SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Art Tracks
Carnegie Museum of Art
July 24, 2015
The Art Tracks Team:
Tracey Berg-Fulton
Data Nerd
(@BergFulton)
David Newbury
Lead Developer
(@workergnome)
Travis Snyder
Collections Database
Administrator
Our Advisors:
Neil Kulas
Head of Digital
Louise (Lulu) Lippincott, Ph.D
Curator, Fine Art
Costas Karakatsanis
Provenance Researcher
And many other advisors
What is Art Tracks?
An Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS)
project to digitize and visualize provenance
information.
—Three year project
—80% complete
HAVE
YOU SEEN
THIS MAN?
Pietro Perugino, St. Augustine with Members of the Confraternity of Perugia, c. 1500.
Carnegie Museum of Art, Acquired through the generosity of Mrs. Alan M. Scaife.
Augustus Wijnantz, Interieur van de Gotische Zaal, paleis Kneuterdijk, Den Haag, met de schilderijencollectie van Willem II, 1846, Rijksmuseum, Acquired 1995.
Digital Provenance Records at CMOA
Durand-Ruel, Paris, August 23, 1872 [1];
Catholina Lambert, New Jersey;
Lambert sale, American Art Association, Plaza Hotel, New York, NY,
February 21, 1916 until February 24, 1916, no. 67;
Durand-Ruel, Paris, until at least 1930;
purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, by June 1936 [2];
anonymous sale, Parke-Bernet Galleries, Inc., February 25, 1970, no. 19 [3];
Sam Salz, Inc., New York, NY;
purchased by Museum, May 1971.
NOTES:
[1] bought from the artist.
[2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France
during the War 1939-1945" (no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
[3] "Highly Important Impressionist, Post-Impressionist &
Modern Paintings and Drawings", illustrated.
What is good about Provenance right now?
—AAM standard.
—Internet Archive, Gallica, HathiTrust, etc.
—NEPIP portal.
—Getty Provenance index.
Unlawful Appropriation
—Created before 1946
—Were acquired by the museum
before 1932
—underwent a change of
ownership between 1932 and
1946
—were or could have been in
Europe between 1932-1946
What is good about Provenance right now?
—AAM standard.
—Internet Archive, Gallica, HathiTrust, etc.
—NEPIP portal.
—Getty Provenance index.
What's not so good about provenance?
—Provenance isn’t searchable.
—Provenance isn’t (really) standardized.
—Provenance research is hard. And expensive. And
slow.
What are the existing global standards?
AAM suggested standard
...the provenanace is listed in chronological order, beginning with the earliest known owner.
Life dates of owners, if known, are enclosed in brackets.
Uncertain information is indicated by the terms "possibly" or "probably" and explained in footnotes.
Dealers, auction houses, or agents are enclosed in parentheses to distinguish them from private owners.
Relationships between owners and methods of transactions are indicated by punctuation:
a semicolon is used to indicate that the work passed directly between two owners
(including dealers, auction houses, or agents),
and a period is used to seperate two owners (including dealers, auction houses, or agents)
if a direct transfer did not occur or is not known to have occured.
Footnotes are used to document or clarify information.
Nancy H. Yeide, Konstantin Akinsha, and Amy L. Walsh. The AAM Guide to Provenance Research.
American Association of Museum, Washington DC, 2001, pp. 33-34.
What are the existing global standards?
—Text, usually in the AAM standard form.
—NGA, Smithsonian have structured records in
TMS.
National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC
The Walters Art Museum, Baltimore, MD
Indianapolis Museum of Art, Indianapolis, IN
Breaking
down
provenance
Acquisition Methods:
Controlled Vocabulary
—"purchased by"
—"gift of"
—"by descent to"
purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2];
[2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945"
(no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
Acquisition Methods:
Party:
Name, life dates, titles, relationships
—Walter P. Chrysler, Jr. [1909-1988]
—Michel Monet, his son
—Thomas George Baring, 1st Earl of Northbrook
purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris France, by 1936 [2];
[2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945"
(no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
Party:
Location:
Building, City, State, Country
—New York, NY
—France
—Highclere Castle, West Berkshire, England
purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2];
[2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945"
(no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
Location:
Dates:
Period of ownership
—January 1, 1995
—until the 15th century
—sometime between 1885 and 1895 until 1950
purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2];
[2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945"
(no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
John Doe, 1995
John Doe, by 1995
John Doe, after 1995
John Doe, until 1995
John Doe, until at least 1995
John Doe, until sometime before 1995
John Doe, in 1960
John Doe, 1950 until 2000
Footnotes:
Additional descriptive information
—Durand Ruel stock no. D1343
—See curatorial file for more information
—Her birth name was Ellen Mary Cassatt
purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2];
[2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945"
(no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
What should it look like?
{
"id": 1011873,
"category": "Painting",
"medium": "oil on canvas",
"title": "The Full-Length Mirror",
"accession_number": "65.17.1",
"image": "http://it-svr-emu03/imucma/imu.php?request=multimedia&irn=10183",
"creation_date": "1910-01-01",
"artist": {
"name": "Pierre Bonnard",
"location": {
"lat": 48.69096,
"lng": 9.14062,
"name": "Europe",
"geonameId": 6255148
}
},
What should it look like?
—JSON API
—LIDO
—Linked Open Data
—Unstructured text blobs
JSON API
Application Programming Interface
A machine readable interface for accessing the
collections information at CMOA.
LIDO
Lightweight Information Describing Objects
XML based data format
Current best practice for museum data interchange
Used by Google Art Project, among others
Linked Open Data
CIDOC-CRM
CIDOC Conceptual Reference Model
ICOM standard for museum Linked Open Data
For connecting to external information
For publishing information for others to link to
Aspirational: future of museum data
Unstructured Text
Human readable
Will need to be supported indefinitely
Current state of Collection Management Systems
How are we getting from here to there?
—CMOA provenance standard
—museum_provenance
—Elysa
CMOA provenance standard
Formalization of AAM standard
Designed for both human and machine readability
Same structure, just stricter
Document available at:
museumprovenance.org/standard
museum_provenance
github.com/cmoa/museum_provenance
Elysanot yet released
Released June 24, 2015.
github.com/cmoa/elysa
Check yourself
—Death is permanent.
—Babies generally don't own
art.
—Dates are tricky, but provide a
check and balance.
—Timelining exhibition data
highlights opportunities for
ownership clarification.
Simon Vouet, The Toilet of Venus, c. 1640, Carnegie Museum of Art, Gift of Mrs.
Horace Binney Hare.
What have we done?
—Created a digital standard for provenance
—Developed a way to digitally publish provenance
(almost)
—Data visualizations to help inform
What have we learned?
—Linked Open Data is essential to do this well
—We need to link our CMS and provenance via an
API
—We need to think about institutional authority
—We need a bibliography standard for provenance
What have we learned?
—Museums are not thinking about provenance in
the context of digital humanities.
—The amount of information is intimidating.
—Our data is not as good as we think it is.
What haven’t we done?
—Fixed the provenance research problem
—User-friendly search interface
—Made sharing this information easy
—Linked the data to other authorities
Next Steps:
—EDTF Support.
—LOD for entity disambiguation.
—Bibliography support.
—Deploy Elysa at other institutions.
—Start working with multi-museum collections.
—The Northbrook Project.
How can you help?
—Connect our institutions.
—Students
—Contacts
—Shared data
—Give us software feedback.
—Publish your provenance.
—Help others find provenance (github.com/
provenancecollaborative)
STAY IN
TOUCH
museumprovenance.org
github.com/cmoa
Twitter: @BergFulton, @Workergnome
Detail of H. Rebele, Bob, the Vigilant Fire Company's Dog, 1863, Carnegie Museum of Art,
By appropriation.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Stadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-Ems
Stadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-EmsStadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-Ems
Stadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-Ems
SCM Fussball
 
Campañas de emails masivos
Campañas de emails masivosCampañas de emails masivos
Campañas de emails masivos
Wingu - Tecnología Sin Fines de Lucro
 
OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...
OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...
OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...
eNovance
 
OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates
OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates
OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates
LizBarry
 
177 181
177 181177 181
Codony
CodonyCodony
Codony
iupino
 
Folleto - PV Manager
Folleto - PV ManagerFolleto - PV Manager
Folleto - PV Manager
Martijn Hanegraaf
 
VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2
VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2
VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2
Ben Taylor
 
The ultimate-e-learning-quiz
The ultimate-e-learning-quizThe ultimate-e-learning-quiz
The ultimate-e-learning-quiz
Pramit Singh
 
Ezkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoa
Ezkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoaEzkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoa
Ezkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoa
ARALAR Araba
 
CURRICULUM VITAE irwan.m
CURRICULUM VITAE irwan.mCURRICULUM VITAE irwan.m
CURRICULUM VITAE irwan.m
Irwan Muslimin
 
57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes
57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes
57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes
Marcos Júlio
 
Imagen mapa de bits y software de tratamiento
Imagen mapa de bits y software de tratamientoImagen mapa de bits y software de tratamiento
Imagen mapa de bits y software de tratamiento
Edgar Quezada
 
Conduccion unidimensional
Conduccion unidimensionalConduccion unidimensional
Conduccion unidimensional
Edward Rodríguez Martinez
 
Performance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For Speed
Performance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For SpeedPerformance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For Speed
Performance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For Speed
Vijay Rayapati
 
20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc
20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc
20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc
Araya Brain Imaging
 
Felicidad posible-y-felicidad-real
Felicidad posible-y-felicidad-realFelicidad posible-y-felicidad-real
Felicidad posible-y-felicidad-real
Sintia Suarez
 
The Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric Success
The Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric SuccessThe Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric Success
The Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric Success
RightNow Technologies
 
Guia cinematica caida libre
Guia cinematica caida libreGuia cinematica caida libre
Guia cinematica caida libre
Grace Andrea Ayala Espinoza
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Stadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-Ems
Stadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-EmsStadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-Ems
Stadionecho SC Melle 03 gegen SV RW Damme - Fussball Landesliga Weser-Ems
 
Campañas de emails masivos
Campañas de emails masivosCampañas de emails masivos
Campañas de emails masivos
 
OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...
OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...
OpenStack in Action 4! Emilien Macchi & Sylvain Afchain - What's new in neutr...
 
OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates
OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates
OSDC Keynote: How Public Lab collaborates
 
177 181
177 181177 181
177 181
 
Codony
CodonyCodony
Codony
 
Folleto - PV Manager
Folleto - PV ManagerFolleto - PV Manager
Folleto - PV Manager
 
VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2
VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2
VL-Visitors Guide-Digital-D2
 
The ultimate-e-learning-quiz
The ultimate-e-learning-quizThe ultimate-e-learning-quiz
The ultimate-e-learning-quiz
 
Ezkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoa
Ezkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoaEzkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoa
Ezkerraberri 21 - Burujabetza energetikoa
 
CURRICULUM VITAE irwan.m
CURRICULUM VITAE irwan.mCURRICULUM VITAE irwan.m
CURRICULUM VITAE irwan.m
 
57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes
57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes
57171182 jorge-luis-borges-ficcoes
 
Imagen mapa de bits y software de tratamiento
Imagen mapa de bits y software de tratamientoImagen mapa de bits y software de tratamiento
Imagen mapa de bits y software de tratamiento
 
Conduccion unidimensional
Conduccion unidimensionalConduccion unidimensional
Conduccion unidimensional
 
Les llengües un tressor
Les llengües un tressorLes llengües un tressor
Les llengües un tressor
 
Performance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For Speed
Performance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For SpeedPerformance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For Speed
Performance Tuning Web Apps - The Need For Speed
 
20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc
20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc
20151017 qs tokyo_final_sc
 
Felicidad posible-y-felicidad-real
Felicidad posible-y-felicidad-realFelicidad posible-y-felicidad-real
Felicidad posible-y-felicidad-real
 
The Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric Success
The Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric SuccessThe Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric Success
The Role of Cloud Computing in Customer-Centric Success
 
Guia cinematica caida libre
Guia cinematica caida libreGuia cinematica caida libre
Guia cinematica caida libre
 

Similar to Art Tracks at Keystone DH

CMoA Art Tracks Colloquium
CMoA Art Tracks ColloquiumCMoA Art Tracks Colloquium
CMoA Art Tracks Colloquium
David Newbury
 
Artistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The ArchiveArtistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The Archive
Andrew Prescott
 
Steve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' Eyes
Steve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' EyesSteve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' Eyes
Steve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' Eyes
Steve Project
 
The National Building Museum ( NBM )
The National Building Museum ( NBM )The National Building Museum ( NBM )
The National Building Museum ( NBM )
Monica Carter
 
Portfolio
PortfolioPortfolio
Portfolio
LoisFenton
 
Essay Hacker
Essay HackerEssay Hacker
Essay Hacker
Kimberly Walters
 
Museum And Race Essay
Museum And Race EssayMuseum And Race Essay
Museum And Race Essay
Alyssa Dennis
 
The Panorama Museum
The Panorama MuseumThe Panorama Museum
The Panorama Museum
Chelsea Porter
 
Research, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and EngagementResearch, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and Engagement
Robert J. Stein
 
Crowd sourcing art history
Crowd sourcing art historyCrowd sourcing art history
Crowd sourcing art history
Robert J. Stein
 
Mill City Museum
Mill City MuseumMill City Museum
Mill City Museum
Beth Hernandez
 
Eyewitness Exhibition
Eyewitness ExhibitionEyewitness Exhibition
Eyewitness Exhibition
Pamela Wright
 
Introduction to Cultural Property
Introduction to Cultural PropertyIntroduction to Cultural Property
Introduction to Cultural Property
Nicholas Poole
 
Networks
NetworksNetworks
2009 AAM Conference Review
2009 AAM Conference Review2009 AAM Conference Review
2009 AAM Conference Review
The Metropolitan Museum of Art
 
Speech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative Spe
Speech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative SpeSpeech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative Spe
Speech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative Spe
Sarah Davis
 
Creative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn I
Creative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn ICreative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn I
Creative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn I
Jenn Smith
 
Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.
Megan Williams
 
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Bandara7
 
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Bandara7
 

Similar to Art Tracks at Keystone DH (20)

CMoA Art Tracks Colloquium
CMoA Art Tracks ColloquiumCMoA Art Tracks Colloquium
CMoA Art Tracks Colloquium
 
Artistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The ArchiveArtistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The Archive
 
Steve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' Eyes
Steve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' EyesSteve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' Eyes
Steve and Social Tagging: Seeing Collections Through Visitors' Eyes
 
The National Building Museum ( NBM )
The National Building Museum ( NBM )The National Building Museum ( NBM )
The National Building Museum ( NBM )
 
Portfolio
PortfolioPortfolio
Portfolio
 
Essay Hacker
Essay HackerEssay Hacker
Essay Hacker
 
Museum And Race Essay
Museum And Race EssayMuseum And Race Essay
Museum And Race Essay
 
The Panorama Museum
The Panorama MuseumThe Panorama Museum
The Panorama Museum
 
Research, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and EngagementResearch, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and Engagement
 
Crowd sourcing art history
Crowd sourcing art historyCrowd sourcing art history
Crowd sourcing art history
 
Mill City Museum
Mill City MuseumMill City Museum
Mill City Museum
 
Eyewitness Exhibition
Eyewitness ExhibitionEyewitness Exhibition
Eyewitness Exhibition
 
Introduction to Cultural Property
Introduction to Cultural PropertyIntroduction to Cultural Property
Introduction to Cultural Property
 
Networks
NetworksNetworks
Networks
 
2009 AAM Conference Review
2009 AAM Conference Review2009 AAM Conference Review
2009 AAM Conference Review
 
Speech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative Spe
Speech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative SpeSpeech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative Spe
Speech Essay Sample. Example Of Informative Spe
 
Creative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn I
Creative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn ICreative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn I
Creative Ways To Introduce Yourself In Writing - Mryn I
 
Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.
Essay Vitamins. Online assignment writing service.
 
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
 
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
Rush to Gold_ The French and the California Gold Rush, 1848–1854 ( PDFDrive )...
 

Recently uploaded

2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates
2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates
2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates
UAE Ppt
 
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Ben Linders
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptxLegislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Charmi13
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Using-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptx
Using-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptxUsing-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptx
Using-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptx
kainatfatyma9
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP IncProposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Raheem Muhammad
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
SkillCertProExams
 
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptxPrsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
prafulpawar29
 
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
kekzed
 
Why Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdf
Why Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdfWhy Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdf
Why Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdf
Ben Linders
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
OECD Directorate for Financial and Enterprise Affairs
 
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
gpww3sf4
 
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPEACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
Charmi13
 

Recently uploaded (20)

2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates
2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates
2 December UAE National Day - United Arab Emirates
 
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...Gamify it until you make it  Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
Gamify it until you make it Improving Agile Development and Operations with ...
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – OECD – June 2024 OECD...
 
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptxLegislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
Legislation And Regulations For Import, Manufacture,.pptx
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – KEMP – June 2024 OECD...
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – LANE – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
Using-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptx
Using-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptxUsing-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptx
Using-Presentation-Software-to-the-Fullf.pptx
 
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussionPro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
Pro-competitive Industrial Policy – OECD – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP IncProposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
Proposal: The Ark Project and The BEEP Inc
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussionArtificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – LIM – June 2024 OECD discussion
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – COLANGELO – June 2024...
 
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...
The Intersection between Competition and Data Privacy – CAPEL – June 2024 OEC...
 
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
ServiceNow CIS-ITSM Exam Dumps & Questions [2024]
 
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptxPrsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
Prsentation for VIVA Welike project 1semester.pptx
 
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
怎么办理(lincoln学位证书)英国林肯大学毕业证文凭学位证书原版一模一样
 
Why Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdf
Why Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdfWhy Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdf
Why Psychological Safety Matters for Software Teams - ACE 2024 - Ben Linders.pdf
 
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
Artificial Intelligence, Data and Competition – SCHREPEL – June 2024 OECD dis...
 
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
原版制作贝德福特大学毕业证(bedfordhire毕业证)硕士文凭原版一模一样
 
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPEACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
ACTIVE IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE IN EUROPE
 

Art Tracks at Keystone DH

  • 1. Art Tracks Carnegie Museum of Art July 24, 2015
  • 2. The Art Tracks Team: Tracey Berg-Fulton Data Nerd (@BergFulton) David Newbury Lead Developer (@workergnome) Travis Snyder Collections Database Administrator
  • 3. Our Advisors: Neil Kulas Head of Digital Louise (Lulu) Lippincott, Ph.D Curator, Fine Art Costas Karakatsanis Provenance Researcher And many other advisors
  • 4. What is Art Tracks? An Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS) project to digitize and visualize provenance information. —Three year project —80% complete
  • 5.
  • 6. HAVE YOU SEEN THIS MAN? Pietro Perugino, St. Augustine with Members of the Confraternity of Perugia, c. 1500. Carnegie Museum of Art, Acquired through the generosity of Mrs. Alan M. Scaife.
  • 7.
  • 8. Augustus Wijnantz, Interieur van de Gotische Zaal, paleis Kneuterdijk, Den Haag, met de schilderijencollectie van Willem II, 1846, Rijksmuseum, Acquired 1995.
  • 9. Digital Provenance Records at CMOA Durand-Ruel, Paris, August 23, 1872 [1]; Catholina Lambert, New Jersey; Lambert sale, American Art Association, Plaza Hotel, New York, NY, February 21, 1916 until February 24, 1916, no. 67; Durand-Ruel, Paris, until at least 1930; purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, by June 1936 [2]; anonymous sale, Parke-Bernet Galleries, Inc., February 25, 1970, no. 19 [3]; Sam Salz, Inc., New York, NY; purchased by Museum, May 1971. NOTES: [1] bought from the artist. [2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945" (no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer). [3] "Highly Important Impressionist, Post-Impressionist & Modern Paintings and Drawings", illustrated.
  • 10. What is good about Provenance right now? —AAM standard. —Internet Archive, Gallica, HathiTrust, etc. —NEPIP portal. —Getty Provenance index.
  • 11. Unlawful Appropriation —Created before 1946 —Were acquired by the museum before 1932 —underwent a change of ownership between 1932 and 1946 —were or could have been in Europe between 1932-1946
  • 12. What is good about Provenance right now? —AAM standard. —Internet Archive, Gallica, HathiTrust, etc. —NEPIP portal. —Getty Provenance index.
  • 13. What's not so good about provenance? —Provenance isn’t searchable. —Provenance isn’t (really) standardized. —Provenance research is hard. And expensive. And slow.
  • 14. What are the existing global standards? AAM suggested standard ...the provenanace is listed in chronological order, beginning with the earliest known owner. Life dates of owners, if known, are enclosed in brackets. Uncertain information is indicated by the terms "possibly" or "probably" and explained in footnotes. Dealers, auction houses, or agents are enclosed in parentheses to distinguish them from private owners. Relationships between owners and methods of transactions are indicated by punctuation: a semicolon is used to indicate that the work passed directly between two owners (including dealers, auction houses, or agents), and a period is used to seperate two owners (including dealers, auction houses, or agents) if a direct transfer did not occur or is not known to have occured. Footnotes are used to document or clarify information. Nancy H. Yeide, Konstantin Akinsha, and Amy L. Walsh. The AAM Guide to Provenance Research. American Association of Museum, Washington DC, 2001, pp. 33-34.
  • 15. What are the existing global standards? —Text, usually in the AAM standard form. —NGA, Smithsonian have structured records in TMS.
  • 16. National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC
  • 17. The Walters Art Museum, Baltimore, MD
  • 18. Indianapolis Museum of Art, Indianapolis, IN
  • 20. Acquisition Methods: Controlled Vocabulary —"purchased by" —"gift of" —"by descent to" purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2]; [2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945" (no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
  • 22. Party: Name, life dates, titles, relationships —Walter P. Chrysler, Jr. [1909-1988] —Michel Monet, his son —Thomas George Baring, 1st Earl of Northbrook purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris France, by 1936 [2]; [2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945" (no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
  • 24. Location: Building, City, State, Country —New York, NY —France —Highclere Castle, West Berkshire, England purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2]; [2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945" (no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
  • 26. Dates: Period of ownership —January 1, 1995 —until the 15th century —sometime between 1885 and 1895 until 1950 purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2]; [2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945" (no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 30. John Doe, by 1995
  • 33. John Doe, until at least 1995
  • 34. John Doe, until sometime before 1995
  • 35. John Doe, in 1960
  • 36. John Doe, 1950 until 2000
  • 37. Footnotes: Additional descriptive information —Durand Ruel stock no. D1343 —See curatorial file for more information —Her birth name was Ellen Mary Cassatt purchased by Simon Bauer, Paris, France, by 1936 [2]; [2] Listed and illustrated in "List of Property Removed from France during the War 1939-1945" (no. 7114, as belonging to Simon Bauer).
  • 38.
  • 39. What should it look like? { "id": 1011873, "category": "Painting", "medium": "oil on canvas", "title": "The Full-Length Mirror", "accession_number": "65.17.1", "image": "http://it-svr-emu03/imucma/imu.php?request=multimedia&irn=10183", "creation_date": "1910-01-01", "artist": { "name": "Pierre Bonnard", "location": { "lat": 48.69096, "lng": 9.14062, "name": "Europe", "geonameId": 6255148 } },
  • 40. What should it look like? —JSON API —LIDO —Linked Open Data —Unstructured text blobs
  • 41. JSON API Application Programming Interface A machine readable interface for accessing the collections information at CMOA.
  • 42. LIDO Lightweight Information Describing Objects XML based data format Current best practice for museum data interchange Used by Google Art Project, among others
  • 43. Linked Open Data CIDOC-CRM CIDOC Conceptual Reference Model ICOM standard for museum Linked Open Data For connecting to external information For publishing information for others to link to Aspirational: future of museum data
  • 44. Unstructured Text Human readable Will need to be supported indefinitely Current state of Collection Management Systems
  • 45. How are we getting from here to there? —CMOA provenance standard —museum_provenance —Elysa
  • 46. CMOA provenance standard Formalization of AAM standard Designed for both human and machine readability Same structure, just stricter Document available at: museumprovenance.org/standard
  • 50. Check yourself —Death is permanent. —Babies generally don't own art. —Dates are tricky, but provide a check and balance. —Timelining exhibition data highlights opportunities for ownership clarification. Simon Vouet, The Toilet of Venus, c. 1640, Carnegie Museum of Art, Gift of Mrs. Horace Binney Hare.
  • 51.
  • 52.
  • 53.
  • 54. What have we done? —Created a digital standard for provenance —Developed a way to digitally publish provenance (almost) —Data visualizations to help inform
  • 55. What have we learned? —Linked Open Data is essential to do this well —We need to link our CMS and provenance via an API —We need to think about institutional authority —We need a bibliography standard for provenance
  • 56. What have we learned? —Museums are not thinking about provenance in the context of digital humanities. —The amount of information is intimidating. —Our data is not as good as we think it is.
  • 57. What haven’t we done? —Fixed the provenance research problem —User-friendly search interface —Made sharing this information easy —Linked the data to other authorities
  • 58. Next Steps: —EDTF Support. —LOD for entity disambiguation. —Bibliography support. —Deploy Elysa at other institutions. —Start working with multi-museum collections. —The Northbrook Project.
  • 59. How can you help? —Connect our institutions. —Students —Contacts —Shared data —Give us software feedback. —Publish your provenance. —Help others find provenance (github.com/ provenancecollaborative)
  • 60. STAY IN TOUCH museumprovenance.org github.com/cmoa Twitter: @BergFulton, @Workergnome Detail of H. Rebele, Bob, the Vigilant Fire Company's Dog, 1863, Carnegie Museum of Art, By appropriation.