1. RECOVERING THE PAST:
A “WESTERN” LESBIAN, GAY,
BISEXUAL, TRANSGENDER,
INTERSEX & QUEER HISTORY:
PART FOUR
Warren J. Blumenfeld
warrenblumenfeld@gmail.com
2. •Dr. Warren J. Blumenfeld is
available to come to your campus
or community organization.
•Contact:
warrenblumenfeld@gmail.com
3. IDENTITY
“…the organization of the individual’s drives, abilities, beliefs,
and history into a consistent image of self. It involves deliberate
choices and decisions, particularly about work, values,
ideology, and commitments to people and ideas.”
Anita Woolfolk
4. ASCRIBED IDENTITIES
• In large part, identity depends on who the world around
us says we are through socialization.
• Charles Horton Cooley: Other people are the
mirror in which we see ourselves.
• What Cooley refers to as the “Looking Glass Self.”
5. ERIC ERIKSON
• Psychologist who asserted that there
is a genetic, instinctual drive or quest
for personal identity.
• This propels the personality
development of the individual.
• Development is contingent on how
we handle “identity crises” or “tasks”
at various stages of life.
6. SOME SOCIAL IDENTITY CATEGORIES
• Race
• Ethnicity
• Nationality
• Tribe
• Linguistic Background
• Sex Assigned at Birth
• Religion
• Sexual Identity
• Gender Identity & Expression
• Socioeconomic Class
• Age
• Physical and Mental Abilities
• Physical Size & Appearance
7. INTERSECTIONALITY OR
INTERSECTIONALISM
• Kimberlé Crenshaw
• Distinguished Professor of Law, UCLA Law
School
• Definition: the study of intersections
between forms or systems of oppression,
domination, or discrimination,
• And how these impact the lives of
people by investigating multiple
identities.
8. INTERSECTIONALITY OR
INTERSECTIONALISM
• Each person is composed of MULTIPLE identities that
interconnect with each other.
• Depending on time and location, some of these identities
may seem more or less important to the individual.
• Most of us have some identities accorded more social
privilege.
• Simultaneously having some identities accorded less social
privilege.
11. HARRY HAY
• Grassroots Labor Union organizer
• Member: Wobblies (Industrial Workers of the
World)
• Member U.S. Community Party, 1934-51
• Homosexuals must join with other
minorities to defeat Capitalism
• Root of oppression
• Need for a Movement based on:
• Ideology
• Organizational Strategy
• Leaders
Harry Hay
12. INTERNATIONAL BACHELORS
FRATERNAL ORDERS FOR PEACE AND SOCIAL DIGNITY
• Harry Hay supported Henry Wallace
• Progressive Party Presidential Candidate
• Hay founded “International Bachelors
Fraternal Order for Peace and Social
Dignity”
• a.k.a. “Bachelors Anonymous”
• To “be respected for our difference, not our sameness to
heterosexuals. Our organization would renegotiate the place
of our minority into the majority.”
13. INTERNATIONAL BACHELORS
FRATERNAL ORDERS FOR PEACE AND SOCIAL DIGNITY
The group is described as “a service and welfare
organization devoted to the protection and improvement of
Society’s Androgynous Minority! The reasons for
the group’s formation…:
• Encroaching American Fascism…seeks to bend
unorganized and unpopular minorities into
isolated fragments…The Androgynous Minority
was…stampeded into serving as hoodlums, stool
pigeons…hangmen, before it was ruthlessly
exterminated…
Harry Hay
14. • Hay could not find others to join
gay political organization
• Not even his lover, Will Geer
Harry Hay
Will Geer, “Grandpa,” The Waltons
15. MATTACHINE SOCIETY
• By 1950, Los Angeles, Hay found homosexual men
interested in a group
• The Mattachine Society
• Les Societes Mattachines
• 13th- 14th-century France
& Spain
• Theater group
• Unmarried men
• Cross dressed
• Hay quit Communist
Party, 1951,
Harry Hay (upper left)
(l-r) Konrad Stevens, Dale Jennings,
Rudi Gernreich, Stan Witt, Bob Hull,
Chuck Rowland, Paul Bernard
16. MISSION & PURPOSE
“The Mattachine Society holds it possible and desirable
that a highly ethical homosexual culture emerge, as a
consequence of its work, paralleling the emerging cultures
of our fellow-minorities—the Negro, Mexican, and Jewish
Peoples. The Society believes homosexuals can lead well-
adjusted, wholesome, and socially productive lives once
ignorance and prejudice against them is successfully
combated, and once homosexuals feel they have a
dignified and useful role to play in society.”
from Radically Gay: Gay Liberation in the Words of Its Founder,
Harry Hay
18. DALE JENNINGS
• A founding Mattachine Society member
• 1952, public men’s room Westlake Park
• Man walked up to him with hand on his crotch.
• Jennings wasn’t interested, and left men’s room.
• The man talked to Jennings and followed him home.
• Jennings said “good-bye” and went inside, but the man invited
himself inside.
• The stranger continued to make sexual advances to Jennings in
his home, but Jennings refused. “At last he grabbed my hand
and tried to force it down the front of his trousers. I jumped up
and away. Then there was the badge and he was snapping the
handcuffs on with the remark, ‘Maybe you’ll talk better with my
partner outside’.”
19. MATTACHINE SOCIETY
• Mattachine Society: Subcommittee
• Citizens Committee to Outlaw Entrapment
• Lawyer, George Shibley took the case
• Won: 11 out of 12 voted for acquittal, 1 did not
• : Hung Jury
George and wife Elenor
20. “OUT OF MANY, ONE”
• The publicity over the trial sparked other Mattachine
Society Chapters in U.S.
• Jan. 1953, One, Inc. separately published first issue of One
Magazine devoted to Dale Jennings story.
21. ONE
• First U.S. pro-homosexual publication
Sold openly on the streets
• 1954, U.S. Postal Service declared
“obscene” under Comstock Law
• 1958, Roth v. United States
U.S. Supreme Court
• One, Inc. successful
• Freedom of Speech
22. MATTACHINE SOCIETY
• 1953 leadership struggle at chapter conference
• Increasing anti-Communism climate in U.S.
• Delegates votes to take more conservative direction
• Original Members left the organization
• Kenneth Burns took over as new head of Mattachine.
23. KENNETH BURNS
• Homosexuals are like heterosexuals except for what they do in bed:
• The Mattachine Society “will consist of aiding established and recognized
scientists, clinics, research organizations and institutions…studying sex
variation problems.”
27. DAUGHTERS OF BILITIS
• Purpose:
• to educate “the variant” to “understand herself and make her adjustment to
society”
• Leading public discussions
• “advocating a mode of behavior and dress acceptable to society”
• hoped to shatter negative myths
• Worked to eliminate
prejudicial laws
29. BILLY LEE TIPTON
• Born Dorothy Lucille
Tipton
• American Jazz
musician &
bandleader
• Lived as trans man 40
years
30. DWIGHT D. EISENHOWER
• Mattachine, & Daughters of Bilitis membership small
• Conservative times
• 1953, Executive Order 10450
• Excluding people engaging in
“sexual perversion”
from obtaining government jobs
31. ALLEN GINSBERG
• 1955
• Controversial book Howl
• Openly explores homoerotic themes
Peter Orlovsky & Allen Ginsberg
32. JAMES BALDWIN
• Novelist
• Issues of homophobia & racism
• Defended homosexuality
• Exposed heterosexual hostility
34. LESBIAN “PULP FICTION
• New genre
• Drug stores & train stations
• Steamy stories of lesbian & bisexual love and adventure
35. VIN PARKER, SPRING FIRE
“A story once held in
whispers, now frankly,
honestly written.”
36. ARTEMIS SMITH, THE THIRD SEX
“To fool society, they
married, for Joan
loved women and
Marc preferred men.”
“Told with
unblushing honesty.
Here is a penetrating
story of society’s
greatest curse:
homosexuality.”
38. ANN BANNON, ODD GIRL OUT
They witnessed “a
confession of love — as
shocking and as honest — as
SPRING FIRE.”
39. LESLEY EVANS,
STRANGE ARE THE WAYS OF LOVE
“She’d come to New York to find
someone to love. When she met
Mike, she thought he might be the
one. Then she met Laura.”
40. ANN BANNON, BEEBO BRINKER
“Lost, lonely, boyishly
appealing—this is Beebo
Brinker—who never really
knew what she wanted –
until she came to
Greenwich Village and
found the love that
smoulders in the shadows
of the twilight world.”
41. CHRISTINE JORGENSEN
• 1952, Coming out from another shadow
• MtF gender confirmation procedure
• Copenhagen, Denmark
• Dr. Joseph Angelo
42. FRANKLIN KAMENY
• Political front
• 1957, Franklin Kameny fired from Army post
• Homosexual
• First to appeal
• Lost in court
• Founded Mattachine, DC
43. STOCKELY CARMICHAEL
(KWAME TURE)
• Kameny followed African Americans
• Stokely Carmichael in 1960s
• Motto: “Black is Beautiful” & “Black Power”
• Kameny: “Gay is Good”
• Urged others to take more
militant stance
• Pushed for homosexual rights
• Radical departure from
• Pleas for tolerance
45. JOSÉ SARRIA
• 1961, first “out” homosexual
• Run for elective public office U.S.
• Entertainer Black Cat Club
• San Francisco City Supervisor
• Did not win
• 5600 Votes
46. JOSÉ SARRIA
• Sarria nightly performed the opera Carmen
• Black Cat Bar
• Following, patrons linked arms singing
• “God Save Us Nelly Queens”
• To tune of “God Save the Queen”
47. SOCIETY FOR INDIVIDUAL
RIGHTS
• San Francisco, 1964
• SIR, Political Organization
• Formed by Tavern Guild, bar owners of LGBT bars to
protect against police harassment
48. HOMOPHILE DEMONSTRATION
• Coalition organized by One, Inc. with
• Daughters of Bilitis
• Mattachine Society
• White House, April 17, 1965
• Protest federal government policy
• “…discrimination and hostility
against its homosexual American
citizens.”
• Men: suits & ties
• Women: dresses and heels
49. HOMOPHILE DEMONSTRATION
• Coalition
• Daughters of Bilitis
• Mattachine Society
• July 4, 1966 – 1969
• Philadelphia: Independence Hall
• “Annual Reminder”
• Forerunner:
• Annual LGBT Marches & Parades
50. U.S. SUPREME COURT
• Griswold v. Connecticut, 7-2 decision, 1965
• Connecticut’s anti-contraception law, passed in 1879
prohibited the use of “any drug, medicinal article or
instrument for the purpose of preventing conception.”
• The Constitution guarantees
right of privacy.
• Connecticut’s law unconstitutional.
51. NOW ON LESBIANS
• Beginning of NOW
• 1969, Lesbian board member Rita Mae Brown purged
Rita Mae Brown
52. “THE LAVENDER MANACE”
• NOW founder, Betty Friedan referred to lesbians as “the lavender menace”
Betty Friedan Lesbians wearing “Lavender
Menace” T-shirts
53. RECONCILIATION
• 1970
• NOW annual convention
• Resolution:
• “The oppression of lesbians as a legitimate concern of feminism.”
• Today, lesbians & bisexual women integral part of NOW.
54. THE HOMOSEXUALS
• March 7, 1967, CBS Reports, 1 hour
• Interview:
• Gay men
• one partially hid by potted palm
• Psychiatrists
• Legal experts
• Cultural critics
• Footage of police raid on gay bar
• Franklin Kameny picketing Independence Hall
• Dr. Charles Socarides, disease model
55. THE HOMOSEXUALS
• Professor Albert Goldman:
“…homosexuality is just one of a number of...things all tending toward
the subversion, toward the final erosion, of our cultural values."
• Gay author Gore Vidal: Homosexuality is as natural as heterosexuality”
"The United States is living out some mad Protestant 19th century
dream of human behavior....I think the so-called breaking of the moral
fiber of this country is one of the healthiest things that's begun to
happen.”
56. THE HOMOSEXUALS
• Host Mike Wallace concluded:
• “The dilemma of the homosexual: told by the medical profession he
is sick; by the law that he's a criminal; shunned by employers;
rejected by heterosexual society. Incapable of a fulfilling a
relationship with a woman, or for that matter with a man. At the
center of his life he remains anonymous. A displaced person. An
outsider.”
57. CHINA
“CULTURAL REVOLUTION” (1966-1976)
• Period of persecution
• Government considered homosexuality a social disgrace and form of
mental illness.
• Police regularly arrested LGBT people.
• Charged with hooliganism or disturbing public order.
58. END OF 1960S
• Film
• “The Boys in the Band”
• Reflects stereotypes, shame, and humor of homosexual
(not “gay”) men
“The only happy
homosexual is a dead
homosexual.”
65. GENE COMPTON’S CAFETERIA
RIOTS
• San Francisco, August 1966
• First collective violent resistance to oppression against
LGBT people in U.S.
• Police conducted raid, entered Compton’s, began
physically harassing the clientele.
66. GENE COMPTON’S CAFETERIA
RIOTS
• People fought back hurling coffee at the officers,
heaving cups, dishes, and trays around the cafeteria.
• Police retreated outside as customers smashed windows.
Over the course of the next night, people gathered to
picket the cafeteria, which refused to allow trans people
back inside.
67. THE ADVOCATE
• The Advocate
• Los Angeles gay newspaper
• Begins Publication
• September 1967
• Begun by landscape gardener,
Steve Ginsberg and PRIDE
group.
68. LGBT BOOKSTORES
• Craig Rodwell, a key person in the later Stonewall Inn riots
• Founded first “Gay Bookstore”
• New York City, 1967
• Oscar Wilde Memorial Bookshop
69. THE STONEWALL INN RIOTS
• June 28, 1969
• Stonewall Inn, 53 Christopher Street
• Greenwich Village, NYC
• Transgender people, lesbians, gays,
bisexuals, People of Color,
street people, students
• Police Raid
• Trumped-up charge:
Selling alcohol without license
70. THE STONEWALL INN RIOTS
Harassed too long
One of first time challenging police
flinging bottles, rocks, bricks, trash cans, parking meters as battering rams
Five nights
73. GAY LIBERATION FRONT
• Young people
• Groups in U.S. & other countries
• Living rooms, church basements, storefronts
• Explore new ways of living
Martha Shelley, GLF Co-Founder
77. • Snake Pit raid, NYC - March 8, 1970
• Unlicensed bar, dancing and alcohol, a few blocks from
Stonewall Inn.
• All of the patrons taken to police station.
• One patron, Alfred Diego Vinales, 23-years old, Argentinian
national, expired visa.
• At police station, terrified, threw himself from a window in
effort to escape
• Impaled on iron spiked fence below in five places on his
body.
• Fence had to be cut away.
• He was taken to hospital.
• He survived
• Community organized protest march.
78. MAY DAY DEMONSTRATIONS
• May 1, 1971, D.C.
• Purpose: Shut down government
• Protest Vietnam War
• GLF Washington, D.C.
organized “Gay May Day”
• Thousands arrested
79. GAY ACTIVISTS ALLIANCE
• Ideological differences
• Another Group: GAA
• Militant, non-violent
• Single Issue
• More structured
• Logo: Greek Lambda,
• Symbol for wavelength in
quantum physics,
suggesting dynamism
80. GAY ACTIVISTS ALLIANCE
• From GAA Preamble, demanded:
• Freedom for expression of our dignity and value as human beings through
confrontation with and disarmament of all mechanisms which unjustly inhibit us:
economic, social and political.
81. GLF & GAA WOMEN
• Some women remained in GLF & GAA,
• Many women considered their issues different from gay men
• Also, they sometimes
experienced sexism in
GLF & GAA
82. RADICALESBIANS
• Separated
• Formed groups
• Publications
• Argued:
• fight against sexism required
all women to band together to
challenge male privilege &
heterosexual institutions.
84. SYLVIA RIVERA
• Latina U.S.-American gay liberationist and transgender
rights activist.
• Sylvia (Ray) Rivera
• Co-Founded STAR —
Street Transvestite
Action Revolutionaries
• Shelter , support to young
people living on the street
• She worked tirelessly for the most vulnerable members of
the community: drag queens, homeless youth, LGBT
people in prison and jail, and transgender people.
• Rivera worked on issues of intersectionality: issues of
poverty and discrimination faced by people of color,
85. MARCIA P. JOHNSON
• Marcia P. Johnson, a prominent activist in the Stonewall Inn uprising in 1969, a
founding member of the Gay Liberation Front, co-founded the radical activist group
Street Transvestite Action Rebolutionaries (S.T.A.R.) alongside close friend Sylvia
Rivera.
• A popular figure in New York City’s art scene, Johnson modeled for Andy Warhol,
and a stage performer with the drag performance troupe Hot Peaches.
• Johnson was known as the "mayor of Christopher Street, and an AIDS activist from
1987-1992 with the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power (ACT UP).
86. RADICAL FAIRIES
• Founder: Harry Hay
• Offshoot of men’s GLF
• Nationwide, grassroots movement
• Alternative ways of living
• Spiritual movement
• Nurture special gay
consciousness
that society
attempts to kill
Harry Hay & John Burnside
87. PRIDE MARCHES
• Christopher Street Liberation Day Umbrella Committee
• New York City
• First March
• Sunday, June 28, 1970
• Sixth Avenue
• June:
• “Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual,
&Transgender Pride
Month”
89. FEMINIST BOOKSTORES
• 1970, First Feminist Bookstore
• Amazon Bookstore Cooperative
• (called later True Colors)
• Minneapolis, Minnesota
90. LGBT COMMUNITY CENTERS
• Morris Kight, an organizer of GLF Los Angeles
• Founded first LGBT Community Center
• 1971, Los Angeles
91. NATIONAL GAY STUDENT CENTER
• 1971, Washington, DC
• National organization
• Founded by Warren J. Blumenfeld
• Serving student campus organizations
• Office of National Student Association
• Became office of U.S. Student
Association
93. FIRST UNIVERSITY CAMPUS
GROUPS
• 1967, Student Homophile League
• Columbia University in 1967
• Followed soon by
• MIT, Stanford, Cornell
• 1920s, Oberlin Lesbian Society
• Oberlin College
• Women’s group devoted to writing poetry
94. CAMPUSES DENIED
RECOGNITION
San Jose State University, Boston College, University of New Hampshire
Virginia Commonwealth University, University of Southern California
Texas A & M University , Tulane University , University of Maryland
Florida State University, Colorado College, University of Tennessee
University of Alabama, Sacramento State University , California
Polytechnic, William Jewell College, University of Texas at Austin,
University of Southern Mississippi, University of South Carolina,
University of Washington, Austin Peay State University ,
Polk Community College , Pennsylvania State University,
University of Oklahoma at Norman, University of Missouri at Columbia,
Georgetown University , California State University Fullerton,
College of the Sequoias, University of Kansas at Lawrence,
West Virginia University, Fordham University
96. 1. …the effect of recognition by the college of the Gay
Liberation Front could conceivably be to endorse or
promote homosexual behavior, to attract homosexuals
to the campus, and to expose minors to homosexual
advocacy and practices, and
2. …belief that the proposed Front created too great a risk
for students – a risk which might lead students to engage
in illegal homosexual behavior. [1970]
97. PRECEDENT SETTING COURT CASE
• GLF Students, Sacramento State University,
• Sued Chancellor Glen Dunke
• Sacramento County Superior Court
• Won case on First Amendment rights
• Freedom of Speech
• Freedom of Association
• “…to justify suppression of free speech, there must be
reasonable grounds to fear that serious evil will result if
free speech is practiced; there must be reasonable
ground to believe that the danger apprehended is
imminent.”
98. FIRST “OUT” ELECTED UNIVERSITY
STUDENT PRESIDENT
1970, Jack Baker,
University of Minnesota
“PUT YOURSELF---in---JACK BAKER’S SHOES!
IF YOU Were ELECTED MSA President
Could YOU Forget The People Who Put YOU There?
100. DEADLY HATE CRIME – LGBT CLUB
• Arson Fire, Molotov Cocktail, Kills 32
• June 24, 1973
• The UpStairs Lounge, New Orleans, LA
101. HATE CRIME – GAY CLUB
• Shooting Outside Club, No Injuries
• November 18, 1980
• Ramrod club, New York City, NY
Shooter said gay men are agents
of the devil, are stalking him and
“trying to steal my soul just by
looking at me.”
102. HATE CRIME – LESBIAN CLUB
• Nail Bomb, 150 Inside, 5 Injured
• February 21, 1997
• Other Side Lounge, Atlanta, GA
103. DEADLY HATE CRIME – LGBT CLUB
• Bomb, 2 Killed, 81 Injured
• April 30, 1999
• Admiral Duncan pub, London, England
104. DEADLY HATE CRIME – LGBT CLUB
• Shooter Opened Fire, 1 Killed, 6 Wounded
• September 22, 2000
• The Back Street Cafe, Roanoke, VA
105. HATE CRIME – LGBT CLUB
• Arson Fire, Gasoline on Carpeted Stairway
• No injuries
• December 31, 2013
• Neighbours night club, Seattle, WA
106. DEADLY HATE CRIME – LGBT CLUB
• Shooter with Semiautomatic Weapon & Hand Gun
• 49 Killed, 53 Injured
• June 12, 2016
• Pulse club, Latin Night, Orlando, FL
107. NATIONAL GAY & LESBIAN TASK
FORCE
• 1973, National Gay Task Force, New York City
• Changed to National Gay and Lesbian Task Force
• Washington, D.C.
Founders at 1973 Press Conference
108. HUMAN RIGHTS CAMPAIGN
• 1980
"The Human Rights Campaign envisions an America
where LGBT people are ensured of their basic equal
rights, and can be open, honest and safe at home, at
work and in the community.”
109. PFLAG
• 1972, parents and friends organizing
• Support for themselves & loved ones
• Today, international network
110. LGBT POLITICAL CLUBS
• 1972, Jim Foster, San Francisco
• Developed concept
• LGBT political clubs
• First, Alice B. Toklas
Memorial Democratic Club
• Foster, first out person address
a national political convention,
July 12, 1972, Democratic
112. KATHY KOZACHENKO
• First “Out” lesbian
• 1974 elected to public office
• Ann Arbor, Michigan city council.
113. ELAINE NOBLE
• First “out” lesbian
• 1974, Elected to statewide office
• House of Representatives in Massachusetts
114. FRED KARGER
• First “out” candidate of a major political
party (Republican) in the U.S., 2012
• Though unsuccessful, he had experience
working in several political campaigns,
and as a senior consultant to the
campaigns of Gerald Ford, Ronald
Reagan, and George H. W. Bush
116. FIRST OUT AMBASSADOR
• James Hormel
• Ambassador to Luxembourg, 1999
• Bill Clinton, Congressional Recess Appointment
117. LEONARD MATLOVICH
• Air Force Technical Sergeant
• Vietnam War Veteran
• Race Relations Instructor
• Purple Heart, Bronze Star
• 1975, Came out to
oppose Military Policy
• Discharged
118. LEONARD MATLOVICH
• 1978, won case
• Could be reinstated
• Cash settlement
• Donated to LGBT
Organizations
• Died 1988
"Never Again, Never Forget – A Gay Vietnam Veteran –
When I was in the military they gave me a medal for
killing two men and a discharge for loving one."
119. “SAVE OUR CHILDREN”
• Anita Bryant
• Former Beauty Queen
• 1977, Campaign
• Overturned
• LGBT Rights Ordinance
• Dade County, Florida
121. “THE BRIGGS INITIATIVE”
• 1978, California Proposition 6
• John Briggs, California State Legislature
• Ban Lesbians &
Gays & Supporters
• Working in California
public schools.
• Failed
• Dampened climate
122. RAINBOW FLAG
• 1978
• Designed by S.F. Artist
• Gilbert Baker
• Symbol LGBT diversity
• Originally 8 colors
• Pink & Turquoise removed
124. HARVEY MILK
• 1977, San Francisco
• Harvey Milk, open gay man
• Elected City Supervisor
125. MILK & MOSCONE MURDERED
• November 27, 1978
• Harvey Milk & pro-gay
Mayor George Moscone murdered
126. DAN WHITE
• Former police officer
• Former San Francisco
City Supervisor,
127. VERDICT
• White convicted
• “Twinkie Defense”
• Reduced charge:
• Voluntary Manslaughter
• 6 year sentence
• Released 5 1/2 years
• October 21, 1985
• Committed suicide
May 21, 1979
“White Night Riots”
San Francisco
128. HARVEY MILK HIGH SCHOOL
• Founded by Hetrick-Martin Institute
• 1985, NYC, small high school
• At-risk non-heterosexual & non-
gender conforming youth
• Fully accredited 2002
• Run by NYC School system
129. FRICKE V. LYNCH, 1980
• Aaron Fricke
• Prevented by school officials from taking
male date, Paul Guilbert, to Senior Prom
• Cumberland, Rhode Island
• Successfully sued, U.S. District Court
• Fricke and Guilbert attended prom.
130. JAMIE NABOZNY
• Subjected to relentless antigay bullying
• By other students, High School, Ashland,
Wisconsin
• Mock rape, urinated on, kicked
• Required surgery
• School officials: “he should expect it
because he is gay”
• Attempted suicide several times,
• Dropped out
• Ran away
131. NABOZNY V. PODLESNY, 1996
• Sued school
• Trial court dismissed lawsuit
• Lambda Legal took case to federal appeals court
• Finding: public school could be held accountable for not
stopping antigay abuse.
• Back to trial & jury
• Verdict: school officials liable for harm they caused
• Settlement: about $1 million
132. VANCE V. SPENCER COUNTY PUBLIC
SCHOOL DISTRICT, 2000
• Parents of 6th grade girl filed suit again Kentucky school
under Title IX, Kentucky’s Civil Rights Act for failing to
intervene against harassment on basis of sex, sexual
orientation, and national (German) origin.
• Court found “deliberate indifference” by Spencer County
Public School District claiming that “[w]here a school
district has actual knowledge that its efforts to remediate
are ineffective, and it continues to use those same
methods to no avail, such district has failed to act
reasonably in light of current circumstances.”
133. MCLAUGHLIN V. PULESKI COUNTY SPECIAL
SCHOOL DISTRICT, 2003
• Thomas McLaughlin, an openly gay 14-year-old 9th grade
student at Jacksonville Junior High School, Jacksonville,
Arkansas. School officials prohibited him from discussing his
identity with other students.
Thomas McLaughlin
134. MCLAUGHLIN V. PULESKI COUNTY SPECIAL
SCHOOL DISTRICT, 2003
• An assistant principal preached his religious beliefs at Thomas.
• Forced him to read Bible.
• Expelled him for two days for telling peers about this.
• McLaughlin family sued in court for violating First Amendment
Establishment Clause.
• Also, prohibiting him from discussing his identity, a violation of
First Amendment freedom of speech, and 14th Amendment
Equal Protection Clause.
• Court ordered school to pay $25,ooo for violation of rights.
135. FLORES V. MORGAN HILL UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT, 2004
• Six students charged Morgan Hill (CA) Unified School District ignoring or
minimizing claims of harassment & abuse by others who perceived them as
LGBT.
Alana Flores with Lawyer, Kate Kendall, 2004
136. FLORES V. MORGAN HILL UNIFIED SCHOOL
DISTRICT, 2004
• Students plaintiffs: Alena Flores, Freddie Fuentes, Jeanette Dousharm, and
three others.
• 9th District Court of Appeals ruled unanimously for the students declaring if a
school knows anti-gay harassment is occurring, it must take meaningful steps
to end it and protect students.
• School ordered to implement comprehensive training program for
administrators, staff, and students to combat homophobic harassment.
138. GLSEN
• Gay, Lesbian, Straight Education Network
• 1990, NYC, National Organization
“GLSEN seeks to develop school climates where
difference is valued for the positive contribution it makes
to creating a more vibrant and diverse community. “
139. MELVIN BOOZER
• 1980, Lesbian & Gay Caucus
• Democratic Presidential Convention
• Nominate for Vice-President
• Melvin Boozer, Chair GAA – DC
• Addressed Convention
• Raised LGBT issues
• Then declined nomination
140. SHARON KOWALSKI
• 1983, car accident
• Seriously injured
• Partner, Karen Thompson
• Battled 10 years
• Guardianship
• Kowalski’s parents
• Denied contact 3 ½ years
• Thompson eventually won
Kowalski & Thompson
150. INTERSEX MOVEMENT
• More that two sexes
• Approximately 1 in 2000 people
• Fighting for the rights of intersex people to make their own choices regarding
their bodies and to increase awareness of intersex people.
151. INTERSEX MOVEMENT
“‘Intersex’" is the word that describes those of us who,
without voluntary medical interventions, possess bodies
that doctors can't neatly classify as male or female. This
includes people who have chromosomal sex other than XX
(female) or XY (male), or primary or secondary sex
characteristics that defy the medical definitions of male
and female. Somehow, doctors get freaked out when a
newborn baby is found to be intersexed, and often
mutilate her or his genitals to conform them to the doctors'
idea of what a normal baby should look like, even though
intersex conditions usually do not threaten the health of
the infant. Parents are often not given enough information
or support to make an informed decision regarding their
babies' care.”
Emi Koyama, Intersex Initiative Portland