Vermont Yankee to Hanover Rotary

R
Vermont Yankee Hanover NH Rotary Club 24 Mar 2010 Bob Hargraves
Entergy bought Vermont Yankee in 2002 for $180 million. $0.35/watt invested, vs $4/watt today.
Entergy bought Vermont Yankee in 2002 for $180 million. 600 MW x 365 x 24 x 4 cents/kWh x 90% = $189 million revenue.
Vermont Yankee is a 1972 GE 620 MW boiling water reactor.
Vermont Yankee is cooled by river water in winter, cooling towers in summer.
Aug 2007, the cooling tower collapsed.
An EXIT sign is powered by 1 curie of radioactive tritium.
An EXIT sign is powered by 1,000,000,000,000 picocuries.
Human body radioactivity is 100,000 picocuries.
7 Jan 2010  "Laboratory tests of samples taken from this monitoring well have shown tritium levels at 700, 14,500 and 17,000 picocuries per liter"
Drinking 20,000 picocurie/liter water for a year increases your radiation dose 1%. … about the same as one airplane trip.
Vermont Yankee stopped leaks in 2 pipes in tunnel, will fix during May refueling.
Vermont Yankee tritium leaks were relatively small . 2.5 million picocuries per liter l00 gallons/day for year is  0.35 curies (Thanks to Rod Adams at Atomic Insights.)
Vermont Yankee tritium leaks were relatively small . 2.5 million picocuries per liter l00 gallons/day for year is  0.35 curies Canada's nuclear reactors use heavy water and release tritium:  5200 curies . (Thanks to Rod Adams at Atomic Insights.)
Vermont Department of Public Health website is factual, current, and neutral.
Vermont Yankee decommissioning fund lacks money. $320 million in 2002 $347  in 2010 $875  needed Yankee Rowe site
Vermont Yankee decommissioning fund lacks money. $320 million in 2002 $347  in 2010 $875  needed Yankee Rowe site
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7%
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66  (Vt dept nat resources)
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66  (Vt dept nat resources) Methane 351 402,000 cows
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66  (Vt dept nat resources) Methane 351 402,000 cows clouds 100 MW standby natural gas
Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy  GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66  (Vt dept nat resources) Methane 351 402,000 cows clouds 100 MW standby natural gas lulls 670 MW standby natural gas
Follow the money ………………………................ to the Vermont Conservation Law Foundation.
Follow the money from the natural gas industry to the Vermont Conservation Law Foundation. AES CORPORATION Siting a Super Clean Power Plant in New Hampshire  CLF Ventures [ non-profit affiliate  of the Conservation Law Foundation ] assisted the AES Corporation with the siting of a  720 MW combined-cycle natural gas fired power plant  at a proposed eco-industrial park in Londonderry, New Hampshire. 
Vermont's renewable energy programs cost a lot.
Taxpayers and ratepayers subsidize wind and solar. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Taxpayers and ratepayers subsidize wind and solar. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
License renewal will be decided in courts. Federal NRC has safety responsibility. Entergy agreed to Vermont PUC approval of extension. Vermont legislature gave itself approval authority. Vermont state senate voted against extending license.
Energy Policy and Environmental Choices: Rethinking Nuclear Power :  Thursday! Call Dartmouth ILEAD 603 653 0154 to enroll.
Thank you Bob Hargraves
1 of 34

Recommended

NJ Future Forum 2012 Energizing Redevelopment Matos by
NJ Future Forum 2012 Energizing Redevelopment MatosNJ Future Forum 2012 Energizing Redevelopment Matos
NJ Future Forum 2012 Energizing Redevelopment MatosNew Jersey Future
489 views7 slides
Renewables Press Article by
Renewables Press ArticleRenewables Press Article
Renewables Press ArticleBen Davies
72 views1 slide
March 2012 - Michigan Energy Forum - Richard Vander Veen by
March 2012 - Michigan Energy Forum - Richard Vander VeenMarch 2012 - Michigan Energy Forum - Richard Vander Veen
March 2012 - Michigan Energy Forum - Richard Vander VeenAnnArborSPARK
1.7K views10 slides
Elk River Energy City: One City's Attempt to Make a Difference by
Elk River Energy City: One City's Attempt to Make a DifferenceElk River Energy City: One City's Attempt to Make a Difference
Elk River Energy City: One City's Attempt to Make a DifferenceUniversity of Minnesota
724 views27 slides
Why go greena by
Why go greenaWhy go greena
Why go greenagogreena
209 views27 slides
Post globe andrew livingston by
Post globe andrew livingstonPost globe andrew livingston
Post globe andrew livingstonONEIA
284 views14 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

The Growth of Distributed Solar Power by
The Growth of Distributed Solar PowerThe Growth of Distributed Solar Power
The Growth of Distributed Solar PowerHelioVolt
464 views24 slides
April 27 Ut Presentation by
April 27  Ut PresentationApril 27  Ut Presentation
April 27 Ut PresentationIHallberg
493 views24 slides
Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation? by
Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation?Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation?
Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation?ENERGplc
1.6K views23 slides
A Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UK by
A Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UKA Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UK
A Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UKJeremy Leggett
591 views66 slides
4TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_12052007 by
4TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_120520074TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_12052007
4TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_12052007finance26
169 views15 slides
Slideshare -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab... by
Slideshare  -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab...Slideshare  -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab...
Slideshare -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab...Deeply Digital
420 views23 slides

What's hot(19)

The Growth of Distributed Solar Power by HelioVolt
The Growth of Distributed Solar PowerThe Growth of Distributed Solar Power
The Growth of Distributed Solar Power
HelioVolt464 views
April 27 Ut Presentation by IHallberg
April 27  Ut PresentationApril 27  Ut Presentation
April 27 Ut Presentation
IHallberg493 views
Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation? by ENERGplc
Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation?Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation?
Energy Prices Explained: What are Feed-in Tariffs and the Renewables Obligation?
ENERGplc1.6K views
A Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UK by Jeremy Leggett
A Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UKA Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UK
A Green New Deal 2018 - energy and jobs in the UK
Jeremy Leggett591 views
4TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_12052007 by finance26
4TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_120520074TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_12052007
4TTPSCo_Plan_Xcel_Energy_12052007
finance26169 views
Slideshare -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab... by Deeply Digital
Slideshare  -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab...Slideshare  -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab...
Slideshare -energy_prices_explained_what_are_feed-in_tariffs_and_the_renewab...
Deeply Digital420 views
Sunlight solar green needham presentation sep 2010 by Green Needham
Sunlight solar green needham presentation sep 2010Sunlight solar green needham presentation sep 2010
Sunlight solar green needham presentation sep 2010
Green Needham401 views
Residential Solar Presentation by Kevin Ricer
Residential Solar PresentationResidential Solar Presentation
Residential Solar Presentation
Kevin Ricer1.3K views
Desert Research Institute - Science Distilled - Batteries Included by Meghan Collins
Desert Research Institute - Science Distilled - Batteries IncludedDesert Research Institute - Science Distilled - Batteries Included
Desert Research Institute - Science Distilled - Batteries Included
Meghan Collins367 views
Repurposing of west virginia strip mines for sustainable by mabartl
Repurposing of west virginia strip mines for sustainableRepurposing of west virginia strip mines for sustainable
Repurposing of west virginia strip mines for sustainable
mabartl47 views
Piotr nowakowski energy_communities by WinWind Project
Piotr nowakowski energy_communitiesPiotr nowakowski energy_communities
Piotr nowakowski energy_communities
WinWind Project167 views
News 20111017 growth by Paul Keisch
News 20111017 growthNews 20111017 growth
News 20111017 growth
Paul Keisch178 views

Viewers also liked

Lime & Vodka-New by
Lime & Vodka-NewLime & Vodka-New
Lime & Vodka-NewPaul ...
657 views44 slides
Aim High! by
Aim High!Aim High!
Aim High!Robert Hargraves
3.3K views134 slides
Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon Commission by
Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon CommissionLiquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon Commission
Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon CommissionRobert Hargraves
3.1K views32 slides
Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion! by
Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion!Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion!
Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion!Paul ...
686 views42 slides
Financial planning guide 2010 by
Financial planning guide 2010Financial planning guide 2010
Financial planning guide 2010Paul ...
1.6K views48 slides
Liquid Fuel Nuclear Reactors by
Liquid Fuel Nuclear ReactorsLiquid Fuel Nuclear Reactors
Liquid Fuel Nuclear ReactorsRobert Hargraves
21.3K views63 slides

Viewers also liked(14)

Lime & Vodka-New by Paul ...
Lime & Vodka-NewLime & Vodka-New
Lime & Vodka-New
Paul ...657 views
Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon Commission by Robert Hargraves
Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon CommissionLiquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon Commission
Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor Blue Ribbon Commission
Robert Hargraves3.1K views
Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion! by Paul ...
Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion!Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion!
Lime & Vodka-Get High On Fashion!
Paul ...686 views
Financial planning guide 2010 by Paul ...
Financial planning guide 2010Financial planning guide 2010
Financial planning guide 2010
Paul ...1.6K views
Retail Mix Case Study By Larry Kilduff by Paul ...
Retail Mix Case Study By Larry KilduffRetail Mix Case Study By Larry Kilduff
Retail Mix Case Study By Larry Kilduff
Paul ...1.8K views
Survey On Fair Value Disclosures In 10 K by Philip Green
Survey On Fair Value Disclosures In 10 KSurvey On Fair Value Disclosures In 10 K
Survey On Fair Value Disclosures In 10 K
Philip Green378 views

Similar to Vermont Yankee to Hanover Rotary

FCOG Final Deliverable amen by
FCOG Final Deliverable amenFCOG Final Deliverable amen
FCOG Final Deliverable amenJacob Tolman
516 views66 slides
Gas versus Wind as an Energy Source - James by
Gas versus Wind as an Energy Source - JamesGas versus Wind as an Energy Source - James
Gas versus Wind as an Energy Source - JamesHawkesdale P12 College
1.2K views23 slides
North Dakota Department of Commerce by
North Dakota Department of CommerceNorth Dakota Department of Commerce
North Dakota Department of CommercePorts-To-Plains Blog
425 views35 slides
Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ... by
Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ...Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ...
Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ...Sherri Akers
536 views56 slides
PITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdf by
PITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdfPITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdf
PITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdfThane Heins
15 views22 slides
8115630 hydro-power by
8115630 hydro-power8115630 hydro-power
8115630 hydro-powerProbodh Mallick
423 views12 slides

Similar to Vermont Yankee to Hanover Rotary(20)

FCOG Final Deliverable amen by Jacob Tolman
FCOG Final Deliverable amenFCOG Final Deliverable amen
FCOG Final Deliverable amen
Jacob Tolman516 views
Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ... by Sherri Akers
Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ...Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ...
Kevin O'Donnell presentation on buildings and energy from the Wise Power Use ...
Sherri Akers536 views
PITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdf by Thane Heins
PITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdfPITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdf
PITCH DECH - GTAN, Angel One and WECAN Investors - Potential Difference Inc..pdf
Thane Heins15 views
Sanctuary Belize BioMass Energy Proof of Concept by ecologicalfox
Sanctuary Belize BioMass Energy Proof of ConceptSanctuary Belize BioMass Energy Proof of Concept
Sanctuary Belize BioMass Energy Proof of Concept
ecologicalfox768 views
Durable alternatives to coal by Lonnie Gamble
Durable alternatives to coalDurable alternatives to coal
Durable alternatives to coal
Lonnie Gamble323 views
Renewable Energy : The United Kingdom Approach by Gavin Harper
Renewable Energy : The United Kingdom ApproachRenewable Energy : The United Kingdom Approach
Renewable Energy : The United Kingdom Approach
Gavin Harper1.7K views
29 Bauer sustainability project by malwil1944
29 Bauer sustainability project29 Bauer sustainability project
29 Bauer sustainability project
malwil1944202 views
Malcolm Williams by malwil1944
Malcolm WilliamsMalcolm Williams
Malcolm Williams
malwil1944183 views
2009 10 09 Elite Re Info by paul9aber
2009 10 09 Elite Re Info2009 10 09 Elite Re Info
2009 10 09 Elite Re Info
paul9aber198 views
Wind Energy Research Paper by Kendra Cote
Wind Energy Research PaperWind Energy Research Paper
Wind Energy Research Paper
Kendra Cote3 views
2009 05 19 EDK Goldman Sachs Pwr and Utility Conf Final by Edward Kee
2009 05 19 EDK Goldman Sachs Pwr and Utility Conf   Final2009 05 19 EDK Goldman Sachs Pwr and Utility Conf   Final
2009 05 19 EDK Goldman Sachs Pwr and Utility Conf Final
Edward Kee939 views
EcoOne - SolarEnergy Presentation 2014 by EcoOne Homes
EcoOne - SolarEnergy Presentation 2014EcoOne - SolarEnergy Presentation 2014
EcoOne - SolarEnergy Presentation 2014
EcoOne Homes3.8K views

Recently uploaded

"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan Kochan by
"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan Kochan"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan Kochan
"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan KochanFwdays
34 views18 slides
Optimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBM by
Optimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBMOptimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBM
Optimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBMYaman Kumar
38 views49 slides
MVP and prioritization.pdf by
MVP and prioritization.pdfMVP and prioritization.pdf
MVP and prioritization.pdfrahuldharwal141
39 views8 slides
Cencora Executive Symposium by
Cencora Executive SymposiumCencora Executive Symposium
Cencora Executive Symposiummarketingcommunicati21
160 views14 slides
Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit... by
Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit...Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit...
Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit...ShapeBlue
162 views25 slides
Initiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance Strategy by
Initiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance StrategyInitiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance Strategy
Initiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance StrategySafe Software
184 views68 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan Kochan by Fwdays
"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan Kochan"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan Kochan
"Package management in monorepos", Zoltan Kochan
Fwdays34 views
Optimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBM by Yaman Kumar
Optimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBMOptimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBM
Optimizing Communication to Optimize Human Behavior - LCBM
Yaman Kumar38 views
Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit... by ShapeBlue
Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit...Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit...
Transitioning from VMware vCloud to Apache CloudStack: A Path to Profitabilit...
ShapeBlue162 views
Initiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance Strategy by Safe Software
Initiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance StrategyInitiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance Strategy
Initiating and Advancing Your Strategic GIS Governance Strategy
Safe Software184 views
The Power of Generative AI in Accelerating No Code Adoption.pdf by Saeed Al Dhaheri
The Power of Generative AI in Accelerating No Code Adoption.pdfThe Power of Generative AI in Accelerating No Code Adoption.pdf
The Power of Generative AI in Accelerating No Code Adoption.pdf
Saeed Al Dhaheri39 views
Future of AR - Facebook Presentation by Rob McCarty
Future of AR - Facebook PresentationFuture of AR - Facebook Presentation
Future of AR - Facebook Presentation
Rob McCarty65 views
What’s New in CloudStack 4.19 - Abhishek Kumar - ShapeBlue by ShapeBlue
What’s New in CloudStack 4.19 - Abhishek Kumar - ShapeBlueWhat’s New in CloudStack 4.19 - Abhishek Kumar - ShapeBlue
What’s New in CloudStack 4.19 - Abhishek Kumar - ShapeBlue
ShapeBlue265 views
Don’t Make A Human Do A Robot’s Job! : 6 Reasons Why AI Will Save Us & Not De... by Moses Kemibaro
Don’t Make A Human Do A Robot’s Job! : 6 Reasons Why AI Will Save Us & Not De...Don’t Make A Human Do A Robot’s Job! : 6 Reasons Why AI Will Save Us & Not De...
Don’t Make A Human Do A Robot’s Job! : 6 Reasons Why AI Will Save Us & Not De...
Moses Kemibaro35 views
DRaaS using Snapshot copy and destination selection (DRaaS) - Alexandre Matti... by ShapeBlue
DRaaS using Snapshot copy and destination selection (DRaaS) - Alexandre Matti...DRaaS using Snapshot copy and destination selection (DRaaS) - Alexandre Matti...
DRaaS using Snapshot copy and destination selection (DRaaS) - Alexandre Matti...
ShapeBlue141 views
"Node.js Development in 2024: trends and tools", Nikita Galkin by Fwdays
"Node.js Development in 2024: trends and tools", Nikita Galkin "Node.js Development in 2024: trends and tools", Nikita Galkin
"Node.js Development in 2024: trends and tools", Nikita Galkin
Fwdays33 views
The Power of Heat Decarbonisation Plans in the Built Environment by IES VE
The Power of Heat Decarbonisation Plans in the Built EnvironmentThe Power of Heat Decarbonisation Plans in the Built Environment
The Power of Heat Decarbonisation Plans in the Built Environment
IES VE84 views
Business Analyst Series 2023 - Week 4 Session 8 by DianaGray10
Business Analyst Series 2023 -  Week 4 Session 8Business Analyst Series 2023 -  Week 4 Session 8
Business Analyst Series 2023 - Week 4 Session 8
DianaGray10145 views
Enabling DPU Hardware Accelerators in XCP-ng Cloud Platform Environment - And... by ShapeBlue
Enabling DPU Hardware Accelerators in XCP-ng Cloud Platform Environment - And...Enabling DPU Hardware Accelerators in XCP-ng Cloud Platform Environment - And...
Enabling DPU Hardware Accelerators in XCP-ng Cloud Platform Environment - And...
ShapeBlue108 views
Why and How CloudStack at weSystems - Stephan Bienek - weSystems by ShapeBlue
Why and How CloudStack at weSystems - Stephan Bienek - weSystemsWhy and How CloudStack at weSystems - Stephan Bienek - weSystems
Why and How CloudStack at weSystems - Stephan Bienek - weSystems
ShapeBlue247 views
Webinar : Desperately Seeking Transformation - Part 2: Insights from leading... by The Digital Insurer
Webinar : Desperately Seeking Transformation - Part 2:  Insights from leading...Webinar : Desperately Seeking Transformation - Part 2:  Insights from leading...
Webinar : Desperately Seeking Transformation - Part 2: Insights from leading...

Vermont Yankee to Hanover Rotary

  • 1. Vermont Yankee Hanover NH Rotary Club 24 Mar 2010 Bob Hargraves
  • 2. Entergy bought Vermont Yankee in 2002 for $180 million. $0.35/watt invested, vs $4/watt today.
  • 3. Entergy bought Vermont Yankee in 2002 for $180 million. 600 MW x 365 x 24 x 4 cents/kWh x 90% = $189 million revenue.
  • 4. Vermont Yankee is a 1972 GE 620 MW boiling water reactor.
  • 5. Vermont Yankee is cooled by river water in winter, cooling towers in summer.
  • 6. Aug 2007, the cooling tower collapsed.
  • 7. An EXIT sign is powered by 1 curie of radioactive tritium.
  • 8. An EXIT sign is powered by 1,000,000,000,000 picocuries.
  • 9. Human body radioactivity is 100,000 picocuries.
  • 10. 7 Jan 2010 "Laboratory tests of samples taken from this monitoring well have shown tritium levels at 700, 14,500 and 17,000 picocuries per liter"
  • 11. Drinking 20,000 picocurie/liter water for a year increases your radiation dose 1%. … about the same as one airplane trip.
  • 12. Vermont Yankee stopped leaks in 2 pipes in tunnel, will fix during May refueling.
  • 13. Vermont Yankee tritium leaks were relatively small . 2.5 million picocuries per liter l00 gallons/day for year is 0.35 curies (Thanks to Rod Adams at Atomic Insights.)
  • 14. Vermont Yankee tritium leaks were relatively small . 2.5 million picocuries per liter l00 gallons/day for year is 0.35 curies Canada's nuclear reactors use heavy water and release tritium: 5200 curies . (Thanks to Rod Adams at Atomic Insights.)
  • 15. Vermont Department of Public Health website is factual, current, and neutral.
  • 16. Vermont Yankee decommissioning fund lacks money. $320 million in 2002 $347 in 2010 $875 needed Yankee Rowe site
  • 17. Vermont Yankee decommissioning fund lacks money. $320 million in 2002 $347 in 2010 $875 needed Yankee Rowe site
  • 18. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008
  • 19. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7%
  • 20. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines
  • 21. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For
  • 22. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion
  • 23. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66 (Vt dept nat resources)
  • 24. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66 (Vt dept nat resources) Methane 351 402,000 cows
  • 25. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66 (Vt dept nat resources) Methane 351 402,000 cows clouds 100 MW standby natural gas
  • 26. Vermont Public Interest Research Group's solution is unrealistic. Energy GWH/yr Reality Total 5,864 2008 Efficiency - 2.5% + 2.7% Wind 1,642 + 268 2.5 MW turbines Wood 938 2X area of Green Mt Nat For Solar 880 + $7 billion Hydro 351 + 66 (Vt dept nat resources) Methane 351 402,000 cows clouds 100 MW standby natural gas lulls 670 MW standby natural gas
  • 27. Follow the money ………………………................ to the Vermont Conservation Law Foundation.
  • 28. Follow the money from the natural gas industry to the Vermont Conservation Law Foundation. AES CORPORATION Siting a Super Clean Power Plant in New Hampshire  CLF Ventures [ non-profit affiliate of the Conservation Law Foundation ] assisted the AES Corporation with the siting of a 720 MW combined-cycle natural gas fired power plant at a proposed eco-industrial park in Londonderry, New Hampshire. 
  • 29. Vermont's renewable energy programs cost a lot.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32. License renewal will be decided in courts. Federal NRC has safety responsibility. Entergy agreed to Vermont PUC approval of extension. Vermont legislature gave itself approval authority. Vermont state senate voted against extending license.
  • 33. Energy Policy and Environmental Choices: Rethinking Nuclear Power : Thursday! Call Dartmouth ILEAD 603 653 0154 to enroll.
  • 34. Thank you Bob Hargraves