ICPW2007.deLeenheerChristiaens

1,695 views

Published on

Published in: Technology, Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
1,695
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
41
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
47
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

ICPW2007.deLeenheerChristiaens

  1. 1. Mind the Gap! Transcending the Tunnel View on Ontology Engineering Pieter De Leenheer Stijn Christiaens Pragmatic Web 2007 (Tilburg, NL)
  2. 2. Realistic Scenario: http://www.codrive.org/ ONTOLOGY Job Provider (Industry) crystalise competency product job Public Employment skill workflow Agencies Educational Institutes http://cvc.ehb.be/PoCeHRMOM/Frameset.htm http://www.prolixproject.org/
  3. 3. Competency Map HR-XML consortium: “an RCD is a specific, dentifiable, definable, and measurable knowledge, skill, ability and/or other deployment-related characteristic (e.g. attitude, behavior, physical ability) which a human resource may possess and which is necessary for, or material to, the performance of an activity within a specific business context.”
  4. 4. The Gap delivery#1 delivery#2 delivery msg what is delivery ? delivery is a type of educational task
  5. 5. Towards Community-based Evolution
  6. 6. Requirements for Semiotics Engineering • Constructive methodology • Variability and reusability • Application-specific Contextualisation • Flexible Operationalisation
  7. 7. SOCIALISATION delivery#1 delivery#2 delivery msg what is delivery ? delivery is a type of educational task EXTERNALISATION / INTERNALISATION individual mental models community-shared models COMBINATION
  8. 8. Lexon building blocks Context Role Co-role ! = university Jury Thesis evaluates / evaluated by Head-term Tail-term
  9. 9. DOGMA Layers Reusable Lexon (Domain- specific) Applications Base Base Commitment Layer Jury Thesis Person Name Person Name Person Car Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName Man Woman PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameName PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name Person Person Name Person Name Lorem Dotis PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person Person Name Person Name PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person Person Name Person Name PersonPerson NameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person Name Person Name PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person Person Name Person Name PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person Person Name Person Name PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person Person Name Person Name Person Name Name Person Name Name PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person Person Person Person Name Name Person Name Name PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person Person Person Person Name Name Person Name Name PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person Name NameName Person Person Person Person Name Person Name Ipsum Thesis PersonPerson PersonPerson NameNameName Person NameName NameNameName Person Name Person Person Person NameName NameNameName Person PersonPerson PersonPerson Person Person Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name PersonPerson NameNameName PersonPerson NameNameName Person NameNameName NameNameName Person Person Person NameNameName NameNameName Person Person Person Person PersonPerson PersonPerson Person Person Person Person Person NameNameName NameName Person NameNameName NameNameDrink Person Person Person Person Address PersonCoffee Person Person Person NameNameName NameName Person NameNameName NameName Person Person Person Person Person Person Person Person Person NameNameName NameName Person NameNameName NameName Person Person Person Name Person Person Person Person Person Person Person NameNameName NameName Person NameName Name Person Person Person Person NameName Person Person Person Person Person NameNameName NameName Person NameName Name Person Person Person Person Person Name Person Person Person Name Person Person Person NameNameNameName NameName Person NameNameName Name Person PersonPerson Person Person Name Person Person Person Car Name Name Person Man Person NameNameNameName Name Person NameNameName Name Person Person PersonPerson Woman Person Name Person Person Person Person NameNameNameName Name Person NameNameName Name Person PersonPerson Person Person Name Person Person Person Person NameNameNameName Name Person NameNameName Name Person PersonPerson Person Person Name Person Person Person Person NameNameNameName Name Person NameNameName Name Person PersonPerson Person Person Name Person Person Person Person NameNameNameName Name Person NameNameName Person Jury Thesis PersonPerson Person Person Person Name Person Person NameNameNameNameName Name Person Person NameNameNameNameName Name Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPerson Person Person Person NameNameNameNameNameMouse Person Person NameNameNameNameName Wine Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPersonPerson Person Computer PersonYear Person NameNameNameNameName Person NameNameNameNameName Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPerson Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPerson Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPerson Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPerson Person NameNameNameNameNameName Person Person Name Person Person NameNameNameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPerson Person Person Person NameNameNameNameNameName Person NameNameNameNameName Name Person PersonPersonPerson PersonPerson Person Person Person Person Computer Desktop Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName PersonPersonPerson Person Lorem Ipsum Person Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName PersonPersonPerson Person Person Person Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName PersonPersonPerson Person Person Person Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName PersonPersonPerson Person Person Person Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName PersonPersonPerson Person Person Person Person Person NameNameNameNameName Person Person NameNameNameNameName PersonPersonPerson Person Person Person Person Person Car Person Person Person OS Computer PersonPerson NameNameNameName Person NameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson NameNameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson NameNameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson NameNameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameNameName Jury Thesis Person Person PersonPersonPerson NameNameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonPerson NameNameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameNameName Person Person PersonPersonEngine NameNameName Car Person PersonAnimal NameNameName Mammal Person Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person PersonPerson NameNameName Person Person Address NameName Person Person PersonCoffee NameNameDrink Person Person NameName Person NameName Person Person Person NameName Person NameName Person Person Person NameName Person NameName Person Person Person NameName Person NameName Person Person Person NameName Person NameName Jury Soccer Person Car Person Man NameName Woman Person Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Person Name Computer Mouse Year Wine Control Thesis Jury Person Party Thesis “Double articulation principle”
  10. 10. Analysing Communication Breakdown delivery msg Job Seeker Employer what is delivery ? ROOT delivery is a type of educational task Process Quality Educational Task Punctual Competence Skill Attitude Deliver
  11. 11. Context Dependency Management GLOSS = quot;a required work that students must masterquot; SYNSET= {educational GLOSS = quot;a person who work} acts and gets things donequot; SYNSET= {doer, worker} TEMPLATE TAXONOMY exhibiting / exhibited by ROOT Educational Quality Task APP Process Quality Actor Actor performed by / performing Educational Competence Competence Task requiring / required for
  12. 12. Sample Conflict (i) TEMPLATE TEMPLATE exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Educational Educational Quality Competence Task Task SPE SPE SPECIALISATION SPECIALISATION specialiseDifferentia exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Deliver Skill Deliver Skill ROOT changeDifferentiaToSibling Process Quality TEMPLATE TEMPLATE exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Educational Educational Quality Competence Task Task Educational Task Punctual Competence SPE SPE SPECIALISATION SPECIALISATION exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Skill Attitude Deliver Punctual Deliver Punctual Deliver
  13. 13. Sample Conflict (ii) TEMPLATE TEMPLATE exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Educational Educational Quality Competence Task Task SPE SPE SPECIALISATION SPECIALISATION specialiseDifferentia exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Deliver Skill Deliver Skill ROOT Process Quality changeDifferentiaToSibling Educational Task Punctual Competence Skill Attitude Deliver TEMPLATE TEMPLATE exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Educational Educational Quality Competence Task Task SPE SPE SPECIALISATION SPECIALISATION exhibiting / exhibited by exhibiting / exhibited by Deliver Punctual Deliver Punctual
  14. 14. DOGMA Studio demo movies • please visit: • http://www.starlab.vub.ac.be/website/ dogmastudio
  15. 15. DOGMA Studio
  16. 16. Towards Community-based Evolution of K-IS 1 Communication Analysis 2 Community Modelling 3 Negotiation and Argumentation 4 Knowledge Analysis and Evolution
  17. 17. Recommended Reading

×