Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Reading creationism in the web
archive: a utopian dream, a
conspiracy theory and a moral
panic
Peter Webster
Webster Resea...
Creationism ?
• non-evolutionary account of human
origins
• modern
• a long history
• a feature of some parts of evangelic...
Three questions
A justified conspiracy theory about
marginalisation of creationist voices?
A real danger or a moral panic ...
Data: UK Host Link
Graph (1996-2010)
1996 | appserver.ed.ac.uk | portico.bl.uk 1
1996 | art-www.acorn.co.uk | portico.bl.u...
Approach
• selection of key UK creationist sites
• extraction of all unique inbound referring
hosts for 1996-2010
• inspec...
Caveats on method
• partial nature of the dataset
• benchmarking of absolute numbers
• selective sample
• what does a link...
Truth in Science: how
significant?
• only 46 unique inbound hosts
• … of which many were other creationists
or secularist ...
Conclusions
• a utopian dream unfulfilled
• a genuine moral panic
• a justified conspiracy theory?
Questions ?
Peter Webster
peter@websterresearchconsulting.com
@pj_webster
peterwebster.me
websterresearchconsulting.com
Reading creationism in the web archive: a utopian dream, a conspiracy theory and a moral panic
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Reading creationism in the web archive: a utopian dream, a conspiracy theory and a moral panic

935 views

Published on

Slides for a paper given at the ReSAW conference 'Web Archives as Scholarly Sources', Aarhus (Denmark), June 2015

Published in: Internet
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Reading creationism in the web archive: a utopian dream, a conspiracy theory and a moral panic

  1. 1. Reading creationism in the web archive: a utopian dream, a conspiracy theory and a moral panic Peter Webster Webster Research and Consulting @pj_webster
  2. 2. Creationism ? • non-evolutionary account of human origins • modern • a long history • a feature of some parts of evangelicalism • (anti-evolutionism, Intelligent Design)
  3. 3. Three questions A justified conspiracy theory about marginalisation of creationist voices? A real danger or a moral panic (Truth in Science) ? The web as friend of the marginalised opinion?
  4. 4. Data: UK Host Link Graph (1996-2010) 1996 | appserver.ed.ac.uk | portico.bl.uk 1 1996 | art-www.acorn.co.uk | portico.bl.uk 1 1996 | astra.ich.ucl.ac.uk | portico.bl.uk 1 1996 | back.niss.ac.uk | portico.bl.uk 1 1996 | beta.bids.ac.uk | portico.bl.uk 2 19GB, available at: http://tinyurl.com/kon2eve
  5. 5. Approach • selection of key UK creationist sites • extraction of all unique inbound referring hosts for 1996-2010 • inspection and classification
  6. 6. Caveats on method • partial nature of the dataset • benchmarking of absolute numbers • selective sample • what does a link mean, anyway ? • not looking at number of linking resources per host
  7. 7. Truth in Science: how significant? • only 46 unique inbound hosts • … of which many were other creationists or secularist sites • two churches, one school • fewer in 2010 than 2007
  8. 8. Conclusions • a utopian dream unfulfilled • a genuine moral panic • a justified conspiracy theory?
  9. 9. Questions ? Peter Webster peter@websterresearchconsulting.com @pj_webster peterwebster.me websterresearchconsulting.com

×