5. Cal
Discipline
Master
#1 - cross-ref to
see if it is true
John pushed me
and punched me!!
#2 - using purpose,
check if there are
any reasons to hide
info
Trying to get
DM to blame John John is at fault
Biased against john
to achieve purpose!
would be biased
against john so
that he will not
be blamed!
6. Cal
Discipline
Master
#1 - cross-ref to
see if it is true
John pushed me
and punched me!!
#2 - using purpose,
check if there are
any reasons to hide
info
Trying to get
DM to blame John John is at fault
Biased against john
to achieve purpose!
would be biased
against john so
that he will not
be blamed!
Today’s
focus
7. 1) Know the requirements in
answering a reliability question.
objectives
2) Able to determine the reliability of
a source using purpose.
10. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
11. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
Catholics in NI
(stated in Source B)
“nearly killed us”
“want to squash our
culture”
12. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
Catholics in NI
(stated in Source B)
“nearly killed us”
“want to squash our
culture”
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics.
13. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics.
14. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred.
15. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot.
16. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot.
Realise for the message, evidence, and purpose,
it’s all about Catholics in NI to answer the qns,
and not some random inference?
17. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot.
Let’s consider: Given that he is a Protestant, is
there any reason for him to be biased with
regards to the Catholics?
To answer the QNS!
18. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot. As a Protestant, the
interviewee would be biased against the Catholics as they are on opposing sides of
the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Let’s consider: Given that he is a Protestant, is
there any reason for him to be biased with
regards to the Catholics?
To answer the QNS!
19. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot. As a Protestant, the
interviewee would be biased against the Catholics as they are on opposing sides of
the conflict in Northern Ireland.
20. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot. As a Protestant, the
interviewee would be biased against the Catholics as they are on opposing sides of
the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Ok so he has reasons to be biased against the Catholics.
Is he biased against the Catholics in the source (which
means hiding things from us about the Catholics)
to achieve his purpose,
21. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot. As a Protestant, the
interviewee would be biased against the Catholics as they are on opposing sides of
the conflict in Northern Ireland. Also, the Protestant was biased against the
Catholics to achieve his purpose
Ok so he has reasons to be biased against the Catholics.
Is he biased against the Catholics in the source (which
means hiding things from us about the Catholics)
to achieve his purpose,
22. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot. As a Protestant, the
interviewee would be biased against the Catholics as they are on opposing sides of
the conflict in Northern Ireland. Also, the Protestant was biased against the
Catholics to achieve his purpose
Ah. So he since he has reasons to hide things about the
Catholics, and he did that to achieve his purpose, I’m
quite sure he is hiding something. So he’s not reliable!
23. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
I cannot believe what this source says about the Catholics in Northern Ireland.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot. As a Protestant, the
interviewee would be biased against the Catholics as they are on opposing sides of
the conflict in Northern Ireland. Also, the Protestant was biased against the
Catholics to achieve his purpose. Therefore, I cannot believe what this source says
about the Catholics in Northern Ireland.
Ah. So he since he has reasons to hide things about the
Catholics, and he did that to achieve his purpose, I’m
quite sure he is hiding something. So he’s not reliable!
24. Can you believe what this source says about the Catholics in NI? EYA.
I cannot believe what this source says about the Catholics in Northern Ireland.
The Protestant interviewed was trying to convince the British that the Catholics in
Northern Ireland are a threat to Protestants. This is because the source states that
the Catholics “nearly killed us” and “want to squash our culture”. This means that
the Protestants may not survive because of the Catholics. This was published on a
British news interview, after a major riot between the Catholics and Protestants
occurred. Therefore, the Protestant was trying to garner the support of the British to
side with the Protestants and blame the Catholics for the riot. As a Protestant, the
interviewee would be biased against the Catholics as they are on opposing sides of
the conflict in Northern Ireland. Also, the Protestant was biased against the
Catholics to achieve his purpose. Therefore, I cannot believe what this source says
about the Catholics in Northern Ireland.
26. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
27. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
Catholics support IRA?
“I sincerely believe that the armed struggle
by the IRA caused embarrassment and
ridicule for the British Government
throughout the world, forcing the British
Government to resolve the issue by giving
more freedom to the Catholics
28. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
Catholics support IRA?
“I sincerely believe that the armed struggle
by the IRA caused embarrassment and
ridicule for the British Government
throughout the world, forcing the British
Government to resolve the issue by giving
more freedom to the Catholics
Not a single word on
support. So what does this
mean?
29. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
Catholics support IRA?
“I sincerely believe that the armed struggle
by the IRA caused embarrassment and
ridicule for the British Government
throughout the world, forcing the British
Government to resolve the issue by giving
more freedom to the Catholics
This means that the
Catholics support the IRA as
it helped them gained
freedom.
30. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
Catholics support IRA?
“I sincerely believe that the armed struggle
by the IRA caused embarrassment and
ridicule for the British Government
throughout the world, forcing the British
Government to resolve the issue by giving
more freedom to the Catholics
This means that the
Catholics support the IRA as
it helped them gained
freedom.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom.
31. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom.
32. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict.
33. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts.
34. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts.
Let’s consider: Given that he is from a political
party related to the IRA, would he be biased
towards / against the IRA?
To answer the QNS!
35. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Let’s consider: Given that he is from a political
party related to the IRA, would he be biased
towards / against the IRA?
To answer the QNS!
36. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
37. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Ok so he has reasons to be biased towards the IRA. Is he
biased towards the IRA in the source (which means hiding
things from us about the IRA) to achieve his purpose?
38. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Also, Martin McGuinness was biased for the IRA to achieve his purpose.
Ok so he has reasons to be biased towards the IRA. Is he
biased towards the IRA in the source (which means hiding
things from us about the IRA) to achieve his purpose?
39. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Also, Martin McGuinness was biased for the IRA to achieve his purpose.
40. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Also, Martin McGuinness was biased for the IRA to achieve his purpose.
Ah. So he since he has reasons to hide things about the IRA,
and he did that to achieve his purpose, I’m quite sure he is
hiding something. So what he said cannot prove!!
41. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
This source does not prove that the Catholics support the IRA.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Also, Martin McGuinness was biased for the IRA to achieve his purpose. Therefore,
this source does not prove that the Catholics support the IRA.
Ah. So he since he has reasons to hide things about the IRA,
and he did that to achieve his purpose, I’m quite sure he is
hiding something. So what he said cannot prove!!
42. Does this source prove that the Catholics support the IRA? Explain your answer.
This source does not prove that the Catholics support the IRA.
The Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to convince the audience that the IRA
benefitted the Catholics. This is because the source states that “I sincerely believe
that the armed struggle by the IRA caused embarrassment and ridicule for the
British Government throughout the world, forcing the British Government to resolve
the issue by giving more freedom to the Catholics”. This means that the Catholics
support the IRA as it helped them gain freedom. This was published as an account
during the conflict. Therefore, the Deputy President of Sinn Féin was trying to
garner the support of the audience to praise the IRA for their efforts. As a Deputy
President of a political party that is related to the IRA, Martin McGuinness would be
biased towards the IRA as they are on same side of the conflict in Northern Ireland.
Also, Martin McGuinness was biased for the IRA to achieve his purpose. Therefore,
this source does not prove that the Catholics support the IRA.