Against Space

Sean Carroll
Sean CarrollScientist at California Institute of Technology
space is not fundamental.
time might be.
Sean Carroll, Caltech
http://preposterousuniverse.com/
“What is and is not fundamental”
is not fundamental.
What features will be important ingredients in
an ultimate (as yet hypothetical) comprehensive
theory of everything.
Theories often have very different-looking but
equivalent descriptions (e.g. soliton/particle
duality). Who is to say what is “fundamental”?
But some things are certainly not fundamental;
e.g. temperature. Theories using them are not
comprehensive. Space is like that.
Classical Mechanics
Start with a set of coordinates .
These obey second-order equations of motion:
Specifying the coordinates alone doesn’t determine
a solution; need to give and .
Coordinates qi and momenta pj.
Hamiltonian function H(qi, pj).
Hamilton’s equations:
Together we have a = {qi, pj}, defining phase space .
A single point a(t0) in  defines a unique trajectory.
Hamiltonian Mechanics
Phase space is a symplectic manifold.
A symplectic form  is a closed, invertible 2-form.
Trajectories are integral curves of the Hamiltonian
vector field,

a(t)
Xa
The coordinate/momentum distinction is blurred.
Conventionally:
cotangent bundle T*M
= {qi, pi}
= phase space 
configuration space M,
coordinates qi
symplectic form
 =  dpi  dqi
(automatic)
Every cotangent bundle is a symplectic manifold, but
not every symplectic manifold is a cotangent bundle.
Symplecticity is more “fundamental” than
coordinate/momentum distinction.
Mechanics is invariant under canonical transformations:
{q, p}  {Q(q,p), P(q,p)}
that leave the form of Hamilton’s equations unchanged.
Example:
Nothing “fundamental” about which are the coordinates,
which are the momenta.
Qi = pi ,
Pj = -qj .
Why don’t we live in momentum space?
Think of interacting harmonic oscillators.
Interactions are local in position, not in momentum.
Better:
position is the thing in which interactions are local.
Quantum mechanics
States are rays in Hilbert space: |.
Evolution is governed by the Schrödinger equation:
Energy eigenbasis:
Dynamics are defined by the eigenvalues {En},
the spectrum of the Hamiltonian.
Where is “space” in the quantum state?
We can define a position operator with eigenstates
in terms of which the state is
But we don’t have to; momentum also works.
These are related by Fourier transform,
Or other bases, e.g. creation/annihilation operators
for a simple harmonic oscillator.
Here,
These operators raise and lower energy eigenstates:
Entanglement
For a generic multiparticle state |,
The wave function is not a function of space,
but of many copies of space.
Things don’t happen in “space”; they happen
in Hilbert space.
Again, it’s locality of interactions that tempts us
to speak otherwise.
Quantum Field Theory
QFT would seem to deeply privilege “space”; the
Hamiltonian is an integral over space. But why?
Interactions are local in space:
not in momentum:
Gravity
Consider a compact dimension on a circle.
R
A scalar field  can be decomposed
into Kaluza-Klein modes
with energies
From the higher-dimensional perspective, these
modes comprise a tower of massive states.
Conversely: if every field has such a tower,
that implies an extra dimension.
M-theory’s 11th dimension
Witten 1995: there are supersymmetric particle
multiplets in Type IIA string theory with masses
that depend on the coupling  as
Small : states are heavy and decouple.
Large : Kaluza-Klein tower, as if an extra dimension.
Q: How many dimensions are
there in string theory?
A: It depends.
x11

10 dimensional
IIA string theory
11 dimensional
supergravity
T-duality: string theory on a small circle is
equivalent to string theory on a big circle.
Momentum/winding duality.
Mirror symmetries: IIA string theory on one Calabi-Yau
manifold equals IIB string theory on another one.
These are gauge symmetries; exact equivalence.
No such thing as the “true” compactification.
R
Holography
Maximum entropy inside a region
of space doesn’t go as R3, the
volume, but as R2, the area.
Discovered in the context of
black holes, but believed to be more general.
Significance:
The world is not made of separate degrees of
freedom at each point in space.
Emergent space isn’t just a matter of discreteness.
Maldacena, 1997:
quantum gravity
(string theory) on
five-dimensional
anti-de Sitter space
times a five-sphere
is equivalent to a
conformal field theory
without gravity on the
four-dimensional boundary.
“The spacetime one is in” is not unambiguously defined.
10 dimensions
AdS5 x S5
4-dimensional
Minkowski space
AdS/CFT
• QM, states, time, & the Schrödinger equation:
Space somehow recovered from |.
• QM, states, & the Wheeler-de Witt equation:
Space and time recovered from |.
• A generalization of, or replacement for, QM.
What might be fundamental?
Closing ruminations
• Space/coordinates are picked out by the
specific Hamiltonian of the world, not
by the structure of our theories.
• Investigations of quantum gravity provide
strong evidence that space is emergent,
and in a deeper way than local discreteness.
Degrees of freedom are not local.
• Unwarranted speculation: trying to understand
the early universe will help us understand
the role of space & time.
1 of 20

Recommended

Letting Go of Spacetime by
Letting Go of SpacetimeLetting Go of Spacetime
Letting Go of SpacetimeSean Carroll
1.4K views8 slides
What We (Don't) Know About the Beginning of the Universe by
What We (Don't) Know About the Beginning of the UniverseWhat We (Don't) Know About the Beginning of the Universe
What We (Don't) Know About the Beginning of the UniverseSean Carroll
182.6K views27 slides
Many Worlds, the Born Rule, and Self-Locating Uncertainty by
Many Worlds, the Born Rule, and Self-Locating UncertaintyMany Worlds, the Born Rule, and Self-Locating Uncertainty
Many Worlds, the Born Rule, and Self-Locating UncertaintySean Carroll
2.4K views20 slides
Gifford Lecture One: Cosmos, Time, Memory by
Gifford Lecture One: Cosmos, Time, MemoryGifford Lecture One: Cosmos, Time, Memory
Gifford Lecture One: Cosmos, Time, MemorySean Carroll
146.4K views30 slides
Philosophical Issues in Quantum Thermodynamics by
Philosophical Issues in Quantum ThermodynamicsPhilosophical Issues in Quantum Thermodynamics
Philosophical Issues in Quantum ThermodynamicsSean Carroll
562 views17 slides
Setting Time Aright by
Setting Time ArightSetting Time Aright
Setting Time ArightSean Carroll
17.5K views25 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Quantum entaglement by
Quantum entaglementQuantum entaglement
Quantum entaglementSreepadmanabh M
727 views12 slides
The Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics by
The Many Worlds of Quantum MechanicsThe Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
The Many Worlds of Quantum MechanicsSean Carroll
64.8K views36 slides
Einstein's theory of general relativity by
Einstein's theory of general relativityEinstein's theory of general relativity
Einstein's theory of general relativitySmithDaisy
4.4K views7 slides
Applications of Quantum Entanglement Presentation by
Applications of Quantum Entanglement PresentationApplications of Quantum Entanglement Presentation
Applications of Quantum Entanglement PresentationParis-Anne O'Shea
3.2K views14 slides
Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained! by
Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained!Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained!
Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained!Dipakchandra Sarkar
10.9K views50 slides
Presentation on Time Travel by
Presentation on Time TravelPresentation on Time Travel
Presentation on Time TravelSourav Dey
7.3K views21 slides

What's hot(20)

The Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics by Sean Carroll
The Many Worlds of Quantum MechanicsThe Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
The Many Worlds of Quantum Mechanics
Sean Carroll64.8K views
Einstein's theory of general relativity by SmithDaisy
Einstein's theory of general relativityEinstein's theory of general relativity
Einstein's theory of general relativity
SmithDaisy4.4K views
Applications of Quantum Entanglement Presentation by Paris-Anne O'Shea
Applications of Quantum Entanglement PresentationApplications of Quantum Entanglement Presentation
Applications of Quantum Entanglement Presentation
Paris-Anne O'Shea3.2K views
Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained! by Dipakchandra Sarkar
Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained!Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained!
Einstein's theory of relativity - Explained!
Dipakchandra Sarkar10.9K views
Presentation on Time Travel by Sourav Dey
Presentation on Time TravelPresentation on Time Travel
Presentation on Time Travel
Sourav Dey7.3K views
Quantum entanglement by AKM666
Quantum entanglementQuantum entanglement
Quantum entanglement
AKM66610.3K views
Quantum Field Theory and the Limits of Knowledge by Sean Carroll
Quantum Field Theory and the Limits of KnowledgeQuantum Field Theory and the Limits of Knowledge
Quantum Field Theory and the Limits of Knowledge
Sean Carroll158.4K views
Basic Concepts of Entanglement Measures by Ryohei Suzuki
Basic Concepts of Entanglement MeasuresBasic Concepts of Entanglement Measures
Basic Concepts of Entanglement Measures
Ryohei Suzuki1.5K views
Dark matter & dark energy by surat murthy
Dark matter & dark energyDark matter & dark energy
Dark matter & dark energy
surat murthy2K views
Quantum Entanglement by Alexis Diaz
Quantum EntanglementQuantum Entanglement
Quantum Entanglement
Alexis Diaz951 views
General Relativity and Cosmology by Pratik Tarafdar
General Relativity and CosmologyGeneral Relativity and Cosmology
General Relativity and Cosmology
Pratik Tarafdar1.4K views
Quantum Geometry: A reunion of math and physics by Rafa Spoladore
Quantum Geometry: A reunion of math and physicsQuantum Geometry: A reunion of math and physics
Quantum Geometry: A reunion of math and physics
Rafa Spoladore1.6K views
A Brief Tour of Relativity and Cosmology by Robert McNees
A Brief Tour of Relativity and CosmologyA Brief Tour of Relativity and Cosmology
A Brief Tour of Relativity and Cosmology
Robert McNees1.4K views
Quantum entanglement (1).pptx by SandraJoseph49
Quantum entanglement (1).pptxQuantum entanglement (1).pptx
Quantum entanglement (1).pptx
SandraJoseph49532 views

Viewers also liked

Purpose and the Universe by
Purpose and the UniversePurpose and the Universe
Purpose and the UniverseSean Carroll
66K views37 slides
The Cosmic Web - Lincoln by
The Cosmic Web - LincolnThe Cosmic Web - Lincoln
The Cosmic Web - LincolnPeter Coles
2.6K views77 slides
Lecture7 by
Lecture7Lecture7
Lecture7Heather Kulik
16.1K views36 slides
Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case - by
Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case -Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case -
Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case -Milan Milošević
518 views21 slides
Quantum modes - Ion Cotaescu by
Quantum modes - Ion CotaescuQuantum modes - Ion Cotaescu
Quantum modes - Ion CotaescuSEENET-MTP
794 views20 slides
zanardi by
zanardizanardi
zanardiqwertyasdfg365
382 views43 slides

Viewers also liked(17)

Purpose and the Universe by Sean Carroll
Purpose and the UniversePurpose and the Universe
Purpose and the Universe
Sean Carroll66K views
The Cosmic Web - Lincoln by Peter Coles
The Cosmic Web - LincolnThe Cosmic Web - Lincoln
The Cosmic Web - Lincoln
Peter Coles2.6K views
Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case - by Milan Milošević
Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case -Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case -
Tachyonic and Localy Equivalent Canonical Lagrangians - The Polynomial Case -
Milan Milošević518 views
Quantum modes - Ion Cotaescu by SEENET-MTP
Quantum modes - Ion CotaescuQuantum modes - Ion Cotaescu
Quantum modes - Ion Cotaescu
SEENET-MTP794 views
Elementary Landscape Decomposition of the Hamiltonian Path Optimization Problem by jfrchicanog
Elementary Landscape Decomposition of the Hamiltonian Path Optimization ProblemElementary Landscape Decomposition of the Hamiltonian Path Optimization Problem
Elementary Landscape Decomposition of the Hamiltonian Path Optimization Problem
jfrchicanog680 views
Hamilton application by Samad Akbar
Hamilton applicationHamilton application
Hamilton application
Samad Akbar5K views
Distruct week 15 graphs theory (updated) by Robert Almazan
Distruct week 15 graphs theory (updated)Distruct week 15 graphs theory (updated)
Distruct week 15 graphs theory (updated)
Robert Almazan2.1K views
The Hamiltonian constraint and its possible deformations by Orchidea Maria Lecian
The Hamiltonian constraint and its possible deformationsThe Hamiltonian constraint and its possible deformations
The Hamiltonian constraint and its possible deformations
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 1/3 by SEENET-MTP
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 1/3N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 1/3
N. Bilic - "Hamiltonian Method in the Braneworld" 1/3
SEENET-MTP653 views
Non-equilibrium Green's Function Calculation of Optical Absorption in Nano Op... by Oka Kurniawan
Non-equilibrium Green's Function Calculation of Optical Absorption in Nano Op...Non-equilibrium Green's Function Calculation of Optical Absorption in Nano Op...
Non-equilibrium Green's Function Calculation of Optical Absorption in Nano Op...
Oka Kurniawan1.4K views

Similar to Against Space

Vasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity by
Vasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravityVasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity
Vasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravityVasil Penchev
1K views197 slides
Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity by
Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravityGravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity
Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravityVasil Penchev
855 views23 slides
London A Holographic Universe? by
London A Holographic Universe?London A Holographic Universe?
London A Holographic Universe?Sebastian De Haro
1.1K views25 slides
Berlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and Gravity by
Berlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and GravityBerlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and Gravity
Berlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and GravitySebastian De Haro
797 views39 slides
Quantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worlds by
Quantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worldsQuantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worlds
Quantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worldsLex Pit
583 views17 slides

Similar to Against Space(20)

Vasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity by Vasil Penchev
Vasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravityVasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity
Vasil Penchev. Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity
Vasil Penchev1K views
Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity by Vasil Penchev
Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravityGravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity
Gravity as entanglement, and entanglement as gravity
Vasil Penchev855 views
Berlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and Gravity by Sebastian De Haro
Berlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and GravityBerlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and Gravity
Berlin Slides Dualities and Emergence of Space-Time and Gravity
Sebastian De Haro797 views
Quantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worlds by Lex Pit
Quantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worldsQuantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worlds
Quantum phenomena modeled by interactions between many classical worlds
Lex Pit583 views
G. Djordjevic/ Lj. Nesic: Notes on Real and p-Adic Inflation by SEENET-MTP
G. Djordjevic/ Lj. Nesic: Notes on Real and p-Adic InflationG. Djordjevic/ Lj. Nesic: Notes on Real and p-Adic Inflation
G. Djordjevic/ Lj. Nesic: Notes on Real and p-Adic Inflation
SEENET-MTP803 views
natsci1report (2007version) by alezandria
natsci1report (2007version)natsci1report (2007version)
natsci1report (2007version)
alezandria1K views
Epstemologic controversy on quantum operators by raalbe autor
Epstemologic controversy on quantum operatorsEpstemologic controversy on quantum operators
Epstemologic controversy on quantum operators
raalbe autor478 views
Quantum cosmologyjj halliwell by Lívia Rezende
Quantum cosmologyjj halliwellQuantum cosmologyjj halliwell
Quantum cosmologyjj halliwell
Lívia Rezende143 views
The Theory Of Quantum Mechanics by Ashley Thomas
The Theory Of Quantum MechanicsThe Theory Of Quantum Mechanics
The Theory Of Quantum Mechanics
Ashley Thomas4 views
Could Einstein’s Relativity be Wrong? by Jeffrey Huang
Could Einstein’s Relativity be Wrong?Could Einstein’s Relativity be Wrong?
Could Einstein’s Relativity be Wrong?
Jeffrey Huang242 views
Quantum mechanics by hplap
Quantum mechanicsQuantum mechanics
Quantum mechanics
hplap1.5K views

Recently uploaded

Combining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean Architecture by
Combining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean ArchitectureCombining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean Architecture
Combining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean ArchitectureThomasHeinrichs1
68 views24 slides
MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects) by
MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects)MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects)
MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects)CXL Forum
112 views16 slides
Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa... by
Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa...Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa...
Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa...The Digital Insurer
28 views18 slides
CXL at OCP by
CXL at OCPCXL at OCP
CXL at OCPCXL Forum
208 views66 slides
AMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL Demo by
AMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL DemoAMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL Demo
AMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL DemoCXL Forum
126 views6 slides
Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum... by
Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum...Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum...
Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum...NUS-ISS
28 views35 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Combining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean Architecture by ThomasHeinrichs1
Combining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean ArchitectureCombining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean Architecture
Combining Orchestration and Choreography for a Clean Architecture
ThomasHeinrichs168 views
MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects) by CXL Forum
MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects)MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects)
MemVerge: Gismo (Global IO-free Shared Memory Objects)
CXL Forum112 views
Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa... by The Digital Insurer
Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa...Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa...
Webinar : Competing for tomorrow’s leaders – How MENA insurers can win the wa...
CXL at OCP by CXL Forum
CXL at OCPCXL at OCP
CXL at OCP
CXL Forum208 views
AMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL Demo by CXL Forum
AMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL DemoAMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL Demo
AMD: 4th Generation EPYC CXL Demo
CXL Forum126 views
Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum... by NUS-ISS
Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum...Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum...
Beyond the Hype: What Generative AI Means for the Future of Work - Damien Cum...
NUS-ISS28 views
Astera Labs: Intelligent Connectivity for Cloud and AI Infrastructure by CXL Forum
Astera Labs:  Intelligent Connectivity for Cloud and AI InfrastructureAstera Labs:  Intelligent Connectivity for Cloud and AI Infrastructure
Astera Labs: Intelligent Connectivity for Cloud and AI Infrastructure
CXL Forum125 views
Microchip: CXL Use Cases and Enabling Ecosystem by CXL Forum
Microchip: CXL Use Cases and Enabling EcosystemMicrochip: CXL Use Cases and Enabling Ecosystem
Microchip: CXL Use Cases and Enabling Ecosystem
CXL Forum129 views
Samsung: CMM-H Tiered Memory Solution with Built-in DRAM by CXL Forum
Samsung: CMM-H Tiered Memory Solution with Built-in DRAMSamsung: CMM-H Tiered Memory Solution with Built-in DRAM
Samsung: CMM-H Tiered Memory Solution with Built-in DRAM
CXL Forum105 views
TE Connectivity: Card Edge Interconnects by CXL Forum
TE Connectivity: Card Edge InterconnectsTE Connectivity: Card Edge Interconnects
TE Connectivity: Card Edge Interconnects
CXL Forum96 views
JCon Live 2023 - Lice coding some integration problems by Bernd Ruecker
JCon Live 2023 - Lice coding some integration problemsJCon Live 2023 - Lice coding some integration problems
JCon Live 2023 - Lice coding some integration problems
Bernd Ruecker67 views
GigaIO: The March of Composability Onward to Memory with CXL by CXL Forum
GigaIO: The March of Composability Onward to Memory with CXLGigaIO: The March of Composability Onward to Memory with CXL
GigaIO: The March of Composability Onward to Memory with CXL
CXL Forum126 views
Spesifikasi Lengkap ASUS Vivobook Go 14 by Dot Semarang
Spesifikasi Lengkap ASUS Vivobook Go 14Spesifikasi Lengkap ASUS Vivobook Go 14
Spesifikasi Lengkap ASUS Vivobook Go 14
Dot Semarang35 views
Future of Learning - Khoong Chan Meng by NUS-ISS
Future of Learning - Khoong Chan MengFuture of Learning - Khoong Chan Meng
Future of Learning - Khoong Chan Meng
NUS-ISS31 views
.conf Go 2023 - How KPN drives Customer Satisfaction on IPTV by Splunk
.conf Go 2023 - How KPN drives Customer Satisfaction on IPTV.conf Go 2023 - How KPN drives Customer Satisfaction on IPTV
.conf Go 2023 - How KPN drives Customer Satisfaction on IPTV
Splunk86 views
PharoJS - Zürich Smalltalk Group Meetup November 2023 by Noury Bouraqadi
PharoJS - Zürich Smalltalk Group Meetup November 2023PharoJS - Zürich Smalltalk Group Meetup November 2023
PharoJS - Zürich Smalltalk Group Meetup November 2023
Noury Bouraqadi113 views

Against Space

  • 1. space is not fundamental. time might be. Sean Carroll, Caltech http://preposterousuniverse.com/
  • 2. “What is and is not fundamental” is not fundamental. What features will be important ingredients in an ultimate (as yet hypothetical) comprehensive theory of everything. Theories often have very different-looking but equivalent descriptions (e.g. soliton/particle duality). Who is to say what is “fundamental”? But some things are certainly not fundamental; e.g. temperature. Theories using them are not comprehensive. Space is like that.
  • 3. Classical Mechanics Start with a set of coordinates . These obey second-order equations of motion: Specifying the coordinates alone doesn’t determine a solution; need to give and .
  • 4. Coordinates qi and momenta pj. Hamiltonian function H(qi, pj). Hamilton’s equations: Together we have a = {qi, pj}, defining phase space . A single point a(t0) in  defines a unique trajectory. Hamiltonian Mechanics
  • 5. Phase space is a symplectic manifold. A symplectic form  is a closed, invertible 2-form. Trajectories are integral curves of the Hamiltonian vector field,  a(t) Xa
  • 6. The coordinate/momentum distinction is blurred. Conventionally: cotangent bundle T*M = {qi, pi} = phase space  configuration space M, coordinates qi symplectic form  =  dpi  dqi (automatic) Every cotangent bundle is a symplectic manifold, but not every symplectic manifold is a cotangent bundle. Symplecticity is more “fundamental” than coordinate/momentum distinction.
  • 7. Mechanics is invariant under canonical transformations: {q, p}  {Q(q,p), P(q,p)} that leave the form of Hamilton’s equations unchanged. Example: Nothing “fundamental” about which are the coordinates, which are the momenta. Qi = pi , Pj = -qj .
  • 8. Why don’t we live in momentum space? Think of interacting harmonic oscillators. Interactions are local in position, not in momentum. Better: position is the thing in which interactions are local.
  • 9. Quantum mechanics States are rays in Hilbert space: |. Evolution is governed by the Schrödinger equation: Energy eigenbasis: Dynamics are defined by the eigenvalues {En}, the spectrum of the Hamiltonian.
  • 10. Where is “space” in the quantum state? We can define a position operator with eigenstates in terms of which the state is But we don’t have to; momentum also works. These are related by Fourier transform,
  • 11. Or other bases, e.g. creation/annihilation operators for a simple harmonic oscillator. Here, These operators raise and lower energy eigenstates:
  • 12. Entanglement For a generic multiparticle state |, The wave function is not a function of space, but of many copies of space. Things don’t happen in “space”; they happen in Hilbert space. Again, it’s locality of interactions that tempts us to speak otherwise.
  • 13. Quantum Field Theory QFT would seem to deeply privilege “space”; the Hamiltonian is an integral over space. But why? Interactions are local in space: not in momentum:
  • 14. Gravity Consider a compact dimension on a circle. R A scalar field  can be decomposed into Kaluza-Klein modes with energies From the higher-dimensional perspective, these modes comprise a tower of massive states. Conversely: if every field has such a tower, that implies an extra dimension.
  • 15. M-theory’s 11th dimension Witten 1995: there are supersymmetric particle multiplets in Type IIA string theory with masses that depend on the coupling  as Small : states are heavy and decouple. Large : Kaluza-Klein tower, as if an extra dimension. Q: How many dimensions are there in string theory? A: It depends. x11  10 dimensional IIA string theory 11 dimensional supergravity
  • 16. T-duality: string theory on a small circle is equivalent to string theory on a big circle. Momentum/winding duality. Mirror symmetries: IIA string theory on one Calabi-Yau manifold equals IIB string theory on another one. These are gauge symmetries; exact equivalence. No such thing as the “true” compactification.
  • 17. R Holography Maximum entropy inside a region of space doesn’t go as R3, the volume, but as R2, the area. Discovered in the context of black holes, but believed to be more general. Significance: The world is not made of separate degrees of freedom at each point in space. Emergent space isn’t just a matter of discreteness.
  • 18. Maldacena, 1997: quantum gravity (string theory) on five-dimensional anti-de Sitter space times a five-sphere is equivalent to a conformal field theory without gravity on the four-dimensional boundary. “The spacetime one is in” is not unambiguously defined. 10 dimensions AdS5 x S5 4-dimensional Minkowski space AdS/CFT
  • 19. • QM, states, time, & the Schrödinger equation: Space somehow recovered from |. • QM, states, & the Wheeler-de Witt equation: Space and time recovered from |. • A generalization of, or replacement for, QM. What might be fundamental?
  • 20. Closing ruminations • Space/coordinates are picked out by the specific Hamiltonian of the world, not by the structure of our theories. • Investigations of quantum gravity provide strong evidence that space is emergent, and in a deeper way than local discreteness. Degrees of freedom are not local. • Unwarranted speculation: trying to understand the early universe will help us understand the role of space & time.