SlideShare a Scribd company logo
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 1/12
European Scientist
Join our newsletter EN
Home » Features » Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
- Features -
Red meat bashing and human
ancestral diet
By Guy-André Pelouze - 16.10.2019
Con ict of interest: The author received no fee nor grant for this commentary. He is
personally omnivorous and practices thoracic and cardiovascular surgery.
 
THERE IS, OBVIOUSLY, SINCE THE END OF WWII, A BATTLE IN THE FIELD OF HUMAN NUTRITION:
ANIMAL PRODUCTS ARE VILIFIED BY SOME ACADEMICS ON THE GROUNDS OF STUDIES WHICH MERELY
ARE OBSERVATIONAL.
The same academics took power and heavily in uenced the nutritional guidelines. This is
why of cial recommendations regarding of human health and political decisions stir up some
very disputed assertions. This short opinion published in the BMJ[1] sums up them very
interestingly. Tim Spector and Christopher Gardner (subsequently named the “authors”)

Privacy & Cookies Policy
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 2/12
discussed the recent recommendations issued by Canadian researchers from Mac Master
University[2] that there is no evidence to cut on red meat because of health risks. They warn
against the work of these Canadian researchers who recently demonstrated that one might
be skeptical on scienti c evidence of the red meat bashing. It is not surprising that such a
skeptical attitude is unbearable for those who believe that the weak and inconstant
associations between meat consumption and chronic diseases –even death – are non-
questionable.  It does not matter to them that in those studies the type of meat was very
imprecise, as the type of transformation, that those associations were mainly found in
quartiles of high consumption and predominate in groups of people with risky lifestyle (male
sex, smoking, alcohol). More generally this debate, whatever its polarization, is not only a
methodological one or a civilization issue; it is simply a question of ef ciency in the actual
battle against diabesity.  As a physician, this is the aim of our commitment to patients
because diabesity is a public health priority. The worldwide prevalence of overweight and
obesity has approximately doubled since 1980. Nearly a third of the world’s population is
now overweight or obese. Obesity rates have increased in all ages and both sexes
irrespective of geographical locality, ethnicity or socioeconomic status. This trend is similar
across regions and countries, although absolute prevalence rates of overweight and obesity
varied widely. In this battle, this is not an opinion, academic authors and governments failed
to tackle the problem by promoting their well-known food pyramids[3]. On the other hand,
red meat consumption is not at the origin of this number one problem in public health.
 
IT IS SIMPLE BUT, FOR SCIENTISTS, IT IS FUNDAMENTAL TO POINT OUT THAT THE AUTHORS BEGAN
THEIR PIECE WITH SIGNIFICANT CONFUSION.
Bacon is not red meat. In mixing them authors perfectly exempli ed the huge risk of error in
observational studies. The reason why those studies are imprecise, weak and without any
evidence of causality whatsoever. On the contrary, randomization will balance this kind of
mistakes and control of diet will suppress them. In mixing bacon, red meat, processed meats
and environmental issues authors deliberately began to add incomprehensiveness to an
already complex issue. As it is their mantra they continued in this path.  “The criteria are well
suited to studies of pharmaceuticals when there are randomized, double-blind, placebo-
controlled trials available, but not for studies of meat, eggs, vegetables or any speci c food.”
No. It is nonsense to make a rule for drugs and another for diets. Simply this is the heart of
the problem. The high-pro le authors, evoked in this opinion piece, made their career by
making such a double standard an obvious knowledge and at the same time selling their
observational studies with a low association between factors as fuzzy as the Mediterranean
diet, grains, fat, dairy or meat… It is a shame that observational studies on diet of 10 years or
more were published with only one or two assessments by self-reported questionnaires at
the beginning of the “prospective” study. Aside from the fact that other academic authors
and organisations disagree with this impossibility to do RCT in diets, several very high-
quality papers were published and recently. Kevin D. Hall did such RCT which shows that

Privacy & Cookies Policy
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 3/12
junk food causes weight gain on a short time basis[4]. So, patients and physicians are worth
high-quality studies. There are several innovative paths to get rid of observational studies.
The rst is the RCT. For instance, RCT brings quality information in order to help to solve the
obesity epidemics that high pro le nutritionists failed to curb. It is untrue to assert: “Given
that RCTs with foods or food groups are not possible”. By designing RCT it is possible to
precisely assess each type of food or food group in the setting of a clear hypothesis. The
second is the use of genetic variants as instruments to test the causal associations[5].  The
third is personalised nutrition which is the way to discriminate the effects of nutriments or
carcinogens on different genomes and epigenomes[6].
Authors chose the weakest evidence, aka association of factors because they are reluctant
to embark on causality studies.
 
FURTHERMORE THE AUTHORS MADE TWO ASSERTIONS IN THE SAME SENTENCE WHICH ARE NOT
RELEVANT TO RED MEAT.
“The authors also chose to leave out all arti cial ex-vivo lab studies and animal studies,
included in other meta-analyses, that have, for example, implicated nitrites or acrylamides as
carcinogens. “ The carcinogens quoted are totally out of the subject. Is it necessary to point
out that nitrites and acrylamide are not present in red meat? How this could be possible in a
peer-reviewed opinion? Technically, processed meat means pork, beef or duck that has been
salted and cured, with or without smoking. A fresh pound of red meat is not processed. A
hard stick of cured salami is. The health risk of bacon, if any, is largely to do with two food
additives: potassium nitrate (also known as saltpetre) and sodium nitrite. On the other hand,
major food sources of acrylamide are French fries and potato chips; but also, crackers, bread,
and cookies; breakfast cereals those last foods that high-pro le nutritionists advise eating if
they are made of “whole our”. Furthermore, animal studies and other “mechanistic studies”
are not relevant to the new strict analysis of the observational studies about red meat by
Canadian authors. Indeed, animal and mechanistic studies are only warning studies for
launching clinical trials. No more no less. And another time the great carnivores do not
exhibit cancers or CVD after eating meat all their lives. An example of aw animal study is to
give meat to a non-carnivore as it is a poor mechanistic study to give a high-fat diet to
rabbits to explain atheroma. Last but not least they didn’t mention the 2010 review which
showed that eating charred, smoked, well done red meat is associated with a higher risk of
colorectal cancer only in smokers[7]! Interestingly one of the studies reviewed in this
paper[8] didn’t nd any association between well done or very well-done meat (processed
or not) and health issues below 5 steaks/week. We are very near to the advice of the
Canadian authors who concluded that until 3 steaks per week there is no measurable risk. In
order to understand the complexity of the issue of cancer and meat consumption we need to
be clear about the potential causes. It is rather surprising that they didn’t mention the proven
carcinogens in high temperature cooked red or processed meat: heterocyclic amines and

Privacy & Cookies Policy
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 4/12
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. These organic compounds which are also produced by
high-temperature cooking of white meat, sh and vegetable protein although in less
quantity are not present in fresh meat nor in low temperature cooked meat.
 
THEN THEY CAME TO THE DEMONSTRATION THAT CANADIAN AUTHORS CHERRY-PICKED STUDIES IN
THEIR META-ANALYSIS.
Authors argued that Canadian researchers eliminated some observational studies in order to
bias the nal results. They point out the eviction of Lyon heart study and PREDIMED but
they don’t prove that taking into account these studies would have changed the conclusions
of the revision meta-analysis about red meat. Doing that, they again delegitimated
observational studies. Indeed, meta-analysis of RCT are far less subjected to contest; if red
meat consumption is the hypothesis to test, you cannot eliminate an RCT which stated that.
In observational studies, the selection is a very complex process as their design and the
modelling of multivariate analysis in uence the results. Eventually, they agreed with
Canadian authors: “Previous summaries, which have been more inclusive, have shown
modest health risks for red meat, but clear links between processed meat, heart disease and
early death. The evidence for cancer causation is less clear-cut, and several trials of meat
reduction have not resulted in lowering of cancer risks. “ In the same paragraph, they also
recognize that the issue is not red meat but junk food, a point we strongly agree with.
Nonetheless, RCT are very rare despite being more powerful than dozens of observational
studies.
 
THEN COME THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS WHICH ARE ONLY AUTHORS’ OPINION.
They wrote: “but in our view, we should all be eating less meat and more high bre, nutrient-
dense foods that include many vegetables, legumes, fruits and nuts and seeds.” We were
waiting for a better backing than wishful thinking and political correctness. This advice is no
more than a copy/paste of the average, standardized, non-personalised nutritional guidelines
which proved to be meaningless and inef cient. Nonsense.
BACK TO THE OPINION PIECE I WANT TO POINT OUT TWO ERRORS THAT WERE MADE AT THE END.
FIRST, WHY REIGNITE A CONTROVERSY IN A BIASED MANNER?
They compare the review articles about meat with an, according to them, a complacent
subsidised paper about sugar from the same lead author. Making it short, the Canadian meat
meta-analysis would be corrupted by a precedent study on sugar because of hidden con ict
of interests. It is a concern. But one may wonder why the EAT-Lancet initiative that they also
quoted is not under the same scrutiny? It is suspicious to imply that government subsidies,
non-pro t organisation subsidies or any other subsidy are neutral… In order to get out of this
Privacy & Cookies Policy
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 5/12
biased debate, I think we don’t need such a suspicion. It is only a matter of good sense or
bayesian evidence: we eat sugar approximately since 1800 and meat since at least 500 000
years. That could help in nding the truth.
 
SECOND, IT IS HARD TO BELIEVE THAT THE AUTHORS DECIDED TO CONCLUDE THEIR OPINION PIECE BY A SO
PREDICTABLE GREENWASHING.
 
The EAT-Lancet initiative that they quoted, is not a new study. It is not a meta-analysis. It is
indeed a very sophisticated but biased piece of statistical manipulation in order to impose
not less meat but a vegan diet. Their opinion is respectable as long as they state it sincerely.
I think that this kind of reasoning is reductionistic as it leads to blaming all people around the
planet for eating too much meat. While for instance, south European people eat a very
moderate amount of meat and numerous other populations don’t eat suf cient animal
products and suffer several de ciencies. It is the same reasoning which is used by bad
teachers who punish all the classroom instead of targeting those who are making the
heckling. Again, this assertion is not backed by evidence. All agricultural practices have been
found to have a variety of effects on the environment. Some of the environmental effects
that have been associated with meat production are pollution through fossil fuel usage,
animal methane, ef uent waste, and water and land consumption. The issue is destructive
farming, not whether you eat meat or dairy or vegetables or grains. Another issue is the
quantum of those impacts. Contrary to different assertions in the different EAT-Lancet
papers, the matter of anthropogenic emissions is extremely complex and still poorly known
in details. Particularly meat production is a multifactorial process which is managed very
differently in different countries and according to ancestral or industrial practices. The
amount of direct GHG emissions of animal husbandry is 2,3 GigaTons of CO2 equivalent id
est 5% and indirect GHG emissions linked to all meat, eggs and dairy products are 4,8
gigatons of CO2 equivalent per year or 9.5% of all anthropogenic emissions. It is important
to address these emissions with rationality that is why indirect emissions are the true target,
not animals. Indirect emissions are the most important and are largely improvable through
energy transition and other agricultural practices, the same means used in other sectors of
agriculture. Direct emissions are less avoidable but represent only half of the indirect GHG
emissions.
As a matter of fact, in the United States 60% of calories come from re ned sugar, re ned
grains and re ned omega-6 seed oils, which is saying that meat consumption does not have
a prominent role in obesity and type 2 diabetes. It is remarkable that carbs and vegetable
oils are recommended by food pyramids. In a recent paper[9], C. Christie et al brought the
evidence that excess calories, whatever it comes from, do have a big environmental impact.
Among those excess calories, processed foods have a bigger impact in general because they
need more energy to be produced, packaged, transported and nally more frequently treated

Privacy & Cookies Policy
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 6/12
as waste. Excess calories are consumed in developed countries[10], but it is not meat which
brings calories in excess because meat and poultry are composed of naturally occurring
water, muscle, connective tissue, fat, and bone. The muscle is approximately 75% water
(although different cuts may have more or less water) and 20% protein, with the remaining
5% representing a combination of fat, carbohydrates, and minerals. On the contrary, sugar
and fats in processed foods, which are in excess, are packed in very dense foods with
minimal water increasing signi cantly the number of calories per day.
 
 
FINALLY, WE HAVE TO RECALL THE NUTRITIONAL ADVANTAGES OF MEAT FOR HUMANS A LIFELONG.
Meat is a very good source of nutritionally complete and digestible proteins, bioavailable
iron, zinc, and selenium and the exclusive source of vitamin B12. Consumption of red meat
has decreased since 2000 in developed countries and the average consumption in Europe is
around three portions a week. This amount of red meat is not associated with any increased
risk in observational studies. When consumed, meat and offal have an important role in
maintaining good health through its supply of high-quality nutrients. In the setting of a
exitarian diet like shown in the blue zone countries, the bene ts of meat add those of sh
and seafood, more high bre, plant-based foods, with the nutritional durability of an
omnivorous diet. Red meat bashing is against human ancestral diet and will increase human
health issues. We should think twice before throwing away red meat production together
with fossil fuels because of environmental issues. There are smarter paths to curb
anthropogenic emissions without endangering human health.
 
[1] https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2019/10/09/bacon-rashers-statistics-and-controversy/?
fbclid=IwAR2453O8TZURygfDz3cz4871bsXTAHhHJ16mhKDHnq7p_3-zjJacTRMmnII
[2] https://annals.org/aim/fullarticle/2752328/unprocessed-red-meat-processed-meat-
consumption-dietary-guideline-recommendations-from
[3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30253139
[4] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31105044
[5] https://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2019/06/05/db19-0153
[6] https://www.bmj.com/content/361/bmj.k2173
[7] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2769029/
[8] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0027510702001641?via%3Dihub

Privacy & Cookies Policy
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 7/12
[9] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5799208/
[10] http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/FBS/visualize
SHARE
meat bashing nutrition observational studies Red meat
GUY-ANDRÉ PELOUZE
Guy-André Pelouze is a renowned surgeon with a keen interest for the progress made in his eld
of work. He pays close attention to changes in doctor’s working conditions and systemic evolutions
that affect the standard of care for patients.
Like this:
Like
Be the first to like this.
Related
How to meet both dietary health and
sustainability goals in the future
Everything that 2018 teaches us about
scienti c communication
A surge in antimicrobial resistance
threatens the livestock industry
18.09.2019
In "Agriculture"
20.12.2018
In "Editor's choice"
24.09.2019
In "Agriculture"

Privacy & Cookies Policy
16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet
https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 8/12

Privacy & Cookies Policy

More Related Content

What's hot

Animal research
Animal researchAnimal research
Animal research
Subhi Sharma
 
Period 5 group 3 bioethics
Period 5 group 3 bioethicsPeriod 5 group 3 bioethics
Period 5 group 3 bioethics
school
 
Animal experimentation
Animal experimentationAnimal experimentation
Animal experimentation
Alexis Renick
 
ACVIM e-poster
ACVIM e-posterACVIM e-poster
ACVIM e-poster
Nancy E. Moran
 
Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)
Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)
Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)
İrfan Meriç
 
COMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION
COMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATIONCOMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION
COMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION
Lauren Bradshaw
 
Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance?
Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance? Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance?
Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance?
Seth GSMC and KEM Municipal Hospital
 
Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)
Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)
Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)
ahil thiagarajan
 
Oral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronic
Oral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronicOral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronic
Oral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronic
wahyu purnama
 
Op-Ed writing sample - NEAVS
Op-Ed writing sample - NEAVSOp-Ed writing sample - NEAVS
Op-Ed writing sample - NEAVS
Nate Leskovic
 
Ethics of Using animals in Research
Ethics of Using animals in ResearchEthics of Using animals in Research
Ethics of Using animals in Research
Rabie Fayed
 
Animal testing pp
Animal testing ppAnimal testing pp
Animal testing pp
zinajassim83
 
Animal testing
Animal testing Animal testing
Animal testing
Louisatom
 
Animal Testing
Animal TestingAnimal Testing
Animal Testing
Katie Whelpton
 
Annoted bibliography#2
Annoted bibliography#2Annoted bibliography#2
Annoted bibliography#2
Aquilles07
 
Informatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discovery
Informatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discoveryInformatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discovery
Informatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discovery
Chirag Patel
 
ANIMAL STUDIES
ANIMAL STUDIESANIMAL STUDIES
ANIMAL STUDIES
Koppala RVS Chaitanya
 
Experimental animal models ( lab animals )
Experimental animal models ( lab animals )Experimental animal models ( lab animals )
Experimental animal models ( lab animals )
ebrahem elalfy
 
Animal Testing: Case Study
Animal Testing: Case StudyAnimal Testing: Case Study
Animal Testing: Case Study
Gabriela Sokol
 

What's hot (19)

Animal research
Animal researchAnimal research
Animal research
 
Period 5 group 3 bioethics
Period 5 group 3 bioethicsPeriod 5 group 3 bioethics
Period 5 group 3 bioethics
 
Animal experimentation
Animal experimentationAnimal experimentation
Animal experimentation
 
ACVIM e-poster
ACVIM e-posterACVIM e-poster
ACVIM e-poster
 
Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)
Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)
Experiments And Tests On Animals (Case study)
 
COMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION
COMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATIONCOMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION
COMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO DEBATE ABOUT ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION
 
Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance?
Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance? Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance?
Bioethics in Animal Research- Impetus or Impedance?
 
Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)
Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)
Statistical methods for research scholars (cd)
 
Oral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronic
Oral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronicOral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronic
Oral turmeric (curcumin) effects on inflammatory markers in chronic
 
Op-Ed writing sample - NEAVS
Op-Ed writing sample - NEAVSOp-Ed writing sample - NEAVS
Op-Ed writing sample - NEAVS
 
Ethics of Using animals in Research
Ethics of Using animals in ResearchEthics of Using animals in Research
Ethics of Using animals in Research
 
Animal testing pp
Animal testing ppAnimal testing pp
Animal testing pp
 
Animal testing
Animal testing Animal testing
Animal testing
 
Animal Testing
Animal TestingAnimal Testing
Animal Testing
 
Annoted bibliography#2
Annoted bibliography#2Annoted bibliography#2
Annoted bibliography#2
 
Informatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discovery
Informatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discoveryInformatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discovery
Informatics and data analytics to support for exposome-based discovery
 
ANIMAL STUDIES
ANIMAL STUDIESANIMAL STUDIES
ANIMAL STUDIES
 
Experimental animal models ( lab animals )
Experimental animal models ( lab animals )Experimental animal models ( lab animals )
Experimental animal models ( lab animals )
 
Animal Testing: Case Study
Animal Testing: Case StudyAnimal Testing: Case Study
Animal Testing: Case Study
 

Similar to Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet

Integrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancer
Integrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancerIntegrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancer
Integrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancer
raynoronha
 
ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?
ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?
ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?
Steven Rhyner
 
Recipe cards task 4 pro forma
Recipe cards task 4 pro formaRecipe cards task 4 pro forma
Recipe cards task 4 pro forma
PJG123
 
Nutrition: Avoiding Metabolic Derangement
Nutrition: Avoiding Metabolic DerangementNutrition: Avoiding Metabolic Derangement
Nutrition: Avoiding Metabolic Derangement
warehousegymexpert
 
Dietary guidelines are right
Dietary guidelines are rightDietary guidelines are right
Dietary guidelines are right
Reijo Laatikainen
 
2013 List_Weight Cycling
2013 List_Weight Cycling2013 List_Weight Cycling
2013 List_Weight Cycling
Edward List
 
Is meat killing us
Is meat killing us Is meat killing us
Is meat killing us
New Food Innovation Ltd
 
healthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docxhealthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docx
SaranyaManoharan15
 
Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2
Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2
Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2
Acasa
 
Cancer etiology
Cancer etiologyCancer etiology
Cancer etiology
Nilesh Kucha
 
healthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docxhealthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docx
SaranyaManoharan15
 
WR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docx
WR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docxWR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docx
WR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docx
dunnramage
 
Coughlin_IFT_2019_Science of Food Additives.pdf
Coughlin_IFT_2019_Science of Food Additives.pdfCoughlin_IFT_2019_Science of Food Additives.pdf
healthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docxhealthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docx
SaranyaManoharan15
 
DIET-HEARTfinal
DIET-HEARTfinalDIET-HEARTfinal
2914.docx
2914.docx2914.docx
2914.docx
sdfghj21
 
Red Meat and Cancer_ Crimson Publishers
Red Meat and Cancer_ Crimson PublishersRed Meat and Cancer_ Crimson Publishers
Red Meat and Cancer_ Crimson Publishers
CrimsonpublishersNTNF
 
ASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's Slides
ASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's SlidesASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's Slides
ASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's Slides
Amanda Vasi
 
Asc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slides
Asc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slidesAsc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slides
Asc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slides
Amanda Vasi
 
4th july 2020 daily global regional and local rice e newsletter
4th july 2020  daily global regional and local rice e newsletter4th july 2020  daily global regional and local rice e newsletter
4th july 2020 daily global regional and local rice e newsletter
Riceplus Magazine
 

Similar to Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet (20)

Integrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancer
Integrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancerIntegrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancer
Integrative medicine - The link between red meat and cancer
 
ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?
ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?
ASK THE EXPERT: DO VEGETARIANS LIVE LONGER?
 
Recipe cards task 4 pro forma
Recipe cards task 4 pro formaRecipe cards task 4 pro forma
Recipe cards task 4 pro forma
 
Nutrition: Avoiding Metabolic Derangement
Nutrition: Avoiding Metabolic DerangementNutrition: Avoiding Metabolic Derangement
Nutrition: Avoiding Metabolic Derangement
 
Dietary guidelines are right
Dietary guidelines are rightDietary guidelines are right
Dietary guidelines are right
 
2013 List_Weight Cycling
2013 List_Weight Cycling2013 List_Weight Cycling
2013 List_Weight Cycling
 
Is meat killing us
Is meat killing us Is meat killing us
Is meat killing us
 
healthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docxhealthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docx
 
Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2
Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2
Accademical essay to be or not to be a vegetarian mla sem 2
 
Cancer etiology
Cancer etiologyCancer etiology
Cancer etiology
 
healthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docxhealthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docx
 
WR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docx
WR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docxWR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docx
WR 123Renjie WeiEssay 1.2Beneficial of Vegetarian DietIN.docx
 
Coughlin_IFT_2019_Science of Food Additives.pdf
Coughlin_IFT_2019_Science of Food Additives.pdfCoughlin_IFT_2019_Science of Food Additives.pdf
Coughlin_IFT_2019_Science of Food Additives.pdf
 
healthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docxhealthy eating.docx
healthy eating.docx
 
DIET-HEARTfinal
DIET-HEARTfinalDIET-HEARTfinal
DIET-HEARTfinal
 
2914.docx
2914.docx2914.docx
2914.docx
 
Red Meat and Cancer_ Crimson Publishers
Red Meat and Cancer_ Crimson PublishersRed Meat and Cancer_ Crimson Publishers
Red Meat and Cancer_ Crimson Publishers
 
ASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's Slides
ASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's SlidesASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's Slides
ASC Combined Sustainability presentation including Rebecca's Slides
 
Asc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slides
Asc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slidesAsc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slides
Asc combined sustainability presentation including rebecca's slides
 
4th july 2020 daily global regional and local rice e newsletter
4th july 2020  daily global regional and local rice e newsletter4th july 2020  daily global regional and local rice e newsletter
4th july 2020 daily global regional and local rice e newsletter
 

More from Pelouze Guy-André

L’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptx
L’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptxL’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptx
L’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptx
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Pour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuelle
Pour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuellePour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuelle
Pour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuelle
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Covid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdf
Covid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdfCovid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdf
Covid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdf
Pelouze Guy-André
 
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemicHow the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Richard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentation
Richard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentationRichard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentation
Richard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentation
Pelouze Guy-André
 
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemicHow the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
Pelouze Guy-André
 
L'alimentation industrielle est addictive
L'alimentation industrielle est addictiveL'alimentation industrielle est addictive
L'alimentation industrielle est addictive
Pelouze Guy-André
 
La dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écrans
La dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écransLa dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écrans
La dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écrans
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Emergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evar
Emergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evarEmergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evar
Emergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evar
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Fructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcoolique
Fructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcooliqueFructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcoolique
Fructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcoolique
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Le retour en grâce du gras
Le retour en grâce du grasLe retour en grâce du gras
Le retour en grâce du gras
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Télémédecine cardiovasculaire
Télémédecine cardiovasculaireTélémédecine cardiovasculaire
Télémédecine cardiovasculaire
Pelouze Guy-André
 
We need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelines
We need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelinesWe need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelines
We need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelines
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Lait, Fromages et produits laitiers industriels
Lait, Fromages et produits laitiers industrielsLait, Fromages et produits laitiers industriels
Lait, Fromages et produits laitiers industriels
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Why Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 years
Why Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 yearsWhy Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 years
Why Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 years
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Statines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usage
Statines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usageStatines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usage
Statines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usage
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Numerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ans
Numerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ansNumerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ans
Numerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ans
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Les repas paléo aujourd'hui
Les repas paléo aujourd'huiLes repas paléo aujourd'hui
Les repas paléo aujourd'hui
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Le régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athérome
Le régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athéromeLe régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athérome
Le régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athérome
Pelouze Guy-André
 
Paris Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oil
Paris Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oilParis Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oil
Paris Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oil
Pelouze Guy-André
 

More from Pelouze Guy-André (20)

L’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptx
L’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptxL’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptx
L’hôpital public_ une entreprise paralysée 23_11_2019.pptx
 
Pour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuelle
Pour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuellePour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuelle
Pour sortir le système de soins de l'impasse actuelle
 
Covid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdf
Covid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdfCovid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdf
Covid 19 - petit état des lieux de la pandémie après le variant BA.2.pdf
 
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemicHow the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
 
Richard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentation
Richard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentationRichard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentation
Richard Feinman et les études observationnelles sur l'alimentation
 
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemicHow the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
How the low fat obsession enabled the obesity epidemic
 
L'alimentation industrielle est addictive
L'alimentation industrielle est addictiveL'alimentation industrielle est addictive
L'alimentation industrielle est addictive
 
La dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écrans
La dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écransLa dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écrans
La dextérité des jeunes chirurgiens mise à mal par l'usage des écrans
 
Emergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evar
Emergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evarEmergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evar
Emergency treatment for type 1 endoleak after evar
 
Fructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcoolique
Fructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcooliqueFructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcoolique
Fructose connexion: la stéato-hépatite non alcoolique
 
Le retour en grâce du gras
Le retour en grâce du grasLe retour en grâce du gras
Le retour en grâce du gras
 
Télémédecine cardiovasculaire
Télémédecine cardiovasculaireTélémédecine cardiovasculaire
Télémédecine cardiovasculaire
 
We need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelines
We need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelinesWe need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelines
We need to revise asymptomatic carotid atheroma guidelines
 
Lait, Fromages et produits laitiers industriels
Lait, Fromages et produits laitiers industrielsLait, Fromages et produits laitiers industriels
Lait, Fromages et produits laitiers industriels
 
Why Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 years
Why Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 yearsWhy Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 years
Why Numerus clausus failed in France since 40 years
 
Statines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usage
Statines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usageStatines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usage
Statines en France: éléments de preuves pour favoriser le bon usage
 
Numerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ans
Numerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ansNumerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ans
Numerus Clausus: les mauvais résultats d'un système depuis 40 ans
 
Les repas paléo aujourd'hui
Les repas paléo aujourd'huiLes repas paléo aujourd'hui
Les repas paléo aujourd'hui
 
Le régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athérome
Le régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athéromeLe régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athérome
Le régime anti-inflammatoire dans l'athérome
 
Paris Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oil
Paris Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oilParis Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oil
Paris Palm Oil Symposium: CVD and palm oil
 

Recently uploaded

FUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam Iqbal
FUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam IqbalFUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam Iqbal
FUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam Iqbal
Zain Umar
 
Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...
Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...
Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...
Trustlife
 
Interpretation of ECG - Cardiac Arrhythmias
Interpretation of ECG - Cardiac ArrhythmiasInterpretation of ECG - Cardiac Arrhythmias
Interpretation of ECG - Cardiac Arrhythmias
MedicoseAcademics
 
medical law and ethics presentation .ppt
medical law and ethics presentation .pptmedical law and ethics presentation .ppt
medical law and ethics presentation .ppt
PseudoPocket
 
MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1
MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1
MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1
kavyanshiverma75
 
NUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdf
NUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdfNUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdf
NUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdf
MatsikoAlex
 
High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...
High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...
High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...
hf66550
 
Prostatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptx
Prostatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptxProstatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptx
Prostatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptx
AmandaChou9
 
Approach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptx
Approach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptxApproach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptx
Approach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptx
Bipul Thakur
 
Clinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nerves
Clinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nervesClinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nerves
Clinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nerves
DrpoonamHealthclinic
 
Text book of comprehensive Medical Surgical Nursing
Text book of comprehensive Medical Surgical NursingText book of comprehensive Medical Surgical Nursing
Text book of comprehensive Medical Surgical Nursing
BP KOIRALA INSTITUTE OF HELATH SCIENCS,, NEPAL
 
How to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptx
How to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptxHow to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptx
How to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptx
AmandaChou9
 
Drug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptx
Drug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptxDrug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptx
Drug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptx
drebrahiim
 
Therapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptx
Therapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptxTherapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptx
Therapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptx
vidyariner7
 
Types of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and Cyanosis
Types of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and CyanosisTypes of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and Cyanosis
Types of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and Cyanosis
MedicoseAcademics
 
Care and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptx
Care and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptxCare and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptx
Care and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptx
Dr. Jagroop Singh
 
Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024
Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024
Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024
Anindya Das Adhikary
 
selllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptx
selllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptxselllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptx
selllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptx
Joebest8
 
POTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptx
POTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptxPOTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptx
POTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptx
souravpaul769171
 
lessonplan JTR.pptx For medical education
lessonplan JTR.pptx For medical educationlessonplan JTR.pptx For medical education
lessonplan JTR.pptx For medical education
DrJALAGAMTHIRUPATHIR
 

Recently uploaded (20)

FUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam Iqbal
FUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam IqbalFUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam Iqbal
FUNCTIONAL DYSPEPSIA by Dr. Maryam Iqbal
 
Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...
Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...
Article - Design and evaluation of novel inhibitors for the treatment of clea...
 
Interpretation of ECG - Cardiac Arrhythmias
Interpretation of ECG - Cardiac ArrhythmiasInterpretation of ECG - Cardiac Arrhythmias
Interpretation of ECG - Cardiac Arrhythmias
 
medical law and ethics presentation .ppt
medical law and ethics presentation .pptmedical law and ethics presentation .ppt
medical law and ethics presentation .ppt
 
MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1
MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1
MALARIA- PowerPoint presentation pptx part 1
 
NUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdf
NUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdfNUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdf
NUTRICONNECT NEWSLETTER 3RD ISSUE 2ND VOLUME.pdf
 
High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...
High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...
High Girls Call Ranchi 000XX00000 Provide Best And Top Girl Service And No1 i...
 
Prostatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptx
Prostatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptxProstatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptx
Prostatitis Severity- How to Determine if You Have Mild Symptoms.pptx
 
Approach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptx
Approach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptxApproach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptx
Approach to Head Injuiry, Intracranial Pressure Measurement and Management.pptx
 
Clinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nerves
Clinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nervesClinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nerves
Clinical examination of- CRANIAL.- nerves
 
Text book of comprehensive Medical Surgical Nursing
Text book of comprehensive Medical Surgical NursingText book of comprehensive Medical Surgical Nursing
Text book of comprehensive Medical Surgical Nursing
 
How to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptx
How to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptxHow to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptx
How to Relieve Prostate Congestion- Here are some Effective Strategies.pptx
 
Drug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptx
Drug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptxDrug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptx
Drug Repurposing for Parasitic Diseases.pptx
 
Therapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptx
Therapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptxTherapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptx
Therapeutic modalities ( Psychopharmacology).pptx
 
Types of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and Cyanosis
Types of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and CyanosisTypes of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and Cyanosis
Types of Hypoxia, Hypercapnia, and Cyanosis
 
Care and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptx
Care and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptxCare and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptx
Care and Maintenance of Laboratory Equipment in Histotechnology.pptx
 
Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024
Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024
Amygdala Medi-Trivia Quiz (Prelims) | FAQ 2024
 
selllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptx
selllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptxselllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptx
selllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.pptx
 
POTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptx
POTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptxPOTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptx
POTENTIAL TARGET DISEASES FOR GENE THERAPY SOURAV.pptx
 
lessonplan JTR.pptx For medical education
lessonplan JTR.pptx For medical educationlessonplan JTR.pptx For medical education
lessonplan JTR.pptx For medical education
 

Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet

  • 1. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 1/12 European Scientist Join our newsletter EN Home » Features » Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet - Features - Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet By Guy-André Pelouze - 16.10.2019 Con ict of interest: The author received no fee nor grant for this commentary. He is personally omnivorous and practices thoracic and cardiovascular surgery.   THERE IS, OBVIOUSLY, SINCE THE END OF WWII, A BATTLE IN THE FIELD OF HUMAN NUTRITION: ANIMAL PRODUCTS ARE VILIFIED BY SOME ACADEMICS ON THE GROUNDS OF STUDIES WHICH MERELY ARE OBSERVATIONAL. The same academics took power and heavily in uenced the nutritional guidelines. This is why of cial recommendations regarding of human health and political decisions stir up some very disputed assertions. This short opinion published in the BMJ[1] sums up them very interestingly. Tim Spector and Christopher Gardner (subsequently named the “authors”)  Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • 2. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 2/12 discussed the recent recommendations issued by Canadian researchers from Mac Master University[2] that there is no evidence to cut on red meat because of health risks. They warn against the work of these Canadian researchers who recently demonstrated that one might be skeptical on scienti c evidence of the red meat bashing. It is not surprising that such a skeptical attitude is unbearable for those who believe that the weak and inconstant associations between meat consumption and chronic diseases –even death – are non- questionable.  It does not matter to them that in those studies the type of meat was very imprecise, as the type of transformation, that those associations were mainly found in quartiles of high consumption and predominate in groups of people with risky lifestyle (male sex, smoking, alcohol). More generally this debate, whatever its polarization, is not only a methodological one or a civilization issue; it is simply a question of ef ciency in the actual battle against diabesity.  As a physician, this is the aim of our commitment to patients because diabesity is a public health priority. The worldwide prevalence of overweight and obesity has approximately doubled since 1980. Nearly a third of the world’s population is now overweight or obese. Obesity rates have increased in all ages and both sexes irrespective of geographical locality, ethnicity or socioeconomic status. This trend is similar across regions and countries, although absolute prevalence rates of overweight and obesity varied widely. In this battle, this is not an opinion, academic authors and governments failed to tackle the problem by promoting their well-known food pyramids[3]. On the other hand, red meat consumption is not at the origin of this number one problem in public health.   IT IS SIMPLE BUT, FOR SCIENTISTS, IT IS FUNDAMENTAL TO POINT OUT THAT THE AUTHORS BEGAN THEIR PIECE WITH SIGNIFICANT CONFUSION. Bacon is not red meat. In mixing them authors perfectly exempli ed the huge risk of error in observational studies. The reason why those studies are imprecise, weak and without any evidence of causality whatsoever. On the contrary, randomization will balance this kind of mistakes and control of diet will suppress them. In mixing bacon, red meat, processed meats and environmental issues authors deliberately began to add incomprehensiveness to an already complex issue. As it is their mantra they continued in this path.  “The criteria are well suited to studies of pharmaceuticals when there are randomized, double-blind, placebo- controlled trials available, but not for studies of meat, eggs, vegetables or any speci c food.” No. It is nonsense to make a rule for drugs and another for diets. Simply this is the heart of the problem. The high-pro le authors, evoked in this opinion piece, made their career by making such a double standard an obvious knowledge and at the same time selling their observational studies with a low association between factors as fuzzy as the Mediterranean diet, grains, fat, dairy or meat… It is a shame that observational studies on diet of 10 years or more were published with only one or two assessments by self-reported questionnaires at the beginning of the “prospective” study. Aside from the fact that other academic authors and organisations disagree with this impossibility to do RCT in diets, several very high- quality papers were published and recently. Kevin D. Hall did such RCT which shows that  Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • 3. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 3/12 junk food causes weight gain on a short time basis[4]. So, patients and physicians are worth high-quality studies. There are several innovative paths to get rid of observational studies. The rst is the RCT. For instance, RCT brings quality information in order to help to solve the obesity epidemics that high pro le nutritionists failed to curb. It is untrue to assert: “Given that RCTs with foods or food groups are not possible”. By designing RCT it is possible to precisely assess each type of food or food group in the setting of a clear hypothesis. The second is the use of genetic variants as instruments to test the causal associations[5].  The third is personalised nutrition which is the way to discriminate the effects of nutriments or carcinogens on different genomes and epigenomes[6]. Authors chose the weakest evidence, aka association of factors because they are reluctant to embark on causality studies.   FURTHERMORE THE AUTHORS MADE TWO ASSERTIONS IN THE SAME SENTENCE WHICH ARE NOT RELEVANT TO RED MEAT. “The authors also chose to leave out all arti cial ex-vivo lab studies and animal studies, included in other meta-analyses, that have, for example, implicated nitrites or acrylamides as carcinogens. “ The carcinogens quoted are totally out of the subject. Is it necessary to point out that nitrites and acrylamide are not present in red meat? How this could be possible in a peer-reviewed opinion? Technically, processed meat means pork, beef or duck that has been salted and cured, with or without smoking. A fresh pound of red meat is not processed. A hard stick of cured salami is. The health risk of bacon, if any, is largely to do with two food additives: potassium nitrate (also known as saltpetre) and sodium nitrite. On the other hand, major food sources of acrylamide are French fries and potato chips; but also, crackers, bread, and cookies; breakfast cereals those last foods that high-pro le nutritionists advise eating if they are made of “whole our”. Furthermore, animal studies and other “mechanistic studies” are not relevant to the new strict analysis of the observational studies about red meat by Canadian authors. Indeed, animal and mechanistic studies are only warning studies for launching clinical trials. No more no less. And another time the great carnivores do not exhibit cancers or CVD after eating meat all their lives. An example of aw animal study is to give meat to a non-carnivore as it is a poor mechanistic study to give a high-fat diet to rabbits to explain atheroma. Last but not least they didn’t mention the 2010 review which showed that eating charred, smoked, well done red meat is associated with a higher risk of colorectal cancer only in smokers[7]! Interestingly one of the studies reviewed in this paper[8] didn’t nd any association between well done or very well-done meat (processed or not) and health issues below 5 steaks/week. We are very near to the advice of the Canadian authors who concluded that until 3 steaks per week there is no measurable risk. In order to understand the complexity of the issue of cancer and meat consumption we need to be clear about the potential causes. It is rather surprising that they didn’t mention the proven carcinogens in high temperature cooked red or processed meat: heterocyclic amines and  Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • 4. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 4/12 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. These organic compounds which are also produced by high-temperature cooking of white meat, sh and vegetable protein although in less quantity are not present in fresh meat nor in low temperature cooked meat.   THEN THEY CAME TO THE DEMONSTRATION THAT CANADIAN AUTHORS CHERRY-PICKED STUDIES IN THEIR META-ANALYSIS. Authors argued that Canadian researchers eliminated some observational studies in order to bias the nal results. They point out the eviction of Lyon heart study and PREDIMED but they don’t prove that taking into account these studies would have changed the conclusions of the revision meta-analysis about red meat. Doing that, they again delegitimated observational studies. Indeed, meta-analysis of RCT are far less subjected to contest; if red meat consumption is the hypothesis to test, you cannot eliminate an RCT which stated that. In observational studies, the selection is a very complex process as their design and the modelling of multivariate analysis in uence the results. Eventually, they agreed with Canadian authors: “Previous summaries, which have been more inclusive, have shown modest health risks for red meat, but clear links between processed meat, heart disease and early death. The evidence for cancer causation is less clear-cut, and several trials of meat reduction have not resulted in lowering of cancer risks. “ In the same paragraph, they also recognize that the issue is not red meat but junk food, a point we strongly agree with. Nonetheless, RCT are very rare despite being more powerful than dozens of observational studies.   THEN COME THE FOLLOWING STATEMENTS WHICH ARE ONLY AUTHORS’ OPINION. They wrote: “but in our view, we should all be eating less meat and more high bre, nutrient- dense foods that include many vegetables, legumes, fruits and nuts and seeds.” We were waiting for a better backing than wishful thinking and political correctness. This advice is no more than a copy/paste of the average, standardized, non-personalised nutritional guidelines which proved to be meaningless and inef cient. Nonsense. BACK TO THE OPINION PIECE I WANT TO POINT OUT TWO ERRORS THAT WERE MADE AT THE END. FIRST, WHY REIGNITE A CONTROVERSY IN A BIASED MANNER? They compare the review articles about meat with an, according to them, a complacent subsidised paper about sugar from the same lead author. Making it short, the Canadian meat meta-analysis would be corrupted by a precedent study on sugar because of hidden con ict of interests. It is a concern. But one may wonder why the EAT-Lancet initiative that they also quoted is not under the same scrutiny? It is suspicious to imply that government subsidies, non-pro t organisation subsidies or any other subsidy are neutral… In order to get out of this Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • 5. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 5/12 biased debate, I think we don’t need such a suspicion. It is only a matter of good sense or bayesian evidence: we eat sugar approximately since 1800 and meat since at least 500 000 years. That could help in nding the truth.   SECOND, IT IS HARD TO BELIEVE THAT THE AUTHORS DECIDED TO CONCLUDE THEIR OPINION PIECE BY A SO PREDICTABLE GREENWASHING.   The EAT-Lancet initiative that they quoted, is not a new study. It is not a meta-analysis. It is indeed a very sophisticated but biased piece of statistical manipulation in order to impose not less meat but a vegan diet. Their opinion is respectable as long as they state it sincerely. I think that this kind of reasoning is reductionistic as it leads to blaming all people around the planet for eating too much meat. While for instance, south European people eat a very moderate amount of meat and numerous other populations don’t eat suf cient animal products and suffer several de ciencies. It is the same reasoning which is used by bad teachers who punish all the classroom instead of targeting those who are making the heckling. Again, this assertion is not backed by evidence. All agricultural practices have been found to have a variety of effects on the environment. Some of the environmental effects that have been associated with meat production are pollution through fossil fuel usage, animal methane, ef uent waste, and water and land consumption. The issue is destructive farming, not whether you eat meat or dairy or vegetables or grains. Another issue is the quantum of those impacts. Contrary to different assertions in the different EAT-Lancet papers, the matter of anthropogenic emissions is extremely complex and still poorly known in details. Particularly meat production is a multifactorial process which is managed very differently in different countries and according to ancestral or industrial practices. The amount of direct GHG emissions of animal husbandry is 2,3 GigaTons of CO2 equivalent id est 5% and indirect GHG emissions linked to all meat, eggs and dairy products are 4,8 gigatons of CO2 equivalent per year or 9.5% of all anthropogenic emissions. It is important to address these emissions with rationality that is why indirect emissions are the true target, not animals. Indirect emissions are the most important and are largely improvable through energy transition and other agricultural practices, the same means used in other sectors of agriculture. Direct emissions are less avoidable but represent only half of the indirect GHG emissions. As a matter of fact, in the United States 60% of calories come from re ned sugar, re ned grains and re ned omega-6 seed oils, which is saying that meat consumption does not have a prominent role in obesity and type 2 diabetes. It is remarkable that carbs and vegetable oils are recommended by food pyramids. In a recent paper[9], C. Christie et al brought the evidence that excess calories, whatever it comes from, do have a big environmental impact. Among those excess calories, processed foods have a bigger impact in general because they need more energy to be produced, packaged, transported and nally more frequently treated  Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • 6. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 6/12 as waste. Excess calories are consumed in developed countries[10], but it is not meat which brings calories in excess because meat and poultry are composed of naturally occurring water, muscle, connective tissue, fat, and bone. The muscle is approximately 75% water (although different cuts may have more or less water) and 20% protein, with the remaining 5% representing a combination of fat, carbohydrates, and minerals. On the contrary, sugar and fats in processed foods, which are in excess, are packed in very dense foods with minimal water increasing signi cantly the number of calories per day.     FINALLY, WE HAVE TO RECALL THE NUTRITIONAL ADVANTAGES OF MEAT FOR HUMANS A LIFELONG. Meat is a very good source of nutritionally complete and digestible proteins, bioavailable iron, zinc, and selenium and the exclusive source of vitamin B12. Consumption of red meat has decreased since 2000 in developed countries and the average consumption in Europe is around three portions a week. This amount of red meat is not associated with any increased risk in observational studies. When consumed, meat and offal have an important role in maintaining good health through its supply of high-quality nutrients. In the setting of a exitarian diet like shown in the blue zone countries, the bene ts of meat add those of sh and seafood, more high bre, plant-based foods, with the nutritional durability of an omnivorous diet. Red meat bashing is against human ancestral diet and will increase human health issues. We should think twice before throwing away red meat production together with fossil fuels because of environmental issues. There are smarter paths to curb anthropogenic emissions without endangering human health.   [1] https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2019/10/09/bacon-rashers-statistics-and-controversy/? fbclid=IwAR2453O8TZURygfDz3cz4871bsXTAHhHJ16mhKDHnq7p_3-zjJacTRMmnII [2] https://annals.org/aim/fullarticle/2752328/unprocessed-red-meat-processed-meat- consumption-dietary-guideline-recommendations-from [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30253139 [4] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31105044 [5] https://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2019/06/05/db19-0153 [6] https://www.bmj.com/content/361/bmj.k2173 [7] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2769029/ [8] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0027510702001641?via%3Dihub  Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • 7. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 7/12 [9] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5799208/ [10] http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/FBS/visualize SHARE meat bashing nutrition observational studies Red meat GUY-ANDRÉ PELOUZE Guy-André Pelouze is a renowned surgeon with a keen interest for the progress made in his eld of work. He pays close attention to changes in doctor’s working conditions and systemic evolutions that affect the standard of care for patients. Like this: Like Be the first to like this. Related How to meet both dietary health and sustainability goals in the future Everything that 2018 teaches us about scienti c communication A surge in antimicrobial resistance threatens the livestock industry 18.09.2019 In "Agriculture" 20.12.2018 In "Editor's choice" 24.09.2019 In "Agriculture"  Privacy & Cookies Policy
  • 8. 16/10/2019 Red meat bashing and human ancestral diet https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/features/red-meat-bashing-and-human-ancestral-diet/ 8/12  Privacy & Cookies Policy