Implementation of Evidence- Based Medicine in Practice           Carolyn M. Clancy, MD                  DirectorAgency for...
Understanding a             Changing Landscape Health care reform, including  payment reform, has already  begun   – How ...
Maintaining the Status Quo               is Not an Option Evidence is being produced at an extremely  rapid rate, but its...
Aiming for the Sweet Spot   There is an overlap    among patient-centered    care, population    health, and advanced    ...
Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine     Making the Case: AHRQ and Its      Role in Advancing High-Quality      Healt...
AHRQ’s Mission             Improve the   quality, safety, efficiency, andeffectiveness of health care for all             ...
AHRQ’s Focus and                  Strategic Goals Quality: Deliver the right care at the right  time to the right patient...
HHS Organizational Focus      NIH                CDC                 AHRQ   Biomedical       Population health     Long-te...
AHRQ Priorities                                  Patient Safety                                Health IT                 ...
AHRQ 2011 National Healthcare         Quality and Disparities Reports Overall, improvement in the  quality of care remain...
Progress is Uneven Toward              National Priority Areas 2011 Findings:     – Health care quality and access are   ...
Quality Is Improving Slowly Quality measures that are improving, not changing  or worsening, overall and for select popula...
Few Disparities in Quality              of Care Are Getting Smaller           Quality measures for which disparities relat...
Illinois: Overall Quality of Care             Compared with All States                           Average       Weak       ...
Illinois Snapshot:                   Quality MeasuresMeasure                                              PerformanceESRD:...
Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine     Making the Case: AHRQ and Its      Role in Advancing High-Quality      Healt...
What We Know                         ―The truth is that for a                         large part of medical               ...
Research that Addresses              Patient Outcomes   Patient-Centeredness: The final frontier? Patient-centeredness ma...
Until Recently, Few Tools toGet From Evidence to Practice         AHRQ is working to:           – Translate scientific   ...
Effective Health Care Program                         Summaries     Policymakers                  Clinicians              ...
AHRQ’s EffectiveHealth Care Program
Implementing Evidence-           Based Treatment Decisions Which treatments work, for which patients, and what   are the ...
The Patient-Centered Outcomes         Research Institute and AHRQ Provides funding for AHRQ  to disseminate research  fin...
Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine     Making the Case: AHRQ and Its      Role in Advancing High-Quality      Healt...
Assumptions We’ve always assumed flawless  execution We’ve also always assumed that  any issues that arise are caused  b...
Sometimes,It’s The Little Things
AHRQ HAI                        Research Portfolio                                 Healthcare-associated infections      ...
CUSP Cuts CLABSIs by 40           Percent in 1,100 Hospital Units Nationwide patient safety   project    –    Developed a...
Keystone: Maintaining            Improvement Practices Example of building improvement into the  research   – Partnership...
AHRQ Health IT                Research Portfolio AHRQ has invested more  than $300 million since 2004  in contracts and g...
Enabling Evidence-Based         Medicine through Health IT    Streamlining Information and Clinical Processes Faster and ...
Who Benefits from AHRQ’s               Health IT Work? Patients get the right treatment at the right  time; and when thei...
Preparing the Field for       Innovation: Project ECHO             Project ECHODevelops capacity to safely and effectively...
MEADERSMedication Error and Adverse Drug Event ReportingSystem (MEADERS) Web-based and downloadable reporting  system for...
AHRQ Hip and Knee Registry Function and Outcomes Research for  Comparative Effectiveness in Total Joint  Replacement (FOR...
Generating Information and            Evidence with Registries Registries increasingly used  to inform clinical decision-...
How Do We Engage Patients? Two requests to  make of patients:   – ―Tell me your     goals.‖   – ―Tell me what     you hea...
A Decent Meal,                     Or a New Model of Care? The challenge:       – Serving millions of people       – Deli...
Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine     Making the Case: AHRQ and Its      Role in Advancing High-Quality      Healt...
This is an Evolving Enterprise Evidence, quality assessment, and othertools are important—but only inasmuch as       they ...
Getting There will Be a             New Learning Model We will develop a more intuitive grasp of the  power of data over ...
Key Considerations Interest in assessing clinician  performance will continue Much of the measurement  enterprise is ―ev...
How Will We Know                    We’re On Track? The quality enterprise adds value to    clinical practice   Care inc...
Health System Transformation:             Current and Future         Current                         FutureVariable qualit...
The Journey:From Knowledge to Practice           System transformation is            a long-term endeavor           It r...
Thank You  AHRQ Mission  To improve the  quality, safety, efficiency, and  effectiveness of health care for  all Americans...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Implementation of evidence based medicine in practice

337 views

Published on

  • Be the first to comment

Implementation of evidence based medicine in practice

  1. 1. Implementation of Evidence- Based Medicine in Practice Carolyn M. Clancy, MD DirectorAgency for Healthcare Research and Quality CMIO Leadership Forum: Transforming Healthcare through Evidence-based Medicine Chicago, IL – October 4, 2012
  2. 2. Understanding a Changing Landscape Health care reform, including payment reform, has already begun – How is evidence integrated into the new environment? – How has the nature of CHANGE evidence changed? AHEAD – How do these changes affect providers, payers and patients? How do we ensure that these changes are beneficial?
  3. 3. Maintaining the Status Quo is Not an Option Evidence is being produced at an extremely rapid rate, but its incorporation into clinical practice is happening much more slowly Transparency efforts don’t offer enough usable data for decisions regarding a specific disease and selection of a treatment option We face an underperforming health care system and untenable cost forecasts Too often, the patient is an afterthought
  4. 4. Aiming for the Sweet Spot There is an overlap among patient-centered care, population health, and advanced modern medicine All three call for organizing care around the patient rather than around systems of care All three call for a fresh examination of how we conduct and disseminate research
  5. 5. Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine  Making the Case: AHRQ and Its Role in Advancing High-Quality Health Care  Patient-Centered Outcomes Research: The Collection of Modern Evidence to Enable Modern Medicine  Putting the Patient at the Center of Care  21st Century Health Care
  6. 6. AHRQ’s Mission Improve the quality, safety, efficiency, andeffectiveness of health care for all Americans
  7. 7. AHRQ’s Focus and Strategic Goals Quality: Deliver the right care at the right time to the right patient Safety: Reduce the risk of harm by promoting delivery of the best possible health care Efficiency: Enhance access to effective health care services and reduce unnecessary costs Effectiveness: Improve health care outcomes by encouraging the use of evidence to make more informed health care decisions
  8. 8. HHS Organizational Focus NIH CDC AHRQ Biomedical Population health Long-term and Research to and the role of system-wideprevent, diagnose community based improvement ofand treat disease interventions to health care quality improve health and effectiveness
  9. 9. AHRQ Priorities Patient Safety  Health IT  Patient Safety Organizations Ambulatory  Patient Safety Effective Health Patient Safety Grants (incl. Care Program simulation)  Comparative Safety & Quality Measures, Effectiveness Reviews Drug Management, & Patient-Centered Care  Patient-Centered Survey of Patient Safety Culture Outcomes Research Diagnostic Error Research  Clear Findings for Multiple Audiences Other Research & Medical Expenditure Dissemination Activities Panel Surveys  Quality & Cost-Effectiveness, e.g.,  Visit-Level Information on Prevention & Pharmaceutical Medical Expenditures Outcomes  Annual Quality &  U.S. Preventive Services Disparities Reports Task Force  MRSA/HAIs
  10. 10. AHRQ 2011 National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Reports Overall, improvement in the quality of care remains suboptimal and access to care is not improving Few disparities in quality are getting smaller and almost no disparities in access are getting smaller Quality of care varies not only across types of care but also across parts of the country
  11. 11. Progress is Uneven Toward National Priority Areas 2011 Findings: – Health care quality and access are suboptimal, especially for minority and low-income groups – Quality is improving; access and disparities are not – Urgent attention needed to ensure continued improvement in quality and progress on reducing disparities for services, geographic areas and populations, including:  Diabetes care and adverse events  Disparities in cancer screening and access to care  States in the South Reports include evidence of progress toward priorities identified inNational Quality Strategy and HHS Plan to Reduce Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities
  12. 12. Quality Is Improving Slowly Quality measures that are improving, not changing or worsening, overall and for select populations  Nearly 60 percent of health care quality measures tracked showed improvement  However, the median rate of change was 2.5 percent per yearAHRQ 2011 National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Reports
  13. 13. Few Disparities in Quality of Care Are Getting Smaller Quality measures for which disparities related toage, race, ethnicity and income are improving, not changing or worsening  Few disparities in quality showed significant improvement.  The number of disparities that were getting smaller exceeded the number that were getting larger AHRQ 2011 National Healthcare Quality and Disparities Reports
  14. 14. Illinois: Overall Quality of Care Compared with All States Average Weak StrongVery VeryWeak Strong Performance Meter: All Measures = Most Recent Year = Baseline Year National Healthcare Quality Report, State Snapshots
  15. 15. Illinois Snapshot: Quality MeasuresMeasure PerformanceESRD: Renal failure – received a Better thantransplant averageDiabetes: Diabetes eye exams AverageCancer: Prostate cancer deaths Worse than average National Healthcare Quality Report, State Snapshots
  16. 16. Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine  Making the Case: AHRQ and Its Role in Advancing High-Quality Health Care  Patient-Centered Outcomes Research: The Collection of Modern Evidence to Enable Modern Medicine  Putting the Patient at the Center of Care  21st Century Health Care
  17. 17. What We Know ―The truth is that for a large part of medical practice, we don’t know what works. But we pay for it anyway.‖ H. Gilbert Welch, MD Geisel School of Medicine at DartmouthTesting What We Think We Know. New York Times - August 19, 2012
  18. 18. Research that Addresses Patient Outcomes Patient-Centeredness: The final frontier? Patient-centeredness may be the most challenging of all 6 domains of quality, because it is so difficult to define and measure But, it is also likely the most important, because it includes elements of all other domains
  19. 19. Until Recently, Few Tools toGet From Evidence to Practice  AHRQ is working to: – Translate scientific advances into actual clinical practice – Translate scientific advances into usable information for clinicians and for patients – Deliver information in the right places at the right time
  20. 20. Effective Health Care Program Summaries Policymakers Clinicians ConsumersSummarize research review findings on the benefits and harms of different treatmentoptions. Provide useful background on health conditions. Medication guides contain basic wholesale price information.
  21. 21. AHRQ’s EffectiveHealth Care Program
  22. 22. Implementing Evidence- Based Treatment Decisions Which treatments work, for which patients, and what are the trade-offs? – Patient-centered outcomes research informs decisions by providing evidence and information on effectiveness, benefits and harms How can evidence-based improvements be translated and shared with providers, patients? – Effective Health Care Clinician and Consumer Guides – Continuing Medical Education – Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation; AHRQ Innovation Exchange
  23. 23. The Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute and AHRQ Provides funding for AHRQ to disseminate research findings of the Institute and other government-funded research, train and build capacity for research – Up to 20% of Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Trust www.pcori.org Fund can be used to support research capacity building and dissemination activities
  24. 24. Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine  Making the Case: AHRQ and Its Role in Advancing High-Quality Health Care  Patient-Centered Outcomes Research: The Collection of Modern Evidence to Enable Modern Medicine  Putting the Patient at the Center of Care  21st Century Health Care
  25. 25. Assumptions We’ve always assumed flawless execution We’ve also always assumed that any issues that arise are caused by a knowledge problem Neither is always true A case in point…
  26. 26. Sometimes,It’s The Little Things
  27. 27. AHRQ HAI Research Portfolio  Healthcare-associated infections (HAIs) are infections that patients get in the course of medical care  HAIs affect up to 1 in 20 patients in hospitals at any one time  $34 million in support of goals of Partnership for Patients and HHS Action Plan to Prevent HAIswww.ahrq.gov/qual/haify11.htm  Projects include: – Three new modules for the Comprehensive Unit-based Safety Program (CUSP) – Research on ways to reduce MRSA and Clostridium difficile (C-diff) – Use of health system facility design to reduce HAIs
  28. 28. CUSP Cuts CLABSIs by 40 Percent in 1,100 Hospital Units Nationwide patient safety project – Developed at Johns Hopkins, tested in Michigan – Implemented in more than 1,100 hospital units  Results: – CLABSIs reduced from 1.903 infections per 1,000 central line days to 1.137 per 1,000 days – Savings: more than 500 lives, $34 million in costs New toolkit for implementation AHRQ Patient Safety Project Reduces Bloodstream Infections by 40 Percent. Press Release, September 10, 2012. www.ahrq.gov/news/press/pr2012/pspclabsipr.htm
  29. 29. Keystone: Maintaining Improvement Practices Example of building improvement into the research – Partnership with grants from AHRQ and various commitments from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, the Michigan Hospital Association, Johns Hopkins University and others – Stakeholders, end users and others are able to use the data to monitor progress – Innovative methods of dissemination and communication – An ongoing effort to learn and improve
  30. 30. AHRQ Health IT Research Portfolio AHRQ has invested more than $300 million since 2004 in contracts and grants More than 200 communities, hospitals, provi ders, and health care systems in 48 states AHRQ Health IT Investment: $300 Million
  31. 31. Enabling Evidence-Based Medicine through Health IT Streamlining Information and Clinical Processes Faster and broader dissemination of new evidence Inclusion of new evidence and treatments into electronic quality reporting systems, EHRs, etc. Registries
  32. 32. Who Benefits from AHRQ’s Health IT Work? Patients get the right treatment at the right time; and when their records are shared, tests don’t have to be repeated Doctors manage information in the office, and get decision support and helpful reminders Hospitals coordinate care among units and among each other Payers get faster, more accurate data States get real-time data on services statewide
  33. 33. Preparing the Field for Innovation: Project ECHO Project ECHODevelops capacity to safely and effectively treat chronic, common, complex diseases in rural, underserved areas and monitor outcomes
  34. 34. MEADERSMedication Error and Adverse Drug Event ReportingSystem (MEADERS) Web-based and downloadable reporting system for ambulatory care settings to document medication errors and adverse drug events ―Cloud‖ reporting system users can compare their results to national data Piloting testing underway at Cleveland Clinic and two sites that are part of the HRSA ―Patient Safety and Clinical Pharmacy Services Collaborative
  35. 35. AHRQ Hip and Knee Registry Function and Outcomes Research for Comparative Effectiveness in Total Joint Replacement (FORCE-TJR) – Collecting data on 30,000 patients on functions including:  Longitudinal patient pain and function  Post-procedure complications and revisions  Characteristics of patients, procedure, physician and hospital – Developing tools for patient-centered outcomes research:  Establish consensus on the definition of ―functional failure‖  Construct, validate and refine prediction algorithms for patients at risk for early post-TJR functional failure  Develop and institute an integrated, brief TJR-specific physical function outcome measure
  36. 36. Generating Information and Evidence with Registries Registries increasingly used to inform clinical decision- making – Revised AHRQ guide (2010) includes 4 new chapters:  When to Stop a Registry  Use of Registries in Product Safety Assessment  Linking Registry Data  Interfacing Registries and Electronic Health Records
  37. 37. How Do We Engage Patients? Two requests to make of patients: – ―Tell me your goals.‖ – ―Tell me what you heard.‖
  38. 38. A Decent Meal, Or a New Model of Care? The challenge: – Serving millions of people – Delivering a range of services – Keeping costs reasonable – Attaining a consistently high level of quality Can care be mechanized? Should it be? Are there models we can use?Gawande A. Big Med: Restaurant chains have managed to combine quality control, cost control, and innovation. Can health care? New Yorker. August 13, 2012
  39. 39. Implementation ofEvidence-Based Medicine  Making the Case: AHRQ and Its Role in Advancing High-Quality Health Care  Patient-Centered Outcomes Research: The Collection of Modern Evidence to Enable Modern Medicine  Putting the Patient at the Center of Care  21st Century Health Care
  40. 40. This is an Evolving Enterprise Evidence, quality assessment, and othertools are important—but only inasmuch as they improve care for patients
  41. 41. Getting There will Be a New Learning Model We will develop a more intuitive grasp of the power of data over time – Young physicians tend to be first adopters of health IT – Older physicians generally experience more difficulty in adapting to the rapidly changing practice environment – New practice arrangements are increasingly offering more alternatives to physicians entering practice
  42. 42. Key Considerations Interest in assessing clinician performance will continue Much of the measurement enterprise is ―evolving‖ Collective interest in using quality measures that reflect the profession’s knowledge and authority ―Some day‖ health IT will make data collection, reporting and updating of measures easy – but not today!
  43. 43. How Will We Know We’re On Track? The quality enterprise adds value to clinical practice Care includes focus on missed opportunities and dropped balls: transitions; handoffs; anticipating errors Physicians say, ―we‖ rather than ―I‖ Patient activation and engagement is welcomed and encouraged ―Best doctors‖ are evaluated in terms of care for individual patients and leadership in health of population
  44. 44. Health System Transformation: Current and Future Current FutureVariable quality; expensive, Consistently better quality; wasteful lower cost, more efficient Pay for volume Pay for quality Pay for transactions Care-based episodesQuality assessment based Quality assessment based on provider and setting on patient experience (process) (outcomes)
  45. 45. The Journey:From Knowledge to Practice  System transformation is a long-term endeavor  It requires research, incentives, and desire to improve  Communication at every juncture is critical  So is measurement!  Change is not only possible, but it is inevitable if we are committed to it
  46. 46. Thank You AHRQ Mission To improve the quality, safety, efficiency, and effectiveness of health care for all Americans AHRQ Vision As a result of AHRQs efforts, American health care will provide services of the highest quality, with the best possible outcomes, at the lowest costwww.ahrq.gov

×