Pay for Success Projects and Social Impact Bonds: Structuring Considerations and Adaptations Arising from the Field

894 views

Published on

In NFF's first SIB e-vent, we held a live web chat exploring the challenges and opportunities of SIB and their potential to develop in the US marketplace. In this second e-vent, experts from The Young Foundation (UK), the Centre for Social Impact (New South Wales), and NFF discussed:

1. What SIB models exist for risk sharing and rewards incentives
2. How other countries have come to determine the right SIB structures for their transactions
3. Initial implications for structuring SIBs/Pay for Success projects in the United States

See this and other resources, including the recording of the live webinar at our Social Impact Bond discussion group, which is free for anyone to join here: http://nonprofitfinancefund.org/sib

Published in: Economy & Finance, Business
0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total views
894
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
91
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Pay for Success Projects and Social Impact Bonds: Structuring Considerations and Adaptations Arising from the Field

  1. 1. ® Nonprofit Finance FundPay for Success Projects andSocial Impact BondsStructuring Considerations andAdaptations Arising from the FieldApril 28, 2011nonprofitfinancefund.org
  2. 2. Welcome to the Webinar Before we get started…. !  All audience members are muted. !  If you’re participating by phone, make sure to select the ‘Use Telephone’ option in the control panel. In order for you to hear the presentation on the phone, press the audio pin number followed by the # sign when you call in. If you’re already on the call, press #audiopin# !  To submit questions, simply type in your question in the ‘Question’ box at the bottom of your control panel and hit ‘send.’ !  Having trouble? Please email meetings2@nffusa.org and we’ll respond right away.nonprofitfinancefund.org
  3. 3. !"#$%&$()**+,,$ "-.$(&*/"0$123"*4$ 5&-.,6$&34/&-,$ %&$2&.+0,$7$ /230+2+-4"4/&- 8/*&0"$5"*&- 9:$;3/0$9<==!"#$%&
  4. 4. !"#$%&$&($)*$+"&,-$)./$0&/,-$*0$1#/2/3)%)&2/$&32/()/3)$+4$0&3-&35$3/6$6%4($*0$0"3-&35$)./$1#/2/3)&*3$*0$"3-/(&#%+,/$(*7&%,$*")7*/($%)$%$)&/$*0$0&3%37&%,$1#/(("#/(8$9/$.%2/: ;"+,&(./-$%3$&3&)&%,$1%1/# </5%3$6*#=$6&).$>?$,*7%,$%").*#&)&/(@$./%,).$%3-$.*"(&35$%5/37&/( A"11*#)/-$)./$-/2/,*1/3)$*0$!"#$%& ()%&*+,-.&/+,-$01#+-&233
  5. 5. !"#$%&( )*$+%,*-./*%.$01"+23%."4&1+5$3%6$5&//*45+327$8&4$19:2+5$;&32-$3.$3$.+/*$&8$-5345*$4*-&945*- <*..*4$+%.*4,*%.+&%-$."3.$14*,*%.$89.94*$5&-.-$3%6$14&:2*/-$8&4$;&,*4%/*%. =$14*--94*$8&4$:*..*4$8&59->$6*2+,*4#$3%6$,329*$8&4$/&%*#!"#$%& ()%&*+,-.&/+,-$01#+-&2344
  6. 6. E(&M/7;8&N(/(9?C($"(#&.-*&(#&F"66&.0<( E(;#"<#/77&("6(/*$0"3( $"(#&.-*&(@"-$%(#&F !"#$%&#()"*+( "66&.0<(*"3$0<(=>7 ,"-./$0" G003$#@("6(H-3$0*&( ?7;8&7&$&.(4@(3;&*0/8( *"770$3($"(;/@(0($2"( 1#"2.(3"-#*&.(4". ;-#;"3&(:&%0*8&(*"$#/*$0<( @&/#3($07&("(#&/*%0<( 20$%(+&@(8"*/8($%0#.(3&*$"#( #&"66&.0<(#/$&(/$("#( 5-+&("6(!"#$%-74&#8/. "#</03/$0"3(A&B<B( 4&8"2(>IJ(*"7;/#&.($"( C/#/."3D /$0"/8(#/$&("6(KIJ 9"*0/8(:&$-#&(*/;0$/8 )/030<(=>7(6"#( E(*"770$7&$($"(#&;/@( 0:&3$7&$ =>BL7("(<"".(#&3-8$3 )&;/@7&$(("6("#0<0/8(0:&3$7&$!
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
  10. 10. !"#$%&()*%+,($*,)%)$&#$"+-" ,%+-#.#"#*/&& *%-*#)0 2+8#)0&*;%& 1 2%*3#4- $%+" =4*#6)& A@+":+*%&()#*#+"&#$%+ ?%"#@%3/ 1 564+"&7+38%* 1 <%06*#+*#)0 >"+) B&3%@#%C 1 9:*"#)%& 1 ,#)+)4#)0 .:-#)%--&4+-% .+/,-0#$1+%"$*,22+))+,(#&)3$+(4#)%,&)3$5#/+4#&#&)$(5$67#&) !"#$%&
  11. 11. !"##$%&()&$*+,((-")&#.("/0$"1(2!"#$%&( )*%&+,-./&0,-.$12#,.&3(
  12. 12. !"##$%&()&$*+,((-")&#.("/0$"1(2
  13. 13. !"#$%#%$&#%(%)#*(+&,%-&.#+/&01.-(% !"#$%&(%)+((/#%$&233(.#,"&.()1.%+&2.&3#4(-& 32)#*,)#2%+5&,#3&)2&3#%#3#+(&.#+/6&&& *#$("+$"&,-./$( +((/#%$&3#%#313&.#+/& 7#-(,""8&239"()(&).,%+:(.;&,%-&3,4#313&%(<&32%(8 !"&$(+$01.(/)<#)=&)89#,""8&"#))"(&,9,#)8&)2&,..8& .#+/ 2(#10$(%,0$31#$(% )89#,""8&239,.,0"(&.#+/+& )2&2)=(.&9.2$.,33(+5&29)#2%+&2:&#%(%)#*(&0,+(-& 9,83(%)!"#$%&( )*%&+,-./&0,-.$12#,.&(3
  14. 14. !"#$%&()$*%#*%+$,-(-%*&#./%01%+121#--/*3 Very efficientCost efficiencies Less efficient Small Size of organisation/unit Large
  15. 15. !"#$%&#()$*+($%,-./0$1#(2/0#13$&)4$)&/+)&.$5+2#()6#)17$1+$-#1$/6%&0$+*$89:1$/1$(#%./0&/+)$)+$)#0#11&(/.;$10&./)53$0(#&/)5$-+"$1(+)5#($%,1"$&)4$1(+)5#($/)0#)/2#1$*+($&4+%/+)Very efficient Cost efficiencies Less efficient Small Size of organisation/unit Large
  16. 16. !"#$%&()%*+%($,-.,)#-,/%#-,%.0*-$#($1 2,3%0*$,($#4%-*4,%/%!"#$%&"()#%*+*,)%)+!#"-#&",*%%).#*+/#$+!),*!$"+#*0"..#*,)+01#.$2".5 6/%$",%7*-,%/&44%+(#(7,89#(&(:1%%;-%-,4#$*(/"0/%<$"%(=,/$*-/8+*>()#$*(/%.#3?%%#94$3%$*%),/:(%#()%.04,.,($%0-*:-#..,/1 @/%<$"%$",%9-*#),-%($,-.,)#-3%+,4)%#%.A%*+%/&44/%<44%9,%,//,($#4%$*%#7",=(:%/:(+7#($%.0#7$%555%!"#$%&( )*%&+,-./&0,-.$12#,.&34
  17. 17. 6#.1.7#1"& . /01023 6 =0/4=58 #.@%92:%.2 /0435637/15/38 %@1"-12#,.&921.$18$#912#,. <"126,8:9 7,::-.#2B&$%@%",<%89C 5%.%6#7#18#%9 7,::-.#2B&9*18%&#99-%&58,?%89 <%86,8:1.7%&#.$#7%9 E8,>$A9,-87#./&<"126,8:9 :%19-8%:%.2&7,.9-"21.7#%9 /81.2:1?%89 #..,@12#,.D7*1""%./%&6-.$9C :#78,A6-.$#./ <*#"1.2*8,<#7&.%2>,8?9 9,7#1"&#:<172&5,.$&<8,@#$%89 9,7#1"&#.@%92:%.2&58,?%89 9,7#1"&"%.$%89 615934/0: 107 9,7#1"&@%.2-8%&71<#21"&6-.$9C 7/845/;<4/=0 9<%7#1"#92&51.?9 /0435637/15/38 @%.2-8%&<*#"1.2*8,<B&6-.$9C 5#$$#./&<"126,8:9 7-92,:%89 7,::#99#,.#./&1$@#9,89C 9,7#1"&@%.2-8%&$#8%72,8#%9 %;<%82#9%=&<%,<"%=& > 3=>?3@034A=598 107 !"#$%& .%2>,8?9 3B>354/83 /0435637/15/38 ()*+,-)! /00=C14/=0 /0435637/15/38 5%92A<8172#7%&9*18#./&<"126,8:9 7,::#99#,.#./&1$@#9,89C& 7,::-.#2B&$%@%",<%89C 7,:<%2#2#,.9D<8#F%9 $%9#/.&#.2%8:%$#18#%9C $%9#/.&#.2%8:%$#18#%9C #..,@12#,.D7*1""%./%&6-.$9C #..,@12#,.D7*1""%./%&6-.$9C #..,@12#,.&<"126,8:9C #..,@12#,.&<"126,8:9C #.@%92,8&8%1$#.%99&<8,@#$%89 9,7#1"&#..,@12#,.&@%.2-8%&"159C& #.9#/*29=&8%9,-87%9=& "%1$%89*#<&177%"%812,89 :%2*,$9 <*B9#71"&#.7-512,89 <8,A5,.,&.%2>,8?9 9,7#1"&%.28%<8%.%-89*#<&97*,,"9 9,7#1"&#..,@12#,.&@%.2-8%&"159C 9,7#1"&@%.2-8%&71<#21"&6-.$9C 9,7#1"&@%.2-8%&.%2>,8?9 9<%7#1"#92&7,.9-"21.7#%9D%;<%829 9-<<,82&58,?%89 @%.2-8%&<*#"1.2*8,<B&6-.$9C!"#$%&( )*%&+,-./&0,-.$12#,.&34
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
  19. 19. !"#$%&()*+(*,$$"&-./0$1+2/-,$3&*4$5.0&,!5)(6(*,(4$78$9(6$:(+6$/*4$;80.($<=/)0,&*$ >?,=$@2).0$>ABB$
  20. 20. !"#$%&()*+,)%-.-%/(%#)01%!"#$%"&$(")#*+,#-,./01020*3#/*&3#-%4#567#8%9,4":,"*;#*+,#<,"*4,#-%4#6%$0.2#!:=.$*#><6!?#.&&4,//,&#*@%#A,3#B,/(%"/C##DE  7+,*+,4#*+,#6!F#$%"$,=*#0/#-,./012,#0"#.#5,@# 6%*+#7.2,/#>567?#$%"*,G*H#."&##IE#7+,*+,4#567#+./#*+,#",$,//.43#0")4,&0,"*/#J# :.4A,*#$%"&0(%"/;#58K#$.=.$0*3;#/%$0.2#0:=.$*# 0"9,/*:,"*#0"*,4,/*#."&#)%9,4":,"*# =4,=.4,&",//#J#-%4#*+0/#",@#.==4%.$+#*%#-"&0")E##
  21. 21. !"#$%&(")*+,$-*#&./(*#"01,/&!"#$%&($(&)*+&($(+,-.,,+/0,$1+)%$*0($-/0,+(&2&($)%&$3&2,3&-45&,$/67$•  8/5&209&0)$*:&0-+&,$•  ;/)<6/2<32/=)$/2:*0+,*4/0,$>;?@,AB$$•  "/-+*$+05&,)/2,$C$3%+*0)%2/3+,),$*0($)%&+2$ :*)&D&&3&2,$>1&*)%$9*0*:&2,C*(5+,&2,AE$!"#$F&0&=G&($:2&*)H$62/9$*(5+-&$*0($,.33/2)7$•  I*-J.*2+&$82/.3B$KLM&2&B$!/22,$!%*9F&2,$ M&,):*2)%B$N/.0:$O/.0(*4/0B$"/-+*$O+0*0-&$PQ$
  22. 22. !"#$%&#(#)*+,-$)%,)."/+%,/$!"#$%&(&)&*$+,-+.$•  /,&$"#0$1231&4+$(*$5&-*(%&$-36$$•  7"8$62&*$,-)&$+,&$3&1&**-9:$(3;9&6(&3+*$0</$•  /,&9&$(*$=>1,$?29@$+2$%&$623&$+2$6&()&9$-$"#0$ 4(2+$(3$7"8$•  /,&$"#0$*+9>1+>9&$=>*+$%&$1>*+2=(A&6$529$+,&$ 21-$123+&B+$•  C)(6&31&$-36$=&-*>9&=&3+$-9&$+,&$%(;;&*+$ 1,-&3;&*$
  23. 23. !"#$%&("&)$*+$*,&$-*.-/,)*.)$•  !"#$%&(")**%+"&*,+-.+/&-0"&#"*$,"*+%+##-0"•  123#"+4&#,",5,"-+"%67(+"8"(+9((0"*/" )**%&((0":"*/";&((&*9",$"&##<+""=>?"•  =$%&("&.6%,"&*@+#,$-#"5@+""6-+A+-+*%+"A$-"" /&-+%,"-+(B$*#5&6";&,5"123"•  123"6-+A+-+*%+"A$-"/&-+%,"-+(B$*#5&6#";&,5" C$@+-*.+*,"*/"#$%&("&.6%,"&*@+#,$-#"
  24. 24. !"#$%"#&()"*")+"&,-%.%/0)1•  !"#$%&()*+,%-•  ./#0#"*12()*3)0-403)%%&*15#*-%•  .6"&%7#%•  81"50+,%2#0,%•  9%021)0+,%206"732030"7253*6%)7-%75(*,"#: ()"*)";%2•  <*=,%6%,2*>6*,0;,"5:?%@5%)70,";%2
  25. 25. !"#$%"#&()"*%+%,-).)(/01•  !"#"$%&(&)(*+,%-+.(/(%0$,1*%02(3$",%02(1#(•  4+,"5)036%#(7%&6(2)-+.08+0&(•  9&.)02(.+#1&"5)0(:).(*+,%-+.(•  9&.)02(2)-+.0"0$+;(<0"0$%",($)0&.),;(6%26( =1",%&;(8)0%&).%02("0*(+-",1"5)0;($,%+0&>$"3+( 8"0"2+8+0&(33&+8(•  ?."$@(.+$).*():(3)$%",(%00)-"5)0(•  4+,"5)036%#(7%&6(3)$%",(%8#"$&(%0-+3&).3(
  26. 26. !"#$%%"&"()*+(,-./#-/."( !"#$%&()*%#+ (,-./+"0/ = =@//$5,).,+"3 !(>(//?. :?+#").>%/.A9%B).,+ :?+#").>%/.A@50..).,+ 1"/+,"+23"02*0"4+ <"-.0,).,+ "05%,$/%6",789:; =:?+#").>%/.A9%B).,+ 90"50%)7/;
  27. 27. !"#$$%&(%)*+$,-%.$-.$+%!"#$%&& ()*%+*",-&,%.&)/0,).&",12/%3&3$&4$+*,-& *2",+3&*%5/43$)4&*4&67--1&./"/%./%3&$%&38/& ,+8*/5/2/%3&$6&,%&,9)//.&$73+$2/:&/01*2%(% (3,324$%*5%#6-78-"3#629%:$.;$$2% 9*<$#2)$2.=%."$%>?/%32+%-*463,%6)034.% 62<$-.*#-@%&.32+629%4"3#9$%4*<$#-%03#.%*5% 0#*9#3)%#A22629%4*-.-@%B$)362629%4*-.-% 32+%#$;3#+%03C)$2.%+$0$2+$2.%*2% 34"6$<$)$2.%-A44$--5A,%*A.4*)$@%%!"#$%&;& <$+*,-&*2",+3&*%5/43$)4&")/6/)/%+/&3$& ")$3/+3&38/*)&+,"*3,-:&
  28. 28. !"#$%&(&&)*&*+,-&.$&/00.&/,-01.$%012&3$405%/0%.& •  !"#$%&!%()*%+,-%)(%.)$/%)(%0*)1*"23%% •  4"5.67$%0*)1*"2%8)6$59/%0"#%()*% :50*)8:.;<6%0*)1*"2$3%6$1.&78!& •  =)$6$%.*68>?>7>/#%@>/A%1)<6*5265/3% •  =)$6$%.*68>?>7>/#%@>/A%$).>"7%>5<6$/)*$3%%9$:,+-&)/"+:.& •  B6.6><6$%)57#%+,-%)(%0*>5.>0"7%?".CD%)%401.$51& 7)$>51%E,-%)(%0*>5.>0"7%"58%*6.6><>51% 5)%6.)5)2>.%*6/:*5%()*%8607)#68% ."0>/"73%
  29. 29. !"##$%&($%%)*+*,-%)./0$123!"#$%&()*&%+,%-.#/&01.2&3)*.(-&#42).%&)%.%&(),*$-.)5#3&%)24.#3.%3)&/,#,-6/)47&,%(8)97&#),54/,-&2).%&)*.%4()3&4&%-6#&3)1()2&%:6/&)*%,:63&%;2)&<,%4).#3)*.%4()3&4&%-6#&3)1()+./4,%2)1&(,#3)47&)2&%:6/&)*%,:63&%;2)/,#4%,=),*$-.)/,#4%./42)>&#&%.()6#:,:&3).)?@&3),%)/,2401.2&3)*.(-&#4)/,-*,#&#4=).#3).)*&%+,%-.#/&0*.(-&#4)2(24&-8A)BC6&1-.#=)DEFFG8)!
  30. 30. !"#$%&((")*"+$&",$ -./0+1)"++$.2$"34,")%"$),$ 7..(+! 5"+06"5")1$!"  #$!%&!()*)+!,$!-.,/.*0! "  ;),2,01)!*26!92*2)1*:! 12%.324,25! 0,6:5!"  #$!%&!651.6!,7%),0!8! "  <,)1*:!.%7.2!,2!1235%02%! 92*2)1*:!*26!5,)1*:! "  =*5!0*2*/02%!5+5%05!"  #$!%&!%*./%!):12%!),&,.%! "  >,2/1%7612*:!0*57.02%! 0%&,6,:,/15!
  31. 31. Thank You!To Stay Connected… About SIB nonprofitfinancefund.org/sibinitiative About NFF’s work to build SIB resources Join the nonprofitfinancefund.org/SIB Group Building community resources on SIB and other models. The Webinar recording will be available here shortly. You’ll also find the transcript from our first web chat, articles, and more. About NFF nonprofitfinancefund.org Twitter twitter.com/nff_news Facebook facebook.com/nonprofitfinancefund Our Blog nonprofitfinancefund.org/blog Sign Up nonprofitfinancefund.org/sign-upnonprofitfinancefund.org 19

×