Skip to main content
02/06/2019
1
Nobody said it was easy:
Promoting Critical Thinking in STEM
Leuven, 3rd june 2019
Maria M. Nascimento – mmsn@utad.pt
Caroline Dominguez – carold@utad.pt
Paula Catarino – pcatarin@utad.pt
University of Trás-os-Montes e Alto Douro, Vial Real, Portugal
02/06/2019
2
Interventions at the course level:
• To model
The teacher offers ill-structured problems, addresses multiple sides of a problem,
weights alternatives, engages in critical discourse and conversation, and values
different approaches.
• To induce
To offer ill-structured problems;
provide authentic tasks;
confront students with dilemmas;
make use of constructive controversies;
use prompts to make students think deeper;
engage students in elaborating research questions, interpreting and discuss
research results;
provide tools that orient students thinking and reflections;
ask why-questions; provide autonomy; ……
02/06/2019
3
Interventions at the course level:
• To declare
Use critical thinking rubrics; elaborate concept maps; make models, heuristics
and strategies available; discuss issues.
• To surveil
When discussing issues ask students to reflect and share their reflections,
provide feedback and set targets together with the students, in case of
problem solving tasks engage in peer assessment and peer-feedback about the
learning processes engaged in.
PROGRAMPROGRAMPROGRAMPROGRAM
1. Probability Theory (Review): Basic definitions; Definitions of probability and its properties;
Conditional probability; Independence of events
2. Real random variables: Discrete and continuous random variables; Distribution function; Mass
probability function and density function; Localization and dispersion parameters; Discrete and
continuous laws; Central limit theorem
3. Descriptive Statistics (Review)
4. Inferential Statistics: Point estimation and confidence intervals
5. Parametric and non-parametric hypotheses tests
6. ANOVA(s)
7. Simple linear regression
• STATISTICSSTATISTICSSTATISTICSSTATISTICS IN (IN (IN (IN (ENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATIONENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATIONENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATIONENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATION
UCUCUCUC ofofofof PROBABILITYPROBABILITYPROBABILITYPROBABILITY ANDANDANDAND STATISTICSSTATISTICSSTATISTICSSTATISTICS orororor STATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODS
02/06/2019
4
TC
Lecture
Test 1
Test 2
Test 3
Google
Classroom
Google Drive
Survey
Concept maps
(links)
UCUCUCUC ofofofof PROBABILITYPROBABILITYPROBABILITYPROBABILITY ANDANDANDAND STATISTICSSTATISTICSSTATISTICSSTATISTICS orororor STATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODS
• STATISTICS IN (ENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATIONSTATISTICS IN (ENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATIONSTATISTICS IN (ENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATIONSTATISTICS IN (ENGINEERING) HIGHER EDUCATION
UCUCUCUC ofofofof PROBABILITY AND STATISTICSPROBABILITY AND STATISTICSPROBABILITY AND STATISTICSPROBABILITY AND STATISTICS orororor STATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODSSTATISTICAL METHODS
Theoretical
Classes TC
2h/week
15 weeks
Laboratory Practices
LP
2h/week
15 weeks
02/06/2019
5
Homework
How did we move from
the probabilities to the
random variables?
UC of Probability and Statistics or Statistical Methods
Interventions at the course level:
• To declare
UC of Probability and Statistics or Statistical Methods
Interventions at the course level:
• To declare
Homework
02/06/2019
6
FRISCO GUIDELINES
IDENTIFY THE FOCUS
ANALYZE THE REASONS
ASSESS INFERENCES
DETERMINE THE SITUATION
ANALYZE THE CLARITY
OVERVIEW
ENNIS, R. H. (1996) CRITICAL THINKING. UPPER SADDLE RIVER, NJ:
PRENTICE-HALL. HTTP://CRITICALTHINKING.NET/INDEX.HTML
UC of Probability and Statistics or Statistical Methods
Interventions at the course level:
• To induce
UC of Probability and Statistics or Statistical Methods
Interventions at the course level:
• To induce
02/06/2019
7
UC of Probability and Statistics or Statistical Methods
Interventions at the course level:
• To model
• To induce
• To declare
• To surveil
• Out of the class
• Specifically directed to
CT
• Using technology
• HOMEWORK
with
feedback
• Out of the class
• Specifically
directed to CT
• CLASSES
TESTS PAPER(S)
MINI-
Project
GDrive
quizzes &
concept
maps
Interventions at the course level:
• To model
• To induce
• To declare
• To surveil
You have 30 minutes to think about the question:
HOW SHOULD I DO
to implement the 4 types of interventions
at one of my courses level?
02/06/2019
8
Interventions at the course level:
• To model
• To induce
• To declare
• To surveil
We have 20 minutes to think about the questions:
HOW SHOULD I DO
to implement the 4 types of interventions
at the program level?
at the institutional level?
Nobody said it was easy:
Promoting Critical Thinking in STEM
Leuven, 3rd june 2019
Maria M. Nascimento – mmsn@utad.pt
Caroline Dominguez – carold@utad.pt
Paula Catarino – pcatarin@utad.pt
University of Trás-os-Montes e Alto Douro, Vial Real, Portugal