SlideShare a Scribd company logo

Freedom of movement within the EU and extradition.

After Pisciotti and Petruhhin (and waiting for CJEU's decision on the question raised by the Wiesbaden Court) it seems that extradition law must face a new challenge.

1 of 11
Download to read offline
HOW CAN FREE
MOVEMENT RIGHTS
IMPACT EU CITIZEN
EXTRADITION TO A
THIRD COUNTRY?
NICOLA CANESTRINI
LECCO, JUNE 24TH 2019
”nationality bar”
refusal ground of extradition
Within the scope of
application of the Treaties (.,),
any discrimination on grounds
of nationality shall be
prohibited
(art. 18 TFEU)
Every citizen of the Union
shall have the right to move
and reside freely within the
territory of the Member
States
(art. 21 TFEU)
are restrictions to
extradition for nationals
of a ms discriminatory for
other EU nationals?
1. Is a EU Member State required to
extend a prohibition on the extradition
of its own nationals to every EU citizen?
2. Does a citizen of an EU Member State which
prohibits the extradition of its own nationals
carry nationality bar with him when
exercising his free movement rights in the
EU ?
1. Is a EU Member State required to
extend a prohibition on the extradition
of its own nationals to every EU citizen?
Ad

Recommended

European Investigation order and rights of the defence
European Investigation order and rights of the defenceEuropean Investigation order and rights of the defence
European Investigation order and rights of the defenceNicola Canestrini
 
Asylum Procedures in the EU_A Method in the Madness_by Elisabeth Vos
Asylum Procedures in the EU_A Method in the Madness_by Elisabeth VosAsylum Procedures in the EU_A Method in the Madness_by Elisabeth Vos
Asylum Procedures in the EU_A Method in the Madness_by Elisabeth VosElisabeth Vos LL.M.
 
Militello finanz terrorismo traffico e tratta ue 2019 bruxelles en
Militello finanz terrorismo traffico e tratta ue 2019 bruxelles enMilitello finanz terrorismo traffico e tratta ue 2019 bruxelles en
Militello finanz terrorismo traffico e tratta ue 2019 bruxelles enVincenzo58
 
ALL ABOUT CONSTITUTION IN MYANMAR ENGLISH-BURMESE VERSION COLLECTION BY MYO AUNG
ALL ABOUT CONSTITUTION IN MYANMAR ENGLISH-BURMESE VERSION COLLECTION BY MYO AUNGALL ABOUT CONSTITUTION IN MYANMAR ENGLISH-BURMESE VERSION COLLECTION BY MYO AUNG
ALL ABOUT CONSTITUTION IN MYANMAR ENGLISH-BURMESE VERSION COLLECTION BY MYO AUNGMYO AUNG Myanmar
 
Convención Europea de Derechos Humanos
Convención Europea de Derechos Humanos Convención Europea de Derechos Humanos
Convención Europea de Derechos Humanos C C
 
Скорочується строк звернення до ЄСПЛ
Скорочується строк звернення до ЄСПЛ Скорочується строк звернення до ЄСПЛ
Скорочується строк звернення до ЄСПЛ Pravotv
 
"ALEKSEI PETRUHHIN" European court of Justice case analysis by Navinya Kamble...
"ALEKSEI PETRUHHIN" European court of Justice case analysis by Navinya Kamble..."ALEKSEI PETRUHHIN" European court of Justice case analysis by Navinya Kamble...
"ALEKSEI PETRUHHIN" European court of Justice case analysis by Navinya Kamble...NAVINYAKAMBLE1
 

More Related Content

More from Nicola Canestrini

Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024
Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024
Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024Nicola Canestrini
 
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...Nicola Canestrini
 
Fundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal law
Fundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal lawFundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal law
Fundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal lawNicola Canestrini
 
Criminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalization
Criminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalizationCriminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalization
Criminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalizationNicola Canestrini
 
Mandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla salute
Mandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla saluteMandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla salute
Mandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla saluteNicola Canestrini
 
OIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesa
OIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesaOIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesa
OIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesaNicola Canestrini
 
Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...
Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...
Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...Nicola Canestrini
 
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAE
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAEDiritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAE
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAENicola Canestrini
 
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europeaDiritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europeaNicola Canestrini
 
Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali.
Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali. Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali.
Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali. Nicola Canestrini
 
Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)
Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)
Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)Nicola Canestrini
 
Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung.
Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung. Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung.
Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung. Nicola Canestrini
 
Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...
Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...
Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...Nicola Canestrini
 
Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders.
Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders. Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders.
Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders. Nicola Canestrini
 
Difendere diritti, a quale costo?
Difendere diritti, a quale costo? Difendere diritti, a quale costo?
Difendere diritti, a quale costo? Nicola Canestrini
 
".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...
".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...
".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...Nicola Canestrini
 
European fair trial and effective participation rights
European fair trial and effective participation rightsEuropean fair trial and effective participation rights
European fair trial and effective participation rightsNicola Canestrini
 
Right to a new trial under directive 343/16
Right to a new trial under directive 343/16Right to a new trial under directive 343/16
Right to a new trial under directive 343/16Nicola Canestrini
 
Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.
Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.
Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.Nicola Canestrini
 
Cooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAE
Cooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAECooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAE
Cooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAENicola Canestrini
 

More from Nicola Canestrini (20)

Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024
Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024
Avvocati non ammessi. Focus Iran, avvocati minacciati 2024
 
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...
#NoTranslationNoJustice. The illusionary right to translation in Italian crim...
 
Fundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal law
Fundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal lawFundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal law
Fundamental rights defense: strategic litigation EU crimilal law
 
Criminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalization
Criminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalizationCriminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalization
Criminalizzazione soccorso in mare - sea rescue criminalization
 
Mandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla salute
Mandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla saluteMandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla salute
Mandato di arresto europeo e diritto alla salute
 
OIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesa
OIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesaOIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesa
OIE e suo impatto nell’ordinamento interno: i diritti della difesa
 
Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...
Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...
Garanzie della difesa nei procedimenti di competenza della Procura europea - ...
 
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAE
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAEDiritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAE
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea: OIE e MAE
 
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europeaDiritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea
Diritti fondamentali e cooperazione penale europea
 
Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali.
Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali. Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali.
Europa, istruzioni per l'uso. MAE e difesa dei diritti fondamentali.
 
Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)
Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)
Diritti in epoca di pandemia (In difesa di..)
 
Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung.
Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung. Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung.
Schamlos! Kriminalisierung der Seenotrettung.
 
Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...
Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...
Human Rights defense, il ruolo dell'avvocato nella difesa dei diritti fondame...
 
Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders.
Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders. Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders.
Discorsi pubblici ostili. Rischi per human right defenders.
 
Difendere diritti, a quale costo?
Difendere diritti, a quale costo? Difendere diritti, a quale costo?
Difendere diritti, a quale costo?
 
".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...
".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...
".. to use or not to use? Risks and advantages of trial by videolink for defe...
 
European fair trial and effective participation rights
European fair trial and effective participation rightsEuropean fair trial and effective participation rights
European fair trial and effective participation rights
 
Right to a new trial under directive 343/16
Right to a new trial under directive 343/16Right to a new trial under directive 343/16
Right to a new trial under directive 343/16
 
Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.
Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.
Giustizia sospesa.Emergenza, diritto e diritti.
 
Cooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAE
Cooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAECooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAE
Cooperazione giudiziaria internazionale penale: estradizione e MAE
 

Recently uploaded

AI and Arbitration - Ethical considerations
AI and Arbitration - Ethical considerationsAI and Arbitration - Ethical considerations
AI and Arbitration - Ethical considerationsNino Sievi
 
Types of Security in Industrial Security
Types of Security in Industrial SecurityTypes of Security in Industrial Security
Types of Security in Industrial SecurityRJCubillo
 
POSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training Module
POSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training ModulePOSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training Module
POSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training Modulestudyneur
 
How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?
How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?
How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?BridgeWest.eu
 
2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdf
2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdf2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdf
2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdfJack Pringle
 
MSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdf
MSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdfMSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdf
MSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdfManiKandanKaleshwara
 
The Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance Environment
The Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance EnvironmentThe Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance Environment
The Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance EnvironmentUniversity of Ferrara
 
The Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in Manchester
The Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in ManchesterThe Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in Manchester
The Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in ManchesterBridgeWest.eu
 
SYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdf
SYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdfSYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdf
SYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdfSyed Muhammad Humza Hussain
 

Recently uploaded (10)

AI and Arbitration - Ethical considerations
AI and Arbitration - Ethical considerationsAI and Arbitration - Ethical considerations
AI and Arbitration - Ethical considerations
 
Types of Security in Industrial Security
Types of Security in Industrial SecurityTypes of Security in Industrial Security
Types of Security in Industrial Security
 
POSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training Module
POSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training ModulePOSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training Module
POSH Act 2013 Awareness And Training Module
 
How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?
How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?
How is Personal Injury Compensation Calculated?
 
2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdf
2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdf2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdf
2024-02-16 Building Soul Force- Changing to Stay Stable in Challenging Times.pdf
 
MSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdf
MSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdfMSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdf
MSME_Payment_New Rule for the payment audit.pdf
 
The Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance Environment
The Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance EnvironmentThe Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance Environment
The Transfer pricing agreements in the Cooperative Compliance Environment
 
Turn premiums into profit - MIJS 5726_04.pdf
Turn premiums into profit - MIJS 5726_04.pdfTurn premiums into profit - MIJS 5726_04.pdf
Turn premiums into profit - MIJS 5726_04.pdf
 
The Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in Manchester
The Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in ManchesterThe Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in Manchester
The Services of Our Criminal Solicitors in Manchester
 
SYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdf
SYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdfSYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdf
SYNOPSIS ON THE COMPANIES REGULATIONS, 2024 .pdf
 

Freedom of movement within the EU and extradition.

  • 1. HOW CAN FREE MOVEMENT RIGHTS IMPACT EU CITIZEN EXTRADITION TO A THIRD COUNTRY? NICOLA CANESTRINI LECCO, JUNE 24TH 2019
  • 3. Within the scope of application of the Treaties (.,), any discrimination on grounds of nationality shall be prohibited (art. 18 TFEU) Every citizen of the Union shall have the right to move and reside freely within the territory of the Member States (art. 21 TFEU)
  • 4. are restrictions to extradition for nationals of a ms discriminatory for other EU nationals?
  • 5. 1. Is a EU Member State required to extend a prohibition on the extradition of its own nationals to every EU citizen? 2. Does a citizen of an EU Member State which prohibits the extradition of its own nationals carry nationality bar with him when exercising his free movement rights in the EU ?
  • 6. 1. Is a EU Member State required to extend a prohibition on the extradition of its own nationals to every EU citizen?
  • 7. C-182/15, Petruhhin, 6 September 2016 Case C-247/17, Raugevicius, 13 November 2018 C-191/16, Pisciotti, 10 April 2018
  • 8. national rules of a Member State on extradition which give rise to a difference in treatment depending on whether the person concerned is a national of that Member State or a national of another Member State, in so far as they result in nationals of other Member States who have moved to the requested Member State not being granted the protection against extradition enjoyed by nationals of the latter Member State, are liable to affect the freedom of nationals of other Member States to move within the European Union (Petruhhin, 32; Pisciotti 44). Unequal treatment which allows the extradition of a Union citizen who is a national of a Member State other than the requested Member State, such as Mr Pisciotti, gives rise to a restriction of freedom of movement, within the meaning of Article 21 TFEU (Petruhhin, 33, Pisciotti 45).
  • 9. Restrictions to extradition based on nationality must be based on objective considerations and must be proportionate to the legitimate objective pursued (Runevič, 2011, 83; Petruhhin, 34, Pisciotti 46). The Court has held that the objective of preventing the risk of impunity for persons who have committed an offence is to be seen in the context of the prevention and combating of crime. That objective must be considered, in the context of the area of freedom, security and justice without internal frontiers referred to in Article 3(2) TEU, to be a legitimate objective of EU law (Petruhhin, 36 and 37; Pisciotti 47). However, measures which restrict a fundamental freedom, such as that laid down in Article 21 TFEU, may be justified by objective considerations only if they are necessary for the protection of the interests which they are intended to secure and only in so far as those objectives cannot be attained by less restrictive measures (Runevič-Vardyn and Wardyn, 88; Petruhhin, 38, Pisciotti 48).
  • 10. 2. Does a citizen of an EU Member State which prohibits the extradition of its own nationals “carry” nationality bar with him when exercising his free movement rights in the EU ?