- 1. Introduction to COSMOLOGY CERN Lectures July 2022 Daniel Baumann University of Amsterdam & National Taiwan University
- 2. Disclaimer: Teaching all of cosmology in 3 hours is an impossible task. I will focus on the big picture and suppress technical details. More can be found in:
- 3. OUTLINE: The Expanding Universe Structure Formation Quantum Origin • Hubble-Lemaitre law • Friedmann equation • Matter and radiation • Dark energy • Nucleosynthesis • Cosmic microwave background • Density fluctuations • Gravitational clustering • Galaxy formation • Power spectrum • Cosmic sound waves • CMB anisotropies • Horizon problem • Cosmological inflation • Quantum fluctuations • Primordial perturbations
- 5. Goal of this Lecture We wish to derive, and then solve, the equation governing the evolution of the entire Universe. This is possible because, on large scales, the Universe is homogeneous and isotropic, and therefore allows for a simple mathematical description. 100 Mpc Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- 6. 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 −0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 ×103 km/s 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 0 5 10 15 20 ×103 Hubble’s Law In 1929, Hubble discovered the velocity-distance relation of galaxies: V = H0R Inferred from redshifts Inferred from luminosities
- 7. Hubble’s Law In General Relativity, this can be interpreted as the expansion of space: time R(t) = a(t)R0 Scale factor R0 V ⌘ Ṙ = ȧ a R ⌘ H R Hubble parameter
- 8. Hubble’s Law The observed value of the Hubble constant is H0 = (68 ± 2) km s 1 Mpc 1 where Mpc = 3.2 ⇥ 106 light-years. ⇠ 1026 m The corresponding Hubble time and Hubble distance are tH ⌘ H 1 0 = (14.38 ± 0.42) Gyrs dH ⌘ cH 1 0 = (4380 ± 130) Mpc These are the characteristic age and size of the universe.
- 9. Friedmann Equation Let us now determine the evolution of the scale factor. We will do this using Newtonian gravity (but comment on GR corrections). The force on a test particle on the surface of the sphere is F = GMm R2 Consider a spherical region in a homogeneous universe: ⇢(t) R(t) M m
- 10. Friedmann Equation The acceleration of the test particle is d2 R dt2 = GM R2 Integrating this gives the conservation of energy: 1 2 ✓ dR dt ◆2 GM R = U = const. Substituting M = 4⇡ 3 R3 ⇢ and R(t) = a(t)R0 , we find ✓ ȧ a ◆2 = 8⇡G 3 ⇢ + 2U R2 0 1 a2 Friedmann Equation Hubble parameter
- 11. U > 0 U < 0 U = 0 Friedmann Equation ✓ ȧ a ◆2 = 8⇡G 3 ⇢ + 2U R2 0 1 a2 There are three diﬀerent cases: expands forever stops and recollapses limiting case In GR, these correspond to: negatively curved positively curved flat Observations favor a ﬂat universe.
- 12. Friedmann Equation For a flat universe, the Friedmann equation reduces to H2 = 8⇡G 3 ⇢ From the measured value of the Hubble constant, we infer the average density of the universe today: ⇢0 = 3H2 0 8⇡G = 0.8 ⇥ 10 29 grams cm 3 = 1.3 ⇥ 1011 M Mpc 3 = 5.1 protons m 3
- 13. Rµ⌫ 1 2 Rgµ⌫ = 8⇡G Tµ⌫ H2 = 8⇡G 3 ⇢ Friedmann Equation In GR, the Friedmann equation is derived from the Einstein equation: Curvature tensor Energy-momentum tensor where the mass density is replaced by the energy density . " ⌘ ⇢c2 (In natural units (c ⌘ 1), we use ⇢ interchangeably.) " and To solve the Friedmann equation, we need to know how the energy density evolves as the universe expands.
- 14. Cosmic Inventory Radiation (photons, neutrinos) Dark matter Atoms Dark energy The universe is filled with four diﬀerent types of energy: We need to determine how each of these components evolves and sources the expansion of the universe.
- 15. Fluid Equation Consider a fluid in a box: E, P V dE = dQ PdV The First Law of thermodynamics implies Homogeneity doesn’t allow any heat flow ( ), so that dQ = 0 dE dt = P dV dt
- 16. Fluid Equation d⇢ dt = 3 ȧ a (⇢ + P) Cosmological fluids are described by a constant equation of state: w ⌘ P/⇢ The fluid equation then becomes ˙ ⇢ ⇢ = 3(1 + w) ȧ a ⇢ / a 3(1+w) Fluid Equation Using E = ⇢V and V / a3 , we find dE dt = P dV dt
- 17. Matter For a pressureless fluid (= matter), we get P = 0 ⇢ ⌘ E V / a 3 E = const Feeding ⇢ / a 3 into the Friedmann equation, we find ✓ ȧ a ◆2 / ⇢ / a 3 a / t2/3 Most of the matter in the universe is non-luminous dark matter. Ordinary matter is less than 5%.
- 18. Radiation For a relativistic fluid (= radiation), we get P = 1 3 ⇢ ⇢ ⌘ E V / a 4 E / a 1 Most of the radiation in the universe are photons from the early universe (= cosmic microwave background). Starlight is less than 0.1%. ✓ ȧ a ◆2 / ⇢ / a 4 a / t1/2 Feeding into the Friedmann equation, we find ⇢ / a 4
- 19. Matter and Radiation The universe was first dominated by radiation, then by matter: 10−10 10−8 10−6 10−4 10−2 1 10−5 1 105 1010 1015 1020 1025 1030 ρr ∝ a−4 ρm ∝ a−3 a(t) ρ(a)
- 20. Acceleration Equation Combining the Friedmann equation with the fluid equation d dt "✓ ȧ a ◆2 = 8⇡G 3 ⇢ # + d⇢ dt = 3 ȧ a (⇢ + P) ä a = 4⇡G 3 (⇢ + 3P) Acceleration Equation we get There are two diﬀerent cases: P > 1 3 ⇢ P < 1 3 ⇢ Expansion slows down Expansion speeds up ä < 0 ä > 0
- 21. Dark Energy In 1998, it was discovered that the universe is accelerating. The source of the acceleration is unknown. We call it dark energy. 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 Distance modulus CFA1 CFA2 CFA3S CFA3K CFA4p1 CFA4p2 CSP SDSS SNLS SCP CANDELS +CLASH GOODS PS1 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.2 2.4 Redshift °0.5 0.0 0.5 Residuals With DE Without DE
- 22. Dark Energy In 1998, it was discovered that the universe is accelerating. The source of the acceleration is unknown. We call it dark energy. The simplest form of dark energy is a cosmological constant: Rµ⌫ 1 2 Rgµ⌫ + ⇤gµ⌫ = 8⇡G Tµ⌫ Moving this term to the RHS, it becomes a vacuum energy: E / V P = ⇢ ⇢ ⌘ E V = const ✓ ȧ a ◆2 / ⇢ = const a / eH0t Feeding this into the Friedmann equation gives
- 23. Dark Energy 10−10 10−8 10−6 10−4 10−2 1 102 104 10−5 1 105 1010 1015 1020 1025 1030 ρr ρm ρΛ a(t) ρ(a) Today, the universe is dominated by dark energy (Why now?): today
- 24. Cosmological Constant Problem The observed value of the dark energy density is much smaller than our (naive) theoretical expectation: ⇢QFT ⇠ ⇤UV Z 0 dk3 (2⇡)3 1 2 ~! ⇠ ⇤4 UV o ⇢obs = (2 ⇥ 10 3 eV) Quantum zero-point fluctuations Sum over wavelengths Explaining the observed dark energy density remains one of the most important open questions in fundamental physics.
- 25. Questions?
- 26. The Hot Big Bang The universe started in a hot and dense state: As the universe expands, it cools. Many interesting things happened. temperature earlier later time hotter colder T(t) / a(t) 1
- 27. The universe is filled with almost equal amounts of matter and antimatter For some mysterious reason, there was initially a fraction more matter than antimatter. This matter survived the annihilation. 10 000 000 001 10 000 000 000 matter Without this asymmetry we wouldn’t exist. As the universe cools, matter and antimatter annihilate. + = light t = 10 19 s
- 28. t = 10 5 s Quarks and gluons condense into nuclei: temperature time u d u u d d proton neutron 10 μs
- 29. t = 1 s Neutrinos decouple and neutrons freeze out: temperature time 1 s Free-streaming neutrinos • 40% of the energy density • Significant eﬀect on the expansion
- 30. t = 3 min Light elements (H, He, and Li) form: temperature time H He 3 min • Heavier nuclei were fused inside stars. • Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) predicts the correct abundances of the light elements. 25% 75%
- 31. Atoms form and the first light is released: 370 000 yrs e- e- e- e- e- e- H He e temperature time Free-streaming photons t = 370 000 yrs
- 32. • 410 photons per cubic centimeter • cooled by the expansion: 2.7 K • faint microwave radiation: CMB This afterglow of the Big Bang is still seen today: 0 100 200 300 400 Intensity [MJy/sr] 100 200 300 400 500 600 −0.1 0 0.1 Frequency [GHz] Cosmic Microwave Background
- 33. temperature time 1 billion yrs t > 1 billion yrs Matter collapses into stars and galaxies:
- 34. This history of the universe is an observational fact: 10 μs 370 000 yrs 1 s 3 min QCD phase transition Neutrino decoupling BBN e - Photon decoupling Structure formation 1 billion yrs • The basic picture has been confirmed by many independent observations. • Many precise details are probed by measurements of the CMB.
- 35. Where did it all come from?
- 37. How did the structure in the universe form? Light in the Universe Light on Earth The large-scale structure of the universe isn’t randomly distributed, but has spatial correlations. What created these correlations?
- 38. Our best answer to these questions involves a fascination connection between the physics of the very small and the very large: Gravitational clustering Quantum fluctuations CMB fluctuations Galaxies Cosmic sound waves Part II.1 Part II.2 Part III 10 32 s 370 000 yrs 1 billion yrs
- 39. Our best answer to these questions involves a fascination connection between the physics of the very small and the very large: This allows us to use cosmological observations to learn about short-distance/ high-energy particle physics. Quantum fluctuations CMB fluctuations Galaxies 10 32 s 370 000 yrs 1 billion yrs
- 40. Gravitational Clustering Consider a spherical overdensity in a homogeneous universe: We are interested in the evolution of the density contrast: ¯ ⇢(t) ⇢(t) ⌘ ⇢ ¯ ⇢ ¯ ⇢ Galaxies form when the density contrast reaches a critical value.
- 41. Gravitational Clustering • In a static universe, the density contrast grows exponentially: • In an expanding universe, the growth is slower: during the matter era during the radiation era (t) / ln t (t) / t2/3 (t) / et/⌧ The clustering of matter only begins after matter-radiation equality. The evolution of the density contrast can be derived using Newtonian gravity (see slides online). Here, I just quote the results:
- 42. Fourier Modes In reality, density perturbations are not spherically symmetric. A general density fluctuation can be decomposed into its Fourier modes: Each Fourier mode satisfies the same equation of motion as a spherically symmetric overdensity. X k k sin(kx + k) x = = k = 2⇡/
- 43. Power Spectrum The power spectrum is the square of the Fourier amplitude: The Fourier transform of the power spectrum is the two-point correlation function. This is the main statistic of cosmological correlations. P(k) = | k|2 ⇠(r) = Z d3 k (2⇡)3 P(k) eikr
- 44. 10−4 10−3 0.01 0.1 1 10 k [Mpc−1 ] 1 10 102 103 104 P (k) galaxy clustering Lyα CMB Power Spectrum The observed matter power spectrum is Horizon scale at matter-radiation equality Large scales Small scales
- 45. Questions?
- 46. µK +300 300 The CMB has tiny variations in its intensity, corresponding to small density fluctuations in the primordial plasma: These fluctuations aren’t random, but are highly correlated.
- 47. 2 10 30 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 Power [µK 2 ] 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 Multipole 90◦ 18◦ 1◦ 0.2◦ 0.1◦ 0.07◦ Angular separation Large scales Small scales The observed CMB power spectrum is
- 48. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 49. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 50. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 51. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 52. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 53. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 54. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 55. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 56. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 57. 10 100 1000 Multipole Figure courtesy of Mathew Madhavacheril
- 58. 2 10 30 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 Power [µK 2 ] 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 Multipole 90◦ 18◦ 1◦ 0.2◦ 0.1◦ 0.07◦ Angular separation What created the features in the power spectrum? CMB Power Spectrum
- 59. Photon-Baryon Fluid At early times, photons and baryons (mostly protons and electrons) are strongly coupled and act as a single fluid: Dark matter Baryons Photons The photon pressure prevents the collapse of density fluctuations. This allows for sound waves (like for density fluctuations in air).
- 60. The pattern of the CMB fluctuations is a consequence of these sound waves: Superposition of many waves CMB correlations Cosmic Sound Waves
- 61. Cosmic Sound Waves Consider the evolution of a single localized density fluctuation:
- 62. Cosmic Sound Waves This creates a radial sound wave in the photon-baryon fluid: The wave travels a distance of 50 000 light-years (called the sound horizon) before the universe becomes transparent to light. Dark matter Photons + baryons rs Sound horizon
- 63. CMB Anisotropies This sound horizon is imprinted in the pattern of CMB fluctuations: Temperature Polarization 2 +2 1 +1 0 2 +2 1 +1 0 20 40 60 80 0 0.4 0.2 0.4 intensity of 11396 cold spots ✓s ✓s 1 2 ✓s Planck (2015)
- 64. CMB Anisotropies This sound horizon is imprinted in the pattern of CMB fluctuations: 90◦ 18◦ 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 Power [µK 2 ] 2◦ 0.2◦ 0.1◦ 0.07◦ Angular separation
- 65. CMB Anisotropies The precise pattern of the CMB fluctuations depends on the composition of the universe (and its initial conditions): Atoms Dark matter Dark energy Observations of the CMB have therefore allowed us to determine the parameters of the cosmological standard model.
- 66. Without dark matter, the data would look very diﬀerent: Figures courtesy of Zhiqi Huang and Dick Bond [ACT collaboration] Data No Dark Matter Dark Matter
- 67. 2 10 30 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 Power [µK 2 ] 500 1000 1500 2000 Multipole This can also be seen in the power spectrum: ⌦m = 0.32 without dark matter Planck (2018)
- 68. Without dark energy, the data would look very diﬀerent: Data No Dark Energy Dark Energy Figures courtesy of Zhiqi Huang and Dick Bond [ACT collaboration]
- 69. 2 10 30 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 Power [µK 2 ] 500 1000 1500 2000 Multipole This can also be seen in the power spectrum: Planck (2018) ⌦⇤ = 0.68 without dark energy with dark energy
- 70. with dark energy without dark energy Riess et al (1998) Perlmutter et al (1998) This is consistent with the direct observation of dark energy from supernova observations:
- 71. The peak heights depend on the baryon density: ⌦b = 0.04 The measured baryon density is consistent with BBN. more baryons 2 10 30 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 Power [µK 2 ] 500 1000 1500 2000 Multipole Planck (2018) Baryons
- 72. As ✓ k k0 ◆ns 1 The CMB power spectrum also probes the initial conditions: A B C D A B C D Amplitude scale-dependence As = 2.20 ⇥ 10 9 evolution Initial Conditions
- 73. ns = 0.96 The primordial power spectrum is close to scale invariant: WMAP (2009) Planck (2018) 2 10 30 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 Power [µK 2 ] 500 1000 1500 2000 Multipole ns = 0.75 ns = 1.25 The observed deviation from scale invariance is significant.
- 74. The Standard Model A simple 5-parameter model fits all observations: Amount of ordinary matter Amount of dark matter Amount of dark energy Amplitude of density fluctuations Scale dependence of the fluctuations ⌦b = 0.04 ns = 0.96 109 As = 2.20 ⌦⇤ = 0.68 ⌦m = 0.32
- 75. The Standard Model A key challenge of modern cosmology is to explain these numbers: ⌦b = 0.04 ns = 0.96 109 As = 2.20 ⌦⇤ = 0.68 ⌦m = 0.32 Why is there more matter than antimatter? What is the dark matter? What is the dark energy? What was the origin of the fluctuations?
- 76. Appendix
- 77. Gravitational Clustering Consider a spherical overdensity in a homogeneous universe: We are interested in the evolution of the density contrast: R(t) ¯ ⇢(t) ⇢(t) ⌘ ⇢ ¯ ⇢ ¯ ⇢
- 78. Let us first study this overdensity in a static universe. The acceleration at the sphere’s surface is R̈ = G M R2 = G R2 ✓ 4⇡ 3 R3 ¯ ⇢ ◆ R̈ R = 4⇡G¯ ⇢ 3 (t) M = 4⇡ 3 R3 (t) ¯ ⇢ [1 + (t)] = const Conservation of mass implies , so that for | | ⌧ 1 . R(t) = ✓ 3M 4⇡¯ ⇢ ◆1/3 h 1 + (t) i 1/3 ⇡ R0 1 1 3 (t) Substituting this into the equation of motion, we get ¨ = (4⇡G ¯ ⇢) (t) = Aet/⌧ + Be t/⌧ Exponential growth Gravitational Clustering
- 79. Adding Expansion Now, consider the same overdensity in an expanding universe with only pressureless matter: R(t) ⇢(t) ¯ ⇢(t) / a 3 (t) The acceleration at the sphere’s surface is R̈ = GM R2 = G R2 ✓ 4⇡ 3 R3 ⇢ ◆ = 4⇡G 3 ¯ ⇢R 4⇡G 3 (¯ ⇢ )R
- 80. M = 4⇡ 3 R3 (t) ¯ ⇢(t) [1 + (t)] = const Adding Expansion Mass conservation implies , so that R(t) / ¯ ⇢ 1/3 (t) h 1 + (t) i 1/3 / a(t) 1 1 3 (t) Substituting this into the equation of motion, we get R̈ R = ä a 1 3 ¨ 2 3 ȧ a ˙ = 4⇡G 3 ¯ ⇢ 4⇡G 3 ¯ ⇢ ¨ + 2H ˙ = (4⇡G¯ ⇢) The density contrast therefore satisfies Hubble friction Gravitational force
- 81. Clustering of Dark Matter In a matter-dominated universe, with a / t2/3 H = 2 3t and , we get ¨ + 2H ˙ = 3 2 H2 ¨ + 4 3t ˙ = 2 3t2 The solution for the density contrast is Power-law growth (t) = At2/3 + B t 1 In a radiation-dominated universe, the growth is only logarithmic: (t) = A ln t + B The clustering of matter only begins after matter-radiation equality.
- 82. Quantum Origin
- 83. So far, we have described the evolution of fluctuations in the hot Big Bang and the formation of the large-scale structure of the Universe: Gravitational clustering Primordial fluctuations CMB fluctuations Galaxies Cosmic sound waves What created the primordial fluctuations? We now want to ask:
- 84. 90◦ 18◦ 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 Power [µK 2 ] 2◦ 0.2◦ 0.1◦ 0.07◦ Angular separation An important clue is the fact that the CMB fluctuations are correlated over the whole sky: Superhorizon
- 85. distance light travelled since the Big Bang In the standard hot Big Bang theory, this is impossible: 2 Big Bang Observable universe
- 86. The correlations must have been created before the hot Big Bang: Big Bang ? Photon decoupling distance light travelled since the Big Bang CMB
- 87. Inflation solves the problem by invoking a period of superluminal expansion: Guth (1980) Linde (1982) Albrecht and Steinhardt (1982) Inflation Big Bang Photon decoupling CMB a(t) = eHt Inflation
- 88. In less than The entire observable universe then originated from a microscopic, causally connected region of space. a(t) = eHt Inflation 10 32 seconds, the universe doubled in size at least 80 times:
- 89. Inflation To achieve inflation requires a substance with a nearly constant energy density (like dark energy): V ( )
- 90. Inflation To end inflation, this substance must decay (like a radioactive material): The product of this decay is the hot Big Bang. One of these bubbles is our universe.
- 91. Inflation In quantum mechanics, the end of inflation is probabilistic and varies throughout space: This creates the primordial density ﬂuctuations.
- 92. Quantum Fluctuations In quantum mechanics, empty space is full of violent fluctuations: x p ~
- 93. Lamb shift Quantum Fluctuations These quantum fluctuations are real, but usually have small eﬀects:
- 94. During inflation, these quantum fluctuations get amplified and stretched: Quantum Fluctuations After inflation, these fluctuations become the large-scale density fluctuations.
- 95. The nearly constant inflationary vacuum energy leads to an approximately scale-invariant power spectrum: Primordial Correlations The slow decay of the inflationary energy predicts slightly more power on large scales: P(k) k Askns 1 ns < 1
- 96. ✓ C(✓) The well-understood physics of the photon-baryon fluid turns these primordial correlations into correlations of the CMB anisotropies: CMB Anisotropies
- 97. The predicted correlations are in remarkable agreement with the data: 90◦ 18◦ 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 Power [µK 2 ] 2◦ 0.2◦ 0.1◦ 0.07◦ Angular separation CMB Anisotropies
- 98. How can inﬂation become part of the standard history of the universe with the same level of conﬁdence as BBN ? “Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” Carl Sagan 10 μs 1 s 3 min QCD phase transition Neutrino decoupling BBN 10-32 s Inflation?
- 99. Besides density fluctuations, inflation predicts gravitational waves: Primordial Gravitational Waves The strength of the signal depends on the energy scale of inflation, which may be as high as 1016 GeV.
- 100. These gravitational waves would produce a characteristic swirl pattern (called B-modes) in the polarization of the CMB: B-modes Detecting these B-modes is a central goal of observational cosmology.
- 102. CMB Stage III.5 (2021-2028) Atacama Desert Planned Experiments
- 103. Atacama Desert South Pole Planned Experiments CMB Stage IV (2028-2035)
- 104. Selected by JAXA in 2019 Launch in 2028 LiteBIRD Planned Experiments
- 105. A B-mode detection would be a milestone towards a complete understanding of the origin of all structure in the universe 10 32 s 370 000 yrs 1 billion yrs
- 106. Conclusions
- 107. 10 μs 370 000 yrs 1 s 3 min e - 1 billion yrs We have a remarkably consistent picture of the history of the Universe from fractions of a second after the Big Bang until today: We also have tantalizing evidence that the primordial seed fluctuations for the formation of structure were created during a period of inflation:
- 108. ⌦b Yet, many fundamental questions remain: • What is dark matter and dark energy? • Did inflation really occur? And what was driving it? • What is the origin of the matter-antimatter asymmetry? • … We hope that future observations will shed light on these questions. Observations of the CMB have revolutionized cosmology: ⌦m ⌦⇤ As , ns