Safety Concerns vs. Perceived Performance
Outcomes of Athletic Equipment at a Small
J.D. Fisher; C.P. Gildea; I.W. Weaver
Increased number of participants
Increased in knowledge
House league High School College
Why do athletes manipulate equipment
Sports- MLAX, WLAX, FBL, WRL, MSC, WSC, FH
Degree of Manipulation, # of pieces, Age, Gender,
202 individuals 52 respondents (25.7%)
Male 27 (51.9%) and Female 25 (48.1%)
Most-WSC (16, 30.7%) Least- MSC & WLAX (4, 7.7%)
Mean age 20.1 yrs SD = 1.5
Mean yrs. Collegiate exp. 2.5 SD = 1.2
Pieces of Equip. mean 3.9 SD = 3.4
29 or 56% of respondents modify, manipulate, or
Sport Respondents Average Pieces of Equipment Worn
Field Hockey 5 4.75 SD = 4.38
Football 12 11.25 SD = 2.26
Men’s Lacrosse 5 6.80 SD = 1.30
Women’s Lacrosse 4 2.00 SD = 0.00
Men’s Soccer 4 1.00 SD = 0.82
Women’s Soccer 16 1.13 SD = 0.34
Wrestling 6 2.50 SD = 1.38
TOTAL 52 3.90 SD = 3.40
Top 3 Reasons to manipulate
Comfort (16, 55.2%)
Hinders Athletic performance (13, 44.8%)
Incorrect size (7, 24.1%)
Least important reason to manipulate
Education (0, 0.0% )
Men vs. Women
# of pieces P=0.000
“I am gaining an athletic advantage over someone who does
not change their protective equipment” (P=0.026)
Sport vs. Sport
Action of modification (P=0.021)
‘I don’t think it protects me” (P=0.014)
“I am gaining an advantage…(P=0.006)
Rate and reason for manipulation
56% do manipulate
Main reason is comfort
Number of Pieces- avg.= 3.9 (SD=3.4)
Men- 5.71 (SD=3.31)
Women- 1.84 (SD=1.99)
Reason= FBL & MLAX use more pieces
Sport vs. Sport
Number of Pieces
Men vs. Women
Reason for manipulation
More Men chose “to gain an athletic advantage”
Age vs. Age
Younger athletes- “It does not protect me”
Older athletes- ‘To gain an athletic advantage”
Low number of response
Males and Females should be managed
differently to promote use
Research may be used by coaches, referees,
athletes, ATC’s, manufactures, and anyone else
This is a pilot more research should be
Berg, R. (1992.) Safe at Home? Sport Officials and Equipment Manufacturers are Trying to Develop Products to Make Games Safer
for Athletes, but Researchers Has Not Yet Shown if They’ve Been Successful. Athletic Business. 16(8):27-30.
Bishop, M., P. Fiolkowski, B. Conrad, D. Brunt, J. Hodoryski. (2006.) Athletic Footwear, Leg Stiffness, and Running Kinematics.
Journal of Athletic Training. 41(4):387-392.
Braunstein, J.R., J.J. Zhang. (2005.) Dimensions of Athletic Star Power Associated with Generation Y Sports Consumption.
International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship. 6(4):242-267.
Caswell, S.V., R.G. Deivert. (2002.) Lacrosse Helmet Designs and the Effects of Impact Forces. Journal of Athletic Training.
Cianfrone, B.A., J.J. Zhang. (2006.) Differential Effects of Television Commercials, Athlete Endorsements, and Venue Signage During
a Televised Sports Event. Journal of Sport Management. 20(3):322-344.
Emery, C.A., B. Hagel, B.A. Morrongiello. (2006.) Injury Prevention in Child and Adolescent Sport: Whose Responsibility Is It? Clinical
Journal of Sports Medicine. 16(6):514-521.
Ingersoll, C.D. (2006.) It’s Time for the Evidence. Journal of Athletic Training. 41(1):7-7.
Knapik, J.J., S.W. Marshall, R.B. Lee, S.S. Darakjy, S.B. Jones, T.A. Mitchener, G.G. Delacruz, B.H. Jones. (2005.) Mouthguards in
Sport Activities. Sports Medicine. 37(2): 117-144.
Knowles, S.B., S.W. Marshall, K.M. Gusckiwicz. (2006.) Issues in Estimating Risks and Rates in Sports Injury Research. Journal of
Athletic Training. 41(2): 207-215.
Levy, M.L., B.M. Ozgur, C. Berry, H.E. Arvan, M.L. Apuzzo. (2004.) Birth and Evolution of the Football Helmet. Neurosurgery.
Stevens, J., A. Lathrop, C. Bradish. (2005.) Tracking Generation Y: A Contemporary Sport Consumer Profile. Journal of Sport
Sulheim, S., I. Holme, A. Ekeland, R. Bahr. (2006.) Helmet Use and Risk of head Injuries in Alpine Skiers and Snowboarders. Journal
of the American Medical Association. 295(8): 919-924.
Turbeville, S.D., L.D. Cowan, C.B. Pasque, T. Williams. (2007.) Acceptance of Helmet Use Among National Collegiate Athletic
Association Pole-Vaulting Coaches. International Journal of Sports Science and Coaching. 2(2):191-197.
Ward, C.W. (2004.) Teens Knowledge of Risk Factors for Sports Injuries. The Journal of School Nursing. 20(4):216-220.
Williams-Avery, R.M., D.P. MacKinnon. (1996.) Injuries and Use of Protective Equipment Among College In-line Skaters. Accident:
Analysis and Prevention. 28(6):779-84.