Skip to main content
Material Evaluation
Brian Tomilson
CHAPTER 1
Brian Tomilson
Procedure that
involves measuring
the value ( potential
value ) of a set of
learning material
2
Littlejohn (1998) :
Who presents a general framework for
analyzing materials (pp.92-202) ,
which he suggest could be used prior
to evaluation and action in a model
which is sequenced as :
3
• Analysis of target situation of use
• Material analysis
• Match and evaluation
• Action
Principal in Material Evaluation
▧ The Evaluator’s Theory of learning
and teaching
4
Learning Theory
5
Criteria :
 To what extent are the materials
related to the wants of the learners?
 To what extent do the materials
help the learners to achieve
connections with their own lives?
 To what extent are materials likely
to simulate emotional engagement?
 To what extent are the materials
likely to promote visualization?
Richard
(2001 ; 264)
- Give learners something they can take away from the lesson
- teaches something learners feel they can use
- give learners a sense of achievements
- Practices learning items in an interesting and novel way.
- Provides a pleasurable learning experience
- Provides opportunities for individual practice
- Provides opportunities for personalization
- Provides opportunities for self-assesment of learning
6
Type of Materials Evaluation
Pre –use
Evaluation
Whilst-use
valuation
post - use
Evaluation
Diagram featured by http://slidemodel.com
7
Standart Aproaches to the materials Evaluation.
Developing
Criteria for
materials
Evaluation
8
Concussion
9
Material Evaluation
is initially a time-
consuming and
difficult undertaking
Material evaluation can
help the evaluators to
learn a lot materials,
about learning and
teaching and about
themselves
Evaluation material can
give many contribution
especially for teacher and
government to design
course book for student or
learner to improve their
knowledge about the
subject that they want to
learn
Thanks!
10