1. BRIEF BACKGROUND
•Courts seek to determine facts through rational processes.
• Earlier methods included trial by battle, ordeal and compurgation.
• These methods sought to establish facts through divine or
supernatural guidance.
• Modern courts replaced them with laws and rules for establishing
facts.
• Rules of evidence apply in both civil and criminal proceedings.
2
3.
2. DEVELOPMENT OFTHE RULES OF EVIDENCE
• Rules of evidence gradually developed into principles used to
establish facts.
• Like other common law systems, many rules were developed by
judges through cases.
• One important rule is the best evidence rule: use the best possible
evidence in the circumstances.
• Evidence is part of procedural law because it helps courts reach
justice.
3
4.
3. BENTHAM'S VIEWOF EVIDENCE
• According to Bentham, evidence concerns persuasion about the
existence of facts.
• Evidence is not limited to courts; it is used in both scientific and
non-scientific activities.
• Evidence is any matter of fact that tends to produce persuasion
about another fact.
• Bentham distinguished between primary and evidential facts.
4
5.
4. FACTUM PROBANDI& FACTUM PROBANS
• Factum probandi means the fact in issue or principal fact—the fact
that must be proved.
• Factum probans means the evidential fact—the fact given in
evidence to prove the principal fact.
• The relationship between the two is commonly described as
relevancy.
• Where the fact given in evidence is the same as the fact in issue, the
evidence is direct.
5
6.
5. BEST'S VIEWOF EVIDENCE
• Best criticised Bentham's broad approach to evidence.
• He argued that evidence in courts must consider the special
conditions and policies of litigation.
• He distinguished between natural evidence and judicial evidence.
• Therefore, court evidence requires rules suited to judicial
proceedings.
6
7.
6. MEANING OFEVIDENCE — SECTION 2
• Section 2 of the Evidence Act defines evidence as the means by
which an alleged matter of fact submitted for investigation is
proved or disproved.
• It includes statements, admissions and confessions.
• It also includes judicial notice, presumptions of law and ocular
observations by the court in its judicial capacity.
7
8.
7. PURPOSES OFTHE RULES OF EVIDENCE
• 1. Establish who has the burden of proof.
• 2. Determine which facts may be proved and admitted.
• 3. Prescribe the status or nature of evidence, such as opinion,
character and confessions.
• 4. Exclude certain matters, such as privileged information.
• 5. Prescribe methods of proof, including oral evidence, documents,
exhibits, experts and visiting the locus quo.
• 6. Prescribe the extent or standard of proof required.
8
9.
8. STANDARD OFPROOF
• In criminal cases, the prosecution must prove allegations beyond
reasonable doubt.
• In civil cases, the standard is generally proof on a balance of
probabilities.
• Different types of cases may require different standards of proof.
• The rules of evidence therefore help determine how much proof is
required.
9
10.
9. ORIENTAL FIRE& GENERAL ASSURANCE CO.
LTD v GOVINDER
• The appellant sought to avoid a third-party motor vehicle insurance
policy.
• An issue concerned the truth of answers in the proposal form.
• Spry J.A held that admissions were admissible against the
respondents.
• The case demonstrates the importance of proving allegations and
satisfying the required standard of proof.
10
11.
10. SULLIVAN vALI MOHAMMED OSMAN
• Windham J.A stated that failure to make a necessary allegation of
fact, in light of the other facts alleged, may make a claim bad.
• The case illustrates the importance of allegations and proof in
litigation.
11
12.
11. UGANDA vKAMUGISHA & OTHERS
• An application was made to admit a letter allegedly written by PW6.
• The prosecution challenged its authenticity.
• The court held that admissibility depends on relevance to the issue
before court.
• Evidence that is not sufficiently relevant may prolong proceedings
unnecessarily.
• The letter was inadmissible because there was insufficient proof
that PW6 wrote it or requested it.
12
13.
12. STRUGGLE INSURANCECO. LTD v PAN
AFRICAN INSURANCE CO. LTD
• Evidence was led to show that the defendant company did not exist.
• The issue before court was whether the company owned the suit
premises.
• The court held that non-existence was not a fact in issue because it
had not been pleaded.
• Evidence on the non-existence of the company was therefore
inadmissible.
13
14.
13. R vKURJI (1940) 7 EACA 58
• The accused had assaulted the deceased's brother with a dagger
shortly before the deceased was killed.
• The court held that the acts were so interconnected that they
formed part of the same transaction.
• Evidence of the earlier attack was admissible as part of the res
gestae.
• The case illustrates the importance of relevant facts in explaining a
fact in issue.
14
15.
14. LAW APPLICABLEIN UGANDA
• Uganda's law of evidence is basically statutory.
• Much of it is derived from the Indian Evidence Act of 1872, which
attempted to codify English common law.
• Uganda modified some requirements, including corroboration.
• Other relevant laws include the Trial on Indictments Act,
Magistrates Courts Act, Evidence (Bankers' Books) Act, Foreign
Tribunals Evidence Act, Oaths Act and Children's Act.
15
16.
15. DEVELOPMENT OFTHE EVIDENCE ACT
• Consular courts in East Africa were expected to apply Indian
statutes.
• A local evidence statute was enacted in 1909.
• The legislation was subsequently amended, including in 1935, 1955,
1971 and 1985.
• These amendments particularly affected statements made by
accused persons, including confessions.
16
17.
16. INTERPRETATION OFA CODIFIED LAW
• Codification brings unwritten principles together in written
legislation.
• A key question is whether courts should use common law when
interpreting a code.
• Wallace-Johnson v Republic (1940) 1 All ER 241: where a section
contains the whole law on a subject, interpretation should follow
the words of the statute.
• R v Brabin and Khosla (1947) 14 EACA: where the Act differs from
English law, the Act prevails.
• Sterjnholen v Statenhome (1955) 28 KLR 183: English authorities
may still be referred to where appropriate.
17
18.
17. SCOPE OFTHE EVIDENCE ACT — SECTION 1
• Section 1 applies the Act to judicial proceedings in or before the
Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, High Court and courts established
under the Magistrates Courts Act.
• It does not apply to affidavits presented to a court or officer.
• It also does not apply to proceedings before an arbitration.
• The Act does not apply to local council courts because they are not
established under the Magistrates Courts Act.
18
19.
18. CASES ONTHE SCOPE OF THE ACT
• London Overseas Trading Co. v Raleigh Cycle Co. Ltd (1959) EA 1012:
the Evidence Act did not apply to affidavits presented to court.
• Re-Trade Application No. 8274 by American Tobacco Co: 'court'
includes persons legally authorised to take evidence, including a
registrar.
• The Administration of Justice (Karamoja) Act modified some
evidential rules for crimes committed in Karamoja.
19
20.
19. TYPES /CATEGORIES OF EVIDENCE
• Prima facie evidence: establishes a fact unless contrary evidence is
produced.
• Conclusive evidence: evidence that is treated as final on the matter
concerned.
• Real evidence: physical or material things produced as exhibits.
• Oral evidence: statements permitted or required to be made before
court by witnesses about matters of fact under inquiry.
• Direct evidence and circumstantial evidence are also recognised.
20
21.
20. DIRECT &CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
• Direct evidence may mean evidence from a person who directly
perceived the fact.
• It may also mean evidence directly proving a fact, as opposed to
evidence based on surrounding circumstances.
• Nail Ahmed v Republic (1962) EA 345: fingerprints on stolen cars
and their parts provided sufficient circumstantial evidence
connecting the accused with theft.
• Singh v Republic: circumstantial evidence must be inconsistent with
the hypothesis of innocence.
21
22.
21. ADMISSIBILITY OFEVIDENCE — SECTION 4
• Admissibility is the process by which court accepts or rejects
evidence.
• Section 4: evidence may be given of every fact in issue and other
facts declared relevant, and of no others.
• Therefore, evidence must be relevant and must not be excluded by
law.
22
23.
22. FACTS INISSUE — SECTION 2
• Facts in issue are facts from which the existence, non-existence,
nature or extent of a right, liability or disability necessarily follows.
• In civil cases, issues are framed around material propositions of law
or fact.
• Order 15 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides for issues arising
where one party affirms and the other denies a material
proposition.
• In criminal cases, issues include whether the accused committed
the offence and whether a defence such as alibi applies.
23
24.
23. MEANING OF'FACT'
• Under the Evidence Act, a fact includes:
• • Anything capable of being perceived by the senses.
• • A state of things or relation of things.
• • A mental condition of which a person is conscious.
• Only facts in issue and relevant facts are generally admissible.
24
25.
24. RELEVANCY
• Relevancyis the relationship between two facts where one fact
proves or makes probable the existence or non-existence of
another.
• Section 4 limits admissible evidence to facts in issue and legally
relevant facts.
• Legal relevance is not always the same as logical relevance.
• Not everything logically connected to a case is legally admissible.
25
26.
25. CHANDRA vRAKHAKUNDA
• The court considered the relationship between logical and legal
relevance.
• The Evidence Act lays down matters to be considered in
determining truth.
• It contains the law of evidence.
• Matters excluded by the Act may be regarded as irrelevant, rejected,
or suspect.
• Opinion evidence is generally inadmissible unless it falls within
recognised exceptions such as expert opinion.
26
27.
26. RELEVANCY ANDADMISSIBILITY
• Generally, once evidence is admissible, the manner in which it was
obtained is not important.
• Kuruma v R (1955) 22 EACA 364: evidence obtained through a
search without a warrant was admitted because the method of
obtaining it did not make the evidence inadmissible.
• Exception: confessions must satisfy the requirements of
voluntariness.
27
28.
27. RES GESTAE/ SAME TRANSACTION
• Res gestae connects acts, declarations and circumstances forming,
accompanying or explaining a transaction.
• The doctrine appears throughout sections 4–15 of the Evidence Act.
• Section 5 concerns facts forming part of the same transaction.
• Such facts may be relevant even where they occurred at different
times or places, depending on the transaction.
28
29.
28. R vKURJI — RES GESTAE
• The accused assaulted the deceased's brother with a dagger before
the deceased was killed.
• The acts were closely interconnected.
• The earlier assault was treated as part of the same transaction.
• The evidence was admissible even though it also revealed another
offence.
29
30.
29. MAKINDI vR (1961) EA 327
• The accused was convicted of manslaughter after beating a boy.
• Evidence of previous beatings was admitted.
• The evidence helped explain and substantiate the cause of death.
• It was admitted under section 6 of the Evidence Act.
30
31.
30. GENERAL ELEMENTSOF RES GESTAE
• 1. The statement or declaration must relate to and explain the main
event.
• 2. It must be a natural declaration arising from the event, not
merely a narration of past events.
• 3. It should be a statement of fact and not merely an expression of
opinion, and should be closely connected in time with the event.
• 4. It should be made by a participant in, or witness to, the
transaction.
31
32.
31. SECTION 5— SAME TRANSACTION
• Facts not in issue are relevant where they are so connected with
facts in issue that they form part of the same transaction.
• They may occur at the same or different times and places.
• R v Kurji illustrates this principle.
• Section 5 applies to both civil and criminal proceedings.
32
33.
32. SECTION 6— OCCASION, CAUSE OR
EFFECT
• Facts that are the occasion, cause or effect of a fact in issue are
relevant.
• Relevant facts may also show the state of things under which the
event happened or provide an opportunity for its occurrence.
• R v Brabin and Khosla: previous corrupt transactions were admitted
because they showed the state of things under which the offence
occurred.
• Section 6 may also help explain causation and liability in civil cases.
33
34.
33. SECTION 7— MOTIVE & PREPARATION
• Motive is what influences a person to act in a particular way.
• Under section 7, facts showing motive, preparation and previous or
subsequent conduct may be relevant.
• Preparation means making arrangements or obtaining things
needed to bring about an event.
• Motive may help establish intention, although motive is generally
not an essential element of criminal liability.
34
35.
34. MOTIVE —AUTHORITIES
• Tinkamanyire and another v Uganda (1988–90) HCB 5: motive may
assist in explaining why an offence was committed.
• Bitwire v Uganda (1987) HCB 11: absence of motive may be
considered in a weak case.
• Uganda v Bari Kunda s/o Rwebanda (1985) HCB 12: where
established, motive may be relevant in determining intention.
35
36.
35. PREVIOUS CONDUCT
•Previous conduct may show motive, preparation, attempts, threats
or a declaration of intention.
• Robo v R (1926) 10 KLR 55: a complaint made at the first reasonable
opportunity may be relevant to the complainant's conduct and state
of mind.
• Harris v DPP: previous thefts were considered in relation to the
defence of accident or mistake.
• Evidence of previous acts may be admitted where it serves a
recognised evidential purpose.
36
37.
36. DESIGN, PATTERN& IDENTITY
• Waihi and another v Uganda (1968) EA 278: previous acts and
subsequent evidence were admitted because they helped show that
the accused committed the offence and corroborated other
evidence.
• R v Smith: previous deaths were relevant to rebut an inference of
accident.
• Serraffen's case: previous killings were relevant to establishing
identity because of similarities.
• These cases show that previous acts may be relevant where they
establish a recognised fact such as design, pattern or identity.
37
38.
37. SUBSEQUENT CONDUCT
•Conduct after an event may help explain what happened or indicate
a person's state of mind.
• Running away may sometimes be relevant, but it must be
considered with the circumstances and any explanation given.
• Henry Kifamunte v Uganda: running away was not conclusive
because the appellant gave an explanation that created doubt.
• Uganda v Simon Onen and Uganda v Kabandize: subsequent flight
was treated as relevant conduct in the circumstances.
38
39.
38. SECTION 8— EXPLANATORY &
INTRODUCTORY FACTS
• Section 8 makes relevant facts that:
• • Explain or introduce the fact in issue.
• • Support or rebut an inference suggested by the fact in issue.
• • Identify a person or thing whose identity is relevant.
• • Show the time and place of an event.
• • Show the relationship between parties.
39
40.
39. UGANDA vKASYA GEORGE
• The accused was charged with murder and relied on an alibi.
• Evidence included the accused's connection with the deceased and
tax tickets bearing his name.
• The prosecution evidence contained major inconsistencies.
• The court held that an accused relying on alibi does not assume the
burden of proof.
• The prosecution must disprove the alibi, and circumstantial
evidence must irresistibly point to guilt.
40
41.
40. KEY PRINCIPLESTO REMEMBER
• Evidence must relate to facts in issue or legally relevant facts.
• Logical relevance does not always equal legal admissibility.
• The Evidence Act is mainly statutory and must be applied according
to its provisions.
• Expert and other recognised forms of opinion evidence are
exceptions to the general exclusion of opinion evidence.
• Res gestae allows closely connected facts to explain or form part of
the same transaction.
• Relevance, admissibility, burden and standard of proof are central
to the law of evidence.
41