Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Research at CNNIC<br />China Internet Network Information Center<br />
I lost access to my life! <br />Hitting the refresh button when Google services were blocked in summer of 2009<br />
CCTV Claims Google.CN is Full of Porn<br />http://bit.ly/c0Vqny<br />http://bit.ly/aqk7NF<br />
Google is localized for 180 countries <br />
Different search results on local domains<br />Google.COM<br />Google.COM.MX<br />
2006   Google.CN <br />
2009  Google services blocked<br />
Jan. 2010  Security breach, no more censoring<br />http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/01/new-approach-to-china.html<br />
March 2010  move to Hong Kong <br />http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/03/new-approach-to-china-update.html<br />
Good-bye .CN, hello .COM.HK<br />
PART I<br />ethnographic analysis on why Google.CN wasn’t useful in China<br />PART 2<br />clash in moral orders<br />PART...
PART I<br />ethnographic analysis on why Google.CN wasn’t useful in China<br />
http://culturalbytes.com/post/340498962/googleandchina<br />
Google failed at: <br />1<br />brand <br />recognition<br />2<br />marketing <br />campaign<br />3<br />Understanding<br /...
1<br />brand <br />recognition<br />
微软的名字 <br />苹果<br />
Unsure of Google’s actual name<br />Gogle.CN<br />Gougou.com = DOG<br />
GU GE  谷歌   Harvest Valley Song<br />
www.noGuGE.com<br />
2<br />marketing <br />campaign<br />
Baidu vs. Google commercial<br />http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Ed7oDVyHwA&feature=player_embedded<br />
3<br />Understanding<br />non-elite<br />users<br />
DIGITAL<br />ELITE-USERS<br />highly educated   •fluent in English•own a credit card<br />
ONE<br />software does not fit all<br />hire ethnographers  •go beyond usability tests  •understand local values<br />
PART 2<br />clash in moral orders<br />
“..both Google and China are after the same thing…”<br />-Alex Pasterneck<br />http://bit.ly/bgDiEi<br />
access to information<br />China<br />Google<br />
Google<br />Seeing like a corporation<br />
http://investor.google.com/corporate/2004/ipo-founders-letter.html<br />
Normative statement      versus      prescriptive statement<br />“don’t squeeze bunnies”<br />“squeezing bunnies is bad”<b...
media stereotype of hacker<br />
HACKER ETHIC<br />Information should be free<br />Mistrust of any form of authority  decentralization<br />Computer acces...
Enlightenment Ideals<br />All men are created equal.<br />Kant <br />Morally good acts bring happiness to the greatest num...
Enlightenmentideals<br />Men [sic] are free<br />Contract with society<br />Individuals<br />Educated<br />Rational<br />
2000 CE<br />1700-1800 CE<br />The Enlightenment<br />
2000 CE<br />200 BCE<br />1700-1800 CE<br />The Enlightenment<br />Confucius<br />
China<br />Seeing like a state<br />
Social Harmony<br />
Confucius, China (551 BCE – 479 BCE)<br />Bad-ass Philosopher<br />duty<br />filial piety<br />humility<br />discretion<br...
Obedience<br />virtuous • obey higher forms of authority  • maintain harmony •  acceptance<br />
Moral<br />Clash<br />good versus bad<br />
access to information<br />China<br />Google<br />
WEALTH<br />Generation<br />through information<br />
Google’s PROJECT<br />turn the world<br />into digital bytes of <br />information<br />
Adsense: 97% of Google’s revenue<br />
PART 3<br />The free-information regime as cultural imperialism and neo-informationalism<br />
Umair Haque<br />Economist, Writer at Harvard Review Blog, Director of Havas Media Lab<br />“It's an ethical edge...that's...
MORAL<br />TROPE<br />ethical beliefs that justify expansionary practices of extracting commodities and creating new marke...
WEapons<br />guns, germs, steel<br />free-information, open platforms, and distributed architectures<br />
Neo-informationalism<br />Information functions like currency:<br />Borderless<br />unregulated<br />mobile<br />
NEW QUESTIONS<br />ABOUT SOCIAL INFORMATION<br />For example, what role do we want to play in a social agenda that priorit...
Values<br />that shape our technologies<br />Values<br />that shape the way we use technologies<br />Values<br />that defi...
Thank you!<br />Tricia Wang<br />tw@triciawang.com<br />www.triciawang.com<br />Thanks you to the following funders whose ...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

GOOGLIST REALISM: The Google-China saga and the free-information regimes as a new site of cultural imperialism and moral tensions

5,650 views

Published on

These slides go with my talk on the Google-China saga. My talk can be read here. http://culturalbytes.com/post/781876273/googoochinasaga

Published in: Technology, Business

GOOGLIST REALISM: The Google-China saga and the free-information regimes as a new site of cultural imperialism and moral tensions

  1. Research at CNNIC<br />China Internet Network Information Center<br />
  2. I lost access to my life! <br />Hitting the refresh button when Google services were blocked in summer of 2009<br />
  3. CCTV Claims Google.CN is Full of Porn<br />http://bit.ly/c0Vqny<br />http://bit.ly/aqk7NF<br />
  4. Google is localized for 180 countries <br />
  5. Different search results on local domains<br />Google.COM<br />Google.COM.MX<br />
  6. 2006 Google.CN <br />
  7. 2009 Google services blocked<br />
  8. Jan. 2010 Security breach, no more censoring<br />http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/01/new-approach-to-china.html<br />
  9. March 2010 move to Hong Kong <br />http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2010/03/new-approach-to-china-update.html<br />
  10. Good-bye .CN, hello .COM.HK<br />
  11. PART I<br />ethnographic analysis on why Google.CN wasn’t useful in China<br />PART 2<br />clash in moral orders<br />PART 3<br />The free-information regime as cultural imperialism and neo-informationalism<br />
  12. PART I<br />ethnographic analysis on why Google.CN wasn’t useful in China<br />
  13. http://culturalbytes.com/post/340498962/googleandchina<br />
  14. Google failed at: <br />1<br />brand <br />recognition<br />2<br />marketing <br />campaign<br />3<br />Understanding<br />non-elite<br />users<br />
  15. 1<br />brand <br />recognition<br />
  16. 微软的名字 <br />苹果<br />
  17. Unsure of Google’s actual name<br />Gogle.CN<br />Gougou.com = DOG<br />
  18. GU GE 谷歌 Harvest Valley Song<br />
  19. www.noGuGE.com<br />
  20. 2<br />marketing <br />campaign<br />
  21. Baidu vs. Google commercial<br />http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Ed7oDVyHwA&feature=player_embedded<br />
  22. 3<br />Understanding<br />non-elite<br />users<br />
  23. DIGITAL<br />ELITE-USERS<br />highly educated •fluent in English•own a credit card<br />
  24. ONE<br />software does not fit all<br />hire ethnographers •go beyond usability tests •understand local values<br />
  25. PART 2<br />clash in moral orders<br />
  26. “..both Google and China are after the same thing…”<br />-Alex Pasterneck<br />http://bit.ly/bgDiEi<br />
  27. access to information<br />China<br />Google<br />
  28. Google<br />Seeing like a corporation<br />
  29. http://investor.google.com/corporate/2004/ipo-founders-letter.html<br />
  30. Normative statement versus prescriptive statement<br />“don’t squeeze bunnies”<br />“squeezing bunnies is bad”<br />
  31. media stereotype of hacker<br />
  32. HACKER ETHIC<br />Information should be free<br />Mistrust of any form of authority  decentralization<br />Computer access should be free<br />Information should be shared<br />Computers and free-information improves quality of life<br />
  33. Enlightenment Ideals<br />All men are created equal.<br />Kant <br />Morally good acts bring happiness to the greatest number of people<br />Bentham<br />I think therefore I am.<br />Descarte<br />
  34. Enlightenmentideals<br />Men [sic] are free<br />Contract with society<br />Individuals<br />Educated<br />Rational<br />
  35. 2000 CE<br />1700-1800 CE<br />The Enlightenment<br />
  36. 2000 CE<br />200 BCE<br />1700-1800 CE<br />The Enlightenment<br />Confucius<br />
  37. China<br />Seeing like a state<br />
  38. Social Harmony<br />
  39. Confucius, China (551 BCE – 479 BCE)<br />Bad-ass Philosopher<br />duty<br />filial piety<br />humility<br />discretion<br />obedience<br />
  40. Obedience<br />virtuous • obey higher forms of authority • maintain harmony • acceptance<br />
  41. Moral<br />Clash<br />good versus bad<br />
  42. access to information<br />China<br />Google<br />
  43. WEALTH<br />Generation<br />through information<br />
  44. Google’s PROJECT<br />turn the world<br />into digital bytes of <br />information<br />
  45. Adsense: 97% of Google’s revenue<br />
  46. PART 3<br />The free-information regime as cultural imperialism and neo-informationalism<br />
  47. Umair Haque<br />Economist, Writer at Harvard Review Blog, Director of Havas Media Lab<br />“It's an ethical edge...that's always been at the heart of Google's disruptive success.”<br />http://bit.ly/90nClD<br />http://bit.ly/cICMFW<br />
  48. MORAL<br />TROPE<br />ethical beliefs that justify expansionary practices of extracting commodities and creating new markets in the name of a "higher calling." <br />
  49. WEapons<br />guns, germs, steel<br />free-information, open platforms, and distributed architectures<br />
  50. Neo-informationalism<br />Information functions like currency:<br />Borderless<br />unregulated<br />mobile<br />
  51. NEW QUESTIONS<br />ABOUT SOCIAL INFORMATION<br />For example, what role do we want to play in a social agenda that prioritizes the ubiquity of free-information?<br />How comfortable are we with this approach when it is part of an imposition of <br />neo-informationalist values in support of capitalism's search for new information markets? <br />
  52. Values<br />that shape our technologies<br />Values<br />that shape the way we use technologies<br />Values<br />that define who we are<br />
  53. Thank you!<br />Tricia Wang<br />tw@triciawang.com<br />www.triciawang.com<br />Thanks you to the following funders whose grants have allowed me to conduct my research in China: National Science Foundation and UC Pacific Rim Research Program<br />

×