Differentiated Instruction: Teachers’ Perceived Challenges in Hong Kong Secondary Schools

C
C&IC&I
Presented at 2016 AERA Annual Meeting, Washington DC, USA, April 10, 2016
ABSTRACT
Differentiated instruction has been widely promoted in
catering for learner diversity in different educational
settings. Recent Hong Kong curriculum reform has
highlighted differentiated instruction as an approach to
cater to learner diversity (CDC, 2009). This study explores
teachers' perceptions of differentiated instruction in two
Hong Kong secondary schools (Grades 7-12). The main
purpose of this investigation is to explore what obstacles
teachers encountered in implementing differentiated
instruction. Data were collected with the use of multi-
methods approach, utilizing a whole-school survey and
focus group interviews with teachers. Future curriculum
development and teacher development will be discussed,
as followed by research implications.
Introduction
Differentiated instruction (DI)
• A term used to describe “the process of making
educational expectations match individual students’
different learning needs” (Matthews & Foster, 2009:
112)
• A way of structuring learning and teaching with the key
elements of curriculum and assessment strategies that
can be differentiated by content, process, product and
learning environment (Chapman & King, 2005; Subban
& Round, 2015; Tomlinson, 1999)
• Individual students’ diverse needs are addressed
through multiple learning options that cater to their
different readiness levels, interests, and learning
profiles (Tomlinson, 2003)
• Help all students achieve maximum growth as learners
(Tomlinson, 1999; Tomlinson & Imbeau, 2013)
• Based on constructivist approach, which recognizes that
all learners have the right to be challenged at
moderately challenging level (Tomlinson, 2001;
Tomlinson et al., 2003)
• Teachers should have high, reasonable expectations on
student learning (Hanover Research, 2012)
Conditions for differentiated instruction
Key elements that hindered DI:
 Lack of content knowledge and pedagogical knowledge and
skills
 Classroom management skills
 Beliefs as required for supporting differentiated teaching
 Lack of understanding on how to accommodate approaches
to learning for gifted learners
 Ineffective use of resources
 Lack of planning time
 Lack of support or encouragement by the school leadership
Research Aims
• To explore what obstacles Hong Kong secondary
schools (Grades 7-12) teachers encountered in
implementing differentiated instruction.
Research Questions
1. What perceived challenges do Hong Kong teachers
face when doing differentiated instruction?
2. What are in-service Hong Kong teachers’ perceptions
of meanings, perceived readiness, and challenges of the
use of differentiated instruction?
Methodology
• Multi-method approach
Survey (QUAN) + In-depth Focus group interview
(QUAL)
• 2 subsidized Christian schools (S08, S15)
• Response rate
 S08 : 62.5% (N=35)
 S15 : 65% (N=39)
• Data analysis: Based on an extensive literature related
to obstacles towards differentiation implementation,
the written responses in questionnaire were categorized
and quantified
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by the
Direct Grant for Research (2012-13) [Project Code:
4058008], The Chinese University of Hong Kong.
Table 1. Demographic variables for respondents..
Table 2. Basic information about interviewees.
Findings & Discussion
Teachers’ perceived challenges towards
differentiated instruction
Great diversity between high and low ability students
• Biggest concern, with 17.14% (N=6) of S08 and 20.51% (N=8)
of S15 respectively.
• Teachers were also worried about examination due to diverse
academic abilities of students.
Fairness
• S15 teachers were more anxious, with 15.38% (N=6)
Teachers perceived that
• Lower ability students would hold back those high ability
students
• Individual guidance or help would be regarded as unfairness.
• Teachers showed concerns that provision of individual guidance
may deteriorate inter-relationships among students.
Time
• In the written comment data, a total of 11.43% (N=4) teachers
whilst 10.26% (N=4) realized time is one of the obstacles to
differentiated instruction.
• Hard to prepare appropriate materials for students due to
shortage of time
• Limited lesson time would result in weaker understanding of
students’ needs.
• Preparation time for learning materials was insufficient as a
result of heavy workload.
• DI increases their workload and shorten their lesson
preparation time.
Teachers’ dilemma
• To cover the curriculum or to look after slower learners
• Teachers felt that they had to sacrifice those slow students.
Professional development
• Teachers were uncertain about how to do differentiated
instruction due to lack of effective professional development.
• Teachers were doubted about how to evaluate the effectiveness
of the measures in handling learner diversity.
Sally Wai-Yan WAN Alice Hoi-Yan HUI Rita Hau-Kwan LAU Coby Ka-Yau WU Thomas Wing-Ki LEE Kelvin Shing-Pan CHONG
Lik-Chun Leo WONG Ylena Yan WONG Fergus Tsz-Hin CHEUNG David Chong-Kwai YEUNG Donix Kwan-Ho CHAN
Faculty of Education, The Chinese University of Hong Kong Corresponding email: sallywywan@cuhk.edu.hk
Significance of the study
• Understanding teachers’ concerns is one
of the ways to bringing curriculum change
in a more effective way (Anderson, 1997;
Hall & Loucks, 1978; Hall & Hord, 1987)
• This study has examined teachers’
perceptions of obstacles towards the use
of differentiated instruction in the Hong
Kong context.
• School leadership and administration for
providing teachers with sufficient support,
and teacher professional development for
preparation of pedagogical knowledge and
skills in using differentiate instruction
should be taken into account
1 of 1

Recommended

TLC - Creating an Inclusive Curriculum by
TLC - Creating an Inclusive CurriculumTLC - Creating an Inclusive Curriculum
TLC - Creating an Inclusive CurriculumAcademic Development
1.5K views24 slides
Action Research Effective Stategies for Teaching Inferencing by
Action Research Effective Stategies for Teaching InferencingAction Research Effective Stategies for Teaching Inferencing
Action Research Effective Stategies for Teaching InferencingNicole Shankula (Quintanilla)
3.8K views85 slides
Action research for Strategic Intervention Materials by
Action research for Strategic Intervention MaterialsAction research for Strategic Intervention Materials
Action research for Strategic Intervention MaterialsKristine Barredo
126.3K views18 slides
Differentiating instruction, MTE 533 by
Differentiating instruction, MTE 533Differentiating instruction, MTE 533
Differentiating instruction, MTE 533acreynolds224
999 views13 slides
Integrating student centered approaches in science teacher training in Cambodia by
Integrating student centered approaches in science teacher training in CambodiaIntegrating student centered approaches in science teacher training in Cambodia
Integrating student centered approaches in science teacher training in CambodiaStefaan Vande Walle
897 views14 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Concepts on supervision and the teaching process by
Concepts on supervision and the teaching processConcepts on supervision and the teaching process
Concepts on supervision and the teaching processReggie Cruz
644 views22 slides
Reflective level of teaching by
Reflective level of teachingReflective level of teaching
Reflective level of teachingBeulahJayarani
1.4K views10 slides
Action researchpresentation (1) by
Action researchpresentation (1)Action researchpresentation (1)
Action researchpresentation (1)malhabshan
172 views8 slides
Developing teacher quality and effectiveness in new teachers for nyu by
Developing teacher quality and effectiveness  in new teachers for nyuDeveloping teacher quality and effectiveness  in new teachers for nyu
Developing teacher quality and effectiveness in new teachers for nyuPioneer One
1.6K views15 slides
The Impact of Differentiated Instruction and Assessment by
The Impact of Differentiated Instruction and AssessmentThe Impact of Differentiated Instruction and Assessment
The Impact of Differentiated Instruction and AssessmentMary Fenby-Rocks
435 views6 slides
Role Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary Level by
Role Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary LevelRole Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary Level
Role Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary LevelPakistan
13 views10 slides

What's hot(20)

Concepts on supervision and the teaching process by Reggie Cruz
Concepts on supervision and the teaching processConcepts on supervision and the teaching process
Concepts on supervision and the teaching process
Reggie Cruz644 views
Reflective level of teaching by BeulahJayarani
Reflective level of teachingReflective level of teaching
Reflective level of teaching
BeulahJayarani1.4K views
Action researchpresentation (1) by malhabshan
Action researchpresentation (1)Action researchpresentation (1)
Action researchpresentation (1)
malhabshan172 views
Developing teacher quality and effectiveness in new teachers for nyu by Pioneer One
Developing teacher quality and effectiveness  in new teachers for nyuDeveloping teacher quality and effectiveness  in new teachers for nyu
Developing teacher quality and effectiveness in new teachers for nyu
Pioneer One1.6K views
The Impact of Differentiated Instruction and Assessment by Mary Fenby-Rocks
The Impact of Differentiated Instruction and AssessmentThe Impact of Differentiated Instruction and Assessment
The Impact of Differentiated Instruction and Assessment
Mary Fenby-Rocks435 views
Role Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary Level by Pakistan
Role Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary LevelRole Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary Level
Role Of Interactive Notes On The Learning Of Students At Elementary Level
Pakistan13 views
Proposal rehearsal by jlps0601
Proposal rehearsalProposal rehearsal
Proposal rehearsal
jlps0601279 views
Implementation practices of 4 teachers by rgeurtz
Implementation practices of 4 teachersImplementation practices of 4 teachers
Implementation practices of 4 teachers
rgeurtz240 views
Building RTI Capacity by Texas ACE
Building RTI CapacityBuilding RTI Capacity
Building RTI Capacity
Texas ACE 1.1K views
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo... by Alexander Decker
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...
Effects of teacher preparation on students academic achievements in ss2 biolo...
Alexander Decker5K views
A workshop on writing "Rencana Pembelajaran Semester" (RPS) and "Satuan Acara... by Iwan Syahril
A workshop on writing "Rencana Pembelajaran Semester" (RPS) and "Satuan Acara...A workshop on writing "Rencana Pembelajaran Semester" (RPS) and "Satuan Acara...
A workshop on writing "Rencana Pembelajaran Semester" (RPS) and "Satuan Acara...
Iwan Syahril629 views
Assessment FOR Learning: Mathematics by Monika Gruss
Assessment FOR Learning: MathematicsAssessment FOR Learning: Mathematics
Assessment FOR Learning: Mathematics
Monika Gruss1.3K views
External moderation of School Practice 2017 by Stephen Ndawula
External moderation of School Practice 2017External moderation of School Practice 2017
External moderation of School Practice 2017
Stephen Ndawula98 views
DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 2 by WENDELL TARAYA
DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 2DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 2
DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 2
WENDELL TARAYA168 views
DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 1 by WENDELL TARAYA
DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 1DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 1
DESIGN HEARING ON DIFFERENTIATED INSTRUCTION CHAPTER 1
WENDELL TARAYA87 views
The Role of the Teacher in Teaching Physics in the Third Language (L3) Accord... by Mirlan Jussambayev
The Role of the Teacher in Teaching Physics in the Third Language (L3) Accord...The Role of the Teacher in Teaching Physics in the Third Language (L3) Accord...
The Role of the Teacher in Teaching Physics in the Third Language (L3) Accord...
Mirlan Jussambayev119 views
EL7002 Assignment 8 by eckchela
EL7002 Assignment 8EL7002 Assignment 8
EL7002 Assignment 8
eckchela671 views

Similar to Differentiated Instruction: Teachers’ Perceived Challenges in Hong Kong Secondary Schools

Differentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash Course by
Differentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash CourseDifferentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash Course
Differentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash CourseKatie Gelinas
6.9K views76 slides
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti... by
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...sallywywan
405 views1 slide
Hea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson study by
Hea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson studyHea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson study
Hea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson studyPhilwood
942 views30 slides
Di udl.1.14.11 by
Di udl.1.14.11Di udl.1.14.11
Di udl.1.14.11Maritess Jariolne
219 views24 slides
Di udl.1.14.11 copy by
Di udl.1.14.11   copyDi udl.1.14.11   copy
Di udl.1.14.11 copyDods Dodong
521 views24 slides
Di udl.1.14.11 by
Di udl.1.14.11Di udl.1.14.11
Di udl.1.14.11Dods Dodong
525 views24 slides

Similar to Differentiated Instruction: Teachers’ Perceived Challenges in Hong Kong Secondary Schools(20)

Differentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash Course by Katie Gelinas
Differentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash CourseDifferentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash Course
Differentiated Instruction and Assessment Presentation- A Crash Course
Katie Gelinas6.9K views
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti... by sallywywan
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
Exploring Hong Kong Secondary School Teachers' Teaching Beliefs of Differenti...
sallywywan405 views
Hea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson study by Philwood
Hea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson studyHea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson study
Hea workshop session 1 an introduction to lesson study
Philwood942 views
Di udl.1.14.11 copy by Dods Dodong
Di udl.1.14.11   copyDi udl.1.14.11   copy
Di udl.1.14.11 copy
Dods Dodong521 views
Developing a comprehensive, empirically based research framework for classroo... by Amir Hamid Forough Ameri
Developing a comprehensive, empirically based research framework for classroo...Developing a comprehensive, empirically based research framework for classroo...
Developing a comprehensive, empirically based research framework for classroo...
Developing a comprehensive empirically based research framework for classroom... by ahfameri
Developing a comprehensive empirically based research framework for classroom...Developing a comprehensive empirically based research framework for classroom...
Developing a comprehensive empirically based research framework for classroom...
ahfameri372 views
Using Action Research to Identify Data During Clinical Experience (main) by Antwuan Stinson
Using Action Research to Identify Data During Clinical Experience (main)Using Action Research to Identify Data During Clinical Experience (main)
Using Action Research to Identify Data During Clinical Experience (main)
Antwuan Stinson279 views
Differentiated instruction web one by Lisa Stack
Differentiated instruction web oneDifferentiated instruction web one
Differentiated instruction web one
Lisa Stack1.4K views
7.effectiveteachingmethodsforlargerclasses by realhope
7.effectiveteachingmethodsforlargerclasses7.effectiveteachingmethodsforlargerclasses
7.effectiveteachingmethodsforlargerclasses
realhope520 views
Exploring Teachers Practices of Classroom Assessment in Secondary Science Cla... by Md. Mehadi Rahman
Exploring Teachers Practices of Classroom Assessment in Secondary Science Cla...Exploring Teachers Practices of Classroom Assessment in Secondary Science Cla...
Exploring Teachers Practices of Classroom Assessment in Secondary Science Cla...
Md. Mehadi Rahman467 views
Response To Intervention by Paul Schumann
Response To InterventionResponse To Intervention
Response To Intervention
Paul Schumann649 views
ACTIVITY BASED LEARNING ELIMINATE ROTE FOR ACADEMIC GROWTH Impact Factor-5.414 by Don Dooley
ACTIVITY BASED LEARNING  ELIMINATE ROTE FOR ACADEMIC GROWTH Impact Factor-5.414ACTIVITY BASED LEARNING  ELIMINATE ROTE FOR ACADEMIC GROWTH Impact Factor-5.414
ACTIVITY BASED LEARNING ELIMINATE ROTE FOR ACADEMIC GROWTH Impact Factor-5.414
Don Dooley3 views
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education by Sails-project
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science educationImplementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education
Implementing assessment of inquiry skills in science education
Sails-project420 views

More from C&I

Exploring teaching efficacy by
Exploring teaching efficacyExploring teaching efficacy
Exploring teaching efficacyC&I
66 views25 slides
Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a... by
Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a...Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a...
Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a...C&I
57 views10 slides
A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes... by
A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes...A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes...
A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes...C&I
205 views24 slides
Lesson 1-2 Antarctica by
Lesson 1-2 AntarcticaLesson 1-2 Antarctica
Lesson 1-2 AntarcticaC&I
324 views13 slides
Lesson 3 Historical Explorers in Antarctica by
Lesson 3 Historical Explorers in AntarcticaLesson 3 Historical Explorers in Antarctica
Lesson 3 Historical Explorers in AntarcticaC&I
457 views11 slides
Lesson 3 historical explorers by
Lesson 3 historical explorersLesson 3 historical explorers
Lesson 3 historical explorersC&I
266 views11 slides

More from C&I(13)

Exploring teaching efficacy by C&I
Exploring teaching efficacyExploring teaching efficacy
Exploring teaching efficacy
C&I66 views
Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a... by C&I
Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a...Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a...
Future employment & Learning expectations: Profiles of university students' a...
C&I57 views
A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes... by C&I
A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes...A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes...
A cluster exploration analysis of prospective teachers' perceptions of profes...
C&I205 views
Lesson 1-2 Antarctica by C&I
Lesson 1-2 AntarcticaLesson 1-2 Antarctica
Lesson 1-2 Antarctica
C&I324 views
Lesson 3 Historical Explorers in Antarctica by C&I
Lesson 3 Historical Explorers in AntarcticaLesson 3 Historical Explorers in Antarctica
Lesson 3 Historical Explorers in Antarctica
C&I457 views
Lesson 3 historical explorers by C&I
Lesson 3 historical explorersLesson 3 historical explorers
Lesson 3 historical explorers
C&I266 views
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 4 by C&I
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 4PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 4
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 4
C&I225 views
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 3 by C&I
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 3PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 3
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 3
C&I305 views
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 3 by C&I
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 3PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 3
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 3
C&I287 views
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 2 by C&I
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 2PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 2
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 2
C&I207 views
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 2 by C&I
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 2PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 2
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 2
C&I271 views
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 1 by C&I
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 1PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 1
PKC Grade 9C World Healer Project Lesson 1
C&I221 views
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 1 by C&I
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 1PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 1
PKC G8B Alternative Energy Lesson 1
C&I363 views

Recently uploaded

unidad 3.pdf by
unidad 3.pdfunidad 3.pdf
unidad 3.pdfMarcosRodriguezUcedo
117 views38 slides
Education and Diversity.pptx by
Education and Diversity.pptxEducation and Diversity.pptx
Education and Diversity.pptxDrHafizKosar
193 views16 slides
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue Doe by
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue DoeWomen from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue Doe
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue DoeHistory of Stoke Newington
163 views21 slides
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB... by
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
88 views113 slides
The basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdf by
The basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdfThe basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdf
The basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdfJonathanCovena1
146 views1 slide
Gross Anatomy of the Liver by
Gross Anatomy of the LiverGross Anatomy of the Liver
Gross Anatomy of the Liverobaje godwin sunday
61 views12 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Education and Diversity.pptx by DrHafizKosar
Education and Diversity.pptxEducation and Diversity.pptx
Education and Diversity.pptx
DrHafizKosar193 views
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB... by Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (GLOB...
The basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdf by JonathanCovena1
The basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdfThe basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdf
The basics - information, data, technology and systems.pdf
JonathanCovena1146 views
Sociology KS5 by WestHatch
Sociology KS5Sociology KS5
Sociology KS5
WestHatch85 views
Relationship of psychology with other subjects. by palswagata2003
Relationship of psychology with other subjects.Relationship of psychology with other subjects.
Relationship of psychology with other subjects.
palswagata200352 views
EIT-Digital_Spohrer_AI_Intro 20231128 v1.pptx by ISSIP
EIT-Digital_Spohrer_AI_Intro 20231128 v1.pptxEIT-Digital_Spohrer_AI_Intro 20231128 v1.pptx
EIT-Digital_Spohrer_AI_Intro 20231128 v1.pptx
ISSIP386 views
When Sex Gets Complicated: Porn, Affairs, & Cybersex by Marlene Maheu
When Sex Gets Complicated: Porn, Affairs, & CybersexWhen Sex Gets Complicated: Porn, Affairs, & Cybersex
When Sex Gets Complicated: Porn, Affairs, & Cybersex
Marlene Maheu85 views
Narration lesson plan by TARIQ KHAN
Narration lesson planNarration lesson plan
Narration lesson plan
TARIQ KHAN61 views
Dance KS5 Breakdown by WestHatch
Dance KS5 BreakdownDance KS5 Breakdown
Dance KS5 Breakdown
WestHatch99 views
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptx by Breach_P
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptxCreate a Structure in VBNet.pptx
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptx
Breach_P78 views
Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November) by Esquimalt MFRC
Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November)Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November)
Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November)
Esquimalt MFRC72 views
Drama KS5 Breakdown by WestHatch
Drama KS5 BreakdownDrama KS5 Breakdown
Drama KS5 Breakdown
WestHatch98 views
Structure and Functions of Cell.pdf by Nithya Murugan
Structure and Functions of Cell.pdfStructure and Functions of Cell.pdf
Structure and Functions of Cell.pdf
Nithya Murugan719 views

Differentiated Instruction: Teachers’ Perceived Challenges in Hong Kong Secondary Schools

  • 1. Presented at 2016 AERA Annual Meeting, Washington DC, USA, April 10, 2016 ABSTRACT Differentiated instruction has been widely promoted in catering for learner diversity in different educational settings. Recent Hong Kong curriculum reform has highlighted differentiated instruction as an approach to cater to learner diversity (CDC, 2009). This study explores teachers' perceptions of differentiated instruction in two Hong Kong secondary schools (Grades 7-12). The main purpose of this investigation is to explore what obstacles teachers encountered in implementing differentiated instruction. Data were collected with the use of multi- methods approach, utilizing a whole-school survey and focus group interviews with teachers. Future curriculum development and teacher development will be discussed, as followed by research implications. Introduction Differentiated instruction (DI) • A term used to describe “the process of making educational expectations match individual students’ different learning needs” (Matthews & Foster, 2009: 112) • A way of structuring learning and teaching with the key elements of curriculum and assessment strategies that can be differentiated by content, process, product and learning environment (Chapman & King, 2005; Subban & Round, 2015; Tomlinson, 1999) • Individual students’ diverse needs are addressed through multiple learning options that cater to their different readiness levels, interests, and learning profiles (Tomlinson, 2003) • Help all students achieve maximum growth as learners (Tomlinson, 1999; Tomlinson & Imbeau, 2013) • Based on constructivist approach, which recognizes that all learners have the right to be challenged at moderately challenging level (Tomlinson, 2001; Tomlinson et al., 2003) • Teachers should have high, reasonable expectations on student learning (Hanover Research, 2012) Conditions for differentiated instruction Key elements that hindered DI:  Lack of content knowledge and pedagogical knowledge and skills  Classroom management skills  Beliefs as required for supporting differentiated teaching  Lack of understanding on how to accommodate approaches to learning for gifted learners  Ineffective use of resources  Lack of planning time  Lack of support or encouragement by the school leadership Research Aims • To explore what obstacles Hong Kong secondary schools (Grades 7-12) teachers encountered in implementing differentiated instruction. Research Questions 1. What perceived challenges do Hong Kong teachers face when doing differentiated instruction? 2. What are in-service Hong Kong teachers’ perceptions of meanings, perceived readiness, and challenges of the use of differentiated instruction? Methodology • Multi-method approach Survey (QUAN) + In-depth Focus group interview (QUAL) • 2 subsidized Christian schools (S08, S15) • Response rate  S08 : 62.5% (N=35)  S15 : 65% (N=39) • Data analysis: Based on an extensive literature related to obstacles towards differentiation implementation, the written responses in questionnaire were categorized and quantified Acknowledgements This research was supported by the Direct Grant for Research (2012-13) [Project Code: 4058008], The Chinese University of Hong Kong. Table 1. Demographic variables for respondents.. Table 2. Basic information about interviewees. Findings & Discussion Teachers’ perceived challenges towards differentiated instruction Great diversity between high and low ability students • Biggest concern, with 17.14% (N=6) of S08 and 20.51% (N=8) of S15 respectively. • Teachers were also worried about examination due to diverse academic abilities of students. Fairness • S15 teachers were more anxious, with 15.38% (N=6) Teachers perceived that • Lower ability students would hold back those high ability students • Individual guidance or help would be regarded as unfairness. • Teachers showed concerns that provision of individual guidance may deteriorate inter-relationships among students. Time • In the written comment data, a total of 11.43% (N=4) teachers whilst 10.26% (N=4) realized time is one of the obstacles to differentiated instruction. • Hard to prepare appropriate materials for students due to shortage of time • Limited lesson time would result in weaker understanding of students’ needs. • Preparation time for learning materials was insufficient as a result of heavy workload. • DI increases their workload and shorten their lesson preparation time. Teachers’ dilemma • To cover the curriculum or to look after slower learners • Teachers felt that they had to sacrifice those slow students. Professional development • Teachers were uncertain about how to do differentiated instruction due to lack of effective professional development. • Teachers were doubted about how to evaluate the effectiveness of the measures in handling learner diversity. Sally Wai-Yan WAN Alice Hoi-Yan HUI Rita Hau-Kwan LAU Coby Ka-Yau WU Thomas Wing-Ki LEE Kelvin Shing-Pan CHONG Lik-Chun Leo WONG Ylena Yan WONG Fergus Tsz-Hin CHEUNG David Chong-Kwai YEUNG Donix Kwan-Ho CHAN Faculty of Education, The Chinese University of Hong Kong Corresponding email: sallywywan@cuhk.edu.hk Significance of the study • Understanding teachers’ concerns is one of the ways to bringing curriculum change in a more effective way (Anderson, 1997; Hall & Loucks, 1978; Hall & Hord, 1987) • This study has examined teachers’ perceptions of obstacles towards the use of differentiated instruction in the Hong Kong context. • School leadership and administration for providing teachers with sufficient support, and teacher professional development for preparation of pedagogical knowledge and skills in using differentiate instruction should be taken into account