Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Understanding cross-border
religion in the Irish web
Dr Peter Webster
Webster Research and Consulting
@pj_webster / @Webst...
One island, two nations
Counties of Ireland, north and south
(Wikimedia Commons)
CC-BY-SA 3.0
A unique mix of faith and politics?
Ian Paisley and Edward Carson, Stormont (1985)
(Burns Library, Boston College, CC-BY-N...
Cross-border religion?
• Historic Christian denominations: RC,
Presbyterian (PCI), Church of Ireland,
Methodist, Baptist
•...
All-Ireland religion
Church of Ireland dioceses
(CoI, via Wikimedia Commons)
CC-BY-SA 3.0
Research questions
Using link graph data, to ask:
• how does web estate of each church
interact across the border (& betwe...
JISC UK Web Domain Dataset
(1996-2013)
• copy of Internet Archive holdings for .uk
• bought by JISC, held by British Libra...
UK Host Link Graph (1996-
2010)
2008 | catholic_church.co.uk | catholic_church.ie | 4
2001 | belfast_anglican.co.uk | derr...
But UK not just .uk
British Library Legal Deposit archiving
2013: 3.9 million seeds with .uk domain names
2014: non-.uk bu...
So where are the domains ?
Domains Coverage .uk .com other .ie
% % % % %
RC 100 < 40 12 64 21 3
Where are the domains? (2)
Domains Coverage .uk .com .ie Other
% % % % %
RC 100 < 40 12 64 3 21
PCI 203 < 50 43 17 - 40
Ba...
Other denominations
• Church of Ireland: c.75% in .uk
… but many more are: parish.diocese.anglican.org
• Methodists (Belfa...
(Tentative) conclusions
• >50% of NI religious web outside .uk ?
• no easy reading of political sentiment in
national doma...
Baptists in Ireland (2016)
• Association of Baptist Churches in Ireland
has 117 congregations: 28 in RoI, 89 in NI
• 8.5k ...
Counties of Northern Ireland
(Map by Maximilian Dörrbecker, CC-BY-SA 2.5)
Where are the congregations?
County County Code % of congregations
(with domains)
Antrim AN 44
Armagh AR 7
Down DO 25
Lond...
Coded link graph (NI-to-NI)
1999 | AN27 | AR07 | 11
2003 | DW13 | LD05 | 17
2010 | AN11 | AN21 | 3
Coded link graph (NI-to-NI)
Inbound Outbound Internal
AN 248 299 151
AR 56 98 10
DW 125 64 15
LD 52 20 2
Counties of Northern Ireland
(Map by Maximilian Dörrbecker, CC-BY-SA 2.5)
Where are the domains?
Domains Coverage .uk .com .ie Other
% % % % %
Baptist 101 > 80 40 24 - 36
Baptist
(Antrim)
48 40 31...
(Tentative) conclusions
• The NI Baptist web sphere very tightly
localised
• .. but spread across four TLDs
• link analysi...
Questions ?
Peter Webster
peter@websterresearchconsulting.com
@pj_webster
peterwebster.me
websterresearchconsulting.com
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

The limitations of the ccTLD as a proxy for the national Web: lessons from cross-border religion in the Irish web

415 views

Published on

A paper given to the National Webs workshop, University of Aarhus (DK), 9 December 2016)

Published in: Internet
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

The limitations of the ccTLD as a proxy for the national Web: lessons from cross-border religion in the Irish web

  1. 1. Understanding cross-border religion in the Irish web Dr Peter Webster Webster Research and Consulting @pj_webster / @WebsterRandC
  2. 2. One island, two nations Counties of Ireland, north and south (Wikimedia Commons) CC-BY-SA 3.0
  3. 3. A unique mix of faith and politics? Ian Paisley and Edward Carson, Stormont (1985) (Burns Library, Boston College, CC-BY-NC-ND 2.0 via Flickr)
  4. 4. Cross-border religion? • Historic Christian denominations: RC, Presbyterian (PCI), Church of Ireland, Methodist, Baptist • all three organised on an all-Ireland basis • … spanning two political jurisdictions • …. and two ccTLDs - .uk and .ie
  5. 5. All-Ireland religion Church of Ireland dioceses (CoI, via Wikimedia Commons) CC-BY-SA 3.0
  6. 6. Research questions Using link graph data, to ask: • how does web estate of each church interact across the border (& between ccTLDs)? • are there distinct web spheres for each in NI and the RoI?
  7. 7. JISC UK Web Domain Dataset (1996-2013) • copy of Internet Archive holdings for .uk • bought by JISC, held by British Library • 60TB of data • no direct access to content • prototype search at webarchive.org.uk/shine • derived datasets in public domain • no equivalent for .ie
  8. 8. UK Host Link Graph (1996- 2010) 2008 | catholic_church.co.uk | catholic_church.ie | 4 2001 | belfast_anglican.co.uk | derry_anglican.co.uk | 1 2002 | derry_anglican.org.uk | derry_catholic.co.uk | 1 Data in public domain: data.webarchive.org.uk
  9. 9. But UK not just .uk British Library Legal Deposit archiving 2013: 3.9 million seeds with .uk domain names 2014: non-.uk but geolocated in UK: 2.5 million hosts http://britishlibrary.typepad.co.uk/webarchive/2015/07/geo-location-in-th e-2014-uk-domain-crawl.html
  10. 10. So where are the domains ? Domains Coverage .uk .com other .ie % % % % % RC 100 < 40 12 64 21 3
  11. 11. Where are the domains? (2) Domains Coverage .uk .com .ie Other % % % % % RC 100 < 40 12 64 3 21 PCI 203 < 50 43 17 - 40 Baptist 101 > 80 40 24 - 36
  12. 12. Other denominations • Church of Ireland: c.75% in .uk … but many more are: parish.diocese.anglican.org • Methodists (Belfast): >50% in .uk • Free Presbyterian : >70% in .org
  13. 13. (Tentative) conclusions • >50% of NI religious web outside .uk ? • no easy reading of political sentiment in national domains → need to understand why content is where it is
  14. 14. Baptists in Ireland (2016) • Association of Baptist Churches in Ireland has 117 congregations: 28 in RoI, 89 in NI • 8.5k members, community of 20k • Including independents, 93 in NI and 30 in RoI • 28 congregations with domains in RoI, 77 NI
  15. 15. Counties of Northern Ireland (Map by Maximilian Dörrbecker, CC-BY-SA 2.5)
  16. 16. Where are the congregations? County County Code % of congregations (with domains) Antrim AN 44 Armagh AR 7 Down DO 25 Londonderry LD 10 Tyrone TY 10 Fermanagh FE 4
  17. 17. Coded link graph (NI-to-NI) 1999 | AN27 | AR07 | 11 2003 | DW13 | LD05 | 17 2010 | AN11 | AN21 | 3
  18. 18. Coded link graph (NI-to-NI) Inbound Outbound Internal AN 248 299 151 AR 56 98 10 DW 125 64 15 LD 52 20 2
  19. 19. Counties of Northern Ireland (Map by Maximilian Dörrbecker, CC-BY-SA 2.5)
  20. 20. Where are the domains? Domains Coverage .uk .com .ie Other % % % % % Baptist 101 > 80 40 24 - 36 Baptist (Antrim) 48 40 31 29
  21. 21. (Tentative) conclusions • The NI Baptist web sphere very tightly localised • .. but spread across four TLDs • link analysis hard in national web archives
  22. 22. Questions ? Peter Webster peter@websterresearchconsulting.com @pj_webster peterwebster.me websterresearchconsulting.com

×