Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Relevance of the business model for startup success

769 views

Published on

This presentation answers three questions: (1) What are viable definitions of the business model? (2) Is the business model relevant for start-up success? (3) What elements of the business model are very success sensitive in the start-up context? The short case study of wegreen is used to exemplify the main arguments of the presentation.

Published in: Business

Relevance of the business model for startup success

  1. 1. © HWTK 2017 Relevance of the business model for start-up success Prof. Dr. Christian Schultz christian.schultz@hwtk.de
  2. 2. © HWTK 2017 1. Key questions Questions Relevance of the business model for start-up success § What are viable definitions of the business model? § Is the business model relevant for start-up success? § What elements of the business model are very success sensitive in the start-up context?
  3. 3. © HWTK 2017 Different perspectives on the business model The Intrapreneur à Focus: Help exploit the latest techno- logical developments with the right business models The Senior Executive à Focus: Establish a new business model in an old industry The Entrepreneur à Focus: Address unsatisfied customer needs and build new business models The Investor à Focus: Invest in companies with the most competitive business models The Consultant à Focus: Help clients question their business models, and envision and build new ones The Designer à Focus: Find the right business model to launch an innovative product The Conscientious Entrepreneur à Focus: Bring about positive social and economic change through Source: Osterwalder & Pigneur, 2004, 11.
  4. 4. © HWTK 2017 Business model definitions (examples) Article Definition Timmers (1998): Business Models for electronic markets, Electronic Markets, p. 2. The business model is an architecture of the product, service and information flows, including a description of the various business actors and their roles; a description of the potential benefits for the various business actors; a description of the sources of revenue. Amitt & Zott (2001): Value creation in e- business, SMJ, p. 511. A business model depicts the content, structure and governance of transactions designed so as to create value through the exploitation of business opportunities. Chesbrough & Rosenbloom (2002): The role of the business model in capturing value from innovation: Evidence from Xerox corporation’s technology spin-off companies, Industrial and Corporate Change, p. 529. The business model is the heuristic model that connects technical potential with the realization of economic value. Magretta (2002): Why business models matter, HBR, p. 87. Business models are stories that explain how enterprises work. A good business model answers Peter Drucker´s age old questions: Who is the customer? And what does the customer value? It also answers the fundamental questions every manager must ask: How do we make money in this business? What is the underlying economic logic that explains how we can deliver value to the customers at an appropriate cost? George & Bock (2011): The business model is the design of organizational structures to enact a commercial opportunity, p. 99. A business model is the design of organizational structures to enact a commercial opportunity.
  5. 5. © HWTK 2017 The evolution of the business model concept Starting point: Michael E. Porter’s work on the generic value chain in 1985. Perceived standard: Osterwalder & Pigneur’s business model canvas published in 2004. Further refinements: The sophisticated framework of Bernd Wirtz in 2010. For a timeline of the business model concept go to: http://www.affarsmodeller.se/Business-Model-Timeline.gif
  6. 6. © HWTK 2017 Key Activities Key Partners Key Ressources Value Creation Offer Value Proposition Customer Relationship Channels Customer Segments Customer Interface Revenue Streams Cost Structure Finance Source: Osterwalder & Pigneur, 2004, 43. 6 The business model canvas
  7. 7. © HWTK 2017 The business model lifecycle Entrepreneurial Mode Adaptive Mode Planning Mode Time Revenue Introduction Growth Maturity Stagnation/ Degeneration Adaptive Mode/ Planning Mode Business Model 1 Business Model 2 Source:Wirtz,2010,215 „The fact is, no matter how bulletproof your firm’s current business model, it will be challenged by new business models.[…] You must constantly attempt to discover new business models if your company hopes to survive and grow.“ Source: Tucker, 2001, 23.
  8. 8. © HWTK 2017 § Success for start-ups can be captured by looking at the pure survival of the organization (at a very early stage) and the economic success e.g. revenue and profit (at a later stage). § Success will always not solely depend of the business model but also on management execution and contextual factors (market, country, customer values, competition). § Technology by itself has no single objectice value. The economic value of a technology remains latent until it is commercialized in some way via a business model. „Having a well-thought-out business model is important for several reasons. While some models are better than others, it is dangerous to link the performance of a firm solely to the configuration of its business model. In most cases, performance is a choice of a business model and how effectively a firm uses its chosen model.“ – Barringer & Ireland, 2006, 102. “ ” Relevance of the business model 8
  9. 9. © HWTK 2017 Key Activities Key Partners Key Ressources Value Creation Offer Value Proposition Customer Relationship Channels Customer Segments Customer Interface Revenue Streams Cost Structure Finance Source: Osterwalder, 2004, 43. Business model canvas: Two crucial areas for start-up success
  10. 10. © HWTK 2017 Meet Maurice Stanszus § Maurice holds master degrees in sustainability and innovation management by HTW Berlin and University of Potsdam. § When Maurice wrote his master thesis he discovered a lack of viability of sustainability measurements. § With more than 400 available measurements it’s nearly impossible to make balanced “sustainable” purchase decision. § He developed the “Nachhaltigkeitsampel” as a meta-ranking for sustainability measurement and to help the customer making informed buying decisions.
  11. 11. © HWTK 2017 His startup Wegreen in 2011 § The social ranking lists of other organizations are used (Greenpeace, greenbrands, greenleaks etc.) to create a meta-ranking. § In 2011 www.wegreen.de is a search engine to classify ven- tures in regard to their social responsibility.
  12. 12. © HWTK 2017 Evolved business model: Wegreen in April 2012 § Wegreen offers new functions and services. § The consumer can engage in the discussion on sustainability and sustainable products. § Wegreen has the vision of becoming the market leader for sustainability information on the web. § Wegreen pays especially attention to the challenge of preserving their high reputation in the community. New branding New functionalities
  13. 13. © HWTK 2017 The new Wegreen (since 2013) § Wegreen added strong revenue potential to their business model by incorporating product search on their site. § Wegreen has evolved into a sustainable product search engine for sustainable-conscious customers. There is a clear revenue model now. § Now, Wegreen enables consumers to act socially responsible in an instant. Their value proposition has clearly risen.
  14. 14. © HWTK 2017 Conclusion 1. What are viable definitions of the business model? § There are many definitions, which mostly depend on the perspective of the practitioner or academic. § A timeline of the business model concept can be identified. 2. Is the business model relevant for start-up success? § The business model is of high relevance for start-up success. But it is never the single relevant success factor. § Don‘t forget that business models (have to) change over the company‘s life cycle. § Especially the elements of capturing the value proposition and developing a clear revenue model are of crucial importance. 3. What elements of the business model are very success sensitive in the start-up context? § Value proposition remains unclear or low. For example in the case of wegreen in 2010. Tools to enhance the value proposition is the value proposition map by Alexander Osterwalder. § Revenue streams are underdeveloped. Wegreen has evolved into a sustainable product search engine… so far.
  15. 15. © HWTK 2017 Literature Bucherer, E. et al. (2012): Towards systematic business model innovation: Lessons from product innovation management, in: Creativity and Innovation Management, 183-192. Barringer, B. & Ireland, D. (2006): Successfully launching new ventures, . Osterwalder, A. & Pigneur, Y. (2004): Business model generation, Lausanne. Porter, M. E. (1985): Competitive advantage, Free Press: New York. Tucker, J. (2001): Driving growth through innovation, Berret Publishers: New York. Wirtz, B. (2010): Business model management, Wiesbaden: Gabler. Further Reading Lean start-up initiative: www.theleanstartup.com Book on the basics of business models by Prof. Christian Nielsen & Morten Lund (Aalborg University, Denmark): http://bookboon.com/en/the-basics-of-business-models-ebook Blog on Business Model Research: http://www.affarsmodeller.se/ Literature and further reading
  16. 16. © HWTK, 2015© HWTK, 2015 © HWTK 2016 Your Future. Your Success. Prof. Dr. Christian Schultz Head of Distance Learning at HWTK christian.schultz@hwtk.de

×