1. A search for SCS roll model in the researcher’s Carrier Path and the Management of Knowledge Society The research and Study project Presented for COMUNDUS Science, Communication and Society Shingo Hamada

2. Dans le cadre de thèse doctorale ; La Trilogie de la techno-cratie, techno-democratie et la créativité des citoyens dans la communauté des savoirs Univ. Bourgogne Science, Communication et Soci été Shingo Hamada La direction de Prof. P.Lardellier (LIMSIC) et Prof. D.Raichvarg (CRCMD) REFERENCE

5. JIES2005 Mémoire Donnée Savoirs Buziness Recherche pub1 Proposition de Thèse Th èse pub2 pub3 Pub bis2 Pub bis3 SJDF2006 Pour abregé, Voir Targeted Journals PUS: Public Understanding of Science SC: Science Communication Publication au marché PUS: SC: SPP: RE: TFSC: The trial and the modeling the Science Communication : Evaluation of Public understanding of science by its proto-type of hybridization of technology and society. Le Benchmark test de la gouvernance des sciences : Trilogie de discours science-Société et l’analyse barometrique de la communication Lobbying Préliminaire Non déterminé The typology of the participatory science governance – the trilogy of science-society and the forecasting mechanism by the S&T Lobby. Pub bis1 FOS filière scientifique face à l’Année Mondiale de la Physique 2005 : Jules Verne, derrière Einstein et ITER ? PS, SSS Start-up Non déterminé L’état actuel 2006 Plan de Thèse Structure de trame de travail en recherche

9. Hypothèse Du Travail Prognose des problématiques Opérabilité STS-STP-MOT Aspect Communication Aspect Interdisciplinaire Bench Marking OGM ITER E&E STOA/EPTA OPECST EPR 2003 CNDP EPR 2003 IPCC Techno Cratie Techno Democratie Créativité Citoyens Lemma Structure du travail en Thèse Données Par sondage Débat Méthodologie Extraction du principe Ex-Ante Analyse NPO Lobbyist

23. Society Science Fact Theory Deduction Deduction Science Society Hybridization of Technology and Society Scientific Knowledge Fact Theory Thought System Observation by STS Social context of scientific discovery Oppositional relation of Science and Society Communication and Transmission of Knowledge Source Emission Channel Reception Destination Message Signal Signal Message Coding Decoding Noise Thought System Thought System Fact Theory

25. Diffusion model of Knowledge Sagredo (Agent) Salviati (Technocrate) Simplitio （ Pape ） Simplitio Salviati （ Galileo ） Salviati Sagredo Simplitio Sagredo (Communicator) Salviati (Scientist) Simplitio People/power Sagredo （ Citizen ） Democratic Consumer Society Authority Knowledge Agent/Contract Society Society ≒ Thought System Mutual Transformation of Knowledge Knowledge Society Dialogo dei due massimi sistemi del mondo

27. T S T S T S S T T S S T Hybrid T S T S T S T S T S T S T S Phase I Phase II Phase III S ： Society T ： Technology Typology of STS interaction (D.Vinck) Road Map Social Agenda Technology Push Market Pull Techno-society hybridization

29. Communication phase and route among the stakeholders Specialization In S & T Non Specialization in S&T Knowledge Production Oriented Scientific Communication Technology Communication Episteme Communication Living Science Communication Consumption oriented Expertise of Techno- Industry Expertise of Scientific Research Industrial Society Integrated Science Journal Scientific Communication Technical Journal Science Communication Technology & Society Communication General Journalism Figure １ -- Emerging communication route -- Emerging communication phase -- Existed communication phase

31. ITEM 1-4 of Basic Research and Investigation Skill Practice １． Writing Skill ２． Communication training In ３． Science and Media, Art Skill ４． Laboratory Studies/Management Skill ５． Town Meeting Skill Fundamental Report on Research Investigation Synergy between Basic Research and Skill Practice Outcome by group works

33. 2 nd year Outcome 3 rd year Outcome Methodology Instruction From different countries Methodology Instruction Collaboration Technique Instruction Collaboration With Asia Market trial in US and EU Instruction phase to Production Phase Brain storming Catering practice To public institutions Industry-Academy Research writer Communicator Application Completion Production Phase Application Development Methodology Implementation Into internal/external body 1 st year Outcome Incubation Centre ① ② ③ ④ ⑤ Venturing Implementation To Centre Cliental alliance MRS Practice MRS MRS MRS MRS Practice Practice Practice Practice Synthesis Synthesis Synthesis Synthesis

35. Capita investment K Labor L Production F Production function ： F=f(K,L) F1 F2 A B C D E C B D Co-Evolution of Technology and Society （ Airy Rip ） Agricultural Plant modification Assessment Bio-Agri buziness Plant Modification by GM Technology Gene Therapy Nano-Bio Bio-Info GM Technology Phase I Phase II Phase III Phase I

39. Policy Oriented Citizen Panel Café Scientifique EU ESF CNAM CIS MCF TA Gov. Action S&T Laboratories University Regional Action German TA CNRS MPG etc Society oriented Science Communication Flow of HR Communication Technology Transfer Entrust Feed Back Social Trust ? ? Social Trust Social Trust Issues in STS-STP-MOT Biotechnology Nanotechnology ITC Energie-Evironment ANVAR ANRT HFSP DFG Scheme of Mobility and Career Path of Researchers in STP-STS-MOT

40. EU S&S Collectivité Internationale Collectivité régionale Orientation Policy centrifuge Citizen Panel Café Scientifique Mouv. Paysans ICSU ESF ITER TA Gov. Action S&T Laboratories University TA Régional CNRS INRA etc Orienté à l’ouverture de service publique Science Communication Social Trust Social Trust Social Trust Issues en STS ITER OGM ITC IPCC ANVAR ANRT OCDE GSF OST Schema de l’opérabilité STS Marché Techno Economie

41. Methodology Development Report Information Policy Recommendation Investigation Analysis Expertise Panel Consensus Conference Participatory Assessment UK: How media Treats the GM 2000 DE: Risk cognition Risk Management 2000 FR: Agro-Food SED Assessment 1998 NL: 25 Years of GM Debate 1999 DK: Environment Human Risk Under Dev. 1999 EU: RTD Policy 1999 NZ: Integral Strategy Shaping 2002 Research Questions Conclusion Methodology Hearing to Expertise GMO Related Technology Assessment at the PTA bodies

42. Research Duality Correlation Strong Week Multi GM Tec Ethics Regulation Law Management Road Map Bio Ethics Bio Cluster RTD+SSH Hybridization

43. MOT STS STP Dicp 2 Dicp 3 Dicp 1 GM therapy GM Regulation GM Technology Bio Ethics GMO Food SNIPs DDS GM Contamination SSH + RTD Assessment GM Trasable Market GMO Moratorium Transplant

44. SCJ: Science Communication Japan FSC: Fondation des Sciences et Citoyens WimD: Wissenschaft im Dialog La comparaision des NPO

47. MOT STS STP Dicp 2 Dicp 3 Dicp 1 GM therapy GM Regulation GM Technology Bio Ethics GMO Food SNIPs DDS GM Contamination SSH + RTD Assessment GM Trasable Market GMO Moratorium Transplant Foresight Agenda Assessment

48. MOT STS STP Dicp 2 Dicp 3 Dicp 1 Renewable Energy IPCC-CDM Energy & Environment Milennium Eco Assessment GM Water Management CO Tax Ecomoney COP9,10 SSH + RTD Assessment IPCC Foresight Agenda Assessment Bio Diversity CDM-JI Global Climate Change

49. MOT STS STP Dicp 2 Dicp 3 Dicp 1 ITER Nuclear Energy EPR 2003 FBR HTTR SSH + RTD Assessment IPCC Foresight Roadmap Assessment Nuclear Accident JCO, Three Mile, Chernobil Global Climate Change Nuclear Waste

50. Green Peace Sortir du Nuc Paysans Green Peace Int. Negociation JP Gov EU FR Gov RU, CN IAEA JAEA CEA ITER OECD NEA/IEA GSF MNERT STA MEXT US, KR EFDA JET Garching Collaboration Administration Cadarache 六ヶ所村 Rokkasho NIFS University Industry and Society Industry and Society AREVA EDF JAIF TEPCO DOE Sandiego Moscow REAGAN-GORBACHEV ACCORD JRC EURATOM DEFENSE Debat National REP Debat CADARACHE Phoenix Super Phoenix La Haag FBR 文殊 A.N. OPECST ? EU Parliament

53. La Trilogie de la techno-cratie, techno-democratie et la créativité des citoyens dans la communauté des savoirs Proposition de la thèse Science, Communication et Soci été Université de Bourgogne 2005-2006 Shingo Hamada

59. Policy Oriented Citizen Panel Café Scientifique EU ESF CNAM CIS MCF TA Gov. Action S&T Laboratories University Regional Action German TA CNRS MPG etc Society oriented Science Communication Flow of HR Communication Technology Transfer Entrust Feed Back Social Trust ? ? Social Trust Social Trust Issues in STS-STP-MOT Biotechnology Nanotechnology ITC Energie-Evironment ANVAR ANRT HFSP DFG Scheme of Mobility and Career Path of Researchers in STP-STS-MOT

60. EU S&S Collectivité Internationale Collectivité régionale Orientation Policy centrifuge Citizen Panel Café Scientifique Mouv. Paysans ICSU ESF ITER TA Gov. Action S&T Laboratories University TA Régional CNRS INRA etc Orienté à l’ouverture de service publique Science Communication Social Trust Social Trust Social Trust Issues en STS ITER OGM ITC IPCC ANVAR ANRT OCDE GSF OST Schema de l’opérabilité STS Marché Techno Economie