Tree Board Members: Who Are They? Why Should We Care?
Dr. Paul Ries, Oregon State University
Growing Relationships for a Greener Future
Todd Mistor, City of Detroit
Clueless! How Many Employees Does it Take to Build an Urban Forestry Program?
Matt Clinton, City of Rock Hill, SC
This American Forest
Dr. Eric North, University of Nebraska–Lincoln | Graham Herbst, Nebraska Forest Service
1. UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA-
LINCOLN
This American Forest
Eric North, Ph.D. - University of Nebraska-Lincoln
Graham Herbst - Nebraska Forest Service
https://www.ecowatch.com/10-interesting-facts-about-earthworms-1881871982.html
1
17. Citizen Advisory Boards
• A form of participatory
democracy
• Common in most cities
• Found across topics and
city functions
• Tree Boards are one type
you may be familiar with
18. Tree Boards
• Many cities have a Tree Board as
a result of being a Tree City USA
• No one knows how many Tree
Boards are out there, who
serves on them, and why
• OSU graduate student Sarah
Greenleaf and I decided to try
and find out
19. Research Design
• No national census of
Tree Board members
exists
• Survey of Tree City USA
communities
• Online survey forwarded
by TCUSA contact to
Tree Board members
20. Research Questions
• Research questions
–what demographic information
describes Tree Board members?
–what motivates people to
volunteer on a Tree Board?
–is there a connection between
demographics and motivation?
21. Survey Results - Demographics
• 1,025 completed surveys from 49 states
• 53% male, 45.5% female, 1.5% no response
• 92.5% White, 2.1% Black/African, 1.2% Hispanic
• 66% held college degree, 37% held advanced degree
• 29% retired, 14.6% public, 11% natural resources,
5.6% blue collar
• 50% were over age 60, while 10% were under age 40
22. Survey Results - ”Average” Tree Board
• Has 7 members
• Meets 9 times a year
• Each member
contributes 6.9 hours per
month volunteer time
• Average respondent was
a white, well educated,
58 year-old, retired male
23. Findings - Motivations
• 47% - management of their
urban forest
• 20% - arboriculture
• 19% - local government
issues
• 10% - volunteer work in
general
24. Findings - Motivations
• Functional benefit of
volunteering
– Values
– Understanding
– Social
– Enhancement
– Career
25. Findings – Demographics & Motivations
• Female respondents were only slightly more apt to
volunteer for learning experiences than males
• Younger respondents were more likely to volunteer
to receive career benefit than older respondents
• Retired respondents had the highest value reason for
volunteering
26. Implications of This Research
• Most Tree Board members are
white, male, older, and retired
• Most Tree Boards are not
representative of the
communities they serve
• People value Tree Board service
as a way to help their community
27. Future Research Needs
• Take a deeper dive
• Perspectives or biases of Tree
Board members
• Measure effectiveness
• Connect with urban forest health
• Evaluate recruitment, retention,
and training
28. Take Home Thoughts
• Tree Boards are a vehicle for
people to participate in
Democracy
• We need to recruit for
diversity, in all its forms, on
our Tree Boards
• We need more focus on Tree
Boards
29. Thank you for attending today
• A refereed journal
article based on
this research has
been submitted
for publication
and a decision is
pending
Dr. Paul D. Ries
Instructor & Director,
Graduate Certificate in
Urban Forestry
Oregon State University
Email: paul.ries@oregonstate.edu
31. Growing Relationships for a Greener Future
Detroit’s Urban Forest
Todd Mistor
Sr. Associate Forester
32. Detroit by the Numbers • Founded 1701: French explorers
• Current geographic size: 139 sq. miles
• Peak population 1.8 million
• Population today 673,104 (July 2017 estimate)
• 309 parks
• 4,908 acres of park land (including Belle Isle)
• 187,124 street trees
• Approximately 2,500 miles of streets
• Forestry Division: 25 employees
33. History
• 1854 - DETROIT CREATES A PARKS COMMISSION
• LATE 1800’S – DETROIT HIRES A FORESTER TO MANAGE ITS TREES
• 1900 – CITY STARTS ITS OWN NURSERY
• 1910 – DETROIT PASSES A STREET TREE ORDINANCE AND DEFINES THE SPECIES
THAT WERE ALLOWED TO BE PLANTED ALONG CITY STREETS
• 1914 – CITY OPENS A SAW MILL
• FIRST HALF OF 20TH CENTURY – CITY GROWS IN SIZE, POPULATION AND SCOPE OF
SERVICES
• SECOND HALF OF 20TH CENTURY – POPULATION DECLINES, BUDGETS, STAFF AND
SERVICES ARE REDUCED
37. Doing the same thing over
and over again and
expecting different results
Insanity:
38. Engagement
If the perception is that Green
Infrastructure is OPTIONAL, get resident to
OPT IN
We are only planting trees for
residents that request and desire to
have a tree planted
39. Engagement
If the perception is that Green
Infrastructure is OPTIONAL, get resident to
OPT IN
We are only planting trees for
residents that request and desire to
have a tree planted