SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 56
Download to read offline
Net neutrality:
days of future past?
Thomas Lohninger | Initiative für Netzfreiheit
Rejo Zenger | Bits of Freedom
Thomas Lohninger Rejo Zenger
Remember
Ordinary citizens put net neutrality on
the political agenda before.
We need to do that again.
Remember
There are unsolved issues and civil
society needs your expertise.
“Net neutrality requires that the
internet be maintained as an open
platform, on which network providers
treat all content, applications and
services equally, without
discrimination.”
thisisnetneutrality.org
Three principles
●End to end
●Best effort
●Vertical intregration
“The [article] aims to maximise choice
and freedom of expression on the
internet for end users.”
explanatory memorandum Telecommunications Act
“End-users should be able to decide
what content they want to send and
receive [...]”
explanatory memorandum Telecommunications Act
“Providers of [internet access
services] do not hinder or slow down
applications and services on the
internet, unless [...]”
Telecommunications Act
“a) to minimize the effects of
congestion, whereby equal types of
traffic should be treated equally”
Telecommunications Act
“b) to preserve the integrity and
security of the network and service [...]
or the customer premises equipment”
Telecommunications Act
“Providers [...] do not make the price
[...] dependent on the services and
applications which are offered or used
[...].”
Telecommunications Act
So, how does that compare?
sources (mostly unofficial translation):
http://is.gd/lt9lS4 and Global Net Neutrality Coalition
Specialised Services
Managed Services
sources (mostly unofficial translation):
http://is.gd/lt9lS4 and Global Net Neutrality Coalition
.eu
Campaign facts
●40.374 faxes send (21.794 delivered)
●translated in 9 languages
●266 git commits from 12 contributors
Making the speeches talk
Vote in European
Parliament● Adopted with S&D, ALDE,
Greens and GUE
● We got real net neutrality!
● Text is still not perfect
● And enforcement is weak
source: edri.org, accessnow.org, netzpolitik.org and others
Summary
● Their goal: market consolidation
● We suck at the Council
● National fallbacks are necessary
The Dutch Experience [tm]
“[The NRA] believes that in this case
[...] blocking and delaying services that
require a large capacity, is necessary
to minimize the effects of congestion
on mobile connection.”
Dutch NRA to Dutch Railways and T-Mobile
“Vodafone will end this violation by
offering the Sizz-app as a seperate
service, which can be used
independent to the internet access
service.”
Dutch NRA to Vodafone and RTL
Open debates
Wikipedia Zero
Letter from Wikimedia to Chile
“Imagine a world in which every single
human being can freely share the sum
of all knowledge. That is our
commitment.”
Wikimedia Foundation Vision Statement
Remember
Ordinary citizens put net neutrality on
the political agenda before.
We need to do that again.
Support digital civil rights
Remember
There are unsolved issues and civil
society needs your expertise.
Day 3 | 17:00 | Noise Square
Net neutrality: what about
interconnect?
Now: question
everything.
Thomas Lohninger | thomas.lohninger@netzfreiheit.org
Rejo Zenger | rejo.zenger@bof.nl

More Related Content

What's hot

Net Neutrality
Net NeutralityNet Neutrality
Net NeutralitySourav Dey
 
Net Nutrality
Net NutralityNet Nutrality
Net NutralityJay Patel
 
Net Neutrality Divy
Net Neutrality DivyNet Neutrality Divy
Net Neutrality DivyDivy Sharma
 
NET NEUTRALITY
NET NEUTRALITYNET NEUTRALITY
NET NEUTRALITYMavis Osei
 
TRAI Net Neutrality Consultation
TRAI Net Neutrality ConsultationTRAI Net Neutrality Consultation
TRAI Net Neutrality ConsultationAPNIC
 
Net Neutrality, Internet Freedom
Net Neutrality, Internet FreedomNet Neutrality, Internet Freedom
Net Neutrality, Internet FreedomDina Grimes
 
Mac309 Network Effect: Net Neutrality
Mac309 Network Effect: Net NeutralityMac309 Network Effect: Net Neutrality
Mac309 Network Effect: Net NeutralityRob Jewitt
 
CGI 20Years Net Neutrality Marsden
CGI 20Years Net Neutrality MarsdenCGI 20Years Net Neutrality Marsden
CGI 20Years Net Neutrality MarsdenChris Marsden
 
Final presentation: Net Neutrality
Final presentation: Net NeutralityFinal presentation: Net Neutrality
Final presentation: Net NeutralityJoey Dweck
 
Net Neutrality Complete
Net Neutrality CompleteNet Neutrality Complete
Net Neutrality CompleteSiddhartha Rao
 
Net Neutrality discussion
Net Neutrality discussionNet Neutrality discussion
Net Neutrality discussionUoS
 
Net Neutrality Capacity Building Seminar
Net Neutrality Capacity Building SeminarNet Neutrality Capacity Building Seminar
Net Neutrality Capacity Building SeminarExcel Asama
 
Net Neutrality in INDIA
Net Neutrality in INDIANet Neutrality in INDIA
Net Neutrality in INDIAPankil Shah
 
Net neutrality explained
Net neutrality explainedNet neutrality explained
Net neutrality explainedGrant Wright
 

What's hot (20)

Net Neutrality
Net NeutralityNet Neutrality
Net Neutrality
 
Net neutrality
Net neutralityNet neutrality
Net neutrality
 
Net Nutrality
Net NutralityNet Nutrality
Net Nutrality
 
NET NEUTRALITY final
NET NEUTRALITY finalNET NEUTRALITY final
NET NEUTRALITY final
 
Net Neutrality Divy
Net Neutrality DivyNet Neutrality Divy
Net Neutrality Divy
 
Net neutrality
Net neutralityNet neutrality
Net neutrality
 
NET NEUTRALITY
NET NEUTRALITYNET NEUTRALITY
NET NEUTRALITY
 
TRAI Net Neutrality Consultation
TRAI Net Neutrality ConsultationTRAI Net Neutrality Consultation
TRAI Net Neutrality Consultation
 
Net neutrality
Net neutralityNet neutrality
Net neutrality
 
Net Neutrality
Net NeutralityNet Neutrality
Net Neutrality
 
Net Neutrality, Internet Freedom
Net Neutrality, Internet FreedomNet Neutrality, Internet Freedom
Net Neutrality, Internet Freedom
 
Mac309 Network Effect: Net Neutrality
Mac309 Network Effect: Net NeutralityMac309 Network Effect: Net Neutrality
Mac309 Network Effect: Net Neutrality
 
CGI 20Years Net Neutrality Marsden
CGI 20Years Net Neutrality MarsdenCGI 20Years Net Neutrality Marsden
CGI 20Years Net Neutrality Marsden
 
Final presentation: Net Neutrality
Final presentation: Net NeutralityFinal presentation: Net Neutrality
Final presentation: Net Neutrality
 
Net Neutrality
Net Neutrality Net Neutrality
Net Neutrality
 
Net Neutrality Complete
Net Neutrality CompleteNet Neutrality Complete
Net Neutrality Complete
 
Net Neutrality discussion
Net Neutrality discussionNet Neutrality discussion
Net Neutrality discussion
 
Net Neutrality Capacity Building Seminar
Net Neutrality Capacity Building SeminarNet Neutrality Capacity Building Seminar
Net Neutrality Capacity Building Seminar
 
Net Neutrality in INDIA
Net Neutrality in INDIANet Neutrality in INDIA
Net Neutrality in INDIA
 
Net neutrality explained
Net neutrality explainedNet neutrality explained
Net neutrality explained
 

Similar to #31c3 net neutrality: days of future past

Network Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to information
Network Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to informationNetwork Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to information
Network Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to informationŚrodkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Net neutrality by Mitesh Kumar
Net neutrality by Mitesh KumarNet neutrality by Mitesh Kumar
Net neutrality by Mitesh KumarMitesh Kumar
 
Network Neutrality Policy Summary
Network Neutrality Policy SummaryNetwork Neutrality Policy Summary
Network Neutrality Policy SummaryKim Moore
 
Net neutrality & it’s legal issues
Net neutrality & it’s legal issuesNet neutrality & it’s legal issues
Net neutrality & it’s legal issuesmruns_96
 
ID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan Siber
ID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan SiberID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan Siber
ID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan SiberIGF Indonesia
 
Unit 2 Regulation of Cyberspace
Unit 2 Regulation of CyberspaceUnit 2 Regulation of Cyberspace
Unit 2 Regulation of CyberspaceTushar Rajput
 
Key Note Presentation - Jani Makraduli
Key Note Presentation - Jani MakraduliKey Note Presentation - Jani Makraduli
Key Note Presentation - Jani Makradulie-Democracy Conference
 
[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makraduli
[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makraduli[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makraduli
[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makradulie-Democracy Conference
 
seoul-declaration
seoul-declarationseoul-declaration
seoul-declarationmaolins
 
20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)
20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)
20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)Tom Lyons
 
Indonesia ina018 1366698387
Indonesia ina018 1366698387Indonesia ina018 1366698387
Indonesia ina018 1366698387Nurul Yakin
 
Taking A Look At Net Neutrality
Taking A Look At Net NeutralityTaking A Look At Net Neutrality
Taking A Look At Net NeutralityRochelle Schear
 
seoul-declaration
seoul-declarationseoul-declaration
seoul-declarationmaolins
 
CTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security Minister
CTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security MinisterCTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security Minister
CTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security Ministersegughana
 

Similar to #31c3 net neutrality: days of future past (20)

Network Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to information
Network Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to informationNetwork Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to information
Network Neutrality: Potential impact on free speech and the right to information
 
Net neutrality by Mitesh Kumar
Net neutrality by Mitesh KumarNet neutrality by Mitesh Kumar
Net neutrality by Mitesh Kumar
 
Network Neutrality Policy Summary
Network Neutrality Policy SummaryNetwork Neutrality Policy Summary
Network Neutrality Policy Summary
 
Net neutrality & it’s legal issues
Net neutrality & it’s legal issuesNet neutrality & it’s legal issues
Net neutrality & it’s legal issues
 
ID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan Siber
ID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan SiberID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan Siber
ID IGF 2016 - Hukum 3 - Peran Negara dalam Kedaulatan Siber
 
6.bocconi rights
6.bocconi rights6.bocconi rights
6.bocconi rights
 
Unit 2 Regulation of Cyberspace
Unit 2 Regulation of CyberspaceUnit 2 Regulation of Cyberspace
Unit 2 Regulation of Cyberspace
 
Savannah Smith
Savannah Smith Savannah Smith
Savannah Smith
 
Key Note Presentation - Jani Makraduli
Key Note Presentation - Jani MakraduliKey Note Presentation - Jani Makraduli
Key Note Presentation - Jani Makraduli
 
[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makraduli
[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makraduli[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makraduli
[2010] Key Note Presentation - by Jani Makraduli
 
Cr4 tpp fgv
Cr4 tpp fgvCr4 tpp fgv
Cr4 tpp fgv
 
Cr4 tpp leesburg2012
Cr4 tpp leesburg2012Cr4 tpp leesburg2012
Cr4 tpp leesburg2012
 
seoul-declaration
seoul-declarationseoul-declaration
seoul-declaration
 
20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)
20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)
20190626 eu blockchain_how europe supports blockcahcin (cv conference) (1)
 
Indonesia ina018 1366698387
Indonesia ina018 1366698387Indonesia ina018 1366698387
Indonesia ina018 1366698387
 
Cr4 tpp aucklan2012_edit
Cr4 tpp aucklan2012_editCr4 tpp aucklan2012_edit
Cr4 tpp aucklan2012_edit
 
Taking A Look At Net Neutrality
Taking A Look At Net NeutralityTaking A Look At Net Neutrality
Taking A Look At Net Neutrality
 
sylviane toporkoff one conference prague 2013
sylviane toporkoff one conference  prague 2013sylviane toporkoff one conference  prague 2013
sylviane toporkoff one conference prague 2013
 
seoul-declaration
seoul-declarationseoul-declaration
seoul-declaration
 
CTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security Minister
CTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security MinisterCTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security Minister
CTO Cyber Security Conference Key Note Address by UK Security Minister
 

More from Thomas Lohninger

Austrian NetzDG / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law
Austrian NetzDG  / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law Austrian NetzDG  / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law
Austrian NetzDG / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law Thomas Lohninger
 
Colombia Zero-Rating in the EU
Colombia Zero-Rating in the EUColombia Zero-Rating in the EU
Colombia Zero-Rating in the EUThomas Lohninger
 
[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coin
[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coin[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coin
[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coinThomas Lohninger
 
34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...
34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...
34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...Thomas Lohninger
 
np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump
np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump
np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump Thomas Lohninger
 
#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...
#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...
#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...Thomas Lohninger
 
#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der Datenberge
#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der Datenberge#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der Datenberge
#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der DatenbergeThomas Lohninger
 
Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?
Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?
Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?Thomas Lohninger
 
Why Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of Speech
Why Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of SpeechWhy Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of Speech
Why Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of SpeechThomas Lohninger
 
32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte Massenüberwachung
32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte Massenüberwachung32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte Massenüberwachung
32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte MassenüberwachungThomas Lohninger
 
winning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rights
winning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rightswinning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rights
winning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rightsThomas Lohninger
 
1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und Staatsschutzgesetz
1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und Staatsschutzgesetz1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und Staatsschutzgesetz
1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und StaatsschutzgesetzThomas Lohninger
 
Netzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im Internet
Netzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im InternetNetzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im Internet
Netzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im InternetThomas Lohninger
 
Netzneutralität – Endspurt in Europa
Netzneutralität – Endspurt in EuropaNetzneutralität – Endspurt in Europa
Netzneutralität – Endspurt in EuropaThomas Lohninger
 
G’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-Überwachung
G’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-ÜberwachungG’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-Überwachung
G’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-ÜberwachungThomas Lohninger
 
SCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITY
SCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITYSCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITY
SCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITYThomas Lohninger
 
31c3 "Framing Data Retention"
31c3 "Framing Data Retention"31c3 "Framing Data Retention"
31c3 "Framing Data Retention"Thomas Lohninger
 
10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur Netzneutralität
10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur Netzneutralität10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur Netzneutralität
10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur NetzneutralitätThomas Lohninger
 
Netzpolitik fh st-pölten
Netzpolitik fh st-pöltenNetzpolitik fh st-pölten
Netzpolitik fh st-pöltenThomas Lohninger
 

More from Thomas Lohninger (20)

Austrian NetzDG / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law
Austrian NetzDG  / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law Austrian NetzDG  / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law
Austrian NetzDG / KoPlG / anti-hate speech law
 
Colombia Zero-Rating in the EU
Colombia Zero-Rating in the EUColombia Zero-Rating in the EU
Colombia Zero-Rating in the EU
 
[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coin
[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coin[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coin
[Open Source Lisbon] Innovation and Net Neutrality two sides of one coin
 
34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...
34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...
34c3: Die Sprache der Überwacher Wie in Österreich über Sicherheit und Überwa...
 
np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump
np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump
np13 – Netzneutralität: Von StreamOn zu Trump
 
#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...
#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...
#33c3: Make the Internet Neutral Again Let's put the new EU Net Neutrality ru...
 
#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der Datenberge
#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der Datenberge#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der Datenberge
#33c3: Netzpolitik in Österreich Ein Jahresrückblick aus dem Land der Datenberge
 
Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?
Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?
Was hat Netzneutralität mit Baden-Württemberg zu tun?
 
Why Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of Speech
Why Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of SpeechWhy Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of Speech
Why Net Neutrality matters for Freedom of Speech
 
32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte Massenüberwachung
32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte Massenüberwachung32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte Massenüberwachung
32c3: AKVorrat Österreich – Der Kampf gegen unkontrollierte Massenüberwachung
 
winning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rights
winning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rightswinning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rights
winning battles while losing ground - asymmetric campaigning for digital rights
 
1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und Staatsschutzgesetz
1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und Staatsschutzgesetz1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und Staatsschutzgesetz
1. Netzpolitischer Abend Wien Netzneutralität und Staatsschutzgesetz
 
Netzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im Internet
Netzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im InternetNetzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im Internet
Netzpolitik - Die Machtfrage im Internet
 
Netzneutralität – Endspurt in Europa
Netzneutralität – Endspurt in EuropaNetzneutralität – Endspurt in Europa
Netzneutralität – Endspurt in Europa
 
G’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-Überwachung
G’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-ÜberwachungG’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-Überwachung
G’schichten aus Österreich: Über den Kampf gegen Massen-Überwachung
 
SCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITY
SCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITYSCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITY
SCHROEDINGER’S NET NEUTRALITY
 
31c3 "Framing Data Retention"
31c3 "Framing Data Retention"31c3 "Framing Data Retention"
31c3 "Framing Data Retention"
 
10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur Netzneutralität
10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur Netzneutralität10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur Netzneutralität
10 Jahre Netzpolitik - Ein Update zur Netzneutralität
 
Cccamp14 nn-post tsm
Cccamp14 nn-post tsmCccamp14 nn-post tsm
Cccamp14 nn-post tsm
 
Netzpolitik fh st-pölten
Netzpolitik fh st-pöltenNetzpolitik fh st-pölten
Netzpolitik fh st-pölten
 

#31c3 net neutrality: days of future past