SlideShare a Scribd company logo
On the Axiom of Choice
Flora Dellini
Marco Natale
Francesco Urso
Preliminary
›For every set S, a set U is a subset of S
if, for every item in U, this item belongs to
S too.
›For every set S, we define the set of the
parts of S, P(S), as the set of all the
possible subsets of S.
Example:
𝑆 = 1,2,3
𝑃 𝑆 = {∅, 1 , 2 , 3 , 1,2 , 1,3 , 2,3 , {1,2,3}}
The Axiom of Choice (AC)
› The Axiom of Choice is a statement about the
existence of a certain kind of functions.
› A choice function is a function which selects an
item from a subset of a given set.
› AC claims that, for every group of subsets of S,
there exists a function of choice which selects a
particular item from every given subset.
∀𝑆, ∀𝑈 ⊆ 𝑃 𝑆 ∅, ∃𝑓: 𝑈 → 𝑆
such that ∀𝑋 ∈ 𝑈, 𝑓(𝑋) ∈ 𝑋
AC: Examples with finite sets
When a set is finite, everything is trivial. The
existence of f is not disputable: we can actually
show and build it!
𝑆 = 1,2,3,4,5
𝑈 = { 1 , 1,2,3 , 2,3 , 3,4,5 } ⊆ 𝑃(𝑆)
𝑓: 𝑈 ⊆ 𝑃(𝑆){∅} → 𝑆
𝑓 1 = 1 ∈ 1
𝑓 1,2,3 = 3 ∈ 1,2,3
𝑓 2,3 = 2 ∈ 2,3
𝑓 3,4,5 = 5 ∈ 3,4,5
AC: Examples of Infinite Sets
Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks
› Let’s suppose there is a shop with infinite pair of
shoes, we want to built an infinite set containing
a shoe for each pair.
› A Turing machine (i.e. a personal computer) can
choose between right or left shoe because it
can distinguish them. For example we can build
the set of all right shoes.
› Can we do the same with
infinite pair of socks?
AC: Examples of Infinite Sets
Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks
› A machine can not do it while a man could do.
› The reason is: right and left shoes can be
distinguished due to this feature. A man can do
this, a machine can do it too.
› It is not possible to choose right or left socks,
because there are no such things as right or left
socks!
› As a consequence, in principle, a compuer can
not build the wanted set.
AC: Examples of Infinite Sets
Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks
›Could a man build a set from a single
sock for each pair?
›Actually, it is impossible, because we
would die before we can name all the
items in the set.
›But is it possible in principle? How can we
distinguish between the socks of a pair?
›We do this by choosing “this one”, without
any criterion but our free will.
AC: Examples of Infinite Sets
Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks
›As human beings, it is in our everyday
experience that we can distinguish
between two socks by calling «this
one» or «that one».
›Is it admissible that in maths it is also
possible to act in such a way?
›The answer is far from trivial!
The Way of Formalism
› The mathematical concept of Set raised up in
XIX century by Georg Cantor (1845-1918).
› Cantor’s idea of Set was a “collection” of
“objects” which satisfy certain properties (e.g.
“the set of all odd numbers”, “the set of all the
right shoes”).
› Paradoxes arise from a “too free” use of the
concept of “property”.
The Way of Formalism
› Russell Paradoxes: the set of all the sets which
don’t contain themselves.
› The problem is in the semantic.
› D. Hilbert’s “Formalism” school proposed the
reduction of mathematics to a pure “formal
game”. In this way, Mathematics would have
been stripped of all its “human components”.
The Way of Formalism
› Zermelo and Fraenkel, following Hilbert’s intuition,
began to develop the Formal Set Theory (also
known as ZF).
› In according to the formalistic concept of
mathematics, the semantic in ZF is “eliminated”
reducing the concept of proprieties to pure
syntactic formulas, computable in principle by a
machine.
› The nature of Sets is so implicitly defined by
syntactic formulas.
The Way of Formalism
›The validity of a formula must be
determined through “propositional
calculus”, an absolutely formal procedure
which can be, theoretically, implemented
on an ideal machine.
›E.g. instead of saying “there is the empty
set”, we shall write the following formula:
∃𝑦 ∀𝑥 (𝑥 ∉ 𝑦)
The Axioms of Zermelo-Fraenkel
1. Axioms describing implicitly the concept of Set
(Regularity and Extensionality Axioms).
2. Axiom of Existence. The unique axiom of
existence in ZF is the Axiom of Infinity, which
asserts that there exists an infinite set.
3. Axioms of Individuation, which allow us to
“individuate” (i.e. build) new sets starting from
ones already known (Axiom of Power Set, Axiom
of Union and Axiom of Replacement).
Is AC compatible with ZF?
› Being compatible means that, if we add AC to ZF,
we cannot deduce a theorem and its negation.
› ZF claims to describe all mathematical universe:
“…with regard to ZF it’s hard to conceive
of any other model”. P. Cohen.
› Because we would like to proceed in maths as we
do with socks, that is by choosing items as we
want to, the compatibility of AC with ZF is highly
desirable.
ZF does not disprove AC
“Inside only ZF, it’s not possible to prove
that AC is false” (Gödel, 1938).
Main steps of proof:
1. Gödel added another axiom to ZF
(“every set is constructible”), obtaining
the stronger theory ZFL.
2. Gödel proved that ZFL is consistent. In
this stronger theory he proved that
every set can be well-ordered, that is a
demonstration of AC. So, ZFL → AC.
ZF does not disprove AC
3. If, by contradiction, AC is false in ZF, it has to
be false also in ZFL. But we have just seen
that AC is true in ZFL! So AC could not be
disproved in ZF.
ZF does not disprove AC!
This does NOT mean that AC is true in ZF
!
ZF does not imply AC
In 1960 Cohen has completed
Gödel’s demonstration about
independence of AC from ZF.
So ZF does not imply AC.
Independence of AC from ZF
As a consequence, we can add or
remove AC from ZF as we like.
So, its presence is actually a
preference of the mathematician who
can want a “richer” or “poorer”
theory.
Theorems we lose without AC
• Every non empty Vectorial Space has a
base
– i.e. imagine that, in the classic Euclidean
3D space, you don’t have the 𝑖, 𝑗, and 𝑘
vectors you use to build every other
vector.
• Every field has an algebraic closure
– i.e. imagine that you could not define the
complex numbers
What does it mean?
“Simply” that there are sets whose volume is not invariant under
translation and rotation.
Strange! Isn’t it?
This is why some mathematicians worry
about the Axiom of Choice
Decomposition of a ball into four pieces which, properly
rotated and traslated, yield two balls
Counterintuitive effects of AC:
Banach-Tarski Paradox
Counterintuitive effects of AC:
Zermelo’s Lemma
This statement is equivalent to the Axiom of
Choice:
Every set S can be well ordered
As a consequence, we could «well order»
ℝ - i.e. defining an order in ℝ such that
every subset of ℝ has a minimum. This
order relation is strongly counterintuitive, as
it implies that sets like (0,1), without a
minimum – 0 ∉ (0,1) do not exist.

More Related Content

What's hot

Sets PowerPoint Presentation
Sets PowerPoint PresentationSets PowerPoint Presentation
Sets PowerPoint Presentation
Ashna Rajput
 
union and intersection of events.ppt
union and intersection of events.pptunion and intersection of events.ppt
union and intersection of events.ppt
Izah Catli
 
Absolute Value
Absolute ValueAbsolute Value
Absolute Value
DC Marie Lagura
 
Linear algebra-Basis & Dimension
Linear algebra-Basis & DimensionLinear algebra-Basis & Dimension
Linear algebra-Basis & Dimension
Manikanta satyala
 
Measures of variability grouped data
Measures of variability grouped dataMeasures of variability grouped data
Measures of variability grouped data
Jean Claudette Tolentino
 
Combinations
CombinationsCombinations
Combinations
Dr. Nirav Vyas
 
Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8
Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8
Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8
DC Marie Lagura
 
Probability 3.4
Probability 3.4Probability 3.4
Probability 3.4
herbison
 
Group abstract algebra
Group  abstract algebraGroup  abstract algebra
Group abstract algebra
NaliniSPatil
 
What is an axiom?
What is an axiom?What is an axiom?
What is an axiom?
Vishesh Kumar
 
Sets and venn diagrams
Sets and venn diagramsSets and venn diagrams
Sets and venn diagrams
Farhana Shaheen
 
5.4 mathematical induction
5.4 mathematical induction5.4 mathematical induction
5.4 mathematical induction
math260
 
Lesson Plan on Basic concept of probability
Lesson Plan on Basic concept of probabilityLesson Plan on Basic concept of probability
Lesson Plan on Basic concept of probability
Lorie Jane Letada
 
Chapter 1, Sets
Chapter   1, SetsChapter   1, Sets
Chapter 1, Sets
Ananya Sharma
 
Set Operations
Set OperationsSet Operations
Set Operations
Bilal Amjad
 
Sets
SetsSets
SET THEORY
SET THEORYSET THEORY
SET THEORY
Lena
 
Abstract algebra i
Abstract algebra iAbstract algebra i
Abstract algebra i
Marco Antonio Moya Silvestre
 
A detailed lesson plan in permutation
A detailed lesson plan in permutationA detailed lesson plan in permutation
A detailed lesson plan in permutation
Ruby Rose Ann Panganod
 
Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)
Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)
Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)
Decena15
 

What's hot (20)

Sets PowerPoint Presentation
Sets PowerPoint PresentationSets PowerPoint Presentation
Sets PowerPoint Presentation
 
union and intersection of events.ppt
union and intersection of events.pptunion and intersection of events.ppt
union and intersection of events.ppt
 
Absolute Value
Absolute ValueAbsolute Value
Absolute Value
 
Linear algebra-Basis & Dimension
Linear algebra-Basis & DimensionLinear algebra-Basis & Dimension
Linear algebra-Basis & Dimension
 
Measures of variability grouped data
Measures of variability grouped dataMeasures of variability grouped data
Measures of variability grouped data
 
Combinations
CombinationsCombinations
Combinations
 
Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8
Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8
Lesson Plan Sample for Grade 8
 
Probability 3.4
Probability 3.4Probability 3.4
Probability 3.4
 
Group abstract algebra
Group  abstract algebraGroup  abstract algebra
Group abstract algebra
 
What is an axiom?
What is an axiom?What is an axiom?
What is an axiom?
 
Sets and venn diagrams
Sets and venn diagramsSets and venn diagrams
Sets and venn diagrams
 
5.4 mathematical induction
5.4 mathematical induction5.4 mathematical induction
5.4 mathematical induction
 
Lesson Plan on Basic concept of probability
Lesson Plan on Basic concept of probabilityLesson Plan on Basic concept of probability
Lesson Plan on Basic concept of probability
 
Chapter 1, Sets
Chapter   1, SetsChapter   1, Sets
Chapter 1, Sets
 
Set Operations
Set OperationsSet Operations
Set Operations
 
Sets
SetsSets
Sets
 
SET THEORY
SET THEORYSET THEORY
SET THEORY
 
Abstract algebra i
Abstract algebra iAbstract algebra i
Abstract algebra i
 
A detailed lesson plan in permutation
A detailed lesson plan in permutationA detailed lesson plan in permutation
A detailed lesson plan in permutation
 
Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)
Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)
Lesson plan in mathematics 9 (illustrations of quadratic equations)
 

Similar to On the axiom of choice

The Mathematical Universe in a Nutshell
The Mathematical Universe in a NutshellThe Mathematical Universe in a Nutshell
The Mathematical Universe in a Nutshell
Kannan Nambiar
 
mechanizing reasoning
mechanizing reasoningmechanizing reasoning
mechanizing reasoning
Rajendran
 
Presentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perception
Presentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perceptionPresentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perception
Presentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perception
Michel Paillet
 
Zeno paradoxes
Zeno paradoxesZeno paradoxes
Zeno paradoxes
Đậu Đậu
 
paper publication
paper publicationpaper publication
paper publication
rikaseorika
 
Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...
Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...
Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...
Lietuvos kompiuterininkų sąjunga
 
Category Theory made easy with (ugly) pictures
Category Theory made easy with (ugly) picturesCategory Theory made easy with (ugly) pictures
Category Theory made easy with (ugly) pictures
Ashwin Rao
 
Euclids postulates
Euclids postulatesEuclids postulates
Euclids postulates
Manthan Somvanshi
 
Standrewstalk
StandrewstalkStandrewstalk
Standrewstalk
Igor Rivin
 
Basics of set theory
Basics of set theoryBasics of set theory
Basics of set theory
Tarun Gehlot
 
Fractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic Model
Fractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic ModelFractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic Model
Fractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic Model
Osman Villanueva
 
lect14-semantics.ppt
lect14-semantics.pptlect14-semantics.ppt
lect14-semantics.ppt
RichardBobisSanAnton
 
True but Unprovable
True but UnprovableTrue but Unprovable
True but Unprovable
Rishi Banerjee
 
Prolog 01
Prolog 01Prolog 01
Prolog 01
saru40
 
Fractals
FractalsFractals
Fractals
guestc5cd98e
 
Albert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General Theory
Albert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General TheoryAlbert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General Theory
Albert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General Theory
Kukuasu
 
The quantum strategy of completeness
The quantum strategy of completenessThe quantum strategy of completeness
The quantum strategy of completeness
Vasil Penchev
 
Second_Update_to my 2013 Paper
Second_Update_to my 2013 PaperSecond_Update_to my 2013 Paper
Second_Update_to my 2013 Paper
Herb Doughty
 
Dialectica and Kolmogorov Problems
Dialectica and Kolmogorov ProblemsDialectica and Kolmogorov Problems
Dialectica and Kolmogorov Problems
Valeria de Paiva
 
The Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
The Many Worlds of Quantum MechanicsThe Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
The Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
Sean Carroll
 

Similar to On the axiom of choice (20)

The Mathematical Universe in a Nutshell
The Mathematical Universe in a NutshellThe Mathematical Universe in a Nutshell
The Mathematical Universe in a Nutshell
 
mechanizing reasoning
mechanizing reasoningmechanizing reasoning
mechanizing reasoning
 
Presentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perception
Presentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perceptionPresentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perception
Presentation X-SHS - 27 oct 2015 - Topologie et perception
 
Zeno paradoxes
Zeno paradoxesZeno paradoxes
Zeno paradoxes
 
paper publication
paper publicationpaper publication
paper publication
 
Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...
Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...
Matricų kombinatorikos taikymas automatų rūšiavimui ir NP ir P automatų klasi...
 
Category Theory made easy with (ugly) pictures
Category Theory made easy with (ugly) picturesCategory Theory made easy with (ugly) pictures
Category Theory made easy with (ugly) pictures
 
Euclids postulates
Euclids postulatesEuclids postulates
Euclids postulates
 
Standrewstalk
StandrewstalkStandrewstalk
Standrewstalk
 
Basics of set theory
Basics of set theoryBasics of set theory
Basics of set theory
 
Fractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic Model
Fractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic ModelFractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic Model
Fractals, Geometry of Nature and Logistic Model
 
lect14-semantics.ppt
lect14-semantics.pptlect14-semantics.ppt
lect14-semantics.ppt
 
True but Unprovable
True but UnprovableTrue but Unprovable
True but Unprovable
 
Prolog 01
Prolog 01Prolog 01
Prolog 01
 
Fractals
FractalsFractals
Fractals
 
Albert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General Theory
Albert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General TheoryAlbert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General Theory
Albert Einstein (2) Relativity Special And General Theory
 
The quantum strategy of completeness
The quantum strategy of completenessThe quantum strategy of completeness
The quantum strategy of completeness
 
Second_Update_to my 2013 Paper
Second_Update_to my 2013 PaperSecond_Update_to my 2013 Paper
Second_Update_to my 2013 Paper
 
Dialectica and Kolmogorov Problems
Dialectica and Kolmogorov ProblemsDialectica and Kolmogorov Problems
Dialectica and Kolmogorov Problems
 
The Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
The Many Worlds of Quantum MechanicsThe Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
The Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
 

More from 2idseminar

The importance of being human 3
The importance of being human 3The importance of being human 3
The importance of being human 3
2idseminar
 
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriageCan christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
2idseminar
 
The unlimited desire IIS2019
The unlimited desire IIS2019The unlimited desire IIS2019
The unlimited desire IIS2019
2idseminar
 
Causality from outside Time
Causality from outside TimeCausality from outside Time
Causality from outside Time
2idseminar
 
Can computers replace teachers?
Can computers replace teachers?Can computers replace teachers?
Can computers replace teachers?
2idseminar
 
Future contingents and the Multiverse
Future contingents and the MultiverseFuture contingents and the Multiverse
Future contingents and the Multiverse
2idseminar
 
The CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humans
The CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humansThe CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humans
The CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humans
2idseminar
 
Achilles, the Tortoise and Quantum Mechanics
Achilles, the Tortoise and Quantum MechanicsAchilles, the Tortoise and Quantum Mechanics
Achilles, the Tortoise and Quantum Mechanics
2idseminar
 
Transpostgenderism 5 jean_davidponci
Transpostgenderism 5 jean_davidponciTranspostgenderism 5 jean_davidponci
Transpostgenderism 5 jean_davidponci
2idseminar
 
Transhumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brainTranshumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brain
2idseminar
 
Transhumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brainTranshumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brain
2idseminar
 
Netherhall 2018 m fox
Netherhall 2018 m foxNetherhall 2018 m fox
Netherhall 2018 m fox
2idseminar
 
Sequential processing in nature
Sequential processing in natureSequential processing in nature
Sequential processing in nature
2idseminar
 
Infinite Chess: winning and draw
Infinite Chess: winning and drawInfinite Chess: winning and draw
Infinite Chess: winning and draw
2idseminar
 

More from 2idseminar (14)

The importance of being human 3
The importance of being human 3The importance of being human 3
The importance of being human 3
 
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriageCan christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
Can christian schools continue to teach only about traditional marriage
 
The unlimited desire IIS2019
The unlimited desire IIS2019The unlimited desire IIS2019
The unlimited desire IIS2019
 
Causality from outside Time
Causality from outside TimeCausality from outside Time
Causality from outside Time
 
Can computers replace teachers?
Can computers replace teachers?Can computers replace teachers?
Can computers replace teachers?
 
Future contingents and the Multiverse
Future contingents and the MultiverseFuture contingents and the Multiverse
Future contingents and the Multiverse
 
The CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humans
The CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humansThe CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humans
The CRISPR/CAS9 genome editing system and humans
 
Achilles, the Tortoise and Quantum Mechanics
Achilles, the Tortoise and Quantum MechanicsAchilles, the Tortoise and Quantum Mechanics
Achilles, the Tortoise and Quantum Mechanics
 
Transpostgenderism 5 jean_davidponci
Transpostgenderism 5 jean_davidponciTranspostgenderism 5 jean_davidponci
Transpostgenderism 5 jean_davidponci
 
Transhumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brainTranshumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brain
 
Transhumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brainTranshumanism and brain
Transhumanism and brain
 
Netherhall 2018 m fox
Netherhall 2018 m foxNetherhall 2018 m fox
Netherhall 2018 m fox
 
Sequential processing in nature
Sequential processing in natureSequential processing in nature
Sequential processing in nature
 
Infinite Chess: winning and draw
Infinite Chess: winning and drawInfinite Chess: winning and draw
Infinite Chess: winning and draw
 

Recently uploaded

Gasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpective
Gasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpectiveGasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpective
Gasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpective
Recupera
 
Bragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptx
Bragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptxBragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptx
Bragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptx
Lisandro Cunci
 
Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)
Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)
Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)
vanshgarg8002
 
How Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdf
How Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdfHow Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdf
How Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdf
Task Train
 
Review Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPY
Review Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPYReview Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPY
Review Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPY
niranjangiri009
 
SCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptx
SCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptxSCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptx
SCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptx
WALTONMARBRUCAL
 
Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...
Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...
Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...
Sérgio Sacani
 
Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...
Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...
Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...
Travis Hills MN
 
ANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDE
ANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDEANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDE
ANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDE
RanjithaSL
 
[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf
[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf
[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf
PANDURANGLAWATE1
 
The Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary Track
The Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary TrackThe Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary Track
The Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary Track
Sérgio Sacani
 
LOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratory
LOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratoryLOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratory
LOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratory
JCKH
 
Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...
Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...
Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...
Sérgio Sacani
 
smallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptx
smallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptxsmallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptx
smallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptx
muralinath2
 
El Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdf
El Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdfEl Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdf
El Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdf
Champs Elysee Roldan
 
Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...
Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...
Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...
Hossein Fani
 
MCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII pptx
MCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII  pptxMCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII  pptx
MCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII pptx
ArunachalamM22
 
Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)
Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)
Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)
Robert Luk
 
Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...
Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...
Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...
University of Maribor
 
A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...
A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...
A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...
Sérgio Sacani
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Gasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpective
Gasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpectiveGasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpective
Gasification and Pyrolyssis of plastic Waste under a Circular Economy perpective
 
Bragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptx
Bragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptxBragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptx
Bragg Brentano Alignment for D4 with LynxEye Rev3.pptx
 
Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)
Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)
Introduction to Space (Our Solar System)
 
How Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdf
How Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdfHow Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdf
How Does TaskTrain Integrate Workflow and Project Management Efficiently.pdf
 
Review Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPY
Review Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPYReview Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPY
Review Article:- A REVIEW ON RADIOISOTOPES IN CANCER THERAPY
 
SCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptx
SCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptxSCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptx
SCIENCEgfvhvhvkjkbbjjbbjvhvhvhvjkvjvjvjj.pptx
 
Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...
Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...
Transmission Spectroscopy of the Habitable Zone Exoplanet LHS 1140 b with JWS...
 
Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...
Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...
Travis Hills of Minnesota Sets a New Standard in Carbon Credits With Livestoc...
 
ANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDE
ANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDEANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDE
ANTIGENS_.pptx ( Ranjitha SL) PRESENTATION SLIDE
 
[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf
[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf
[1] Data Mining - Concepts and Techniques (3rd Ed).pdf
 
The Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary Track
The Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary TrackThe Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary Track
The Dynamical Origins of the Dark Comets and a Proposed Evolutionary Track
 
LOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratory
LOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratoryLOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratory
LOB LOD LOQ for method validation in laboratory
 
Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...
Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...
Possible Anthropogenic Contributions to the LAMP-observed Surficial Icy Regol...
 
smallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptx
smallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptxsmallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptx
smallintestinedisorders-causessymptoms-240626042532-363e8392.pptx
 
El Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdf
El Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdfEl Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdf
El Nuevo Cohete Ariane de la Agencia Espacial Europea-6_Media-Kit_english.pdf
 
Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...
Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...
Collaborative Team Recommendation for Skilled Users: Objectives, Techniques, ...
 
MCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII pptx
MCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII  pptxMCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII  pptx
MCQ in Electrostatics. for class XII pptx
 
Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)
Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)
Testing the Son of God Hypothesis (Jesus Christ)
 
Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...
Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...
Modelling, Simulation, and Computer-aided Design in Computational, Evolutiona...
 
A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...
A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...
A slightly oblate dark matter halo revealed by a retrograde precessing Galact...
 

On the axiom of choice

  • 1. On the Axiom of Choice Flora Dellini Marco Natale Francesco Urso
  • 2. Preliminary ›For every set S, a set U is a subset of S if, for every item in U, this item belongs to S too. ›For every set S, we define the set of the parts of S, P(S), as the set of all the possible subsets of S. Example: 𝑆 = 1,2,3 𝑃 𝑆 = {∅, 1 , 2 , 3 , 1,2 , 1,3 , 2,3 , {1,2,3}}
  • 3. The Axiom of Choice (AC) › The Axiom of Choice is a statement about the existence of a certain kind of functions. › A choice function is a function which selects an item from a subset of a given set. › AC claims that, for every group of subsets of S, there exists a function of choice which selects a particular item from every given subset. ∀𝑆, ∀𝑈 ⊆ 𝑃 𝑆 ∅, ∃𝑓: 𝑈 → 𝑆 such that ∀𝑋 ∈ 𝑈, 𝑓(𝑋) ∈ 𝑋
  • 4. AC: Examples with finite sets When a set is finite, everything is trivial. The existence of f is not disputable: we can actually show and build it! 𝑆 = 1,2,3,4,5 𝑈 = { 1 , 1,2,3 , 2,3 , 3,4,5 } ⊆ 𝑃(𝑆) 𝑓: 𝑈 ⊆ 𝑃(𝑆){∅} → 𝑆 𝑓 1 = 1 ∈ 1 𝑓 1,2,3 = 3 ∈ 1,2,3 𝑓 2,3 = 2 ∈ 2,3 𝑓 3,4,5 = 5 ∈ 3,4,5
  • 5. AC: Examples of Infinite Sets Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks › Let’s suppose there is a shop with infinite pair of shoes, we want to built an infinite set containing a shoe for each pair. › A Turing machine (i.e. a personal computer) can choose between right or left shoe because it can distinguish them. For example we can build the set of all right shoes. › Can we do the same with infinite pair of socks?
  • 6. AC: Examples of Infinite Sets Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks › A machine can not do it while a man could do. › The reason is: right and left shoes can be distinguished due to this feature. A man can do this, a machine can do it too. › It is not possible to choose right or left socks, because there are no such things as right or left socks! › As a consequence, in principle, a compuer can not build the wanted set.
  • 7. AC: Examples of Infinite Sets Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks ›Could a man build a set from a single sock for each pair? ›Actually, it is impossible, because we would die before we can name all the items in the set. ›But is it possible in principle? How can we distinguish between the socks of a pair? ›We do this by choosing “this one”, without any criterion but our free will.
  • 8. AC: Examples of Infinite Sets Hilbert’s Shoes and Socks ›As human beings, it is in our everyday experience that we can distinguish between two socks by calling «this one» or «that one». ›Is it admissible that in maths it is also possible to act in such a way? ›The answer is far from trivial!
  • 9. The Way of Formalism › The mathematical concept of Set raised up in XIX century by Georg Cantor (1845-1918). › Cantor’s idea of Set was a “collection” of “objects” which satisfy certain properties (e.g. “the set of all odd numbers”, “the set of all the right shoes”). › Paradoxes arise from a “too free” use of the concept of “property”.
  • 10. The Way of Formalism › Russell Paradoxes: the set of all the sets which don’t contain themselves. › The problem is in the semantic. › D. Hilbert’s “Formalism” school proposed the reduction of mathematics to a pure “formal game”. In this way, Mathematics would have been stripped of all its “human components”.
  • 11. The Way of Formalism › Zermelo and Fraenkel, following Hilbert’s intuition, began to develop the Formal Set Theory (also known as ZF). › In according to the formalistic concept of mathematics, the semantic in ZF is “eliminated” reducing the concept of proprieties to pure syntactic formulas, computable in principle by a machine. › The nature of Sets is so implicitly defined by syntactic formulas.
  • 12. The Way of Formalism ›The validity of a formula must be determined through “propositional calculus”, an absolutely formal procedure which can be, theoretically, implemented on an ideal machine. ›E.g. instead of saying “there is the empty set”, we shall write the following formula: ∃𝑦 ∀𝑥 (𝑥 ∉ 𝑦)
  • 13. The Axioms of Zermelo-Fraenkel 1. Axioms describing implicitly the concept of Set (Regularity and Extensionality Axioms). 2. Axiom of Existence. The unique axiom of existence in ZF is the Axiom of Infinity, which asserts that there exists an infinite set. 3. Axioms of Individuation, which allow us to “individuate” (i.e. build) new sets starting from ones already known (Axiom of Power Set, Axiom of Union and Axiom of Replacement).
  • 14. Is AC compatible with ZF? › Being compatible means that, if we add AC to ZF, we cannot deduce a theorem and its negation. › ZF claims to describe all mathematical universe: “…with regard to ZF it’s hard to conceive of any other model”. P. Cohen. › Because we would like to proceed in maths as we do with socks, that is by choosing items as we want to, the compatibility of AC with ZF is highly desirable.
  • 15. ZF does not disprove AC “Inside only ZF, it’s not possible to prove that AC is false” (Gödel, 1938). Main steps of proof: 1. Gödel added another axiom to ZF (“every set is constructible”), obtaining the stronger theory ZFL. 2. Gödel proved that ZFL is consistent. In this stronger theory he proved that every set can be well-ordered, that is a demonstration of AC. So, ZFL → AC.
  • 16. ZF does not disprove AC 3. If, by contradiction, AC is false in ZF, it has to be false also in ZFL. But we have just seen that AC is true in ZFL! So AC could not be disproved in ZF. ZF does not disprove AC! This does NOT mean that AC is true in ZF !
  • 17. ZF does not imply AC In 1960 Cohen has completed Gödel’s demonstration about independence of AC from ZF. So ZF does not imply AC.
  • 18. Independence of AC from ZF As a consequence, we can add or remove AC from ZF as we like. So, its presence is actually a preference of the mathematician who can want a “richer” or “poorer” theory.
  • 19. Theorems we lose without AC • Every non empty Vectorial Space has a base – i.e. imagine that, in the classic Euclidean 3D space, you don’t have the 𝑖, 𝑗, and 𝑘 vectors you use to build every other vector. • Every field has an algebraic closure – i.e. imagine that you could not define the complex numbers
  • 20. What does it mean? “Simply” that there are sets whose volume is not invariant under translation and rotation. Strange! Isn’t it? This is why some mathematicians worry about the Axiom of Choice Decomposition of a ball into four pieces which, properly rotated and traslated, yield two balls Counterintuitive effects of AC: Banach-Tarski Paradox
  • 21. Counterintuitive effects of AC: Zermelo’s Lemma This statement is equivalent to the Axiom of Choice: Every set S can be well ordered As a consequence, we could «well order» ℝ - i.e. defining an order in ℝ such that every subset of ℝ has a minimum. This order relation is strongly counterintuitive, as it implies that sets like (0,1), without a minimum – 0 ∉ (0,1) do not exist.