Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Improving knowledge through social interaction using argumentation
 Resource: Semantic Wikis         Edit      Discussion ...
Improving knowledge through social interaction using argumentation
 Resource: SWiM      Edit      Discussion       History...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Improving knowledge through social interaction using argumentation

448 views

Published on

ISWC 2008, Semantic Wiki Meeting

Published in: Technology, Education
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Improving knowledge through social interaction using argumentation

  1. 1. Improving knowledge through social interaction using argumentation Resource: Semantic Wikis Edit Discussion History Issue Alice 2008–05–30 [Idea][Argument][Agree][Disagree][Decision] It’s hard to find out how to improve content (= resources) in semantic wikis Agree Bob 2008–05–31 Indeed, it’s hard to get focused feedback from users. Idea Claire 2008–06–01 [Argument][Agree][Disagree][Decision] So let’s make wiki discussions semantic! Example Dave 2008–06–02 [Agree][Disagree] Yes, we could reuse existing argumentation ontologies, like DILIGENT. Justification Eric 2008–06–03 [Agree][Disagree] Excellent, that keeps discourses connected to the resources they are about. Agree Anonymous 2008–06–04 That’s great, old decisions would be documented. Decision Christoph 2008–06–05 Let’s do it! (Added to IkeWiki, math-specific extensions and assistance in SWiM) Christoph Lange (Jacobs University Bremen, Germany) October 26, 2008 1
  2. 2. Improving knowledge through social interaction using argumentation Resource: SWiM Edit Discussion History Issue Christoph 2008–10–01 [Idea][Argument][Agree][Disagree][Decision] Argumentation in practice is more diverse than our schema. Agree James 2008–10–02 Yes, I need more flexibility in order to express my concerns. Evaluation Christoph 2008–10–03 [Agree][Disagree] A look at argumentations in e-mail discussions shows that there are posts like requests for explanations, arguments pointing to multiple resources, and other posts that “just don’t fit”. Idea Christoph 2008–10–04 [Argument][Agree][Disagree][Decision] Let’s carefully extend the model. Issue Michael 2008–10–26 [Idea][Argument][Agree][Disagree][Decision] How are we going to pay Christoph’s trip to Karlsruhe? Idea Olga 2008–10–27 [Argument][Agree][Disagree][Decision] JEM-Thematic-Network ECP-038208 (Joining Educational Mathematics) will pay for it, but please acknowledge us Christoph Lange (Jacobs University Bremen, Germany) October 26, 2008 2

×