A pós-modernidade e a necessidade de um diálogo interdisciplinar no direito ambiental - Rogério Santos Rammê e Márcio Frezza Sgarioni
- 1. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
&
!" #$ %
%
: !+
* 9 " 7 '
# ": " " *+ 4 "
@ # 6! - 2
! # " , *A
B- ,
! # $
2 #! " *+ ! "
2 )
! $" ! *
" + # " #
6! " 2 )
! $ "$ # "
" * B $ " *+ ( ! 6 !
" " ! " C
! 6! ! " " $+
D " 6! D # "D 6!
" ! # C E - 2 )
! '
# " " B" " * 6
+ ! "$ !
B " # ( B " @ "
" @ # 6 ! - '
# "
'( " (* '
) $ # " " , "
( 6! 2
! # " 1 *+
+ "
FD !G #! D " B " " " G
B ! $ " !" D B D " " " G
$" " G# D $ B $ "
B G
D ! D D " " B G B " C
! " " D #G D D " " BD $
9
' # " " / $ ,C !H /
" , 1 D ( 6! : $ '
I" ,(% . )
! F# "
! . *
! % !" % *
" & : JD "
7
' # " " / $ ,C !H /
" , 1 D ( 6! : $ '
I" ,(% $ % * " & : J #
- 2. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
BL ;" F D
D G D D ; D! D " ! ; D D L ;"
% $ " 1 ; ;"" " L" G ;D L "$ $ "
B
" ""G "G D " B " G D
C B D D B $ "" ;
, -. * % $ " 1; " G % " " 1 "
D $ 1 G
/0
, ! # 2 )
! ! " " ) ! '
# " 6! 2 + " $
" ! # C M' $ " 6 "
!
@ " 6! -
2
! # "M%C " # $ M ' # "
N ' #! ! !+
* $ "$ $
" M
# "D # $
2 # 6! A +
" # 6! + B B " 6!
" @ # ' # ! 6!
- " $ "! +
* " ! !
" , ! @ $ *
6! - " ' # " # B *+
! # 2 )
! " ) B "! A
* 2
! B $ E !"
" $ C E 6! A
2 B
! "
( ! 6! B " !
" C ! 6! !" "
$+ D " 6! D
# "D 6! " ! # C E -
2 )
! ' # " " B" " * 6
+ !
!" " C # " !
9K>
- 3. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
" + *A # #" # "
C " $ # 2 )
! ! "
" @ # ' # " "
" *+ ( B ! " @
" @ # 6! - '
# " # C - $ ! "
"
@ # ! " $ "$
& 6! " C" *+ ! ! F" "
$ "$ D!
B!
! !*A
! ! # C" *+ & !" + !"
" !- *+ !$ " )
" $ *+ " 6! %!
!" O0 6! # B
! ! !
! * ! C , !
# " D G 6! !*A
! 6! ! *
" A D! B! !
$ B # ! ! B 2$ :
!# + D E " ! # "D * $
" !$ " " " *+ # ! #
") P " Q ! " *+ ! % !
4
" $ :! !
4
' %
' D G 6-
! 9K 9=
9K=
- 4. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
' ! # ! D! ! ! )
! 2 ! " *+ "
! ! $ B " "
% # 2 !) "
$ #" B $ ! "
*+ " # ! B 6 #
!
D! $$ "2 C "!) $ *
B 6! " @ !
R ! 6! B
" $"
" $ "$ &
# ! 6! CA ! ! $ "
*+ " ! ! '$ 1G S
T
3
! B" B 2
! #" * ! $ !
) "
" , $ !
) " 6! 2 + ! 6!
" " 6! $ E ! " 6! !"
+ ! 6! " !
" B! " C ! !" R
$" ! % 6 1 BK S
! B
UR ! " *A , # "
?
"C ! $ !
) $ 2 "
! B " 2 *+
" *A $ D * + ! ! #
C +
6 " 6
! ! "$ 2 $ $ " D 6!
EB" 6! # *
! + &! $ "
T
1V '$ ( 9?
3
F * ! E " : " E $ =
K
1% % 6! # # " ! #" " " C 9?
?
/ F "C - " ? >
9?8
- 5. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
$ "$ $" !" % # ! B" 6! #"
# + " # B" 6! " 2
$"
! #" " & ") B$
! *
" + ! " B $ 6! # "
! *+ B
W " , " , "" " "" ! $ $ I
>
# # ! B " D !
6! "! # " $ "$ "
# A B & B" 6! " *A
# % 9==9 ! ! *
" + 6!
I ! " 6! B ! D $ !
N $"
! C ! !
! + $ $ !*+ B
1; ! DB I ! " E ! -
A 6! ) # B " !
# " : # !
! * S
+ U ) ) ! : $ !
)
# $ + $$ !B B B
"!*+ # " : " " & )
# - ! ! # C 6! ) !
# "
F B 6!
!- 6! # *
! + C " $
!$ ! *
" A $"
! $ 6!
# B B! " $ "$ D 6!
6! "C + 6! !
C " $ !$ " &
>
, %1 ' W %11 , " , "" " I %
%X ! $ $ 6! . *
!
# " ? >
9?9
- 6. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
" 6! *+ C " :
6 " 6 0
! ! D$ =
+ "$ "*+ /" DI L98 6! 6!
6! ! " # *
! + D
!" *A " C !
B # " * 6 "
! 6! ! ! 6 "!
!
" 6 "
! 6 I L
! B
6! " 6! "
B $)
$ 6! * !
! !+
* !+
*
*+ D
!!
" $ ! " B
#"DA ! )
# + B !
*+
D #
! " * %" # "
N "
" B # ! " !+*
) " : B " " $!
$ " !
99
+ "
C ' D "! A
*
#" 2 *
! " ! # '
# " " D 6! # 2)
! 6 "
!
"! A
* 2
! 6! "$ B
" "
2 *
! # 6! 6! B 6! + +
" C " !+
* ! $ " 2
! # "
( A " ' # " "
! # C ' 6! B $ "
6! # 2 )
! $" E *+ #
=
W0 0 ! 1 9K4 9>K
98
I Y /
%, " D : ! ! ! F !+* # + 7?
99
I Y /
%, " D : ! ! ! T3
9?7
- 7. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
& * /0
97
"*+ , ' ' # " B
B 6! *+ !" !2
2 S ! !E * C - D! " $
D UR # " *A
# " * D
+ !
! $ + D ") ' # " #2 ! " $
! A , ! - #2 ! " " '
# 6 ")
! # " " E 6 "
!
$ D!
( " $ # 2 )
! ! " " ' # "
" # #" # 2 )
! " !!
" ! # C , ! "
6! $ 6 ")
! # " " *A
#! + C *A " B-
"!
B
) 6)
! # " " & ") ! 6!
A " C #2 ! " " ' # "M W
* 2 )
+ ! # 6!
" # 2 )
! " *+ "
D
I " W" . N $ +
$ " $ ! *
" + " #
" ) #" " 6!
C! " * $ ! P ! Q $
94
"
97
'% , ' # "% & 3K
94
1%
0 " I 1% , % I F ! " : !
!+
* 94=
9?4
- 8. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
$ * # " !
! $ B A
! ! "
" " !" ! "! "
9T
! Z" & !" ! "! "
E2
! *+ " B ! " $ "$ !
)
B $ " ! !
) # B6! )
B " # $
2
! ! # !& $ #2 ' ! #
" ! "
!" ! # #" " 6!
*A $ "$
( # 6! " ' $ "$ !
2 )
! " " # C '
$" "*A * D" 0 Y L D $ 93
6! " " 6! @ # 6!
6! 6! #" * ! "
" ( B ! B & 2 )
!
! " B !*+ ! -
" ' # ! # P C Q !
" $ P *+ " ' Q 2
! ! "
9K
P2 B
! $ ) ' Q 6! C" '
6! ' # " + B"
" 6! " ! #
' $ "D B *+ ' # "
6 "
! " $ " D " 2 6! "
D " " # 2 )
! B
"! !
$ " !"
# B
! B B %C "
9T
F% %F Z "
X & # #" ! ) " '
97?
93
F% %F Z "
X & # #" ! ) " '
94?
9K
F% %F Z "
X & # #" ! ) " '
94K
9?T
- 9. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
$ " + B" : ' # " " ' ( "
6! #2 " + # " '
$ " # " ' ,$"
6! $ #" $" # "
" *A $ D * ' % & 6!
$ ) $ "$ ! $" '
/# ) 6! + ! '
( !" )
B #"
" $ ' , ! " 6! 6! !
2 B
! ! " B
! ! % $ "
' # " B
" 6 .
! . 6! , "D C
A B
9?
' ! # B $ " $ " 6!
$ C ' # " 6 "
! 6!
2
! # " " ! # C + 2 )
!
% $ * " $ !
" 6! ' # + N ' #! !
!+
* $ "$ # " "
% " B R D
B 2 )
! ( C " 6! + D
! $ " " 6! + # 6
! ! ! )
# "
! +
' F#! # ,$" % " $
B
"! A " ! ' P6! # $
! Q ' )
" "
$ B! *A B " 6! A E $ $" 1
" " + $ 6! -
' # "
9?
, F1W . . 6! 1 F .
% % !# ' , ! " # "I "
3
9?3
- 10. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
, ! # + ) C "! $ " 6 !
!
' # " 6! 6! + " ! ! # P C Q
! ! B !
' # " 2
! #! B
" C " !" "! A
* 6! E
" " B 6! '
# " C 6! 2 )
! !"
" " C " *A # "D $"
2
! $ $ B *A 6! " *A
!" ! "*+ B" B ,D D Y"
6! #" !D! $ "$ !
A D 6 "
! 6!
-" ! 6 $
!
9>
. " Z" 1$ C" * D ")
+ ' # "
6 "
! B D ! )
)
B C 6! ! " ! A " !
6! #- 2 )
! +
! B ! :
+ ) "
$ " * 6!
! 2 )
! + D !
- ! E
- # " # :
! ' ! $ $ " *+
9=
# # "
" B $ " *+ '
# " " 6! ! "*+ & , "
Z "L !" B
! *
$" ) " 1 6! A "
9>
Y 1 ,D D F . *
! 4K
9=
1 . 1 V Z"
%0 " B
! : BC
" A ! $
" # " T8
9?K
- 11. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
*+ B 2
! $ " " $ 6!
+ B 2 B *
! + ' # *+ !"
78
! + *+ " % !
" #! " *+ ' # "
6! "! " " " "
B "79 $ * ! E B *+ ! $ "
2
! # "
+ "$ ! 6! ) " + 6!
" @ # ' 6! #
" @ # 6! - 2
! # " #
$ !" C - " " "
"
1 2 3 4
5
[! #" $ *+ ! " "
6! - 2
! # "M %C " E *+ "
" M% + ! *A 6! *A 6!
!
77
.G ($ "$ (!" I B )
" ! ! B * 6! "
2! B" "! +
* " ! !# *+ " E *+
D B ! "
" " $ " 6! BC S U S "! U S ! U
"
78
Z 1 %
Y & , " ( ! 1 *+ . *
! ("! " '
T9?
79
Z 1 %
Y & , " ( ! 1 *+ . *
! ("! " '
T9>
77
(0 .G I F R ) (!
"$ " " : B *
! A ! -
9=
9??
- 12. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
S U + "$ #" " *+
D B 6! " *+ BC +
74
"! A
* B $ 6! ! ! $"
' ! # # %" # "D 6 "D
! !" B D$
! S - ! !
! B " ! !
! "D $ *A " B UF - 6! !
%" # S "
# $ % $
7T
U
N$ C " 6! + ($ I
6! " + ! # *+
" 6! 6! $ "
73
#! #" #" *+ D
B ! 6! *+ C + " B"
" *A *A $ " D
! B" "! +
* F " !- ! "
+ #" " *A N" "
" D C 6! #" *+
" + ! "D #
B +
! *+ $ C A 6! !# !
7K
$" "D $ " *A
Y LD $ # B " - 2 )
!
# C - )
$ #" "
6! $ B !*+ ! - "
' F #" ! B ! "
$ ! C" $ 6! $ " - 2 )
!
74
(0 .G I F R ) (!
"$ " " : B *
! A ! -
93
7T
%1 # # ?=
73
(0 .G I F R ) (!
"$ " " : B *
! A ! -
73
7K
(0 .G I F R ) (!
"$ " " : B *
! A ! -
7K
9?>
- 13. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
" # $ $" #
! C $ 6! - "
' $ "$ ! $ C # $
2 C" $
6! C" ' " ! #
7?
C
' B # 6! C #" " E
" 6! + "$ 6! # $
2
!+
* ! $ " 2 )
! " % #
- 2 )
! " + $ $" C "! $
$ C # " ! $ "
$ " ! # C B ! $
" 2 )
! ( $" C "! $ $
" " # B
) " "
% 6! - 2
! # " " $
+ 6! 2
! # " -
! 2
! #2 " ! " !
6! " ") " & "
'$ " " #" # C
#! B *+ ! " ) # 2)
! $" E *+ # "
" C" # ! $ "
2 )
! " C C
"*+ " 1 " , :
! "
2
! ! $ #
$ 2
! D
# " 2 ! " 6
+!
# # ! "
!) B 6 " $
!
- # " $ #! !
7?
F% %F Z "
X & # #" ! ) " '
94> =
9?=
- 14. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
"D ! " !
7>
B *
, B 6! - 6! # $
2 $ "$ ! 6!
2
! # " " *+ + B D "D
$ "
($ 6! 6! ! " "
- B!" " D B
B ! #2 ! " !! )
#! ! $ B &
$ $ $
7=
6! C 6! - $ ! !
$ D B B $ "$
6! + " $ # 6! 2
# " *A D C "
@ !) " B" 6 !
! - " $ 6!
! # ! - # %" 6!
$ #" " "
( + "$ " $ " @ #
6! - 2
! # " ,# !"
"! 6! B ! A " B "D
"D #" # # !# !
# "!) $
#" "C C " *+
*+ # " ! *
" A
$ 2 *
! # ! B # "D
7>
% % 1 " , # ": ! "
7=
(0 .G " : *A ?7
9>8
- 15. ! "
" # " $ %" & ' ( ") ( ( !*+
,- . )
! / 01 2) $3 4 45 6! 7898 ' ) "
$ :
;;; ! $ " # < " 9=>8 ??=9
C #" " # $ ! $
48
2
! 6!
, B + $ $ "
2
! # " # " D !
"* .
+ * 1G :
' " *+ $ "- D
D B " ( B : " +
6 !
# #" " + 6!
6! " $ " !
49
2
!" 6! ' # " C "*A
C ) " # ! )
B " # "
- D! 6! " "D " "
)
B # "
( !" "* I $
+ ! ! :
% ! ' (% P78 4 Q
8 B 6!
$ ! ) *+
6! *+ - H
6! B!
6 @ "
; $ P !
!" QH ! - - 6!
, #
" $ BC
" +
B
) !B ) "D$ B 6!
! D !" ! *+
6! $ - " :
! <! !
" ! "< B " $$ <
< # $ <# $ ! 2 $ <#
# 2 $
% " + #! #"
" ! ! *+
- ! - [ !
! *+ D - !
$ ! " P # " Q6 ! !
- E - ! $ 6 ! -
48
1 . 1 V Z"
%0 " B
! : BC
" A ! $
" # " T7
49
1 F ' .
V * *+ =3
9>9