhse 90 lĂĄ in Ă©ag, tĂĄ an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș
comhdaithe agra, nĂł a bhĂ iarrtha an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș fĂłgra ceart agartha bhun §
1601.28 (a) (1) nĂł (2), beidh an fĂłgra rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a fhĂĄgĂĄil NĂ bheidh an
dĂfhostĂș nĂł litir a chinneadh, ach an fĂłgra a chĂșlghairm de cheart ag agairt a
dhĂ©anamh. Tar Ă©is athbhreithniĂș a eiseoidh an CoimisiĂșn cinneadh as an nua. Sna
himthosca ina bhfuil an fĂłgra ceart agartha aige a chĂșlghairm, dĂ©anfaidh an CoimisiĂșn,
i gcomhrĂ©ir le § 1601.28, fĂłgra a eisiĂșint de cheart ag agairt a dhĂ©anamh as an nua a
sholĂĄthrĂłidh an pĂĄirtĂ muirir le 90 lĂĄ ar laistigh di a oireann a thabhairt.
(2) DĂ©anfaidh an CoimisiĂșn fĂłgra go pras ar a intinn a athbhreithniĂș, atĂĄ Ă©ifeachtach
ar eisiĂșint, agus a chinneadh crĂochnaitheach tar Ă©is athbhreithniĂș a sholĂĄthar don
duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir, an duine a rinne an muirear ar son an duine sin, mĂĄs ann,
agus an bhfreagróir, nó i gcås muirear Coimisinéir, an duine atå ainmnithe ar an
muirear nĂł a aithnĂodh ag an gCoimisinĂ©ir sa deimhniĂș trĂĂș pĂĄirtĂ, mĂĄs ann, agus an
freagrĂłir.
(C) I gcĂĄs go mbeidh comhalta den ChoimisiĂșn a comhdaĂodh muirear CoimisinĂ©ir,
cuirfidh sé nó sà aon iarratas faoi cinneadh a dhéanamh sa chås sin.
(D) an CoimisiĂșn leis seo toscairĂ le StiĂșrthĂłirĂ DĂșiche, nĂł ar tharmligean, StiĂșrthĂłirĂ
Field, StiĂșrthĂłirĂ Ceantair ĂitiĂșil nĂł StiĂșrthĂłirĂ; agus an StiĂșrthĂłir ar an Oifig ClĂĄir
Field, nĂł ar thoscaireacht, an StiĂșrthĂłir ClĂĄir BainistĂochta Field, an t-ĂșdarĂĄs, ach
amhĂĄin i na gcĂĄsanna a bhaineann le saincheisteanna atĂĄ ainmnithe faoi lĂĄthair ag an
gCoimisiĂșn le haghaidh athbhreithnithe tosaĂochta, ar chrĂochnĂș ar imscrĂșdĂș, cinneadh
a dhĂ©anamh teacht ar chĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach, a eisiĂșint litir cĂșis a chinneadh agus cĂłip den
chinneadh ar na pĂĄirtithe a sheirbheĂĄil. TĂĄ gach cinneadh a eiseofar faoin alt seo
dheireanach nuair a bheidh an litir cinneadh eisithe. Mar sin fĂ©in, an StiĂșrthĂłir ar an
Oifig ClĂĄir Field, nĂł ar thoscaireacht, an StiĂșrthĂłir ClĂĄir BainistĂochta Field;
FĂ©adfaidh gach StiĂșrthĂłir Ceantair agus gach StiĂșrthĂłir ĂitiĂșil, maidir le cinntĂ a
d'eisigh sĂ© nĂł sĂ oifig, ar; gach StiĂșrthĂłir DĂșiche; gach StiĂșrthĂłir Field Ă© nĂł Ă a
thionscnamh féin athmhachnamh a dhéanamh ar chinntà den sórt sin, nà féidir ach
amhĂĄin go stiĂșrthĂłirĂ den sĂłrt sin cinntĂ ar chĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach roimhe sin a eisĂodh i
gcoinne gnĂomhaireacht rialtais, rialtais nĂł foroinnt pholaitĂochta tar Ă©is teip ar idir-
réitigh mar atå leagtha amach i § 1,601.25 athmhachnamh a dhéanamh.
(1) I gcĂĄsanna ina gcinnfidh an StiĂșrthĂłir a eisiĂșint chun athbhreithniĂș a bhriseadh nĂł
cinneadh a aimsiĂș cĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach aige chun a chreidiĂșint go bhfuil muirear fĂor, beidh
fĂłgra rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a eisiĂșint go pras. MĂĄ tĂĄ an fĂłgra sin ar intinn
athmhachnamh a eisiĂșint laistigh de 90 lĂĄ tar Ă©is fĂłgra ceart agartha aici agus nach
bhfuil an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș comhdaithe oireann agus nĂ raibh a iarraidh fĂłgra ceart
agartha bhun § 1601.28 (a) (1) nĂł (2), beidh an fĂłgra rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a
dhĂ©anamh ar fhĂĄgĂĄil an dĂfhostaithe nĂł litir cinneadh agus an fĂłgra de cheart ag
agairt a chĂșlghairm. MĂĄ tĂĄ an trĂ©imhse 90 lĂĄ in Ă©ag, tĂĄ an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș
comhdaithe agra, nĂł a fuair an pĂĄirtĂ a mhuirearĂș fĂłgra ceart agartha bhun § 1601.28
6. (a) (1) nĂł (2), beidh an fĂłgra rĂșin chun athbhreithniĂș a fhĂĄgĂĄil NĂ bheidh an dĂfhostĂș
nĂł litir a chinneadh, ach an fĂłgra a chĂșlghairm de cheart ag agairt a dhĂ©anamh. Tar
Ă©is athbhreithniĂș a bheidh an StiĂșrthĂłir a eisiĂșint a eisiĂșint cinneadh as an nua. Sna
himthosca ina bhfuil an fĂłgra ceart agartha aige a chĂșlghairm, dĂ©anfaidh an StiĂșrthĂłir a
eisiĂșint, de rĂ©ir § 1601.28, fĂłgra a eisiĂșint de cheart ag agairt a dhĂ©anamh as an nua a
sholĂĄthrĂłidh an pĂĄirtĂ muirir le 90 lĂĄ ar laistigh di a oireann a thabhairt.
(2) Nuair a dhĂ©anann an StiĂșrthĂłir eisitheach athbhreithniĂș, beidh sĂ© nĂł sĂ fĂłgra go
pras a fheidhmeanna nĂł a hintinn a athbhreithniĂș, atĂĄ Ă©ifeachtach ar eisiĂșint, agus
cinneadh crĂochnaitheach tar Ă©is athbhreithniĂș a sholĂĄthar don duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb
Ă©agĂłir, an duine a rinne an muirear ar thar ceann an duine sin, mĂĄs ann, agus ar an
bhfreagrĂłir, nĂł ar an muirear nĂł a aithnĂodh ag an gCoimisinĂ©ir sa deimhniĂș trĂĂș pĂĄirtĂ,
mĂĄs ann, agus an freagrĂłir.
(E) Le linn cinneadh maidir le cibĂ© an bhfuil cĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach, dĂ©anfar meĂĄchan
substaintiĂșil a thugtar torthaĂ deiridh agus orduithe arna ndĂ©anamh ag
gnĂomhaireachtaĂ FEP ainmnithe a iarchur an CoimisiĂșn muirir de bhun § 1,601.13.
Chun crĂocha an ailt seo, beidh feidhm ag na sainmhĂnithe seo a leanas:
(1) "torthaĂ deiridh agus orduithe" ciallĂłidh:
(I) cinntĂ fĂorais agus leis sin eachtra ordĂș arna eisiĂșint ag gnĂomhaireacht FEP ar na
buntĂĄistĂ a chĂșiseamh; nĂł
(Ii) an t-ordĂș nĂł foraithne toiliĂș toiliĂș a rinne an ghnĂomhaireacht FEP ar fhiĂșntas na
muirear.
Ar choinnĂoll, ĂĄfach, Beidh an nĂ dhĂ©anfar aon torthaĂ agus ord na gnĂomhaireachta
FEP a mheas deiridh chun crĂocha an ailt seo mura rachaidh an ghnĂomhaireacht FEP
tar Ă©is a sheirbheĂĄil cĂłip den ordĂș sin agus torthaĂ ar an gCoimisiĂșn agus ar an duine a
Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir leis agus go bhfuil eolas an duine sin de cearta aige nĂł aici ar
achomharc nĂł ar athbhreithniĂș a iarraidh, nĂł athĂ©isteacht nĂł cearta den chineĂĄl
cĂ©anna; agus an t-am le haghaidh achomhairc den sĂłrt sin, dĂ©anfar athbhreithniĂș, nĂł
athéisteacht iarraidh sin in éag nó ar na saincheisteanna a d'achomharc den sórt sin,
dĂ©anfar athbhreithniĂș nĂł a athĂ©isteacht tar Ă©is a chinneadh.
(2) Beidh "meĂĄchan substaintiĂșil" chiallaĂonn beidh an bhreithnithe sin go hiomlĂĄn
agus go cĂșramach a thabhairt do na torthaĂ deiridh agus orduithe, mar a shainmhĂnĂtear
thuas, de rĂ©ir mar is cuĂ i bhfianaise na fĂricĂ tacĂș leo nuair atĂĄ siad freastal ar gach
ceann de na rĂ©amhriachtanais atĂĄ leagtha amach thĂos:
(I) Ba iad na himeachtaĂ cĂłir agus rialta; agus
(Ii) Is iad na cleachtais toirmiscthe le dlĂ an StĂĄit nĂł ĂĄitiĂșil inchomparĂĄide i scĂłip chun
na cleachtais toirmiscthe le dlĂ ChĂłnaidhme; agus
(Iii) freastal ar na torthaĂ deiridh agus d'fhonn an leas an forfheidhmiĂș Ă©ifeachtach an
teideal VII, an Ada, nĂł Gina: Ar choinnĂoll, Go NĂ thugann meĂĄchan mĂłr le torthaĂ
deiridh agus orduithe sin do ghnĂomhaireacht FEP san ĂĄireamh de rĂ©ir meĂĄchain, chun
crĂocha chur i bhfeidhm dlĂ cĂłnaidhme, a leithĂ©id GnĂomhaireachta conclĂșidĂ an dlĂ.
1. Ar mhaithe leis an gceartas agus caomhnĂș cearta reachtĂșla chosanta, rudaĂ Newsome
chuig an gCoimisiĂșn Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta sĂĄruithe ar dhlĂthe a bhaint di cearta faighte
faoi Theideal VII, CĂłd RialachĂĄin CĂłnaidhme, tAcht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin, StĂĄit Aontaithe
mBunreacht, Ohio Chearta Sibhialta, agus dĂșirt sĂ© reachtanna eile / dlĂthe de Ohio agus StĂĄit Aontaithe
MheiriceĂĄ rialaĂonn ĂĄbhair.
2. Newsome iarraidh leis seo athbhreithniĂș a DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta, sa mhĂ©id is
go bhfuil an CoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta tiomanta EARRĂID i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na Muirear
seo agus tĂĄ FĂGTHA Newsome na cearta a rĂĄthaĂtear go reachtĂșil faoi dhlĂthe na Ohio agus StĂĄit
Aontaithe MheiriceĂĄ. CĂłipeanna den 31 Bealtaine , 2012 Litir leis an DhĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgraĂ um
Chearta do FhreagrĂłirĂ an gnĂłlacht Garretson RĂșn GrĂșpa Inc Messina agus SolĂĄthar Foirne / Messina
CĂłrais BhainistĂochta atĂĄ ceangailte leis seo faoi seach mar TaispeĂĄntas S "A" agus "B" agus a
ionchorprĂș trĂ thagairt a dhĂ©anamh amhail is dĂĄ atĂĄ leagtha amach i anseo iomlĂĄn.
7. 3. Ar nĂł thart ar 30 AibreĂĄn, 2012, chuir sĂ Newsome "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As
IdirdhealĂș" a bhĂ comhdhĂ©anta de thart ar 196 Leathanaigh agus 86 TaispĂ©antar - cĂłip de d'fhĂ©adfadh
a fheiceĂĄil / faighte ag:
http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f
4. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" comhdhĂ©anta de thart ar 109
Ceisteanna uimhrithe a ArdaĂodh agus ina measc tĂĄ Ailt i dteideal: (I) SĂĄrĂș ar an Reacht, (II)
CuspĂłir de Theideal VII (III) PatrĂșn As IdirdhealĂș, (IV) Foirceannadh FostaĂochta Neamhdhleathach
/ Urscaoileadh Ă©agĂłrach, (V) Ciapadh, (VI) Naimhdeach, (VII) retaliation, (VIII) pretext / Bad Faith,
(IX) StaitisticĂ / CĂłireĂĄil dĂchosĂșla, (X) GnĂomhaĂocht Employment-At-Will/Protected, (XI) PoiblĂ
PolasaĂ, (XII) chĂșis, (XIII) Comhcheilg, (XIV) IdirdhealĂș chĂłrasach, Dliteanas FostĂłra (XV), agus
(XVI) Faoiseamh ĂĄ lorg.
5. TĂĄ Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" ar a aghaidh agus / nĂł
amplified ag na rĂĄitis atĂĄ ann le tacaĂocht Ăł fĂricĂ, fianaise agus conclĂșidĂ dlĂ a chothĂș na tĂĄillĂ ann
maith leis an faoiseamh ĂĄ lorg maidir leis na gortuithe / dĂobhĂĄil a tharla Newsome .
6. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" chomhlĂonann na ceanglais
phlĂ©adĂĄil mar a cheanglaĂtear le reacht / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin agus, dĂĄ bhrĂ sin, is ar a n-Ă©ileamh
luaigh an faoiseamh atĂĄ ĂĄ lorg ag Newsome a DEONAĂODH! , Bunaithe fĂ©in ar na gnĂomhartha
treallach agus capricious an ChoimisiĂșin FostaĂochta Comhionann agus an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio
CoimisiĂșn i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" Newsome ar go dtĂ seo, tĂĄ faoi
rĂ©ir Newsome le dĂobhĂĄil irreparable / dĂobhĂĄil agus tĂĄ sĂ© ag iarraidh a bhaint di de chearta reachtĂșla
RĂTHAĂOCHT faoi dhlĂthe an StĂĄit Ohio, chomh maith le StĂĄit Aontaithe MheiriceĂĄ.
7. An CoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta earrĂĄid a dhĂfhostĂș ar "GearĂĄn
OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" Newsome ar agus a eisiĂșint "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta."
8. An CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta na Ohio earrĂĄid ina TEIP a fhĂĄil agus a
ionchĂșiseamh Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" ag lĂomhain go raibh sĂ©
anabaĂ chomhdĂș - ie sa mhĂ©id is go raibh sĂ© TRĂTHĂIL comhdaĂodh i gcomhrĂ©ir leis na reachtanna /
dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin. Newsome tar Ă©is di faoi bhrĂĄid "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As
IdirdhealĂș" chun an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșn le 240 lĂĄ is incheadaithe faoi na dlĂthe do
Muirir a comhdaĂodh i stĂĄt "athlĂł" mar Ohio.
9. Ag an am Newsome chuir sĂ "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" sĂ go trĂĄthĂșil,
i gceart agus go sĂĄsĂșil iarr Muirear COIMISINĂIR a eisiĂșint.
10. An CoimisiĂșn Comhionannais Deiseanna FostaĂochta botĂșn i
NEAMHDHLEATHACHA / NEAMHDHLEATHACH gnĂomhartha tiomanta nuair a Newsome
isteach in Ă©ineacht le "Muirir ar IdirdhealĂș" sa mhĂ©id is go bhfĂ©adfaidh duine rĂ©asĂșnta / aigne, bunaithe
ar na gnĂomhartha a thabhairt i gcrĂch go bhfuil an EEOC dhrĂ©achtaigh "Muirir ar IdirdhealĂș" le
toiliĂșil, MAILĂSEACHA agus hintinn wanton a imghabhĂĄil a bhfuil a aghaidh a thabhairt ar na
CEISTEANNA a ardaĂodh sa Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș." Mar sin
fĂ©in, bhĂ dĂomĂĄ ar an EEOC nuair a rinne Newsome na ceartĂșchĂĄin CRITICIĂIL agus GĂ chun Muirir
ar IdirdhealĂș a ionchorprĂș "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" a chaomhnĂș SOILĂIR a
cearta, chomh maith le go leordhĂłthanach TacaĂonn cad SAINCHEISTEANNA a bhĂ os comhair na
EEOC ag an am a eisiĂșint "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta." Chun a thuilleadh, crĂocha
SAINCHEISTEANNA chaomhnĂș, fianaise agus imnĂ ar rannphĂĄirtĂocht na EEOC i COIRIĂIL /
SIBHIALTA hĂ©agĂłracha cĂłrasach leveled AGHAIDH Newsome i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na IonchorpraĂonn
"OifigiĂșla GearĂĄn / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" Newsome trĂ thagairt a dhĂ©anamh amhail is dĂĄ atĂĄ
8. leagtha amach i anseo go hiomlĂĄn, a AibreĂĄn 30, 2012 Litir ClĂșdach ghabhann "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil /
Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f
chomh maith leis na Bealtaine Newsome ar 24, 2012 "Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn
Derwin E. Jamison" atĂĄ corpraithe leis seo amhail is dĂĄ mba thagairt a leagtar amach i anseo go
hiomlån agus is féidir a fhåil ó: http://www.slideshare. net/VogelDenise/052412-response-to-eeoc-letter-of-
050812
11. An EEOC TĂĄ ĂșdarĂĄs reachtĂșil ag athmhachnamh a dhĂ©anamh ar "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra
um Chearta" a eisĂodh i gceist seo agus a chinntiĂș go bhfuil sĂ© eisithe de mheon macĂĄnta agus nĂ chun
crĂocha / motives idirleabharlainne.
12. De bhun na reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin, theip ar an EEOC chun a dualgais
SAINORDAITHIGH aireachta atĂĄ dlite faoi reacht (Ă) chun aghaidh a thabhairt GACH saincheisteanna
a ardaĂodh i "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș" agus ina dhiaidh sin Freagra "Chun Litir 8
Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison. "DĂĄ bhrĂ sin, is fĂ©idir le duine ar intinn rĂ©asĂșnacha / i gcrĂch
go bhfuil gnĂomhartha na EEOC ar treallach agus capricious.
13. An EEOC earrĂĄid dĂ©anta ina TEIP a eisiĂșint "Litir Cinneadh" ina leagtar amach na
cinntĂ fĂorais agus tabhairt i gcrĂch an dlĂ a cheanglaĂtear le REACHT (Ă) a dĂșirt rialaĂonn ĂĄbhair. DĂĄ
bhrĂ sin, tĂĄ trĂd an phlĂ©adĂĄil an toirt, RUDAĂ Newsome a dĂșirt an teip agus ag Ă©ileamh go dĂșirt an
cheist EEOC "Litir Cinneadh" i gcomhrĂ©ir leis na reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn ĂĄbhair (ie a Ă©ilĂonn
CHĂAD athlĂĄ ĂĄbhar chuig an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn). I bhfocail eile, bhĂ an EEOC GAN-
ĂșdarĂĄs a eisiĂșint an "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta" i go bhfuil sĂ© le hintinn d'aon ghnĂł,
MAILĂSEACHA agus COIRIĂIL ORBH FHĂ a chur siar Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear
As IdirdhealĂș" leis an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn mar a cheanglaĂtear le MANDATORILY
REACHT!
14. CĂ© gur fĂ©idir StiĂșrthĂłir an EEOC le gnĂomhĂș ar a thionscnamh aige / aici fĂ©in a
athbhreithniĂș aige / aici cinneadh crĂochnaitheach ar aon chĂșis rĂ©asĂșnach, faoi bhrĂĄid Newsome seo a
phléadåil an toirt i bhfianaise go bhfuil an taifead chomh maith le córasach an EEOC cleachtais
idirdhealaitheacha agus PATRĂN-DE-idirdhealaitheach ar chleachtais i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na cĂșiseanna a bhĂ
ag teaståil Newsome Newsome ag cur na céimeanna Gà i CAOMHNà de na saincheisteanna a
ardaĂodh agus CAOMHNĂ ar chearta Newsome ar choimeĂĄd slĂĄn agus a rĂĄthaĂtear le REACHTANNA
/ DHLĂTHE rialaĂonn ĂĄbhair sin.
15. I gcomhrĂ©ir leis na Reachtanna / DlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin, a iarraidh go Newsome an
cheist EEOC an TEASTĂIL "FĂłgra Intinne a athbhreithniĂș" go pras!
16. Newsome Creideann go bhfĂ©adfadh aigne rĂ©asĂșnach tĂĄtal gur theip ar an an EEOC /
Wilma Javey le hintinn d'aon ghnĂł, MAILĂSEACHA agus COIRIĂIL chun an comhad an Muirear
CoimisinĂ©ir TEASTĂIL iarrann Newsome a chuirfeadh bac soilĂ©ir a eisiĂșint an "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra
um Chearta" chun bĂĄis. Agus sin ĂĄ dhĂ©anamh, FĂGTHA an EEOC Newsome ar chearta cosanta
urraithe / a rĂĄthaĂtear le reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn a dĂșirt ĂĄbhair.
17. An EEOC earrĂĄid dĂ©anta i USURPATION an ĂșdarĂĄis chomh maith le MĂ-ĂSĂID an
ĂdarĂĄis i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As Idirdhealaithe." Ina theannta sin,
tacaĂonn an fhianaise taifead gur theip ar an EEOC a chur ar fĂĄil "a aimsiĂș maidir le gach lĂomhain
aghaidh i Newsome ar" OifigiĂșla GearĂĄin / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș "agus ina dhiaidh sin" Freagra
Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison. "
29 CFR § 1601.8 CĂ HĂIT A NDĂANFAIDH MAKE A TĂILLE:
9. Is féidir tåille a dhéanamh go pearsanta nó leis an bpost ag aon oifig de chuid an
ChoimisiĂșin nĂł le haon ionadaĂ ainmnithe an ChoimisiĂșin. . .
29 CFR § 1601.9 FOIRM AS TĂILLE:
Beidh tĂĄille a bheith i scrĂbhinn agus Ă© sĂnithe agus a fhĂorĂș.
29 CFR § 1,601.12 CLĂR AS MUIREAR; LEASĂ AS TĂILLE:
(A) Ba chóir do gach muirear go bhfuil an méid seo a leanas:
(1) an t-ainm iomlĂĄn, seoladh agus uimhir theileafĂłin an duine a rinne an muirear ach
amhåin mar a fhoråiltear i § 1601.7;
(2) an t-ainm iomlån agus seoladh an duine a mbeidh an muirear a dhéanamh, mås eol
(dĂĄ ngairtear an freagrĂłir);
(3) Aon rĂĄiteas soilĂ©ir agus gonta ar na fĂorais a, lena n-ĂĄirĂtear dĂĄtaĂ ĂĄbhartha, arb
iad na cleachtais fostaĂochta lĂomhnaithe neamhdhleathach: FĂ©ach § 1601.15 (b);
(4) MĂĄs eol, is fĂ©idir leis an lĂon thart ar fhostaithe de chuid an fhostĂłra nĂł an
freagrĂłir an lĂon thart ar bhaill den eagraĂocht saothair freagrĂłir, mar a bheidh, agus
(5) Aon rĂĄiteas a nochtadh cibĂ© acu imeachtaĂ leis an gcleachtas fostaĂochta a
lĂomhnaĂtear go neamhdhleathach a bheith tosaithe roimh gnĂomhaireacht StĂĄit nĂł
ĂĄitiĂșla freagrach as forfheidhmiĂș na ndlĂthe fostaĂochta cothrom cleachtas agus, mĂĄ
tĂĄ, an dĂĄta an tosach feidhme sin agus an t-ainm na gnĂomhaireachta.
(B) D'ainneoin fhorĂĄlacha mhĂr (a) den alt seo Ă©, muirear leor nuair a fhaigheann an
CoimisiĂșn Ăł an duine a rinne an muirear rĂĄiteas scrĂofa beacht go leor chun na
pĂĄirtithe, agus chun cur sĂos ginearĂĄlta ar an ngnĂomh nĂł cleachtais a ndearnadh
gearĂĄn faoi. Is fĂ©idir tĂĄille a leasĂș chun leigheas fabhtanna teicniĂșla nĂł easnaimh, lena
n-ĂĄirĂtear teip chun a fhĂorĂș an muirear, nĂł a shoilĂ©iriĂș agus lĂomhaintĂ a rinneadh ann
amplify. Beidh leasuithe den sĂłrt sin agus na leasuithe ag lĂomhain bhreise
gnĂomhartha arb Ă©ard iad na cleachtais fostaĂochta neamhdhleathach a bhaineann leis
nĂł atĂĄ ag fĂĄs as an ĂĄbhar an muirear bunaidh mbaineann ar ais go dtĂ an dĂĄta an
muirear a fuarthas an chĂ©ad. NĂ bheidh muirear atĂĄ arna leasĂș amhlaidh a cheanglaĂtear
a redeferred.
18. Beidh an fhianaise taifead a chomhdĂș TRĂTHĂIL Newsome isteach ar "GearĂĄn
OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" tacaĂocht a thabhairt don ChoimisiĂșn FostaĂochta agus Deiseanna
Comhionann Ohio Chearta Sibhialta gCoimisiĂșn. DĂĄ bhrĂ sin, a chomhlĂonann ceanglais an phlĂ©adĂĄil
mar a "ĂIT A DHĂANAMH MUIREAR."
19. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" chomhlĂonann na ceanglais
SOILĂIR phlĂ©adĂĄil le haghaidh "FOIRM in aisce" agus SAINCHEISTEANNA lĂĄthair, solĂĄthraĂonn
fĂricĂ, fianaise agus conclĂșidĂ dlĂ a chothĂș ar an GearĂĄn / Muirear agus cuireadh i lĂĄthair i bhfoirm
"clĂłscrĂofa".
20. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" chomhlĂonann na ceanglais
phlĂ©adĂĄil an "CLĂR in aisce" san i bhfuil: (1) an t-ainm iomlĂĄn, seoladh agus uimhir theileafĂłin an
duine a rinne an muirear; (2) an t-ainm iomlĂĄn agus seoladh an duine a ndearnadh an cĂșiseamh a
dhĂ©anamh, mĂĄs eol; (3) Aon rĂĄiteas soilĂ©ir agus gonta ar na fĂorais a, lena n-ĂĄirĂtear dĂĄtaĂ ĂĄbhartha,
arb iad na cleachtais fostaĂochta lĂomhnaithe neamhdhleathach; (4) MĂĄs eol, ar an lĂon thart ar
fhostaithe de chuid an fostĂłir bhfreagrĂłir nĂł ar an lĂon thart ar bhaill an fhreagrĂłra; agus (5) Aon
rĂĄiteas a nochtadh cibĂ© acu imeachtaĂ leis an gcleachtas fostaĂochta a lĂomhnaĂtear go
neamhdhleathach a bheith tosaithe roimh gnĂomhaireacht StĂĄit nĂł ĂĄitiĂșil de chĂșram a fhorfheidhmiĂș
na ndlĂthe fostaĂochta cothrom chleachtas agus, mĂĄs amhlaidh, dhĂĄta an tosach feidhme sin agus an t-
ainm na gnĂomhaireachta.
10. 21. N ewsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" leagtha amach go soilĂ©ir
amach creideamh go bhfuil "IDIRDHEALĂ BUNAITHE AR: (1) Cine; (2) Aois; (3) retaliation; (4)
eile - eolas ar rannphĂĄirtĂocht i ngnĂomhaĂocht cosanta (Ă); agus (5) IdirdhealĂș chĂłrasach "- FĂ©ach
Leathanach 2.
22. Ar nĂł thart ar 8 Bealtaine, 2012, chuir an CoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta
Newsome le "MUIREAR AR IDIRDHEALĂ" do gach ceann de na freagrĂłirĂ (ie an gnĂłlacht
Garretson RĂșn GrĂșpa, Inc agus Messina Foireann / Messina CĂłrais BhainistĂochta).
23. Ar nĂł thart ar 9 Bealtaine, 2012, chuir an CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta Ohio
Newsome le comhfhreagras i dteideal, "Do FiosrĂșchĂĄin Maidir Muirear fĂ©ideartha de IdirdhealĂș"
atĂĄ luaite sa chuid:
"Tåimid ag fåil do litir agus voluminous doiciméadacht maidir le muirear
ionchasacha idirdhealaithe in aghaidh d'iarfhostĂłir, an gnĂłlacht Garretson RĂșn GrĂșpa, Inc
agus Messina SolĂĄthar Foirne. Mar a thuigeann muid do chĂĄipĂ©isĂocht, cuireadh deireadh
le tĂș Ăł fhostaĂocht ar 21 Deireadh FĂłmhair, 2011. Fuair muid do chĂĄipĂ©isĂocht 2
Bealtaine, 2012. An tAcht um Chearta Sibhialta na Ohio, Ohio Athbhreithnithe CĂłd
a Ă©ilĂonn go bhfuil tĂĄille de idirdhealĂș a chomhdĂș
Caibidil 4112,
laistigh de shé mhà ó dhåta an dochar agus då bhrà sin tå an
muirear mheastar anabaĂ dĂșinn a shaothrĂș.
LĂ©irĂonn do litir dĂșinn araon Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn agus chuig an
gCoimisiĂșn um Chomhdheiseanna US Deiseanna FostaĂochta a fuarthas doicimĂ©adĂș
comhionann. Muirir a chomhadĂș leis an gCoimisiĂșn US Comhionann FostaĂochta
Deis laistigh de 300 lĂĄ Ăł dhĂĄta an dochar agus fhĂ©adfaĂ a mheas go trĂĄthĂșil leo.
Is Ă© ĂĄr gnĂomhaireacht, an CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta Ohio, an stĂĄt ghnĂomhaireacht
forfheidhmithe dlĂ riarachĂĄin go riarann an Acht um Chearta Sibhialta Ohio, Ohio
Athbhreithnithe CĂłd Caibidil 4112, agus tĂĄ muid FREAGRACH do
IMSCRĂDAITHE muirir ar chine, dath, gnĂ©as, bunadh
nĂĄisiĂșnta, stĂĄdas mĂleata, mĂchumas, aois agus reiligiĂșn
idirdhealĂș i rĂ©imsĂ na fostaĂochta, tithĂochta, cĂłirĂocht poiblĂ. . .
CĂ© go bhfuil muid NĂL ĂșdarĂĄs dlĂnse chun imscrĂșdĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar an ĂĄbhar seo, a
dhĂ©anann muid mian leat a fhios a fuair muid agus go cĂșramach na hĂĄbhair ar fĂĄil duit a
léamh.
MĂĄs rud Ă© sa todhchaĂ chreideann tĂș go bhfuil tĂș gur Ăospartach idirdhealĂș a thagann faoi
dhlĂnse ĂĄr, tĂ©igh i dteagmhĂĄil linn agus a iarraidh labhairt le imscrĂșdaitheoir. . . "
forghnĂomhaithe ag Sandra R. Aukeman / SeirbhĂsĂ CĂł agus ag gnĂomhĂș thar ceann agus leis an
CEADĂ de Fheidhmeannacht na Chearta Sibhialta Ohio ChoimisiĂșin StiĂșrthĂłir G. Michael Payton.
cĂłip den Chearta Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșn 9 Bealtaine tĂĄ, 2012 litir a ghabhann leis seo agus a
ionchorprĂș trĂ thagairt a dhĂ©anamh mar "B." TaispeĂĄntas
24. Mar is lĂ©ir, dearbhaĂonn an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșn a EOLAS de submittal
Newsome de "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" chun an dĂĄ an OCRC agus an CoimisiĂșn
Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta. Faoin REACHTANNA dĂșirt / DHLĂTHE rialaĂonn ĂĄbhair,
Newsome a bhfuil thart ar 240 lĂĄ, in ionad an 180 lĂĄ Dhearbhaigh an OCRC chun an comhad a
Muirear StĂĄit.
11. Alsup v Comhar IdirnĂĄisiĂșnta na BrĂceadĂłirĂ agus Ceardaithe Allied de Toledo, Ohio,
ĂitiĂșil Aontas Uimh. 3, 679 F.Supp. 716 (ND Ohio W. RannĂĄn 1987.) - I "stĂĄit
iarchur", mar shampla Ohio, ĂĄit a iarchur an EEOC chun an ghnĂomhaireacht stĂĄit a
bunaĂodh chun imscrĂșdĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar na muirir ar idirdhealĂș, nĂ mĂłr tĂĄille EEOC a
chomhdĂș laistigh de 300 lĂĄ tar Ă©is an ghnĂmh lĂomhanta neamhdhleathach. Cearta
Sibhialta Acht 1964, § 706 (e), arna leasĂș, 42 USCA § 2000e-5 (f) (1). . .
Nuair a gceannas ar an idirdhealĂș faoi bhrĂĄid an dĂĄ an ChoimisiĂșin FostaĂochta
Comhionann Deiseanna agus gnĂomhaireacht stĂĄit i "stĂĄt iarchur," nĂ bheidh an EEOC
chomhdĂș go foirmiĂșil a gceannas ar an idirdhealĂș go dtĂ tar Ă©is an ghnĂomhaireacht stĂĄit
foirceannadh ar a himeachtaĂ. . . dĂĄ bhrĂ sin, nĂ mĂłr tĂĄille staid riarachĂĄin maidir le
hidirdhealĂș a chomhdĂș de ghnĂĄth laistigh de 240 lĂĄ Ăł na gcleachtas neamhdhleathach
lĂomhnaithe d'fhonn a chaomhnĂș ceart Ă©ilitheora chun an comhad a VII Teideal lawsuit
sa chĂșirt cĂłnaidhme. Cearta Sibhialta Acht 1964, § 706 (e), arna leasĂș, 42 USCA §
2000e-5 (f) (1). . . Mohasco Corp v Silver, 447 US 807, 814 n. 16, 100 Shivnan S.Ct.
2486, 2491 n. 16, 65 L.Ed.2d 532 (1980).
DĂĄ bhrĂ sin, tĂĄ an OCRC earrĂĄid a lĂĄimhseĂĄil "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" Newsome
agus an EEOC is leis an gceist seo gĂ©illeadh an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn. Ina theannta sin,
earrĂĄid an EEOC a eisiĂșint "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta" sa mhĂ©id is go dĂșirt teip ĂĄbhar a chur
siar chuig an OCRC Cosc ar R / gCOSC an EEOC Ăł eisiĂșint "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta."
25. O hio Chearta Sibhialta gCoimisiĂșn ("OCR C") StiĂșrthĂłir FeidhmiĂșchĂĄin Michael G.
Payton is AIGHNE / DlĂodĂłir, dĂĄ bhrĂ sin, creideann Newsome gur fĂ©idir le duine rĂ©asĂșnta / intinn a
thabhairt i gcrĂch go bunaithe ar fĂricĂ, fianaise agus conclĂșidĂ dlĂ a chuirtear i lĂĄthair sa phlĂ©adĂĄil an
toirt mar BhĂ a fhios go maith mar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș" agus / nĂł ba chĂłir
gurbh eol dĂł go bhfĂ©adfaidh an OCR tar Ă©is gnĂomhĂș le hintinn d'aon ghnĂł, go toiliĂșil agus
MAILĂSEACHA a chur ar fĂĄil Newsome le faisnĂ©is BRĂAGACH agus / nĂł mĂthreorach comhairle a
thabhairt go h "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș "chomhdĂș leis an OCRC bhĂ anabaĂ
comhdaĂodh na dlĂthe atĂĄ soilĂ©ir agus / nĂł go maith socraithe ar sin, maidir le hĂĄbhair
TRĂTHĂLACHT do thabhairt gnĂomhartha agus cad go dĂreach a fhrisnĂ©is agus TARSCAOILEADH
le héilimh mar go bhfuil an OCRC.:
Weise v Syracuse University, Ba dĂfhostĂș CĂșirte gearĂĄin bunaithe ar dhĂfhostĂș
EEOC ar in aisce mar gheall ar untimeliness ceaptha in aisce
EARRĂID, Ăłs rud Ă© nach An ChĂșirt DĂșiche a bhĂ faoi cheangal glacadh le cinneadh
EEOC ar cheist - 522 F.2d 524 (2 Ăș Cir 1975.), 33 BNA FEP Cas 544 a bheadh mar
ghabhåltas ceangailteach agus a mhalairt a dhéanamh ciall ag an ceart chun agra a
dhĂ©anamh tar Ă©is briseadh ag an gCoimisiĂșn; agus torthaĂ EEOC ar dteideal ghnĂĄth chun
bĂ©im an-mhĂłr, agus bhain sĂ© go bhfuil tĂĄille misread, a lĂomhnaĂtear go soilĂ©ir
idirdhealĂș LEANĂNACH (rud a dhĂ©anamh a chomhdĂș
TRĂTHĂIL).
Meiriceånach Airgeadais Córas, Inc vs Harlow, 65 FRD 94 (1974) - tréimhse
teorann nĂłcha lĂĄ nach mbaineann mĂĄ LEANANN idirdhealĂș lĂomhnaithe go dtĂ go
mbeidh Ă©ileamh dĂĄta a thabhairt os comhair na EEOC; is fĂ©idir gnĂomhartha atĂĄ caite
patrĂșn LĂTHAIR iompair,
maidir le hidirdhealĂș a thabhairt ar aghaidh le
ach sa chĂĄs amhĂĄin go bhfuil cleachtais neamhdhleathach faoi lĂĄthair
agus athfhillteach bhfeidhm ar an ngearĂĄnaĂ-ionadaĂ ranga.
Grohal vs Stauffer Cheimiceach Co, 385 F.Supp 1267 (1974), 10 BNA FEP Cas
785 - MĂĄ tĂĄ gearĂĄn idirdhealaithe de TĂĄ LEANĂNACH nĂł leanĂșint,
trĂ©imhsĂ ama reachtĂșla THARSCAOILTE; Ba chĂłir gearĂĄnaĂ ag
Ă©ileamh den sĂłrt sin a tharscaoileadh lĂomhnaĂonn gcĂĄsanna ĂĄirithe de
LEANĂNACH idirdhealĂș i lena gearĂĄn.
12. Tyson vs Sun BeachtĂș & MargaĂocht Co, 599 F.Supp 136, 36 BNA FEP Cas 875
(1984) -Tå EISCEACHT le 180 lå tréimhse teorainneacha
dhĂ©anamh do "SĂRĂ LEANĂNACH" faoina NĂ MĂR
gearĂĄnaithe teoiric TaispeĂĄin SRAITH gnĂomhartha
GAOLMHARA, ceann amhĂĄin nĂł nĂos mĂł de
theorainneacha a thagann faoi réim tréimhse, nó cothabhåil
córas idirdhealaitheach roimh agus i rith na tréimhse srianta.
Marinelli vs Chao, 222 F.Supp 2d 402 (2002) - An ChĂșirt Uachtarach go bhfuil
aisghairthe foirceadal sĂĄrĂș leanĂșnach i gcomhthĂ©acs na n-Ă©ileamh idirdhealaithe arna
dtionscnamh de bhun Theideal VII den Chearta Sibhialta d'Acht 1964, 42 USCS § §
2000e et seq, rĂ©asĂșnaĂocht a fhostĂș. a bheadh go bhfuil an chuma a chur i bhfeidhm go
cothrom le IdirdhealĂș Aoise in Acht FostaĂochta agus Ă©ilimh Acht AthshlĂĄnĂș.
Austion v Chathair Clarksville, 244 Fed.Appx. 639 (CA 6, 2007) - An "leanĂșnach
såruithe teoiric" Is é a theagasc ar leith cothrom go dolaà tréimhse chomhdaithe 300-lå do
mhuirear idirdhealaithe. Acht um Chearta Sibhialta 1964, § 706 (e) (1), 42 USCA §
2000e-5 (e) (1).
Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" Leagann amach go soilĂ©ir LEANĂNACH
cleachtais idirdhealaithe / dĂoltais leveled i gcoinne di freagrĂłirĂ. FĂ©ach ar Leathanaigh 26, 38, 58, 64
66, 69, 105, 135 agus 189 Newsome tacĂș le aghaidh a thabhairt ar chleachtais LEAN de FreagrĂłir (Ă).
Thairis sin, Leathanaigh 12, 28, 55, 68, 74, 79, 81, 116-118, 120, 129, 136 agus 138 aghaidh a
thabhairt ar an 3 Feabhra, 2012 Lawsuit dĂoltais MAILĂSEACHA comhdaithe ag an RĂșn gnĂłlacht
Garretson GrĂșpa, Inc ag iarraidh a bhaint Newsome um Chearta COSANTA. Is fĂ©idir cĂłip den Bhileog
DuillĂn a fheiceĂĄil / faighte ag:
http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f
Thiocfaidh chun bheith Conspirator an gnĂomhaire de chuid an conspirator (Ă) eile, agus
tĂĄ sĂ© aon ghnĂomh a dhĂ©anamh ag ceann de na meascĂĄn a mheastar faoi dhlĂ mar an
gnĂomh an dĂĄ cheann nĂł gach ceann. I bhfocail eile, cad a dhĂ©anann amhĂĄin, mĂĄ tĂĄ
meascĂĄn seo, beidh an gnĂomh an dĂĄ cheann nĂł gach ceann acu, is cuma a d'fhĂ©adfadh
duine aonair a bheith dĂ©anta air. TĂĄ sĂ© seo fĂor i dtaobh gach comhalta den
chomhcheilg, fiĂș iad siĂșd a bhfuil baint a bhĂ teoranta chun rĂłl bheag an t-idirbheart
neamhdhleathach, agus a dhĂ©anann sĂ© aon difrĂocht cibĂ© acu atĂĄ nĂł nach bhfuil duine
aonair den sĂłrt sin roinnte i brabĂșis na gnĂomhartha. (Am. JUR phlĂ©adĂĄil agus
Foirmeacha Cleachtais, Comhcheilg § 9.) COMHAONTĂ INTUIGTHE -. TharlaĂonn nuair a
beirt nĂł nĂos mĂł a shaothrĂș ag a gcuid gnĂomhartha an rud cĂ©anna ar an modh cĂ©anna a
hAon duine a bheidh cuid amhĂĄin agus an ceann eile i gcuid eile, ionas go mbeidh ar. i
gcrĂch acu a fhaightear ar an rĂ©ad shaothrĂș. Beag beann ar cibĂ© an raibh a fhios ag
gach duine de na sonraà nó an chuid a bhà gach a dhéanamh, ar na torthaà deireadh å fhåil
acu an rĂ©ad saothrĂș. GComhaontĂș atĂĄ intuigthe nĂł thuiscint as gnĂomhartha nĂł rĂĄitis.
26. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" lĂomhnaĂonn nĂ amhĂĄin nĂł
sĂĄruithe cĂłrasacha SRAITHUIMHIR ach solĂĄthraĂonn fĂricĂ, FIANAISE agus conclĂșidĂ dlĂ chun
tacĂș le cĂ©anna:
Moore vs San Jose, 615 F.2d 1265 (1980), 22 BNA FEP Cas 1053 - beartas forleatach
ionas go mbeidh
idirdhealaithe cĂłrasach Ă© LEANĂNACH sĂĄrĂș de Theideal VII,
NACH muirear a lĂomhnaĂonn lĂĄithreacht beartais den sĂłrt sin
cosc ama.
Kassaye vs Bryant CholĂĄiste, 999 F.2d 603 (1993), 62 BNA FEP Cas 724 - TĂĄ dhĂĄ
chineĂĄl de sĂĄruithe LEANĂNACH, cĂłrasach agus SRAITHUIMHIR; Is sĂĄrĂș
sraithuimhir lĂon gnĂomhartha idirdhealaitheach a thagann Ăłn animus idirdhealaitheach
cĂ©anna, gach gnĂomh arb Ă©agĂłir inchaingne ar leithligh faoi Theideal VII.
13. Moore v Chathair San Jose, Is Ă© [18] A polasaĂ forleatach idirdhealaithe cĂłrasach sĂĄrĂș
leanĂșnach Teideal VII - 615 F.2d 1265 (1980). Cearta Sibhialta Acht 1964, § 701 et seq.
mar atĂĄ arna leasĂș 42 USCA § 2000e et seq.
[19] Nuair a raibh polasaĂ forleatach idirdhealaithe cĂłrasach, nach bhfuil an
trĂ©imhse srianta ar agra faoi Theideal VII tĂșs a reĂĄchtĂĄil go dtĂ an t-am nuair a bhĂonn an
polasaĂ scortha. Cearta Sibhialta Acht 1964, arna leasĂș § 706 mar 42 USCA § 2000e-5.
FĂ©ach mĂreanna Uimh 7, 14, 16, 17, 19, 20, 29, 33, 37, 38, 55, 63, 71, 73, 76, 87, 96, 99, 100; ina theannta
sin, Alt "XIV. IDIRDHEALĂ cĂłrasach "ar" GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș. "
http://www.filesanywhere.com/fs/v.aspx?v=8a70628a5b6271a86f9f
29 CFR § 1601.28 (3) FĂGRA AR DHEIS CHUN SUE: NĂS IMEACHTA AGUS ĂDARĂS:
. . . (3) Beidh EisiĂșint fĂłgra ceart agartha aige deireadh a chur imeacht breise ar aon
chĂșiseamh nach bhfuil muirear CoimisinĂ©ir mura ndĂ©anfaidh an StiĂșrthĂłir DĂșiche;
StiĂșrthĂłir Field; StiĂșrthĂłir Ceantair; StiĂșrthĂłir ĂitiĂșil; StiĂșrthĂłir ar an Oifig ClĂĄir Field
nĂł ar tharmligean, an StiĂșrthĂłir ClĂĄir BainistĂochta Field; nĂł an AbhcĂłide GhinearĂĄlta
a chinnfidh, ag an am sin nĂł ag trĂĄth nĂos dĂ©anaĂ go mbeadh sĂ© effectuate crĂche an
teideal VII, an Ada, nĂł Gina a phrĂłiseĂĄil tuilleadh an muirear EisiĂșint fĂłgra ceart
déanfaidh agairt a dhéanamh. Nà deireadh a chur le próiseåil muirear Coimisinéir.
(4) NĂ eisiĂșint fĂłgra ceart agartha aige bac ar an gCoimisiĂșn as cĂșnamh a thairiscint do
dhuine den sĂłrt sin a eisĂodh fĂłgra den sĂłrt sin a mheasfaidh an CoimisiĂșn is gĂĄ nĂł is
cuĂ.
27. Newsome RUDAĂ leis seo chuig an gCoimisiĂșn Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta
NEAMHDHLEATHACHA / NEAMHDHLEATHACH cleachtais de bheith ag mainneachtain a
eisiĂșint ar an Muirear CoimisinĂ©ir Ă©ileamh sa GearĂĄn "OifigiĂșla / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș. "
28. Newsome trĂd an ĂILIMH comhdaithe an toirt go bhfuil an Deiseanna FostaĂochta
Comhionann ar fĂĄil di doicimĂ©id tacaĂochta go bhfuil an CoimisiĂșn Muirear eisiĂșint agus, mĂĄs rud Ă©,
cén fåth nach ORBH FHà na h EEOC mar agus / nó bac ar an Riaradh an Cheartais i låimhseåil
iarratas Newsome do Muirear gCoimisiĂșn eisiĂșint.
29. Beidh an fhianaise TAIFEAD tacĂș leis, cĂ© go raibh an CoimisiĂșn Deiseanna
Comhionann FostaĂochta go feasach, go toilteanach, d'aon ghnĂł agus go mailĂseach, iarracht a
choinneĂĄil ar "Newsome le GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș "as an" Muirir ar IdirdhealĂș "ar
fĂĄil dĂł lĂ©i, a rinneadh Newsome na ceartĂșchĂĄin GĂ / CRITICIĂIL agus cuireadh faoi bhrĂĄid tagairt
faoi deara le GearĂĄn clĂłscrĂofa / Muirear isteach chomh maith le TABHAIRT DĂ nAIRE DĂIBH"
chĂłrasach "cleachtais idirdhealaitheach i gceist. FĂ©ach ar na Bealtaine Newsome ar 24, 2012 "Freagra
Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison" - atĂĄ corpraithe faoi threoir amhail is dĂĄ atĂĄ
leagtha amach i anseo iomlĂĄn: http://www.slideshare.net/VogelDenise/052412-response-to-eeoc-letter -de-
050,812
30. NACH bhfuil iarratas Newsome do Muirear CoimisiĂșn a eisiĂșint bac ar an dualgas
Chearta Sibhialta Ohio ChoimisiĂșin chun na hoibleagĂĄidĂ aireachta dlite Newsome i bprĂłiseĂĄil agus
lĂĄimhseĂĄil "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș. "
II. FĂGRA SĂRUITHE NĂS IMEACHTA RIARACHĂIN AN TACHT UM
Is Ă© a chomhdĂș StĂĄt Ă©igeantach - Morris v InnealtĂłirĂ Kaiser, Inc, 471 NE2d 471 (Ohio,
1984) rĂ©amhriachtanas IdirdhealĂș Aoise i ngnĂomh Acht FostaĂochta. IdirdhealĂș Aoise
in Acht FostaĂochta 1967, § 14, 29 USCA § 633.
14. Piecuch v Murascaille & Mfg Co an Iarthair, 626 F.Supp. 65 (ND Ohio E.Div, 1985..) -
NĂ raibh DĂșiche cĂșirt dlĂnse ag gnĂomh idirdhealaithe aois, nuair nach raibh gearĂĄnaĂ a
chomhdĂș in aisce le Ohio Chearta Sibhialta gCoimisiĂșn. IdirdhealĂș Aoise in Acht
FostaĂochta 1967, § 14 (b), 29 USCA § 633 (b).
31. TĂĄ an CoimisiĂșn tar Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta a eisiĂșint "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra
Ceart" GAN siar Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" chun an Chearta Sibhialta
Ohio CoimisiĂșn mar thoradh ar ghortĂș / harmed agus faoi mhĂbhuntĂĄiste cearta Newsome urraithe /
rĂĄthĂș faoin REACHTANNA / REACHTAĂOCHTA a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin.
32. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" lĂomhnaĂonn "AOIS"
IdirdhealĂș; dĂĄ bhrĂ sin, tĂĄ sĂ© SAINORDAITHIGH A go h GearĂĄin / Muirear a chur siar go dtĂ an
CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta Ohio lĂĄimhseĂĄil / a phrĂłiseĂĄil.
33. An CoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta earrĂĄid a eisiĂșint "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra
um Chearta" a dhearbhaĂonn go bhfuil Newsome 90-Laethanta thabhairt gnĂomh sa chĂșirt cĂłnaidhme.
Mar thoradh air sin DĂREACH agus gar agus na gnĂomhartha toiliĂșil, MAILĂSEACHA agus wanton an
EEOC ĂĄbhar a chur siar chuig an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșn, an ChĂșirt DĂșiche "in easnamh ar
DLĂNSE" ĂĄbhar chun aghaidh a thabhairt mar gheall ar an "AOIS" ceist a ardaĂodh i IdirdhealĂș
"GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil TĂĄ / Muirear As Idirdhealaithe. "Thairis sin, an OCRC, mar ĂĄbhar reacht / dlĂ ag
teastĂĄil MANDATORILY a lĂĄimhseĂĄil / GearĂĄn Newsome BaintrĂ / Muirear phrĂłiseĂĄil. Bealtaine an
OCRC ar 9, 2012, AdmhaĂonn fhĂĄil Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș."
Ramirez v driogairĂ NĂĄisiĂșnta agus Cheimiceach Corp, 586 F.2d 1315 (1978) - [4] I gcĂĄs
ina mbeidh EEOC theip ar mhuirear idirdhealaithe fostaĂochta a tharchur chuig
gnĂomhaireacht stĂĄit mar a cheanglaĂtear le Teideal VII, ba chĂłir dĂșiche chĂșirte a
choinneĂĄil dlĂnse don trĂ©imhse go leor ama chun deis a EEOC fĂłgra a thabhairt don
ghnĂomhaireacht stĂĄit cuĂ agus chun go gnĂomhaireacht trĂ©imhse iarchuir reachtĂșil a
bheith ag gnĂomhĂș a cheadĂș. Cearta Sibhialta Acht 1964, arna leasĂș § 706 (d) mar 42
USCA § 2000e-5 (e).
. . . TĂĄ an chĂșirt seo ar siĂșl arĂs agus arĂs eile go bhfuil "nuair a theip ar an
EEOC a leanĂșint alt 2000e-5 (c), ba cheart don chĂșirt dĂșiche a choinneĂĄil dlĂnse ar feadh
trĂ©imhse am chun go mbeidh an EEOC fĂłgra a thabhairt don ghnĂomhaireacht stĂĄit cuĂ
agus chun go gnĂomhaireacht a cheadĂș an trĂ©imhse iarchuir reachtĂșil a bheith ag
gnĂomhĂș. "(v Gallego Arthur G. McKee & Co (9 Cir. 1977) 550 F.2d 456, 457. Cf.
EEOC v Wah Chang Albany Corp (9 Cir. 1974 D'fhéadfadh) 499 F.2d 187, 189 N.3
("nach bhfuil iarchur rud dlĂnse sa chiall go deprives ina Ă©agmais na cĂșirte de chumhacht
chun gnĂmh").) Thairis sin, tĂĄ sĂ© amhrasach go bhfuil earrĂĄid dĂ©anta ag an nĂłs imeachta
EEOC cosc a gearĂĄnaĂ ar cheart dul sa tĂłir ar VII Teideal Ă©ileamh. (FĂ©ach Miller v
IdirnĂĄisiĂșnta Co PĂĄipĂ©ar (5 Cir 1969) 408 F.2d 283, 291 ("NĂ fĂ©idir an gnĂomh nĂł
neamhghnĂomh an EEOC difear grievant cearta substaintiĂșla faoi reacht.");. Cf Gates v
tSeoirsia. -AigĂ©an CiĂșin Corp (9 Cir. 1974) 492 F.2d 292, 295.) Mar gheall ar an EEOC
deireadh thiar raibh tagairt muirear arna leasĂș Ramirez chuig an ghnĂomhaireacht stĂĄit
iomchuĂ, fĂ©adfaidh an chĂșirt dĂșiche botĂșn i dĂbhe ar fhorais dlĂnse an Teideal VII Ă©ileamh
maidir le an layoff 1974.
Judulang v SealbhĂłir, 132 Shivnan S.Ct. 476 (2011) - Nuair a athbhreithniĂș caingean
gnĂomhaireacht faoi Acht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin (APA), nĂ mĂłr do chĂșirt a
mheas, i measc nithe eile, cibĂ© acu a bhĂ bunaithe ar an gcinneadh ar bhreithniĂș ar na
fachtĂłirĂ ĂĄbhartha agus cibĂ© ar tharla earrĂĄid shoilĂ©ir de bhreithiĂșnas, a bhaineann le
scrĂșdĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar na cĂșiseanna atĂĄ leis an ghnĂomhaireacht cinntĂ nĂł d'Ă©agmais
cĂșiseanna sin. 5 USCA § 706 (2) (A).
34. A earrĂĄid Clear de bhreithiĂșnas agus eisiĂșint na "DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta" a
Ă©ilĂonn tuilleadh SCRĂDĂ na cleachtais neamhdhleathach / mĂdhleathach de chuid an ChoimisiĂșin
FostaĂochta Comhionann Deiseanna. Thairis sin, ceanglas Muirear COIMISINĂIR a EISIĂINT!
15. NLRB v Fiontar Ass'n na Gaile, uisce te, aisréadóra hiodrålacha, iompróirà aeroibrithe
Tube, Ice Mach. agus Pipefitters GinearĂĄlta na Nua-Eabhrac agus gcomharsanacht,
Aontais ĂitiĂșil Uimh 638, 97 Shivnan S.Ct. 891 (1977) - Nuair a bheidh gnĂomhaireacht
riarachĂĄin a dhĂ©antar earrĂĄid dlĂ, dleacht cĂșirte Is Ă© a cheartĂș earrĂĄid dlĂ dĂ©anta ag an
gcomhlacht sin agus dĂĄ Ă©is sin a dhĂ©anamh cĂĄs a athchur chuig an ngnĂomhaireacht sin
mar a thabharfaidh sĂ© deis scrĂșdĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar fhianaise agus fĂricĂ a aimsiĂș mar a
cheanglaĂtear le dlĂ.
ChĂłnaidhme Power CoimisiĂșn v Idaho Co Power, 73 Shivnan S.Ct. 85 (1952) - Ar
athbhreithniĂș ar ord na CĂłnaidhme Power gCoimisiĂșn deireadh, an fheidhm atĂĄ leis an
gcĂșirt athbhreithniĂș a dhĂ©anamh nuair a dhĂ©antar earrĂĄid de dhlĂ an leagan lom agus
ag an bpointe sin an t-ĂĄbhar uair nĂos mĂł a thĂ©ann chuig an gCoimisiĂșn um athbhreithniĂș.
ChĂłnaidhme Power Acht, § 313 (b), arna leasĂș, 16 USCA § 825 l (b).
35. Newsome caomhnaĂonn tuilleadh ceisteanna agus FIANAISE na FostaĂochta Deiseanna
Comhionann ChoimisiĂșin agus EOLAS Ohio Chearta Sibhialta ChoimisiĂșin a EARRĂIDĂ a bheith
trĂĄthĂșil, i gceart agus go leordhĂłthanach a thabhairt chun a n-aird.
36. Subha tuilleadh Newsome trĂd an comhdĂș an toirt phlĂ©adĂĄil an SAINCHEISTEANNA
ardaithe anseo. Thairis sin, gur faoi na reachtanna a dĂșirt / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn ĂĄbhair, Newsome leis seo
TRĂTHĂIL, CEART agus leordhĂłthanach a chur in iĂșl go bhfuil rialuithe Ăł Chearta Sibhialta Ohio
gCoimisiĂșn agus chuig an gCoimisiĂșn Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta TORTHAĂ NA FACT agus
CONCLĂID DLĂ chun tacĂș leis na cinntĂ a rinneadh. Thairis sin, chun tacĂș go GACH saincheisteanna
a ardaĂodh sa "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" tugadh aghaidh.
37. Newsome Creideann go mbeidh an fhianaise TAIFEAD tacĂș go lĂĄimhseĂĄil
CEACHTAR an CoimisiĂșn Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta NOR an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio
ChoimisiĂșin Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" i gcomhrĂ©ir leis na reachtanna /
dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin agus, dĂĄ bhrĂ sin, mar go dĂreach agus go cĂłngarach thoradh ar sin tĂĄ TEIP
faoi rĂ©ir Newsome le dĂobhĂĄil / dochar a bhaint de agus a cearta urraithe / rĂĄthaithe faoi na reachtanna /
dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin.
38. Newsome Creideann an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn agus chuig an gCoimisiĂșn
Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta lĂĄimhseĂĄil "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" Newsome
ar TacĂłidh na gnĂomhartha treallach agus capricious chun crĂocha tinn agus go h gortĂș / dĂobhĂĄil
Toirmiscthe ag reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn faoi deara sin ĂĄbhair.
39. Newsome Creideann go mbeidh an fhianaise taifead tacaĂocht a "Clear shĂĄrĂș agus
dochrach ar reachtanna agus rialachĂĄin is infheidhme" ag an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn agus
chuig an gCoimisiĂșn Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na Newsome ar "GearĂĄn
OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș."
40. Newsome Creideann go dtacaĂonn an FIANAISE taifead go bhfuil sĂ gortaĂodh / Dochar
ag an gCoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta TEIP ĂĄbhar a chur siar chuig an Chearta Sibhialta
Ohio ChoimisiĂșn mar aon le "TorthaĂ FĂricĂ agus ConclĂșid an DlĂ" a chur ar fĂĄil chun tacĂș leis an
DĂfhostĂș "agus FĂłgra um Chearta; "ina theannta sin, Ă©ileofar TEIP an EEOC ar a iarraidh ar an Muirear
COIMISINĂIR a EISIĂINT mar atĂĄ i Newsome ar" OifigiĂșla GearĂĄn / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș "agus
ina dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012" Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison ".
41. Newsome Creideann go dtacaĂonn an FIANAISE taifead iad a LEASANNA a iarrtar a
s'acu dearthaithe fĂĄ fhĂ©adfaĂ a rĂĄ LAISTIGH "CRIOS de ĂIS" agus tĂĄ CEISTEANNA COSANTA
agus cearta ag reachtanna / dlĂthe atĂĄ i gceist agus atĂĄ leagtha amach i "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar
IdirdhealĂș" agus ina dhiaidh sin "Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison. "
16. Kroger Co v Aerfort RĂ©igiĂșnach ĂdarĂĄs na Louisville agus Contae Jefferson, 286 F.3d
382 (6 Ăș Cir 2002.) - Faoi an caighdeĂĄn treallach nĂł capricious ar athbhreithniĂș faoin
Acht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin (APA), an pĂĄirtĂ dĂșshlĂĄnach an ghnĂomhaireacht
gnĂomhaĂocht NĂ mĂłr a thaispeĂĄint go raibh an gnĂomh aon bhonn rĂ©asĂșnach nĂł go
pĂĄirteach sĂ© sĂĄrĂș soilĂ©ir agus dochar de reachtanna nĂł rialachĂĄin is infheidhme, agus
mĂĄ tĂĄ aon fhianaise chun tacĂș leis an ghnĂomhaireacht ar chinneadh, nach bhfuil an
gnĂomhaireachta cinneadh treallach nĂł capricious. 5 USCA § § 701 et seq., 706 (2) (A).
StiĂșrthĂłir, Oifig na ClĂĄir CĂșiteamh Oibrithe ', An Roinn Labor v Baile UĂ FhiachĂĄin
Nuacht LongthĂłgĂĄil agus Tirim Duga Co, 115 Shivnan S.Ct. 1278 (US, 1995) - TĂĄ
gnĂomh dlĂthĂ ghnĂomhaireacht dĂșshlĂĄnach is gĂĄ chun a thaispeĂĄint, ag tĂșs an chĂĄis, go
bhfuil sĂ© gortaithe go deimhin ag gnĂomh gnĂomhaireacht agus is Ă© an leas sin fĂ©achann
sé a sheasamh fhéadfaà a rå laistigh de chrios na leasanna a chosaint le reacht atå i
gceist. 5 USCA § 702.
Lujan v FiadhĂșlra NĂĄisiĂșnta CĂłnaidhm, 110 Shivnan S.Ct. 3177 (1990) - Chun a fhĂĄil ar
athbhreithniĂș breithiĂșnach faoi fhorĂĄlacha athbhreithniĂș ginearĂĄlta ar an Acht um NĂłs
Imeachta RiarachĂĄin, nĂ mĂłr don duine atĂĄ ag Ă©ileamh ceart agartha aithint gnĂomh Ă©igin
gnĂomhaireacht a thĂ©ann i bhfeidhm air i bhealach sonraithe agus NĂ mĂłr a thaispeĂĄint
go bhfuil fhulaing sĂ© mĂcheart dlĂ mar gheall ar an ngnĂomh atĂĄ ghnĂomhaireacht
dĂșshlĂĄn nĂł go bhfuil drochthionchar nĂł arb Ă©agĂłir leis an chaingean sin de rĂ©ir bhrĂ an
reacht åbhartha. 5 USCA § 702.
LĂĄrionad BitheolaĂochta ĂagsĂșlacht v Lueckel, 417 F.3d 532 (6 Ăș Cir 2005.) - Chun a
fhĂĄil ar athbhreithniĂș breithiĂșnach faoin Acht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin (APA), nĂ
mĂłr an ghearĂĄnaĂ gearĂĄn a bhaineann le gnĂomh ghnĂomhaireacht nĂł neamhghnĂmh de
chuid, agus nĂ mĂłr gearĂĄnaĂ fhulaing ceachtar dlĂthiĂșil mĂcheart nĂł dĂobhĂĄil a thagann
faoi chrios leasanna lorg a chosaint le reacht ar a bhfuil gearån bunaithe. 5 USCA §
551 et seq.
ChĂłnaidhme Power Com'n v Colorado Interstate GĂĄis Co, 75 Shivnan S.Ct. TĂĄ feidhm
ag alt den Acht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin a shainmhĂniĂș de scĂłip athbhreithnithe ach
amhĂĄin maidir le cĂĄsanna ina bhfuil cheist a cuireadh i lĂĄthair i gceart - 467 (1955).
Acht um Nós Imeachta Riarachåin, § 10 (e), 5 USCA § 1009 (e).
42. Newsome Creideann mar thoradh dĂreach agus cĂłngarach den ChoimisiĂșn
Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta TEIP cloĂ leis na reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn an lĂĄimhseĂĄil
"GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș," bhaint an EEOC di an iarchur SAINORDAITHIGH na
nGearĂĄn / Muirear don StĂĄtseirbhĂs Ohio um Chearta an CoimisiĂșn agus, dĂĄ bhrĂ sin, i dĂșirt bhĂ faoi
rĂ©ir dĂothacht a claonadh, idirdhealaitheach, dochrach, agus NEAMHDHLEATHACHA /
NEAMHDHLEATHACH a phróiseåil agus a låimhseåil a héileamh. Ina theannta sin, go
neamhdhleathach / FĂGTHA mĂdhleathach Newsome de cheart REACHTĂLA go bhfuil ĂĄbhar i
lĂĄthair agus a imscrĂșdĂș ag an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn. Mar thoradh dĂreach agus gar de
lĂĄimhseĂĄil neamhdhleathach / mĂdhleathach an EEOC de Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As
IdirdhealĂș" ar bhain sĂ agus leanann sĂ© ag fulaingt hĂ©agĂłracha dlĂ agus cleachtais idirdhealaithe
cĂłrasach ag an EEOC agus iad siĂșd lena bhfuil sĂ© comhcheilg a bhaint cearta Newsome urraithe /
rĂĄthaithe agus ar fĂĄil ag reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin.
43. Newsome creideann gur mar thoradh dĂreach agus gar de lĂĄimhseĂĄil neamhdhleathach /
mĂdhleathach an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio ChoimisiĂșin de Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As
IdirdhealĂș" ar bhain sĂ agus leanann sĂ© ag fulaingt hĂ©agĂłracha dlĂ agus cleachtais idirdhealaithe
cĂłrasach i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na nGearĂĄn / Muirear ag an OCRC agus iad siĂșd lena bhfuil sĂ© comhcheilg a
bhaint cearta Newsome urraithe / rĂĄthaithe agus ar fĂĄil ag reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin.
44. An Chearta Sibhialta na Ohio CoimisiĂșn TEIP a lĂĄimhseĂĄil agus a ionchĂșiseamh
Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" faoi an argĂłint BRĂAGACH /
suaibhreosach ag lĂomhain go raibh sĂ© anabaĂ chomhdĂș: (a) gur bhain gortĂș / dĂobhĂĄil a rinneadh ag
17. an OCRC AGHAIDH Newsome atĂĄ nithiĂșla agus particularized sa mhĂ©id is go bhfuil a bhfuil thart ar
240 Newsome lĂĄ chun an comhad GearĂĄn / Muirear agus a fear "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As
IdirdhealĂș" faoi bhrĂĄid an OCRC go maith laistigh den reacht teorainneacha a chomhdĂș. TacaĂonn (b)
an fhianaise taifead go bhfuil dTAOBH idir an gnĂomhaĂocht arna dĂ©anamh ag an OCRC agus an
EEOC a chur faoi deara Newsome an dĂobhĂĄil / dĂobhĂĄil a tharla i iarrachtaĂ baint aici le cearta cosanta
atĂĄ laistigh de na "chrios an Ășis" chun an faoiseamh atĂĄ ĂĄ lorg. Ina theannta sin, tĂĄ dea-bhunaithe
cleachtas idirdhealaitheach cĂłrasach ag an EEOC i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na GearĂĄin / Muirir arna dtionscnamh ag
Newsome. DealraĂonn sĂ© go uair a fuarthas an EEOC comhfhreagras Ăł na OCRC ag lĂomhain go raibh
Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" anabaĂ chomhdĂș, cheap an EEOC go
mbeadh Newsome bheith aineolach ar dhlĂthe agus nĂ ar an eolas faoi na hĂ©agĂłracha COIRIĂIL agus
SHIBHIALTA i lĂĄimhseĂĄil agus a prĂłiseĂĄil a GearĂĄin / Muirear. Chun an OCRC agus dĂomĂĄ ar an
EEOC ar, leagann Newsome amach agus a n-idirdhealaitheach exposes, claonadh a lĂĄimhseĂĄil agus
dochar a "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș." (C) go gcreideann Newsome go mbeidh an
fhianaise taifead tacĂș leis an dĂłchĂșlacht go leanann an dĂobhĂĄil / dĂobhĂĄil sĂ leanĂșnach agus a chothĂș sa
ar OCRC agus a lĂĄimhseĂĄil an EEOC ar na nGearĂĄn / Mhuirir a sĂĄsamh le cinneadh fabhrach Ăł chĂșirt
GAN ceangail / naisc agus pearsanta / airgeadais / ĂIS gnĂł na FreagrĂłirĂ agus iad siĂșd a raibh siad
hĂ©adan a fhĂĄil ar an EEOC agus OCRC chun dul i mbun na cleachtais neamhdhleathach / mĂdhleathach
i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș."
Courtney v Smith, 297 F.3d 455 (6 Ăș Cir Ohio, 2002.) - Chun crĂocha an athbhreithniĂș
breithiĂșnach faoin Acht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin (APA), nĂ fĂ©idir le pĂĄirtĂ a bheith
"drochthionchar ... de rĂ©ir bhrĂ an reacht iomchuĂ" mura bhfuil an pĂĄirtĂ laistigh den
chrios an Ășis a iarrtar a chosaint ag an reacht. 5 USCA § 702. . . .
[4] a shĂĄsamh cĂĄs-nĂł-chonspĂłid Airteagal III riachtanas, nĂ mĂłr gearĂĄnaĂ a
bhunĂș trĂ ghnĂ©: (1) gortĂș i bhfĂric go bhfuil nithiĂșla agus particularized; (2) ceangal idir
an dĂobhĂĄil agus an t-iompar atĂĄ i gceist, sa mhĂ©id is go NĂ mĂłr a bheith gortaithe go
cothrom inrianaithe a chosantĂłra gnĂomhaĂochta; agus (3) a dĂłchĂșlacht go mbeadh an
dĂobhĂĄil a sĂĄsamh le cinneadh fabhrach na cĂșirte. USCAConst. 3, § 2, CL. 1
[5] cheadaĂonn [6] Alt 10 (a) den Acht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin (APA)
pĂĄirtithe gortaithe a fhĂĄil ar athbhreithniĂș breithiĂșnach ar ghnĂomhartha
gnĂomhaireachta a shĂĄraĂonn lĂomhnaĂtear reachtanna cĂłnaidhme. 5 USC § 702 ("TĂĄ
duine ag fulaingt mar gheall ar ghnĂomh dlĂthiĂșil mĂcheart gnĂomhaireachta, nĂł
dochar difear nĂł arb Ă©agĂłir leis gnĂomh ghnĂomhaireacht de rĂ©ir bhrĂ an reacht
ĂĄbhartha, i dteideal athbhreithniĂș breithiĂșnach de."). A gearĂĄnaĂ iarraidh ar athbhreithniĂș
breithiĂșnach ar ghnĂomh gnĂomhaireacht faoi na APA, ĂĄfach, nach mĂłr, a chomhlĂonadh
ach amhĂĄin na rialacha bunreachtĂșla faoi na sheasamh, ach nĂ mĂłr a lĂ©iriĂș stuamachta
seasamh freisin. Nat'l Creidmheasa Admin. v An Chéad Nat'l Bank & Trust Co, 522 US
479, 488, 118 S.Ct. 927, 140 L.Ed.2d 1 (1998) (NCUA) ("TĂĄimid tar Ă©is a lĂ©iriĂș § 10 (a)
den APA a fhorchur ina riachtanas seasamh stuamachta sa bhreis ar an riachtanas, a
fhorchuirtear le hAirteagal III den Bhunreacht, go gearĂĄnaĂ ar bhain gortĂș leor i
ndĂĄirĂre. "). Stuamachta seasamh ann mĂĄ tĂĄ an leas a dhĂ©anann iarracht an gearĂĄnaĂ a
chosaint "fhĂ©adfaĂ a rĂĄ laistigh den chrios na leasanna a chosaint nĂł a rialĂș ag an reacht ...
atĂĄ i gceist. "Id. (Ellipsis i bunaidh) (luaigh Ass'n de Serv PrĂłiseĂĄil SonraĂ. EagraĂochta.,
Inc v Campa, 397 US 150, 153, 90 Shivnan S.Ct. 827, 25 L.Ed.2d 184 (1970)).
Bunten v Bunten, 710 757 NE2d (.. Ohio App.3.Dist, 1998) - d'fhéadfadh teacht
BreithiĂșnas a bheith i gcoitinne; nuair nach raibh cinntĂ fĂorais agus conclĂșidĂ an dlĂ a
iarrann pĂĄirtĂ, beidh rialtacht na n-imeachtaĂ ag an leibhĂ©al triail a thoimhdiĂș. Rialacha
Civ.Proc., Riail 52.
NG Yip Yee v Barber, 267 F.2d 206 (9 Ăș Cir 1959.) - FĂ©adfaidh cĂșirt fhĂĄgĂĄil ar thorthaĂ
comhlacht riarachĂĄin mĂĄs rud Ă© nach dtacaĂonn an fhianaise nĂł mĂĄs rud Ă© ar an
taifead ina iomlĂĄine dealraĂonn sĂ© go bhfuil botĂșn dĂ©anta.
45. Newsome Creideann go dtacaĂonn an FIANAISE taifead a thuilleadh agus a chothabhĂĄil
go bhfuil an phlĂ©adĂĄil an toirt, chomh maith le "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș" agus ina
dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012 "Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison" Buaileann
18. an seasamh bunreachtĂșil, ach freisin LĂ©irĂonn "STUAMACHTA" seasamh le tacaĂocht Ăł na fĂricĂ,
fianaise agus conclĂșidĂ i lĂĄthair i plĂ©adĂĄlacha dlĂ ar Newsome.
46. STUAMACHTA seasamh ann atĂĄ sa mhĂ©id is go lorgaĂonn an Newsome leas a chosaint
fhĂ©adfaĂ a rĂĄ laistigh den chrios leasa a chosaint agus tĂĄ sĂ© rialaithe ag reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn
cĂșrsaĂ sin.
47. Chun crĂocha CAOMHNĂ de na saincheisteanna atĂĄ leagtha amach sa phlĂ©adĂĄil an toirt,
chomh maith le Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș" agus ina dhiaidh sin Beal
24, 2012 "Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison," tĂĄ sĂ go sonrach iarraidh
go cinntĂ arna solĂĄthar ag an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn agus chuig an gCoimisiĂșn
Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta a thacĂș le "TorthaĂ FĂricĂ agus ConclĂșid an DlĂ" doicimĂ©adaithe
maidir leis na saincheisteanna a ardaĂodh ina GearĂĄn / Muirear agus a chomhdĂș ina dhiaidh sin.
48. Newsome trĂĄthĂșil, DearbhaĂonn i gceart agus go sĂĄsĂșil a agĂłid i gcoinne an EEOC ar
"DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta" i go sĂĄraĂonn sĂ© cearta ar Newsome ar urraithe / a rĂĄthaĂtear le
reachtanna / dlĂthe a rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin. Thairis sin, go bhfuil an OCRC agus an EEOC botĂșn i
lĂĄimhseĂĄil na Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș."
49. Toisc go bhfuil an StĂĄt de Ohio ar "athlĂł" StĂĄt, raibh cosc ar an EEOC Ăł rindreĂĄla a
"DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta." DĂĄ bhrĂ sin,, Newsome trĂĄthĂșil, RUDAĂ i gceart agus go sĂĄsĂșil ar
na gnĂomhartha atĂĄ neamhdhleathach / neamhdhleathach an EEOC agus a chuid iarrachtaĂ chun a
bhaint aici le cearta atĂĄ sainordaithe ag REACHT leis an gceist seo chur siar chuig an OCRC a
lĂĄimhseĂĄil agus a phrĂłiseĂĄil.
50. An EEOC TĂĄ earrĂĄid i lĂĄimhseĂĄil a neamhdhleathach / neamhdhleathach iarraidh
Newsome ar a bheith acu Muirear COIMISINĂIR a EISIĂINT.
51. Newsome trĂd an comhdĂș an phlĂ©adĂĄil an toirt, chomh maith le "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil /
Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș" agus ina dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012 "Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012
Ăn Derwin E. Jamison," caomhnaĂonn an SAINCHEISTEANNA atĂĄ laistigh de na plĂ©adĂĄlacha /
doicimĂ©id . NĂ MĂR GACH Saincheisteanna a cheanglaĂtear le reacht / dlĂ a thabhairt orthu.
III. IARRATAS AR EEOC'S A CHINNEADH "SCRĂOFA" - TORTHAĂ DE FĂRICĂ AGUS
CONCLĂID AN DLĂ, IARRATAS AR "SCRĂOFA" TEIDEAL VII LĂIRIĂ / TUAIRIM
Cleveland v Posner, 2011-Ohio-1370 (Ohio App.8.Dist, 2011..) - Chun fhonn a
chinneadh an ghnĂomhaireacht riarachĂĄin a chinneadh an TĂĄ tacaĂocht ag
substaintiĂșil, fianaise iontaofa, agus profa, "reliabl e fhianaise" Is iontaofa; go bhfuil,
is fĂ©idir Ă© a bheith iontaofa go muinĂneach.
Sarr v Gonzales, 485 F.3d 354 (6 Ăș Cir 2007.) - NĂ mĂłr ChĂșirt Achomhairc chothĂș
cinneadh riarachĂĄin mĂĄs rud Ă© go bhfuil an cinneadh le tacaĂocht Ăł rĂ©asĂșnta,
substaintiĂșil, agus profa fianaise ar an taifead a mheas ina n-iomlĂĄine.
ComhghuaillĂocht le haghaidh SolĂĄthair an Rialtais v Tionscail PhrĂosĂșin ChĂłnaidhme,
Inc, 365 F.3d 435 (6 Ăș Cir 2004.) - MĂĄ tĂĄ aon fhianaise chun tacĂș le cinneadh
gnĂomhaireachta, nach bhfuil cinneadh gnĂomhaireachta treallach nĂł capricious. . . .
NĂ athbhreithniĂș breithiĂșnach Deferential gnĂomhaĂochta gnĂomhaireacht faoi
Acht um NĂłs Imeachta RiarachĂĄin (APA) faoiseamh gnĂomhaireacht de chuid dualgas a
fhorbairt ar bhonn fianaise le haghaidh a chuid torthaĂ. 5 USCA § 551 et seq.
19. 52. An toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . "Ă chur i lĂĄthair chun crĂocha CHAOMHNĂ na
saincheisteanna a ardaĂodh i Newsome ar" GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș "agus ina
dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012" Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison. "
53. TĂĄ an CoimisiĂșn tar Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta botĂșn i lĂĄimhseĂĄil na Newsome ar
"OifigiĂșla GearĂĄn / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș" agus ina dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012 "Freagra Chun Litir
8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison."
54. TĂĄ an CoimisiĂșn tar Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta earrĂĄid ina TEIP a chur siar
Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" chun an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn.
55. TrĂd an toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . "Newsome TRĂTHĂIL, CEART agus go sĂĄsĂșil i
lĂĄthair agus caomhnaĂonn an CEIST go NĂ MĂR an cinneadh (Ă) ag an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio
gCoimisiĂșn agus chuig an gCoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta a thacĂș le FIANAISE
substaintiĂșil, iontaofa agus profa.
56. An REACHTANNA / DHLĂTHE rialaĂonn DĂșirt nithe tacĂș leis go bhfuil an Chearta
Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșn DLĂNSE a lĂĄimhseĂĄil agus a phrĂłiseĂĄil Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil /
Muirear As Idirdhealaithe." Ina theannta sin, aithnĂonn an OCRC fhĂĄil "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear
As IdirdhealĂș" Newsome d'fhĂ©adfadh a shĂĄbhĂĄil COSTAIS / COSTAIS sa mhĂ©id go bhfuil a
atĂĄirgeadh ar a bhfuil an OCRC aghaidh mar "voluminous."
57. An CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta na Ohio comhairle Newsome go bhfuil sĂ© ag fĂĄil,
agus voluminous doiciméadacht maidir le muirear ionchasacha idirdhealaithe in aghaidh d'iarfhostóir, an
"litir
gnĂłlacht Garretson RĂșn GrĂșpa, Inc agus Messina SolĂĄthar Foirne. "DĂĄ bhrĂ sin, is fĂ©idir le duine rĂ©asĂșnta / aigne i
gcrĂch go Newsome le GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" TĂĄ tacaĂocht ag substaintiĂșil, iontaofa
agus FIANAISE profa!
58. An fhianaise taifead TacaĂonn an CoimisiĂșn freisin go Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta
lĂĄimhseĂĄil neamhdhleathach / mĂdhleathach agus claontacht, dochrach, agus idirdhealaitheach na
nGearĂĄn a OifigiĂșil Newsome BaintrĂ / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș. "
59. An CoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta ar lĂĄimhseĂĄil na nGearĂĄn a OifigiĂșil
Newsome BaintrĂ / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș Is Ă© "treallach agus capricious.
60. TĂĄ an CoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise FostaĂochta TEIP a chur siar GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil /
Muirear As IdirdhealĂș "chun an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn mar a cheanglaĂtear le reacht
MANDATORILY / dlĂ treallach agus capricious.
61. An CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta na Ohio TĂĄ i teip a lĂĄimhseĂĄil agus GearĂĄn
OifigiĂșil Newsome BaintrĂ / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș "lĂomhain sĂ© go raibh a phrĂłiseĂĄil anabaĂ
chomhdĂș is treallach agus capricious! BhĂ comhdaĂodh GearĂĄn Newsome BaintrĂ / Muirear MAITH
laistigh de na 240 Laethanta gĂĄ chun gnĂomh a bhfuil an CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta Ohio.
62. An Chearta Sibhialta na Ohio CoimisiĂșn ORBH FHĂ a chur i lĂĄthair aon fhianaise ann
go GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil Newsome BaintrĂ / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș "BhĂ anabaĂ chomhdĂș cĂ© AithnĂonn
sĂ©," le fios do litir dĂșinn araon Chearta Sibhialta Ohio ChoimisiĂșn agus do na Comhionann US
CoimisiĂșn Deiseanna FostaĂochta a fuarthas doicimĂ©adĂș comhionann. " FĂ©ach ar thaispeĂĄint "C" de
seo ceangailte agus a ionchorprĂș trĂ thagairt a dhĂ©anamh amhail is dĂĄ atĂĄ leagtha amach i anseo
iomlĂĄn.
20. 29 CFR § 1601.15 (b) ĂDARĂS IMSCRĂDAITHE:
(A) Beidh an t-imscrĂșdĂș de mhuirear a dhĂ©anamh ag an gCoimisiĂșn, a
imscrĂșdaitheoirĂ, nĂł aon ionadaĂ eile arna ainmniĂș ag an gCoimisiĂșn. Le linn an
imscrĂșdaithe den sĂłrt sin, fĂ©adfaidh an CoimisiĂșn ĂșsĂĄid a bhaint as na seirbhĂsĂ
gnĂomhaireachtaĂ StĂĄit agus ĂĄitiĂșla a bhfuil de chĂșram ag riaradh an dlĂ fostaĂochta
cothrom cleachtas nĂł gnĂomhaireachtaĂ ChĂłnaidhme cuĂ, agus fĂ©adfaidh an t-eolas a
bailĂodh trĂ ĂșdarĂĄis nĂł gnĂomhaireachtaĂ den sĂłrt sin a ĂșsĂĄid. Mar chuid de gach
imscrĂșdĂș, cuirfidh an CoimisiĂșn glacadh le haon rĂĄiteas nĂł fianaise a seasamh i
ndĂĄil leis na lĂomhaintĂ an mhuirir a bhfuil an duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir is mian leis
an duine atå ag déanamh an muirear ar son an duine sin, mås ann, nó an freagróir a
chur isteach.
(B) Mar chuid den imscrĂșdĂș an ChoimisiĂșin, fĂ©adfaidh an CoimisiĂșn a cheangal ar an
duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir a chur ar fĂĄil rĂĄiteas a n-ĂĄirĂtear:
(1) Aon rĂĄiteas ar gach dochar ar leith go ndearna an duine fhulaing agus an dĂĄta ar
ar tharla gach dĂobhĂĄil;
(2) I gcĂĄs gach dĂobhĂĄil, rĂĄiteas a shonraĂonn an gnĂomh, beartas nĂł cleachtas aige
a lĂomhnaĂtear a bheith neamhdhleathach;
(3) Maidir le gach gnĂomh, polasaĂ chleachtas, nĂł a lĂomhnaĂtear a harmed an duine a
Ă©ilĂonn gurb Ă©agĂłir, rĂĄiteas ar na fĂorais a bheith ina chĂșis an duine a Ă©ilĂonn gurb
Ă©agĂłraithe chun a chreidiĂșint go bhfuil an gnĂomh, beartas nĂł cleachtas
idirdhealaitheach.
(C) FĂ©adfaidh an CoimisiĂșn a cheangal ar chomhdhĂĄil fĂricĂ a aimsiĂș leis na pĂĄirtithe
roimh cinneadh ar chĂșiseamh an idirdhealaithe. Is Ă© an chomhdhĂĄil go prĂomha fĂłram
imscrĂșdaithe atĂĄ beartaithe a shainmhĂniĂș ar na saincheisteanna, chun a chinneadh a
bhfuil gnéithe undisputed, a réiteach na saincheisteanna sin Is féidir a réiteach agus
chun a fhĂĄil amach an bhfuil bunĂșs le haghaidh socrĂș idirbheartaithe an muirear.
(D) nach bhfuil an ChoimisiĂșin ĂșdarĂĄs a fhiosrĂș muirear teoranta do na nĂłsanna
imeachta atĂĄ leagtha amach i mĂreanna (a), (b), agus (c) den alt seo.
63. Beidh an fhianaise taifead tacĂș go Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar
IdirdhealĂș" agus ina dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012 dhearbhaigh "Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012
Ăn Derwin E. Jamison" SAINCHEISTEANNA i lĂĄthair agus ĂĄ dtacĂș ag RĂITEAS de GACH dochar
ar leith ag Newsome . DĂĄ bhrĂ sin, tĂĄ Newsome ag Ă©ileamh go bhfuil an cinneadh (Ă) an Chearta
Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn agus CoimisiĂșn Comhionannais Deiseanna FostaĂochta "TorthaĂ FĂricĂ agus
ConclĂșid an DlĂ" a chothĂș rialĂș / cinneadh.
64. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș" agus ina dhiaidh sin Beal 24,
2012 "Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison" ardaĂonn an
SAINCHEISTEANNA agus solĂĄthraĂonn RĂITIS sonrĂłfar an gnĂomh, beartas nĂł cleachtas aige a
lĂomhnaĂtear a bheith neamhdhleathach. Thairis sin, acht, beartas nĂł cleachtas aige le "GearĂĄn
OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" tacaĂochtaĂ Newsome agus ina dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012 "Freagra
Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison."
65. Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" Leagann amach an "FĂRICĂ
AN GHEARĂIN" a thacaĂonn leis an faoiseamh ĂĄ iarraidh sĂ ann.
66. TrĂd an toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . "De bhun an gCeathrĂș LeasĂș DĂ©ag ar an
mBunreacht,, ĂILIMH Newsome agus CHEANGAL go Chearta Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșn agus na
Deiseanna FostaĂochta Comhionann a chur ar fĂĄil di cĂłip de na freagrĂłirĂ 'FREAGRA le" GearĂĄn
OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș " ionas gur fĂ©idir lĂ©i a cheart nĂł a ceart chun CHOMĂRTAS agus /
nó RESPOND i fhrisnéis (må toghadh é sin a dhéanamh).
21. 67. Newsome trĂd an toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . "RUDAĂ le lĂĄimhseĂĄil neamhdhleathach /
mĂdhleathach, claonadh, dochrach agus idirdhealaitheach an ChoimisiĂșin Deiseanna Comhionann
FostaĂochta lĂĄimhseĂĄil" GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș. "
68. CĂ© gur chuir an FostaĂochta Deiseanna Comhionann CoimisiĂșn / Wilma Javey TĂĄillĂ
maidir le Newsome a comhdaĂodh i gcoinne freagrĂłirĂ - an gnĂłlacht Garretson RĂșn Group Inc agus
Messina Staffi NG / Messina CĂłrais BainistĂochta - a luaitear i bpĂĄirt:
"TĂĄ muid i gcrĂch athbhreithniĂș cĂșramach ar an muirear an idirdhealaithe fostaĂochta a
chomhdĂș tĂș i gcoinne an RĂșn gnĂłlacht Garretson GrĂșpa, Inc (473-2012-00832
Muirear Uimh.). Ăr athbhreithniĂș san ĂĄireamh ar an measĂșnĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar fhaisnĂ©is
ar fad ar fĂĄil duit.
Mar thoradh ar ĂĄr n-athbhreithniĂș cĂșramach a dhĂ©anamh ar an muirear comhdaithe
agat, nĂ mĂłr dĂșinn a chinn go STOP PRĂISEĂIL an muirear. LĂ©irĂonn ĂĄr n-
athbhreithniĂș ar an bhfianaise atĂĄ ar fĂĄil go raibh d'aois agus cine aon tionchar ar do
fhoirceannadh. TĂĄ fianaise ann go lĂ©irĂonn NĂL raibh retaliated tĂș i gcoinne. TĂĄ NĂL
lĂ©iriĂș go mbeidh tuilleadh imscrĂșdaithe mar thoradh ar chinneadh de shĂĄrĂș. . . . "
"TĂĄ muid i gcrĂch athbhreithniĂș cĂșramach ar an muirear an idirdhealaithe fostaĂochta a
chomhdĂș tĂș i gcoinne SolĂĄthar Foirne Messina & Messina CĂłrais BhainistĂochta
(473-2012-00837 Uimh. Muirear). Ăr athbhreithniĂș san ĂĄireamh ar an measĂșnĂș a
dhéanamh ar fhaisnéis ar fad ar fåil duit.
Mar thoradh ar ĂĄr n-athbhreithniĂș cĂșramach a dhĂ©anamh ar an muirear comhdaithe
agat, nĂ mĂłr dĂșinn a chinn go STOP PRĂISEĂIL an muirear. LĂ©irĂonn ĂĄr n-
athbhreithniĂș ar an bhfianaise atĂĄ ar fĂĄil go bhfuil do aois agus cine raibh aon tionchar
ar do fhoirceannadh. TĂĄ fianaise ann go lĂ©irĂonn NĂL raibh retaliated tĂș i gcoinne. TĂĄ
NĂL lĂ©iriĂș go mbeidh tuilleadh imscrĂșdaithe mar thoradh ar chinneadh de shĂĄrĂș. . . . "
agus ar fĂĄil DĂfhostĂș agus FĂłgra um Chearta a deir go pĂĄirteach:
DĂFHOSTĂ AGUS FĂGRA UM CHEARTA: "eisĂonn an EEOC an cinneadh seo a leanas:
Bunaithe ar a imscrĂșdĂș, tĂĄ an EEOC in ann a thabhairt i gcrĂch go mbunaĂonn an t-
eolas a fhaightear sĂĄruithe ar na reachtanna. NĂ bhaineann sĂ© seo a dheimhniĂș go
bhfuil an freagrĂłir ag comhlĂonadh na reachtanna. Bhfuil cinneadh dĂ©anta maidir le
NĂL AON saincheisteanna eile a d'fhĂ©adfadh a fhorlĂ©iriĂș mar a bheith arna dtarraingt
anuas ag an muirear seo. "
Bosca neamh-mharcĂĄilte: "TĂĄ an EEOC ghlac torthaĂ an stĂĄit nĂł ĂĄitiĂșil fostaĂochta
cleachtais chĂłra ghnĂomhaireacht a imscrĂșdĂș ar an muirear seo."
an toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . "A sheirbheĂĄil leis seo ar an gCoimisiĂșn FostaĂochta Comhionann
Deiseanna agus Ohio Chearta Sibhialta CoimisiĂșn um sholĂĄthar FIANAISE an CAOMHNĂ de na
ceisteanna atĂĄ anseo agus iad siĂșd a ardaĂodh i" GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear Ar IdirdhealĂș "agus ina
dhiaidh sin Beal 24, 2012" Freagra Chun Litir 8 Bealtaine, 2012 Ăn Derwin E. Jamison. "
Newsome Creideann an gnĂomh aon ghnĂł agus go toiliĂșil an ChoimisiĂșin Deiseanna Comhionann
FostaĂochta TEIP chun ceiliĂșradh a dhĂ©anamh ar an Bosca ĂĄ rĂĄ, "TĂĄ an EEOC ghlac an thorthaĂ na
gnĂomhaireachta fostaĂochta stĂĄit nĂł ĂĄitiĂșil cothrom cleachtais a imscrĂșdĂș ar an muirear seo"
TacaĂonn eile go raibh a fhios sĂ© agus / nĂł Ba chĂłir a bheith dTABHARFAR an riachtanas agus / nĂł
SAINORDAITHIGH reacht a chur siar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" chun an Chearta
Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn.
69. Newsome trĂd an toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . " TRĂTHĂIL, i lĂĄthair CEART agus
leordhĂłthanach a agĂłidĂ i gcoinne an lĂĄimhseĂĄil neamhdhleathach / neamhdhleathach agus a phrĂłiseĂĄil
22. "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" ag an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșin agus CoimisiĂșn
Comhionannais Deiseanna FostaĂochta.
70. TĂĄ NĂL FIANAISE profa chun tacĂș leis an dearbhĂș um Chearta Sibhialta Ohio
ChoimisiĂșin go raibh Newsome ar "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș" anabaĂ chomhdĂș.
Gladieux v Ohio State Med. Is Ă© "fianaise profa" chun tacĂș le cinneadh ag
gnĂomhaireacht riarachĂĄin fianaise go bhfuil claonadh a chruthĂș ar an tsaincheist atĂĄ i
gceist, agus tå sé åbhartha - Bd, 728 NE2d 459 (Ohio. App.10.Dist 1999.)..
71. TĂĄ NĂL FIANAISE profa chun tacĂș leis an gCoimisiĂșn Comhionannas Deise
FostaĂochta TEIP ĂĄbhar a chur siar chuig an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn mar a cheanglaĂtear
MANDATORILY ag REACHTANNA / DHLĂTHE rialaĂonn cĂșrsaĂ sin.
72. Newsome trĂd an toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . "ĂilĂonn seo go bhfuil an Chearta Sibhialta
Ohio CoimisiĂșn na dualgais a AIREACHTA dlite Newsome i bprĂłiseĂĄil a lĂĄimhseĂĄil, agus a imscrĂșdĂș
a" GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As Idirdhealaithe. "Thairis sin, ar fĂĄil lena Newsome" TorthaĂ FĂricĂ
agus ConclĂșid an DlĂ "le aon / na cinntĂ go lĂ©ir a rinneadh san ĂĄbhar seo.
Dayton Tavern, Inc v Ohio Deochanna RialĂș Comm, 732 NE2d 465 (Ohio App.2.Dist
1999..) -. AthbhreithniĂș ĂĄ dhĂ©anamh ar ordĂș riarachĂĄin, nĂ mĂłr coitianta plĂ©adĂĄlacha
cĂșirte chur siar chun gnĂomhaireacht riarachĂĄin ar chinntĂ fĂorais mura gcinnfidh an
chĂșirt go bhfuil siad go hinmheĂĄnach ar neamhrĂ©ir, thĂĄinseamh le fianaise de rĂĄiteas
neamhrĂ©ireacha roimhe sin, ar chuid eile tĂĄtail mĂchuĂ, nĂł ar shlĂ eile unsupportable.
73. I CAOMHNĂ cearta Newsome agus CAOMHNĂ de SAINCHEISTEANNA, an toirt
"RFROD & NOR. . . "Faoi bhrĂĄid leis seo chuig an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio gCoimisiĂșn agus chuig an
gCoimisiĂșn Deiseanna Comhionann FostaĂochta.
74. I CHAOMHNA cearta Newsome agus CAOMHNĂ de SAINCHEISTEANNA, stĂĄit
Newsome go bhfuil NĂL fianaise inchreidte chun tacĂș le cinneadh an teip ar an Chearta Sibhialta Ohio
ChoimisiĂșin chun ionchĂșiseamh a dhĂ©anamh ar Newsome "GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As
IdirdhealĂș" ag lĂomhain go raibh sĂ© anabaĂ chomhdĂș. DĂĄ bhrĂ sin, ag tacĂș go bhfuil EARRĂID Clear
i mbreithiĂșnas an OCRC!
Wurzelbacher v Colerain Twp. Bd. Iontaobhaithe, 663 NE2d 713 (Ohio App.1.Dist
Hamilton Co, 1995...) - Is Ă© Nuair a Ă©ileoidh pĂĄirtĂ go raibh dĂłthain fianaise mar ĂĄbhar
dlĂ chun tacĂș le cinneadh riarachĂĄin, An ChĂșirt Achomhairc. . . chun a chinneadh cibĂ© an
bhfuil aon inniĂșil, fianaise inchreidte chun tacĂș le cinneadh riarachĂĄin.
LP Cavett Co v US Roinn Labor, 892 F.Supp. 973 (SD Ohio W.Div, 1995..) - Ba chĂłir
athbhreithniĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar ChĂșirt cinneadh gnĂomhaireachta scrĂșdĂș a dhĂ©anamh ar cĂ©
acu a bhà bunaithe cinneadh ar thosca åbhartha agus cibé an raibh earråid shoiléir ar
bhreithiĂșnais. 5 USCA § 706 (2) (A).
Conley v NĂĄisiĂșnta Mines Corp, 595 297 F.3d (6 Ăș Cir 2010.) -. . . NĂ mĂłr cinntĂ
fĂorasach a sheas mĂĄ tĂĄ siad le tacaĂocht Ăł fhianaise shuntasach sa taifead riarachĂĄin, agus
nĂ mĂłr an cinneadh ar fad a dhearbhaigh mĂĄ tĂĄ an. . . cinneadh rĂ©asĂșnach, le tacaĂocht Ăł
fhianaise shuntasach sa taifead, agus i gcomhrĂ©ir le rialĂș dlĂ.
75. Newsome trĂd an toirt "RFROD & NOR. . . BhĂ comhdaĂodh "trĂĄthĂșil, arna iarraidh sin
go cuĂ agus go sĂĄsĂșil go bhfuil an CoimisiĂșn um Chearta Sibhialta Ohio ar fĂĄil di a" TorthaĂ FĂricĂ agus
ConclĂșid an DlĂ "chun tacĂș le go Newsome ar" GearĂĄn OifigiĂșil / Muirear As IdirdhealĂș "anabaĂ.
NACH bhfuil ach nĂ bhĂonn ach "briathartha / clĂłscrĂofa i" dearbhĂș a chomhdĂș anabaĂ leor sa mhĂ©id is
go bhfuil Newsome i lĂĄthair fĂricĂ, fianaise a thabhairt i gcrĂch agus dlĂthiĂșla a chothĂș ag gnĂomhartha
na Chearta Sibhialta Ohio CoimisiĂșn a bheith treallach agus / nĂł capricious.