One day, Benny gets a call from cat named Teddy, who owns a busy pizza restaurant. Teddy needs help because he is overwhelmed with customers and lacks employees. Benny's cousin, Cheddar, an orange-tabby cat, joins him in helping Teddy. When they reach the restaurant, they quickly realize it is crowded and chaotic.
Despite their efforts, things go wrong. Cheddar eats the pizza dough, which shocks Teddy, and Benny accidentally overcooks the pizzas. Frustrated with their performance, Teddy scolds them, ultimately deciding that they'd be better off not helping. Upset, Benny and Cheddar leave the restaurant.
Later, Benny the cat reads fan mail from his fans, answering questions about his preferences, including music and superpowers.