SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 14
Toll Free: 877.880.4477
Phone: 281.880.6525
www.hrp.net
Tax Court Cautionary Tale:
Classifying Workers as Contractors
www.hrp.net
The issue of whether workers should be classified as employees or
independent contractors for federal employment tax purposes has been a
source of controversy for decades. The saga continues. This article
summarizes a recent Tax Court decision on the classification of a manager in
the home care industry.
»
Note: To make things more understandable, we will call businesses that hire
workers "employers" (whether the workers are employees or independent
contractors), and we will call the individuals who get the job done
"workers" (whether they are employees or independent contractors).
Seven Factors to Decide Worker Classification
www.hrp.net
The Tax Court considers these factors when
deciding whether workers should be classified as
independent contractors or employees for federal
employment tax purposes:
11 Degree of Control. When an employer exercises significant control over
how a worker performs duties or has the right to do so, this factor indicates
employee status. When there's little or no control or right to exercise it,
this factor indicates independent contractor status.
Based on longstanding tradition, this factor is considered the most
important. So, it's often used as the tie-breaker in situations where there
are an equal number of factors on both sides.
www.hrp.net
22 Investment in Equipment and Facilities. When the worker covers most or all
of the cost of equipment and facilities used for the job, this factor indicates
independent contractor status. For example, say the worker performs his
duties out of an office in his home using equipment (computer, printer and
phone) that he pays for himself. In such a case, this factor would clearly
indicate independent contractor status. On the other hand, if the employer
provides most or all of the equipment and facilities, this factor would indicate
employee status.
33 Whether Worker Has Opportunity for Open-Ended Profit or Outright Loss. A
worker who can make an open-ended profit through the strength of his or her
own efforts or, alternatively, suffer an outright loss on the job, is likely to be an
independent contractor rather than an employee. For example, this would be
the case when an outside sales person is paid by commission only.
On the other hand, when the compensation arrangement dictates that the
worker can only make a fixed profit and not suffer a loss, it indicates employee
status. For example, this would be the case when the worker is paid a fixed
amount for each day of work and the only significant job-related expense is
the cost of commuting to and from the work site.
www.hrp.net
44 Whether Worker Can Be Discharged. A worker who can be discharged is
more likely to be an employee than an independent contractor.
55 Whether Work Is Related to Employer's Core Business. When the worker's
duties relate to the employer's core business it indicates employee status,
while work related to a tangential enterprise indicates independent
contractor status.
55 Permanency of Relationship between Employer and Worker. Lack of
permanency indicates independent contractor status while permanency
indicates employee status.
55 Relationship Employer and Worker Believed they Were Creating. If the
employer and the worker believed the same thing at the time they entered
into their arrangement, courts rule this factor can indicate either employee
or independent contractor status, depending on the facts. If the parties
believed two different things, this factor may be thrown out.
Why Worker Classification Matters
When a worker is properly classified as a common-law employee, the
employer generally must withhold from the worker's wages:
www.hrp.net
• Federal income tax (FIT), and
• The employee's portion of the Social Security and Medicare taxes
(FICA tax).
The employer must also pay the employer's portion of the Social Security and
Medicare taxes, pay federal unemployment tax (FUTA), file federal payroll tax
returns, and comply with various IRS and Department of Labor (DOL) rules
and regulations.
www.hrp.net
In addition, the employer may have to deal with state and local income tax
withholding, pay state unemployment and Workers' Compensation taxes,
and comply with even more local rules and regulations. Handling all of this
red tape can cost a bundle every year for each employee. If employee
benefits -- such as health insurance, paid vacations, and sick leave -- are also
provided, the cost of keeping a common-law employee on the payroll can
become prohibitive.
In contrast, when a worker is properly classified as an independent
contractor, the employer must simply provide the worker and the IRS with a
Form 1099-MISC each year to report how much the worker was paid. That's
why many businesses prefer to treat as many workers as possible as
independent contractors instead of employees.
Common-Law Employee vs. Independent Contractor
Common-law employees are workers considered to be employees (as
opposed to independent contractors) based on various statutes, regulations
and court decisions. IRS and DOL rules can differ from state and local rules.
That said, if an employer is allowed to treat a worker as an independent
contractor under IRS rules, it will generally be the same across the board.
Therefore, this article only discusses the IRS rules.
Properly classifying a worker as an independent contractor is beneficial
because the employer doesn't have to worry about employment tax issues or
provide expensive fringe benefits.
However, when an employer mistakenly treats an employee as an
independent contractor, the employer could owe unpaid employment taxes,
as well as interest and penalties. The employer also may be liable for
employee benefits that should have been provided but were not. So, it's
important to get worker classification questions right.
www.hrp.net
Facts of the Recent Tax Court Case
In its recent decision, the Tax Court used seven factors (see right-hand box)
to evaluate whether a worker who provided home care services to disabled
clients was an employee. The taxpayer in this case, Atig Rahman, was hired
by Ever Care Adult Care Services, which provides home and other care
services to disabled adults. The taxpayer was quickly promoted to manager of
a group home, where he worked about 40 hours per week and was paid at an
hourly rate every two weeks.
www.hrp.net
www.hrp.net
Ever Care dictated the taxpayer's duties and responsibilities, which included
preparing a monthly financial forecast, hiring and firing staff, scheduling staff
hours, meeting with officials from the Florida state licensing agency,
maintaining and repairing the facilities, buying groceries for the home,
assisting residents with personal grooming, and arranging transportation for
residents. The taxpayer also met weekly with the owner regarding grocery
purchases and gave the owner daily status reports.
Although Ever Care treated the taxpayer as a self-employed independent
contractor and issued him a Form 1099-MISC, he did not pay any self-
employment (SE) tax for the year in question. After an audit, the IRS claimed
he was an independent contractor and issued an assessment for
unpaid SE tax.
Tax Court Decision
The Tax Court analyzed these seven factors and found that none of them
supported the self-employed independent contractor status:
www.hrp.net
1. Specifically enumerating his duties and responsibilities,
2. Specifying when and where his duties were to be performed, and
3. Requiring frequent reports to the owner.
Investment in Equipment and Facilities. The taxpayer did not provide his
own equipment or facilities.
Opportunity for Profit or Loss. Ever Care paid the taxpayer at an hourly rate,
so he had no open-ended opportunity for profit or loss.
Degree of Control. The Tax Court found that Ever Care had the right to
control the taxpayer's work and did in fact exercise a high degree of control
by:
Right to Discharge. Ever Care retained the right to discharge the taxpayer and
did, in fact, discharge him the following year.
www.hrp.net
Work Related to Core Business. The work performed by the taxpayer was an
integral part of Ever Care's core business of providing home care and other
services to adults with disabilities.
Permanency of Relationship. The taxpayer worked full-time for Ever Care for
approximately nine months, at which point he was discharged. While it
lasted, the relationship between Ever Care and the taxpayer was not thought
to be temporary or short-term by either party.
Relationship the Parties Believed they Were Creating. Ever Care treated the
taxpayer as a self-employed independent contractor by issuing him a Form
1099-MISC and not withholding taxes from his pay. While this indicated that
Ever Care intended for the taxpayer to be an independent contractor, this
intention was self-serving because it allowed Ever Care to avoid paying
employment taxes on his compensation and benefits.
Because all but the last factor weighed in favor of the taxpayer being a common-law
employee, the Tax Court ruled that he did not owe self-employment tax because he was not a
self-employed independent contractor (Atig Rahman, T.C. Summary Opinion 2014-35).
Bottom Line
While the Rahman decision was in favor of the taxpayer (worker), it opened
the door for the IRS to go after Ever Care (the employer) for unpaid federal
employment taxes, interest, and penalties. Therefore, the decision is yet
another cautionary tale that failure to properly classify workers can be an
expensive mistake for employers. In many cases, proactive planning can lock
in tax-saving independent contractor status for workers.
But, if nothing is done before an IRS audit takes place, it may be too late to
achieve the desired tax-saving results. Consult your payroll and tax advisers if
you have questions about worker classification issues.
www.hrp.net
14550 Torrey Chase Blvd., Ste. 360 Houston, TX 77014 USA
www.hrp.net
E-mail : info@hrp.net
Toll Free
Phone
Fax
:
:
:
877.880.4477
281.880.6525
281.866.9426

More Related Content

What's hot

ACC Docket Article July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...
ACC Docket Article  July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...ACC Docket Article  July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...
ACC Docket Article July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...
martinvisalaw
 
Independent contractor or common law employee 2013
Independent contractor or common law employee   2013Independent contractor or common law employee   2013
Independent contractor or common law employee 2013
lukem
 
BHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law Newsletter
BHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law NewsletterBHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law Newsletter
BHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law Newsletter
BHWSolicitors
 

What's hot (20)

Startup Your Startup: Tips and Tricks for Founders at the Starting Line
Startup Your Startup: Tips and Tricks for Founders at the Starting LineStartup Your Startup: Tips and Tricks for Founders at the Starting Line
Startup Your Startup: Tips and Tricks for Founders at the Starting Line
 
Employee vs Independent Contractor
Employee vs Independent ContractorEmployee vs Independent Contractor
Employee vs Independent Contractor
 
Is that Worker an Employee? Questions and Answers on Worker Classification.
Is that Worker an Employee? Questions and Answers on Worker Classification.Is that Worker an Employee? Questions and Answers on Worker Classification.
Is that Worker an Employee? Questions and Answers on Worker Classification.
 
A Sea Change in Wage and Hour Law
A Sea Change in Wage and Hour LawA Sea Change in Wage and Hour Law
A Sea Change in Wage and Hour Law
 
Employment Law Newsletter
Employment Law NewsletterEmployment Law Newsletter
Employment Law Newsletter
 
IRS Worker Classification
IRS Worker ClassificationIRS Worker Classification
IRS Worker Classification
 
2012 Human Resources Updates
2012 Human Resources Updates2012 Human Resources Updates
2012 Human Resources Updates
 
Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?
Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?
Employee vs. Independent Contractor - How to Differentiate and Avoid Penalties?
 
WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...
WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...
WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...
 
ACC Docket Article July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...
ACC Docket Article  July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...ACC Docket Article  July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...
ACC Docket Article July/August 2010, Immigration Consequences of Corporate R...
 
Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee
Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee
Misclassification: 1099 Contractor or Employee
 
New_Whistleblowing_Protections_for_Employees_of_Government_Contractors
New_Whistleblowing_Protections_for_Employees_of_Government_ContractorsNew_Whistleblowing_Protections_for_Employees_of_Government_Contractors
New_Whistleblowing_Protections_for_Employees_of_Government_Contractors
 
Contractor Versus Employee Sb Gorilla
Contractor Versus Employee Sb GorillaContractor Versus Employee Sb Gorilla
Contractor Versus Employee Sb Gorilla
 
Independent contractor or common law employee 2013
Independent contractor or common law employee   2013Independent contractor or common law employee   2013
Independent contractor or common law employee 2013
 
WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...
WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...
WHAT H-1B EMPLOYERS NEED TO KNOW ABOUT THE LCA TO AVOID POTENTIAL DOL COMPLIA...
 
Employee Leaves of Absence: FLSA, FMLA, ADA, and ACA
Employee Leaves of Absence: FLSA, FMLA, ADA, and ACAEmployee Leaves of Absence: FLSA, FMLA, ADA, and ACA
Employee Leaves of Absence: FLSA, FMLA, ADA, and ACA
 
Payroll Webinar: W-2’s vs. 1099’s: Understanding Who Should be an Independent...
Payroll Webinar: W-2’s vs. 1099’s: Understanding Who Should be an Independent...Payroll Webinar: W-2’s vs. 1099’s: Understanding Who Should be an Independent...
Payroll Webinar: W-2’s vs. 1099’s: Understanding Who Should be an Independent...
 
Employment Law Update, August 2015
Employment Law Update, August 2015Employment Law Update, August 2015
Employment Law Update, August 2015
 
BHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law Newsletter
BHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law NewsletterBHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law Newsletter
BHW Solicitors Summer Employment Law Newsletter
 
Terminating Employees in California
Terminating Employees in CaliforniaTerminating Employees in California
Terminating Employees in California
 

Similar to Tax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as Contractors

Reply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docx
Reply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docxReply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docx
Reply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docx
audeleypearl
 
May 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or IC
May 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or ICMay 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or IC
May 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or IC
Chris Parfitt
 
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By BusinessesTop 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Frank C. Cardenas
 
Contingent Workers
Contingent Workers Contingent Workers
Contingent Workers
lnarvid
 
1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx
1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx
1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx
jeremylockett77
 
’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...
’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...
’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...
Umesh Heendeniya
 
HR Update with Cyndi Mergele
HR Update with Cyndi MergeleHR Update with Cyndi Mergele
HR Update with Cyndi Mergele
Greenlights
 

Similar to Tax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as Contractors (20)

Reply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docx
Reply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docxReply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docx
Reply 1 OdellaThe difference between an employee and an indep.docx
 
Classifying independent contractors vs. employees
Classifying independent contractors vs. employeesClassifying independent contractors vs. employees
Classifying independent contractors vs. employees
 
20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor
20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor
20 Factor Test Employee Or Sub Contractor
 
Independent Contractor vs Employee
Independent Contractor vs EmployeeIndependent Contractor vs Employee
Independent Contractor vs Employee
 
Tax Planning for Self-Employed Business Owners
Tax Planning for Self-Employed Business OwnersTax Planning for Self-Employed Business Owners
Tax Planning for Self-Employed Business Owners
 
May 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or IC
May 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or ICMay 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or IC
May 2014 IRS 20 factor test re Employee or IC
 
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By BusinessesTop 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
Top 10 Employment Law Mistakes Made By Businesses
 
Contingent Workers
Contingent Workers Contingent Workers
Contingent Workers
 
Hiring Workers as Employees vs Independent Contractors.pptx
Hiring Workers as Employees vs Independent Contractors.pptxHiring Workers as Employees vs Independent Contractors.pptx
Hiring Workers as Employees vs Independent Contractors.pptx
 
Legal Considerations of Hiring Employees and Retaining Contractors in Ontario
Legal Considerations of Hiring Employees and Retaining Contractors in OntarioLegal Considerations of Hiring Employees and Retaining Contractors in Ontario
Legal Considerations of Hiring Employees and Retaining Contractors in Ontario
 
Emploment law issues for the gig economy
Emploment law issues for the gig economyEmploment law issues for the gig economy
Emploment law issues for the gig economy
 
Employment Law Issues for the Gig Economy
Employment Law Issues for the Gig EconomyEmployment Law Issues for the Gig Economy
Employment Law Issues for the Gig Economy
 
Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up
Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up
Lean Start-up Business Tactics Seminar - HR Issues and Your Start-up
 
Employee or Independent Contractor?
Employee or Independent Contractor?Employee or Independent Contractor?
Employee or Independent Contractor?
 
1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx
1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx
1. Think of at least one item in each of these areas that may impa.docx
 
’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...
’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...
’Employers’ Responsibilities When Making Settlements in Employment Related La...
 
Independent Contractor Requirements & How To Save On Taxes
Independent Contractor Requirements & How To Save On TaxesIndependent Contractor Requirements & How To Save On Taxes
Independent Contractor Requirements & How To Save On Taxes
 
Temporary Employees and the Employer Mandate
Temporary Employees and the Employer MandateTemporary Employees and the Employer Mandate
Temporary Employees and the Employer Mandate
 
HR Update with Cyndi Mergele
HR Update with Cyndi MergeleHR Update with Cyndi Mergele
HR Update with Cyndi Mergele
 
Tx nonprofit hr update august 2011
Tx nonprofit hr update august 2011Tx nonprofit hr update august 2011
Tx nonprofit hr update august 2011
 

More from Human Resources & Payroll

More from Human Resources & Payroll (20)

Can You Monitor Your Employees’ Communications?
Can You Monitor Your Employees’ Communications?Can You Monitor Your Employees’ Communications?
Can You Monitor Your Employees’ Communications?
 
The Link Between Employee Motivation and Your Compensation Philosophy
The Link Between Employee Motivation and Your Compensation PhilosophyThe Link Between Employee Motivation and Your Compensation Philosophy
The Link Between Employee Motivation and Your Compensation Philosophy
 
A Fresh Look at Employee Incentive Compensation
A Fresh Look at Employee Incentive CompensationA Fresh Look at Employee Incentive Compensation
A Fresh Look at Employee Incentive Compensation
 
Train Employees to Avoid Cybercrime
Train Employees to Avoid CybercrimeTrain Employees to Avoid Cybercrime
Train Employees to Avoid Cybercrime
 
Leverage Benefits to Recruit and Retain Talent
Leverage Benefits to Recruit and Retain TalentLeverage Benefits to Recruit and Retain Talent
Leverage Benefits to Recruit and Retain Talent
 
Accommodating Employees with Mental Illness
Accommodating Employees with Mental IllnessAccommodating Employees with Mental Illness
Accommodating Employees with Mental Illness
 
New Overtime Rules Suspended for Now
New Overtime Rules Suspended for NowNew Overtime Rules Suspended for Now
New Overtime Rules Suspended for Now
 
Avoid the Legal Traps of Relocating Jobs
Avoid the Legal Traps of Relocating JobsAvoid the Legal Traps of Relocating Jobs
Avoid the Legal Traps of Relocating Jobs
 
EEOC Seeks Enforcement of Pregnancy Discrimination Laws
EEOC Seeks Enforcement of Pregnancy Discrimination LawsEEOC Seeks Enforcement of Pregnancy Discrimination Laws
EEOC Seeks Enforcement of Pregnancy Discrimination Laws
 
Making the Most of Staff Meetings
Making the Most of Staff MeetingsMaking the Most of Staff Meetings
Making the Most of Staff Meetings
 
Avoid Inadvertent Hiring Discrimination
Avoid Inadvertent Hiring DiscriminationAvoid Inadvertent Hiring Discrimination
Avoid Inadvertent Hiring Discrimination
 
Employer Complaints Pour in as EEOC Wants More Data
Employer Complaints Pour in as EEOC Wants More DataEmployer Complaints Pour in as EEOC Wants More Data
Employer Complaints Pour in as EEOC Wants More Data
 
Avoid Giving Birth to a Pregnancy Discrimination Charge
Avoid Giving Birth to a Pregnancy Discrimination ChargeAvoid Giving Birth to a Pregnancy Discrimination Charge
Avoid Giving Birth to a Pregnancy Discrimination Charge
 
Overtime Pay Rules: Avoid Making Costly Wrong Assumptions
Overtime Pay Rules: Avoid Making Costly Wrong AssumptionsOvertime Pay Rules: Avoid Making Costly Wrong Assumptions
Overtime Pay Rules: Avoid Making Costly Wrong Assumptions
 
DOL Announces Increased Civil Penalties for Violations of Federal Laws
DOL Announces Increased Civil Penalties for Violations of Federal LawsDOL Announces Increased Civil Penalties for Violations of Federal Laws
DOL Announces Increased Civil Penalties for Violations of Federal Laws
 
New OSHA Rules Spotlight Workplace Injuries, Illnesses
New OSHA Rules Spotlight Workplace Injuries, IllnessesNew OSHA Rules Spotlight Workplace Injuries, Illnesses
New OSHA Rules Spotlight Workplace Injuries, Illnesses
 
New Overtime Rules Issued: What it Means for You
New Overtime Rules Issued: What it Means for YouNew Overtime Rules Issued: What it Means for You
New Overtime Rules Issued: What it Means for You
 
EEOC Takes Aim at Gender-Based Pay Discrimination
EEOC Takes Aim at Gender-Based Pay DiscriminationEEOC Takes Aim at Gender-Based Pay Discrimination
EEOC Takes Aim at Gender-Based Pay Discrimination
 
Employee Health Screenings Can Be Well Worth the Effort
Employee Health Screenings Can Be Well Worth the EffortEmployee Health Screenings Can Be Well Worth the Effort
Employee Health Screenings Can Be Well Worth the Effort
 
Video Job Interviews Gaining Popularity
Video Job Interviews Gaining PopularityVideo Job Interviews Gaining Popularity
Video Job Interviews Gaining Popularity
 

Recently uploaded

Constitution of Company Article of Association
Constitution of Company Article of AssociationConstitution of Company Article of Association
Constitution of Company Article of Association
seri bangash
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg Pfizer
Jual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg PfizerJual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg Pfizer
Jual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg Pfizer
Pusat Herbal Resmi BPOM
 
Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...
Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...
Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...
jual Obat Aborsi Bandung, Wa : 085180626899 Apotik jual Obat Cytotec Di Bandung
 
Future of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot Report
Future of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot ReportFuture of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot Report
Future of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot Report
Dubai Multi Commodity Centre
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Guide to Networking Essentials 8th Edition by Greg Tomsho solution manual.doc
Guide to Networking Essentials 8th Edition by Greg Tomsho solution manual.docGuide to Networking Essentials 8th Edition by Greg Tomsho solution manual.doc
Guide to Networking Essentials 8th Edition by Greg Tomsho solution manual.doc
 
Stages of Startup Funding - An Explainer
Stages of Startup Funding - An ExplainerStages of Startup Funding - An Explainer
Stages of Startup Funding - An Explainer
 
Constitution of Company Article of Association
Constitution of Company Article of AssociationConstitution of Company Article of Association
Constitution of Company Article of Association
 
wagamamaLab presentation @MIT 20240509 IRODORI
wagamamaLab presentation @MIT 20240509 IRODORIwagamamaLab presentation @MIT 20240509 IRODORI
wagamamaLab presentation @MIT 20240509 IRODORI
 
Jual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg Pfizer
Jual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg PfizerJual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg Pfizer
Jual Obat Aborsi Di Sibolga wa 0851/7541/5434 Cytotec Misoprostol 200mcg Pfizer
 
Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...
Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...
Apotik Jual Obat Aborsi asli Mataram, Wa : 085180626899 - Penjual obat Cytote...
 
The Truth About Dinesh Bafna's Situation.pdf
The Truth About Dinesh Bafna's Situation.pdfThe Truth About Dinesh Bafna's Situation.pdf
The Truth About Dinesh Bafna's Situation.pdf
 
hyundai capital 2023 consolidated financial statements
hyundai capital 2023 consolidated financial statementshyundai capital 2023 consolidated financial statements
hyundai capital 2023 consolidated financial statements
 
Future of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot Report
Future of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot ReportFuture of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot Report
Future of Trade 2024 - Decoupled and Reconfigured - Snapshot Report
 
Toyota Kata Coaching for Agile Teams & Transformations
Toyota Kata Coaching for Agile Teams & TransformationsToyota Kata Coaching for Agile Teams & Transformations
Toyota Kata Coaching for Agile Teams & Transformations
 
Hyundai capital 2024 1q Earnings release
Hyundai capital 2024 1q Earnings releaseHyundai capital 2024 1q Earnings release
Hyundai capital 2024 1q Earnings release
 
NFS- Operations Presentation - Recurrent
NFS- Operations Presentation - RecurrentNFS- Operations Presentation - Recurrent
NFS- Operations Presentation - Recurrent
 
5 Brilliant Ways To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In 2024
5 Brilliant Ways To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In 20245 Brilliant Ways To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In 2024
5 Brilliant Ways To Buy Verified Payoneer Accounts In 2024
 
(推特)Twitter账号批发(自助购买网址🎉top233.com🎉)
(推特)Twitter账号批发(自助购买网址🎉top233.com🎉)(推特)Twitter账号批发(自助购买网址🎉top233.com🎉)
(推特)Twitter账号批发(自助购买网址🎉top233.com🎉)
 
Blinkit: Revolutionizing the On-Demand Grocery Delivery Service.pptx
Blinkit: Revolutionizing the On-Demand Grocery Delivery Service.pptxBlinkit: Revolutionizing the On-Demand Grocery Delivery Service.pptx
Blinkit: Revolutionizing the On-Demand Grocery Delivery Service.pptx
 
بروفايل شركة ميار الخليج للاستشارات الهندسية.pdf
بروفايل شركة ميار الخليج للاستشارات الهندسية.pdfبروفايل شركة ميار الخليج للاستشارات الهندسية.pdf
بروفايل شركة ميار الخليج للاستشارات الهندسية.pdf
 
Elevate Your Online Presence with SEO Services
Elevate Your Online Presence with SEO ServicesElevate Your Online Presence with SEO Services
Elevate Your Online Presence with SEO Services
 
Your Work Matters to God RestorationChurch.pptx
Your Work Matters to God RestorationChurch.pptxYour Work Matters to God RestorationChurch.pptx
Your Work Matters to God RestorationChurch.pptx
 
How to refresh to be fit for the future world
How to refresh to be fit for the future worldHow to refresh to be fit for the future world
How to refresh to be fit for the future world
 
Exploring-Pipe-Flanges-Applications-Types-and-Benefits.pptx
Exploring-Pipe-Flanges-Applications-Types-and-Benefits.pptxExploring-Pipe-Flanges-Applications-Types-and-Benefits.pptx
Exploring-Pipe-Flanges-Applications-Types-and-Benefits.pptx
 

Tax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as Contractors

  • 1. Toll Free: 877.880.4477 Phone: 281.880.6525 www.hrp.net Tax Court Cautionary Tale: Classifying Workers as Contractors
  • 2. www.hrp.net The issue of whether workers should be classified as employees or independent contractors for federal employment tax purposes has been a source of controversy for decades. The saga continues. This article summarizes a recent Tax Court decision on the classification of a manager in the home care industry. » Note: To make things more understandable, we will call businesses that hire workers "employers" (whether the workers are employees or independent contractors), and we will call the individuals who get the job done "workers" (whether they are employees or independent contractors).
  • 3. Seven Factors to Decide Worker Classification www.hrp.net The Tax Court considers these factors when deciding whether workers should be classified as independent contractors or employees for federal employment tax purposes: 11 Degree of Control. When an employer exercises significant control over how a worker performs duties or has the right to do so, this factor indicates employee status. When there's little or no control or right to exercise it, this factor indicates independent contractor status. Based on longstanding tradition, this factor is considered the most important. So, it's often used as the tie-breaker in situations where there are an equal number of factors on both sides.
  • 4. www.hrp.net 22 Investment in Equipment and Facilities. When the worker covers most or all of the cost of equipment and facilities used for the job, this factor indicates independent contractor status. For example, say the worker performs his duties out of an office in his home using equipment (computer, printer and phone) that he pays for himself. In such a case, this factor would clearly indicate independent contractor status. On the other hand, if the employer provides most or all of the equipment and facilities, this factor would indicate employee status. 33 Whether Worker Has Opportunity for Open-Ended Profit or Outright Loss. A worker who can make an open-ended profit through the strength of his or her own efforts or, alternatively, suffer an outright loss on the job, is likely to be an independent contractor rather than an employee. For example, this would be the case when an outside sales person is paid by commission only. On the other hand, when the compensation arrangement dictates that the worker can only make a fixed profit and not suffer a loss, it indicates employee status. For example, this would be the case when the worker is paid a fixed amount for each day of work and the only significant job-related expense is the cost of commuting to and from the work site.
  • 5. www.hrp.net 44 Whether Worker Can Be Discharged. A worker who can be discharged is more likely to be an employee than an independent contractor. 55 Whether Work Is Related to Employer's Core Business. When the worker's duties relate to the employer's core business it indicates employee status, while work related to a tangential enterprise indicates independent contractor status. 55 Permanency of Relationship between Employer and Worker. Lack of permanency indicates independent contractor status while permanency indicates employee status. 55 Relationship Employer and Worker Believed they Were Creating. If the employer and the worker believed the same thing at the time they entered into their arrangement, courts rule this factor can indicate either employee or independent contractor status, depending on the facts. If the parties believed two different things, this factor may be thrown out.
  • 6. Why Worker Classification Matters When a worker is properly classified as a common-law employee, the employer generally must withhold from the worker's wages: www.hrp.net • Federal income tax (FIT), and • The employee's portion of the Social Security and Medicare taxes (FICA tax). The employer must also pay the employer's portion of the Social Security and Medicare taxes, pay federal unemployment tax (FUTA), file federal payroll tax returns, and comply with various IRS and Department of Labor (DOL) rules and regulations.
  • 7. www.hrp.net In addition, the employer may have to deal with state and local income tax withholding, pay state unemployment and Workers' Compensation taxes, and comply with even more local rules and regulations. Handling all of this red tape can cost a bundle every year for each employee. If employee benefits -- such as health insurance, paid vacations, and sick leave -- are also provided, the cost of keeping a common-law employee on the payroll can become prohibitive. In contrast, when a worker is properly classified as an independent contractor, the employer must simply provide the worker and the IRS with a Form 1099-MISC each year to report how much the worker was paid. That's why many businesses prefer to treat as many workers as possible as independent contractors instead of employees.
  • 8. Common-Law Employee vs. Independent Contractor Common-law employees are workers considered to be employees (as opposed to independent contractors) based on various statutes, regulations and court decisions. IRS and DOL rules can differ from state and local rules. That said, if an employer is allowed to treat a worker as an independent contractor under IRS rules, it will generally be the same across the board. Therefore, this article only discusses the IRS rules. Properly classifying a worker as an independent contractor is beneficial because the employer doesn't have to worry about employment tax issues or provide expensive fringe benefits. However, when an employer mistakenly treats an employee as an independent contractor, the employer could owe unpaid employment taxes, as well as interest and penalties. The employer also may be liable for employee benefits that should have been provided but were not. So, it's important to get worker classification questions right. www.hrp.net
  • 9. Facts of the Recent Tax Court Case In its recent decision, the Tax Court used seven factors (see right-hand box) to evaluate whether a worker who provided home care services to disabled clients was an employee. The taxpayer in this case, Atig Rahman, was hired by Ever Care Adult Care Services, which provides home and other care services to disabled adults. The taxpayer was quickly promoted to manager of a group home, where he worked about 40 hours per week and was paid at an hourly rate every two weeks. www.hrp.net
  • 10. www.hrp.net Ever Care dictated the taxpayer's duties and responsibilities, which included preparing a monthly financial forecast, hiring and firing staff, scheduling staff hours, meeting with officials from the Florida state licensing agency, maintaining and repairing the facilities, buying groceries for the home, assisting residents with personal grooming, and arranging transportation for residents. The taxpayer also met weekly with the owner regarding grocery purchases and gave the owner daily status reports. Although Ever Care treated the taxpayer as a self-employed independent contractor and issued him a Form 1099-MISC, he did not pay any self- employment (SE) tax for the year in question. After an audit, the IRS claimed he was an independent contractor and issued an assessment for unpaid SE tax.
  • 11. Tax Court Decision The Tax Court analyzed these seven factors and found that none of them supported the self-employed independent contractor status: www.hrp.net 1. Specifically enumerating his duties and responsibilities, 2. Specifying when and where his duties were to be performed, and 3. Requiring frequent reports to the owner. Investment in Equipment and Facilities. The taxpayer did not provide his own equipment or facilities. Opportunity for Profit or Loss. Ever Care paid the taxpayer at an hourly rate, so he had no open-ended opportunity for profit or loss. Degree of Control. The Tax Court found that Ever Care had the right to control the taxpayer's work and did in fact exercise a high degree of control by: Right to Discharge. Ever Care retained the right to discharge the taxpayer and did, in fact, discharge him the following year.
  • 12. www.hrp.net Work Related to Core Business. The work performed by the taxpayer was an integral part of Ever Care's core business of providing home care and other services to adults with disabilities. Permanency of Relationship. The taxpayer worked full-time for Ever Care for approximately nine months, at which point he was discharged. While it lasted, the relationship between Ever Care and the taxpayer was not thought to be temporary or short-term by either party. Relationship the Parties Believed they Were Creating. Ever Care treated the taxpayer as a self-employed independent contractor by issuing him a Form 1099-MISC and not withholding taxes from his pay. While this indicated that Ever Care intended for the taxpayer to be an independent contractor, this intention was self-serving because it allowed Ever Care to avoid paying employment taxes on his compensation and benefits. Because all but the last factor weighed in favor of the taxpayer being a common-law employee, the Tax Court ruled that he did not owe self-employment tax because he was not a self-employed independent contractor (Atig Rahman, T.C. Summary Opinion 2014-35).
  • 13. Bottom Line While the Rahman decision was in favor of the taxpayer (worker), it opened the door for the IRS to go after Ever Care (the employer) for unpaid federal employment taxes, interest, and penalties. Therefore, the decision is yet another cautionary tale that failure to properly classify workers can be an expensive mistake for employers. In many cases, proactive planning can lock in tax-saving independent contractor status for workers. But, if nothing is done before an IRS audit takes place, it may be too late to achieve the desired tax-saving results. Consult your payroll and tax advisers if you have questions about worker classification issues. www.hrp.net
  • 14. 14550 Torrey Chase Blvd., Ste. 360 Houston, TX 77014 USA www.hrp.net E-mail : info@hrp.net Toll Free Phone Fax : : : 877.880.4477 281.880.6525 281.866.9426