Skip to main content
A case for analog thinking in the age of AI
S‌
o‌
u‌
l Searching
LOU CIMAGLIA
UXPA 2026
LOU CIMAGLIA
Boston MA | UX Content Strategist | Nearsighted
LOU CIMAGLIA
Exhausting | Asking a lot already | Nearsighted
People your age just don’t get it.
You’re not prepared.
84
Organizations increasing their AI investment
Deloitte's State of AI in the Enterprise report – January 2026
%
78
Leaders expressing higher confidence in AI
Deloitte's State of AI in the Enterprise report – January 2026
%
65
Americans who report using AI weekly
Edison Research, May 2026
%
54
Students using AI for “assistance with school tasks”
Pew Research, February 2026
%
$300 BILLION
Cost to put a man on the moon
Adjusted for 2026 inflation
$700 BILLION
Projected AI infrastructure spend by end of 2026
TechCrunch, February 2026
We’ve gone from rough idea to working
prototype before anyone leaves the room...
What used to take a week……now happens
in a single conversation.
– Product Manager, DataDog
Compile UX research
Create personas
Competitive analysis
Prototyping
Content brainstorm
Governance and gap analysis
The
The
EAGERADOPTER
EAGERADOPTER
“AI is the future, and the future is now.”
The
The
CAUTIOUSLYCURIOUS
CAUTIOUSLYCURIOUS
“I’m skeptical, but I don’t want to fall behind.”
The
The
MORALLYOPPOSED
MORALLYOPPOSED
“...and for that reason, I’m out.”
The
The
DOOMSAYER
DOOMSAYER
“Respectfully, we are so cooked.”
An uncanny resemblance.
...overly nostalgic...
You’re not fun to talk to about this stuff.
– Lou’s Wife
Digital technology….is good medicine for an ailing
society. TV has given us government by image;
interactivity will return power to the people.
Top-down programming has isolated us;
bottom-up networks will reunite us.
– Johnathan Franzen, 1995
Content marketing executive
– UX Principal
AI is a tool to help me do things more efficiently.
– Content strategist
It’s been helpful in the research and
discovery phase. Good for refining tone
and generating ideas.
– UX Principal
I swing between hopeful and existential dread.
– UX Principal
Companies want to implement AI but
can’t seem to articulate how or exactly
what results they’re wanting.
Thinking
process
AI in the...
Take that, The Road
UX
process
AI in the...
The customer experience
Wireframes
Research
Content strategy
Accessibility
Behavioral science
Governance
Information architecture
Problem statements
Customer
experience
AI in the...
We have no idea
where AI is taking UX
Before we continue...
WHAT IS ANALOG THINKING?
Trying to make sense of something new by
searching for lessons from something old.
Stepping away from AI and taking a deep breath.
Touching grass, as the kids say.
Life Is A Carnival
Roll ‘em down and turn it up: it’s the UX mixtape
Breakdown
EDITORIAL
DISCIPLINE
(Or, resisting the temptation to
overdo it, and what happens if we do)
Analog skill #1
Not everything can make it on the tape
AI tutors for students
AI grading for teachers
AI scribes for ambulance reports
AI care for chronic lung disease
AI for social facilitation
AI for the physical world
We’ve got a
trust problem.
Side B:
AI is showing up everywhere.
Whether it should or not.
Side A:
AI tutors for students
AI grading for teachers
AI scribes for ambulance reports
AI care for chronic lung disease
AI for social facilitation
AI for the physical world
– Paul Graham, CEO,
Y Combinator
It feels like being lied to, and who would
stand for that?
TRUST, BY THE NUMBERS
76% of Americans believe they can trust AI-generated
information only some of the time or hardly ever.
A June 2025 survey indicated that
half of U.S. adults are more
concerned than excited about AI.
AI has a net negative
20 favorability rating.
I Don’t Wanna Lie
Because there’s no set definition
of AI, one breakdown somewhere
hurts trust in AI everywhere.
Hitting pause:
The
The
BLOATRISK
BLOATRISK
When the buffet table looks a little too good.
Do we care if we
recognize AI?
Flip the deck:
YOU GOT YOUR AI IN MY PEANUT BUTTER!
89% of people said they’d prefer speaking with a real
person when contacting a healthcare provider.
75% of consumers said they’ve
received a fast AI response and still
felt frustrated.
29% said talking to AI is their
most frustrating service
experience. (Forbes)
Just As Strange
I talked to employers who were frustrated
when they realized students were trying to
consult ChatGPT during an interview.
– University administrator
The recruiter would take really long pauses after I
answered a question.
He said, ‘sorry, just validating your answer with ChatGPT.
Looks like it agrees with you.’
Iendedtheinterview.
– Senior Marketing Director
How does UX make sure
we aren’t building AI just
for the sake of AI?
Hitting pause:
WHAT IS THIN SLICING?
Listen to someone speak for 5 seconds.
The sociological principle that trained observation of
someone’s body language, tone, intonation, etc., can
generate insights that might contradict what was
actually said.
Conversation mining
Listen for the spaces between the notes
Power to the People
Into the Great Wide Open
A new UX ceremony
Listen to call center recordings and
user interviews regularly
Foster a culture of empathy through
qualitative storytelling.
Make real voices the star of your
research and product decisions
PRACTICING RESTRAINT
Institute a culture of consistent feedback
from real customers.
Keep a running “Futures File” for your team.
Schedule quarterly meetings, or more
often, possibly, to discuss the ideas that
the team has been slowly logging.
Lessons from the editor’s desk
What UX should do
Musta Got Lost
I'm mad. This makes me angry. I'm angry,
and I'm mad. I feel injured. Betrayed. Like a
sacred trust has been violated ... People are
having anxiety headaches. They've been
placed in a distressed state.
– Washington Post interview,
1985
We don’t want to stray
from what works. But how
can we stand out?
Flip the tape:
I Fought The Law
INTELLIGENT
DISOBEDIENCE
(Or, how UX Moneyballed itself,
and what we should do to fix it)
Analog skill #2
Learn the rules, then break ‘em
Intelligent disobedience
Intelligent disobedience
Intelligent disobedience
Intelligent disobedience
Intelligent disobedience
Everything already looks the same.
In 5 years, I don’t know how we’ll even
be able to tell anything apart.
– Senior Creative Director, UX
I don’t know if a digital experience
should be memorable.
– UX Director
Working with UX used to feel like
working with the creative department.
Now it feels like working with the
creative police.
– Senior Director, Product Owner
The
The
CURSEOFKNOWLEDGE
CURSEOFKNOWLEDGE
No one likes inside baseball. At this point, no one likes regular baseball.
The
The
ENDOWMENTEFFECT
ENDOWMENTEFFECT
The reason you haggle at yard sales.
Intelligent disobedience
RECONSIDER BEFORE DEFAULTING TO PAST PATTERNS
In UIs, and in our UX process - show, don’t tell.
AI will allow us to create interactive tools, calculators,
and experiences. Spend less time lecturing.
We’re not debating hamburger menus. We’re
debating the strategy.
– Jared Wrobleski
Instead of starting with nothing, AI can generate
something for people to edit. Let them refine, not
create from scratch.
They learn by seeing what's possible, by
modifying, by doing.