E. Aloiau’s POWER-S
          vs
  H.D. Brown’s
Writing Assessment
     Criteria

          Slides by Daniel Beck
        ...
Round 1
POWER-S
POWER-S 4 Criteria for
  Assessing Writing


     USC-S
POWER-S 4 Criteria for
   Assessing Writing

• Unity
• Support
• Coherence
• Sentence Structure
Unity

Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
Support

Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
Coherence

Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
Sentence
        Structure
Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
POWER-S 4 Criteria for
   Assessing Writing

• Unity
• Support
• Coherence
• Sentence Structure
POWER-S 4 Criteria for
  Assessing Writing


     USC-S
Round 2
H.D. Brown
J.D. Brown’s Criteria for
    Assessing Writing



 COD-SVM
J.D. Brown’s Criteria for
     Assessing Writing
• Content
• Organization
• Discourse
• Syntax
• Vocabulary
• Mechanics
Content
Content • Organization • Discourse
 Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
Organization
 Content • Organization • Discourse
  Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
Discourse
Content • Organization • Discourse
 Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
Syntax
Content • Organization • Discourse
 Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
Vocabulary
Content • Organization • Discourse
 Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
Mechanics
Content • Organization • Discourse
 Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
J.D. Brown’s Criteria for
     Assessing Writing
• Content
• Organization
• Discourse
• Syntax
• Vocabulary
• Mechanics
J.D. Brown’s Criteria for
    Assessing Writing



 COD-SVM
E. Aloiau’s POWER-S
          vs
  H.D. Brown’s
Writing Assessment
     Criteria

          Slides by Daniel Beck
        ...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Aloiau's POWER-S Vs H.D. Brown’S Writing Assessment Criteria

3,082 views

Published on

I prepared this slideshow to prepare for the midterm of my grad school class at Temple University Japan's TESOL Methods II class. This slideshow highlights the outline of Aloiau's POWER-S Writing Assessment and H.D. Brown's writing assessment criteria.

Published in: Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
3,082
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
11
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
171
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Aloiau's POWER-S Vs H.D. Brown’S Writing Assessment Criteria

  1. 1. E. Aloiau’s POWER-S vs H.D. Brown’s Writing Assessment Criteria Slides by Daniel Beck (aka SamuraiTheologian) samuraitheologian@gmail.com
  2. 2. Round 1 POWER-S
  3. 3. POWER-S 4 Criteria for Assessing Writing USC-S
  4. 4. POWER-S 4 Criteria for Assessing Writing • Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
  5. 5. Unity Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
  6. 6. Support Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
  7. 7. Coherence Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
  8. 8. Sentence Structure Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
  9. 9. POWER-S 4 Criteria for Assessing Writing • Unity • Support • Coherence • Sentence Structure
  10. 10. POWER-S 4 Criteria for Assessing Writing USC-S
  11. 11. Round 2 H.D. Brown
  12. 12. J.D. Brown’s Criteria for Assessing Writing COD-SVM
  13. 13. J.D. Brown’s Criteria for Assessing Writing • Content • Organization • Discourse • Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  14. 14. Content Content • Organization • Discourse Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  15. 15. Organization Content • Organization • Discourse Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  16. 16. Discourse Content • Organization • Discourse Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  17. 17. Syntax Content • Organization • Discourse Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  18. 18. Vocabulary Content • Organization • Discourse Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  19. 19. Mechanics Content • Organization • Discourse Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  20. 20. J.D. Brown’s Criteria for Assessing Writing • Content • Organization • Discourse • Syntax • Vocabulary • Mechanics
  21. 21. J.D. Brown’s Criteria for Assessing Writing COD-SVM
  22. 22. E. Aloiau’s POWER-S vs H.D. Brown’s Writing Assessment Criteria Slides by Daniel Beck (aka SamuraiTheologian) samuraitheologian@gmail.com

×