Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Thirteen Years of SysML: A Systematic Mapping Study


Published on

Presentation of the journal article "Thirteen Years of SysML: A Systematic Mapping Study" at Models 2019 in Munich

  • Login to see the comments

Thirteen Years of SysML: A Systematic Mapping Study

  1. 1. Christian Doppler Laboratory for Model-Integrated Smart Production Institute of Business Informatics – Software Engineering Johannes Kepler University Linz Altenberger Straße 69, Science Park 3 4040 Linz Christian Doppler Laboratory for Model-Integrated Smart Production CDL-MINT Thirteen years of SysML: A systematic mapping study Models Conference 2019, Munich Sabine Wolny, · Alexandra Mazak, · Christine Carpella,· Verena Geist,· Manuel Wimmer Software & Systems Modeling ISN 1619-1374 00735-y
  2. 2. Systems Modeling Language (SysML)  Out for 13 years  Established standard?  Domains?  Community?  Various tools available  Papyrus 4 SysML  MagicDraw  Enterprise Architect  ….  SysML v2 emerging  First release planned soon!  Textual DSL  Jupiter notebooks – Representation of SysML engineering/engineering-risk-and-safety-management/ s/automotive/prototyping-in-automotive.html
  3. 3. Systems Modeling Language (SysML) 3 Activity Diagram Sequence Diagram State Machine Diagram Behavior Diagram SysML Diagram Structure Diagram Internal Block Diagram Block Definition Diagram Package Diagram Parametric Diagram Requirement Diagram Use Case Diagram Same as UML 2 Modified from UML 2 New diagram type
  4. 4. Systematic Mapping Study of SysML 4Procedure: K. Petersen, R. Feldt, S. Mujtaba, M. Mattsson: Systematic Mapping Studies in Software Engineering. In Proc. of the 12th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering (EASE), 2008 All Papers • Conduct Search • 4 different digital libraries (Scopus, ACM, DBLP, IEEE) • 2005 until 2017; SysML in the title • 1613 papers Review Scope • Definition of Research Questions • RQ 1 Bibliometric • RQ 2 Major contributors and networks • RQ 3 Classification of SysML papers • RQ 4 Key aspects of SysML Classification Scheme • Analyse Abstracts • Type facets, contribution type, system engineering phase Systematic Map • Data Extraction and Mapping Process Relevant Papers • Screening of Papers • Removing duplicates, no abstracts, no context to SysML • 579 papers
  5. 5. Bibliometric RQ1: What are the bibliometric key facts of SysML publications?  Identify possible trends  Over the years  Considering the type of publication (articles, conference and workshop papers)  Which are the main venues?  Conferences  Journals 5
  6. 6. Major contributors and networks RQ2: Where are the scientific communities of SysML located and are there main contributors, who scientifically promote SysML topics?  Are there only single authors?  Small groups?  Working networks over the world?  Are there frequent authors? 6
  7. 7. Classification of SysML Papers RQ3: Which research type facets do the identified publications address? 7 K. Petersen, R. Feldt, S. Mujtaba, and M. Mattsson, “Systematic Mapping Studies in Software Engineering,” In Proc. of the 12th International Conference on Evaluation and Assessment in Software Engineering, ser. EASE’08. Swinton, UK, UK: British Computer Society, 2008, p. 71 Category Description Philosophical Papers These papers sketch a new way of looking at existing things by structuring the field in form of a taxonomy or conceptual framework Opinion Papers These papers express the personal opinion of somebody whether a certain technique is good or bad, or how things should been done. They do not rely on related work and research methodologies Experience Papers Experience papers explain on what and how something has been done in practice. It has to be the personal experience of the author Solution Proposal A solution for a problem is proposed; the solution can be either novel or a significant extension of an existing technique. The potential benefits and the applicability of the solution are shown by a small example or a good line of argumentation Validation Research Techniques investigated are novel and have not yet been implemented in practice. Techniques used are, for example, experiments, i.e., work done in the laboratory Evaluation Research Techniques are implemented in practice, and an evaluation of the technique is conducted. That means, it is shown how the technique is implemented in practice (solution implementation) and what are the consequences of the implementation in terms of benefits and drawbacks (implementation evaluation). This also includes to identify problems in industry
  8. 8. Key Aspects of SysML RQ4: What are the key aspects of applying SysML in the classified publications?  In which phase of the engineering process is SysML used?1  Requirement  Design  Implementation  Validation & Verification  Which contribution type does the publications have?2  Technique  Process  Notation  Tool  Specific Solution  Other 8 1: VDI Verein Deutscher Ingenieure:, Accessed: 2017-03-14 2: Shaw, M.: Writing good software engineering research paper. In Proc. of the 25th International Conference on Software Engineering, IEEE Computer Society, 2003, pp. 726–737.
  9. 9. Conduct Search  Tool support  DBLP  Open bibliographic information on computer science journals and proceedings  ACM Digital Library  Research, discovery and networking platform  Collection of full-text articles, bibliographic records  IEEE Xplore Digital Library  Technical literature in engineering and technology  Scopus  Largest abstract and citation database of peer-reviewed literature  Scientific journals, books and conference proceedings  Keywords / Phrases  SysML  Systems Modeling Language / systems modeling language  System Modeling Language / system modeling language 9
  10. 10. Screening of Papers  Restrictions  Years 2005 until 2017  Keyword must be contained in the title of the paper  Delete  Duplicates  Papers without abstract available  Papers without any context to SysML  Books and theses  Final check of the result set: 21.1.2019 579 papers for the analysis 10
  11. 11. Results: Bibliometrics of SysML publications (1)  2005 First draft of SysML by OMG  2007 / 2008 / 2010 / 2012 / 2017 – New versions of SysML 11
  12. 12. Results: Bibliometrics of SysML publications (2) 12 Conference Venue Pub. INCOSE (Annual International Symposium of the International Council on Systems Engineering) 32 IDETC/CIE (International Design Engineering Technical Conferences) 14 ETFA (International Conference on Emerging Technologies and Factory Automation) 13 SysCon (International Systems Conference) 12 MODELSWARD (Conference on Model-Driven Engineering and Software Development) 11 CSER (Conference on Systems Engineering Research) 10 ISSE (International Symposium on Systems Engineering) 9 WSC (Winter Simulation Conference) 9 ICEIS (International Conference on Enterprise Information Systems) 8 Journal Venue Pub. Systems Engineering 11 Innovations in Systems and Software Engineering 5 Software and Systems Modeling 4
  13. 13. Results: Research communities and main contributors of SysML topics (1)  1167 authors worldwide  30 single authors without relationship to another author in the SysML publications  Major contributors located in USA, France, and Germany 13
  14. 14. Results: Research communities and main contributors of SysML topics (2) 14 Network Biggest network (61 authors) with bridge builder - Paredis C.J.J.: Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, USA - Friedenthal S.: Lockheed Martin Corporation, Fairfax, USA - Canedo A.: Siemens Corporate Research, Princeton, USA
  15. 15. Results: Research communities and main contributors of SysML topics (3) 15
  16. 16. Result: Classification of SysML publications  Higher number of philosophical papers from 2005 to 2007  Focus on realization of own approaches and implementations since 2010 16
  17. 17. Results: Key aspects of applying SysML (1)  Phases Design and Validation are predominant topics in all type facet categories  Contribution types  Technique  Notation 17
  18. 18. Results: Key aspects of applying SysML (2) 18
  19. 19. Results: Formalism Transformation Graph (FTG)1 19 1: Lúcio, L., Mustafiz, S., Denil, J., Meyers, B., Vangheluwe, H.: The Formalism Transformation Graph as a Guide to Model Driven Engineering. Tech. rep. McGill University (2012) SysML FTG: SysML T DEVS ExtractSimulationModel Arena ExtractAnalysisModel T ExtractVerificationModel T B T Matlab Orocos-RTT T ExtractCode M3TK Simulink DHC Communication Protocol ExtractTestModel TSmartesting (Tool) VHDL- AMS OWL Stochastic Reward Nets (SRNs) Prolog PetriNets Simscape Modelica DesignStructureMatrix / MultipleDomainMatrix ExtractMatrix TRNSYS Communicating Sequential Processes HDL Recursive Object Model (ROM) T MigrateModel ADL IP Core T GenerateModel Mathematica GAMS Flexsim James II fUML HLA Aspen Plus ABD logic EXPRESS model Clean Axiom set T ExtractCanonicalForm T ExtractDesignModel Alta Rica EPLAN, Modelica CML DTMC OPM MoDAF/DoDAF Architectural Model NuSMV ProVerif Systemigrams Traceability Matrix Promela/Spin UPPAAL Fault Tree Generic Simulation Model eM Plant PIDO framework SafeSlice UML PRISM Interface Automata IBM IEC61499 Python SystemVerilog T ExtractOptimizationModel PyOpt SHIOQ(D) SPL ABM MES Gateway Configurations ARM Cortex-M MCUs Real-Time System IEC 61131-3 SystemC DiVinE 1-3 4-6 7-9 ≥10
  20. 20. Results: Formalism Extension Graph (FEG) 20SysML FEG: SysML DEVS {Simulation} {SoS} {GoalModeling} AVATAR {Verification} DSEE {DSM} OMAC/PackML Traceability Simulink MARTE SystemC/C {Electronics} Architecture Decisions {Architecture Modeling}SysML4 Modelica Contracts/ Refinements SysADL {Mechanics} Contact & Channel {Geometry} GERTRUDe {Saftey & Security} Saftey {Mechatronics} System Architecture {Thermal} TheReSE Trade Studies Variability Modeling {Automation} SysML-AT EIS {IT} OMEGA Aspects AUTOSAR {Automotive} KAOS UPDM TLM fSysML {Execution} Modelica Simscape Space {Libary} Constraints SysML4 IoT {IoT} AutomationML Geometrical Bond Graph 3+1 SysML View-Model Multi-Physical Interactions SysML4 Mechatronics FMI Signal Flow Multi Agent System ISO 26262 Tolerance Specification Design Functional/Non Functional Requirements DSL IEC 61131-3 Fault Tree Security Viewpoint {Embedded Systems} ExSAM Consol-Optcad SysML-Sec Multi-Core Process Knowledge Management B Time Constraints TEPE Use Case Points Design Optimization Verification Management Techno- Economic AMADEOS MES Gateway {Manufacturing} Piping & Instrumentation Diagram Supply Chain OWLVulnerabilities State Analysis1-3 4-6 7-9 ≥10
  21. 21. Conclusion and Outlook  Large set of SysML paper found  A plethora of transformations and extensions available  Worldwide community (but also dedicated groups)  New diagrams (requirement, parametric) are in use  SysML v2  Addresses the issue of ambiguous operational semantics  Planned enhancements (e.g., temporal components, history, …)  Modeling hybrid systems  Most publications consider either discrete or continuous challenges  Formal semantics for SysML combining discrete and continuous parts  Deep analysis for specific topics  Contribution category notation may be further differentiated by specific language engineering aspects, … 21
  22. 22. Questions? 22 Data available at Thirteen years of SysML: A systematic mapping study Sabine Wolny