SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Analyzing Business Models for Network Sharing Success Managed Services for Growth Markets, Dubai, March 18th, 2009 Kim Kyllesbech Larsen Network Economics,  T-Mobile International
Why share your network? OPEX Saving (ca. 30% pa   ) Capex prevention (>30%) Personnel efficiency Network efficiency Environmental Improvements Customer benefits OPEX prevention Operational efficiency Less spectrum demand Extended coverage “ cheap” M&A alternative T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. Rollout speed
A sharing anecdote. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],3G-sharing in The Netherlands – T-Mobile – Orange joint venture. The Financials for network sharing was reasonable, however the case for closing down was better. T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner.
Stages of sharing benefits? Rollout Phase Steady State Renewal / Obsolescence ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],UMTS LTE T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. GSM/UMTS WiMax < 5 years 4 – 8 years > 7 years
The ugly tail. T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. Half the mobile network captures less than 10% of the revenue – Top 10% of the sites typically captures 50% (or more) of the revenue. 50% revenue ≈   10% sites Top 30% sites ≈ 80% revenue 50% sites takes less than 10% revenue 10,000 9,000 8,000 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 Sites 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Cumulated Revenue Low profitability sites
Network sharing – opportunity. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner.
Network sharing – the pressure. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner.
Network sharing example– cost reduction. 2 Operators with each 10,000 site locations intending to share 80% of existing pool and decommission 8,000 site locations. “ Easily” between 30% and 40% (relevant) Opex saving by RAN sharing T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. IDEALIZED EXAMPLE A is leased line based B is Micro Wave based 120 30 90 …… . 120 Yr1 Yr2 Yr3 Yr10 Opex Synergy per Operator (In m€)
Network sharing example– uncertainties. …Whilst the saving potential is substantial keep in mind: T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. 20% Personnel Costs 60% Site Rental 13% Services  7% Other Costs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Network sharing example– termination cost. Decommission 8,000 site locations and sharing 10,000 sites gives a steady-state Opex saving of €120M per operator - But there is no such thing as a free meal: 60 Remove &  Restore Lease termination 70 Personnel cost 25 Other cost 15 Asset Write-off >100 >270 one off 120 (In m€) In cost-reduction scenarios count on at least twice the annual Opex savings  in restructuring cost. T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. annual saving
Network sharing example– integration cost. Depending on the extend of network sharing model (incl. regulatory possibilities), substantial capital investment might be needed to enable the integration and sharing of two networks. 60 - 100+ Capacity extension Civil works 60 – 120 SW feature 30 – 60+ IT invest 30+ (*) Other invest +10% >300 In Capex (In m€) T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. (*) depends on number of customers and business model
… .and the real world is not symmetric. Operator A Operator B T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. 40% market share 20% market share Cover 98% of country Cover less than 50% of country Incumbent status Greenfield / new-entrant status Leased-line based backhaul MW-based backhaul Relative old equipment New equipment Multiple suppliers No supplier match Less efficient More efficient GSM & UMTS UMTS only  15,000 locations 5,000 locations
Network sharing – summary. Network Sharing can significantly reduce Opex costs and capital requirements. Network Sharing can enable a far better network for same or better financials However, high restructuring costs and write-offs may not be (financially) acceptable Cash requirement of mobile broadband deployment (HSPA+, WiMax, LTE,..) may “force” network sharing. Network sharing is a long-term engagement in order for it to make financially & operationally sense. T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. or even possible. (i.e., TMUK – H3G formula).
Why not to share your network? Strategic lock-in Deal complexity Asymmetric benefits  High restructuring cost Coordination overhead Competitive disadvantages  Integration complexity Growth limitations Asset write-off  Regulatory scrutiny Loss of independence T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. Staff resistance Dis-entanglement very complex
Thank you for your attention. Contact details : [email_address] M +31 6 2409 5202 L  http://www.linkedin.com/in/kimklarsen
More than 50% of all Network Related TCO comes from site-related operational and capital expenses. Backup - total cost of ownership & synergies. Site Rental Energy Operate & Maintain Leased Transmission Resources Site-related Opex Radio Node Ancillary Transmission Build / Civil Works Resources Site-related Capex Opex + Annualized Capex = TCO Synergy Potential Antenna T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without  the written permission of the copyright owner. - = Low = High

More Related Content

What's hot

F01 beam forming_srs
F01 beam forming_srsF01 beam forming_srs
F01 beam forming_srs
Luciano Motta
 
RF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS Networks
RF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS NetworksRF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS Networks
RF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS Networks
Apurv Agrawal
 
Overview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche Telekom
Overview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche TelekomOverview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche Telekom
Overview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche Telekom
Eiko Seidel
 
5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...
5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...
5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...
Sayed Chhattan Shah
 
5G Basic Call Flows.pdf
5G Basic Call Flows.pdf5G Basic Call Flows.pdf
5G Basic Call Flows.pdf
IbrahimSayed61
 
Mobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's Approach
Mobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's ApproachMobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's Approach
Mobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's Approach
Coleago Consulting
 
Massive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless Networks
Massive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless NetworksMassive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless Networks
Massive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless Networks
Xiao-an Wang
 
5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation
5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation
5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation
3G4G
 
Waveform coding
Waveform codingWaveform coding
Waveform coding
Alapan Banerjee
 
Advanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public Networks
Advanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public NetworksAdvanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public Networks
Advanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public Networks
3G4G
 
Advance optical modulation formats
Advance optical modulation formatsAdvance optical modulation formats
Advance optical modulation formats
Satya Prakash Rout
 
Mobile Network Sharing
Mobile Network SharingMobile Network Sharing
Mobile Network Sharing
3G4G
 
Beginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRAN
Beginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRANBeginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRAN
Beginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRAN
3G4G
 
(Ofdm)
(Ofdm)(Ofdm)
Master Thesis on LTE and 5G Technology
Master Thesis on LTE and 5G TechnologyMaster Thesis on LTE and 5G Technology
Master Thesis on LTE and 5G Technology
Thesis Scientist Private Limited
 
5G Network Slicing
5G Network Slicing5G Network Slicing
5G Network Slicing
Sridhar Bhaskaran
 
Deep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptx
Deep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptxDeep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptx
Deep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptx
Daniel Estrada
 
Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019
Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019
Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019
3G4G
 
Introduction to 5G NR
Introduction to 5G NRIntroduction to 5G NR
Introduction to 5G NR
Abhijeet Kumar
 
Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)
Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)
Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)
3G4G
 

What's hot (20)

F01 beam forming_srs
F01 beam forming_srsF01 beam forming_srs
F01 beam forming_srs
 
RF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS Networks
RF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS NetworksRF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS Networks
RF Planning and Optimization in GSM and UMTS Networks
 
Overview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche Telekom
Overview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche TelekomOverview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche Telekom
Overview 5G Architecture Options from Deutsche Telekom
 
5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...
5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...
5G Network: Requirements, Design Principles, Architectures, and Enabling Tech...
 
5G Basic Call Flows.pdf
5G Basic Call Flows.pdf5G Basic Call Flows.pdf
5G Basic Call Flows.pdf
 
Mobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's Approach
Mobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's ApproachMobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's Approach
Mobile Network Infrastructure Sharing - Industry Overview & Coleago's Approach
 
Massive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless Networks
Massive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless NetworksMassive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless Networks
Massive MIMO Channel Calibration in TDD Wireless Networks
 
5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation
5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation
5G Network Architecture, Design and Optimisation
 
Waveform coding
Waveform codingWaveform coding
Waveform coding
 
Advanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public Networks
Advanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public NetworksAdvanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public Networks
Advanced: Private Networks & 5G Non-Public Networks
 
Advance optical modulation formats
Advance optical modulation formatsAdvance optical modulation formats
Advance optical modulation formats
 
Mobile Network Sharing
Mobile Network SharingMobile Network Sharing
Mobile Network Sharing
 
Beginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRAN
Beginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRANBeginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRAN
Beginners: Open RAN, White Box RAN & vRAN
 
(Ofdm)
(Ofdm)(Ofdm)
(Ofdm)
 
Master Thesis on LTE and 5G Technology
Master Thesis on LTE and 5G TechnologyMaster Thesis on LTE and 5G Technology
Master Thesis on LTE and 5G Technology
 
5G Network Slicing
5G Network Slicing5G Network Slicing
5G Network Slicing
 
Deep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptx
Deep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptxDeep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptx
Deep Dive 5G NR-RAN Release 2018 Q4.pptx
 
Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019
Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019
Prof. Andy Sutton: 5G RAN Architecture Evolution - Jan 2019
 
Introduction to 5G NR
Introduction to 5G NRIntroduction to 5G NR
Introduction to 5G NR
 
Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)
Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)
Intermediate: 5G Network Architecture Options (Updated)
 

Viewers also liked

Economics of Network Sharing
Economics of Network SharingEconomics of Network Sharing
Economics of Network Sharing
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020
Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020
Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHzTechno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Examine the economics of rolling out LTE
Examine the economics of rolling out LTEExamine the economics of rolling out LTE
Examine the economics of rolling out LTE
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Small Cell Economics
Small Cell EconomicsSmall Cell Economics
Small Cell Economics
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
The Economics of 5G
The Economics of 5GThe Economics of 5G
The Economics of 5G
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Zero Human Touch Networks
Zero Human Touch NetworksZero Human Touch Networks
Zero Human Touch Networks
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...
Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...
Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...
Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...
Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.
Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.
Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3
Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3
Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3leonid-mt-mt
 
Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2
Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2
Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2
Dr. Ayman Elnashar, PhD
 
Baluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_com
Baluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_comBaluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_com
Baluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_comleonid-mt-mt
 
Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1
Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1
Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1
Igor Ereshchenko
 
Opex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmi
Opex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmiOpex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmi
Opex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmi
Qarib Raza
 
Fiber to the Home business model
Fiber to the Home business modelFiber to the Home business model
Fiber to the Home business model
Bill St. Arnaud
 
Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model
Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model
Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Divide by a Decimal
Divide by a DecimalDivide by a Decimal
Divide by a Decimal
Brooke Young
 
Slideshow on the Our Border Program
Slideshow on the Our Border ProgramSlideshow on the Our Border Program
Slideshow on the Our Border Program
Daniel O'Neil
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Economics of Network Sharing
Economics of Network SharingEconomics of Network Sharing
Economics of Network Sharing
 
Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020
Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020
Growth Pains: How mobile networks will supply data capacity for 2020
 
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHzTechno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
Techno-economical aspects of LTE mobile broadband at 800 MHz and 2.6 GHz
 
Examine the economics of rolling out LTE
Examine the economics of rolling out LTEExamine the economics of rolling out LTE
Examine the economics of rolling out LTE
 
Small Cell Economics
Small Cell EconomicsSmall Cell Economics
Small Cell Economics
 
The Economics of 5G
The Economics of 5GThe Economics of 5G
The Economics of 5G
 
Zero Human Touch Networks
Zero Human Touch NetworksZero Human Touch Networks
Zero Human Touch Networks
 
Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...
Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...
Right Pricing Mobile Broadband ... Examining the Business Case for Mobile Bro...
 
Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...
Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...
Mind Share: Right Pricing LTE ... and Mobile Broadband in general (A Technolo...
 
Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.
Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.
Disruptive technology strategies for mobile operators in growth markets.
 
Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3
Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3
Tikhvinskiy mobile network sharing v3
 
Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2
Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2
Lte World Summit 2012 Ver 2
 
Baluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_com
Baluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_comBaluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_com
Baluk active ran sharing in russia vimpel_com
 
Khasianova 4 g
Khasianova 4 gKhasianova 4 g
Khasianova 4 g
 
Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1
Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1
Мобильный ШПД: развитие, технологии, спектр_1
 
Opex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmi
Opex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmiOpex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmi
Opex reduction in telecom industry qarib kazmi
 
Fiber to the Home business model
Fiber to the Home business modelFiber to the Home business model
Fiber to the Home business model
 
Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model
Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model
Eurasia mobile markets - challenges to our mobile networks & business model
 
Divide by a Decimal
Divide by a DecimalDivide by a Decimal
Divide by a Decimal
 
Slideshow on the Our Border Program
Slideshow on the Our Border ProgramSlideshow on the Our Border Program
Slideshow on the Our Border Program
 

Similar to Analyzing Business Models For Network Sharing Success

Maximizing Data Profitability
Maximizing Data ProfitabilityMaximizing Data Profitability
Maximizing Data Profitability
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Maximizing the emerging market BWA business plan
Maximizing the emerging market BWA business planMaximizing the emerging market BWA business plan
Maximizing the emerging market BWA business plan
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...
Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...
Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...
Coleago Consulting
 
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.
frankjoh
 
Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2
Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2
Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2
frankjoh
 
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 szThe future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
Coleago Consulting
 
Cisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal Virtualization
Cisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal VirtualizationCisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal Virtualization
Cisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal Virtualization
Cisco Canada
 
Telco Global Connect 8
Telco Global Connect 8Telco Global Connect 8
Telco Global Connect 8
Sadiq Malik
 
Lessons learnt infrastructure sharing in Africa
Lessons learnt infrastructure sharing in AfricaLessons learnt infrastructure sharing in Africa
Lessons learnt infrastructure sharing in Africa
Wilgon Berthold TSIBO PMP, MPO, MCA
 
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
Coleago Consulting
 
Cowen and company - June 30 2016
Cowen and company - June 30 2016Cowen and company - June 30 2016
Cowen and company - June 30 2016
EXFO Inc.
 
e-conectividad 5G clave para la innovación
e-conectividad 5G clave para la innovacióne-conectividad 5G clave para la innovación
e-conectividad 5G clave para la innovación
Comisión de Regulación de Comunicaciones
 
One Call All the Answers - 5G Calling
One Call All the Answers - 5G CallingOne Call All the Answers - 5G Calling
One Call All the Answers - 5G Calling
David Swift
 
Building the Next Generation IoT & Telematics Platform
Building the Next Generation IoT & Telematics PlatformBuilding the Next Generation IoT & Telematics Platform
Building the Next Generation IoT & Telematics Platform
Cloudera, Inc.
 
02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf
02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf
02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf
Chien Huang Chang
 
Lte workshop business plan-final
Lte workshop  business plan-finalLte workshop  business plan-final
Lte workshop business plan-final
Khazane Hassan
 
Great Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) Nandlall
Great Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) NandlallGreat Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) Nandlall
Great Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) Nandlall
Alan Quayle
 
5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC
5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC
5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC
Simon Pike
 
Customer pres 1 general intro to at&t mobility
Customer pres 1 general intro to at&t  mobilityCustomer pres 1 general intro to at&t  mobility
Customer pres 1 general intro to at&t mobility
Enterprise Mobility Solutions
 
Io t sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-light
Io t   sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-lightIo t   sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-light
Io t sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-light
Thierry Lestable
 

Similar to Analyzing Business Models For Network Sharing Success (20)

Maximizing Data Profitability
Maximizing Data ProfitabilityMaximizing Data Profitability
Maximizing Data Profitability
 
Maximizing the emerging market BWA business plan
Maximizing the emerging market BWA business planMaximizing the emerging market BWA business plan
Maximizing the emerging market BWA business plan
 
Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...
Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...
Spectrum Workshop - Issues and challenges in spectrum allocations and spectru...
 
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.
 
Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2
Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2
Challenges&amp;opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2
 
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 szThe future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
 
Cisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal Virtualization
Cisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal VirtualizationCisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal Virtualization
Cisco connect montreal 2018 - Network Slicing: Horizontal Virtualization
 
Telco Global Connect 8
Telco Global Connect 8Telco Global Connect 8
Telco Global Connect 8
 
Lessons learnt infrastructure sharing in Africa
Lessons learnt infrastructure sharing in AfricaLessons learnt infrastructure sharing in Africa
Lessons learnt infrastructure sharing in Africa
 
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
 
Cowen and company - June 30 2016
Cowen and company - June 30 2016Cowen and company - June 30 2016
Cowen and company - June 30 2016
 
e-conectividad 5G clave para la innovación
e-conectividad 5G clave para la innovacióne-conectividad 5G clave para la innovación
e-conectividad 5G clave para la innovación
 
One Call All the Answers - 5G Calling
One Call All the Answers - 5G CallingOne Call All the Answers - 5G Calling
One Call All the Answers - 5G Calling
 
Building the Next Generation IoT & Telematics Platform
Building the Next Generation IoT & Telematics PlatformBuilding the Next Generation IoT & Telematics Platform
Building the Next Generation IoT & Telematics Platform
 
02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf
02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf
02_5G下物聯網的挑戰與機會.pdf
 
Lte workshop business plan-final
Lte workshop  business plan-finalLte workshop  business plan-final
Lte workshop business plan-final
 
Great Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) Nandlall
Great Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) NandlallGreat Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) Nandlall
Great Expectations: The life and times of 5G. Vish (Vishwamitra) Nandlall
 
5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC
5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC
5G submission by Simon Pike to the NIC
 
Customer pres 1 general intro to at&t mobility
Customer pres 1 general intro to at&t  mobilityCustomer pres 1 general intro to at&t  mobility
Customer pres 1 general intro to at&t mobility
 
Io t sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-light
Io t   sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-lightIo t   sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-light
Io t sagemcom - eucnc - 29062015 - v(0.3)-light
 

More from Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)

What makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5G
What makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5GWhat makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5G
What makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5G
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?
5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?
5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.
Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.
Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
AI for Finance
AI for FinanceAI for Finance
Ethical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systems
Ethical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systemsEthical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systems
Ethical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systems
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception
A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception
A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
AI for Telcos
AI for TelcosAI for Telcos
The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?
The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?
The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Smart life 3.0
Smart life 3.0Smart life 3.0
How do we Humans feel about AI?
How do we Humans feel about AI?How do we Humans feel about AI?
How do we Humans feel about AI?
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Towards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligence
Towards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligenceTowards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligence
Towards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligence
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Big Data @ NT - A Network Technology Perspective
Big Data @ NT - A Network Technology PerspectiveBig Data @ NT - A Network Technology Perspective
Big Data @ NT - A Network Technology Perspective
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.
Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.
Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.
Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.
Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.
Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.
Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Beyond LTE Launch
Beyond LTE LaunchBeyond LTE Launch
Beyond LTE Launch
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Small cell networks why & when to care!
Small cell networks   why & when to care!Small cell networks   why & when to care!
Small cell networks why & when to care!
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society
Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society
Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
A Stranger in a Strange Land
A Stranger in a Strange LandA Stranger in a Strange Land
A Stranger in a Strange Land
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 
Telco 2020 ... A Mature Market Outlook
Telco 2020 ... A Mature Market OutlookTelco 2020 ... A Mature Market Outlook
Telco 2020 ... A Mature Market Outlook
Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen)
 

More from Dr. Kim (Kyllesbech Larsen) (20)

What makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5G
What makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5GWhat makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5G
What makes telco tick and what to expect from real 5G
 
5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?
5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?
5G Standalone Will Deliver! - But What?
 
Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.
Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.
Network Automation & Autonomy - At Pace & Scale.
 
AI for Finance
AI for FinanceAI for Finance
AI for Finance
 
Ethical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systems
Ethical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systemsEthical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systems
Ethical Dilemmas in AI/ML-based systems
 
A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception
A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception
A Tutorial to AI Ethics - Fairness, Bias & Perception
 
AI for Telcos
AI for TelcosAI for Telcos
AI for Telcos
 
The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?
The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?
The Bot Generation ... Are Millennials excited or threatened by AI?
 
Smart life 3.0
Smart life 3.0Smart life 3.0
Smart life 3.0
 
How do we Humans feel about AI?
How do we Humans feel about AI?How do we Humans feel about AI?
How do we Humans feel about AI?
 
Towards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligence
Towards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligenceTowards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligence
Towards 5G - super-agility, hyper-connectivity & networked intelligence
 
Big Data @ NT - A Network Technology Perspective
Big Data @ NT - A Network Technology PerspectiveBig Data @ NT - A Network Technology Perspective
Big Data @ NT - A Network Technology Perspective
 
Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.
Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.
Artificial intelligence - Digital Readiness.
 
Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.
Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.
Artificial intelligence - A Teaser to the Topic.
 
Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.
Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.
Modern Telecommunication ... The Very Basic.
 
Beyond LTE Launch
Beyond LTE LaunchBeyond LTE Launch
Beyond LTE Launch
 
Small cell networks why & when to care!
Small cell networks   why & when to care!Small cell networks   why & when to care!
Small cell networks why & when to care!
 
Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society
Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society
Digitized! Get Ready for the Next Wave of the Digital Society
 
A Stranger in a Strange Land
A Stranger in a Strange LandA Stranger in a Strange Land
A Stranger in a Strange Land
 
Telco 2020 ... A Mature Market Outlook
Telco 2020 ... A Mature Market OutlookTelco 2020 ... A Mature Market Outlook
Telco 2020 ... A Mature Market Outlook
 

Analyzing Business Models For Network Sharing Success

  • 1. Analyzing Business Models for Network Sharing Success Managed Services for Growth Markets, Dubai, March 18th, 2009 Kim Kyllesbech Larsen Network Economics, T-Mobile International
  • 2. Why share your network? OPEX Saving (ca. 30% pa ) Capex prevention (>30%) Personnel efficiency Network efficiency Environmental Improvements Customer benefits OPEX prevention Operational efficiency Less spectrum demand Extended coverage “ cheap” M&A alternative T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. Rollout speed
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. The ugly tail. T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. Half the mobile network captures less than 10% of the revenue – Top 10% of the sites typically captures 50% (or more) of the revenue. 50% revenue ≈ 10% sites Top 30% sites ≈ 80% revenue 50% sites takes less than 10% revenue 10,000 9,000 8,000 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 Sites 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Cumulated Revenue Low profitability sites
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. Network sharing example– cost reduction. 2 Operators with each 10,000 site locations intending to share 80% of existing pool and decommission 8,000 site locations. “ Easily” between 30% and 40% (relevant) Opex saving by RAN sharing T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. IDEALIZED EXAMPLE A is leased line based B is Micro Wave based 120 30 90 …… . 120 Yr1 Yr2 Yr3 Yr10 Opex Synergy per Operator (In m€)
  • 9.
  • 10. Network sharing example– termination cost. Decommission 8,000 site locations and sharing 10,000 sites gives a steady-state Opex saving of €120M per operator - But there is no such thing as a free meal: 60 Remove & Restore Lease termination 70 Personnel cost 25 Other cost 15 Asset Write-off >100 >270 one off 120 (In m€) In cost-reduction scenarios count on at least twice the annual Opex savings in restructuring cost. T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. annual saving
  • 11. Network sharing example– integration cost. Depending on the extend of network sharing model (incl. regulatory possibilities), substantial capital investment might be needed to enable the integration and sharing of two networks. 60 - 100+ Capacity extension Civil works 60 – 120 SW feature 30 – 60+ IT invest 30+ (*) Other invest +10% >300 In Capex (In m€) T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. (*) depends on number of customers and business model
  • 12. … .and the real world is not symmetric. Operator A Operator B T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. 40% market share 20% market share Cover 98% of country Cover less than 50% of country Incumbent status Greenfield / new-entrant status Leased-line based backhaul MW-based backhaul Relative old equipment New equipment Multiple suppliers No supplier match Less efficient More efficient GSM & UMTS UMTS only 15,000 locations 5,000 locations
  • 13. Network sharing – summary. Network Sharing can significantly reduce Opex costs and capital requirements. Network Sharing can enable a far better network for same or better financials However, high restructuring costs and write-offs may not be (financially) acceptable Cash requirement of mobile broadband deployment (HSPA+, WiMax, LTE,..) may “force” network sharing. Network sharing is a long-term engagement in order for it to make financially & operationally sense. T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. or even possible. (i.e., TMUK – H3G formula).
  • 14. Why not to share your network? Strategic lock-in Deal complexity Asymmetric benefits High restructuring cost Coordination overhead Competitive disadvantages Integration complexity Growth limitations Asset write-off Regulatory scrutiny Loss of independence T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. Staff resistance Dis-entanglement very complex
  • 15. Thank you for your attention. Contact details : [email_address] M +31 6 2409 5202 L http://www.linkedin.com/in/kimklarsen
  • 16. More than 50% of all Network Related TCO comes from site-related operational and capital expenses. Backup - total cost of ownership & synergies. Site Rental Energy Operate & Maintain Leased Transmission Resources Site-related Opex Radio Node Ancillary Transmission Build / Civil Works Resources Site-related Capex Opex + Annualized Capex = TCO Synergy Potential Antenna T-Mobile International AG & Co. KG Confidential and Proprietary All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced in any material form without the written permission of the copyright owner. - = Low = High