Composition & critical reading 2


Published on

Published in: Education
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Composition & critical reading 2

  1. 1. COMPOSITION &CRITICAL READING An Introduction to Effective Writing Strategies
  2. 2. Why do we write?• What types of writing Lists Social Media do we do on a daily basis?• All writing seeks to convey a message. Personal School Work Writing
  3. 3. WRITING SKILL IS IMPORTANT “As soon as you move one step up from the bottom, your effectiveness depends on your ability to reach others through the spoken or written word. And the further away your job is from manual work, the larger the organization of which you are an employee, the more important it will be that you know how to convey your thoughts in writing or speaking. In the very large organizations, whether it is the government, the large business corporation, or the Army, this ability to express oneself is perhaps the most important of all the skills a person can possess.”  Peter Drucker, “How to Be an Employee” Work Related
  4. 4. IDENTIFY THE PURPOSE• To Inform• To Persuade• To Express Oneself• To Entertain• Work from the general to the specific• “Having a specific purpose assists you at every stage of the writing process” (Reinking & Osten 5).  Defining the audience  Selecting details, language, and approach  Avoiding sidetracked tangents
  5. 5. IDENTIFY THE AUDIENCE Purpose and Audience are closely linked. All writing is aimed at an audience.  That audience will determine how your writing is shaped.  The language you choose.  The tone you use.  The information you include……….  Public audience  Private or semi-private audience What exactly is a “discourse community”?
  6. 6. KNOWING GOOD WRITING WHENWE SEE IT… Fresh Thinking Sense of Style Effective Organization Ethical  Truthful  Complete  Clear  Helpful, not harmful
  7. 7. CRITICAL READING STRATEGIES Orient your reading – what is your purpose for reading? Read multiple times  First reading:  Read for content comprehension  Look for clues  Make connections  Additional readings:  Read carefully and critically  Annotate the text  Take notes  Analyze text  Respond to the text
  8. 8. CRITICAL READING STRATEGIES “All critical reading begins with an accurate summary” (Behrens & Rosen 48). Identify the main point, subordinate points, and counterarguments. To what extent does the author succeed in his or her purpose? To what extent do you agree with the author?  Identify points of agreement and disagreement.  Explore the reasons for agreement and disagreement.
  9. 9. CRITICAL EVALUATIONEvaluating Informative Writing Evaluating Persuasive Writing Accuracy of Information  Clearly Defined Terms Significance of Information  Fair Use of Information Fair Interpretation of  No Logical Fallacies Information  What is Logical Fallacy?
  10. 10. AVOID LOGICAL FALLACY …Emotionally Loaded Terms Ad Hominem Argument An attempt to sway reader’s  Rejecting opposing views by opinions by choosing attacking those who hold that emotionally charged words viewpoint  “family values”  Appealing to one’s  “pay the price” prejudices, emotions, or Are the terms being used special interests deceptively or to hide the  Disregards the central issue facts? in favor of negative attacks – Should NOT be the ONLY (think political advertising) argument in an academic essay
  11. 11. AVOID LOGICAL FALLACY …Faulty Cause & Effect Either / Or Reasoning Assuming that one event  Suggests that there are only causes the second and two solutions to a problem ignoring other possible  The “correct” one that the writer causes is favoring Demonstrates unwillingness  The “incorrect” one that the writer opposes to thoroughly research and discuss the topic  Demonstrates an unwillingness to recognize Also known as post hoc, ergo complexity proctor hoc (after this, therefore because of this)
  12. 12. AVOID LOGICAL FALLACY …Hasty Generalization False Analogy Drawing conclusions from  Attempting to provide a too little evidence or from comparison between two unrepresentative evidence things when the differences Demonstrates a lack of between them are greater research and an than the similarities unwillingness to thoroughly analyze the specifics of a Oversimplification situation  Offering easy solutions to complicated problems  Ignores the complexity of an issue
  13. 13. AVOID LOGICAL FALLACY …Circular Reasoning Non Sequitur Assumes as proven fact the  Non Sequitur is Latin for “it very thesis being argued does not follow” If a thesis is indeed proven  Describes a conclusion that fact, then there is no need to does not logically follow from write the essay in the first a premise place.  Assumes too much Also known as “begging the question”
  14. 14. COMPOSITION STRATEGIESThere are 4 essential skills in composition:  Summary  Critique  Synthesis  Analysis
  15. 15. SUMMARY
  16. 16. SUMMARY  A Summary is a brief statement, in your own words, of the content of a particular passage.  Approximately 25% of the length of the original material  Include the author’s thesis (in your own words), one-sentence summaries of the subordinate points, and any significant details.  Do NOT include your own personal opinion of the topic.
  17. 17. READ CRITICALLY TO SUMMARIZE Critical Reading for Summary means you should…  Examine the context.  Note the title and subtitle.  Identify the main point.  Identify the subordinate points.  Break the reading into sections or stages of thought.  Distinguish between points, examples, and counterarguments.  Watch for transitions within and between paragraphs.  Read actively and recursively.
  18. 18. SUMMARY WRITING Read the passage carefully. Reread. Provide the context for the essay. Introduce the author and the article title. Write a thesis of the entire passage. Write one-sentence summaries of each stage of thought. Write the first draft  Combine the thesis with your lists of one-sentence summaries OR  Combine the thesis, the one-sentence summaries, and significant details Remember that summaries do NOT include your own personal opinion of the topic.
  19. 19. INCLUDE CITATIONS FOR… Summaries Paraphrases Quotes
  20. 20. INCLUDE CITATIONS FOR…Summary Paraphrase Because a summary is a  Similar to shortened version of the summary, paraphrase means original material, it MUST be conveying a text’s message cited accordingly, even in your own words. though it has been put into  Approximately the same the writer’s own words. length as the original text.  Look for synonyms of the Use a citation at the end of original words and rearrange every summarized section or your own sentences so that paragraph. they read smoothly.  Use a citation at the end of every paraphrased section or paragraph.
  21. 21. INCLUDE CITATIONS FOR…  Use a Direct Quote for: Direct Quotes  Memorable language  Clear and concise language  Authoritative language  Use only what is necessary  IQ = Incorporate your Quote into your own sentence  Avoid free standing quotations  Use ellipsis marks … to indicate omitted material from within a quoted passage.  Use brackets [ ] to add or substitute words within a quote.
  22. 22. AvoidPlagiarismAvoiding PlagiarismSafe Practices forAcademic Writing
  23. 23. CRITIQUE
  24. 24. CRITIQUE “A critique is a formalized, critical reading of a passage” (Behrens and Rosen 62). Begin with critical reading and turn that into a systematic evaluation in order to deepen your reader’s (and your own) understanding of that text. Consider…  What the author says  How well the points are made  What assumptions underlie the argument  What issues are overlooked  What implications can be drawn
  25. 25. CRITIQUE Critique begins with a summary of the work Whether responding positively or negatively, present a fair and accurate summary of the work You might draw on and cite other sources Include a statement of your own assumptions – your opinion is included in a critique State your opinions explicitly
  26. 26. READ CRITICALLY TO CRITIQUE Examine the context  Establish the author’s primary Note the title and subtitle purpose Identify the main point and  Evaluate informative writing subpoints  Accuracy / Significance / Fair Interpretation Break the reading into  Evaluate persuasive writing sections  Clear Definitions / Significance / Fair Distinguish between points, Interpretations examples, and  Evaluating writing that entertains counterarguments  Interesting Characters / Believable Watch for transitions within Action, Plot, and Situations / and between paragraphs Communication of Theme / Use of Language Read actively  Decide whether you agree or disagree
  27. 27. CRITIQUE WRITING Introduce both the author and the article title  State the main argument and the points you intend to make about it  Use background information to provide context – information explaining why the issue is of current interest, a reference to a possible controversy surrounding the topic, biographical information about the author, circumstances under which the passage was written, a reference to the intended audience Summarize the main points and state the author’s purpose for writing Assess the Presentation  Comment on the author’s success in achieving his or her purpose by reviewing three or four specific points  Consider whether the author as argued logically Respond to the Presentation  Where do you agree or disagree?  Discuss your reasons for agreement or disagreement Conclude  State your conclusions regarding the overall validity of the piece – your assessment of the author’s success at achieving his or her purpose – and your reactions to the author’s views.  Comment on the weaknesses or strengths of the article.
  28. 28. SYNTHESIS
  29. 29. SYNTHESIS Written discussion that draws on 2 or more sources Demonstrates an ability to infer relationships between sources Builds on Summary and Critique skills
  30. 30. TYPES OF SYNTHESES Comparison Explanatory Argument and Contrast• Conveys • Conveys • Conveys the information opinion and similarities provides and interpretation differences between texts
  31. 31. SYNTHESIS WRITING Consider your purpose in writing. Select and carefully read your sources. Take notes on your reading. Formulate a thesis.  Informative / Mildly Argumentative / Strongly Argumentative Decide how you will use your source material. Develop an organizational plan. Draft. Document sources. Revise and Edit.
  32. 32. ORGANIZATIONAL STRATEGIES A Synthesis is a blending of sources organized by ideas, not by sources. Thesis. First idea:  Refer to and discuss parts of more than one source in support of the thesis.  What do both the sources suggest about idea #1? Second idea:  Refer to and discuss parts of more than one source in support of the thesis.  What do both the sources suggest about idea #2? Third idea:  Refer to and discuss parts of more than one source in support of the thesis.  What do both the sources suggest about idea #3? Conclusion.
  33. 33. EXPLANATORY SYNTHESISProvide the facts in a reasonably objectivemanner.Do Not attempt to argue a particular point.Convey the relationships between the sources.
  34. 34. ARGUMENT SYNTHESIS Claim – the proposition or conclusion you are trying to prove Support – in the form of fact or expert opinion Assumption – linking the supporting evidence to the claim is your assumption
  35. 35. ARISTOTLE’S RHETORICALAPPEALS Plato and Aristotle (Rafaello-  The three persuasive appeals: 1510)  Logos – the appeal to logic  Pathos – the appeal to emotion  Ethos – the appeal to ethics  These three are often combined to persuade the reader to agree with a specific point of view
  36. 36. LOGOS • Start with a generalization The rational appeal • Then cite a Deductive specific case The appeal to reason related to that Reasoning generalization Employs consistency and • From which logic follows a conclusion Includes statistics, facts, data The basis of persuasive writing in academia Writers must argue logically • Begin with several pieces of specific and supply appropriate evidence evidence to support their Inductive • Draw a conclusion Reasoning from the body of cases evidence Includes Inductive and Deductive Reasoning
  37. 37. ETHOS The ethical appeal Employs trust and credibility Based not on the ethical rationale for the subject or PATHOS topic under discussion…  The emotional appeal But on the ethical status of the person making the  Employs emotions and appeal imagination  Becomes problematic only when it is the sole or primary method of argumentation
  38. 38. FORMULATE AN ARGUMENT STRATEGY Summarize, paraphrase, and quote supporting evidence from your sources Provide various types of evidence and motivational appeal Use climactic order –.  Use the next most important evidence first. Use logical or conventional order. Present and respond to counterarguments.  Remember that good academic writers acknowledge and refute counter arguments. Use concession.  Concede that one or more arguments against your position have some validity; re-assert, nonetheless, that your argument is the stronger one.
  39. 39. WORKS CITED Behrens, Laurence and Leonard J. Rosen. Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum, 11th ed. Boston: Longman, 2011. Reinking, James A. and Robert von der Osten. Strategies for Successful Writing: A Rhetoric, Research Guide, Reader, and Handbook,” 9th ed. New York: Pearson, 2010.