Investigations philosophy

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Ad

Kevin Desprez, L3
Florence 2016
INVESTIGATING

WARNING

• Yes, this seminar slides do contain a lot of
text.

• Yes, this seminar slides do contain a lot of
text.
• I know this isn’t recommended.

• Yes, this seminar slides do contain a lot of
text.
• I know this isn’t recommended.
• But not all of you speak fluent En...

• Yes, this seminar slides do contain a lot of
text.
• I know this isn’t recommended.
• But not all of you speak fluent En...

• Yes, this seminar slides do contain a lot of
text.
• I know this isn’t recommended.
• But not all of you speak fluent En...

And I want you to take
the most out of this☺

FJ and HJ: Two very different roles

FJ and HJ: Two very different roles
• FJs identify issues and report them.

FJ and HJ: Two very different roles
• FJs identify issues and report them.
• HJs investigate and make decisions.

FJ and HJ: Two very different roles
• FJs identify issues and report them.
• HJs investigate and make decisions.
• Without...

FJ and HJ: Two very different roles
• FJs identify issues and report them.
• HJs investigate and make decisions.
• Without...

FJ and HJ: Two very different roles
• FJs identify issues and report them.
• HJs investigate and make decisions.
• Without...

The FJ’s first actions

The FJ’s first actions
• Identify the situation
Simple Rules question or premise of a complicated investigation?

The FJ’s first actions
• Identify the situation
Simple Rules question or premise of a complicated investigation?
• Underst...

The FJ’s first actions
• Identify the situation
Simple Rules question or premise of a complicated investigation?
• Underst...

The FJ’s first actions
• Identify the situation
Simple Rules question or premise of a complicated investigation?
• Underst...

The FJ’s first actions
• Identify the situation
Simple Rules question or premise of a complicated investigation?
• Underst...

You should be paranoid… not complicated

You should be paranoid… not complicated
• You must look so that you can touch
– Understand the game state (Illegal block, ...

You should be paranoid… not complicated
• You must look so that you can touch
– Understand the game state (Illegal block, ...

You should be paranoid… not complicated
• You must look so that you can touch
– Understand the game state (Illegal block, ...

You should be paranoid… not complicated
• You must look so that you can touch
– Understand the game state (Illegal block, ...

You must look so that you can touch
I don’t think players like that much
Heaven knows what players can do
Heaven knows wha...

The FJ’s Goals

The FJ’s Goals
• Gather facts or players’ initial claims
This is the closest-to-truth story you’ll ever get

The FJ’s Goals
• Gather facts or players’ initial claims
This is the closest-to-truth story you’ll ever get
• Get a commit...

The FJ’s Goals
• Gather facts or players’ initial claims
This is the closest-to-truth story you’ll ever get
• Get a commit...

The FJ’s Goals
• Gather facts or players’ initial claims
This is the closest-to-truth story you’ll ever get
• Get a commit...

The FJ’s Goals
• Gather facts or players’ initial claims
This is the closest-to-truth story you’ll ever get
• Get a commit...

The FJ’s Goals
• Gather facts or players’ initial claims
This is the closest-to-truth story you’ll ever get
• Get a commit...

The HJ’s Goals

The HJ’s Goals
• Get the initial picture from the FJ

The HJ’s Goals
• Get the initial picture from the FJ
• Listen to both players

The HJ’s Goals
• Get the initial picture from the FJ
• Listen to both players
• Is it worth investigating?

The HJ’s Goals
• Get the initial picture from the FJ
• Listen to both players
• Is it worth investigating?
• Identifying l...

The HJ’s Goals
• Get the initial picture from the FJ
• Listen to both players
• Is it worth investigating?
• Identifying l...

The HJ’s Goals
• Get the initial picture from the FJ
• Listen to both players
• Is it worth investigating?
• Identifying l...

The HJ’s Goals
• Get the initial picture from the FJ
• Listen to both players
• Is it worth investigating?
• Identifying l...

Getting the initial picture

Getting the initial picture
• Understand before reaching the table
Don’t do this while walking to the table

Getting the initial picture
• Understand before reaching the table
Don’t do this while walking to the table
– Harder to li...

Getting the initial picture
• Understand before reaching the table
Don’t do this while walking to the table
– Harder to li...

Getting the initial picture
• Understand before reaching the table
Don’t do this while walking to the table
– Harder to li...

Getting the initial picture
• Understand before reaching the table
Don’t do this while walking to the table
– Harder to li...

Getting the initial picture
• Understand before reaching the table
Don’t do this while walking to the table
– Harder to li...

Getting the initial picture
• Understand before reaching the table
Don’t do this while walking to the table
– Harder to li...

Listening to players

Listening to players
• If both players agree on facts, summarize
them to confirm the issue.

Listening to players
• If both players agree on facts, summarize
them to confirm the issue.
• If they disagree, or are not...

Listening to players
• If both players agree on facts, summarize
them to confirm the issue.
• If they disagree, or are not...

Listening to players
• If both players agree on facts, summarize
them to confirm the issue.
• If they disagree, or are not...

Listening to players
• If both players agree on facts, summarize
them to confirm the issue.
• If they disagree, or are not...

Are they Cheating?

$Are they Cheating? • It is Cheating if an infraction was committed:$

$Are they Cheating? • It is Cheating if an infraction was committed: a. Intentionally$

$Are they Cheating? • It is Cheating if an infraction was committed: a. Intentionally b. Knowingly$

$Are they Cheating? • It is Cheating if an infraction was committed: a. Intentionally b. Knowingly c. To gain an advantage$

$Are they Cheating? • It is Cheating if an infraction was committed: a. Intentionally b. Knowingly c. To gain an advantage ...$

$Are they Cheating? • It is Cheating if an infraction was committed: a. Intentionally b. Knowingly c. To gain an advantage ...$

$Are they Cheating? • It is Cheating if an infraction was committed: a. Intentionally b. Knowingly c. To gain an advantage ...$

Is it worth investigating?

Is it worth investigating?
• If the quest for Truth is very important to the two players
involved, tournament timing matte...

Is it worth investigating?
• If the quest for Truth is very important to the two players
involved, tournament timing matte...

Is it worth investigating?
• If the quest for Truth is very important to the two players
involved, tournament timing matte...

Is it worth investigating?
• If the quest for Truth is very important to the two players
involved, tournament timing matte...

Is it worth investigating?
• If the quest for Truth is very important to the two players
involved, tournament timing matte...

Identifying lying

Identifying lying
• Does one of the players lie?
– It’s not because two players disagree that one lies

Identifying lying
• Does one of the players lie?
– It’s not because two players disagree that one lies
– Both players may ...

Identifying lying
• Does one of the players lie?
– It’s not because two players disagree that one lies
– Both players may ...

Identifying lying
• Does one of the players lie?
– It’s not because two players disagree that one lies
– Both players may ...

Evidences and Feelings

Evidences and Feelings
• Very few situations rely on “hard” facts.

Evidences and Feelings
• Very few situations rely on “hard” facts.
• Evidence or not, you’ll need to make a
decision.
– Ju...

Evidences and Feelings
• Very few situations rely on “hard” facts.
• Evidence or not, you’ll need to make a
decision.
– Ju...

Evidences and Feelings
• Very few situations rely on “hard” facts.
• Evidence or not, you’ll need to make a
decision.
– Ju...

Making the decision

Making the decision
• As soon as the investigation stops progressing,
it’s time to make a decision (GP LIL12)

Making the decision
• As soon as the investigation stops progressing,
it’s time to make a decision (GP LIL12)
– Looping is...

Making the decision
• As soon as the investigation stops progressing,
it’s time to make a decision (GP LIL12)
– Looping is...

Announcing the decision

Announcing the decision
• If your conclusions indicate a DQ, talk to the
player apart, as this also prevents spectators
fr...

Announcing the decision
• If your conclusions indicate a DQ, talk to the
player apart, as this also prevents spectators
fr...

Reporting the decision

Reporting the decision
• Print the DQ FAQ and give it to the player

Reporting the decision
• Print the DQ FAQ and give it to the player
• Encourage the player to write or email a
statement. ...

Reporting the decision
• Print the DQ FAQ and give it to the player
• Encourage the player to write or email a
statement. ...

Reporting the decision
• Print the DQ FAQ and give it to the player
• Encourage the player to write or email a
statement. ...

Reporting the decision
• Print the DQ FAQ and give it to the player
• Encourage the player to write or email a
statement. ...

Thank you!

Thank you!
Questions?