SlideShare a Scribd company logo

curry vs. weekend

presentation about a court case between Adam Curry and the publishers of the dutch tabloid weekend that involved the improper use of CC licensed material. This presentation was part of the legal track of the isummit 2006

1 of 21
Download to read offline
the ‘curry case’
CC disputes session, iSummit 2006
    Paul Keller Creative Commons NL
curry vs. weekend
curry vs. weekend
curry vs. weekend
curry vs. weekend
curry vs. weekend

Recommended

Html francisco hurtado
Html francisco hurtadoHtml francisco hurtado
Html francisco hurtadoShereYhen
 
3A – DATA PROTECTION: ADVICE
3A – DATA PROTECTION: ADVICE3A – DATA PROTECTION: ADVICE
3A – DATA PROTECTION: ADVICECFG
 
Currys PC World case study
Currys PC World case studyCurrys PC World case study
Currys PC World case studyNewsworks
 
Dixons Carphone – Black Friday
Dixons Carphone – Black FridayDixons Carphone – Black Friday
Dixons Carphone – Black FridayNewsworks
 
BTEC National in ICT: Unit 3 - MIS Features and Functions
BTEC National in ICT: Unit 3 - MIS Features and FunctionsBTEC National in ICT: Unit 3 - MIS Features and Functions
BTEC National in ICT: Unit 3 - MIS Features and Functionsmrcox
 
How Europeana came to embrace openness
How Europeana came to embrace opennessHow Europeana came to embrace openness
How Europeana came to embrace opennessPaul Keller
 
Content Quality and Europeana
Content Quality and EuropeanaContent Quality and Europeana
Content Quality and EuropeanaPaul Keller
 
Cultural heritage Institutions deserve better!
Cultural heritage Institutions deserve better!Cultural heritage Institutions deserve better!
Cultural heritage Institutions deserve better!Paul Keller
 

More Related Content

More from Paul Keller

Maintaining a healthy and thriving Public Domain
Maintaining a healthy and thriving Public DomainMaintaining a healthy and thriving Public Domain
Maintaining a healthy and thriving Public DomainPaul Keller
 
Defining the Cultural Commons
Defining the Cultural Commons Defining the Cultural Commons
Defining the Cultural Commons Paul Keller
 
Open Content and Open Data
Open Content and Open DataOpen Content and Open Data
Open Content and Open DataPaul Keller
 
The Europeana Licensing Framework
The Europeana Licensing FrameworkThe Europeana Licensing Framework
The Europeana Licensing FrameworkPaul Keller
 
the Europeana Licensing framework
the  Europeana Licensing frameworkthe  Europeana Licensing framework
the Europeana Licensing frameworkPaul Keller
 
Main Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange Agreement
Main Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange AgreementMain Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange Agreement
Main Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange AgreementPaul Keller
 
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective Paul Keller
 
Open Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in Europeana
Open Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in EuropeanaOpen Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in Europeana
Open Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in EuropeanaPaul Keller
 
Europeana Licensing Framework overview
Europeana Licensing Framework overviewEuropeana Licensing Framework overview
Europeana Licensing Framework overviewPaul Keller
 
a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)
a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)
a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)Paul Keller
 
Creative Commons & Collective Rights Management
Creative Commons & Collective Rights ManagementCreative Commons & Collective Rights Management
Creative Commons & Collective Rights ManagementPaul Keller
 
COMMUNIA policy recommendations
COMMUNIA policy recommendations COMMUNIA policy recommendations
COMMUNIA policy recommendations Paul Keller
 
alternative online distribution models for film
alternative online  distribution models for film alternative online  distribution models for film
alternative online distribution models for film Paul Keller
 
Creative Commons en Open Data
Creative Commons en Open DataCreative Commons en Open Data
Creative Commons en Open DataPaul Keller
 
Promoting openness in the public sector, the case of the Netherlands
Promoting openness in the public sector, the case of the NetherlandsPromoting openness in the public sector, the case of the Netherlands
Promoting openness in the public sector, the case of the NetherlandsPaul Keller
 
Creative Commons voor Erfgoedprofessionals
Creative Commons voor ErfgoedprofessionalsCreative Commons voor Erfgoedprofessionals
Creative Commons voor ErfgoedprofessionalsPaul Keller
 
the Public Domain Manifesto
the Public Domain Manifesto the Public Domain Manifesto
the Public Domain Manifesto Paul Keller
 
Evaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons Nederland
Evaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons NederlandEvaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons Nederland
Evaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons NederlandPaul Keller
 
The Public Domain Charter
The Public Domain CharterThe Public Domain Charter
The Public Domain CharterPaul Keller
 
wiki loves art/NL
wiki loves art/NLwiki loves art/NL
wiki loves art/NLPaul Keller
 

More from Paul Keller (20)

Maintaining a healthy and thriving Public Domain
Maintaining a healthy and thriving Public DomainMaintaining a healthy and thriving Public Domain
Maintaining a healthy and thriving Public Domain
 
Defining the Cultural Commons
Defining the Cultural Commons Defining the Cultural Commons
Defining the Cultural Commons
 
Open Content and Open Data
Open Content and Open DataOpen Content and Open Data
Open Content and Open Data
 
The Europeana Licensing Framework
The Europeana Licensing FrameworkThe Europeana Licensing Framework
The Europeana Licensing Framework
 
the Europeana Licensing framework
the  Europeana Licensing frameworkthe  Europeana Licensing framework
the Europeana Licensing framework
 
Main Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange Agreement
Main Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange AgreementMain Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange Agreement
Main Aspects of the Europeana Data Exchange Agreement
 
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
towards a global CC license - the affiliate perspective
 
Open Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in Europeana
Open Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in EuropeanaOpen Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in Europeana
Open Data in the cultural sector: Cultural heritage data in Europeana
 
Europeana Licensing Framework overview
Europeana Licensing Framework overviewEuropeana Licensing Framework overview
Europeana Licensing Framework overview
 
a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)
a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)
a brief history copyright (and why it is broken)
 
Creative Commons & Collective Rights Management
Creative Commons & Collective Rights ManagementCreative Commons & Collective Rights Management
Creative Commons & Collective Rights Management
 
COMMUNIA policy recommendations
COMMUNIA policy recommendations COMMUNIA policy recommendations
COMMUNIA policy recommendations
 
alternative online distribution models for film
alternative online  distribution models for film alternative online  distribution models for film
alternative online distribution models for film
 
Creative Commons en Open Data
Creative Commons en Open DataCreative Commons en Open Data
Creative Commons en Open Data
 
Promoting openness in the public sector, the case of the Netherlands
Promoting openness in the public sector, the case of the NetherlandsPromoting openness in the public sector, the case of the Netherlands
Promoting openness in the public sector, the case of the Netherlands
 
Creative Commons voor Erfgoedprofessionals
Creative Commons voor ErfgoedprofessionalsCreative Commons voor Erfgoedprofessionals
Creative Commons voor Erfgoedprofessionals
 
the Public Domain Manifesto
the Public Domain Manifesto the Public Domain Manifesto
the Public Domain Manifesto
 
Evaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons Nederland
Evaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons NederlandEvaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons Nederland
Evaluatieonderzoek pilot Buma/Stemra en Creative Commons Nederland
 
The Public Domain Charter
The Public Domain CharterThe Public Domain Charter
The Public Domain Charter
 
wiki loves art/NL
wiki loves art/NLwiki loves art/NL
wiki loves art/NL
 

Recently uploaded

WEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINES
WEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINESWEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINES
WEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINESMariaeGladysAfrica
 
Kevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdf
Kevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdfKevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdf
Kevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdfKevin Dixon
 
Kingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guide
Kingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guideKingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guide
Kingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guidejiminyjournal0
 
Easter Egg Convergence Research Powerpoint
Easter Egg Convergence Research PowerpointEaster Egg Convergence Research Powerpoint
Easter Egg Convergence Research Powerpoint17mdav134
 
American Horror Story Episode Analysis -
American Horror Story  Episode Analysis -American Horror Story  Episode Analysis -
American Horror Story Episode Analysis -17mdav134
 
Dont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptx
Dont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptxDont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptx
Dont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptxHayleyDerby
 
Music Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.Ivan
Music Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.IvanMusic Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.Ivan
Music Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.IvanRoseZubler1
 
The Walking Dead Content and Conventions
The Walking Dead Content and ConventionsThe Walking Dead Content and Conventions
The Walking Dead Content and Conventions17mdav134
 
The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)
The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)
The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)tarantinovinoofficia
 
Conventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot Research
Conventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot ResearchConventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot Research
Conventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot Research17mdav134
 
Unlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape Rooms
Unlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape RoomsUnlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape Rooms
Unlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape RoomsJoycea Morton
 

Recently uploaded (14)

An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"
An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"
An interview with the director of "Zone of Interest"
 
WEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINES
WEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINESWEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINES
WEEK 3 ISSUES MORAL SOCIAL AND ECONOMICAL ISSUES IN THE PHILIPPINES
 
Kevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdf
Kevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdfKevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdf
Kevin Dixon Personal Brand Exploration.pdf
 
Kingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guide
Kingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guideKingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guide
Kingdom Hearts: A series summary and "quick" guide
 
Easter Egg Convergence Research Powerpoint
Easter Egg Convergence Research PowerpointEaster Egg Convergence Research Powerpoint
Easter Egg Convergence Research Powerpoint
 
American Horror Story Episode Analysis -
American Horror Story  Episode Analysis -American Horror Story  Episode Analysis -
American Horror Story Episode Analysis -
 
Dont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptx
Dont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptxDont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptx
Dont_Think_Prospectus_FINAL_Project_.pptx
 
6 People You See at Every Coffee Shop-Comics
6 People You See at Every Coffee Shop-Comics6 People You See at Every Coffee Shop-Comics
6 People You See at Every Coffee Shop-Comics
 
Music Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.Ivan
Music Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.IvanMusic Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.Ivan
Music Video Prospectus: Don't Think — D.U.Ivan
 
The Walking Dead Content and Conventions
The Walking Dead Content and ConventionsThe Walking Dead Content and Conventions
The Walking Dead Content and Conventions
 
The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)
The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)
The Music Industry by Wesley Conner (V1N0)
 
Conventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot Research
Conventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot ResearchConventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot Research
Conventions of a Sci-fi Horror Pilot Research
 
"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors
"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors
"Schindler’s List" : an oral history with the actors
 
Unlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape Rooms
Unlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape RoomsUnlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape Rooms
Unlocking the Thrill: The World of Escape Rooms
 

curry vs. weekend

  • 1. the ‘curry case’ CC disputes session, iSummit 2006 Paul Keller Creative Commons NL
  • 7. the ‘curry case’ (a. curry v. audax/Weekend) • District Court of Amsterdam - decision on 9 march, 2006 Interim measure, Case number 334492 / KG 06-176 S • English translation available at: mirrors.creativecommons.org/ judgements/Curry-Audax-English.pdf • bought forward by Adam Curry, his wife and daughter (residing in the UK) against Audax, the publisher of the dutch tabloid Weekend and two senior editors • three lines of argument: • violation of right of portrait • privacy violations • copyright (CC license violation)
  • 8. the ‘curry case’- the facts • in issue 3/2006, Weekend used CC-BY-NC-SA 2.0 licensed photos from Adam Curry’s flickr account in a 4-page story about his family life. • By letter of 20 January 2006 the Curry's counsel demanded from Audax that it cease the sales of Weekend issue 3, that it publish a rectification and pay €10000 as an advance to the damages. • in issue 4 the following rectification was published: ‘In the previous Weekend issue we drew attention to Adam Curry [...] The publication was accompanied by photographs taken from a virtual photo album on the Internet. We should have requested permission for publication of those photographs. We regret that we failed to do so and would like to apologize to the Curry family.’ Audax also offered €1500 compensation.
  • 9. arguments brought forward by curry (1) • Curry owns the copyright on all four photos from www.flickr.com. Weekend has acknowledged this by using the copyright notice. • In adding the text ‘Photos: ©Adam Curry’ the suggestion is actually made that Curry has given permission for insertion of the photos, which is not the case. • The photos are published on the website under the conditions laid down in the CC-BY-NC-SA License. • This is recognizable for every visitor of the website, since the photos are accompanied by the text ‘some rights reserved’. • The applicability of the License terms follows from the opening lines of the License, which read: quot;By exercising any rights to the work provided here, you accept and agree to be bound by the terms of this licensequot;
  • 10. arguments brought forward by curry (2) • Weekend has not complied with the requirements for using the photos set by the License. • Article 4 sub c of the License stipulates that the use (of the photos) may not produce any commercial benefits. Weekend is a downright commercial magazine. • Article 4 sub a of the License stipulates that distribution and public display of a work have to be accompanied by a copy of the License. Weekend has not observed this requirement: every reference to the License is lacking. • In violating the above requirements Weekend fails to execute the contract to which it was bound.
  • 11. arguments brought forward by weekend (1) • Adam Curry has actively sought publicity for years and still hundreds of private pictures of the Curry family are accessible for anyone to see at www.flickr.com. • The four photos at dispute have been published in Weekend in good faith. • The statement quot;This photo is publicquot; put Weekend/Audax under the impression that it had the permission to publish the photos, with the note that the copyright rests with Adam Curry. • The link to the License is not traceable in an obvious manner. Audax became aware of the License only after notification by Curry's lawyer. Therefore Audax cannot be blamed the violation of the requirements set in the License.
  • 15. arguments brought forward by weekend (2) • Weekend's not mentioning the conditions of the License did not cause Curry to suffer any harm at all, as fact that the copyright on the photos rests with Curry has been mentioned. • Article 4 sub c of the License has not been violated. Weekend's principal reason to publish the photos is not to make a profit but to inform its readers. Audax is entitled to such freedom of expression. • The non commercial clause seems to be meant to prevent merchandising (e.g. production of picture postcards), not to prevent placement of photos to illustrate news reports.
  • 16. is weekend bound by the license? • Adam Curry owns the copyright in the four photos, and the photos, by their posting on that website, are subject to the Creative Commons License. • Therefore Weekend should observe the conditions that control the use by third parties of the photos as stated in the License • this confirms that a by exercising any rights granted by the license the user is bound by the conditions • It may be expected from a professional party that it conducts a thorough and precise examination before publishing photos originating from the internet. • Had Weekend conducted such an investigation they would have found the CC License. In case of doubt as to the applicability and the contents of the License, it should have requested pemission.
  • 17. does weekend comply with B by-nc-sa? • Articles 4 sub a (atibution) and 4 sub c (non-commercial use only) have been violated: • BY: while Curry is correctly identified as the author/ copyright holder, the edition of Weekend at dispute makes no reference whatsoever to the License. • NC: Audax has violated that provision as well because publication of an entertainment magazine such as Weekend can be regarded first and foremost as a commercial activity. • the court orders Audax to refrain from further using pictures from Curry's flickr page in ways that are not authorized by the CC licenses (or without authorization om Curry) at pain of a penalty of €1000 of each violation with a maximum of €20000.
  • 18. damages? • However, the court does not see any economic damages caused to Curry by Weekends license violations: • Photos that are already accessible for free for everyone on the internet have no commercial value (anymore) • Curry has been acknowledged as the copyright holder and the subsequent rectification states that Weekend was wrong not to ask for permission. • no damages are awarded to Curry • Because of this a lot of people have the impression that Curry has 'lost' the case, a number of people have concluded that the CC licenses offer no protection against violations as there is no monetary risk for infringers. • Judge would have hardly found monetary damage in the absence of CC licenses.
  • 19. issues raised by the case • licenses do work as a tool that can be used by a court of law • there is a problem when attempting to enforce monetary compensation in case of license violation (how to quantify SA) • this case was not really about a license violation but about copyright infringement • a more interesting case would have been a case where commercial use is allowed and this is then disputed by the licensor. • (un)clear definition of non-commercial • fair use anyone?
  • 20. thank you! more information at: http://creativecommons.org/weblog/entry/5944 http://creativecommons.org/weblog/entry/5823 this presentation is licensed under the terms of a Creative Commons BY-NC- SA 2.5 license. All photographs by Adam Curry (obviously!). for a copy of the license see: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/2.5/