RCEC Email 4.7.03 (b)


Published on

Reconstructing Climatic and Environmental Changes"
Email 4.7.03 (b)

  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

RCEC Email 4.7.03 (b)

  1. 1. Page 1 of 44 RECORD TYPE: FEDERALT (NOTES MAIL) - CREATOR:"Watson, Harlan L (OES)" <WatsonHL~state.gov>( "Watson, Harlan L COES)" <Wa CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-APR-2003 19:15:] 6.00 SUBJECT:: TCS Enviro-Sci - Unilateral and Right.htm TO:Phil Cooney ( CN=Phil Cooney/OUJCEQ/o=EOP@BOP [ CEQ READ :UNKNOWN TOrKenneth L. Peel ( CN:4(enneth LD. Pee l/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@BOP[ CEQI READ :UNKNOWN TEXT: «<TCS Enviro-Sci - Unilateral and Right.htm»> A research story that I predict will nolt be carried by The New - TCS Enviro-Sci - Unilateral York Times. and Righ~t.htm--=~======= ATT CREATION ATTACHMENT I TIME/DATE: 0 00:oo:oo.o6 TEXT:I <BASE HREF=Hhttp://www~techcentralsta 0 ti 15/nvrwapellID15- 50&CID=1051-040303B.> <!-- main site poll code -- > <html> <head> <title>TCS: Enviro-Sci - Unilateral and Right</title> <META NAME=Irobots" CONTENT="all "> '<META NAME=&'title'" CONTENT="TCS - Tech entral Station"> <META NAME="ldescriptioni' CONTENT="Where Free Markets Meet Technology. y James K. Glassman">I Hosted b <META NAME="keywords" CONTENT="free market, lames glassman, technology, enviroment, science, CAFE, global defense warming, broadband, telecom, tauzin-dingell HR 1542, energy, Ken Adelman, Sallie galiunas, missle defense, president government policy, politics, news, bush comIentary, think tank, online magazine, iscussion, internet access, issues, d antil-trust, regulation, investing, rket, newsletter, jim glassman">I stock ma <META NAI4E="category" CONTENT="News & Mdia"> <META NAME="author" CONTENT="Tech Centra Station"> <META NAI4B="reply-to" CONTENT="info~techlentralstation <META NAI4E="copyright" CONTENT="Tech com"> Ceniral Station L.L.C. - 2002"1> <META NAME="rating" CONTENT="General"> <script language="JavaScript"> function MM-preloadlmagesc) { /v3.0 var d=document; if~d.images){ if(ld.D41tp) d.MM~p~new Arrayo; var i.]=d.MM~p length a=MM~preload~m ,e~rueis for(i=0; i<a.length; i+ file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03-CEQO29-fiwoefO)3 ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  2. 2. Page 2 of 44 if (a[ i I.indexof('" !-0) ( d.MMpOJ)I=new Image; d.MM~p[j++) .src=a[iJI;) function MMtsWapIMgRestore() ( /1v3.0 var i,x,a=document.MM s; for(i=O;a&&i<a~length&&(x~a[i])&&Xo~c.i 5 x.oSrc; - x.src= function MM-findObjcn, d) { //v4.0 var p,i,x; if(!d) d=docum-ent; if((p~n.indexofcl? rr))>o&:&paetfamentfleg d=parent.framesrn~substring(p+l)]I .oument; flfl-substring(0,p) :1 if(! (x=d[nfl&&d.all) x=d.all[nj; forj (i0o;!x&&i<d.forms~length;i++) xzd.forms for(i=o; !x&&d.layers&&i~d~layersen-th~i±+) x=MM findobj (n,d.layers~ji .docum ent); )if (!x && document.getElementByTd) x-Iocument getElemenltBy~d(n); return x; function MMCswapxmagec) { I/v3.0 var i~=~~~Msa~aeagmns document.MM sr=new Array; for(i=O;i<(a. length-2) ;ii-=3) if ((x=MM findObj(ariJ))!=null)(documnent.MMsr~j+-..=x; src; x.src=ari+2);I if(!x.oSrc) x.oSrc=x. function MMLgoTouRL()O //v3.0 var i, args=MM-goTouRL~arguments. document.MMreturnValue = false; for (i=0; i<(args.length-1); i÷=2)e arsi+loton"agsil,'.) function NMMOpenmrWindow (theURL, winName, window.open(theURL,winName features); features) { / /v2 .0 function doSaveAs C) if (document.execCommand) ( )else(f alert('Feature available only in Internet Exiorer 4.0 and later.'); function doflookrnarko) if U(navigator.appName == "Microsoft Internet Explorer") && (parselnt(navigator .appVersion) >= 4)) window.external.AddFavorite( documentalocation.href, document.tielep; )else{ if (navigator appName == "Netscape") alert('Feature available only in internet Exlorer. To bookmark this tscape press CTRL+D'); page in Ne </script> .nounderline (text-decoration: none; file:/D:SEARCH_7_9_03_CEQO29 fiwoefOO31 ceq.txt 811412003
  3. 3. Page 3 of 44 A:hover {text-decoraeion: underline; color: #ff8600;) input { font-family: Geneva, Anial, lnelvetica, san-serif; font-size: l0px; e-height: l0px; font-weight: lightenl lin select ( font-size: lopx; line-height: lOPx; font-family: Geneva, Anial, Helve tica, san-serif} </style> </head> <body topmangano0 leftmangin=o marginwidth-0 #ff8600 vlink=#003366 bgcolon=white marginheight~o link=#003366 alink= on'oad="MMcelarge('mesio gif', 'images/icon tech gif','images/icon-defense main. 'images/icon~_health.gif', 'im~ages/icon- gjf','images/icon-enviro gif', nvesting.gif','images/icon-energy gif)'I" <table cellpadding=o cellspacing=o widtlh=780> <tr height=82><td width=184><img src-ir1hges/logo-envino jpg width=184 height=82 border="O"></td><td width=596 background-images,'bannernbackgif g src=images/spacerngif height=l width4 valign=top><cim 596><br> <table cellpadding=o cellspacingo width=596 bonder=O> <tr><td width=450 valign=top> <table cellpadding~o cellspacing=o width=450 borden=O> <tr height=l8><td colspkn="l2"I><img src=images/spacen~gif height=l8> <tr height=5><td colspah="12">< I-- Imgflestore()" onD~ouseOver="MM-swap~mage~(.home <a href="javascript:;rr onMouseOut gif' .1)" onClick="MMgowoURL( 'parent', rollout','','images/home_rollout. index.jsp') ;return document.MM returnVal ue"><img src=images/back-hone~gjf heighb=5 bonder="o"'><Ia><img src=images/space r.gif width=109 height=5 name="home rollout"> --></td></tr> <tr height=15><td colsp~n="12"-><img src=images/spacerngif height <tr height=5><<- <td><img src=images/spacer.gif width=lO height <td><a href="javascript:;" onMouseOut-"M waplmagec 'main-roll', '', 'images/icon~-mailn.gif' -swap~mgRestoreo9" onMousec 'Iindex. ,l)" onClick="'MMgoToURL( 'parent' jsp');return document.MMcneturnvalueI><img src=images/back home-main.gi f border="O"></a><Itd> <td><img src=images/spacengif width=21 height=5></td> <td><a hnef="iavascript.I;" onb~ouseOut="MuMrswapImgnestoneoC" ouseOven="MM-swapImage ('tech ro~ll ,I, onM ±ages/icon- tech gif' 1) " onClick="MMuigo ToURL( 'parent', 'tech.jsp') ;return docum6nt .tMMnetunnValue"I><img snc~images,'nav_ back tech.gif bonder="IO"></a></td> <td><img snc=images/spacer~gif width=21 <td><a href="javascriPt:;r Onos~t"Msa~getro height=5></td> ouseoven="MM swap~mage( 'defense-roll', onM ' ',images/icon defense gif' .1)" onClick= "PMhgoToURL( 'parent', 'defense.jisp') ;netuIrn document .MM-retunnValue"><img ages/nav back defense~gif border=" 0><a</d src=im <td><img src=images/spacer.gif width=21 height=5></td> <td><a href="javascript 4 ~1 onMouseOut="MMswaplmgRestoreo" ouseOver='!MM4swap~mage(lenvino_roll' onM M-goToURL( 'parent', 'enviro-sci jsp') ,''4 images/icon envino gif' ,l) " onClick="M ;retiirn document.MMneturnValue"><img mages/nav back-envino_on.gif border="O" snc=i Lidth="71" height="5"></a></td> <td><img snc=images/spac r~gif width=21 <I -- height=5></td> <td><a href="javascr pt.." onMouseOut="MMswaplmgRestone(o" onMouseOver="MMswaplmagec 'health roll')'', k="M~goToURL( 'parent', 'health.html') 'images/icon-health.gif' ,l)" onClic ;re urn document.wMq_neturnValue"><img images/nay back-health.gif border="0"></A></td> src= <td><img src=images/spac rnguf width=21 height=5></td> file://D:SEARCH_7_9-03-CQ09fcweO1 eq.txt 8/14/2003
  4. 4. Page 4 of 44 <td><a href="javascript:;., onosotm-wpm~soe- ouseover='IMM-swapImage( 'investing roll],' onm ','images/icon-investing gif' .1)" on~i ick="MM-goTOUsRL('parent~',investing.ht l');return document.MM returnValue"><img src=images/nav back-investing.gif border="O"></a></td> 'ctd><img src=imageslspacer~gif width=2J. height=5></td> <td><ca href="javascriptY.." 0fMouseOut="MM¶swap~mgRestoreo'. ouseover="lMMswapImage('energy roll', onM '','images/icon energy gif' .1)" onClick-"M lt-goToTRL( 'parent', 'energy.html') ;retun document.MM-returnValue">•img src=imag es/nay back-energy.gif border="0"I></a>L/td>--> <tr height=22> <td align=center><img src=images/spacer~gif 20" name=`main-rollII></td> width="1231 height=", <td><img src=images/spacer~gif width=21 height=5></td> <td align=center><img src=imageslspacer 22" name="tech roll"></td>' guf width="13" height=" <td><img src=images/spacer gif width=21 height=5></td> <td align=center><uing src=images/spacer~gif 22" name="defense~roll"></td> width="23" height=" <td><img src=images/spacer~gif width=21 height=5></td> <ta alignzcenter><irng Arc=images/spacer~gif 22" name=±"enviro-roll`></td> width="14" height=" <td><img src~images/spdcer gif width=190 height=5></td> <!-- <td align=center><im src=images/spacer~gif ht="22" name="health-roll"I></td> width="18" heig <td><img src=images/spacer gif width=21 height=5><c/td> <td align=center><img src=images/spacer 22" name=" investing-roll "></td> ,gu width=",23" height=" <td><img src=images,'spaber~gf width=21 height=5></td> <td align=center><irng s c=images/spacer~gif 22" name=`energy-roll"></td> width="117"' height=" </table> </td><td width=l46 align=right> <table cellpadding=o cel lspacing=4 border=0> <form name="Search" Action="Isearch.jsp"I Method="get"> <tr> <t d> <input type="hidden' name="appid" value="losi"> <input type-"text" ae"erht" style="width:98;height.20;font-size 1;" value="Searchh onClick="this.value-I'">&nbsp;<input 1 type="image" src="image s/arrow.gif" width=l0 height=l0> <I tr> <I/form> <script src="helper/Javascript/menu.js> </script> <form name="all-sections" action="" method="IPOST`> <tr> <td> <select name="1story" onChange="MMjumpMenu( 'parent', thisO0) <option selected>TcS Sections</option> <option value=tech[ jsp>Tech</option> <option value=defe~ise jsp>Defense</option> file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03_CEQ029&j-woefOO3L-ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  5. 5. Page 5 of 44 <option vau~niro-sci .jsp>Enviro-sci</option> </select> <I/form> </table> <I tr> <tr height=15><td colspan=2 bccolor=#1C5586 aliqn=right><font face="Geneva, rial, Helvetica, san-serif" size-'I"l ccilor=`white`><SCRIPT SRC="helper/JavaScri pt/date-time.js"> </SCRTPT></font><img src=images,'spacer.gqif width=8></td></tr> <tr height=l><td colspan=2><img src=images/spacer.gif height=l></td></tr> <c/table> </td><c/tr>bglr=C[ <tr height=l><td colspan=2 bgoo=CDE5><cimg src=images/spacer.gif height=l> </td><c/tr> </ table> <script language= "JavaScript"> function MM-OpenBrWindowStay(theForm, th~URL,winName, features) { /1v2 .0 if( therorm.Password value " theURL = theURL±"?Password="+th&Form.Password value; if( theForm.Ernail.value != " theURm = theURL+"&Emai LttheForm.Email .value; if( theForm.actionreq.value != hi' theURL = thUL"ato~e=+heomatorqvle else if( theormn.Email.value theURL = thetURL+" ?Email=" 4theporm.Email .value; i~f( therorm.actionreq.value != ' thetURL = thUL"atorq"teomatorqvle I theURL = theURL+"?actionreq="+t eForm.actionreq.value; window, open (theURL, winName,features); return false; function MM-OpenBrWindowStayNoPasswordct eForm,theURL,winName, features){ //v2. 0 if( theForm.Email.value 1 theURL = teR+?mi=thor.Email .value; if( theForm.actionreq.value ! "I' theURL = theURL+"&action -eq="-Itherorm.acti~onreq.value; else if( theForm.actionreq.value 1 theURL = theURL+"?actionreqll+th Form.actionreq.value; window.open(theURL,winName, features); return false; file://D:SEARCH-7-9-03-CEQO29-fiwoefOO3 _-ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  6. 6. Page 6 of 4 function mm openBrWindowStayNoParms (th Form, theURL,winj~ame, window.open(theURL,winName features)~ features) ( //v2 .0 return false; </script> <table width="780" border=IOlr cellspac .ng="O' cellpadding'"O" bgoo=#CCC height="1"1> <tr> <td>•</td> </table> <table width="780" border=0O cellspacing="O"l cellpadding="0"> <tr valign="top"> <td width="157"> <table width="l00%" border="O" cellspacing=hOnl cellpadding="O" height=250 <tr> <td background=" images/hs hround enviro gif" align= "right"> <table width="135" border="0' cellspacing'0O" cellpadding=1o'1> <tr> <tr> <div align="right"> <a href=indexwr pper.jsp?PID=1051-155&CID=1051lBIOGLASSMAJA <img src="images/biog-assmanjames.gif" width="108' height="13 9" border="O"1> </td>hih=6"<'d <I tr> <tr> <td begcolo="60oo">< ihtt2><td <tr> <td bgelght="6"></td> gh='2I><t <Itr> <tr> <tr> <div align="right"> <table width="los" border="0" cellspacing="O" cellpadding= <tr> <td bgcolor="#0o3366"> <div align="~ceater"I><font face="Verdana, Anial, 1-jelve file://D:SEARCH-7-9-03-CEQO29-fiwoefoO2 seq.txt 8/14/2003
  7. 7. Page 7 of 44 tica, sans-serif" size='1' COlor="#PFFF FF">James K. Glassman</font></div> <tr> 3 <td bgcolor="# . 6 699"><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helve tica, sans-serif" size="l"1 color="#1FFF FF"'>Host, TCS</font></td> <tr> <td bg olor="#336699"><a hrf"alojlsmntc fftccnrlsaincmsujc nlteral and Right",> <img sr=iae/malato if" border=O></a></td> </tr> <tr> <td bgcolor="#336699"><a href=indexwrappernjsp?PID~l SSMANJAMES><img src='images/biagraphical.gif" border=O></a></td> </ table> </div> <Itd> </table> <I td> <td bgcolor="#000000" width=".."></td> </table> <br> <br> <table width="157" border="O" cel'spacing="O" cellpadding="O"> <tr> <td><a href="index.jsp"><img ~rc="images/archive-newest-articles width="157" height="lO" bcrder="IOI></a </td> gif" </table> <table width="157" border="O" cellspacing="Q" cellpadding="o"> <tr> <td valign=top width=9 bgcolox=#E5P3FF></td> <td valign=top width=145 bgcolor=#E5F3FP height=I8"> <table cellpadding=o cellspacing=Q border=O width=1OO%> <tr> <td valign=tcp height="6'"></td> <td valign=top></td> <tr><td valign=top width 15><img src=images/bullet-link gif><z/td> <td valign=top><font face=verdana,arial size=1><a class=nounderline wrapper. jsp?PID=1051-250&CID=l05l-040703 >American Lower Bducation</a></font></ td> <I tr> file://D:SEARCH_7-9_03-CEQO29-fiwoef~O s~eq.txt 8/14/2003
  8. 8. Page 8 of 44 <tr><td colspan=2><img src=irnagesIspacer.gif height=6><,'td></tr> <tr><td valign=top wid h=15><zimg src=images/bullet-link.gif></td> <td valign=top><font f ce=verdana,arial size=1><a class=nounderline wrapper.jsp?PID=1O51-25O&CTD=1051o o )3B>The Network 4 7 For Living In</a></font>< /td> <tr><td colspan=2><irng src=images/spacer~gif height=6></td></tr> <tr><td valign=top width=l5><img src=images/bullet link gif></td> <td valign=top><font face=verdana,arial size=1><a class=niounderline nsewrapper.jsp?PID=1051350&CID 0 1 Q5 1 0Q0703D>Don't Count On Tt</a></font></td> <tr><td colspan=2><img src=images/spacer-gif height=6></td></tr> </ table> <td valign=top width=8 bgcolcr=#E5F3FF></td> <td width=1 bgcolor=#DIE2F2><img src=images/spacer~gif width=l></td> <td width=l bgcolor=#OO2C5B><img src=images/spacer.gif width=1></td> </table> <table width=l157rr border=llOII eel-spacing="O" cellpadding="0`> <tr> <td><img src="images/archive Eeature-bottom.gif"I width="157" height=" <I tr> </table> <table width="157' height="6 borler="O"1 cellspacing="O" cellpadding'"O> <tr> <I/table> <table width="157" border="O" eel spacing="O" eellpadding="O> <tr> <td><a href='author- search.js ?Bioid=BIOGLASSMANJAMES"><img es/archive~articles-by~author.gif" widtl="157" height=lllor src="imag border="O"I></a></td> </table> <table width="157" border="O" eel spacing="O" cellpadding="o"> <tr> <td valign=top width=9 bgcolox=#E5F3FF></td> <td valign=top width=145 bgcolor=#ESF3EF height="8`> <table cellpadding=o cellspacing=O border=O width=100%> <tr> <td valign=top height=I6I></td> <td valign=top></td> <tr> file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03-CEQO29-fiwoefOO _-ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  9. 9. Page 9 of 44 <td valign=top widt2L=l 5 >cimg src=images/bullet <td valign=top><font face=verdana,arial link gif></td> size=l> <a class=nounderline href=techwrapper. s to Live By</a></font></td> jsp?PID=1051-250&CID=I </tr><tr><td coispar= 2 ><img src=images,'spacer gut height=6></td><1 <tr> <td valign=top width=l 5 ><irng src=images/bullet-irif~gif></td> <td valign=top><font face=verdana,arial size=l> <a class=naunderlne href=techwrapper. jsp?PID=105l-25o&CID=I <Itr><tr><td coispan= 2 ><img src=images/spacer gif height=6></td></ <tr> <td valign=top width:lS><img src=images/bullet-lilk~gif></td> •td valign=top><font fac =verdana,arial size=l> <a class=noundernine href=techwrappernjsp?PID=l Knight<Ia></ font></td> 0 5 1 1 2 5 0 &CID~l </tr><tr><ta coispan : ><img src=imnages/spacer~gif 2 height=6></td></ </table> <td valign=top width=8 bgcol r=#E5F3FF></td> <td width=i bgolr#DEF21mg src=images/spacer~gif width=l></td> <td width=l bgcolor=#oQ2C5B><img src=images/spacer~gif width=l></td> <Itr> </table> <table width="157' border=IIOrr cellspacing="O" cellpadding="O"> <tr> <td><img src="images/archije- eature-bottom.gif'I width-"157" height-" 8 "><Itd> </table> <table width=r1571 height="6" borler=O11 cellspacingzO" cellpadding="O"> <tr> <td></td> </table> <table width="157" border="O" cel spacing="O" cellpadding='O"> <tr> <td><ca href="search jsp'appid=lO5 1&searchstr=Kyoto"><img archive-articles-by issue.gif" width=I157ll src="irnages/ height="lo' 1border="O"></a></td> <Itable> <table width="157" border="O' cellspacing="O" cellpadding='O"> <tr> <td valign=top width=9 bgcolor=#ESF3FF></td> <td valign=top width=145 bgcol r=#E5F3FF height="8"> <table cellpadding=o cellspa ing=O border=O width=100%> <tr> <td valign=top height="6'><c/t> </tr> file:/ID:SEARCH_7_9_03_CEQO29 fiwoefOO3 ceq.txt 811412003
  10. 10. Page 10 of 4 <tr> <td valign=top widtj=l5><img sr~mgsbultln <td valign=top><font fa e=verdana,arial size=l> - -i>/d <a class=noun erline href=envirowrapper. jSP?PID=1051>450&CID </tr><tr><td colspan=2><img src=images/spacer~gjf height=6></td></ <tr> <td valign=top width=15><irng src=images/bullet link gif></td> <td valign~top><font fac =verdana,arial size=l> <a class=nound rline href=envirowrapperjisp?PIID1 itman 's Opportunity</a></font></td> 0 5 l- 5 0 &CID 4 </tr><tr><td coispan= ><img src=images,'spacer~gif 2 height=6></td></ <tr> <td valign=top width::lS><img src=images/bullet-link gif></td> <td valign=tcop><font fac =verdana,arial size=l> <a class=nounderline href=envirawrapper. jsp?PID=l051-450&CID derate No More</a></font></td> </tr><tr><td coispan=2><img src=images/spacer~gif height=6></td></ </table> <I td> <td valign=top width=8 bgcolcr=#E5F3FF></td> <td width=l bgcolor=#D1E2F2><img src~images/spacer gif width=l></td> <td width=l bgcolor=#OQ2C5B><img src=images/spacer.gif width=l></td> <td></td> <I tr> </table> <table width="157' border="O' cel spacingror'" cellpadding='!O"> <tr> <td><img src-"images/archjve-Eeature_bottom.gift" width="157h height=" 8`></td> </table> <br> <br> <br><br> </td> <td> <table width="lOO%"I border="O" cell pacing="O" cellpadding="2"> <tr> <td bgcolor="#005000I><font coclr="#FFFFFF" tica, sans-serif" size="1"><b><a class=rcunderline face="Verdana, Anial, Helve =white>TCS<,'tont><c/a> > <a class=ncundeiline href='index.jsp'><fcnt color href='enviro-sci.jsp'><font colcr= white>ENVIRO SCI<Ifont></a> > <script>var sub = ""; var issue = "Kyoto"; if (sub == null 1 sub.length == 0)( document. nlite("<a class=ncunderline .jsp?appid=1051&searchstr=II+issue.replace href='search (''" '1.+" '><font color=white>`+issue. tcUpperCaseo)+'</fcnt></a>");)lelse( doccment.write( search.jsp?appid=l051&searchstr="sub~relace "<a class=nounderline href=' ("7"ll) +''><font color=white>"÷su b.tcUpperCaseO+"<itcnt></a> > <a class=ncunderline &searchstr=h'+issue replace ("'.', ") +" '><font href='search~jsp?appid=l0 l 5 cclor=white>"+issue tcojpperCaseo)+" </font></a>") ; 1</script></b></font></'td> </table> file://D:SEARCH_7_9-03-CEQO29-fiwoefOO s-eq.txt 8114/2003
  11. 11. Page 11 of 44 <!-main story-- <table Width="100%" border="Q"1 cellspacing='O" cellpaddingrOll bgcolor="-# CCCCCCc" height=",l"> <tr> <td></td> </table> <table width=lOO0%II border="Q"1 callspacing="0"l cellpadding=1'o"> <tr> <td width="l0"></td> <td valign='tOp"><br> <b><font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif"- size= "5'>jnilateral an d Right</font></b> <table Width="1OO%" border: "0", cellspacing="o" cellpadding="o"1> <tr> <td width=99% bgcolor= #003366' height="l"></td> <td width=l% bgcolor=# 103366 align=right height="1l">.ctd> <I tr> <tr> <td width=99%><font fa e=verdana,arial size=1>By James K. Glass man</font></td> <td width=15% bgcolor=f003366 align=right><font face=verdana,ar lal size=l color=white> 04/03/2003 <Ifcnt></td> </table> <table width-"100%" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="5"I> <tr> <td> </td> <td align="right" width="212"> <table width="212" border="O" cellspacing="0O" cellpadding="O" <tr valign="middle"> <td><font face="A ial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a href="javascript:;" onClick="window~op n( 'etaf~article.jsp?CID=105l.o40303B&SE CTION=Enviro-Sci', 'emailarticle', 'scroI bars=yes,width=280,height=400');"><img src="images/article menubar-email.gif" width="12" height="10"1 border="0"-></a> <a style="colo:-:#000000;text-decoration:none;" href="i avascript:;" onClick="window.openc 'etaf--article.jsp?CID=1051o4o303B&SECTION=Ef viro-Sci', 'emailarticle', 'scrollbars=ye ,width=280,height=400'); 1 ">E-Mail</a></f ont>< /td> <td><font face="A ial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"1> a href="javascript :doBookmarko)"><img src"mgsatil < mnbr okakgf width="15" height="10" border="0"I><ia> 0 <a style='colo ':# 0 0000;text-decoration:none;" href="j avascript :doBookmnarko)">Bookmark•<'a></f ~nt></td> <td><font face="A ial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a href="javascript:;" onClick="window.op n( 'printer.jsp?CID=1051-040303B friendly', 'scrollbars=yes,width=555,heicht=400');"><img ,'print src="images/article-men ubar~print.gif" width="ll" height="l10" Iorder="0"></a> <a style="colo :#0OOOOO;text-decorationi:none;" href="i avascript:;" onClick="window~open( 'printer.jsp?CID=1051-040303B','printfriendly 'Iscrollbars=yes,width=555,height=400');">Print<Ia></font></td> <td><font face="Alial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a href='javascript:doSaveAso() ><img src="images/article_menubar-save.gif" width= "10" height="10" border="0"></a> <a style="colo :#00O000;text-decoration:none;u href="i avascript:doSaveAsoC)">Save</a></font></td> file://D:SEARCH_7-9_03_CEQO29-fiwoefOO s-eq.txt 8/14/2003
  12. 12. Page 12 of 44 </table> <ltd> <I tr> </table> <table width=216 horde-=0 cellspacingo0 cellpadding=o align~right> <tr> <td><img src=images/20 3 O4 0 3 -trees-large.jpg width=212 height=l 51 border=2></td> <I tr> <tr> <t d> <table border=0 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=o align=right> <tr> <td width=l0 bgcolor=#336699></'td> <td bgcolor=iOO3366><font face=Arial, Helvetica, sans -serif size=l color=#FFFFFF>&nbsp;Julic L. Betancourt&nbsp;</font></td> </table> <I td> </table> <font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2"> Then the war in Iraq ends a renewed clamor for the s to back harsh restrictions on carbon-dioxide emissions United State will begin. <br> <br>T he reasons are obvious. Environmentalis s, politicians and editorialists in the U.S. will complain that, if only the Bish Administration had been more "'multil ateral" and had backed the Kyoto Protoc 1 on global warming, more Europeans wou ld have joined our military campaign ag inst Saddam Hussein. <br> <br>Tony Bla ir, our strongest overseas ally, has bi terly criticized U.S. opposition to Kyo to - partly to prove to home audiences that he is no lapdog of George W. Bush. It's likely that he'll also want to patch things up with France and Germany by using some of his political capital wit] Bush to push the White House to adopt measures to fight climate change. <br> <br>Key international meetings in Cancui and Florence this fall will be the battleground for the final assault by Green s and their allies to convince Amnerican. to join Kyoto, or something like it. br> <br>That's why a <a target=_blank href="http://cfa-www.harvard~edu/press/pr O3 10.html">new study</a>, funded in part by NASA and announced in a Harvard Uni versity press release on Monday, is so important. The study concludes that, con trary to popular belief, "Many records Teveal that the 20th century is likely < I>not</I> the warmest nor a uniquely extreme climatic period of the last millen nium" [emphasis in the study]. <br> <br>The conclusion comes from "a review of more than 200 climate studies led by researchers at the Harvard-Smithsonian Ce nter for Astrophysics." The researchers were Willie Soon and Sallie Baliunas of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center; Craig Idso and Sherwood Idso of the Center for the Study of Carbon Dioxide and Global Change at Tempe, Ariz.; and David R. Le gates of the Center for Climatic Researci at the University of Delaware. file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03-CEQO29-fiwoefOO _-ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  13. 13. Page 13 of4 <br> br>Baliunas is also deputy director o: the Mt. Wilson observatory in California and co-host of TechCentraiStation, to which Soon is a regular contributor.- <br <br>In the press release distributed ly Harvard, Soon is quoted as saying: "M any true research advances in reconst ucting ancient climates have occurred ove r the past two decades, so we felt it was time to pull together a large sample of recent studies from the last five to ten years and look for patterns of vani ability and change. <br> <br>"In fact, clear patterns did emerg showing egions worldwide experienced the highs of that r the Medieval Warm Period and lows of the Little Ice Age, and that 20th centiry temperatures are generally cooler tha n during the medieval warmth." <br> <br>These findings are vital to the de ate over the Kyoto agreement since the pre ise for cutting back on greenhouse-gas e missions is that humans played a signi icant role in heating up the Barth durnn g the 20th Century. But Soon and his c lleagues confirmed that a warm epoch app eared in various parts of the world fr m about 900 to 1000 A.D. through about 1 200 to 1300'A.D., during which tempera ures were greater than those of the 20th Century. <br> <br>Needless to say, there were no SJVs 1,000 years ago. <br> r>Other warm periods are also identifi d in the study. For example, the researc hers ask, "Was the warmth of the 1980s in western Europe exceptional or unusual 2" Not at all. •br> <br>They cite the respected climate sc olar H. H. Lamb, wh o wrote that "even the great warmth of the years 1989/1991, hailed in some quar ters as proof of the reality of the predicted global warming due to the enhance ment of the greenhouse effect by increasing carbon dioxide and other effluentsm ay have a surprising analogy in the past to the remarkable warmth - well attest ed in Europe - of the year 1540, shortly before the sharpest onset of the so-ca lled Little Ice Age." In the first week of January 1541, Lamb wrote that "young people were still bathing in the Rhine on the Swiss-German border." <br> <br>T he point here is that warm periods don': necessarily precede warmer periods. Th ey may precede colder ones. We just don't know enough about climate to make pre dictions, and it would be folly to spent between $150 billion and $400 billion a year - the estimates for Kyoto-style Litigation - on the flimsy evidence of w arming that currently exists. <br> <br>The study also casts doubt on the sort o f thin anecdotal evidence often cited b- the media to show that the planet is h eating up in unusual fashion. For examp .e, the •I>New York Times</I> is obsesse d with retreating glaciers, but they are not a new phenomenon. <br> <br> "Broad ly," write the scholars, "glaciers retr ated all over the world during the Medi eval Warm Period, with a notable but mi or re-advance between 1050 and 1150. Th e world's small glaciers and tropical glaciers have simultaneously retreated si nce the 19th century, but some glaciers have advanced." Soon and his colleagues cite the work of D. J. A. Evans, who "commented that significant warming phase s, especially those accompanied by relatively warm winters and cool summers, du file:I/D:SEARCH_7_9_03_CEQO29-f-iwoefOO .. ceq.txt 8/1412003
  14. 14. Page 14 of 44 ring intergiacials [like the current reriod] may lead to the onset of another g lobal glaciation.' <br> <br>So, melting glaciers are not uni ue to the industr ial era, and they could signal a peri d of growing, not retreating, glaciers to come. <br> <br>The evidence of earlier warming is not new. But, as Baliunas sa ys, "For a long time, researchers haye Possessed anecdotal evidence supporting the existence of these climate extremes. For example, the Vikings established c olonies in Greenland at the beginning f the second millennium that died out se veral hundred years later when the climate turned colder. And in England, viney ards had flourished during the medieval warmth. Now, we have an accumulation of objective data to back up these cultural indicators." <br> <br>The data were from ice cores, tree-ring samples and Dther methods. And the results are clear: Despite our modern hubris, we aren't -he only humans to experience a warmer ea rth. It makes sense, then, to view wit. skepticism the claims that we have <Ihc aused</I> major changes in climate. <br> <br>Observers such as Bjorn Lomborg, the Danish statistician and author of T:>The Skeptical Environmentaiist,</I> st art their critique by accepting the no ion that the earth is warming and that h umans play a key role. Lomborg argues that trying to fix the problem with huge expenditures or cutbacks that will red ce economic growth is far too costly for the meager benefits that will ensue f om Kyoto's strictures. <br> <br>Yes, bu t now Soon and the other researchers aie showing the shakiness of Kyoto's found ation. The strong implication of their work is that warming is probably natural and cyclical. It happens all the time, and there is not much we can do about i t. Nor can we predict its course with much accuracy. <br> <br>What's needed now - and we certainly have the time - is more research. Risking havoc with the wo rid economy, especially in this fragile period, would be foolish and dangerous. Kyoto has been moved to the back burner, mainly by the U.S. and developing cou ntries. That's where it belongs. <br> <br>But it might not stay there. Policyna kers need to pay attention to the facts - especially after the war ends and env ironmental extremists start applying th~real heat. </font> <br> <br> <a href="javascript:history~b cko;" oniMouseOver="window~status=nack return true" onMouseOut=&'window status= '; return true"><img src="images/bac k2 .gif" border=O><ia> <br> <br> <center> <table width="212" border="O" cellspacing="O" cellpadding="O"> <tr valign="middle'> <td><font face="Arial, Helvet ca, sans-serif" size="1"><ca cript-.;" onClick="window.openc 'etaf art cejpCD15-400BSCINEvr href="javas -Sci , 'emailarticle', 'scrollbars=yes,wi th=280,height=400');"><img src="images,' article-menubar-email.gif" width="12" h ight="1O" border="Q"-></a> <a style="color:#000000;tex -decoration:none;"I href="1javascript:;" file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03_CEQO29-fiwoefoo ~_ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  15. 15. Page 15 of 44 oflClick='window~open( 'etaf article.js ?CID=lQ5l-O4O3O3B3&SECTION=Enviro-Sci, ailarticle', 'scrollbars=yes,width=280 height=400 'em ">E-Mail</a></Eont></td> I); <td><font face="Arial, Helv tica, sans-serif" size="l"I> <a href="java script:doBook~markO"><img src="images article-menubar-bookmark.gif" width="115"1 height='lO" border="O"'></a> <a style="color:#OOOO0o;t xt-decoration:none;" Fhref="javascript:doB ookmarko()">Bookmark</a></font></ta> <td><font face="Arial, Rely tica, sans-serif" size=rrlrr><a href="javas cript:; onClick="window.openc printe .jsp?CIn=1051-04o303B', 'printfriendly',s crollbars=yes,width=555,height=400 I; ><img src="images/article-menubar-printg if" width="l1P heiqht="lo" border="O"><Ia> <a style="color:#O00j000;t xt-decoration:none;" href="1javascript:; onClick="window.open( 'printer.jsp?CID=1051040303B ',printfriendly', 'scrollbars =yes,width=555,height=400r);">Print</a></font></td> <td><font face="Arial, Helvetica, sans-serifrr size="l"I><a cript:doSaveAsO` ><img src="images/article-menubar-save.gif" href="javas width="lO" height= trio" border=rrOrI></a> <a style="Color:#000000;te t-decoration:none;" href="javascript:doS aveAs 9 ">Save</a></font></td> </tr> <Itable></center> <br><br> <table width='lOO%" border="O"l cellspa ,ing="O" cellpadding=rrOr> <tr> <td><img src="irnages/feedback feedback gif" width="89" height="13"></td> <td> <table border="O" cellspacingrror" cellpadding="1l" bgcolor=`#ESF3FF" align="righ- Cr'> <Cr><td><fone face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serifr size=`"1" color='#FFF FFFrr><a class=nounderline href=rrjavasc ~ipt.;" onClick="window.openc 'post.jsp?CI D=1051-040303B' ,'post-feedback', 'scrol bars=yes,width=340,height=500') ; >Post F eedback</a>< /font></ td>< /tr> </ table> </td></tr></table> <table border=Orr cellspacing=rrour cellladding="O"l width="lOO0%"> <tr><td bgcolor="#Oooooo" height=rlrr>.c td></tr> <Cable border="O" cellspacing=1o"1 cellpadding="O"l width=rlOO%rr> <tr> <td width=lO valign=top><img sic=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hel t=lO></td> <td><font face=rVerdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="window.open( 'display comment.jsp?msgid=f453 b93fldr, 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=34O,height=500'); Ir> Peak Oil</a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666" ~by Scot Wilson</font></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing=")" cellpadding="O" width="lOO%`> <tr> <td width=lO valign=top> </td> <td width=lO valign=top><img sr =imnages/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size=Ilr><a class=nou file://D:SEARCH_7-9_03-CEQ029-f-iwoefO(3sceq.txt 8/14/2003
  16. 16. Page 16 of 44 erline href="javascript.;"I onClick="wi dow.open( 'display-comment jsp?msgid=f453 c3df0a', 'mairnt , 'scrollbars=yes,width= 40,height-500');"> Re: Peak Oil</a>&nbsp;<font color="#661666">by Mark Wilson</tont></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing=' 0" cellpadding="O" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> •/td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font tace="Verdana, Arial Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="~javascript:;" onClick="wi dow.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f454 566daf' ,'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width= 40,height=500') ;"> Re: Peak Oil</a>&nbsp;<font color="#66 666">by rob</font></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing=' 0" cellpadding="0" width='l00%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.qif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><fornt face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif' size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascnipt:; <IonClick="wirdow.open( 'display comment .jsp?msgid=f454 d57bll', maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width= 40,height-500');"> Re: Peak Oil</a>&nbsp;<font color='#66 666'>by John Steele</font></td> <I table> <table border="Q"1 cellspacing= cellpadding="Q' width="100%"> Qil <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=lO valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;U'onClick="wirdow.open( 'display~comment.jsp?msgid=f454 fda954' , maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width= '40, height=500') ;'> Re: Re: Peak Oil</a>&nbsp;<font color='#666666">by JB</font></td> </table> <table border=IbO cellspacing=' 0" cellpadding="O" width="lOO%'> <tr> <td width=1O valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size='l"><a class=nOu erline href='javascript:;" onClick='wirdow.open( 'display~comment.jsp?msgid=f455 37ecd5', 'maint' , scrollbars=yes,width= -40,height=500' );"> Re: Re: Re: Peak Oil</a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666">by John Steele</font></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing=' 0" cellpadding="O' width="lOO%"> <tr> <td width=1O valign=top> </td> <td width=1Q valign=top><img s c=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10>< /td> file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03-CEQ029-f-iwoefO)3_ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  17. 17. Page 17 of 44 <td><font face="Verdana, Aria', Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:` onClick="window.open( 'display-comnment. jsp?rnsgid=f455 c5ebSO', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');"> Re: Re: Re: Peak Oil</a>&nbsp;<font c lor="#666666"1>by Mark Wilson</font></td> </ table> <table border="10" celJlspacing="O0" cellpadding="0" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> </td> <td width=10 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback arrow right.gif width=9 hei t=10>'c/td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="wildow.open( 'display-comment .jsp?msgid=f454 d5b652', 'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500') U'> Why don't you study economics?</a>&nbSD;<font color="#666666">by Rick Marliave< /font></td> <c/table> <table border="0"1 cellspacing= '0" cellpadding="O" width="l00%"> <tr> <ctd width=1O valign=top> </td> <ctd width=10 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10><c/ td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><ca class=nou erline href="javascript:;"I onClick="wi dow.open( 'display-comment. jsp?msgid=f455 lc45df' ,'maint,',scrollbars=yes,width= 40,height=500'); U> Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>cnbsp;<cfont color="#666666">by hewhoasks<c /font></td> <c/table> <table border='0" cellspacing= 0"1 cellpadding="Q" width="l00%"> <ctr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><cfont face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size=fll"><a class=nou erline href="~javascript:;" onClick="wiidow.open( 'display comimert.jsp?msgid=f455 dO2Occ', 'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width='40,height=500' );'> Re: Re: Why don't you study economics? /a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666"1>by mark W ilson</font></td> </tr> <c/table> <table border="O" cellspacing=' 0" cellpadding="0" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img sic=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"I>'a class=nou erline href="~javascript:;" onClick="wi dow.open( 'display comment. jsp?msgid=f455 f791cf', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width= 40,height=500') ;"> Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study econom cs?'c/a>&nbsp;<font color="1#666666">by he whoasksc/ font><c/td> 'c/tr> <c/table> file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03_CEQ029 f-iwoefO 3sceq.txt 8/1412003
  18. 18. Page 18 of 44 <table border='10" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="O" width="l00%"1> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=10 valign=top><cimg s c=images/feedback-arrow right.gif width=9 hei t=lO></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="I1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="wi dow.open( 'display comment. jsp?msgid=f456 e02509,',maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height-500') ;"> Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study ec nomics?</a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666"1>b y mark Wilson</font></ed> </table> <table border="10" cellspacing='0" cellpadding="0"l width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> <Itd> <td width=10 valign=top>czimg s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10>< /td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href='~javascript:;"I onClick="wiidow.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f456 f7c3b8' ,'mnaint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width= 40,height-500 I C> A response to Hewhoasks</a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666">by Rick Marliave</font>< /td> </table> <table border="0" cellspacing='0" cellpadding="0" width="~l00%"> <tr> <td width=lO valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback_arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript*.;" onClick="wildow.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f458 3b2de8', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width= 40,height=500') U'> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>&nbsp;<font color="1#66666 6 ">by hewhoasks< /font> /td> </table> <table border="10" cellspacing= 0" cellpadding="0" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=lQ valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="wi dow.open( 'display-commernt.jsp?msgid=f45b '70bd44', 'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width=:40,height-500' );"> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>&nbsp;<font color="#6 66666">by Rick Marliave</font></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing=' 0" cellpadding="O" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> </td> <td width=10 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face='Verdana, Anial Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;"I onClick="wi idow.open( 'display-comment jsp?msgid=f45d f3fbbs , 'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes~width=J 40,height=500');C'> file://D:SEARCHJ7 9O3 CEQ029 fjiwoefO 03_ceq txt 8/14/2003
  19. 19. Page 19 of 44 Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>&nbsp;<font color ="#666666">by hewhoasks</font></td> </ table> <table border="O" cellspacing="O" cellpadding="O" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=1Q valign=top><img src=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="window.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f46a 3c876d', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500'); ;"> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>&nbsp;<font c olor="#~666666">by jp</font></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing= "0"..cellpadding="O" width="1OO%"1> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img s c=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10>< /td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class~nou erline href="1javascript:;" onClick="wi .dow.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f464 a5e7f8' ,'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height-500');;"> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>&nbsp;<font color="#46 66666" >by Mark Wilson</font></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing="Q" cellpadding="O" width="lOO%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> </td> <td width=10 valign=top><img src=images/feedback_arrowcnight.gif width=9 hei t=1O></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:; onClick="wi dow.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f464 fclldc', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');"> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't jou study economics?</a>&nbsp;<font color =`#666666">by hewhoasks</font></td> <I/table> <table border="O"1 cellspacing="0" cellpadding="O" width="lOO%"> <tr> <td width=lO valign=top> </td> <td width=lO valign=top><irng s c=images/feedback_arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=1Q></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"'><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="wi .dow.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f467 de3dcd', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');"> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>&nbsp;<font c olor="#666666"I>by mark wilson</tont></td> </ table> <table border="0" cellspacing="O" cellpadding="O" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> </td> file:f/D:SEARCH 7 9 03-CEQ029_f-iwoef? O3seq.txt 8/14/2003
  20. 20. Page 20 of 44 <td width=lO valign=top><img s c=images/feedback_arrowcright.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"I><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onCliclc="wi dow.open( 'display comment.jsp?msgid=f468 610eda', Imaintr, 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Wh, don't you study economics?</a>&nbsp;<fo nt color="1#666666"1>by hewhoasks</font></td> </table> - <table border="O" cellspacing="O"1 cellpadding="O"l width="lOO%"> <tr> <td width=1O valign=top> </td> <td width=lO valign=top><img scc=images/feedback-arrow right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <ctd><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="~l'><a class=nou erline href="1javascript:;"I onClick='wi .dow.open( 'display~comment. jsp?msgid=f468 5f7Slb', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500') ;"> Still failing economics</a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666">by mark wilson</font></t d> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing="O0" cellpadding="O' width='100%"> <tr> <td width~lO valign=top> </td> <td width=lO valign=top><img src=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=1O></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size=`1"I><a class=nou erline href="javascript.;" onClick="window.open( 'display~comrnent.jsp?msgid=f469 3deOOc', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');"F> Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you stud economics?</a>&nbsp;<font color="1#66666 6 ">by Red</font></td> </table> <table border="O" cellspacing="O"1 cellpadding="O" width="lQO%"> <tr> <td width=1O valign=top> <ltd> <td width=1Q valign=top><img src=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=1Q></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="I1"><a class=nou erline href="~javascnipt: ;` onClick="window.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f45a 2538e7', 'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');"> Re: Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study economics?</a>&flbsp;<foflt color="1#666666">b y Boomer J</font></td> </table> <table border="O"1 cellspacing "0" cellpadding="0" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valigrv'top> <ltd- <td width=10 valign=top><img src=images/feedback arrownright.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Aria] Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"1><a class=nou erline href="javascript:` ponClick="window.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid~f45b 5fe641', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500');"> Re: Re: Why don't you study economics.'c/a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666"I>by Adriaa n Brae</font></td> Oceq.txt file:/D:SEARCH 7 9 03_CEQ029_f iwocf0 8/14/2003
  21. 21. Page 21 of 44 </table> <table border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="O" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=lO valign=top> </td> <td width=10 valign=top><img src=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript.;"I onClick='wi dow.open( 'display~comment.jsp?msgid=f45d f29ldf' ,'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width=340,heightz500') ;"> Re: Re: Re: Why don't you study econom icsN</a>&nbsp;<tont color="#666666"I>by he whoasks< /font>< /td> </table> <table border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="Q" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=1Q valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img src=images/feedback_arrow right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> - <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="wi .dow.open( 'display~comment.jsp?msgid=f456 78a452', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');U'> Peak Oil and Bconomics</a>&nbsp;<font :olor="I#666666">by Scot Wilson</font></td </table> <table border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=1Q valign~top><img src=images/feedback-arrow right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"I><a claSS=nou erline href="~javascript:;"I onClick="window.open( 'display-~comment.jsp?msgid~f456 a85169' ,'maint , 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500' );'> Re: Peak Oil and Economics</a>&nbsp;<font color="1#666666"1>by Dano</font></td> </table> <table border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="10" width="~l00%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=10 valign=top><img src=images/feedback-arrow night.gif width=9 hei t=10>< /td> <td>-cfont face='Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="1javascript:;" onClick="window.open( display-comment.jsp?msgid~f456 effdfb' ,'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');U'> Re: Peak Oil and Economics</a>&nbsp;<font color="1#666666">by Rick Marliave</fon t></ td> <I/table> <table border='0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> <ltd- <td width=l0 valign=top><img Erc=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><tont face="Verdana, Aria], Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou 4 erline href="javascript:;" onClick="window.open( 'display-comment.jsp?tQsgid~f 5a file://D:SEARCH_7_9_O3-CEQ029_f-iwoef O3sceq.txt 8/14/2003
  22. 22. Page 22 of 44 00 b7ba0b', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=5 ');"'> Re: Re: Peak Oil and Economics</a>&nbsp;<tont color="#6666661>hy Scot Wilson</f ont></td> </ table> <table border="10" celispacing=lOt, cellpadding="0" width="l00%'> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td> <td width=lO valign=top><img Erc=irnages/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0>c/td> <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="window.open( 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f45b 009b5b', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500') ;l> Re: Re: Re: Peak Oil and Economics</a &nbsp;•font color="#666666'>by Rick Marli ave</font></td> </table> <table border="10" cellspacing "10" cellpadding='Q" width="lQO%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> <ltd- <td width=l0 valign=top><img ~rc=irnages/feedback_arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=1O>< /td> <td><font face="Verdana, Aria], Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="window.open( 'display-coxmient .jsp?msgid~f45f 3034ec' ,'maint' ,'scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500F) ;fl> Re: Re: Re: Re: Peak Oil and Economic,</a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666">by Scot W ilson</font></td> </table> <table border="10" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td, <td width=lQ valign=top>'cimg Erc=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Aria], Helvetica, sans-serif" size=" l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="w- ndow.openC 'display-comment.jsp?msgid=f45f 81646c' , maint' , scrollbars=yes,width :340,height=500') U> oil and Economics</a>&nbsp;<font color="#666666">by Rick Marliave</font></td> </table> <table border="10" cellspacing::"0"1 cellpadding="0" width='l00%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top><img :rc=images/feedback-arrowvuxight.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><fornt face="Verdana, Aria-, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou 4 53 erline href="javascript:; onClick="w ndow.open( 'display comment.jsp?msgid=f eaf8al' ,'maint' ,'scrollbars~yes,width=340,height=500');" Hide the Sources and Selectively Quot I</a>&nbsp;<font colbor="#666666">by Dano </font></td> <I/table> <table border="0" cellspacing= "0" cellpadding="0" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=lQ valign=top> <ltd~ file://D:SEARCH_7_9_03-CEQ029_f-iwoe 003_ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  23. 23. Page 23 of 44 <td width=l0 valign=top><img src=images/feedback-arrow right.gif width=9 hel t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascnipt:;" onClick="window.open( 'display~comxnent.jsp?msgid=f453 e2b2cb', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500').1> Re: Hide the Sources and Selectively Quote I</a>&nbspvcfont color="#666666">by Mike</font></td> </table> <table border='0' cellspacing="0" cellpadding="O" width="l00%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> <ltd, <td width=l0 valign=top><img Erc=images/feedback-arrovtright.gif width=~9 hei t=10></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Aria] Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;; onClick="wjndow.opef~l(display-cornmnent.jsp?msgid=f453 ec7b55', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500');"> 6 Re: Re: Hide the Sources and Selectiv ly Quote 1</a>&nbsp;<font color="#66666 " >by Dano< /font>< /td> <I/table> <table border='10" cellspacing:"0" cellpadding=0"Ol width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td~ <td width=l0 valign=top><img ~rc=images/feedback_arrow~right.gif width=9 hei t=lO></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Aria', Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou 4 54 erline href="javascript:;" onClick="w ndow.open( 'display~comment.jsp?msgid=f 576c07', 'maint', scrollbars~yes,width 340,height=500');"> Re: Re: Re: Hide the Sources and Sele tively Quote T</a>&nbsp;<font color="1#666 666"1>by Mike</font></td> </table> <table border="0" cellspacingz"0" cellpadding="0' width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td- <td width=l0 va~lign=top><img ;rc=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=10>< /td> <td><font face="Verdana, AriaL, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l">'ca class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="w~ndow.open( 'display-comment. jsp?msgid~f455 02101b', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500')fl"> 6 Re [41: Hide the Sources AkND Dissernbla too!</a>&nbsp;<font color=rr#66666 "Thy D ano</font></td> </ table> <table border=z"0" cellspacing= 0' cellpadding="0" width="100%"1> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> <ltd> <td width=10 valign=top><irng src=images/feedback-arrowvright.gif width=9 hei t=l10>< /td> <td><font face="Verdana, Anial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1l"><a class=nou 4 55 erline href='javascript:;' onClick='window.open( display comment.jsp?msgid~f 9ee994', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');"> 666 Re[41: Hide the Sources AND dissemnble - nimiicel</a>&nbsp;<foflt color='#666 " >by Dano</font></td> file:/D:SEARCH_7_9_03.CEQ029_fiwo~ f003_ceq.txt 8/14/2003
  24. 24. Page 24 of 44 </ table> <table border="0"l celispacirng "0" cellpadding="O" width='100%'> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> </td> <td width=l0 valign=top><img Erc=irnages/feedback arrowright.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td>I <td><font face="Verdana, Aria], Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="window.open( 'display~comment.jsp?msgid=f458 ff3f64', 'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width=340,height=500');"> Re: Re[4] : Hide the Sources AND disse ble - niiiice!</a>&nbsp;<font color="*666 666">by Mike</font></td> </table> <table border="0" cellspacing "0" cellpadding="0" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> <ltd, <td width=lO valign=top><img -rc=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, Aria], Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="wjndow.open( 'display-comment. jsp?msgid=f45b 2f8131',,'maint', 'scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500');"> 6 Re [63: Hide the Sources AND dissernbl( - niiiice!</a>&nbsp;<font color='#66666 ",>by Dano</font></td> </tr> <I/table> <table border="10" celispacing: "0" cellpadding="Q" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign=top> </td. <td width=l0 valign=top><img ;rc=images/feedback arrow-right.gif width=9 hei t=l0></td> <td><fornt face="Verdana, Aria-, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou erline href="javascript:;" onClick="w-ndow.open( 'display-comnment.jsp?msgid=f45f 96cf03' , 'raint', 'scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500') ;'> Re: Re [6] : Hide the Sources AND diss mble - niiiice!</a>&nbsp;<forit color="#66 6666">by Mike</tont></td> </ table> <table border="O" cellspacing "0"l cellpadding="0" width="100%"> <tr> <td width=10 valign=top> <ltd~ <td width=10 valign=top><img 3rc=images/feedback arrow~right.gif width-9 hei t=l0></td> <td><font face="Verdana, AriaL, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="l"><a class=nou 4 4 erlirne href="javascript.;" onClick="window.openfl(display~comment.jsp?msgid~f 6 84t~e2', 'maint' , scrollbars=yes,width 340,height=500') ;"> Re: Re: Re [6] : Hide the Sources AND dissemble - niiiice!</a>&nbsp;<foflt color= "1#666666">by Dario</font></td> </ table> <table border="0" cellspacing=0O" cellpadding="0" width="lOO%"> <tr> <td width=l0 valign~top> <Itd> <td width=l0 valign=top><img src=images/feedback-arrow-right.gif width=9 hei <td><font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><a class=nou file://D:SEARCH_7_9_OX-CEQ029 f-iwo 00O3_ceq.txt 8/14/2003