SlideShare a Scribd company logo

Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success?

The document discusses challenges faced by Chief Strategy Officers (CSOs) in fulfilling their role. It finds that only 25% of CSOs feel very successful in creating value for their company. Common issues CSOs face include unclear priorities, spending too much time on tactical tasks instead of strategy, and not having a strong voice at the leadership table. It provides recommendations for companies to better utilize their CSO, such as making strategy a top executive priority, improving the strategic planning process, and clarifying the CSO's role and focus on strategic questions. When implemented, these recommendations can help CSOs unlock their full potential to drive company strategy and competitive advantage.

1 of 9
Download to read offline
strategy+business
ONLINE JANUARY 15, 2019
BY PAUL LEINWAND, NILS NAUJOK,
AND JOACHIM ROTERING
Memo to the CEO:
Is Your Chief Strategy
Officer Set Up
for Success?
strategy+business
www.strategy-business.com
2
Paul Leinwand
paul.leinwand@pwc.com
is global managing director of
capabilities-driven strategy and
growth for Strategy&, PwC’s
strategy consulting group. Based
in Chicago, he is a principal with
PwC US.
Nils Naujok
nils.naujok@pwc.com
is an advisor to executives in the
chemicals and steel industries
for Strategy& and specializes in
operating model development,
supply chain management,
and sourcing strategies. He is
a partner with PwC Strategy&
Germany, based in Berlin.
Joachim Rotering
joachim.rotering@pwc.com
is the global and Europe, Middle
East, and Africa leader for
Strategy&. Based in Dusseldorf
with PwC Strategy& Germany, he
specializes in operations, working
primarily with clients in the oil,
chemicals, and steel industries.
When Snap appointed a chief strategy officer (CSO) in 2014, the move was wide-
ly noticed — and not just because the owner of the Snapchat messaging app
had picked a banker who made his name advising on the massive initial public
offering of Alibaba, the Chinese e-commerce group. It was the first time Snap
had employed a CSO.
The role of the CSO is only a few decades old, but it is growing increasingly
popular. Companies large and small continue to create the CSO position. They
apparently recognize the value of having a member of the C-suite who is primar-
ily oriented to the long-term future of the company.
Unlike the CEO, whose day job often focuses on short-term performance, the
CSO can, in theory, concentrate on the future. And unlike other C-suite officers
such as the chief financial officer, the chief marketing officer, or the chief infor-
mation officer — whose points of view are influenced by the sometimes large
functions they represent — the CSO can provide an independent perspective.
Yet as desirable as the CSO role may be, there are signs that the role has yet to
be leveraged to its full potential. In a wide-ranging survey of 187 CSOs around
the globe, Strategy&, PwC’s strategy consulting practice, found that only 25
percent of respondents felt they were “very successful” at creating value for their
company. And in our ongoing research into the state of strategy, we find that 65
percent of executives across industries don’t think their company has a winning
strategy.
This tells us that companies need to reexamine how to get the most from this
increasingly critical strategic role. They also need to take a hard look at strategy
www.strategy-business.com
3
itself. It may have been desirable in the past for companies to employ the long-
term planning skills of a senior strategist, but the large number of choices com-
panies need to make today and the unprecedented scale of disruptive challenges
they now face make it imperative.
Indeed, in these turbulent times, companies need to make clear choices on
how they are going to compete and win, and that requires building real advan-
tage. Just responding in an ad hoc fashion — launching initiative after initiative
to seek growth or trying to remain flexible and react to what others are doing —
is a clear path to failure. Companies need to reboot the CSO role and strategy
itself.
The good news is that some CSOs across industries and across regions do get
it right. They feel positive about the value they create for their company, they
report that their strategic plans are of high quality, and they tell us their compa-
nies tend to outperform their peers. And they share a number of characteristics
from which we can learn.
What Ails the Chief Strategist?
Unfortunately, the companies with effective CSOs appear to be in the minority.
For the rest, there is a massive gap between the reasons the role was created and
what the job typically entails. Indeed, our survey found that 65 percent of CSOs
think their priorities aren’t very clear. “The company feels they need a CSO, but
they don’t quite know why,” says the head of strategy at one global manufactur-
ing company. “And then the CSO feels like they need to make up the role as
they go along.”
Rather than spending time and energy addressing the fundamental questions
of strategy, the CSO typically manages a long list of more tactical areas that fall
into what one executive described as “the chief everything-else officer.” Indeed,
many CSOs end up being stretched across too many different areas, making it
difficult for them to drive the company’s strategy. Many are busy dealing with
mergers and acquisitions, restructuring programs, the board agenda, external in-
telligence, or various corporate-wide initiatives they may not be well positioned
to run.
Whether it’s helping drive board documents, executing cost programs,
www.strategy-business.com
4
launching incubator businesses, or supporting individual business units, the
CSO typically has no shortage of areas in which to help, but lacks the freedom
to prioritize the important over the urgent. Adding to the problem is the fact
that the CSO role often overlaps with other C-suite positions, such as the cor-
porate development officer, the chief growth officer, the chief digital officer, and
the chief innovation officer — some of which were introduced after the inven-
tion of the CSO role. At a minimum, this overlap can create confusion about
who is driving the perspective on some longer-term strategic questions.
The environment is not set up for the CSO to live up to the potential of
the role. Most companies address strategy through an annual strategic planning
process. But that process generally doesn’t help the company address the funda-
mentals. Says one CSO at a global consumer packaged goods company, “Our
strategic planning process is currently too detailed, at a level that creates argu-
ments and discussions that don’t focus on high-level concepts that add value. We
need to raise the level at which we have discussions.” This is a widespread issue:
Just 26 percent of CSOs in our research, for example, fully agreed that their
company’s strategic plan clearly states “how we are going to compete and what is
going to make us successful.”
And although many top teams seem to be concerned that the company isn’t
addressing strategy properly, CSOs report that the same teams spend significant-
ly more time discussing operational issues and short-term financial performance
than important strategic matters. Small wonder, then, that although almost half
(47 percent) of CSOs expect their industry to be significantly disrupted in the
next five years, 68 percent admit they need to “get in front and drive change,
rather than react to it.” That’s hard to do if the top team isn’t spending time on
real strategy.
Many CSOs voice frustration over not being systematically involved in stra-
tegic discussions, a situation that allows them little room for influencing the
many decisions that are being made throughout the company. CSOs don’t feel
they have the authority to influence the company’s direction as much as they’d
like. In our survey, only 28 percent of CSOs fully agreed that they have a seat at
the table equal to those of other senior executives. Almost half don’t meet more
than twice a month with their CEO to discuss strategy.
www.strategy-business.com
5
It may be that CSOs need to be more proactive in demonstrating the value
they can add, or that leadership teams need to stop viewing the CSO as a “ge-
nius on demand” — that is, someone who will always be available on an ad hoc
basis for reactive insight — or both. Because, as we know from the way the role
was conceived, and how it must be used today, the CSO needs to be empowered
to drive the strategic agenda with a proper seat at the table.
Three Ways to Unlock the Full Potential of the CSO
We have compared the survey responses of CSOs who report being very success-
ful at creating value for their companies with those of their less successful peers,
and distilled three recommendations for ensuring the CSO is set up for success.
1. Put strategy at the forefront of the executive agenda. Prioritizing strategy
allows the company to make the big choices that shape its future and command
a sustainable competitive advantage. And the CEO needs to hold the CSO ac-
countable to work with the executive team to develop answers to the fundamen-
tal strategic questions that all companies need to address.
There are two powerful tools that a CSO can use to stretch the top team’s
thinking beyond the here and now. The first is to imagine together what a new
competitor would do if it entered this industry: What value would it create?
What customer experience would it offer? What technologies would it use? The
top team will gain new insights into similar technologies and processes they may
want to use, and into how they could use some of their own advantages to win
against this type of competitor.
65 percent of chief strategy officers
feel their priorities aren’t very clear.
“The company feels they need a CSO,
but they don’t quite know why,” says
the head of strategy at one global
manufacturing company.
www.strategy-business.com
6
The second tool is to turn that same scrutiny on their own company. In our
work, we call this the “coherence test.” It requires asking questions about how
the value proposition, capabilities system, and product and service lineup all fit
together. For example: Are you investing in the areas that really matter to your
value proposition (the promises you make to customers)? Can you articulate the
three to six capabilities that deliver on that value proposition? Have you defined
how those capabilities work together in a system? Do most or all of your prod-
ucts and services fit with that capabilities system? Is it reinforced by your perfor-
mance management system, your other incentives and KPIs, and your practic-
es? Do you understand how to leverage your capabilities in new or unexpected
arenas? And does everyone in the organization understand how the company is
distinctive?
In addition to ensuring that strategic questions get a prominent place on the
top team agenda, the CSO should build in mechanisms to hold the company
accountable for its strategy, for example, by getting regular input from key man-
agers across the organization on the critical issues the company faces, and by
defining clear metrics that help measure progress.
2. Make the strategic planning process more effective. Many strategy process-
es focus too closely on short- to medium-term functional and operational issues.
They neglect important stakeholders, do not respond well to a highly dynamic
business environment, and are overly bureaucratic and cumbersome. To avoid
these traps — and to make strategic planning truly strategic — the CSO should
aim to do the following.
•	 Decouple, then relink the strategic planning and budgeting processes. First
separate them, then bring them back together, making sure that the strategic
plan feeds into the budgeting process but is not dominated by it.
•	 Focus the scope of the strategic planning process on the few key strategic
questions that need to be answered, rather than doing comprehensive bottom-up
planning.
•	 Improve inputs to encompass a broader set of external stakeholders — not
just customers, but also ecosystem partners, technology think tanks, and oth-
ers. Use artificial intelligence to identify patterns, generate ideas that contribute
to some of the key strategic questions identified, and improve the efficiency of

Recommended

Rethinking the role_of_the_strategist
Rethinking the role_of_the_strategistRethinking the role_of_the_strategist
Rethinking the role_of_the_strategistSubbarao Jayanti
 
Closing the Gap: Designing and Delivering a Strategy that Works
Closing the Gap: Designing and Delivering a Strategy that WorksClosing the Gap: Designing and Delivering a Strategy that Works
Closing the Gap: Designing and Delivering a Strategy that WorksThe Economist Media Businesses
 
The Strategic Thinking Manifesto
The Strategic Thinking ManifestoThe Strategic Thinking Manifesto
The Strategic Thinking ManifestoRich Horwath
 
Collaborative Energy in Organizations
Collaborative Energy in OrganizationsCollaborative Energy in Organizations
Collaborative Energy in OrganizationsdEquipe_agency
 
2014 The Decade of HR032014
2014 The Decade of HR0320142014 The Decade of HR032014
2014 The Decade of HR032014Dave Forman
 
us-cio-insider-high-performing-companies
us-cio-insider-high-performing-companiesus-cio-insider-high-performing-companies
us-cio-insider-high-performing-companiesRenee Boucher Ferguson
 

More Related Content

What's hot

Top Private Company Board Mistakes
Top Private Company Board MistakesTop Private Company Board Mistakes
Top Private Company Board MistakesCharles Bedard
 
Can You Measure Leadership.doc
Can You Measure Leadership.docCan You Measure Leadership.doc
Can You Measure Leadership.docRobert Gandossy
 
The Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent Development
The Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent DevelopmentThe Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent Development
The Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent Developmentpaperpublications3
 
Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change
Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change
Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change Bhupesh Chaurasia
 
2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updated
2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updated2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updated
2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updatedmohammadtazam10
 
Managing On-Demand Talent
Managing On-Demand TalentManaging On-Demand Talent
Managing On-Demand TalentStewart Levin
 
The Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic Advisor
The Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic AdvisorThe Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic Advisor
The Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic AdvisorHuman Capital Media
 
Strategy prototyping leap into the future look around
Strategy prototyping leap into the future  look aroundStrategy prototyping leap into the future  look around
Strategy prototyping leap into the future look aroundmichaeldmaginn
 
Accounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSH
Accounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSHAccounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSH
Accounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSHBrad Self
 
PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.
PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.
PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.Ann-Marie Johnson
 
The Function of Talent Advisory in an organisation
The Function of Talent Advisory  in an organisationThe Function of Talent Advisory  in an organisation
The Function of Talent Advisory in an organisationKatharine McLennan
 
Making Strategy Work for Entrepreneurs
Making Strategy Work for EntrepreneursMaking Strategy Work for Entrepreneurs
Making Strategy Work for Entrepreneurssohailgondal
 
The StrategyEx Bridge_US
The StrategyEx Bridge_USThe StrategyEx Bridge_US
The StrategyEx Bridge_USTim Wasserman
 
Avoiding blind spots in your next joint venture
Avoiding blind spots in your next joint ventureAvoiding blind spots in your next joint venture
Avoiding blind spots in your next joint venturerob coulson
 
Guide to Talent Planning
Guide to Talent PlanningGuide to Talent Planning
Guide to Talent Planningpholberton
 

What's hot (17)

Top Private Company Board Mistakes
Top Private Company Board MistakesTop Private Company Board Mistakes
Top Private Company Board Mistakes
 
Can You Measure Leadership.doc
Can You Measure Leadership.docCan You Measure Leadership.doc
Can You Measure Leadership.doc
 
The Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent Development
The Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent DevelopmentThe Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent Development
The Impact of Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) on Talent Development
 
Polishing The Crystal Ball
Polishing The Crystal Ball Polishing The Crystal Ball
Polishing The Crystal Ball
 
Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change
Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change
Real-time Workforce Planning: Keeping up with business change
 
2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updated
2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updated2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updated
2014 state of global strategy and leadership survey report updated
 
Managing On-Demand Talent
Managing On-Demand TalentManaging On-Demand Talent
Managing On-Demand Talent
 
The Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic Advisor
The Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic AdvisorThe Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic Advisor
The Case Against Splitting HR: How to Become a True Strategic Advisor
 
Strategy prototyping leap into the future look around
Strategy prototyping leap into the future  look aroundStrategy prototyping leap into the future  look around
Strategy prototyping leap into the future look around
 
Why Organizational Strategy Matters
Why Organizational Strategy MattersWhy Organizational Strategy Matters
Why Organizational Strategy Matters
 
Accounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSH
Accounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSHAccounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSH
Accounting Today - Practice Profile - Clear Paths at CSH
 
PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.
PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.
PWC -17th Annual Global CEO Survey. The talent challenge.
 
The Function of Talent Advisory in an organisation
The Function of Talent Advisory  in an organisationThe Function of Talent Advisory  in an organisation
The Function of Talent Advisory in an organisation
 
Making Strategy Work for Entrepreneurs
Making Strategy Work for EntrepreneursMaking Strategy Work for Entrepreneurs
Making Strategy Work for Entrepreneurs
 
The StrategyEx Bridge_US
The StrategyEx Bridge_USThe StrategyEx Bridge_US
The StrategyEx Bridge_US
 
Avoiding blind spots in your next joint venture
Avoiding blind spots in your next joint ventureAvoiding blind spots in your next joint venture
Avoiding blind spots in your next joint venture
 
Guide to Talent Planning
Guide to Talent PlanningGuide to Talent Planning
Guide to Talent Planning
 

Similar to Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success?

Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34
Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34
Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34Innovation Excellence
 
3 how to improve strategyc planning
3 how to improve strategyc planning3 how to improve strategyc planning
3 how to improve strategyc planningMirna Mendoza
 
Building bench strategic planning ceos executive succession
Building bench strategic planning ceos executive successionBuilding bench strategic planning ceos executive succession
Building bench strategic planning ceos executive successionPwC
 
Strategic planning Document
Strategic planning DocumentStrategic planning Document
Strategic planning Documentbotla
 
Successfully Exploiting Market Adjacencies
Successfully Exploiting Market AdjacenciesSuccessfully Exploiting Market Adjacencies
Successfully Exploiting Market AdjacenciesTory Ramaker
 
10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting
10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting
10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board MeetingRoger Branch
 
Boardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actions
Boardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actionsBoardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actions
Boardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actionsBrowne & Mohan
 
Strategy value ff
Strategy value  ffStrategy value  ff
Strategy value ffFarooq Omar
 
How is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob Khan
How is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob KhanHow is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob Khan
How is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob KhanHealthcare consultant
 
CLC - Diagonising the need to restructure
CLC - Diagonising the need to restructureCLC - Diagonising the need to restructure
CLC - Diagonising the need to restructureRCP Consulting
 
767 .docx
767                                                       .docx767                                                       .docx
767 .docxsodhi3
 
Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...
Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...
Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...Chris Rigatuso
 
Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich 031710
Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich  031710Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich  031710
Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich 031710Mark Kinnich
 
11.business plan strategy as social responsibility
11.business plan strategy as social responsibility11.business plan strategy as social responsibility
11.business plan strategy as social responsibilityAlexander Decker
 
Business plan strategy as social responsibility
Business plan strategy as social responsibilityBusiness plan strategy as social responsibility
Business plan strategy as social responsibilityAlexander Decker
 
How to Grow a Business - Summary
How to Grow a Business - SummaryHow to Grow a Business - Summary
How to Grow a Business - SummaryBob Kacergis
 

Similar to Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success? (20)

Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34
Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34
Innovation Excellence Weekly - Issue 34
 
Tired Of Strategic Planning
Tired Of Strategic PlanningTired Of Strategic Planning
Tired Of Strategic Planning
 
Organizational effectiveness goes digital
Organizational effectiveness goes digital  Organizational effectiveness goes digital
Organizational effectiveness goes digital
 
3 how to improve strategyc planning
3 how to improve strategyc planning3 how to improve strategyc planning
3 how to improve strategyc planning
 
Building bench strategic planning ceos executive succession
Building bench strategic planning ceos executive successionBuilding bench strategic planning ceos executive succession
Building bench strategic planning ceos executive succession
 
Strategic planning Document
Strategic planning DocumentStrategic planning Document
Strategic planning Document
 
Successfully Exploiting Market Adjacencies
Successfully Exploiting Market AdjacenciesSuccessfully Exploiting Market Adjacencies
Successfully Exploiting Market Adjacencies
 
10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting
10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting
10 Questions to Ask at Your Next Board Meeting
 
Boardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actions
Boardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actionsBoardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actions
Boardroom agenda for FY16-17: priorities and actions
 
Strategy value ff
Strategy value  ffStrategy value  ff
Strategy value ff
 
How is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob Khan
How is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob KhanHow is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob Khan
How is COVID-19 Reshaping the role of Institutional strategy? By.Dr.Mahboob Khan
 
CLC - Diagonising the need to restructure
CLC - Diagonising the need to restructureCLC - Diagonising the need to restructure
CLC - Diagonising the need to restructure
 
767 .docx
767                                                       .docx767                                                       .docx
767 .docx
 
Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...
Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...
Corporate Governance a Balanced Scorecard approach with KPIs between BOD, Exe...
 
Organizing for Advantage
Organizing for AdvantageOrganizing for Advantage
Organizing for Advantage
 
Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich 031710
Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich  031710Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich  031710
Driving Organizational Performance in Complex Times - Mark Kinnich 031710
 
Creating The OSM
Creating The OSMCreating The OSM
Creating The OSM
 
11.business plan strategy as social responsibility
11.business plan strategy as social responsibility11.business plan strategy as social responsibility
11.business plan strategy as social responsibility
 
Business plan strategy as social responsibility
Business plan strategy as social responsibilityBusiness plan strategy as social responsibility
Business plan strategy as social responsibility
 
How to Grow a Business - Summary
How to Grow a Business - SummaryHow to Grow a Business - Summary
How to Grow a Business - Summary
 

More from Strategy&, a member of the PwC network

More from Strategy&, a member of the PwC network (20)

The seven stages of strategic leadership
The seven stages of strategic leadershipThe seven stages of strategic leadership
The seven stages of strategic leadership
 
Winning with a data-driven strategy
Winning with a data-driven strategyWinning with a data-driven strategy
Winning with a data-driven strategy
 
Automating trust with new technologies
Automating trust with new technologiesAutomating trust with new technologies
Automating trust with new technologies
 
Facing up to the automotive innovation dilemma
Facing up to  the automotive  innovation dilemmaFacing up to  the automotive  innovation dilemma
Facing up to the automotive innovation dilemma
 
The Four X Factors of Exceptional Leaders
The Four X Factors of Exceptional LeadersThe Four X Factors of Exceptional Leaders
The Four X Factors of Exceptional Leaders
 
What is fair when it comes to AI bias?
What is fair when it comes to AI bias?What is fair when it comes to AI bias?
What is fair when it comes to AI bias?
 
Chinese cars go global
Chinese cars go globalChinese cars go global
Chinese cars go global
 
Power strategies
Power strategiesPower strategies
Power strategies
 
Tomorrow's Data Heros
Tomorrow's Data HerosTomorrow's Data Heros
Tomorrow's Data Heros
 
Is AI the Next Frontier for National Competitive Advantage?
Is AI the Next Frontier for National Competitive Advantage?Is AI the Next Frontier for National Competitive Advantage?
Is AI the Next Frontier for National Competitive Advantage?
 
Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success?
Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success?Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success?
Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success?
 
HQ 2.0: The Next-Generation Corporate Center
HQ 2.0: The Next-Generation Corporate CenterHQ 2.0: The Next-Generation Corporate Center
HQ 2.0: The Next-Generation Corporate Center
 
Keeping Cool under Pressure
Keeping Cool under PressureKeeping Cool under Pressure
Keeping Cool under Pressure
 
The Flywheel Philosophy
The Flywheel PhilosophyThe Flywheel Philosophy
The Flywheel Philosophy
 
Leading a Bionic Transformation
Leading a Bionic TransformationLeading a Bionic Transformation
Leading a Bionic Transformation
 
Why Is It So Hard to Trust a Blockchain?
Why Is It So Hard to Trust a Blockchain?Why Is It So Hard to Trust a Blockchain?
Why Is It So Hard to Trust a Blockchain?
 
The Future of Artificial Intelligence Depends on Trust
The Future of Artificial Intelligence Depends on TrustThe Future of Artificial Intelligence Depends on Trust
The Future of Artificial Intelligence Depends on Trust
 
Approaching Diversity with the Brain in Mind
Approaching Diversity with the Brain in MindApproaching Diversity with the Brain in Mind
Approaching Diversity with the Brain in Mind
 
The Thought Leader Interview: NBA Commissioner Adam Silver
The Thought Leader Interview: NBA Commissioner Adam SilverThe Thought Leader Interview: NBA Commissioner Adam Silver
The Thought Leader Interview: NBA Commissioner Adam Silver
 
Today's Retail Needs Both Tech and the Human Touch
Today's Retail Needs Both Tech and the Human TouchToday's Retail Needs Both Tech and the Human Touch
Today's Retail Needs Both Tech and the Human Touch
 

Recently uploaded

EAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdf
EAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdfEAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdf
EAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdfDarryl_Carr
 
02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdf
02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdf02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdf
02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdfBloomerang
 
Master SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdf
Master SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdfMaster SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdf
Master SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdfenterpriseresearchcentre
 
Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024
Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024
Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024Neil Kimberley
 
Questions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docx
Questions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docxQuestions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docx
Questions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docxPrecious Mvulane CA (SA),RA
 
Cracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptx
Cracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptxCracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptx
Cracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptxWorkforce Group
 
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024Neil Kimberley
 
Dive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptx
Dive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptxDive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptx
Dive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptxRakshaAgrawal21
 
Session 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX Bridges
Session 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX BridgesSession 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX Bridges
Session 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX BridgesAnamaria Contreras
 
Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024
Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024
Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024caddrafting1
 
IT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - Event
IT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - EventIT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - Event
IT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - EventInbay UK
 
Bloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdf
Bloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdfBloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdf
Bloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdfBloomerang
 
Session 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX Bridges
Session 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX BridgesSession 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX Bridges
Session 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX BridgesAnamaria Contreras
 
PUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdf
PUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdfPUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdf
PUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdfUniversity of Exeter MA Publishing
 
SD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivity
SD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivitySD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivity
SD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivitybayusch
 
Your Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer Journeys
Your Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer JourneysYour Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer Journeys
Your Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer JourneysAggregage
 
The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...
The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...
The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...Hamed Mehrzadegan
 
YENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdf
YENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdfYENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdf
YENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdfhlopchik1415
 
2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentation
2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentation2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentation
2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentationsimonecapitalcorp
 
Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)
Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)
Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)Lviv Startup Club
 

Recently uploaded (20)

EAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdf
EAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdfEAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdf
EAPJ Vol VIII February 2024.pdf
 
02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdf
02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdf02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdf
02.22.2024 Email Options in Bloomerang.pdf
 
Master SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdf
Master SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdfMaster SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdf
Master SlideDeck Research Showcase 2024.pdf
 
Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024
Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024
Pernod Ricard presentation at CAGNY 2024
 
Questions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docx
Questions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docxQuestions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docx
Questions to Answer to Prepare for Zero Budget Marketing .docx
 
Cracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptx
Cracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptxCracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptx
Cracking the Leadership Shadow Code.pptx
 
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
 
Dive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptx
Dive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptxDive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptx
Dive into Machine Learning Event MUGDSC.pptx
 
Session 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX Bridges
Session 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX BridgesSession 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX Bridges
Session 1 Intro & InoVet it - JAX Bridges
 
Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024
Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024
Construction Documents Guide: Types and Significance in 2024
 
IT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - Event
IT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - EventIT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - Event
IT Nation Evolve event 2024 - Quarter 1 - Event
 
Bloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdf
Bloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdfBloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdf
Bloomerang Fundraising Week02.26.2024.pdf
 
Session 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX Bridges
Session 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX BridgesSession 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX Bridges
Session 2 - Value Proposition 1 JAX Bridges
 
PUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdf
PUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdfPUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdf
PUBLISHING AND LITERARY NETWORKS IN THE SOUTH WEST_EBOOK_WCOVER.pdf
 
SD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivity
SD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivitySD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivity
SD-WAN_MoD.pptx for SD WAN networks connectivity
 
Your Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer Journeys
Your Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer JourneysYour Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer Journeys
Your Expert Guide to CX Orchestration & Enhancing Customer Journeys
 
The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...
The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...
The value chain is a concept that describes the full range of activities and ...
 
YENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdf
YENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdfYENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdf
YENI MODEL 11 CI SINIF SINAQLARI - 10.pdf
 
2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentation
2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentation2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentation
2024-02 Augusta Gold Corporate Presentation
 
Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)
Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)
Serhii Herasymov: Boost sales through Accelerators (UA)
 

Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success?

  • 1. strategy+business ONLINE JANUARY 15, 2019 BY PAUL LEINWAND, NILS NAUJOK, AND JOACHIM ROTERING Memo to the CEO: Is Your Chief Strategy Officer Set Up for Success? strategy+business
  • 2. www.strategy-business.com 2 Paul Leinwand paul.leinwand@pwc.com is global managing director of capabilities-driven strategy and growth for Strategy&, PwC’s strategy consulting group. Based in Chicago, he is a principal with PwC US. Nils Naujok nils.naujok@pwc.com is an advisor to executives in the chemicals and steel industries for Strategy& and specializes in operating model development, supply chain management, and sourcing strategies. He is a partner with PwC Strategy& Germany, based in Berlin. Joachim Rotering joachim.rotering@pwc.com is the global and Europe, Middle East, and Africa leader for Strategy&. Based in Dusseldorf with PwC Strategy& Germany, he specializes in operations, working primarily with clients in the oil, chemicals, and steel industries. When Snap appointed a chief strategy officer (CSO) in 2014, the move was wide- ly noticed — and not just because the owner of the Snapchat messaging app had picked a banker who made his name advising on the massive initial public offering of Alibaba, the Chinese e-commerce group. It was the first time Snap had employed a CSO. The role of the CSO is only a few decades old, but it is growing increasingly popular. Companies large and small continue to create the CSO position. They apparently recognize the value of having a member of the C-suite who is primar- ily oriented to the long-term future of the company. Unlike the CEO, whose day job often focuses on short-term performance, the CSO can, in theory, concentrate on the future. And unlike other C-suite officers such as the chief financial officer, the chief marketing officer, or the chief infor- mation officer — whose points of view are influenced by the sometimes large functions they represent — the CSO can provide an independent perspective. Yet as desirable as the CSO role may be, there are signs that the role has yet to be leveraged to its full potential. In a wide-ranging survey of 187 CSOs around the globe, Strategy&, PwC’s strategy consulting practice, found that only 25 percent of respondents felt they were “very successful” at creating value for their company. And in our ongoing research into the state of strategy, we find that 65 percent of executives across industries don’t think their company has a winning strategy. This tells us that companies need to reexamine how to get the most from this increasingly critical strategic role. They also need to take a hard look at strategy
  • 3. www.strategy-business.com 3 itself. It may have been desirable in the past for companies to employ the long- term planning skills of a senior strategist, but the large number of choices com- panies need to make today and the unprecedented scale of disruptive challenges they now face make it imperative. Indeed, in these turbulent times, companies need to make clear choices on how they are going to compete and win, and that requires building real advan- tage. Just responding in an ad hoc fashion — launching initiative after initiative to seek growth or trying to remain flexible and react to what others are doing — is a clear path to failure. Companies need to reboot the CSO role and strategy itself. The good news is that some CSOs across industries and across regions do get it right. They feel positive about the value they create for their company, they report that their strategic plans are of high quality, and they tell us their compa- nies tend to outperform their peers. And they share a number of characteristics from which we can learn. What Ails the Chief Strategist? Unfortunately, the companies with effective CSOs appear to be in the minority. For the rest, there is a massive gap between the reasons the role was created and what the job typically entails. Indeed, our survey found that 65 percent of CSOs think their priorities aren’t very clear. “The company feels they need a CSO, but they don’t quite know why,” says the head of strategy at one global manufactur- ing company. “And then the CSO feels like they need to make up the role as they go along.” Rather than spending time and energy addressing the fundamental questions of strategy, the CSO typically manages a long list of more tactical areas that fall into what one executive described as “the chief everything-else officer.” Indeed, many CSOs end up being stretched across too many different areas, making it difficult for them to drive the company’s strategy. Many are busy dealing with mergers and acquisitions, restructuring programs, the board agenda, external in- telligence, or various corporate-wide initiatives they may not be well positioned to run. Whether it’s helping drive board documents, executing cost programs,
  • 4. www.strategy-business.com 4 launching incubator businesses, or supporting individual business units, the CSO typically has no shortage of areas in which to help, but lacks the freedom to prioritize the important over the urgent. Adding to the problem is the fact that the CSO role often overlaps with other C-suite positions, such as the cor- porate development officer, the chief growth officer, the chief digital officer, and the chief innovation officer — some of which were introduced after the inven- tion of the CSO role. At a minimum, this overlap can create confusion about who is driving the perspective on some longer-term strategic questions. The environment is not set up for the CSO to live up to the potential of the role. Most companies address strategy through an annual strategic planning process. But that process generally doesn’t help the company address the funda- mentals. Says one CSO at a global consumer packaged goods company, “Our strategic planning process is currently too detailed, at a level that creates argu- ments and discussions that don’t focus on high-level concepts that add value. We need to raise the level at which we have discussions.” This is a widespread issue: Just 26 percent of CSOs in our research, for example, fully agreed that their company’s strategic plan clearly states “how we are going to compete and what is going to make us successful.” And although many top teams seem to be concerned that the company isn’t addressing strategy properly, CSOs report that the same teams spend significant- ly more time discussing operational issues and short-term financial performance than important strategic matters. Small wonder, then, that although almost half (47 percent) of CSOs expect their industry to be significantly disrupted in the next five years, 68 percent admit they need to “get in front and drive change, rather than react to it.” That’s hard to do if the top team isn’t spending time on real strategy. Many CSOs voice frustration over not being systematically involved in stra- tegic discussions, a situation that allows them little room for influencing the many decisions that are being made throughout the company. CSOs don’t feel they have the authority to influence the company’s direction as much as they’d like. In our survey, only 28 percent of CSOs fully agreed that they have a seat at the table equal to those of other senior executives. Almost half don’t meet more than twice a month with their CEO to discuss strategy.
  • 5. www.strategy-business.com 5 It may be that CSOs need to be more proactive in demonstrating the value they can add, or that leadership teams need to stop viewing the CSO as a “ge- nius on demand” — that is, someone who will always be available on an ad hoc basis for reactive insight — or both. Because, as we know from the way the role was conceived, and how it must be used today, the CSO needs to be empowered to drive the strategic agenda with a proper seat at the table. Three Ways to Unlock the Full Potential of the CSO We have compared the survey responses of CSOs who report being very success- ful at creating value for their companies with those of their less successful peers, and distilled three recommendations for ensuring the CSO is set up for success. 1. Put strategy at the forefront of the executive agenda. Prioritizing strategy allows the company to make the big choices that shape its future and command a sustainable competitive advantage. And the CEO needs to hold the CSO ac- countable to work with the executive team to develop answers to the fundamen- tal strategic questions that all companies need to address. There are two powerful tools that a CSO can use to stretch the top team’s thinking beyond the here and now. The first is to imagine together what a new competitor would do if it entered this industry: What value would it create? What customer experience would it offer? What technologies would it use? The top team will gain new insights into similar technologies and processes they may want to use, and into how they could use some of their own advantages to win against this type of competitor. 65 percent of chief strategy officers feel their priorities aren’t very clear. “The company feels they need a CSO, but they don’t quite know why,” says the head of strategy at one global manufacturing company.
  • 6. www.strategy-business.com 6 The second tool is to turn that same scrutiny on their own company. In our work, we call this the “coherence test.” It requires asking questions about how the value proposition, capabilities system, and product and service lineup all fit together. For example: Are you investing in the areas that really matter to your value proposition (the promises you make to customers)? Can you articulate the three to six capabilities that deliver on that value proposition? Have you defined how those capabilities work together in a system? Do most or all of your prod- ucts and services fit with that capabilities system? Is it reinforced by your perfor- mance management system, your other incentives and KPIs, and your practic- es? Do you understand how to leverage your capabilities in new or unexpected arenas? And does everyone in the organization understand how the company is distinctive? In addition to ensuring that strategic questions get a prominent place on the top team agenda, the CSO should build in mechanisms to hold the company accountable for its strategy, for example, by getting regular input from key man- agers across the organization on the critical issues the company faces, and by defining clear metrics that help measure progress. 2. Make the strategic planning process more effective. Many strategy process- es focus too closely on short- to medium-term functional and operational issues. They neglect important stakeholders, do not respond well to a highly dynamic business environment, and are overly bureaucratic and cumbersome. To avoid these traps — and to make strategic planning truly strategic — the CSO should aim to do the following. • Decouple, then relink the strategic planning and budgeting processes. First separate them, then bring them back together, making sure that the strategic plan feeds into the budgeting process but is not dominated by it. • Focus the scope of the strategic planning process on the few key strategic questions that need to be answered, rather than doing comprehensive bottom-up planning. • Improve inputs to encompass a broader set of external stakeholders — not just customers, but also ecosystem partners, technology think tanks, and oth- ers. Use artificial intelligence to identify patterns, generate ideas that contribute to some of the key strategic questions identified, and improve the efficiency of
  • 7. www.strategy-business.com 7 data collection and analysis. Continually monitor the environment — includ- ing social media data — for early signs of business opportunity and potential disruption. • Improve engagement to make strategic planning an experience rather than an exercise of filling in templates. Use storytelling, workshops, “immersive vi- sualization” sessions, social platforms, strategic simulations, and other tools to create a real dialogue and transform the presentation of strategy into something dynamic, engaging, and tangible in order to bring the best ideas to life. • Hold the organization accountable by measuring the company’s progress in addressing its most important strategic questions. Keep some of the key strate- gic questions the same each year, and put in place a periodic check-in, such as an annual employee survey about strategy. 3. Clarify the CSO’s role and priorities. There’s no doubt companies should want the CSO to shape the company’s strategic direction and make sure that all the leadership team’s major decisions are in line with that strategic agenda. But different companies will have different operational and institutional needs, and the CSO might be called on to add other roles for a limited period of time — for instance, manager of a cost transformation program. In such cases, however, the CEO will need to ensure that these roles are undertaken not at the expense of addressing the company’s strategy, but rather in addition to it. CSOs will find there are different ways to drive the company’s strategic agenda. It helps to be aware of those paths and have an open discussion with the leadership team about which is the right one, given the company’s needs and
  • 8. www.strategy-business.com 8 culture, as well as the CSO’s strengths and personality. These approaches might include playing the following roles. • Truth teller — providing objective insights about strategic challenges in the business and economic environment • Challenger — constantly pushing the organization and presenting ideas leaders might not otherwise consider • Change agent — supporting the organization in achieving its strategic ob- jectives by helping design and implement large transformation programs • Advantage guardian — identifying, securing, and promoting the key ca- pabilities that help differentiate the organization • Facilitator — providing guidance and facilitating strategic thinking across business units or departments • Outsource provider — getting work done for people and helping them solve their biggest problems Executive teams know that their company’s future relies on making the right big choices. But most are also painfully aware that the company’s governance, management structure, and culture don’t facilitate the tough discussions needed to place the right big bets. It’s this exact challenge that the CSO, as an independent insider at the side of the CEO, is uniquely positioned to address. Companies may have used their CSO for many other things in the past — which is understandable given the broad skill set many CSOs have — but it’s time now to have the CSO focus on the fundamental questions of strategy and the most significant opportunities presented to the company. It’s up to the executive team, and especially the CEO, to ensure the CSO is set up to do the job. And it’s up to the CSO to hold every- one else accountable. +
  • 9. strategy+business magazine is published by certain member firms of the PwC network. To subscribe, visit strategy-business.com or call 1-855-869-4862. • strategy-business.com • facebook.com/strategybusiness • linkedin.com/company/strategy-business • twitter.com/stratandbiz Articles published in strategy+business do not necessarily represent the views of the member firms of the PwC network. Reviews and mentions of publications, products, or services do not constitute endorsement or recommendation for purchase. © 2019 PwC. All rights reserved. PwC refers to the PwC network and/or one or more of its member firms, each of which is a separate legal entity. Please see www.pwc.com/structure for further details. Mentions of Strategy& refer to the global team of practical strategists that is integrated within the PwC network of firms. For more about Strategy&, see www.strategyand.pwc.com. No reproduction is permitted in whole or part without written permission of PwC. “strategy+business” is a trademark of PwC.