Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Lengkap Indeksasi Jurnal dan Faktor Dampak

2,200 views

Published on

Lengkap Indeksasi Jurnal dan Faktor Dampak
Mochammad Tanzil Multazam
relawanojs@gmail.com

Published in: Education
  • Be the first to comment

Lengkap Indeksasi Jurnal dan Faktor Dampak

  1. 1. Indeksasi Jurnal dan Faktor Dampak (V.02) Mochammad Tanzil Multazam, M.Kn. https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6373-1199 Ka. P3I UMSIDA, ORCID dan Crossref Ambassador Asia Tim Ahli Relawan Jurnal Indonesia
  2. 2. MATERI Infrastruktur Jurnal Ilmiah Online Tipe Lembaga Pengindeks Academic Repository Impact Factor Google Scholar Metrics, DOAJ, Scopus, and WoS.
  3. 3. •INFRASTRUKTUR JURNAL ILMIAH ONLINE
  4. 4. Infrastruktur Jurnal Ilmiah Online eLife- Continuum PKP-OJS Drupal- eJournal OPS DataCite Crossref DOI Online https://porta l.issn.org/ ISSN
  5. 5. Persistent Identifier PID Author PID Affiliation PID Article and Data
  6. 6. Personal •Proprietary ID •Universal ID Institution •Ringgold •Fundref material •digital object: DOI, handle, ARK, PURLs, URNs, Permalink(perma.cc, webcite, archive.is) XRIs. •non digital object: ISSN, ISBN, ISTC, ISWC, ISRC, ISAN. Persistent Identifier
  7. 7. Personal Persistent Identifier Universal ID ISNI ORCID Prepriatory ID Scopus ID (not unique)(Elsevier) Researcher ID (unique) (Thomson) Loop ID (unique) (frontier and nature)
  8. 8. ORCID Source: Chris Chan ORCID @ HKBU, http://hkbu.libguides.com/c.php?g=159326&p=1042873
  9. 9. • ]
  10. 10. Crossref (Non Profit Org.) Scholarly content (Published): Journals, books, proceedings, etc Member is Publisher, University, Research Institution. Datacite (Non Profit Org.) Dataset Member is Repository, Data Center, and other organization that hold data (except publisher) Material: DOI (two common registration agency)
  11. 11. Contoh Sitasi Data
  12. 12. Wujud DOI
  13. 13. •TIPE LEMBAGA PENGINDEX
  14. 14. Misleading metrics • CiteFactor • Digital Identification Database System (DIDS) • Directory of Research Journals Indexing (DRJI) • Eurasian Scientific Journal Index (ESJI) • Global Impact Factor • Index Scientific Journals (ISJ) • Infobase Index • Institute for Science Information (ISI) • International Scientific Indexing (ISI) • Journals Impact Factor (JIFACTOR) • JPR Impact Factor • RJI Factor (Research Journal Impact Factor) • Science Impact Factor • Scientific Indexing Services (SIS) • Scientific Journal Impact Factor • SCIJOURNAL.ORG (International Scientific Institute) • Universal Impact Factor
  15. 15. Kriteria misleading metrics----J. Beall • Informasi website tidak jelas (tim, yang bertanggung jawab sampai pada tata cara penghitungan) • Berbayar agar bisa masuk di list • Score tiap jurnal naik tiap tahun • Pakai google scholar sebagai database penghitungan • Pakai term “impat factor” untuk jurnal score-nya • Metodologi yang digunakan tidak bisa dipertanggung jawabkan, tidak ilmiah dan tidak original.
  16. 16. Contoh questioned journal.
  17. 17. Contoh Questioned Journal (www.ijeat.org)
  18. 18. Contoh Questioned Journal
  19. 19. Level Jurnal Nasional Berdasarkan Pemerintah Jurnal Nasional • Ber-ISSN (media online) • Mudah ditelusuri online • Penulis/Reviewer/Editor dari berbagai institusi di Indonesia setiap terbit • Terindeks di Pengindeks kelas menengah Jurnal Nasional Terakreditasi • Syarat pada Jurnal Nasional • Terakreditasi Jurnal Nasional Bereputasi • Syarat pada jurnal Nasional • Terindeks DOAJ ber- Green Tick • Berbahasa PBB • Ber-DOI PAK DIKTI 2014 + Permenristekdikti 20 2017 + BUKU PANDUAN PAK DIKTI TERBARU
  20. 20. Level Jurnal Internasional Berdasarkan Pemerintah Jurnal Internasional • Ber-ISSN • Penulis min. 2 negara berbeda setiap terbit • Editor dan Reviewer berbagai Negara • Berbahasa PBB • Terindeks di Lembaga Pengindeks Menengah atau Tinggi Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi • Ber-ISSN • Penulis min. 2 negara berbeda setiap terbit • Editor dan Reviewer berbagai Negara • Berbahasa PBB • Terindeks di Lembaga Pengindeks Tinggi • Memiliki Faktor Dampak PAK DIKTI 2014 + Permenristekdikti 20 2017 + BUKU PANDUAN PAK DIKTI TERBARU
  21. 21. Penyetaraan Penyetaraan Jurnal Internasional •Jurnal Nasional Terakreditasi B •Berbahasa PBB •Terindeks DOAJ ber Green Tick Penyetaraan Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi •Jurnal Nasional Terakreditasi A •Berbahasa PBB •Terindeks DOAJ ber Green Tick PAK DIKTI 2014 + Permenristekdikti 20 2017 + BUKU PANDUAN PAK DIKTI TERBARU
  22. 22. Pembagian Lembaga Pengindeks (Berdasar Aturan Akreditasi) • Google Scholar, ISJD, IPI, World Cat, Moraref dan yang setara. • Tidak menggunakan kualifikasi tertentu agar bisa terindeksRendah • DOAJ, REPEC. ERIC, PubMed, EBSCO, Web of Science (ESCI) dan yang setara, • Memerlukan seleksi kebijakan dan seleksi formal lainnya Menengah • SCOPUS. Web of Science (SSCI, SCIE), dan yang setara • Memerlukan seleksi konten dan kebijakan jurnalTinggi
  23. 23. Google Scholar Penulis “Untuk Jurnal” (Karena Kebutuhan Akreditasi dan SINTA) https://scholar.google.com
  24. 24. Journal Title Database Bibliographic Database Bibliographic and Citation Database Bibliographic and Fulltext Database Bibliographic, Fulltext and Citation Database Open Access Journal Policy Database Pembagian Lembaga Pengindeks (Berdasar Data yang diindeks)
  25. 25. Export XML/File bentuk lain : DOAJ, Scopus, WoS, IndexCopernicus OAI : BASE, World Cat, OpenAire, IPI, Journal ToC. Web Crawl :Google Scholar, Microsoft Academic Search. Pembagian Lembaga Pengindeks (Berdasar Cara Mendapatkan Data)
  26. 26. Journal Title Database • Genamics : http://journalseek.net/contactus.htm • SciJournal : http://www.scijournal.org/journal/ • Academic Keys : http://business.academickeys.com/res_main.php • Journal Guide : https://www.journalguide.com/ • EconBiz (Economic Literature) : https://www.econbiz.de/eb/en/contact-us/suggest-a-journal/ • EBSCO A to Z ; Terindeks otomatis setelah masuk DOAJ • ROAD : http://road.issn.org/en/contenu/contact#.WT-RDdyyTIU
  27. 27. Bibliographic Database • Indonesia OneSearch : http://onesearch.id/Repositories/Flowchart • DOAJ : https://doaj.org/application/new (Kriteria) • JournalTOCs : http://www.journaltocs.ac.uk/suggest.php • Moraref : http://moraref.or.id/pages/view/register • OpenAire : https://www.openaire.eu/validator/go2login.action • REPEC (Economics) : https://ideas.repec.org/stepbystep.html • WorldCat : https://www.oclc.org/en/digital-gateway/getting-started.html • BASE : https://www.base-search.net/about/en/suggest.php • SciLit : http://www.scilit.net/registration • JournalTOCs : https://www.journaltocs.ac.uk/suggest.php#selection • ERIC (Education) : https://eric.ed.gov/submit/ • Pubmed/MEDLINE : https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/publisherportal/ (CRITERIA) • Asean Citation Index : http://www.kmutt.ac.th/jif/ACI/suggest.php (CRITERIA) • ResearchBib: https://www.researchbib.com/?action=editRegister
  28. 28. DOAJ Green Tick
  29. 29. DOAJ Seal
  30. 30. Bibliographic and Citation Database • Google Scholar : 1. https://partnerdash.google.com/partnerdash/d/scholarinclusions#p:id=n ew 2. https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools • Web of Science : ESCI, SSCI, SCIE, AHCI, CPCI. http://mjl.clarivate.com/ • Scopus : http://suggestor.step.scopus.com/suggestTitle/step1.cfm • Microsoft Academic Search : https://www.bing.com/toolbox/webmaster • Index Copernicus https://journals.indexcopernicus.com/app/registration/form
  31. 31. Web of Science (Clarivate Analytic) • SCIE : http://ip-science.thomsonreuters.com/cgi- bin/jrnlst/jloptions.cgi?PC=D • SSCI : http://ip-science.thomsonreuters.com/cgi- bin/jrnlst/jloptions.cgi?PC=SS • ESCI : http://ip-science.thomsonreuters.com/cgi- bin/jrnlst/jloptions.cgi?PC=EX • AHCI : http://ip-science.thomsonreuters.com/cgi- bin/jrnlst/jloptions.cgi?PC=H
  32. 32. Web of Science
  33. 33. Web Of Science Core Collection Book Citation Index - S Book Citation Index - SSH Impact Factor data metrics source ESCI CPCI-SSH CPCI-S AHCI Impact Factor (JCR) SCIE SSCI http://wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/
  34. 34. Bibliographic and Fulltext Database • AgEcon (Applied Economic) (admin by Univ. of Minnesota) : https://ageconsearch.tind.io/static/participate.html • Indonesia Publication Index : http://portalgaruda.org/?ref=home&mod=newsuggest • Econstor (Economics and Business Studies) : https://www.econstor.eu/pubinfo/institutions • Proquest : http://www.proquest.com/about/publishers-partners/ atau kontak personal • EBSCOhost : https://www.ebsco.com/publishers-partnerships/full-text-databases • Project Muse : http://muse.jhu.edu/cgi-bin/journal_submission_form.cgi • CoRE: https://core.ac.uk/contact • JSTOR : http://about.jstor.org/publishers/contribute-content/journals/submit-journal- content/
  35. 35. Bibliographic, Fulltext and Citation Database oISJD ?? oArsip Jurnal Indonesia?? oIPI ??
  36. 36. Open Access Journal Policy Database • Sherpa/Romeo http://www.sherpa.ac.uk/romeo/index.php
  37. 37. Journal Profile in Sherpa Romeo
  38. 38. •FAKTOR DAMPAK
  39. 39. Faktor Dampak (Ranking Journal) •H-Index= Based most cited paper and and number citation in other publication •I10-Index= Number publication with at least 10 citation •H5-Median= for a publication is the median number of citations for the articles that make up its h5-index •H5-Index= h-index for articles published in the last 5 complete years. It is the largest number h such that h articles published in 2012-2016 have at least h citations each Google Scholar Metrics • Citescore = Calculate Citation from all document in year one to all documents in prior three years for a title • Scimago >>> SJR (Scimago Journal Ranking), SNIP (Source Normalized Impact per Paper) Scopus •Impact Factor The calculation is based on a two-year period and involves dividing the number of times articles were cited by the number of articles that are citable. •5-Year Impact Factor = dividing by source item in previous five year Web of Science (Clarivate Analytic)
  40. 40. Citescore http://journalmetrics.scopus.com/
  41. 41. Scimago http://www.scimagojr.com
  42. 42. Scimago (cont)
  43. 43. Impact Factor (Clarivate Analytic)
  44. 44. Impact Factor (Clarivate Analytic)
  45. 45. •ACADEMIC REPOSITORY
  46. 46. Pre-Print And Post-Print pre-prints = the version of the paper before peer review post-prints = the version of the paper after peer-review, with revisions having been made. http://www.sherpa.ac.uk/romeo/definitions.php?la=en&fIDnum=|& mode=simple&version=#prepostprints
  47. 47. Academic Repository Institutional Repository Personal Repository
  48. 48. Institutional Repository • UNAND Repository • UMSIDA Repository • UNDIP Repository • Menggunakan Dspace, Eprint, etc
  49. 49. Personal Repository • Figshare • Researchgate • AcademiaEdu • SSRN • Mendeley Data • DataDryad • Open Science Framework • Zenodo • Dataverse
  50. 50. •Google Scholar Metrics, WoS, dan Scopus Criteria
  51. 51. TOP 100 Indonesia Google Scholar Metrics
  52. 52. Rumus Scholar Metrics
  53. 53. Cara Masuk
  54. 54. Karakteristik TOP 100 Google Scholar Metric a. Mengklasifikasi berdasar bahasa artikel (Contoh. Jurnal Atom dan telkomnika karena berbasa inggris tidak masuk di top 100 Indonesia) Jadi untuk mencari Metric jurnal tersebut memakai menu searc pada scholar metric. b. Menghitung berdasar artikel yang disitasi dari 5 tahun terakhir. (contoh. Jurnal Mimbar Hukum Memiliki sitasi yang banyak namun hanya sedikit yang dari 5 tahun terakhir) Karakteristik TOP in Research Area a. Sementara hanya jurnal berbahasa inggris yang muncul.
  55. 55. 1. Pastikan artikel metadata benar ketika publish (terutama Judul, Abstrak, Referensi, Tahun Terbit, dan Nama Jurnal) 2. Jika terbitkan back issue (cetak ke online). Perhatikan metadata tahun terbit tiap artikel dan terbitan. Ganti dengan tahun aslinya. Karena by default akan berganti ke tahun sekarang, Kesalahan di poin ini bisa berakibat tidak bisa masuk ke Scholar Metric karena dihitung tahun pertama. Hal yang perlu diperhatikan
  56. 56. Article Metadata
  57. 57. Issue Metadata
  58. 58. DOAJ Basic Criteria https://doaj.org/publishers#advice • Coverage: • Subject: all scientific and scholarly subjects are covered in DOAJ. • Types of resource: scientific and scholarly periodicals that publish research or review papers in full text. • Acceptable sources: academic, government, commercial, non-profit and private sources are all acceptable. • Level: the primary target group should be researchers. If the journal is run by a student body, the journal must have an advisory board of which at least two members have a PhD or equivalent. • Content: at least a third of the content should consist of original research and/or review papers. All content should be available in full text on the site without embargo.
  59. 59. Access: • The full text of ALL content must be available for free and be Open Access without delay (i.e. no embargo period). This is a basic requirement for entry into DOAJ. • A charge may exist for a print version of the journal. • User registration is not acceptable and journals requiring users to register to read full text are not accepted into DOAJ. • One URL per site. One dedicated page to the journal. • One unique URL per article. One HTML entry or PDF per article. DOAJ Basic Criteria (cont.)
  60. 60. • All the journal's aims and scope, the editorial board, the instructions for authors, the description of the quality control system, the Open Access statement, the plagiarism policy, and the licensing terms) must be hosted on this same site and not be held centrally on another web site. • All the journal content that the publisher is including in the application must be in one place and not spread over various locations. • A journal's homepage must contain clear navigation with links to a Current Issue, the Archive or Past Issues, Search, Browse, the About page, the Editorial Board and Contact Us. • A journal must have an editor and an editorial board . The following information must be made available on the Editorial Board page: the name and affiliation of the editorial board members. DOAJ Basic Criteria (cont.)
  61. 61. • Every journal must display clearly on its web site information regarding Peer Review Process and Publication Charges • Licensing your material with a CC license. • Clear author guidelines include: 1. A detailed style guide; 2. A description of the quality control processes; 3. Information about copyright (please note the importance of informing authors about whether the journal will be the copyright holder after publication of an article or if the copyright remains with the author(s). We strongly believe that authors should be informed about your copyright/licensing conditions before they submit their work); 4. the plagiarism policy; 5. description of how to submit an article; 6. a contact email address. DOAJ Basic Criteria (cont.)
  62. 62. Scopus • Titles will only be considered for evaluation if they meet the following minimum criteria: ►The title should publish peer reviewed content. ►The title should be published on a regular basis (i.e. have an ISSN that has been confirmed by the ISSN International Centre). To register an ISSN, please visit this page. ►The title should have English language abstracts and article titles. ►The title should have references in Roman script. ►The title should have a publication ethics and publication malpractice statement.
  63. 63. Journal policy • Convincing editorial policy • Type of peer review • Diversity in geographical distribution of editors << PALING SUSAH 1 • Diversity in geographical distribution of authors << PALING SUSAH 2 Quality of content • Academic contribution to the field • Clarity of abstracts • Quality and conformity with stated aims & scope • Readability of articles Journal standing •Citedness of journal articles in Scopus ,<<< PALING SUSAH 3 •Editor standing Regularity •No delays or interruptions in the publication schedule Online availability •Full journal content available online •English language journal home page available •Quality of journal home page
  64. 64. Pengecekan citedness di scopus (contoh jurnal emitter. UPDATE tanggal 13 Juli 2017)
  65. 65. Tahapan • Buka scopus.com dan login • Gunakan pencarian dokumen • Isi dengan nama jurnal • Ganti cakupan pencarian dengan “Source Title”. Tekan search • Klik “view secondary documents” pojok kanan atas.
  66. 66. Pilih 9 Artikel Terbaik yang akan dinilai Scopus Editorial Board
  67. 67. Scopus Re- Evaluation Criteria
  68. 68. Scopus Re- Evaluation Criteria (cont.)
  69. 69. WoS Selection Criteria for ESCI Focused on consideration of Publishing Standards and Editorial Content. These include the following: •Peer review. •Ethical publishing practices. •Electronic format. •English language bibliographic •Recommendation or request for coverage by Web of Science users.
  70. 70. WoS Selection Criteria (SSCI, AHCI, SCIE) • Publishing Standards • Editorial Content • International Focus • Citation Analysis http://wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/
  71. 71. Publishing Standards • Ethical Publishing Practices • Publishing Format • Timeliness • International Editorial Conventions • Full Text English
  72. 72. Ethical Publishing Practices • Evidence of unethical policies such as predatory publishing practices or editorial instructions leading to excessive, inauthentic journal self-citation or any other fraudulent practices are not acceptable in any journal under evaluation and result in immediate rejection.
  73. 73. Timeliness • To measure timeliness we need to see three consecutive current issues, one after another, as soon as they are published online or in print.
  74. 74. International Editorial Conventions • informative journal titles, fully descriptive article titles and author abstracts, complete bibliographic information for all cited references, and full address information for every author.
  75. 75. Editorial Content • Our editors determine if the content of a journal under evaluation will enrich the database or if the topic is already adequately addressed in existing coverage.
  76. 76. International Focus • Editors look for international diversity among the journal’s contributing authors, editors, and editorial advisory board members at a level that is appropriate for the journal’s target audience.
  77. 77. Citation Analysis (Citedness) • citation history of contributing authors and editorial board members • Citation history of journal in Web of Science
  78. 78. Pertanyaan??

×