7 Media Representations of Crime


Published on

Published in: News & Politics
1 Like
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

7 Media Representations of Crime

  1. 1. Media and crime • The media love crime and use it extensively in their war with other papers for circulation and profitability
  2. 2. CRIME AND THE MEDIA QUESTION: Are most rapes committed by: a) Strangers? (stranger danger) b) Someone the victim knows? Can we evaluate this answer? It is probable that a significant proportion of rapes are never reported and/or recorded so difficult to say.
  3. 3. Soothill & Walby (1991) • Studied the coverage of rape in newspapers • Found that newspaper reporting of rape cases increased from under a quarter of all cases in 1951 to over one third in 1985 • Found that the coverage of rape cases focuses on identifying a ‘sex fiend’ or ‘beast’ often with the use of labels like ‘the balaclava rapist’ • The resulting distorted picture of rape is one of serial attacks carried out by psychopathic strangers. The reality is in most cases the victim knows the rapist (research shows that 45% of rapes were by partners) • In other words the media DISTORT the picture of crime we get from crime statistics (official, victim surveys, self-report studies)
  4. 4. CRIME AND THE MEDIA • ACTIVITY 1 – THE DISTORTED NATURE OF CRIME • Pick out some more appropriate examples of how the media distort crime p119 of books and note them on your sheets around the distorted images.
  5. 5. News Values
  6. 6. Gatekeepers G A T Mass of news, issues, views every day 24/7 E G G A A T T E E Gatekeepers include news editors, owners of newspapers and journalists and reporters. They decide just which news stories are going to feature in the news. Crime stories are very attractive to gatekeepers, they are very good for selling papers and enabling publications to hold or even increase their share of the market.
  7. 7. News Values • The distorted picture of crime painted by the news media reflects the fact that the news is a SOCIAL CONSTRUCTION • News does not simply exist out there waiting to be gathered in and written up by the journalist. It is a social construct – the outcome of a social process in which only stories that make people buy newspapers will be printed – all the time stories are being considered - then some are selected, some are rejected. • As Cohen & Young (1973) argued news is not discovered but MANUFACTURED
  8. 8. NEWSWORTHY and NEWS VALUES How are crime stories selected? Through NEWS VALUES – a set of criteria which editors and journalists decide if a story is NEWSWORTHY Key news values influencing selection of crime stories: 1. Immediacy 2. Dramatisation: action + excitement 3. Personalisation: human interest stories about individuals 4. Higher-status persons + celebrities 5. Simplification: eliminating shades of grey/ clear good and evil, ‘innocent victim’/wicked perpetrator’ extreme 6. Novelty or unexpectedness: a new angle 7. Risk: victim-centred stories about vulnerability + fear 8. Violence: especially visible and spectacular acts
  9. 9. a) Oscar Pistorious REEVA STEENKAMP'Sleeping at Oscar's tonight': Final text reveals tired model decided to stay over at last minute 25 Feb 2013 11:19 The 29-year-old model had planned to see Oscar Pistorius and then drive back to her best friend's house but it got too late for her to travel home Tragic Reeva Steenkamp wasn't due to stay with boyfriend Oscar Pistorius the night she died but changed her mind because it became too late for her to drive home safely, it has been revealed. The 29-year-old model had planned to see Oscar and then drive back to her best friend's house. But it got late and Reeva was tired and, at the last moment, she decided to stay over a decision that cost Reeva her life. She sent a text to the father of her best friend, Kim, to let him know that she would not be returning that night. Cecil Myers told South Africa's City Press newspaper: "I've got this thing with all three children (Reeva, and his daughters, Kim and Gina), if they don't come home at night, they must text me." "Then Reeva sent the (SMS) message: 'Hi guys, I'm too tired. It's too far to drive. I'm sleeping at Oscar's tonight. See you tomorrow'. Just hours later, Reeva was shot dead. Shot four times, she died in Pistorius' arms on Valentine's Day.
  10. 10. b) Raoul Moat The 2010 Northumbria Police manhunt was a major police operation in North East England in which armed police officers were under the command of the Northumbria Police force to attempt to apprehend Raoul Moat, a 37-year-old man from Newcastle upon Tyne who had been recently released from Durham Prison. Moat, armed with a sawn-off shotgun, shot three people two days after his release: his ex-girlfriend Samantha Stobbart, her new partner Chris Brown, and police officer David Rathband. Brown was killed, while Rathband remained in hospital for nearly three weeks and was permanently blinded. Seriously injured Stobbart also remains hospitalised. After six days on the run, Moat was recognised by police, leading to a standoff. After nearly six hours of negotiation, Moat shot himself in the early hours of the following morning.
  11. 11. APRIL JONES • April Jones, 5, went missing from her home town of Machynlleth, Powys, Wales, on October 1, 2012. Police and hundreds of residents launched a major search over fears she had been snatched off the street. April was last seen getting into a light coloured van which drove off in Machynlleth at 7.30pm. She had been playing on her bike with friends near her home on the Brynygog estate.
  12. 12. Mark Duggan • Mark Duggan Inquest: Marksman Gives Evidence • The police officer who shot Mark Duggan describes the "freeze frame" moment when he believed the suspect was about to fire. • The police marksman who killed Mark Duggan has said he had "an honestly held belief" that the suspect was about to shoot him. • Known only as V53, the experienced firearms officer was giving evidence at the inquest in London. • He described how he was part of a Metropolitan Police operation tracking Mark Duggan through London on August 4, 2011. • Intelligence reports had said that Mr Duggan had gone in a minicab to pick up a gun from an associate. • The inquest saw dummy images of where the shots entered Mr Duggan's bodyAfter the "hard stop" of the minicab Mr Duggan moved out of the vehicle. • V53 told the inquest: "He has an object in his right hand, he has a handgun in his right hand." • Shouts of "liar" were heard from the public gallery.
  13. 13. c)March 7th 2011 • Superheroes' teenage nicks • BRITAIN'S youngest real-life superheroes have joined forces to fight street crime. • Masked crusaders Night Warrior and The Man In Black, both 18, teamed up like Batman and Robin. • They have already hunted down a suspected drugs gang and tipped off cops about their den in North London. • Hat-wearing The Man In Black said he has been in a few scrapes tackling crime - and was cut on the hand by one thug. But he only uses an UMBRELLA for protection. • He revealed his identity as unemployed Joseph Falica, of Harrow, who started patrols two years ago. He said: "I'm willing to risk my life." • Spandex-clad Night Warrior, who has joined him on patrol in London, is from Salford, Gtr Manchester. He said: "I'm saving up for a bullet-proof vest." • Last week The Sun told of at least 16 other real-life superheroes on Britain's streets.
  14. 14. Madeleine McCann Kidnap 'Was PrePlanned' • Men seen lurking around the McCanns' apartment and potentially bogus charity collectors prompt new theories on the disappearance. • he case suggests it was a premeditated abduction. • New theories have shifted detectives' focus to a second, later sighting of a man carrying a child at around the same time the three-year-old's parents discovered she was missing. • Detective Chief Inspector Andy Redwood said he hoped to gather more information about men seen near the McCanns' apartment on several occasions in the week she disappeared. • When asked whether he believed the family was being watched, he said: "The physical evidence demonstrates to us that there are people, unexplained people, possibly doing just that.
  15. 15. Widow sobs as suspects deny killing soldier hero Lee Rigby • Rebecca Rigby, 30, dabbed her eyes with a handkerchief as Michael -Adebolajo and Michael Adebowale denied the charges against them. • She was comforted by -relatives as she watched the pair appear via video link from high -security Belmarsh Prison in south-east London. • Adebolajo, 28, and Adebowale, 22, also denied the attempted murder of an unnamed police officer on the same day, May 22, that the 25-year-old private was killed. • And they entered not guilty pleas to a separate charge of conspiring to murder a police officer. The pair told Mr Justice Sweeney that they wanted to be known by their adopted names, Mujahid Abu Hamza and Ismail Ibn Abdullah.
  16. 16. White Widow Samantha Lewthwaite feared to be planning more deadly attacks • • • • • • • Files on her seized computer show her relentless quest for mass carnage - and that she has the funds to carry it out Police hunting for the White Widow Samantha Lewthwaite fear she is planning more deadly attacks after masterminding the Nairobi shopping centre massacre. It has been revealed that documents found on her laptop show the British terror suspect had been plotting to target a mall in Kenya’s capital for at least two years. Officers say files on the computer clearly show her relentless quest to commit mass carnage and that she has the funds and knowledge to carry it out. She has fuelled her obsession by studying writings that advocate the cold-blooded killing of women and children. A source said: “The international security community is working round the clock to identify her whereabouts and capture her without delay. “The lives of hundreds, if not thousands, of innocent people are at risk if she is able to launch an attack. She needs to be stopped in her tracks before it is too late. "She is a danger to the world.”
  17. 17. d) Herbie Hyde Boxing champ Herbie Hide peddles cocaine and offers to throw title fight Shame ... Herbie Hide WORLD EXCLUSIVE By MAZHER MAHMOOD Published: 16 hrs ago FORMER boxing world champ Herbie Hide is today exposed as a drug Mr Fixit ready to throw a title fight for £1million. The 41-year-old British heavyweight arranged for cocaine to be delivered to undercover Sun reporters by a dealer who repeatedly boasted about his close links to the fighter. And Hide bragged about how he would fix a showpiece bout, saying: “Whoever, which round you want, whatever you want as long as you put the money. “I can guarantee one thing, you can get whoever is the favourite, you can get them to step down for a million pounds.
  18. 18. e) Jimmy Saville Jimmy Savile scandal: Report reveals decades of abuse • Adults and children, including a boy of eight, were abused by Jimmy Savile, a report detailing allegations over 50 years has revealed. • Police and the NSPCC outlined offences by the late presenter at venues including 13 hospitals and a hospice. • Some 214 crimes were recorded across 28 police force areas, including 34 of rape or penetration, the report said. • The CPS apologised for missing the opportunity to prosecute Savile in 2009, while he was still alive. • The Metropolitan Police said the victims' accounts painted a "compelling picture of widespread sexual abuse by a predatory sex offender", and Cdr Peter Spindler, who is leading the investigation, said Savile had "groomed the nation". • The NSPCC said Savile had been one of the most prolific sex offenders in its 129-year history.
  19. 19. FICTIONAL REPRESENTATIONS OF CRIME • ACTIVITY 3 – how many programmes, books, novels, plays can we think of which are about crime? • As well as from the news media we get a lot of our images of crime from these
  21. 21. FICTIONAL REPRESENTATIONS OF CRIME • Mandel (1984): from 1945-1984 estimates 10 billion crime thrillers sold worldwide • Around 25% of prime time TV and 20% of films are crime shows or movies • Fictional representations of crime, criminals and victims follow what Surette (1998) calls the ‘law of opposites’ – the opposite of the official statistics
  22. 22. FICTIONAL REPRESENTATIONS OF CRIME “FACT”- from official statistics FICTION – books, films..... 1 Property crime 2 3 4 Violence, drugs and sex crimes
  23. 23. Quiz on what we have covered 1 Do the media over or under represent crime and deviance? 2 In 1993 Williams & Dickinson found British newspapers devote that percentage of their news space to crime? 3 Write down two ways in which the media might distort our perception of crime 4 What do we call those editors, journalists and newspaper owners who CONSTRUCT the news? 5 Who said that news is not discovered but MANUFACTURED? 6 Write down 5 news values 7 The Oscar Pistorious case – which news values are present there? 8 Real life murders are mainly the result ofbrawls and domestic disputes; however in fiction they are mainl the result of what?
  24. 24. Two different views of media audiences Hypodermic Syringe Theory Decoding Approach
  25. 25. b) John Galliano • Paris Prosecutors Office have decided to put Galliano on trial over his alleged racial insults. The proceedings could take place in the second quarter of the year. If found guilty the designer could face six months imprisonment or a €22,500 (£19,085) fine. • FASHION guru John Galliano was filmed having a vile racist rant during which he declared: "I love Hitler." • The British designer - an alleged Jew hater then tells a horrified woman: "People like you would be dead. Your mothers, your forefathers, would all be f****** gassed."