SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Esperanto and minority languages
Challenges and opportunities

Federico Gobbo
University of Turin, Italy
federico.gobbo@unito.it

1 of 26

$



BY:

C

CC

University of Liverpool, UK
October 17, 2013
What is a minority language?
European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages
The definition:
languages traditionally used within a given territory of a state by
nationals of that state who form a group numerically smaller
than the rest of the state’s population; they are different from
the official language(s) of that state, and they include neither
dialects of the official language(s) of the state nor the languages
of migrants. (ECRML, Art. 1 – Definitions)
Let us consider some consequences.

3 of 26
Only a matter of number of (native) speakers?
Wikipedia, our repository of common-sense knowledge, states that “a
minority language is a language spoken by a minority of the
population of a territor”. This is a half-truth.
The problem of the (false) equivalence ‘minority languages =
lesser-used languages’: where is the border of lesser-usage?
100,000 native speakers?
10,000?
1,000?
We need to re-engineer the concept of minority languages.

4 of 26
Italy, a multilingual nation-state (look only to colours!)
A taxonomy of minority languages
Let’s take Italy as the reference territory for further analysis.
Edwards [1] introduced a taxonomy of minority languages, where:
local-only minority languages are for example German, French,
Slovene (they are national language elsewhere);

6 of 26
A taxonomy of minority languages
Let’s take Italy as the reference territory for further analysis.
Edwards [1] introduced a taxonomy of minority languages, where:
local-only minority languages are for example German, French,
Slovene (they are national language elsewhere);
unique minority languages are for example Piedmontese, Venetian
(settled only in Italy only in a minority status);

6 of 26
A taxonomy of minority languages
Let’s take Italy as the reference territory for further analysis.
Edwards [1] introduced a taxonomy of minority languages, where:
local-only minority languages are for example German, French,
Slovene (they are national language elsewhere);
unique minority languages are for example Piedmontese, Venetian
(settled only in Italy only in a minority status);
non-unique minority languages: an example is Catalan (present in
more than one state but never at a national level);

6 of 26
The paradox of South Tyrol in Italy

From a state perspective German is a minority language, from the
provincial perspective it is not – paraphrasing Edwards [1].
Framing minority languages as a relational concept
In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in
contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum
(proper territory of the language):
there is a bilingual community, where the minority language
belongs to;

8 of 26
Framing minority languages as a relational concept
In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in
contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum
(proper territory of the language):
there is a bilingual community, where the minority language
belongs to;
for historical and political reasons, a majority language superseded
the minority one;

8 of 26
Framing minority languages as a relational concept
In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in
contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum
(proper territory of the language):
there is a bilingual community, where the minority language
belongs to;
for historical and political reasons, a majority language superseded
the minority one;
the minority language is reserved for the informal and everyday
functions (called ‘low variety’ or L);

8 of 26
Framing minority languages as a relational concept
In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in
contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum
(proper territory of the language):
there is a bilingual community, where the minority language
belongs to;
for historical and political reasons, a majority language superseded
the minority one;
the minority language is reserved for the informal and everyday
functions (called ‘low variety’ or L);
the majority language, often perceived as an imposed second
language (L2), is reserved for the formal functions holding prestige
(‘high variety’ or H).
8 of 26
Is Esperanto a minority
language?
A somehow strange question. . .
Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are
some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of
practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2],
Romaine [8] and Kimura [6].
Analogies:
both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers);

10 of 26
A somehow strange question. . .
Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are
some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of
practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2],
Romaine [8] and Kimura [6].
Analogies:
both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers);
language activists are mostly volunteers – they do not earn a living
in practicing the language;

10 of 26
A somehow strange question. . .
Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are
some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of
practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2],
Romaine [8] and Kimura [6].
Analogies:
both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers);
language activists are mostly volunteers – they do not earn a living
in practicing the language;
speakers consider the language of high value, while non-speakers
are indifferent or even hostile, often for biases;

10 of 26
A somehow strange question. . .
Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are
some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of
practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2],
Romaine [8] and Kimura [6].
Analogies:
both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers);
language activists are mostly volunteers – they do not earn a living
in practicing the language;
speakers consider the language of high value, while non-speakers
are indifferent or even hostile, often for biases;
while Esperanto is clearly a non-ethnic language – rather an ethic
language! – there is a recent tendency to relax the bond between
ethnicity and minority languages (e.g., when learned as a L2).
10 of 26
. . . with a clear answer!
However, adopting our definition of minority language as a relation,
there is no individuable majority language in contrast to Esperanto,
nor a territory with a bilingual community.
For example, a Catalan can choose to be an Esperantist too, while it
cannot choose to be Welsh – unless adopted identity for instance by
marriage, but it is a completely different situation.
Taking the perspective of postmodern linguistics, the rhetorics (in a
technical, neutral sense) behind minority languages and Esperanto are
vey different.
That’s why Esperanto is not a minority language.
11 of 26
. . . with a clear answer!
However, adopting our definition of minority language as a relation,
there is no individuable majority language in contrast to Esperanto,
nor a territory with a bilingual community.
For example, a Catalan can choose to be an Esperantist too, while it
cannot choose to be Welsh – unless adopted identity for instance by
marriage, but it is a completely different situation.
Taking the perspective of postmodern linguistics, the rhetorics (in a
technical, neutral sense) behind minority languages and Esperanto are
vey different.
That’s why Esperanto is not a minority language. Two examples.
11 of 26
The typical discourse behind minority languages
Language activists talk about ethnical, cultural and historical
authenticity. An example from Menominee, an Algonquian language
spoken in norther Wisconsin and Michingan, studied by Bloomfield,
Sapir and Skinner.
That’s why knowing our language is so important, because it
teaches us who we are; it’s not just a set of words. It’s about
our history, it’s about our heritage, it’s about our way of life
that our ancestors have fought and died for.
Karen Washinawatok,
Director of Menominee Language and Culture commission

12 of 26
The typical discourse behind Esperanto
Among others, Jordan [5] effectively resumes the idea that moved
Zamenhof in planning Esperanto, an idea that is at the basis of the
Esperanto movement:
Zamenhof’s ideology treats languages as tools of
communication, and communication as a tool for improving
human welfare. These credos imply that a second-best language
the world can agree to use is better than a “best” language on
which the world cannot agree. They imply also that the peoples
of the world have much in common, so international
communication will contribute to friendship and peace, rather
than animosity and war.

13 of 26
An interlinguistic view of
minority languages
Esperanto as an ally of minority languages
How can Esperanto be an ally of minority language activists? What
are the common traits shared by these movements? Three domains:
1. Language as a value per se. Language activists learn, teach,
promote their languages as they give a value to the language in
itself – while outside the community the language is not considered
important.

15 of 26
Esperanto as an ally of minority languages
How can Esperanto be an ally of minority language activists? What
are the common traits shared by these movements? Three domains:
1. Language as a value per se. Language activists learn, teach,
promote their languages as they give a value to the language in
itself – while outside the community the language is not considered
important.
2. Ecological knowledge. As biodiversity is considered a value in our
contemporary world, also the variety of languages in the world is a
value.

15 of 26
Esperanto as an ally of minority languages
How can Esperanto be an ally of minority language activists? What
are the common traits shared by these movements? Three domains:
1. Language as a value per se. Language activists learn, teach,
promote their languages as they give a value to the language in
itself – while outside the community the language is not considered
important.
2. Ecological knowledge. As biodiversity is considered a value in our
contemporary world, also the variety of languages in the world is a
value.
3. A right-based discourse. Our post-second world war society is
founded upon human rights, where language rights are an
important part. Two examples: the International Mother Language
Day (21 feb) or the Girona Manifesto by the PEN International
Club.
15 of 26
The Language Endangerment Framework

In the last ten years, language planners and activists (both inside and
outside academia) were coordinated by UNESCO forming a panel of
experts assessing a Language Endangerment Framework, i.e., a
practical methodology for what Spolsky [9] calls language
management.
Esperanto should find its way in every multilingual situation, being a
factor of equilibrium and fairness in communication.

16 of 26
The UNESCO guideline Language Vitality and
Endangerment (LVE) and Esperanto (1/2)
LVE assignes a value from ‘0’ (direst situation) to ‘5’ (optimal
situation) to nine domains of the minority language:
1. Intergenerational language transmission
2. Absolute number of speakers
3. Proportion of speakers within the total population
4. Shifts in domains of language use
5. Response to new domains and media
6. Availability of materials for language education and literacy
7. Governmental and institutional language attitudes and
policies including official status and use
8. Community members’ attitudes toward their own language
9. Amount and quality of documentation
17 of 26
The UNESCO guideline Language Vitality and
Endangerment (LVE) and Esperanto (2/2)
In which domains Esperanto could be more helpful?
1. Intergenerational language transmission
2. Absolute number of speakers
3. Proportion of speakers within the total population
4. Shifts in domains of language use
5. Response to new domains and media
6. Availability of materials for language education and literacy
7. Governmental and institutional language attitudes and policies
including official status and use
8. Community members’ attitudes toward their own language
9. Amount and quality of documentation
18 of 26
The Graded Intergenerational Disruption Scale (1/2)
Fishman [4] defines the ‘minimum program’ of reversing language
shift in preserving the intergenerational mother tongue transmission:
Stage 8: Reconstruction and adult acquisition.
Stage 7: Interaction in the language are driven by older
generations, typically grandparents.
Stage 6: The language is used only orally and within the
community, e.g., families and neighbourhood, by three
generations.
Stage 5: The language is used also in written form, with classes
out of school lessons, without any support outside the
community.
In these dramatic stages, pertaining endangered languages, Esperanto
can play little role.
19 of 26
The Graded Intergenerational Disruption Scale (2/2)
Stage 4b: The language is compulsory in lower education,
under control of the minority group.
Stage 4a: The language is compulsory in lower education,
with a wider recognition, i.e., outside the minority group.
Stage 3: The region or local area of the language considers it
normal, so that also members outside the community use it as a
L2.
Stage 2: Public services by the government are provided in the
language, as well as the media usage.
Stage 1: The language is used also in contexts of higher
prestige, including higher education, media and work, within the
region and abroad.
Language acquisition at school (stage 4) is a strategic area to
promote the minority language: the propaedeutic effect of Esperanto
could be tested appropriately.
20 of 26
Concluding remarks
Open problem: how to gather more support?

Romaine [7] recently has pointed out that sustainability is a fuzzy
concept: nowadays, mainstream takes care of what can be measured
in economic terms.
Perhaps language policy experts and language activists should turn to
welfare theory or other areas of economics – economics of
languages being an emergent research field.

22 of 26
An example of language policy as a (missing) variable
The Sustainable Development Solutions Network is a global initiative
for the UN. It publishes a report every year about ‘world happiness’.
Facts worth a mention:
the questionnaire is translated – something controversial in the
literature, for the evaluation of the data;

23 of 26
An example of language policy as a (missing) variable
The Sustainable Development Solutions Network is a global initiative
for the UN. It publishes a report every year about ‘world happiness’.
Facts worth a mention:
the questionnaire is translated – something controversial in the
literature, for the evaluation of the data;
there is no explicit variable concerning the language(s) used in
everyday life as factors of happiness (or not), even if it is clear that
the repertoire strongly affects many variables taken into
considerations, such as ‘freedom to make life choices’ or ‘household
income’.

23 of 26
A final advice

The link between biodiversity conservation,
poverty reduction and language diversity
preservation is worth more investigation, also
for supporters and scholars dealing with
minority languages and Esperanto alike.
Joining forces could be a good win-win
strategy.
24 of 26
References
Edwards, J. 1992 , Sociopolitical aspects of language maintenance and loss: Towards a Typology of Minority
Language Situations, John Benjamins, chapter 3.
In Fase et al. (eds).
Edwards, J. 2010 , Minority Languages and Group Identity, John Benjamins.
Fase, W., Jaspaert, K., Kroon, S., eds 1992, Maintenance and Loss of Minority Languages, John Benjamins.
Fishman, J. A. 1991 , Reversing Language Shift: Theoretical and Empirical Assistance to Threatened Languages,
Multilingual Matters.
Jordan, D. K. 1987, ‘Esperanto & esperantism: symbols and motivations in a movement for linguistic equality’,
Language Problems & Language Planning 11(1), 104–125.
Kimura, G. C. 2012, ‘Esperanto and minority languages: A sociolinguistic comparison’, Language Problems &
Language Planning 36(2), 167–181.
Romaine, S. 2013 , ‘Language and sustainable development: Integrating the economics of language policy with
poverty reduction and biodiversity conservation’, Workshop on The Economics of Language Policy, Venice
International University, San Servolo.
Romaine, S. 2011, ‘Revitalized Languages as Invented Languages’, in Adams, M. eds From Elvish to Klingon,
Oxford University Press.
Spolsky, B. 2009, Language Management, Cambridge University Press.

25 of 26
Thanks for your attention!

Questions?
For proposals, ideas & comments:

federico.gobbo@unito.it

Download & share these slides here:
http:/federicogobbo.name/en/2013.html

$



BY:

C

CC

26 of 26

Federico Gobbo 2013

More Related Content

What's hot

5 language and dialect
5 language and dialect5 language and dialect
5 language and dialect
seemab nazir
 
Chapter 5.sociolinguisitcs
Chapter 5.sociolinguisitcsChapter 5.sociolinguisitcs
Chapter 5.sociolinguisitcs
Shehnaz Mehboob
 
Language planning
Language planningLanguage planning
Language planning
Ayesha Mir
 
Style Register and Dialect
Style Register and DialectStyle Register and Dialect
Style Register and Dialect
Sidra Shahid
 
Social factors governing language variation
Social factors governing language variationSocial factors governing language variation
Social factors governing language variation
ZaraAnsari6
 
Linguistic Imperialism
Linguistic ImperialismLinguistic Imperialism
Linguistic Imperialism
Aiden Yeh
 
01 sociolinguistic
01 sociolinguistic01 sociolinguistic
01 sociolinguistic
ankimakwana
 
Relationship between language, culture, and identity
Relationship between language, culture, and identityRelationship between language, culture, and identity
Relationship between language, culture, and identity
Cool Chaandni
 
Sapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesisSapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesis
Ahmet Ateş
 
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Mar Iam
 
Language Variation
Language VariationLanguage Variation
Language Variation
Dr. Cupid Lucid
 
Language, Culture and Thought
Language, Culture and ThoughtLanguage, Culture and Thought
Language, Culture and Thought
Mutee Ur Rehman
 
Linguistic imperialism
Linguistic imperialismLinguistic imperialism
Linguistic imperialism
KeshabRajRokka
 
Language Planning
Language PlanningLanguage Planning
Language Planning
Ayesha Mir
 
Language variation
Language variation Language variation
Language variation
Umm-e-Rooman Yaqoob
 
Language variation
Language variationLanguage variation
Language variation
idonthaveppt
 
Language death completed presentation
Language death completed presentationLanguage death completed presentation
Language death completed presentation
zeetariq
 
Standardization
StandardizationStandardization
Standardization
Sama Ahmad
 
Presentation of sociolinguistics
Presentation of sociolinguisticsPresentation of sociolinguistics
Presentation of sociolinguistics
TahirRafique10
 
Linguistic And Social Inequality
Linguistic And Social InequalityLinguistic And Social Inequality
Linguistic And Social Inequality
Dr. Cupid Lucid
 

What's hot (20)

5 language and dialect
5 language and dialect5 language and dialect
5 language and dialect
 
Chapter 5.sociolinguisitcs
Chapter 5.sociolinguisitcsChapter 5.sociolinguisitcs
Chapter 5.sociolinguisitcs
 
Language planning
Language planningLanguage planning
Language planning
 
Style Register and Dialect
Style Register and DialectStyle Register and Dialect
Style Register and Dialect
 
Social factors governing language variation
Social factors governing language variationSocial factors governing language variation
Social factors governing language variation
 
Linguistic Imperialism
Linguistic ImperialismLinguistic Imperialism
Linguistic Imperialism
 
01 sociolinguistic
01 sociolinguistic01 sociolinguistic
01 sociolinguistic
 
Relationship between language, culture, and identity
Relationship between language, culture, and identityRelationship between language, culture, and identity
Relationship between language, culture, and identity
 
Sapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesisSapir Whorf hypothesis
Sapir Whorf hypothesis
 
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...Week 2  unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
Week 2 unit 3 & 4 - language maintenance and shift - linguistic varieties an...
 
Language Variation
Language VariationLanguage Variation
Language Variation
 
Language, Culture and Thought
Language, Culture and ThoughtLanguage, Culture and Thought
Language, Culture and Thought
 
Linguistic imperialism
Linguistic imperialismLinguistic imperialism
Linguistic imperialism
 
Language Planning
Language PlanningLanguage Planning
Language Planning
 
Language variation
Language variation Language variation
Language variation
 
Language variation
Language variationLanguage variation
Language variation
 
Language death completed presentation
Language death completed presentationLanguage death completed presentation
Language death completed presentation
 
Standardization
StandardizationStandardization
Standardization
 
Presentation of sociolinguistics
Presentation of sociolinguisticsPresentation of sociolinguistics
Presentation of sociolinguistics
 
Linguistic And Social Inequality
Linguistic And Social InequalityLinguistic And Social Inequality
Linguistic And Social Inequality
 

Viewers also liked

Esperanto. History of English language presentation.
Esperanto.  History of English language presentation.  Esperanto.  History of English language presentation.
Esperanto. History of English language presentation.
María del Pilar Díez Calderón
 
Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shift Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shift
Farah Nadia
 
Esperanto
EsperantoEsperanto
Esperanto: Language and Culture
Esperanto: Language and Culture Esperanto: Language and Culture
Esperanto: Language and Culture
agrao
 
Our blog
Our blogOur blog
The language ideology of Esperanto
The language ideology of EsperantoThe language ideology of Esperanto
The language ideology of Esperanto
Federico Gobbo
 
Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...
Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...
Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...
Federico Gobbo
 
Body Language Presentation
Body Language PresentationBody Language Presentation
Body Language Presentation
AVTAR Career Creators
 
Communication body language
Communication   body languageCommunication   body language
Communication body language
Seta Wicaksana
 
Body language ppt
Body language pptBody language ppt
Body language ppt
Rashmi Shahu
 

Viewers also liked (11)

Esperanto. History of English language presentation.
Esperanto.  History of English language presentation.  Esperanto.  History of English language presentation.
Esperanto. History of English language presentation.
 
Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shift Language maintenance and shift
Language maintenance and shift
 
Esperanto
EsperantoEsperanto
Esperanto
 
Esperanto
EsperantoEsperanto
Esperanto
 
Esperanto: Language and Culture
Esperanto: Language and Culture Esperanto: Language and Culture
Esperanto: Language and Culture
 
Our blog
Our blogOur blog
Our blog
 
The language ideology of Esperanto
The language ideology of EsperantoThe language ideology of Esperanto
The language ideology of Esperanto
 
Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...
Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...
Esperanto, a language for a Global Identity Can Esperanto foster European ide...
 
Body Language Presentation
Body Language PresentationBody Language Presentation
Body Language Presentation
 
Communication body language
Communication   body languageCommunication   body language
Communication body language
 
Body language ppt
Body language pptBody language ppt
Body language ppt
 

Similar to Esperanto and Minority Languages

The Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docx
The Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docxThe Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docx
The Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docx
arnoldmeredith47041
 
Open Issues of Language Contestation in Italy
Open Issues of Language Contestation in ItalyOpen Issues of Language Contestation in Italy
Open Issues of Language Contestation in Italy
Federico Gobbo
 
Sociolinguistics
SociolinguisticsSociolinguistics
Sociolinguistics
Ronnier Barrientos
 
Socio samenvatting
Socio samenvattingSocio samenvatting
Socio samenvatting
Umm-e-Rooman Yaqoob
 
Prof. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhoferProf. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhofer
Richard Pinner
 
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
Richard Pinner
 
An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...
An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...
An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...
José Ramom Pichel Campos
 
Language
LanguageLanguage
Language
because789
 
Honors geo. ch 8 p.p
Honors geo. ch 8 p.pHonors geo. ch 8 p.p
Honors geo. ch 8 p.p
tobin15
 
Language and Regional Variations by Yule
Language and Regional Variations by YuleLanguage and Regional Variations by Yule
Language and Regional Variations by Yule
Ronald Suplido Jr
 
LANE422ch7.ppt
LANE422ch7.pptLANE422ch7.ppt
LANE422ch7.ppt
akshaya601777
 
8.6 Problem of interlingual culture
8.6 Problem of interlingual culture8.6 Problem of interlingual culture
8.6 Problem of interlingual culture
LyNguyn834719
 
What is interlinguistics.
What is interlinguistics.What is interlinguistics.
What is interlinguistics.
Daria33517
 
Lecture 1 ENGL1.pdf
Lecture 1 ENGL1.pdfLecture 1 ENGL1.pdf
Lecture 1 ENGL1.pdf
MohammadKhreisat5
 
Language variartion and varities of language
Language variartion and varities of languageLanguage variartion and varities of language
Language variartion and varities of language
Umm-e-Rooman Yaqoob
 
Interlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new Millennium
Interlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new MillenniumInterlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new Millennium
Interlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new Millennium
Federico Gobbo
 
History of the English Language
History of the English Language History of the English Language
History of the English Language
MehakAli97
 
Summary of "A History of the English Language"
Summary of "A History of the English Language"Summary of "A History of the English Language"
Summary of "A History of the English Language"
Sarah Abdussalam
 
134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx
134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx
134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx
herminaprocter
 
Standard language.
Standard language.Standard language.
Standard language.
zahraa Aamir
 

Similar to Esperanto and Minority Languages (20)

The Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docx
The Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docxThe Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docx
The Geography of Language(Rubenstein, Ch. 5)Geolinguistics =.docx
 
Open Issues of Language Contestation in Italy
Open Issues of Language Contestation in ItalyOpen Issues of Language Contestation in Italy
Open Issues of Language Contestation in Italy
 
Sociolinguistics
SociolinguisticsSociolinguistics
Sociolinguistics
 
Socio samenvatting
Socio samenvattingSocio samenvatting
Socio samenvatting
 
Prof. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhoferProf. barbara seidlhofer
Prof. barbara seidlhofer
 
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
EMI and CLIL and ELF: how do they relate?
 
An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...
An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...
An approach to open source nlp tools for galician as minoritized variety of p...
 
Language
LanguageLanguage
Language
 
Honors geo. ch 8 p.p
Honors geo. ch 8 p.pHonors geo. ch 8 p.p
Honors geo. ch 8 p.p
 
Language and Regional Variations by Yule
Language and Regional Variations by YuleLanguage and Regional Variations by Yule
Language and Regional Variations by Yule
 
LANE422ch7.ppt
LANE422ch7.pptLANE422ch7.ppt
LANE422ch7.ppt
 
8.6 Problem of interlingual culture
8.6 Problem of interlingual culture8.6 Problem of interlingual culture
8.6 Problem of interlingual culture
 
What is interlinguistics.
What is interlinguistics.What is interlinguistics.
What is interlinguistics.
 
Lecture 1 ENGL1.pdf
Lecture 1 ENGL1.pdfLecture 1 ENGL1.pdf
Lecture 1 ENGL1.pdf
 
Language variartion and varities of language
Language variartion and varities of languageLanguage variartion and varities of language
Language variartion and varities of language
 
Interlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new Millennium
Interlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new MillenniumInterlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new Millennium
Interlinguistics and Esperanto Studies in the new Millennium
 
History of the English Language
History of the English Language History of the English Language
History of the English Language
 
Summary of "A History of the English Language"
Summary of "A History of the English Language"Summary of "A History of the English Language"
Summary of "A History of the English Language"
 
134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx
134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx
134 Languages in Contact each other as Aboriginal Australi.docx
 
Standard language.
Standard language.Standard language.
Standard language.
 

More from Federico Gobbo

Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...
Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...
Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...
Federico Gobbo
 
Esperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto Ricevema
Esperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto RicevemaEsperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto Ricevema
Esperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto Ricevema
Federico Gobbo
 
L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...
L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...
L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...
Federico Gobbo
 
One species, many languages
One species, many languagesOne species, many languages
One species, many languages
Federico Gobbo
 
Una lingua comune per l'Europa?
Una lingua comune per l'Europa?Una lingua comune per l'Europa?
Una lingua comune per l'Europa?
Federico Gobbo
 
Esperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondo
Esperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondoEsperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondo
Esperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondo
Federico Gobbo
 
Reflecting upon the European Day of Languages
Reflecting upon the European Day of LanguagesReflecting upon the European Day of Languages
Reflecting upon the European Day of Languages
Federico Gobbo
 
Interlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di Amsterdam
Interlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di AmsterdamInterlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di Amsterdam
Interlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di Amsterdam
Federico Gobbo
 
Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...
Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...
Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...
Federico Gobbo
 
Complex Arguments in Adpositional Argumentation
Complex Arguments in Adpositional ArgumentationComplex Arguments in Adpositional Argumentation
Complex Arguments in Adpositional Argumentation
Federico Gobbo
 
Assessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justice
Assessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justiceAssessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justice
Assessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justice
Federico Gobbo
 
Lingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperanto
Lingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperantoLingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperanto
Lingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperanto
Federico Gobbo
 
Le lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperanto
Le lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperantoLe lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperanto
Le lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperanto
Federico Gobbo
 
The Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective Identity
The Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective IdentityThe Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective Identity
The Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective Identity
Federico Gobbo
 
I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...
I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...
I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...
Federico Gobbo
 
Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...
Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...
Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...
Federico Gobbo
 
Lingva Kafejo: Esperanto
Lingva Kafejo: EsperantoLingva Kafejo: Esperanto
Lingva Kafejo: Esperanto
Federico Gobbo
 
Fare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domani
Fare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domaniFare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domani
Fare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domani
Federico Gobbo
 
Hollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New Millennium
Hollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New MillenniumHollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New Millennium
Hollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New Millennium
Federico Gobbo
 
Language regimes of the European Union
Language regimes of the European UnionLanguage regimes of the European Union
Language regimes of the European Union
Federico Gobbo
 

More from Federico Gobbo (20)

Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...
Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...
Human-Machine Communication strategies in today’s Esperanto community of prac...
 
Esperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto Ricevema
Esperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto RicevemaEsperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto Ricevema
Esperanto as Lingua Receptiva / Esperanto Ricevema
 
L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...
L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...
L’utilizzo di lingue inventate come strumento di educazione interculturale in...
 
One species, many languages
One species, many languagesOne species, many languages
One species, many languages
 
Una lingua comune per l'Europa?
Una lingua comune per l'Europa?Una lingua comune per l'Europa?
Una lingua comune per l'Europa?
 
Esperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondo
Esperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondoEsperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondo
Esperanto: el Eŭropa lulilo al disvastiĝo tra la tuta mondo
 
Reflecting upon the European Day of Languages
Reflecting upon the European Day of LanguagesReflecting upon the European Day of Languages
Reflecting upon the European Day of Languages
 
Interlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di Amsterdam
Interlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di AmsterdamInterlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di Amsterdam
Interlinguistica ed esperantologia oggi: l’esperienza di Amsterdam
 
Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...
Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...
Adpositional Argumentation: How Logic Originates In Natural Argumentative Dis...
 
Complex Arguments in Adpositional Argumentation
Complex Arguments in Adpositional ArgumentationComplex Arguments in Adpositional Argumentation
Complex Arguments in Adpositional Argumentation
 
Assessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justice
Assessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justiceAssessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justice
Assessing linguistic unease to understand (socio)linguistic justice
 
Lingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperanto
Lingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperantoLingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperanto
Lingua di contatto e mobilità: il caso dell'esperanto
 
Le lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperanto
Le lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperantoLe lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperanto
Le lingue di minoranza: il caso dell'esperanto
 
The Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective Identity
The Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective IdentityThe Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective Identity
The Religious Dimensions of the Esperanto Collective Identity
 
I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...
I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...
I limiti dell'invenzione linguistica: la tipologia linguistica dall'esperanto...
 
Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...
Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...
Sei definizioni in cerca di una disciplina - Interlinguistica tra comunicazio...
 
Lingva Kafejo: Esperanto
Lingva Kafejo: EsperantoLingva Kafejo: Esperanto
Lingva Kafejo: Esperanto
 
Fare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domani
Fare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domaniFare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domani
Fare musica in esperanto : ieri, oggi, domani
 
Hollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New Millennium
Hollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New MillenniumHollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New Millennium
Hollywood Languages: The Challenge of Interlinguistics in the New Millennium
 
Language regimes of the European Union
Language regimes of the European UnionLanguage regimes of the European Union
Language regimes of the European Union
 

Recently uploaded

DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008
DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008
DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008
Glenn Rivera
 
2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture produce.pptx
2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture  produce.pptx2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture  produce.pptx
2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture produce.pptx
UmeshTimilsina1
 
Parkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptx
Parkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptxParkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptx
Parkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptx
AnujVishwakarma34
 
Imagination in Computer Science Research
Imagination in Computer Science ResearchImagination in Computer Science Research
Imagination in Computer Science Research
Abhik Roychoudhury
 
SD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptx
SD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptxSD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptx
SD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptx
elwoodprias1
 
ASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
ASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdfASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
ASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
Scholarhat
 
C Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdf
C Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdfC Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdf
C Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdf
Scholarhat
 
Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...
Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...
Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...
Alvaro Barbosa
 
Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.
Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.
Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.
DrRavindrakshirsagar1
 
How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17
How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17
How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17
How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17
How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Java MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Java MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHatJava MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Java MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Scholarhat
 
JavaScript Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat
JavaScript Interview  Questions PDF By ScholarHatJavaScript Interview  Questions PDF By ScholarHat
JavaScript Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat
Scholarhat
 
Introduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal Use
Introduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal UseIntroduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal Use
Introduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal Use
Excellence Foundation for South Sudan
 
RDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEW
RDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEWRDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEW
RDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEW
Murugan Solaiyappan
 
slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...
slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...
slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...
MANIVALANSR
 
Our Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate Change
Our Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate ChangeOur Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate Change
Our Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate Change
Postal Advocate Inc.
 
C# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
C# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdfC# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
C# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
Scholarhat
 
11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx
11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx
11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx
mansk2
 

Recently uploaded (20)

DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008
DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008
DepEd School Calendar 2024-2025 DO_s2024_008
 
2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture produce.pptx
2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture  produce.pptx2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture  produce.pptx
2 Post harvest Physiology of Horticulture produce.pptx
 
Parkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptx
Parkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptxParkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptx
Parkinson Disease & Anti-Parkinsonian Drugs.pptx
 
Imagination in Computer Science Research
Imagination in Computer Science ResearchImagination in Computer Science Research
Imagination in Computer Science Research
 
SD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptx
SD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptxSD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptx
SD_Integrating 21st Century Skills in Classroom-based Assessment.pptx
 
ASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
ASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdfASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
ASP.NET Core Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
 
C Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdf
C Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdfC Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdf
C Interview Questions PDF By Scholarhat.pdf
 
Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...
Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...
Benchmarking Sustainability: Neurosciences and AI Tech Research in Macau - Ke...
 
Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.
Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.
Genetics Teaching Plan: Dr.Kshirsagar R.V.
 
How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17
How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17
How to Manage Access Rights & User Types in Odoo 17
 
BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BỘ ĐỀ THI HỌC SINH GIỎI CÁC TỈNH MÔN TIẾNG ANH LỚP 9 NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
 
How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17
How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17
How to Empty a One2Many Field in Odoo 17
 
Java MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Java MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHatJava MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Java MCQ Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
 
JavaScript Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat
JavaScript Interview  Questions PDF By ScholarHatJavaScript Interview  Questions PDF By ScholarHat
JavaScript Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat
 
Introduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal Use
Introduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal UseIntroduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal Use
Introduction to Google Productivity Tools for Office and Personal Use
 
RDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEW
RDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEWRDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEW
RDBMS Lecture Notes Unit4 chapter12 VIEW
 
slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...
slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...
slidesgo-mastering-the-art-of-listening-insights-from-robin-sharma-2024070718...
 
Our Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate Change
Our Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate ChangeOur Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate Change
Our Guide to the July 2024 USPS® Rate Change
 
C# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
C# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdfC# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
C# Interview Questions PDF By ScholarHat.pdf
 
11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx
11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx
11EHS Term 3 Week 1 Unit 1 Review: Feedback and improvementpptx
 

Esperanto and Minority Languages

  • 1. Esperanto and minority languages Challenges and opportunities Federico Gobbo University of Turin, Italy federico.gobbo@unito.it 1 of 26 $ BY: C CC University of Liverpool, UK October 17, 2013
  • 2. What is a minority language?
  • 3. European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages The definition: languages traditionally used within a given territory of a state by nationals of that state who form a group numerically smaller than the rest of the state’s population; they are different from the official language(s) of that state, and they include neither dialects of the official language(s) of the state nor the languages of migrants. (ECRML, Art. 1 – Definitions) Let us consider some consequences. 3 of 26
  • 4. Only a matter of number of (native) speakers? Wikipedia, our repository of common-sense knowledge, states that “a minority language is a language spoken by a minority of the population of a territor”. This is a half-truth. The problem of the (false) equivalence ‘minority languages = lesser-used languages’: where is the border of lesser-usage? 100,000 native speakers? 10,000? 1,000? We need to re-engineer the concept of minority languages. 4 of 26
  • 5. Italy, a multilingual nation-state (look only to colours!)
  • 6. A taxonomy of minority languages Let’s take Italy as the reference territory for further analysis. Edwards [1] introduced a taxonomy of minority languages, where: local-only minority languages are for example German, French, Slovene (they are national language elsewhere); 6 of 26
  • 7. A taxonomy of minority languages Let’s take Italy as the reference territory for further analysis. Edwards [1] introduced a taxonomy of minority languages, where: local-only minority languages are for example German, French, Slovene (they are national language elsewhere); unique minority languages are for example Piedmontese, Venetian (settled only in Italy only in a minority status); 6 of 26
  • 8. A taxonomy of minority languages Let’s take Italy as the reference territory for further analysis. Edwards [1] introduced a taxonomy of minority languages, where: local-only minority languages are for example German, French, Slovene (they are national language elsewhere); unique minority languages are for example Piedmontese, Venetian (settled only in Italy only in a minority status); non-unique minority languages: an example is Catalan (present in more than one state but never at a national level); 6 of 26
  • 9. The paradox of South Tyrol in Italy From a state perspective German is a minority language, from the provincial perspective it is not – paraphrasing Edwards [1].
  • 10. Framing minority languages as a relational concept In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum (proper territory of the language): there is a bilingual community, where the minority language belongs to; 8 of 26
  • 11. Framing minority languages as a relational concept In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum (proper territory of the language): there is a bilingual community, where the minority language belongs to; for historical and political reasons, a majority language superseded the minority one; 8 of 26
  • 12. Framing minority languages as a relational concept In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum (proper territory of the language): there is a bilingual community, where the minority language belongs to; for historical and political reasons, a majority language superseded the minority one; the minority language is reserved for the informal and everyday functions (called ‘low variety’ or L); 8 of 26
  • 13. Framing minority languages as a relational concept In the prototypical situation, a minority language is always defined in contrast to a majority language settled in the same Sprachraum (proper territory of the language): there is a bilingual community, where the minority language belongs to; for historical and political reasons, a majority language superseded the minority one; the minority language is reserved for the informal and everyday functions (called ‘low variety’ or L); the majority language, often perceived as an imposed second language (L2), is reserved for the formal functions holding prestige (‘high variety’ or H). 8 of 26
  • 14. Is Esperanto a minority language?
  • 15. A somehow strange question. . . Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2], Romaine [8] and Kimura [6]. Analogies: both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers); 10 of 26
  • 16. A somehow strange question. . . Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2], Romaine [8] and Kimura [6]. Analogies: both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers); language activists are mostly volunteers – they do not earn a living in practicing the language; 10 of 26
  • 17. A somehow strange question. . . Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2], Romaine [8] and Kimura [6]. Analogies: both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers); language activists are mostly volunteers – they do not earn a living in practicing the language; speakers consider the language of high value, while non-speakers are indifferent or even hostile, often for biases; 10 of 26
  • 18. A somehow strange question. . . Esperanto is proposed at an international level. However, there are some sociolinguistic analogies between the Esperanto community of practice and minority languages, put in evidence by Edwards [2], Romaine [8] and Kimura [6]. Analogies: both are lesser-used languages (minority in terms of numbers); language activists are mostly volunteers – they do not earn a living in practicing the language; speakers consider the language of high value, while non-speakers are indifferent or even hostile, often for biases; while Esperanto is clearly a non-ethnic language – rather an ethic language! – there is a recent tendency to relax the bond between ethnicity and minority languages (e.g., when learned as a L2). 10 of 26
  • 19. . . . with a clear answer! However, adopting our definition of minority language as a relation, there is no individuable majority language in contrast to Esperanto, nor a territory with a bilingual community. For example, a Catalan can choose to be an Esperantist too, while it cannot choose to be Welsh – unless adopted identity for instance by marriage, but it is a completely different situation. Taking the perspective of postmodern linguistics, the rhetorics (in a technical, neutral sense) behind minority languages and Esperanto are vey different. That’s why Esperanto is not a minority language. 11 of 26
  • 20. . . . with a clear answer! However, adopting our definition of minority language as a relation, there is no individuable majority language in contrast to Esperanto, nor a territory with a bilingual community. For example, a Catalan can choose to be an Esperantist too, while it cannot choose to be Welsh – unless adopted identity for instance by marriage, but it is a completely different situation. Taking the perspective of postmodern linguistics, the rhetorics (in a technical, neutral sense) behind minority languages and Esperanto are vey different. That’s why Esperanto is not a minority language. Two examples. 11 of 26
  • 21. The typical discourse behind minority languages Language activists talk about ethnical, cultural and historical authenticity. An example from Menominee, an Algonquian language spoken in norther Wisconsin and Michingan, studied by Bloomfield, Sapir and Skinner. That’s why knowing our language is so important, because it teaches us who we are; it’s not just a set of words. It’s about our history, it’s about our heritage, it’s about our way of life that our ancestors have fought and died for. Karen Washinawatok, Director of Menominee Language and Culture commission 12 of 26
  • 22. The typical discourse behind Esperanto Among others, Jordan [5] effectively resumes the idea that moved Zamenhof in planning Esperanto, an idea that is at the basis of the Esperanto movement: Zamenhof’s ideology treats languages as tools of communication, and communication as a tool for improving human welfare. These credos imply that a second-best language the world can agree to use is better than a “best” language on which the world cannot agree. They imply also that the peoples of the world have much in common, so international communication will contribute to friendship and peace, rather than animosity and war. 13 of 26
  • 23. An interlinguistic view of minority languages
  • 24. Esperanto as an ally of minority languages How can Esperanto be an ally of minority language activists? What are the common traits shared by these movements? Three domains: 1. Language as a value per se. Language activists learn, teach, promote their languages as they give a value to the language in itself – while outside the community the language is not considered important. 15 of 26
  • 25. Esperanto as an ally of minority languages How can Esperanto be an ally of minority language activists? What are the common traits shared by these movements? Three domains: 1. Language as a value per se. Language activists learn, teach, promote their languages as they give a value to the language in itself – while outside the community the language is not considered important. 2. Ecological knowledge. As biodiversity is considered a value in our contemporary world, also the variety of languages in the world is a value. 15 of 26
  • 26. Esperanto as an ally of minority languages How can Esperanto be an ally of minority language activists? What are the common traits shared by these movements? Three domains: 1. Language as a value per se. Language activists learn, teach, promote their languages as they give a value to the language in itself – while outside the community the language is not considered important. 2. Ecological knowledge. As biodiversity is considered a value in our contemporary world, also the variety of languages in the world is a value. 3. A right-based discourse. Our post-second world war society is founded upon human rights, where language rights are an important part. Two examples: the International Mother Language Day (21 feb) or the Girona Manifesto by the PEN International Club. 15 of 26
  • 27. The Language Endangerment Framework In the last ten years, language planners and activists (both inside and outside academia) were coordinated by UNESCO forming a panel of experts assessing a Language Endangerment Framework, i.e., a practical methodology for what Spolsky [9] calls language management. Esperanto should find its way in every multilingual situation, being a factor of equilibrium and fairness in communication. 16 of 26
  • 28. The UNESCO guideline Language Vitality and Endangerment (LVE) and Esperanto (1/2) LVE assignes a value from ‘0’ (direst situation) to ‘5’ (optimal situation) to nine domains of the minority language: 1. Intergenerational language transmission 2. Absolute number of speakers 3. Proportion of speakers within the total population 4. Shifts in domains of language use 5. Response to new domains and media 6. Availability of materials for language education and literacy 7. Governmental and institutional language attitudes and policies including official status and use 8. Community members’ attitudes toward their own language 9. Amount and quality of documentation 17 of 26
  • 29. The UNESCO guideline Language Vitality and Endangerment (LVE) and Esperanto (2/2) In which domains Esperanto could be more helpful? 1. Intergenerational language transmission 2. Absolute number of speakers 3. Proportion of speakers within the total population 4. Shifts in domains of language use 5. Response to new domains and media 6. Availability of materials for language education and literacy 7. Governmental and institutional language attitudes and policies including official status and use 8. Community members’ attitudes toward their own language 9. Amount and quality of documentation 18 of 26
  • 30. The Graded Intergenerational Disruption Scale (1/2) Fishman [4] defines the ‘minimum program’ of reversing language shift in preserving the intergenerational mother tongue transmission: Stage 8: Reconstruction and adult acquisition. Stage 7: Interaction in the language are driven by older generations, typically grandparents. Stage 6: The language is used only orally and within the community, e.g., families and neighbourhood, by three generations. Stage 5: The language is used also in written form, with classes out of school lessons, without any support outside the community. In these dramatic stages, pertaining endangered languages, Esperanto can play little role. 19 of 26
  • 31. The Graded Intergenerational Disruption Scale (2/2) Stage 4b: The language is compulsory in lower education, under control of the minority group. Stage 4a: The language is compulsory in lower education, with a wider recognition, i.e., outside the minority group. Stage 3: The region or local area of the language considers it normal, so that also members outside the community use it as a L2. Stage 2: Public services by the government are provided in the language, as well as the media usage. Stage 1: The language is used also in contexts of higher prestige, including higher education, media and work, within the region and abroad. Language acquisition at school (stage 4) is a strategic area to promote the minority language: the propaedeutic effect of Esperanto could be tested appropriately. 20 of 26
  • 33. Open problem: how to gather more support? Romaine [7] recently has pointed out that sustainability is a fuzzy concept: nowadays, mainstream takes care of what can be measured in economic terms. Perhaps language policy experts and language activists should turn to welfare theory or other areas of economics – economics of languages being an emergent research field. 22 of 26
  • 34. An example of language policy as a (missing) variable The Sustainable Development Solutions Network is a global initiative for the UN. It publishes a report every year about ‘world happiness’. Facts worth a mention: the questionnaire is translated – something controversial in the literature, for the evaluation of the data; 23 of 26
  • 35. An example of language policy as a (missing) variable The Sustainable Development Solutions Network is a global initiative for the UN. It publishes a report every year about ‘world happiness’. Facts worth a mention: the questionnaire is translated – something controversial in the literature, for the evaluation of the data; there is no explicit variable concerning the language(s) used in everyday life as factors of happiness (or not), even if it is clear that the repertoire strongly affects many variables taken into considerations, such as ‘freedom to make life choices’ or ‘household income’. 23 of 26
  • 36. A final advice The link between biodiversity conservation, poverty reduction and language diversity preservation is worth more investigation, also for supporters and scholars dealing with minority languages and Esperanto alike. Joining forces could be a good win-win strategy. 24 of 26
  • 37. References Edwards, J. 1992 , Sociopolitical aspects of language maintenance and loss: Towards a Typology of Minority Language Situations, John Benjamins, chapter 3. In Fase et al. (eds). Edwards, J. 2010 , Minority Languages and Group Identity, John Benjamins. Fase, W., Jaspaert, K., Kroon, S., eds 1992, Maintenance and Loss of Minority Languages, John Benjamins. Fishman, J. A. 1991 , Reversing Language Shift: Theoretical and Empirical Assistance to Threatened Languages, Multilingual Matters. Jordan, D. K. 1987, ‘Esperanto & esperantism: symbols and motivations in a movement for linguistic equality’, Language Problems & Language Planning 11(1), 104–125. Kimura, G. C. 2012, ‘Esperanto and minority languages: A sociolinguistic comparison’, Language Problems & Language Planning 36(2), 167–181. Romaine, S. 2013 , ‘Language and sustainable development: Integrating the economics of language policy with poverty reduction and biodiversity conservation’, Workshop on The Economics of Language Policy, Venice International University, San Servolo. Romaine, S. 2011, ‘Revitalized Languages as Invented Languages’, in Adams, M. eds From Elvish to Klingon, Oxford University Press. Spolsky, B. 2009, Language Management, Cambridge University Press. 25 of 26
  • 38. Thanks for your attention! Questions? For proposals, ideas & comments: federico.gobbo@unito.it Download & share these slides here: http:/federicogobbo.name/en/2013.html $ BY: C CC 26 of 26 Federico Gobbo 2013