Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education based on a Literature Review

Martin Ebner
Martin EbnerHead of Educational Technology at Graz University of Technology
Mixed Reality Handbooks for Mining Educa8on
Markus EBNER / HCI Interna3onal 2021, 24-29 July, Washington CD, USA
Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality
in Mining Education based on a Literature Review
Presentation of the Full Paper by Stefan Thurner, Lea
Daling, Markus Ebner, Martin Ebner, Sandra Schön
Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education Based on a Literature Review
Thurner, S., Daling, L., Ebner, Markus, Ebner, Martin, Schön, S.: Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education
Based on a Literature Review. In: Learning and Collaboration Technologies. Games and Virtual Environments for Learning. 8th
International Conference. HCII 2021, Proceedings, Part II. Switzerland: Springer. pp. 313-326 (2021).
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-3-030-77943-6_21
Presentation for the full paper
• The MiReBooks development and research project
• A literature research on evalua^on of MR tools in educa^on
• Discussion of results
• Applying the results on the didac^cal framework of MiReBooks
Agenda
Mixed Reality Handbooks for Mining Educa<on
• 45 papers selected (2015-2021)
• These included detailed descrip^on of formal evalua^on
• Classified according to an adapted grid by Duenser et al.*
• Each paper only classified due to their main research focus
Research Design
1. Objective Measurements
2. Subjective measurements
3. Qualitative analysis
4. Usability evaluation techniques
5. Informal evaluations
Classification Categories
Types of Evaluation Techniques by Year and Publication Date
Overview of Types of Evalua<on Techniques Found in all Publica<ons
• As expected, subjective methods most common type
• Followed by objective measurements and qualitative analysis
• Usability evaluation techniques still relatively rare
• Overall amount of evaluation in MR is steadily increasing
Discussion of the Literature Research Results
Applying the Results on the Didac<cal Framework of MiReBooks
Four phases of integrating MR technologies into teaching.
Markus EBNER
markus.ebner@tugraz.at
1 of 11

Recommended

Making of an Open Makerspace in a Secondary Vocational School in Austria: Dev... by
Making of an Open Makerspace in a Secondary Vocational School in Austria: Dev...Making of an Open Makerspace in a Secondary Vocational School in Austria: Dev...
Making of an Open Makerspace in a Secondary Vocational School in Austria: Dev...Martin Ebner
369 views16 slides
School Start Screening Tool by
School Start Screening ToolSchool Start Screening Tool
School Start Screening ToolMartin Ebner
340 views25 slides
Speech-based Learning with Amazon Alexa by
Speech-based Learning with Amazon AlexaSpeech-based Learning with Amazon Alexa
Speech-based Learning with Amazon AlexaMartin Ebner
321 views10 slides
6 24 08 IU20 Secondary Math Conference by
6 24 08 IU20 Secondary Math Conference6 24 08 IU20 Secondary Math Conference
6 24 08 IU20 Secondary Math Conferencesspengler
497 views29 slides
Digital Learning Plan Overview - 2014 Superintendents Conference by
Digital Learning Plan Overview - 2014 Superintendents ConferenceDigital Learning Plan Overview - 2014 Superintendents Conference
Digital Learning Plan Overview - 2014 Superintendents Conferencemjsamber
511 views8 slides
Developing a WERA International Research Network on Didactics - Learning and ... by
Developing a WERA International Research Network on Didactics - Learning and ...Developing a WERA International Research Network on Didactics - Learning and ...
Developing a WERA International Research Network on Didactics - Learning and ...Brian Hudson
806 views19 slides

More Related Content

Similar to Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education based on a Literature Review

Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu... by
Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu...Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu...
Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu...Jari Laru
1.8K views15 slides
Applying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia Quot Narratives by
Applying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia  Quot NarrativesApplying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia  Quot Narratives
Applying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia Quot NarrativesKaren Benoit
3 views20 slides
2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English by
2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English
2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of EnglishAshley Smith
3 views43 slides
Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ... by
Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ...Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ...
Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ...Marianne Riis
426 views13 slides
References and Sources on Educational Design Research by
References and Sources on Educational Design ResearchReferences and Sources on Educational Design Research
References and Sources on Educational Design ResearchManuel Herrera
271 views14 slides
ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019 by
ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019
ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019Saara Nissinen
66 views17 slides

Similar to Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education based on a Literature Review(20)

Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu... by Jari Laru
Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu...Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu...
Scaffolding collaborative learning with cognitive tools based on mobile compu...
Jari Laru1.8K views
Applying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia Quot Narratives by Karen Benoit
Applying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia  Quot NarrativesApplying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia  Quot Narratives
Applying An Analytic Writing Rubric To Children S Hpermedia Quot Narratives
Karen Benoit3 views
2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English by Ashley Smith
2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English
2019 Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English
Ashley Smith3 views
Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ... by Marianne Riis
Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ...Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ...
Development of a Pedagogical Design Matrix - for ICT-based Boundary Crossing ...
Marianne Riis426 views
References and Sources on Educational Design Research by Manuel Herrera
References and Sources on Educational Design ResearchReferences and Sources on Educational Design Research
References and Sources on Educational Design Research
Manuel Herrera271 views
ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019 by Saara Nissinen
ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019
ITK Doctoral Consortium 20.3.2019
Saara Nissinen66 views
Designing Effective Smart City Learning by Pen Lister
Designing Effective Smart City LearningDesigning Effective Smart City Learning
Designing Effective Smart City Learning
Pen Lister355 views
Making connections through multimodal tasks in virtual exchanges- IAEI Interc... by Susana Galante
Making connections through multimodal tasks in virtual exchanges- IAEI Interc...Making connections through multimodal tasks in virtual exchanges- IAEI Interc...
Making connections through multimodal tasks in virtual exchanges- IAEI Interc...
Susana Galante46 views
Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English (2016) by Erin Taylor
Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English (2016)Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English (2016)
Annotated Bibliography Of Research In The Teaching Of English (2016)
Erin Taylor2 views
Edx 3270 literacy slideshow w0099703 by lxdrury
Edx 3270 literacy slideshow w0099703Edx 3270 literacy slideshow w0099703
Edx 3270 literacy slideshow w0099703
lxdrury384 views
EDX 3270 Literacy Education W0099703 by lxdrury
EDX 3270 Literacy Education W0099703EDX 3270 Literacy Education W0099703
EDX 3270 Literacy Education W0099703
lxdrury862 views
Learning lines for geoSpatial thinking: GI Learner Project by Karl Donert
Learning lines for geoSpatial thinking: GI Learner ProjectLearning lines for geoSpatial thinking: GI Learner Project
Learning lines for geoSpatial thinking: GI Learner Project
Karl Donert617 views
The dynamics of knowledge creation: academics' changing writing practices – i... by Queen's University Belfast
The dynamics of knowledge creation: academics' changing writing practices – i...The dynamics of knowledge creation: academics' changing writing practices – i...
The dynamics of knowledge creation: academics' changing writing practices – i...
Social Software and Web2.0 in Teacher Education and Teacher Training (Report) by Marion R. Gruber
Social Software and Web2.0 in Teacher Education and Teacher Training (Report)Social Software and Web2.0 in Teacher Education and Teacher Training (Report)
Social Software and Web2.0 in Teacher Education and Teacher Training (Report)
Marion R. Gruber592 views

More from Martin Ebner

Maker Education by
Maker EducationMaker Education
Maker EducationMartin Ebner
306 views60 slides
Digitalisierung der Lehre – warum, wozu, wie? by
Digitalisierung der Lehre –  warum, wozu, wie?Digitalisierung der Lehre –  warum, wozu, wie?
Digitalisierung der Lehre – warum, wozu, wie?Martin Ebner
495 views56 slides
Effects of Remote Learning on Practitioner Integration by
Effects of Remote Learning on Practitioner IntegrationEffects of Remote Learning on Practitioner Integration
Effects of Remote Learning on Practitioner IntegrationMartin Ebner
425 views33 slides
The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr... by
The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr...The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr...
The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr...Martin Ebner
2K views14 slides
Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ... by
Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ...Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ...
Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ...Martin Ebner
2.1K views14 slides
www – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuell by
www – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuellwww – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuell
www – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuellMartin Ebner
406 views31 slides

More from Martin Ebner(20)

Digitalisierung der Lehre – warum, wozu, wie? by Martin Ebner
Digitalisierung der Lehre –  warum, wozu, wie?Digitalisierung der Lehre –  warum, wozu, wie?
Digitalisierung der Lehre – warum, wozu, wie?
Martin Ebner495 views
Effects of Remote Learning on Practitioner Integration by Martin Ebner
Effects of Remote Learning on Practitioner IntegrationEffects of Remote Learning on Practitioner Integration
Effects of Remote Learning on Practitioner Integration
Martin Ebner425 views
The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr... by Martin Ebner
The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr...The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr...
The relation of prior IT usage, IT skills and field of study: A multiple corr...
Martin Ebner2K views
Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ... by Martin Ebner
Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ...Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ...
Change of IT equipment and communication applications used by first-semester ...
Martin Ebner2.1K views
www – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuell by Martin Ebner
www – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuellwww – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuell
www – was wirkt weiter? Hochschule virtuell
Martin Ebner406 views
TU Graz Lessons Learnt COVID-19 & Digitalisierungsprojekte in der Lehre by Martin Ebner
TU Graz Lessons Learnt COVID-19 & Digitalisierungsprojekte in der LehreTU Graz Lessons Learnt COVID-19 & Digitalisierungsprojekte in der Lehre
TU Graz Lessons Learnt COVID-19 & Digitalisierungsprojekte in der Lehre
Martin Ebner412 views
Digitale Kompetenzen – vom europäischen Rahmenwerk zum Online-Kurs by Martin Ebner
Digitale Kompetenzen – vom europäischen Rahmenwerk zum Online-KursDigitale Kompetenzen – vom europäischen Rahmenwerk zum Online-Kurs
Digitale Kompetenzen – vom europäischen Rahmenwerk zum Online-Kurs
Martin Ebner392 views
MOOC map (Version 3) by Martin Ebner
MOOC map (Version 3)MOOC map (Version 3)
MOOC map (Version 3)
Martin Ebner276 views
ReDesign your lecture Canvas [eng] by Martin Ebner
ReDesign your lecture Canvas [eng]ReDesign your lecture Canvas [eng]
ReDesign your lecture Canvas [eng]
Martin Ebner217 views
ReDesign your lecture Canvas [de] by Martin Ebner
ReDesign your lecture Canvas [de]ReDesign your lecture Canvas [de]
ReDesign your lecture Canvas [de]
Martin Ebner171 views
MOOC-Maker Canvas [eng] by Martin Ebner
MOOC-Maker Canvas [eng]MOOC-Maker Canvas [eng]
MOOC-Maker Canvas [eng]
Martin Ebner684 views
MOOC-Maker Canvas [de] by Martin Ebner
MOOC-Maker Canvas [de]MOOC-Maker Canvas [de]
MOOC-Maker Canvas [de]
Martin Ebner1.3K views
Digitale Lehre in Zeiten von COVID-19 an einer Technischen Universität by Martin Ebner
Digitale Lehre in Zeiten von COVID-19 an einer Technischen UniversitätDigitale Lehre in Zeiten von COVID-19 an einer Technischen Universität
Digitale Lehre in Zeiten von COVID-19 an einer Technischen Universität
Martin Ebner701 views
MOOCs als Teil des zukünftigen digitalen Lernens by Martin Ebner
MOOCs als Teil des zukünftigen digitalen Lernens MOOCs als Teil des zukünftigen digitalen Lernens
MOOCs als Teil des zukünftigen digitalen Lernens
Martin Ebner226 views
Der Ansatz der „Citizen Science“ bei der Erstellung von Lehrmaterialien in ei... by Martin Ebner
Der Ansatz der „Citizen Science“ bei der Erstellung von Lehrmaterialien in ei...Der Ansatz der „Citizen Science“ bei der Erstellung von Lehrmaterialien in ei...
Der Ansatz der „Citizen Science“ bei der Erstellung von Lehrmaterialien in ei...
Martin Ebner658 views
Implementation fo Interactive Learning Objects for German Language Acquisitio... by Martin Ebner
Implementation fo Interactive Learning Objects for German Language Acquisitio...Implementation fo Interactive Learning Objects for German Language Acquisitio...
Implementation fo Interactive Learning Objects for German Language Acquisitio...
Martin Ebner552 views
Practitioner Integration in Computational Thinking Education by Martin Ebner
Practitioner Integration in Computational Thinking EducationPractitioner Integration in Computational Thinking Education
Practitioner Integration in Computational Thinking Education
Martin Ebner507 views
The use of Alexa for mass education by Martin Ebner
The use of Alexa for mass educationThe use of Alexa for mass education
The use of Alexa for mass education
Martin Ebner511 views
Digitalisierung der Lehre - was lernen wir aus der Corona-Krise? by Martin Ebner
Digitalisierung der Lehre - was lernen wir aus der Corona-Krise?Digitalisierung der Lehre - was lernen wir aus der Corona-Krise?
Digitalisierung der Lehre - was lernen wir aus der Corona-Krise?
Martin Ebner708 views

Recently uploaded

ICS3211_lecture 08_2023.pdf by
ICS3211_lecture 08_2023.pdfICS3211_lecture 08_2023.pdf
ICS3211_lecture 08_2023.pdfVanessa Camilleri
187 views30 slides
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx by
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptxAUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptxiammrhaywood
89 views44 slides
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue Doe by
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue DoeWomen from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue Doe
Women from Hackney’s History: Stoke Newington by Sue DoeHistory of Stoke Newington
157 views21 slides
MercerJesse2.1Doc.pdf by
MercerJesse2.1Doc.pdfMercerJesse2.1Doc.pdf
MercerJesse2.1Doc.pdfjessemercerail
237 views5 slides
Gopal Chakraborty Memorial Quiz 2.0 Prelims.pptx by
Gopal Chakraborty Memorial Quiz 2.0 Prelims.pptxGopal Chakraborty Memorial Quiz 2.0 Prelims.pptx
Gopal Chakraborty Memorial Quiz 2.0 Prelims.pptxDebapriya Chakraborty
684 views81 slides
Jibachha publishing Textbook.docx by
Jibachha publishing Textbook.docxJibachha publishing Textbook.docx
Jibachha publishing Textbook.docxDrJibachhaSahVetphys
47 views14 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx by iammrhaywood
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptxAUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx
AUDIENCE - BANDURA.pptx
iammrhaywood89 views
AI Tools for Business and Startups by Svetlin Nakov
AI Tools for Business and StartupsAI Tools for Business and Startups
AI Tools for Business and Startups
Svetlin Nakov111 views
Psychology KS5 by WestHatch
Psychology KS5Psychology KS5
Psychology KS5
WestHatch103 views
CUNY IT Picciano.pptx by apicciano
CUNY IT Picciano.pptxCUNY IT Picciano.pptx
CUNY IT Picciano.pptx
apicciano54 views
11.30.23 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx by mary850239
11.30.23 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx11.30.23 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
11.30.23 Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
mary850239167 views
Ch. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptx by Rommel Regala
Ch. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptxCh. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptx
Ch. 7 Political Participation and Elections.pptx
Rommel Regala105 views
Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November) by Esquimalt MFRC
Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November)Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November)
Monthly Information Session for MV Asterix (November)
Esquimalt MFRC58 views
Sociology KS5 by WestHatch
Sociology KS5Sociology KS5
Sociology KS5
WestHatch76 views
Classification of crude drugs.pptx by GayatriPatra14
Classification of crude drugs.pptxClassification of crude drugs.pptx
Classification of crude drugs.pptx
GayatriPatra1492 views
Pharmaceutical Inorganic chemistry UNIT-V Radiopharmaceutical.pptx by Ms. Pooja Bhandare
Pharmaceutical Inorganic chemistry UNIT-V Radiopharmaceutical.pptxPharmaceutical Inorganic chemistry UNIT-V Radiopharmaceutical.pptx
Pharmaceutical Inorganic chemistry UNIT-V Radiopharmaceutical.pptx

Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education based on a Literature Review

  • 1. Mixed Reality Handbooks for Mining Educa8on Markus EBNER / HCI Interna3onal 2021, 24-29 July, Washington CD, USA Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education based on a Literature Review Presentation of the Full Paper by Stefan Thurner, Lea Daling, Markus Ebner, Martin Ebner, Sandra Schön
  • 2. Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education Based on a Literature Review Thurner, S., Daling, L., Ebner, Markus, Ebner, Martin, Schön, S.: Evaluation Design for Learning with Mixed Reality in Mining Education Based on a Literature Review. In: Learning and Collaboration Technologies. Games and Virtual Environments for Learning. 8th International Conference. HCII 2021, Proceedings, Part II. Switzerland: Springer. pp. 313-326 (2021). https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-3-030-77943-6_21 Presentation for the full paper
  • 3. • The MiReBooks development and research project • A literature research on evalua^on of MR tools in educa^on • Discussion of results • Applying the results on the didac^cal framework of MiReBooks Agenda
  • 4. Mixed Reality Handbooks for Mining Educa<on
  • 5. • 45 papers selected (2015-2021) • These included detailed descrip^on of formal evalua^on • Classified according to an adapted grid by Duenser et al.* • Each paper only classified due to their main research focus Research Design
  • 6. 1. Objective Measurements 2. Subjective measurements 3. Qualitative analysis 4. Usability evaluation techniques 5. Informal evaluations Classification Categories
  • 7. Types of Evaluation Techniques by Year and Publication Date
  • 8. Overview of Types of Evalua<on Techniques Found in all Publica<ons
  • 9. • As expected, subjective methods most common type • Followed by objective measurements and qualitative analysis • Usability evaluation techniques still relatively rare • Overall amount of evaluation in MR is steadily increasing Discussion of the Literature Research Results
  • 10. Applying the Results on the Didac<cal Framework of MiReBooks Four phases of integrating MR technologies into teaching.