Combatting survey fatigue: uncovering the student learning experience using the
ID 164. Combatting survey fatigue: uncovering the student learning experience using the Nominal Group Technique Tunde Varga-Atkins, eLearning Unit Jaye McIsaac, Educational Development University of Liverpool 11-13 Sep 2012, ALT-C Funded by ELESIG
Outcomes•To consider the use of NominalGroup Technique as a studentevaluation strategy•To question the use (and concept)of technology in relation to anevaluation process
One solution: face-to-face Nominal Group Technique sessions
What is the Nominal Group Technique?• Structured group activity• One given topic• Facilitates group decision-making• Immediate results• Reducing researcher/participant bias - Delbecq & Van de Ven (1971)
Nominal Group Technique Stages Example question: ‘What to keep doing (feedback)?’1) Individual responses 2) Clarification and 3) Ranking responses consolidation ‘Nominal’ Group = only in name group, most activities are individual
What to keep doing? (feedback) Stage 1: individual responses 1 2 3 Annotated Model Audio ,personalised answers feedback feedback. giving extensive comments4Giving model 5 Audio 6answers for feedback Drafts thatessay titles for must be everything! submitted and marked prior final work
What to keep doing? (feedback)Stage2 : clarification and consolidation Model answers 4 2 Giving model Model answers for answers essay titles Audio feedback Personalised feedbac 3 Audio 6 5 Drafts that feedback Audio must be 1 giving feedback submitted and Annotated extensive for marked prior ,personalised comments final work feedback. everything!
What to keep doing? (feedback) Stage3 : ranking responses Item no. Item description 5 points 1 Annotated, personalised feedback 4 points 2 Giving model answers 3 points 4 Audio feedback 2 points 7 etc. 1 point 10 etc.
The top five qualities of good feedback1 Timing, quick Detailed, on how to 2 improve Applicable to future 3 work Personal 4 Consistent bw 5 markers
Conclusion: The Nominal Group Technique is a useful student evaluation technique
… (minor) problems of efficiency Credit by Nathan T. Baker
Can technology improve(time & resource) efficiency of the NGT process? Presumption!
No single technology could replicate all the 3 stages of NGT.Technologies we tried: ID275, Thu 9am
References• Delbecq, A., Van de Ven, Andrew, & Gustafson, D. (1975). Group techniques for program planning a : guide to nominal group and Delphi processes. Glenview Ill.: Scott Foresman.• Luff et al (2007) Augmented Paper: Developing relationships between digital content and paper• Oliver, M. (2012) Learning with technology as a coordinated sociomaterial practice: digital literacies as a site of praxiological study• Varga-Atkins, McIsaac et al (2011) Using the nominal group technique with clickers to research student experiences of e-learning: a project report [http://slidesha.re/xQlBCg ]• Varga-Atkins, McIsaac et al (2011) The Nominal Group Technique – a practical guide for facilitators [http://slidesha.re/AmYOgv]
Guide to NGT & Project report See References On slideshare.net , search for Nominal Group Technique