1.
5 Things
Cucumber
Is Bad At
(& why that’s a
good thing)
By Richard Lawrence
For CukeUp NYC, Sept 30, 2014

2.
As we get started…
Discuss with one or two people near you:
What are some common complaints you
hear (or say) about Cucumber?

3.
Problems with My Car

4.
Problems with My Car
1. Doesn’t taste good
2. Doesn’t fit in my carry-on luggage
3. Buggy entertainment system
4. Some people think it’s ugly
5. Bigger than most other cars
6. Relatively low gas mileage

5.
Two kinds of
Weaknesses
Those that represent
opportunities for
improvement
Those that teach us
what the thing is &
what we do or don’t
need

6.
5 “Problems” with Cucumber
that can teach us
about Cucumber,
BDD, and us

7.
“Problems” with Cucumber #1
Gherkin isn’t a very powerful language.
Where are my Gherkin
macros? How am I
supposed to program
with this?

8.
“Problems” with Cucumber #2
I have to describe things in 2 places.
Background:
Given
a
provider
named
"Complex
Schedule
Provider"
serving:
|
From
|
To
|
When
|
Both
Ways?
|
|
Boulder
|
Boulder
|
M-­‐F
7:30am-­‐5pm
|
yes
|
|
Boulder
|
Lafayette
|
M
7:30am-­‐5pm;
W
7:30am-­‐5pm
|
yes
|
|
Boulder
|
Louisville
|
M-­‐F
7:30am-­‐5pm
|
no
|
And
I'm
logged
in
as
a
non-­‐admin
user
Given
/^a
provider
named
"([^"]*)"
serving:$/
do
|provider_name,
schedule|
#
...
end
Given
/I'm
logged
in
as
a
non-­‐admin
user/
do
#
...
end

9.
“Problems” with Cucumber #3
Step definitions are all global.
Why don’t I get
namespaces? Won’t this
lead to ambiguity?

10.
“Problems” with Cucumber #4
Regular expressions.
(?:[a-­‐z0-­‐9!#$%&'*+/=?^_`{|}~-­‐]+(?:.[a-­‐z0-­‐9!#$%&'*+/=?
^_`{|}~-­‐]+)*|"(?:[x01-­‐x08x0bx0cx0e-­‐x1fx21x23-­‐x5bx5d-­‐x7f]|
[x01-­‐x09x0bx0cx0e-­‐x7f])*")@(?:(?:[a-­‐z0-­‐9](?:[a-­‐z0-­‐9-­‐]*[a-­‐
z0-­‐9])?.)+[a-­‐z0-­‐9](?:[a-­‐z0-­‐9-­‐]*[a-­‐z0-­‐9])?|[(?:(?:25[0-­‐5]|
2[0-­‐4][0-­‐9]|[01]?[0-­‐9][0-­‐9]?).){3}(?:25[0-­‐5]|2[0-­‐4][0-­‐9]|
[01]?[0-­‐9][0-­‐9]?|[a-­‐z0-­‐9-­‐]*[a-­‐z0-­‐9]:(?:[x01-­‐x08x0bx0cx0e-­‐
x1fx21-­‐x5ax53-­‐x7f]|[x01-­‐x09x0bx0cx0e-­‐x7f])+)])

11.
“Problems” with Cucumber #4
Regular expressions.
(.+)
cucumbers?
an?
(d+)
(?:I'm
logged|I
log)
See
h%p://www.agileforall.com/2010/07/
just-­‐enough-­‐regular-­‐expressions-­‐for-­‐cucumber/

12.
“Problems” with Cucumber #5
My stakeholders won’t write feature files.
Doesn’t it defeat the purpose
of Gherkin and separate
feature files if I still have to
write it all anyway?

13.
SO What?

14.
Questions?
Contact me…
Twitter: @rslawrence
Email: richard.lawrence@agileforall.com
Blog: www.richardlawrence.info