Application and challenges to the use of mixed methods in health systems research

valéry ridde
valéry riddeProfesseur agrégé à l'université de Montréal at BMJ
Application and challenges to the use of
mixed methods in health systems research
Valéry Ridde, Manuela De Allegri, Quan Nha Hong,
Anne-Marie Turcotte-Tremblay, Nicolas Ortiz Ruis
« Mixed Methods Soup »
multi-trait-multimethod research; integrating
qualitative and quantitative approaches; integrated
methods; interrelating qualitative and quantitative
data; methodological triangulation; multi-
methodological research; multi-method designs and
linking qualitative and quantitative data; multiple
methods; combining qualitative and quantitative
research; mixed model studies; blended methods; mixed
methods research.
Ridde V. A case study on methodological pluralism in public health research in Africa. Research and Reports in Tropical Medicine. 2010.
Application and challenges to the use of mixed methods in health systems research
0
5
10
15
20
25
1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
HSR and MM in Africa : 1950-2013 ; N = 105
Learning objectives
• Identifying and reflecting on experiences,
challenges, and solutions related to the
application of mixed methods in health
systems research
• Canada, Africa, Latin America
5
Session = 4 x (8‘+2’)
• AMTT = Challenges of Using a Mixed Methods Design
to Study a PBF Intervention in Burkina Faso
• MDA = Implementing a Mixed-Methods Protocol in
Impact Evaluation
• NOR = Mixed methods for the analysis of the Social
Vulnerability in Poor Household Colombia
• HQR = Designs and strategies for synthesizing
qualitative and quantitative evidence in systematic
reviews
6
Working groups = 30’ + plenary discussion = 15’
1. discuss and elicit the main challenges
encountered using MMR
2. responses used to address these challenges
3. 2 mn to share the 2 mains challenges and 2
main responses to address it
7
1 of 7

Recommended

Resilient & responsive health systems for a changing world: Analysis of the S... by
Resilient & responsive health systems for a changing world: Analysis of the S...Resilient & responsive health systems for a changing world: Analysis of the S...
Resilient & responsive health systems for a changing world: Analysis of the S...valéry ridde
566 views9 slides
Challenges of using a mix-methods design to study a complex health interventi... by
Challenges of using a mix-methods design to study a complex health interventi...Challenges of using a mix-methods design to study a complex health interventi...
Challenges of using a mix-methods design to study a complex health interventi...valéry ridde
575 views11 slides
Implementing a mixed-methods protocol in impact evaluation: challenges and op... by
Implementing a mixed-methods protocol in impact evaluation: challenges and op...Implementing a mixed-methods protocol in impact evaluation: challenges and op...
Implementing a mixed-methods protocol in impact evaluation: challenges and op...valéry ridde
646 views12 slides
A realist approach to studying the UHC-Partnership by
A realist approach to studying the UHC-PartnershipA realist approach to studying the UHC-Partnership
A realist approach to studying the UHC-PartnershipEmilie Robert
593 views22 slides
The potential of the case study method to understand the heterogeneity of eff... by
The potential of the case study method to understand the heterogeneity of eff...The potential of the case study method to understand the heterogeneity of eff...
The potential of the case study method to understand the heterogeneity of eff...valéry ridde
381 views8 slides
A reflection on frameworks to assess implementation fidelity of an adaptive d... by
A reflection on frameworks to assess implementation fidelity of an adaptive d...A reflection on frameworks to assess implementation fidelity of an adaptive d...
A reflection on frameworks to assess implementation fidelity of an adaptive d...valéry ridde
383 views8 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul... by
Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul...Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul...
Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul...ILRI
936 views10 slides
Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio... by
Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio...Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio...
Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio...valéry ridde
395 views11 slides
Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation? by
Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation?Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation?
Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation?valéry ridde
413 views8 slides
Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences... by
Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences...Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences...
Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences...valéry ridde
385 views9 slides
A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework by
A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework
A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework valéry ridde
371 views8 slides

What's hot(20)

Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul... by ILRI
Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul...Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul...
Integration of quantitative and qualitative research: Observations from a mul...
ILRI936 views
Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio... by valéry ridde
Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio...Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio...
Fidelity assessment in cluster randomized trials of public health interventio...
valéry ridde395 views
Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation? by valéry ridde
Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation?Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation?
Looking at implementation: how useful is realist evaluation?
valéry ridde413 views
Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences... by valéry ridde
Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences...Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences...
Using the Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Study the Unintended Consequences...
valéry ridde385 views
A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework by valéry ridde
A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework
A case study approach to comprehend sustainability's framework
valéry ridde371 views
Correlation between Theoretical Classroom Instruction and Related Learning Ex... by Ryan Michael Oducado
Correlation between Theoretical Classroom Instruction and Related Learning Ex...Correlation between Theoretical Classroom Instruction and Related Learning Ex...
Correlation between Theoretical Classroom Instruction and Related Learning Ex...
Fifteen-Year Multiple Sclerosis Program with No Patient Dropouts by Covance
Fifteen-Year Multiple Sclerosis Program with No Patient DropoutsFifteen-Year Multiple Sclerosis Program with No Patient Dropouts
Fifteen-Year Multiple Sclerosis Program with No Patient Dropouts
Covance21 views
Terminal Competency Assessment of Core Nursing Knowledge in a State University by Ryan Michael Oducado
Terminal Competency Assessment of Core Nursing Knowledge in a State UniversityTerminal Competency Assessment of Core Nursing Knowledge in a State University
Terminal Competency Assessment of Core Nursing Knowledge in a State University
Effects of Participation in a Post-Secondary Honors Program using Propensity ... by Scott R. Furtwengler, Ph.D.
Effects of Participation in a Post-Secondary Honors Program using Propensity ...Effects of Participation in a Post-Secondary Honors Program using Propensity ...
Effects of Participation in a Post-Secondary Honors Program using Propensity ...
School to Prison Pipeline-ACLU by Nikki Parekh
School to Prison Pipeline-ACLUSchool to Prison Pipeline-ACLU
School to Prison Pipeline-ACLU
Nikki Parekh184 views
Opening Weekend Agenda by emphemory
Opening Weekend AgendaOpening Weekend Agenda
Opening Weekend Agenda
emphemory522 views
The Most Significant Change Method: Background by MEASURE Evaluation
The Most Significant Change Method: BackgroundThe Most Significant Change Method: Background
The Most Significant Change Method: Background
MEASURE Evaluation1.1K views
How to Evaluate Complex Interventions by amusten
How to Evaluate Complex InterventionsHow to Evaluate Complex Interventions
How to Evaluate Complex Interventions
amusten1.7K views

Viewers also liked

Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit... by
Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit...Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit...
Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit...valéry ridde
552 views11 slides
Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations... by
Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations...Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations...
Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations...valéry ridde
198 views14 slides
L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali. by
L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali.L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali.
L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali.valéry ridde
211 views13 slides
Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul... by
Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul...Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul...
Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul...valéry ridde
229 views14 slides
The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e... by
The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e...The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e...
The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e...valéry ridde
188 views13 slides
Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la... by
Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la...Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la...
Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la...valéry ridde
236 views11 slides

Viewers also liked(11)

Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit... by valéry ridde
Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit...Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit...
Main types of designs and strategies for synthetizing qualitative and quantit...
valéry ridde552 views
Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations... by valéry ridde
Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations...Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations...
Transferring the purchasing role from international to national organizations...
valéry ridde198 views
L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali. by valéry ridde
L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali.L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali.
L’émergence du registre social unifié au Mali.
valéry ridde211 views
Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul... by valéry ridde
Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul...Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul...
Universal health insurance scheme in Burkina Faso: integrating research resul...
valéry ridde229 views
The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e... by valéry ridde
The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e...The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e...
The global, continental & national adoption of performance-based financing: e...
valéry ridde188 views
Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la... by valéry ridde
Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la...Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la...
Financement basé sur la performance en santé et équité au Burkina Faso: de la...
valéry ridde236 views
Access to global health research: Prevalence and cost of open access by valéry ridde
Access to global health research: Prevalence and cost of open accessAccess to global health research: Prevalence and cost of open access
Access to global health research: Prevalence and cost of open access
valéry ridde236 views
A realist approach to studying the UHC-Partnership by valéry ridde
A realist approach to studying the UHC-PartnershipA realist approach to studying the UHC-Partnership
A realist approach to studying the UHC-Partnership
valéry ridde197 views
Using the realist approach to evaluate public health policies with a health p... by Emilie Robert
Using the realist approach to evaluate public health policies with a health p...Using the realist approach to evaluate public health policies with a health p...
Using the realist approach to evaluate public health policies with a health p...
Emilie Robert932 views
Sophie methods: an introduction to realist review by Davide Malmusi
Sophie methods: an introduction to realist reviewSophie methods: an introduction to realist review
Sophie methods: an introduction to realist review
Davide Malmusi2.9K views
Systematic Reviews: the process, quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods ... by healthlibaust2012
Systematic Reviews: the process, quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods ...Systematic Reviews: the process, quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods ...
Systematic Reviews: the process, quantitative, qualitative and mixed methods ...
healthlibaust201229.2K views

Similar to Application and challenges to the use of mixed methods in health systems research

Harmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock production by
Harmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock productionHarmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock production
Harmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock productionILRI
429 views19 slides
Rapid Assessment Procedures - Report by Cindy Cruz (Cabrera) by
Rapid Assessment Procedures - Report by Cindy Cruz (Cabrera)Rapid Assessment Procedures - Report by Cindy Cruz (Cabrera)
Rapid Assessment Procedures - Report by Cindy Cruz (Cabrera)University of the Philippines Diliman
1.7K views50 slides
SARET_mHealthPrivacy_Aug2015 by
SARET_mHealthPrivacy_Aug2015SARET_mHealthPrivacy_Aug2015
SARET_mHealthPrivacy_Aug2015Frank Grazioli
97 views2 slides
Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at... by
Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at...Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at...
Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at...Zubia Qureshi
26 views6 slides
Hardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.ppt by
Hardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.pptHardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.ppt
Hardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.pptPrabhatVerma76
5 views18 slides
Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves... by
Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves...Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves...
Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves...Dimitrios Gouglas
816 views20 slides

Similar to Application and challenges to the use of mixed methods in health systems research(20)

Harmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock production by ILRI
Harmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock productionHarmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock production
Harmonisation of data collection on antimicrobial use in livestock production
ILRI429 views
Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at... by Zubia Qureshi
Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at...Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at...
Lady health workers' perceptions towards tuberculosis and its determinants at...
Zubia Qureshi26 views
Hardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.ppt by PrabhatVerma76
Hardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.pptHardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.ppt
Hardee_QOC AFP Partners Meeting w.refs July 27 2016.ppt
PrabhatVerma765 views
Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves... by Dimitrios Gouglas
Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves...Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves...
Multi criteria value-maximization methods for the prioritization of r&d inves...
Dimitrios Gouglas816 views
Interventions to change providers' practice in cameroon h hopkins by ACT Consortium
Interventions to change providers' practice in cameroon h hopkinsInterventions to change providers' practice in cameroon h hopkins
Interventions to change providers' practice in cameroon h hopkins
ACT Consortium650 views
Innovations conference 2014 dr tracy robinson using a multidisciplinary pro... by Cancer Institute NSW
Innovations conference 2014   dr tracy robinson using a multidisciplinary pro...Innovations conference 2014   dr tracy robinson using a multidisciplinary pro...
Innovations conference 2014 dr tracy robinson using a multidisciplinary pro...
Integration of WASH and Nutrition: Successes, Challenges, and Implications fo... by Jordan Teague
Integration of WASH and Nutrition: Successes, Challenges, and Implications fo...Integration of WASH and Nutrition: Successes, Challenges, and Implications fo...
Integration of WASH and Nutrition: Successes, Challenges, and Implications fo...
Jordan Teague1.3K views
Gesi webinar of 16/5/2018 by Carl Lachat
Gesi webinar of 16/5/2018 Gesi webinar of 16/5/2018
Gesi webinar of 16/5/2018
Carl Lachat147 views
TACT: a trial of interventions to improve the use of malaria rd ts hreyburn by ACT Consortium
TACT: a trial of interventions to improve the use of malaria rd ts hreyburnTACT: a trial of interventions to improve the use of malaria rd ts hreyburn
TACT: a trial of interventions to improve the use of malaria rd ts hreyburn
ACT Consortium772 views
Getting evidence from economic evaluation into healthcare practice by cheweb1
Getting evidence from economic evaluation into healthcare practiceGetting evidence from economic evaluation into healthcare practice
Getting evidence from economic evaluation into healthcare practice
cheweb1748 views
Implementation Science in HIV Related Work: Case Study of Injection Drug User... by HopkinsCFAR
Implementation Science in HIV Related Work: Case Study of Injection Drug User...Implementation Science in HIV Related Work: Case Study of Injection Drug User...
Implementation Science in HIV Related Work: Case Study of Injection Drug User...
HopkinsCFAR853 views

Recently uploaded

Vyadhikshmatva.pptx 1.pptx by
Vyadhikshmatva.pptx 1.pptxVyadhikshmatva.pptx 1.pptx
Vyadhikshmatva.pptx 1.pptxAkshay Shetty
51 views29 slides
Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad by
Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad
Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad Swetha rani Savala
21 views16 slides
VarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User Perspective by
VarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User PerspectiveVarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User Perspective
VarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User PerspectiveGolden Helix
100 views24 slides
Prodrugs by
ProdrugsProdrugs
ProdrugsDr. Ajmer Singh Grewal
17 views113 slides
The A-Team Against Relapsed/Refractory Myeloma: Community Strategies for Enha... by
The A-Team Against Relapsed/Refractory Myeloma: Community Strategies for Enha...The A-Team Against Relapsed/Refractory Myeloma: Community Strategies for Enha...
The A-Team Against Relapsed/Refractory Myeloma: Community Strategies for Enha...PVI, PeerView Institute for Medical Education
13 views44 slides
Buccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptx by
Buccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptxBuccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptx
Buccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptxABG
162 views43 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad by Swetha rani Savala
Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad
Fetal and Neonatal Circulation - MBBS, Gandhi medical College Hyderabad
VarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User Perspective by Golden Helix
VarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User PerspectiveVarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User Perspective
VarSeq 2.5.0: VSClinical AMP Workflow from the User Perspective
Golden Helix100 views
Buccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptx by ABG
Buccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptxBuccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptx
Buccoadhesive drug delivery System.pptx
ABG162 views
GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY-Principle, Instrumentation Advantage and disadvantage appl... by DipeshGamare
GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY-Principle, Instrumentation Advantage and disadvantage appl...GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY-Principle, Instrumentation Advantage and disadvantage appl...
GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY-Principle, Instrumentation Advantage and disadvantage appl...
DipeshGamare18 views
Gastro-retentive drug delivery systems.pptx by ABG
Gastro-retentive drug delivery systems.pptxGastro-retentive drug delivery systems.pptx
Gastro-retentive drug delivery systems.pptx
ABG227 views
Pulmonary Embolism for Nurses.pptx by Asraf Hussain
Pulmonary Embolism for Nurses.pptxPulmonary Embolism for Nurses.pptx
Pulmonary Embolism for Nurses.pptx
Asraf Hussain35 views
communication and nurse patient relationship by Tamanya Samui.pdf by TamanyaSamui1
communication and nurse patient relationship by Tamanya Samui.pdfcommunication and nurse patient relationship by Tamanya Samui.pdf
communication and nurse patient relationship by Tamanya Samui.pdf
TamanyaSamui131 views

Application and challenges to the use of mixed methods in health systems research

  • 1. Application and challenges to the use of mixed methods in health systems research Valéry Ridde, Manuela De Allegri, Quan Nha Hong, Anne-Marie Turcotte-Tremblay, Nicolas Ortiz Ruis
  • 2. « Mixed Methods Soup » multi-trait-multimethod research; integrating qualitative and quantitative approaches; integrated methods; interrelating qualitative and quantitative data; methodological triangulation; multi- methodological research; multi-method designs and linking qualitative and quantitative data; multiple methods; combining qualitative and quantitative research; mixed model studies; blended methods; mixed methods research. Ridde V. A case study on methodological pluralism in public health research in Africa. Research and Reports in Tropical Medicine. 2010.
  • 4. 0 5 10 15 20 25 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 HSR and MM in Africa : 1950-2013 ; N = 105
  • 5. Learning objectives • Identifying and reflecting on experiences, challenges, and solutions related to the application of mixed methods in health systems research • Canada, Africa, Latin America 5
  • 6. Session = 4 x (8‘+2’) • AMTT = Challenges of Using a Mixed Methods Design to Study a PBF Intervention in Burkina Faso • MDA = Implementing a Mixed-Methods Protocol in Impact Evaluation • NOR = Mixed methods for the analysis of the Social Vulnerability in Poor Household Colombia • HQR = Designs and strategies for synthesizing qualitative and quantitative evidence in systematic reviews 6
  • 7. Working groups = 30’ + plenary discussion = 15’ 1. discuss and elicit the main challenges encountered using MMR 2. responses used to address these challenges 3. 2 mn to share the 2 mains challenges and 2 main responses to address it 7