Compensation and Employee
           Behaviour: Part I
Dr. G C Mohanta, BE(Mech), MSc(Engg), MBA, PhD(Mgt)
                   Professor




                                                1
Bases for Traditional Pay System
Based on cost of living and labour market
Base wage or salary
Evenly distributed between employees
Correlated with seniority
Based on individual performance daily, weekly,
 monthly




                                                  2
Bases for Modern Pay System
Variable pay
Based on business performance
Differentiated
Based on individual performance
Based on team and organisational performance
Used as a means of communicating values




                                                3
Traditional Pay System
Sets pay levels in a narrow band with regular increase
May be 3 to 4 percent pay increase annually
Increases meant for promotions, merit, cost of living
Less distinction betn. merit & cost of living increase
 Most merit raises perceived as little more than cost
 of living increases due to low levels (3 to 4 percent)
Often, it includes a set salary or wage, a set schedule
 for merit increases, and a set benefits package


                                                           4
Modern Pay System
It pays greater emphasis on variable pay
Base wage seen as job worth in open market,
  merit pay - reward for results by employee each year
An employee can get a raise either by increasing his
  job's value or by performing well
Some companies use three-way system to determine
  annual increases:
- Did the employee accomplish his goals?
- Did the company reach its targets?
- Did the employee act in accordance with established
  competencies for his job?
                                                         5
Modern Pay System
Some companies create broader bands in salary
 structures
In past, large companies had many salary levels in
 each department, making it difficult for employees to
 move to different jobs
Employees can seek more opportunities now without
 penalty with 5 large bands, instead of 25 narrow bands
Incentives available, like bonuses, team based
 incentives/gain sharing, profit sharing, quality
 awards, stock purchase options, etc.
                                                          6
Purpose of Compensation
                     Contribution based                       Ensure Equity
                     Remuneration




                      Attract talent




                                             Co Effec
                                                                      Administratively




                                               m
                                                                      Efficient            Legal


                                                 pe tive
Institutionalized                                                                        Compliance

                                                   ns
    Processes
                                                      ati
                                                         on
                              Motivate &
                              Retain Staff                    Reward Valued
                                                              Behavior




    Thursday, September 20, 2012                                                                7
Establishing Pay Plans
                                           Business Goals
                                                                    Compensation
                                                                     Compensation
                                                              Philosophy/ activities
                                                               Philosophy/ activities
CEO




                                                                    serve Business
                                             Business                serve Business
                                                                        Objectives
                                              Strategy                    Objectives




      Business Strategy – This defines the direction in which
      organization is going in relation to its environment in order
      to achieve its objectives.

       Compensation Philosophy – Consists of a set of beliefs
       which underpin the reward/compensation strategy of the
       organization and govern the reward policies that determine
       how reward processes operate


      Thursday, September 20, 2012                                                      8
Establishing Pay Plans
                                                                   Compensation activities
                                                                     Compensation activities
                                               Business Goals    serve Business Objectives
                                                                  serve Business Objectives
CEO




                                                 Business         Compensation strategy is
                                                                    Compensation strategy is
                                                  Strategy      periodically reevaluated and
                                                                 periodically reevaluated and
                                                                     the Compensation plan
                                                                      the Compensation plan
                                                                      periodically developed
                                                                       periodically developed
                                                Compensation
HR Head




                                                  Strategy
                       Org.Structure                                  Non-Financial
                                                                        Rewards
                                                Compensation
                                                    Plan


               Compensation Strategy – defines the intentions of the
               organization on reward policies, processes and practices
               required to ensure that it has the skilled, competent and
               well-motivated workforce it needs to achieve its business
               goals


          Thursday, September 20, 2012                                                          9
Establishing Pay Plans
                                               Business Goals
                                                                        Compensation
                                                                         Compensation
                                                                        activities serve
                                                                         activities serve
CEO




                                                                   Business Objectives
                                                 Business           Business Objectives
                                                  Strategy


                                                                       Compensation strategy
                                                Compensation            Compensation strategy
HR Head




                                                                                 is periodically
                                                  Strategy                         is periodically
                                                                          reevaluated and the
                                                                           reevaluated and the
                                                                Non-Financial
                       Org.Structure                                       Compensation plan
                                                                  Rewards Compensation plan
                                                                        periodically developed
                                                                         periodically developed
                                                Compensation
                                                    Plan


              A strategic perspective on compensation takes the
               position that how employees are compensated can
               be a source of sustainable competitive advantage



          Thursday, September 20, 2012                                                        10
Establishing Pay Plans
                                                      Business Goals
                                                                                               Compensation
                                                                                                Compensation
                                                                                               activities serve
                                                                                                activities serve
CEO




                                                                                          Business Objectives
                                                        Business                           Business Objectives
                                                         Strategy


                                                                                           Compensation strategy
                                                       Compensation                         Compensation strategy
HR Head




                                                                                                     is periodically
                                                         Strategy                                      is periodically
                                                                                              reevaluated and the
                                                                                               reevaluated and the
                                                                                    Non-Financial
                         Org.Structure                                                         Compensation plan
                                                                                      Rewards Compensation plan
                                                                                            periodically developed
                                                                                             periodically developed
                                                       Compensation
                                                           Plan
C & B/S M




              Performance            Job Evaluation                     Market Surveys
              Management
                                                         Unit Inputs


                                                        Pay levels /
                                                        structures                           Compensation
                               Contribution                                                    Compensation
                                                                                        Manager, along with
Employee




                                 /outputs                                                Manager, along with
                                                                                     team is responsible for
                                                          Total                       team is responsible for
                                                                                                carrying out
                                                       remuneration                              carrying out
                                                                                      compensation related
                                                                                       compensation related
                                                                                                   activities
                        Performance                                                                 activities
                         linked Pay
                                                       Individual Pay
                                   Internal Equity                      External Equity
            Thursday, September 20, 2012                                                                           11
Establishing Pay Plans

          Compensation
           Plan Design



              Job Analysis



            Job
          Description


Market Wage                     Job
   Survey                     Evaluation

              Pay Structure
                                           12
Job Analysis
• Process to identify & determine particular job duties and
requirements
• Relative importance of duties
• Judgments are made about data collected on job
• Used in compensation to identify or determine:

   •skill levels
   •compensable job factors
   •work environment
   •responsibilities
   •required level of education


                                                         13
Job Description

-  Output from job analysis used to develop job
description and its specification
- Summarize job analysis information in readable
format
- Provide basis for job-related actions
- Identify individual jobs by providing
documentation
- Identify tasks, duties and responsibilities of a job
- Describes what is done, why it is done , where it is
done, and how it is done .
                                                    14
Job Evaluation
The methods and practices of ordering jobs or
 positions with respect to their value or worth to
 the organization.




                                                     15
Market Wage Surveys

- Goal of market wage surveys is to find data from
employers with whom organization competes for
employees
- Data collected & analyzed
- Simplest analysis involves comparing going market
rate & approximating this rate within organization's
own pay structure



                                                  16
Methods of Wage Surveys
Generally three methods are employed for
 wage surveys;
 • Personal Interviews
 • Mailed Questionnaires
 • Telephone Inquiries




                                            17
Pay Structure
-Basis for establishing pay plan is pay
structure
- Hierarchy of jobs with pay ranges and/or
rates assigned
- Pay structures designed so that greater the
worth of a job, higher the pay grade and range




                                            18
Objectives of Pay Plans
• Internal equity.
• External equity (or competitiveness),
• Individual equity,
• Process equity,
• Performance or productivity incentives,
• Maximum use of financial resources,
• Compliance with laws and regulations, and
• Administrative efficiency

                                              19
Aligning Compensation Strategy with HR
                        Strategy
      HR Strategy                    Compensation Strategy
– Attract staff              – Total reward approaches that help to make the
– Retain effective           organisation a great place to work
performers                                                               –
– Support change             Competitive pay structure that helps to retain high
management process           quality employee
– Establish positive                                 – Variable pay schemes that
corporate reputation         contributes to the motivation of the people
– Administer reward
management to maximise         – Performance management process that
positive impact           promotes continuous improvement
– Enhance purchasing                                                   –
power of employees        Performance management processes that identify
– Make Compensation       learning needs and how they can be satisfied
package simple
– Develop human resources
                                                              – Career family
                          structure that defines knowledge and skills     20
Aligning Compensation Strategy with
                Business Strategy

       Business Strategy                  Compensation Strategy

– Achieving competitive advantage   – Provide financial incentive/reward and
through innovation                  recognition for innovation
– Achieving competitive advantage   – Link reward to quality performance
through quality
– Achieving competitive advantage   – Review all reward practices to ensure
through low costs                   they provide value for money




                                                                               21
Seniority & Longevity Pay
Salary or wages based on seniority or length of service
 with an organization
The greater the length of service, the greater the
 longevity pay
It may also be used as a bonus for remaining on a job
 beyond a certain period
These systems reward employees with periodic
 additions to base pay according to employees’ length
 of service in performing their jobs

                                                         22
Design of Seniority Pay and Longevity
                 Pay Plans
     Seniority Pay             Longevity Pay
To reward job tenure or   To reward employees who
 employees’ time as         have reached pay grade
 members of a company       maximum and who are not
 explicitly through         likely to move into higher
 permanent increases to     grades
 base pay




                                                      23
Advantages of Seniority Pay
     To Employees                   To Employers
Perceive they are treated    It facilitates the
 fairly because they earn      administration of pay
 pay increases according to    programs
 seniority, which is an       Employers are less likely
 objective standard            to offend employees by
                               showing favouritism to
                               others




                                                           24
Fitting Seniority Pay with Competitive
                  Strategy
Seniority pay does not fit well with the imperatives of
 competitive strategies because employees can count
 on receiving same pay raises for average and
 exemplary performance




                                                           25
Thank you

Compensation and employee behaviour Part I

  • 1.
    Compensation and Employee Behaviour: Part I Dr. G C Mohanta, BE(Mech), MSc(Engg), MBA, PhD(Mgt) Professor 1
  • 2.
    Bases for TraditionalPay System Based on cost of living and labour market Base wage or salary Evenly distributed between employees Correlated with seniority Based on individual performance daily, weekly, monthly 2
  • 3.
    Bases for ModernPay System Variable pay Based on business performance Differentiated Based on individual performance Based on team and organisational performance Used as a means of communicating values 3
  • 4.
    Traditional Pay System Setspay levels in a narrow band with regular increase May be 3 to 4 percent pay increase annually Increases meant for promotions, merit, cost of living Less distinction betn. merit & cost of living increase  Most merit raises perceived as little more than cost of living increases due to low levels (3 to 4 percent) Often, it includes a set salary or wage, a set schedule for merit increases, and a set benefits package 4
  • 5.
    Modern Pay System Itpays greater emphasis on variable pay Base wage seen as job worth in open market, merit pay - reward for results by employee each year An employee can get a raise either by increasing his job's value or by performing well Some companies use three-way system to determine annual increases: - Did the employee accomplish his goals? - Did the company reach its targets? - Did the employee act in accordance with established competencies for his job? 5
  • 6.
    Modern Pay System Somecompanies create broader bands in salary structures In past, large companies had many salary levels in each department, making it difficult for employees to move to different jobs Employees can seek more opportunities now without penalty with 5 large bands, instead of 25 narrow bands Incentives available, like bonuses, team based incentives/gain sharing, profit sharing, quality awards, stock purchase options, etc. 6
  • 7.
    Purpose of Compensation Contribution based Ensure Equity Remuneration Attract talent Co Effec Administratively m Efficient Legal pe tive Institutionalized Compliance ns Processes ati on Motivate & Retain Staff Reward Valued Behavior Thursday, September 20, 2012 7
  • 8.
    Establishing Pay Plans Business Goals Compensation Compensation Philosophy/ activities Philosophy/ activities CEO serve Business Business serve Business Objectives Strategy Objectives Business Strategy – This defines the direction in which organization is going in relation to its environment in order to achieve its objectives. Compensation Philosophy – Consists of a set of beliefs which underpin the reward/compensation strategy of the organization and govern the reward policies that determine how reward processes operate Thursday, September 20, 2012 8
  • 9.
    Establishing Pay Plans Compensation activities Compensation activities Business Goals serve Business Objectives serve Business Objectives CEO Business Compensation strategy is Compensation strategy is Strategy periodically reevaluated and periodically reevaluated and the Compensation plan the Compensation plan periodically developed periodically developed Compensation HR Head Strategy Org.Structure Non-Financial Rewards Compensation Plan Compensation Strategy – defines the intentions of the organization on reward policies, processes and practices required to ensure that it has the skilled, competent and well-motivated workforce it needs to achieve its business goals Thursday, September 20, 2012 9
  • 10.
    Establishing Pay Plans Business Goals Compensation Compensation activities serve activities serve CEO Business Objectives Business Business Objectives Strategy Compensation strategy Compensation Compensation strategy HR Head is periodically Strategy is periodically reevaluated and the reevaluated and the Non-Financial Org.Structure Compensation plan Rewards Compensation plan periodically developed periodically developed Compensation Plan  A strategic perspective on compensation takes the position that how employees are compensated can be a source of sustainable competitive advantage Thursday, September 20, 2012 10
  • 11.
    Establishing Pay Plans Business Goals Compensation Compensation activities serve activities serve CEO Business Objectives Business Business Objectives Strategy Compensation strategy Compensation Compensation strategy HR Head is periodically Strategy is periodically reevaluated and the reevaluated and the Non-Financial Org.Structure Compensation plan Rewards Compensation plan periodically developed periodically developed Compensation Plan C & B/S M Performance Job Evaluation Market Surveys Management Unit Inputs Pay levels / structures Compensation Contribution Compensation Manager, along with Employee /outputs Manager, along with team is responsible for Total team is responsible for carrying out remuneration carrying out compensation related compensation related activities Performance activities linked Pay Individual Pay Internal Equity External Equity Thursday, September 20, 2012 11
  • 12.
    Establishing Pay Plans Compensation Plan Design Job Analysis Job Description Market Wage Job Survey Evaluation Pay Structure 12
  • 13.
    Job Analysis • Processto identify & determine particular job duties and requirements • Relative importance of duties • Judgments are made about data collected on job • Used in compensation to identify or determine: •skill levels •compensable job factors •work environment •responsibilities •required level of education 13
  • 14.
    Job Description - Output from job analysis used to develop job description and its specification - Summarize job analysis information in readable format - Provide basis for job-related actions - Identify individual jobs by providing documentation - Identify tasks, duties and responsibilities of a job - Describes what is done, why it is done , where it is done, and how it is done . 14
  • 15.
    Job Evaluation The methodsand practices of ordering jobs or positions with respect to their value or worth to the organization. 15
  • 16.
    Market Wage Surveys -Goal of market wage surveys is to find data from employers with whom organization competes for employees - Data collected & analyzed - Simplest analysis involves comparing going market rate & approximating this rate within organization's own pay structure 16
  • 17.
    Methods of WageSurveys Generally three methods are employed for wage surveys; • Personal Interviews • Mailed Questionnaires • Telephone Inquiries 17
  • 18.
    Pay Structure -Basis forestablishing pay plan is pay structure - Hierarchy of jobs with pay ranges and/or rates assigned - Pay structures designed so that greater the worth of a job, higher the pay grade and range 18
  • 19.
    Objectives of PayPlans • Internal equity. • External equity (or competitiveness), • Individual equity, • Process equity, • Performance or productivity incentives, • Maximum use of financial resources, • Compliance with laws and regulations, and • Administrative efficiency 19
  • 20.
    Aligning Compensation Strategywith HR Strategy HR Strategy Compensation Strategy – Attract staff – Total reward approaches that help to make the – Retain effective organisation a great place to work performers – – Support change Competitive pay structure that helps to retain high management process quality employee – Establish positive – Variable pay schemes that corporate reputation contributes to the motivation of the people – Administer reward management to maximise – Performance management process that positive impact promotes continuous improvement – Enhance purchasing – power of employees Performance management processes that identify – Make Compensation learning needs and how they can be satisfied package simple – Develop human resources – Career family structure that defines knowledge and skills 20
  • 21.
    Aligning Compensation Strategywith Business Strategy Business Strategy Compensation Strategy – Achieving competitive advantage – Provide financial incentive/reward and through innovation recognition for innovation – Achieving competitive advantage – Link reward to quality performance through quality – Achieving competitive advantage – Review all reward practices to ensure through low costs they provide value for money 21
  • 22.
    Seniority & LongevityPay Salary or wages based on seniority or length of service with an organization The greater the length of service, the greater the longevity pay It may also be used as a bonus for remaining on a job beyond a certain period These systems reward employees with periodic additions to base pay according to employees’ length of service in performing their jobs 22
  • 23.
    Design of SeniorityPay and Longevity Pay Plans Seniority Pay Longevity Pay To reward job tenure or To reward employees who employees’ time as have reached pay grade members of a company maximum and who are not explicitly through likely to move into higher permanent increases to grades base pay 23
  • 24.
    Advantages of SeniorityPay To Employees To Employers Perceive they are treated It facilitates the fairly because they earn administration of pay pay increases according to programs seniority, which is an Employers are less likely objective standard to offend employees by showing favouritism to others 24
  • 25.
    Fitting Seniority Paywith Competitive Strategy Seniority pay does not fit well with the imperatives of competitive strategies because employees can count on receiving same pay raises for average and exemplary performance 25
  • 26.