SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 40
Download to read offline
#0 retweets: Things I hate
about digital advertising


        By Michael Goldstein
          strategist, nyc
            @mickeyg77
                 	
  
Since when did how become

more important than what 	
  
WHY DID AN OBSESSION WITH THE
SPREAD OF A MESSAGE OVERTAKE THE
        MESSAGE ITSELF?
                	
  
why do people think that
social media platforms are magic
tricks to get people to love your
             brand?
WHY are people treating Platforms like a

        message not a medium ?
                   	
  
They are just platforms.

Without great content, they
       are nothing.
Everyone got really excited over this
              tweet...
Many thought that if their brand
joined a conversation in a timely
  manner they would be able to
influence further conversation
      and drive brand love.
                	
  
WRONG.	
  
wOULD YOUR FRIENDS LOVE TO TALK ABOUT THEIR
WEEKEND ANTICS WITH YOUR NANNA IF SHE WANTED TO
           CHAT AT THE RIGHT TIME?	
  




                .	
  
wOULD YOU talk to your high school teacher about the
time you lost your virginity if he asked STRAIGHT away?!	
  
Would you talk to a stranger about your darkest
                    secrets ?	
  
PROBABLY NOT!	
  
But your nanna, a teacher and even a
stranger can all offer valuable
conversation.......	
  




              .........IT just has to be   RELEVANT	
  
Breaking down brand relevancy	
  
It comes down to three cs:




Content
Context
conversation	
  
Quick note!
I define online conversation as the relevant
intersection of context and content.
                                             CONVERSATION	
  


                      RELEVANCY	
  




               context 	
      content	
  
how did the famous Superbowl tweet use the
                  3 C s?
THEY HAD GREAT CONTENT.
(powered by the BRAND LOVE for Oreo)


THE APPROPRIATE CONTEXT.
(THE SUPERBOWL BLACKOUT)


And AUTHENTIC CONVERSATION.
(the relevant intersection of context and
content)
	
  
The lesson from Oreo s Superbowl tweet should
have been about how brands can use their
personality to comment in a relevant fashion on
current events.
INSTEAD, EVERYONE BECAME OBSESSED WITH THE TIMING
          OF brand TWEETS, NOT THE CONTENT OF TWEETS!




	
  
They even came up with a brand new buzzword:
            REAL TIME MARKETING 	
  
REAL TIME MARKETING did not go too well	
  
Time for a

Truth bomb.	
  
JUST BECAUSE YOU join a conversation,
	
  
         even in real time DOES NOT MEAN
        PEOPLE VAlUE WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY.	
  
Another way brands try to spread weak
       messages is through incentivized word of mouth,
	
  
       or worse, a beg for retweets or other forms of
                        engagement.
An incentivized piece of
	
  
       content is not only
       inauthentic.....



       It is advocacy prostitution ! 	
  
Just because you give someone
monetary incentive to engage with
you does not mean they genuinely
	
  


enjoy that engagement.....
	
  




advocacy
prostitution. 	
  
Strong communication will
	
  




         always gain momentum,
        regardless of platforms.
 
Chuck another shrimp
	
  




        on the barbie hit an
        infectious cultural
       friction that is a part
       of pop culture today.
 




       HOW MANY ReTweetS DID IT GET?	
  
 




       0 ReTweetS.	
  
 




       0 retweets.	
  
 




       0 retweets.	
  
 




       0 retweets.	
  
 




       0 retweets.	
  
 




       0 retweets.	
  
INFECTIOUS CONTENT IS NOT
       CREATED JUST THROUGH
	
  




       CLEVER USE OF PLATFORMS.

       iNFECTIOUS CONTENT IS
       CREATED BY INFECTIOUS
       CONTENT.	
  
             Thank you!


         Any thoughts or feedback tweet
                  @mickeyg77

       chuck another email on the internet ‒
        michaeldgoldstein77@gmail.com

More Related Content

What's hot

Fresh State of Social 2019 - September 4th
Fresh State of Social 2019 - September 4thFresh State of Social 2019 - September 4th
Fresh State of Social 2019 - September 4thRoderick Cremers
 
Toy Story 3's Social Media Campaign
Toy Story 3's Social Media CampaignToy Story 3's Social Media Campaign
Toy Story 3's Social Media Campaignkkorona
 
Social Media Strategy for creating Intellectual property
Social Media Strategy for creating Intellectual propertySocial Media Strategy for creating Intellectual property
Social Media Strategy for creating Intellectual propertySocial Media Strategy
 
Opinion corporate emotional responsibility
Opinion corporate emotional responsibilityOpinion corporate emotional responsibility
Opinion corporate emotional responsibilityKate Sieck, PhD
 
Social Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social Narrative
Social Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social NarrativeSocial Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social Narrative
Social Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social NarrativeRosetta Marketing
 
It's the dose that makes the poison
It's the dose that makes the poisonIt's the dose that makes the poison
It's the dose that makes the poisonPanos Papadopoulos
 
TACO BELL & FACEBOOK
TACO BELL & FACEBOOKTACO BELL & FACEBOOK
TACO BELL & FACEBOOKDolly Awati
 

What's hot (10)

Fresh State of Social 2019 - September 4th
Fresh State of Social 2019 - September 4thFresh State of Social 2019 - September 4th
Fresh State of Social 2019 - September 4th
 
Media Trust for managers
Media Trust for managersMedia Trust for managers
Media Trust for managers
 
Toy Story 3's Social Media Campaign
Toy Story 3's Social Media CampaignToy Story 3's Social Media Campaign
Toy Story 3's Social Media Campaign
 
Toy Story PR Plan
Toy Story PR PlanToy Story PR Plan
Toy Story PR Plan
 
Transmedia extract
Transmedia extractTransmedia extract
Transmedia extract
 
Social Media Strategy for creating Intellectual property
Social Media Strategy for creating Intellectual propertySocial Media Strategy for creating Intellectual property
Social Media Strategy for creating Intellectual property
 
Opinion corporate emotional responsibility
Opinion corporate emotional responsibilityOpinion corporate emotional responsibility
Opinion corporate emotional responsibility
 
Social Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social Narrative
Social Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social NarrativeSocial Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social Narrative
Social Media Storytelling: Using Wall Posts As a Social Narrative
 
It's the dose that makes the poison
It's the dose that makes the poisonIt's the dose that makes the poison
It's the dose that makes the poison
 
TACO BELL & FACEBOOK
TACO BELL & FACEBOOKTACO BELL & FACEBOOK
TACO BELL & FACEBOOK
 

Viewers also liked

Manufacturing a sense of urgency
Manufacturing a sense of urgency Manufacturing a sense of urgency
Manufacturing a sense of urgency Michael Goldstein
 
Examples of native advertising
Examples of native advertisingExamples of native advertising
Examples of native advertisingStackAdapt
 
Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience
Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience
Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience Michael Goldstein
 
Advertising in a digital world
Advertising in a digital world Advertising in a digital world
Advertising in a digital world EvolverHQ
 
The Marketers Guide to Native Advertising
The Marketers Guide to Native AdvertisingThe Marketers Guide to Native Advertising
The Marketers Guide to Native AdvertisingBrian Honigman
 
WTF Is Native Advertising?
WTF Is Native Advertising?WTF Is Native Advertising?
WTF Is Native Advertising?Ishraq Dhaly
 
Digital Advertising Training Presentation
Digital Advertising Training PresentationDigital Advertising Training Presentation
Digital Advertising Training PresentationMutlu Dogus Yildirim
 
2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices
2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices 2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices
2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices TripleLift
 
Digital Advertising (An Introduction)
Digital Advertising (An Introduction)Digital Advertising (An Introduction)
Digital Advertising (An Introduction)Farzin Fardiss
 
Digital advertising 101
Digital advertising 101Digital advertising 101
Digital advertising 101451 Marketing
 
Elements of a print ad
Elements of a print adElements of a print ad
Elements of a print adE.j. Gb
 
Sine Qua Non: Core Values and Content Strategy
Sine Qua Non: Core Values and Content StrategySine Qua Non: Core Values and Content Strategy
Sine Qua Non: Core Values and Content StrategyJonathon Colman
 
China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...
China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...
China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...Qianzhan Intelligence
 
Intresting changes in mongo 2.6
Intresting changes in mongo 2.6Intresting changes in mongo 2.6
Intresting changes in mongo 2.6David Murphy
 
China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...
China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...
China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...Qianzhan Intelligence
 
토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안
토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안
토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안Seonbae Kim
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Manufacturing a sense of urgency
Manufacturing a sense of urgency Manufacturing a sense of urgency
Manufacturing a sense of urgency
 
Examples of native advertising
Examples of native advertisingExamples of native advertising
Examples of native advertising
 
Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience
Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience
Boiler Room approach to cultivating and amplifying a fragmented audience
 
Advertising in a digital world
Advertising in a digital world Advertising in a digital world
Advertising in a digital world
 
The Marketers Guide to Native Advertising
The Marketers Guide to Native AdvertisingThe Marketers Guide to Native Advertising
The Marketers Guide to Native Advertising
 
WTF Is Native Advertising?
WTF Is Native Advertising?WTF Is Native Advertising?
WTF Is Native Advertising?
 
Digital Advertising Training Presentation
Digital Advertising Training PresentationDigital Advertising Training Presentation
Digital Advertising Training Presentation
 
2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices
2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices 2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices
2015 State of Native Advertising - Trends and Best Practices
 
Digital Advertising (An Introduction)
Digital Advertising (An Introduction)Digital Advertising (An Introduction)
Digital Advertising (An Introduction)
 
Digital advertising 101
Digital advertising 101Digital advertising 101
Digital advertising 101
 
Elements of a print ad
Elements of a print adElements of a print ad
Elements of a print ad
 
Print Ads
Print AdsPrint Ads
Print Ads
 
Sine Qua Non: Core Values and Content Strategy
Sine Qua Non: Core Values and Content StrategySine Qua Non: Core Values and Content Strategy
Sine Qua Non: Core Values and Content Strategy
 
Qodamah's Recommendation
Qodamah's RecommendationQodamah's Recommendation
Qodamah's Recommendation
 
China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...
China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...
China coal industry development trend and investment strategic decision repor...
 
모바일
모바일모바일
모바일
 
Intresting changes in mongo 2.6
Intresting changes in mongo 2.6Intresting changes in mongo 2.6
Intresting changes in mongo 2.6
 
China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...
China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...
China cardiovascular system drugs industry market demand forecast and investm...
 
토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안
토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안
토픽기반 컨텐츠관리와 실시간 개발 지원방안
 
Job analysis-bharat-employment
Job analysis-bharat-employmentJob analysis-bharat-employment
Job analysis-bharat-employment
 

Similar to #0retweets, things I hate about digital advertising

Social Media Marketing
Social Media Marketing Social Media Marketing
Social Media Marketing Kittyhawk
 
Social media what's all the chat about by jez jowett 2009
Social media   what's all the chat about   by jez jowett 2009Social media   what's all the chat about   by jez jowett 2009
Social media what's all the chat about by jez jowett 2009Jez Jowett
 
Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...
Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...
Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...LEAD
 
Future of Social Media + Trends 2016
Future of Social Media + Trends 2016Future of Social Media + Trends 2016
Future of Social Media + Trends 2016Brie Stewart
 
Socialmediaineducation
SocialmediaineducationSocialmediaineducation
SocialmediaineducationRidhwan Yusoff
 
How-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdf
How-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdfHow-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdf
How-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdfrodbart
 
Ohio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-Facebook
Ohio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-FacebookOhio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-Facebook
Ohio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-FacebookGreg Verdino
 
Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.
Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.
Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.Panos Papadopoulos
 
24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social Media
24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social Media24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social Media
24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social MediaFlightpath Inc
 
McCannBlue 7 Social Truths
McCannBlue 7 Social TruthsMcCannBlue 7 Social Truths
McCannBlue 7 Social TruthsMcCannBlue
 
Mission-Oriented Social Media
Mission-Oriented Social MediaMission-Oriented Social Media
Mission-Oriented Social MediaLiveWorkPlay
 
Is Social Media Really Effective?
Is Social Media Really Effective?Is Social Media Really Effective?
Is Social Media Really Effective?milaruiz4u
 
Your Authentic Self
Your Authentic SelfYour Authentic Self
Your Authentic SelfMike Russell
 
What is Social Media?
What is Social Media?What is Social Media?
What is Social Media?harshdutta
 
New Business Case Studies
New Business Case StudiesNew Business Case Studies
New Business Case Studiesmcgitj8
 

Similar to #0retweets, things I hate about digital advertising (20)

Social Media Marketing
Social Media Marketing Social Media Marketing
Social Media Marketing
 
3 Social Trends For 2014
3 Social Trends For 20143 Social Trends For 2014
3 Social Trends For 2014
 
Social media what's all the chat about by jez jowett 2009
Social media   what's all the chat about   by jez jowett 2009Social media   what's all the chat about   by jez jowett 2009
Social media what's all the chat about by jez jowett 2009
 
Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF
Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTFMesh12 Session - Social Media WTF
Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF
 
Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...
Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...
Main Presentation Slides from the #iprevent San Diego Conference - April 20-2...
 
Future of Social Media + Trends 2016
Future of Social Media + Trends 2016Future of Social Media + Trends 2016
Future of Social Media + Trends 2016
 
Socialmediaineducation
SocialmediaineducationSocialmediaineducation
Socialmediaineducation
 
How-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdf
How-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdfHow-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdf
How-to-use-social-media-responsibly.pdf
 
Content & conversation
Content & conversationContent & conversation
Content & conversation
 
Ohio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-Facebook
Ohio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-FacebookOhio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-Facebook
Ohio Library Council 2013 Keynote: Face-2-Facebook
 
Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.
Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.
Strangers when we meet. Advocacy and the changing face of communication.
 
Social Media 101
Social Media 101Social Media 101
Social Media 101
 
24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social Media
24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social Media24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social Media
24/Seven Why Candy Culture Fell in Love with Social Media
 
McCannBlue 7 Social Truths
McCannBlue 7 Social TruthsMcCannBlue 7 Social Truths
McCannBlue 7 Social Truths
 
Mission-Oriented Social Media
Mission-Oriented Social MediaMission-Oriented Social Media
Mission-Oriented Social Media
 
Is Social Media Really Effective?
Is Social Media Really Effective?Is Social Media Really Effective?
Is Social Media Really Effective?
 
Ma cultural policy and tourism - Social Media Class
Ma cultural policy and tourism - Social Media ClassMa cultural policy and tourism - Social Media Class
Ma cultural policy and tourism - Social Media Class
 
Your Authentic Self
Your Authentic SelfYour Authentic Self
Your Authentic Self
 
What is Social Media?
What is Social Media?What is Social Media?
What is Social Media?
 
New Business Case Studies
New Business Case StudiesNew Business Case Studies
New Business Case Studies
 

#0retweets, things I hate about digital advertising

  • 1. #0 retweets: Things I hate about digital advertising By Michael Goldstein strategist, nyc @mickeyg77  
  • 2. Since when did how become more important than what  
  • 3. WHY DID AN OBSESSION WITH THE SPREAD OF A MESSAGE OVERTAKE THE MESSAGE ITSELF?  
  • 4. why do people think that social media platforms are magic tricks to get people to love your brand?
  • 5. WHY are people treating Platforms like a message not a medium ?  
  • 6. They are just platforms. Without great content, they are nothing.
  • 7. Everyone got really excited over this tweet...
  • 8. Many thought that if their brand joined a conversation in a timely manner they would be able to influence further conversation and drive brand love.  
  • 10. wOULD YOUR FRIENDS LOVE TO TALK ABOUT THEIR WEEKEND ANTICS WITH YOUR NANNA IF SHE WANTED TO CHAT AT THE RIGHT TIME?   .  
  • 11. wOULD YOU talk to your high school teacher about the time you lost your virginity if he asked STRAIGHT away?!  
  • 12. Would you talk to a stranger about your darkest secrets ?  
  • 14. But your nanna, a teacher and even a stranger can all offer valuable conversation.......   .........IT just has to be RELEVANT  
  • 15. Breaking down brand relevancy  
  • 16. It comes down to three cs: Content Context conversation  
  • 17. Quick note! I define online conversation as the relevant intersection of context and content. CONVERSATION   RELEVANCY   context   content  
  • 18. how did the famous Superbowl tweet use the 3 C s?
  • 19. THEY HAD GREAT CONTENT. (powered by the BRAND LOVE for Oreo) THE APPROPRIATE CONTEXT. (THE SUPERBOWL BLACKOUT) And AUTHENTIC CONVERSATION. (the relevant intersection of context and content)  
  • 20. The lesson from Oreo s Superbowl tweet should have been about how brands can use their personality to comment in a relevant fashion on current events.
  • 21. INSTEAD, EVERYONE BECAME OBSESSED WITH THE TIMING OF brand TWEETS, NOT THE CONTENT OF TWEETS!  
  • 22. They even came up with a brand new buzzword: REAL TIME MARKETING  
  • 23. REAL TIME MARKETING did not go too well  
  • 24. Time for a Truth bomb.  
  • 25. JUST BECAUSE YOU join a conversation,   even in real time DOES NOT MEAN PEOPLE VAlUE WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY.  
  • 26. Another way brands try to spread weak messages is through incentivized word of mouth,   or worse, a beg for retweets or other forms of engagement.
  • 27. An incentivized piece of   content is not only inauthentic..... It is advocacy prostitution !  
  • 28. Just because you give someone monetary incentive to engage with you does not mean they genuinely   enjoy that engagement.....   advocacy prostitution.  
  • 29. Strong communication will   always gain momentum, regardless of platforms.
  • 30.  
  • 31. Chuck another shrimp   on the barbie hit an infectious cultural friction that is a part of pop culture today.
  • 32.   HOW MANY ReTweetS DID IT GET?  
  • 33.   0 ReTweetS.  
  • 34.   0 retweets.  
  • 35.   0 retweets.  
  • 36.   0 retweets.  
  • 37.   0 retweets.  
  • 38.   0 retweets.  
  • 39. INFECTIOUS CONTENT IS NOT CREATED JUST THROUGH   CLEVER USE OF PLATFORMS. iNFECTIOUS CONTENT IS CREATED BY INFECTIOUS CONTENT.  
  • 40.   Thank you! Any thoughts or feedback tweet @mickeyg77 chuck another email on the internet ‒ michaeldgoldstein77@gmail.com