This document summarizes a thesis presentation about using art education to help students with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). The presentation discusses:
- A case study of a first grade student named Scott who was struggling in class and missing assignments.
- Research into how art can help students with ADHD develop skills, self-esteem, and behavior.
- Methods used in working one-on-one with Scott, including adaptations like checklists, choices, discussions, and special supplies.
- Findings that through art interventions Scott showed improved focus, independence, peer interactions, and completion of projects.
1. A case of study of how accommodations to art
education can teach personal strategies, and promote
academic advancement in a student with Attention
Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
Thesis Presentation
Moore College of Art & Design
Allison M. Schellenger
August 9, 2014
2.
Personal Experience
My goal is to develop, define, and utilize teaching strategies
to improve behavior and attention in students displaying
symptoms of ADHD.
Inspiration & Intent
3.
Scott: The Participant
First grader
High energy, loves to
make his classmates
laugh
Throughout the
semester he began
missing more class time
and not completing
assignments.
How could I help?
4.
How can we, as art educators, help students to
overcome negative feelings and behaviors that are
outcomes from their struggle with ADHD?
How can art teachers motivate and build a student’s
confidence through projects in the art room?
Research Questions
5.
Through art, how can art educators develop skills
that translate beyond the art room and improve the
well-being of students with ADHD?
How can we improve a student’s self-concept and
self-esteem through art?
How can we improve a student’s social skills and
behavior? How can we reinforce these skills through
projects utilizing adaptations?
How can educators ensure the emotional well-being
of a student and create a safe space within the art
room to inspire students?
Research Sub-questions
6.
“The mind of individuals
with ADHD as a
symphony where the
complexity of the brain’s
processes and functions
prevents the symphony
from playing as a whole.
In other words, the
conductor is not properly
communicating with the
band” (Brown, 2008).
What is Attention
Deficit Hyperactivity
Disorder?
7.
Students with ADHD often have “the incapacity to accurately
interpret, and then follow established rules required in social
or school situations often results in interpersonal conflicts with
authority figures or peers“(Henley, 1998).
8. “The art classroom can be a place for developing critical
thinking. The difference is in careful consideration of goals
and techniques by applying insights and skills that teachers
develop over the course of their professional lives” (Henley,
2011).
Creating a safe space in the art room.
The art room presents new opportunities to open new forms
of communication and allows students to gain awareness
and ownership of their actions.
Benefits of Art for
Students with ADHD
9.
Greenberg (1999) claims, “Children as well as adults
with ADHD, particularly if undiagnosed and
untreated, develop a number of coping strategies.”
Early intervention to prevent future struggles.
Equip him with his own set of tools to find success in
the classroom.
I believed that he would best benefit from one-on-
one instruction.
Why Choose Scott?
10.
The approach to this case study concentrated on gathering data
on one particular student, the first grader Scott.
My role will be that of an action researcher in the classroom
with a primary art teacher, following their curriculum. I will
work with the student individually. This is to identify
strategies and materials that could possibly keep the student
actively engaged or distracted.
Research Methodology
11. Scott and I met two to three times a week, in class, one-on-
one sessions during school hours, and during his after
school program for 45 minutes.
Interviews
Observations
Artifacts
Photographs
Audio Recordings
Research Methodology
13.
Observing the participant in various classroom settings and on
one-on-one situations allowed me to understand how the
participant behaves and reacts to different teaching styles,
learning environments, and with his peers.
Observations
14.
Data will be collected through artifacts
Student artwork
Photographs of interactions in the classroom and other
work
Artifacts
17.
Utilizing the special supplies made the experience for Scott
unique. Despite the fact his friends were playing at
aftercare, he was able to focus and enjoy the art project due
to the presentation of special tools I gathered just for him to
use.
Special Supplies
19.
First lesson utilizing the “special supplies.”
One-on-one setting
Scott was surprised to have his very own
sketchbook.
Scott’s favorite drawing tools are Sharpies.
“What am I supposed to draw?”
Findings
21.
Findings
Scott displayed an
increased focus, visible
confidence, and a
distinct empowerment
during this lesson.
Unlike prior lessons,
where he was one of
the last students to
begin working, he was
the first to finish the
assignment.
23.
Steps Importance Notes
Discussion/Step given
by teacher: Setup our
table
Choosing our table and
seats helped Scott
control his
environment.
Choose a different table
than the last time, made
sure I had a seat that
the sun was not in our
eyes.
Step #1: Write our
name and classroom
number.
Make the paper his,
help him stay
organized.
Begin to take
ownership of his work.
In-between
discussion/teacher step:
“Can you write the
date?”
To create importance in
each work of art he
creates, and help
associate his work with
other artists.
“When an artist draws
really cool things they
like to remember when
they drew it.”
Step #2: Pick one leaf to
draw.
Another choice allows
him to actively
participate in each step
of the creation process.
Had to go back to study
each lesson to pick
which one was right for
him.
Findings
24.
Question Prompt/Response Purpose
“What do I do?”
“Can I do…?”
“You are the artist, you
decide.”
Help Scott to understand as
long as he is following the
directions and/or checklist,
he can create whatever he
wants.
He has the power to decide
the direction of his art.
Help him take ownership of
his artwork.
“What should… look like?” “Use your imagination.” Usually, Scott would close
his eyes and visualize what
he was supposed to draw.
Allow him to either make-
up or recall what something
looks like.
“What should I do next?” “What do you think you
should do next?”
“What is next on the
checklist?”
Scott was forced to think
critically, and decide what is
next without my help.
Foster independent
thinking.
Findings: Prompts
26.
Findings
Utilized our “special
supplies”
Mixed paints
Recalled information
This lesson shows
growth in Scott’s ability
to work independently.
Shows his creativity
and focus
28.
Pre-Behavior Post-Behavior
Distracts classmates
Pulls classmates away from work
Works with classmates
Positive conversations during lessons
Sent out of the classroom frequently
Misses class and directions
Leads the class
Helps classmates
Used as a positive example by teacher
Trouble remembering or following directions
Needed prompting
Independently works on assignments
Helps classmates remember assignments
steps
Prompts classmates
Rarely finished projects Finished all projects
Assignments completed with greater detail
and thought
Less enthusiastic about work
Unmotivated to begin assignments
Wanted to take work home
Immediately wanted to share work with the
art teacher
Eager to begin work
Does not follow direction
Works through cleanup
Helps others to follow directions and stay
on task
Motivates other students to cleanup
Does extra cleanup
Teacher special helper for handing out
materials or collecting materials
29.
Modification/Strategy Why
Checklist Helped Scott to stay on task
The directions were always visible
Broke down the project step-by-step
Choices Increased Scott’s Involvement in creating art
Gave him ownership on assignments
Discussion of Assignments Made subjects relatable
Broke down creation process
One-On-One Sessions Individualized instruction
Address areas where Scott struggled
Personal Artwork Critique Learn how to feel pride in his artwork
Gain appreciation of creation process
Remember how hard he worked
Use of Empowering Vocabulary Highlight importance of creating artwork
Build confidence
Empower the student
Motivate
Increase productivity
Create positive connections
30.
Overall Findings
Improved Peer Interactions
Increased Classroom Participation
Increased Involvement in the art
process
Active Leader in the Classroom
Positive View of Self
Increased Focus
More Independent
Completion of Projects
31. Utilizing one-on-one sessions, students can learn about
themselves as a student and as an artist.
I have learned that as an educator, for my future
classes, that there is not just a single tool, adaptation,
modification, or strategy we can utilize as educators to
ensure the success of our students, but the
incorporation of these together.
Creating a meaningful and special experience for each
lesson allows students to view assignments as fun,
rather then another assignment.
Plan of Action
32. A big thank you to Scott
for all of his hard work,
dedication, and effort
during this entire process.
Thank you
Editor's Notes
The purpose of this study was to find strategies to help aid students struggling with attention and behavioral problems associated with ADHD. To discover the best practices for art educators to utilize within the classroom to make learning easier and more enjoyable for students who face these challenges. While using these strategies the student was able to become empowered and motivated to create art and enjoy the process.
The inspiration for this research originates from my own experiences as an individual with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), and as a tutor to younger family members and other children with the same diagnosis.
A student with ADHD will display inabilities to pay attention or follow directions, forgetfulness, impulsivity, difficulty with organization, will become frustrated easily, and tend to have mood swings. They appear to struggle with the ability to “self-regulate”.
Behaviors in the classroom can affect:
Classroom participation
Peer interactions
Fidgeting in Seat
Distracts easily and can disengage
Interviews were taken from Scott, his art teacher, his learning specialist and his mother. The purpose behind the interviews were to identify tools and strategies that are successful or unsuccessful for the student.
Simplified, easy to refer to,
Peer Relationships, Leadership Skills & /// several lessons stood out during our time together
Scott was one of the best sewers in the class, and quickly finished his sewing. Rather than playing around like in the past months, he took initiative, and went around the classroom helping his classmates who were struggling. Instead of distracting them from the lesson, Scott was preventing his classmates from falling behind, much like he had in the past. At one point, there was a line of students waiting for his help. This also displayed a large increase in positive peer interactions that was not present before.
Increased focus
The Leaf Study: Discussion of the anatomy of a leaf helped Scott understand what he was drawing and as a result was able to focus and draw a very detailed leaf.
Why? Inspired? What happened Scott’s final project shows his ability to stay on task, despite some distractions. He appeared to be extremely invested in each layer of his collage. He finished the entire project, and was able to recall the specific mixtures to make the missing colored paints. He was confident and directed his own project while not being afraid to take risks with color. He was also brave enough to create his own star shaped flowers. This lesson shows growth in Scott’s ability to work independently. He remembered the directions and was able to experiment with different techniques.